Neurohistological findings after experimental anterior cruciate ligament allograft transplantation

Which muscle performance can be improved after arthroscopic Bankart repair?

BACKGROUND

There are no published reports available regarding neuromuscular control recovery in nonathletic patients after arthroscopic (A/S) Bankart repair. This study aimed to compare neuromuscular control and performance of the rotator cuff muscles between patients who underwent A/S Bankart repair and normal controls.

METHODS

In total, 32 nonathletic patients who underwent A/S Bankart repair were compared with 32 asymptomatic nonathletic volunteers. Neuromuscular control index (time to peak torque and acceleration time), muscle strength ratio, muscle strength, and muscle endurance of the internal rotators (IRs) and external rotators (ERs) were measured using an isokinetic device at an angular velocity of 180°/s, with 90° shoulder abduction.

RESULTS

The neuromuscular control indices of both IRs and ERs were significantly lower in patients who underwent A/S Bankart repair than in normal controls (time to peak torque, IRs: 1059 ± 143 ms vs. 679 ± 226 ms, P = .011; ERs: 595 ± 286 ms vs. 379 ± 123 ms, P = .044; acceleration time, IRs: 75 ± 16 ms vs. 62 ± 15 ms, P = .039, ERs: 70 ± 19 ms vs. 54 ± 18 ms, P = .047). Muscle endurance was significantly lower in patients who underwent A/S Bankart repair than in normal controls (IRs: 670 ± 1 J vs. 718 ± 2 J, P = .002, ERs: 422 ± 6 J vs. 501 ± 2 J, P = .044). The neuromuscular control index showed a significant negative correlation with muscle endurance for both IRs and ERs after the operation (IRs: r = -0.737, P = .003, ERs: r = -0.617, P = .019).

CONCLUSION

Compared with normal controls, patients who underwent A/S Bankart repair did not show complete recovery of neuromuscular control of IRs and ERs, although their muscle strength ratio and muscle strength had fully recovered.

Impaired neuromuscular control up to postoperative 1 year in operated and nonoperated knees after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

The current study was performed to assess serial changes in neuromuscular control until 1 year postoperatively in nonathletic patients undergoing anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR).Ninety-six patients were included. Serial neuromuscular control tests were performed preoperatively, at 6 months, and 1 year postoperatively. Neuromuscular control was evaluated using acceleration time (AT) and dynamic postural stability (overall stability index, OSI). Functional activity levels were assessed using the Tegner activity-level scale.Preoperative AT of quadriceps and hamstrings in operated knees was 78.9 ± 6.4 and 86.5 ± 6.2 ms, respectively, which significantly reduced to 56.9 ± 2.0 and 62.5 ± 2.8 ms at 1 year (P = 0.006 and 0.002, respectively). In nonoperated knees, preoperative AT of quadriceps and hamstrings was 47.6 ± 1.7 and 56.5 ± 1.7 ms, respectively, which was significantly prolonged to 54.3 ± 2.0 and 67.9 ± 2.7 ms at 1 year (P = 0.02 and 0.001, respectively). Preoperative OSI of nonoperated knees was 1.2 ± 0.0°. It significantly increased to 1.5 ± 0.1° at 1 year (P < 0.001). In operated knees, preoperative OSI was 1.8 ± 0.1°. It significantly decreased to 1.4 ± 0.1° at 1 year (P = 0.001). Tegner scale at 6 months and 1 year were significantly lower than pre-operative scale (P < 0.001). AT and OSI on both knees showed significant negative correlation with Tegner scale at 6 months and 1 year.Neuromuscular control in both knees was not restored to preoperative levels of the nonoperated knees until 1 year after ACLR. Therefore, clinicians and physical therapists should attempt to enhance neuromuscular control in both nonoperated and operated knees.

Insufficient recovery of neuromuscular activity around the knee after experimental anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

BACKGROUND

Operative and nonoperative treatment of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries is often associated with a lack of proprioception and persistent muscle weakness of unknown origin.

METHODS

This long-term study in the cat experimentally compares both neural and muscular activity in the articular nerves of the knee (PAN and MAN), quadriceps and hamstrings, in the chronic unstable knee, and in the reconstructed knee. We also investigated changes in neuromuscular response due to the mechanical competence of the graft, comparing stable and unstable reconstructed knees.

RESULTS

We found increased periarticular muscle activity during anterior tibial translation in chronically unstable knees. Both reconstructed and non-reconstructed knees lost fast reactive activity in the articular nerves. When stability was recovered after reconstruction, the knees showed a more adjusted - although incomplete - muscular reaction.

INTERPRETATION

ACL-injured knees in the cat, with or without reconstruction, show definite abnormalities in neuromuscular reaction in the long term. Regaining stability with a competent graft in the reconstructed knee is crucial for reduction of this anomalous reaction.

Morphologic and functional features of the canine cruciate ligaments

OBJECTIVE

To review the gross, microscopic, and functional anatomy of the cranial cruciate ligament (CCL) in dogs.

STUDY DESIGN

Literature review.

METHODS

Reports of the anatomy and function of the cruciate ligaments in dogs were retrieved by search of the 1975-2005 PubMed database.

RESULTS

The CCL has an important biomechanical function resisting cranial drawer, hyperextension, and internal rotation and acts to fine tune and guide the stifle through its rolling and sliding motion. It has a complex architecture, and distinct geographic regions within the ligament have different functional roles depending on the angle and loading conditions. Collagen type I is the main component of the extracellular matrix; the fibrils have a crimped structure. The cruciate ligaments are almost completely covered by synovium, protecting them from synovial fluid. Cruciate blood supply is mainly of soft tissue origin. The intraligamentous network is relatively limited whereas the core of the middle third of the CCL is even less well vascularized. Neurohistologic studies are very limited in the dog. Various mechanoreceptors and proprioceptive receptors have been identified within the substance of the cruciate ligaments.

CONCLUSIONS

CCL structural characteristics play an important part in its complex behaviour with the crimped pattern of the collagen fibrils being an important determinant of its biomechanical properties. In contrast to reports of managing CCL rupture, there are few reports describing the microanatomy and neurovascular morphology of the cruciate ligaments.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Cruciate disease is likely multi-factorial. Improved understanding of CCL degradation leading to CCL rupture is critical to development of new diagnostic tests for cruciate disease in dogs. Appropriate intervention during the early stages of disease process might preserve CCL structural properties by preventing further collagen degradation. Accurate knowledge of functional and fiber bundle anatomy is imperative for reconstruction and restoration of normal stifle joint physiology. Reconstructive goals should alleviate existing instability and mimic normal kinematics. Knowledge of the exact function of the CCL in the neuromuscular control around the stifle joint could possibly explain osteoarthritis progression after CCL damage.

Benefits of active motion for joint position sense

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) ruptures lead to a proprioceptive deficit and therefore joint position sense. This study examined whether active motion is better suited than passive motion to address this deficit. Sixty patients with ACL rupture were prospectively randomised into two groups [continuous active motion (CAM)/continuous passive motion (CPM)]. All patients had an ACL reconstruction. An angle reproduction test was used to assess the proprioceptive deficit. The relevant examinations were performed before surgery (pre-op evaluation) and after the seventh postoperative day. No preoperative difference was found between the two groups. After postoperative treatment, the deficit was reduced in both groups. Significantly better results were, however, obtained in the CAM group (CPM, 4.2+/-1.6 degrees; CAM, 1.9+/-1.2 degrees; P<0.001). During the first postoperative week, a CAM device produced a significantly greater reduction in the proprioceptive deficit and should be the first choice in immediately postoperative rehabilitation after ACL replacement.

Decrease in anterior knee laxity by electrical stimulation of normal and reconstructed anterior cruciate ligaments

We have investigated the changes in anterior laxity of the knee in response to direct electrical stimulation of eight normal and 45 reconstructed anterior cruciate ligaments (ACLs). In the latter, the mean time from reconstruction was 26.7 months (24 to 32). The ACL was stimulated electrically using a bipolar electrode probe during arthroscopy. Anterior laxity was examined with the knee flexed at 20 degrees under a force of 134 N applied anteriorly to the tibia using the KT-2000 knee arthrometer before, during and after electrical stimulation. Anterior tibial translation in eight normal and 17 ACL-reconstructed knees was significantly decreased during stimulation, compared with that before stimulation. In 28 knees with reconstruction of the ACL, in 22 of which the grafts were found to have detectable somatosensory evoked potentials during stimulation, anterior tibial translation was not decreased. These findings suggest that the ACL-hamstring reflex arc in normal knees may contribute to the functional stability and that this may not be fully restored after some reconstructions of the ACL.

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using cryopreserved allografts

Primary ACL reconstruction historically has been done using autograft tissues whereas allografts have been limited to revision cases and patients who are older or with lower physical demands because some animal studies suggested a slower biologic incorporation rate. The purpose of the current study was to evaluate the effectiveness of the cryopreserved Achilles tendon allograft in primary ACL reconstruction in a consecutive series of athletes. Fifty consecutive patients with a strenuous or moderate preinjury activity level, as defined by the International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC), had ACL reconstruction using cryopreserved Achilles tendon allografts secured with bioabsorbable interference screws. Five patients were professional athletes. The average age of the patients was 36 years (range, 17-50 years). A 3- to 5-year followup study was done in all of the patients using the IKDC form. Tunnel widening was measured in the lateral radiographs at the widest level. The overall outcome was normal or nearly normal in 94% of the patients. No failures were reported in this series. Forty-six patients (92%) returned to their same preinjury sport activity level. The average KT-1000 side-to-side difference was 2.3 mm. Average tibial tunnel widening was 2.7 mm (range, 0-6 mm); no significant correlation was observed between increased tunnel size and a fair or poor clinical outcome. This experience shows that favorable results can be obtained with cryopreserved Achilles tendon allografts in athletes in whom avoiding donor site morbidity may be an issue in terms of a prompt return to sport.

Neuromuscular training and injury prevention in sports

Exercises that help develop neuromuscular control and increase functional joint stability are critical in conditioning and rehabilitation programs designed for injury prevention in sports. Information regarding joint movement and joint position provided by mechanoreceptors in the skin, muscles, tendons, ligaments, and joints combine with input from the vestibular and visual systems to maintain balance. Insufficient neurologic input or improperly processing that input at the spinal, brain stem, or cognitive centers can lead to an inadequate response by the motor system resulting in an injury. Therefore, it is important to include drills that enhance neuromuscular control into traditional training, conditioning, and rehabilitation programs for sports.

Shoulder proprioception and function following thermal capsulorraphy

PURPOSE

Because monopolar radiofrequency energy has a denaturing effect on the glenohumeral joint capsule during thermal capsulorraphy, we hypothesized that thermal treatment would have a deleterious effect on the mechanoreceptors present within the capsule, thereby affecting proprioception and function. The purpose of this study was to evaluate proprioception and function following thermal capsulorraphy.

TYPE OF STUDY

Case series.

METHODS

Twenty subjects (13 male, 7 female) diagnosed with unilateral anterior, anteroinferior, or multidirectional glenohumeral instability with no significant concomitant pathologies, were treated with monopolar radiofrequency thermal capsulorraphy by one surgeon. Capsular redundancy was the primary diagnosis in all subjects. Subjects were bilaterally tested retrospectively 6 to 24 months (11.90 +/- 5.65 months) following surgery. Each subject's ability to actively reproduce joint positions (ARJP) and reproduce paths of motion (PMR) was measured with an electromagnetic motion analysis system. Both passive reproduction of joint positions (PRJP) and threshold to detect passive motion (TTDPM) were measured using a proprioception testing device. Function was quantified with the Shoulder Rating Questionnaire (SRQ). Proprioception data were analyzed with separate repeated measures ANOVA (P <.05).

RESULTS

Statistical analysis revealed a significant ARJP difference between the involved and uninvolved limb (P =.005) indicating that reproduction error was less with the involved limb compared to the uninvolved limb. No significant interactions were present for TTDPM, PRJP, or PMR. The SRQ indicates that the subjects returned to near normal function (91.86/100 +/- 5.38 points) at the time of testing.

CONCLUSIONS

The results from this study do not support our hypothesis of proprioception and functional deficits following thermal treatment. Normalized proprioception following thermal capsulorraphy may have resulted from the healing effects of thermal treated ligament, as reported in the literature, as well as facilitation of other mechanoreceptors present in adjacent tissue about the shoulder joint during rehabilitation. The results of this study indicate that no appreciative deleterious effects exist with proprioception and function following treatment of shoulder instability with thermal capsulorraphy.

Proprioceptive improvement in knees with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

The correlation between the prospective course of proprioceptive improvement and knee stability after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction was investigated in 38 patients. Proprioception, on the basis of the patient's capacity to reposition the limb accurately, was evaluated at 3-month intervals for 24 months after hamstring graft anterior cruciate ligament surgery. Knee stability was evaluated concurrently with a KT-2000 knee arthrometer. Thirty patients experienced improvement in postoperative position sense in at least one of the examinations, although eight patients had no improvement at any time. Of the 30 patients who had improvement, 28 maintained improved position sense from 18 months to the final followup. Thirty patients maintained significantly better knee stability for a postoperative period of at least 24 months. These results indicated that a minimum of 18 months after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction may be needed for complete restoration of the proprioceptive function in knees, although the mean position sense in all patients gradually improved from 9 months. Improvement in postoperative knee stability may have facilitated recovery of proprioception.

Sensorimotor changes after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

The restoration of joint stability is unlikely to be dependent on passive properties of the joint alone, yet the effect of anterior cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery on the sensorimotor system largely remains unexplored. This study evaluated whether surgical reconstruction of the ligament had any effect on one indicator of sensorimotor function, hamstring contraction latency, which previously has been shown to be related to function. Twenty-five patients with unilateral chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficiency had measures of hamstring contraction latency obtained before and after (3 and 6 months) reconstruction. After surgery, the contraction latency difference was found to improve significantly (decrease) in patients who had a preexisting deficit. The mechanism for alteration in response time remains unclear, but an observed relationship between contraction latency and tibial translation supports a mechanical basis for the findings. It was concluded the sensorimotor changes associated with surgical reconstruction of the cruciate ligament may help to restore joint stability. The study highlights the need to appreciate sensorimotor consequences of cruciate ligament surgery.

Evidence of reinnervation of free patellar tendon autograft used for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

We studied six adult male dogs to determine whether free patellar tendon grafts show evidence of reinnervation when used for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Histologic return of neural elements and return of a somatosensory-evoked potential defined evidence of reinnervation. Before removal, the native anterior cruciate ligament was electrically stimulated with a bipolar electrode and a somatosensory-evoked potential was recorded from a scalp electrode. The ligament was excised and reconstructed using an autogenous patellar tendon graft. Somatosensory-evoked potential was attempted immediately after reconstruction. Histology for nerve endings was performed on the native ligaments. Each animal underwent repeat arthrotomy 6 months later. The grafts were isolated and somatosensory-evoked potentials were attempted. An evoked potential was seen in all six dogs before reconstruction. No graft demonstrated a somatosensory-evoked potential acutely; however, 6 months postoperatively, the somatosensory-evoked potential returned in two cases. Histology of native ligaments showed that 25% of the 100 sections evaluated contained neural elements. Of the receptors present, 89% were mechanoreceptors and 11% were free nerve endings. Histologic examination of the graft tissue 6 months postoperatively revealed that all six grafts also contained neural elements. Mechanoreceptors and free nerve endings were present in approximately equal numbers in the grafts. The results of histology and somatosensory-evoked potential demonstrate that in at least some cases, free patellar tendon grafts show evidence of reinnervation when used for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.

[Projections and fiber characteristics of sensory afferents of the anterior cruciate ligament in an animal experiment]

The sensory innervation of the rabbit anterior cruciate ligament was studied by retrograde tracing technique using wheat-germ-agglutinin-horseradish-peroxidase (WGA-HRP) and Fast Blue as neuronal tracers. Injection of the tracer into the ligament was followed by histo- and immunohistochemical investigation of labelled nerve cell bodies located in the dorsal root ganglia. In 4 animals we injected the tracer into the joint cavity to label general joint afferents. The segmental distribution of retrogradely labelled neurons following injection into the anterior cruciate ligament (L6, L7, S1) is significantly different from the distribution pattern after injection into the knee joint (L4-S2). Retrogradely labelled nerve cells innervating the anterior cruciate ligament were further investigated using immunohistochemical and morphometric analysis. The sensory innervation of the anterior cruciate ligament is therefore comprised of at least 2 different qualities of sensory afferent nerves: 1. Small neurones immunoreactive to the inflammatory peptide substance P most likely transmitting nociceptive information centrally (44%). 2. Large, presumably fast conducting A-fibre-afferents characterized by neurofilament proteins transmitting proprioceptive information from corpuscular mechanoreceptors (43%). The results of this study put further weight to the importance of the sensory role of the anterior cruciate ligament using neuroanatomical and immunohistochemical techniques.

The future of anterior cruciate ligament restoration

Advancements in the understanding of anatomy, kinematics, and physiology should improve future treatment of anterior cruciate ligament injured knees. The ultimate goal of full restoration of an anterior cruciate ligament injured knee to preinjury status, may be possible in the distant future through genetic manipulation inducing regeneration of tissues. In the midterm future, resorbable stents with incorporated bioactive growth factors have the potential of inducing normal anterior cruciate ligament anatomy without the need for detrimental harvesting of the patient's tissues, or risk of microbial transmission with the use of an allograft. In the near future, the development of more benign autografts and allografts is possible along with methods of resorbable fixation of the graft to bone. Future development of 3-dimensional arthroscopic visualization and robotic surgical techniques have the potential for improvement in graft placement. Advancements in treatment of anterior cruciate ligament deficient knees also can be expected from nonsurgical areas, such as control of muscle atrophy, enhancing cerebellar-proprioceptive rehabilitation, and better bracing techniques. The basic principle of therapy should be to maximize the functional load acceptance and transference capacity of the knee with the least degree of risk to the patient.

Proprioception of the shoulder joint in healthy, unstable, and surgically repaired shoulders

Shoulder proprioception was measured in 90 subjects who were assigned to three experimental groups: group 1 (n = 40), healthy college-age subjects; group 2 (n = 30), patients with anterior instability; and group 3 (n = 20), patients who have had surgical reconstruction. Kinesthesia and joint position sense were measured with a specially designed proprioception testing device. The results revealed no significant differences in proprioception between dominant and nondominont shoulders in group 1 for any test condition. Significant differences (p < 0.05) were revealed between the unstable and uninvolved shoulder for both kinesthesia and joint position sense in group 2. No significant mean differences were revealed between the surgical and contralaterol shoulder in group 3 under any test condition. This series of studies provides evidence that proprioceptive deficits caused by partial deafferentiation result when copsuloligomentous structures are damaged. Reconstructive surgery appears to restore some of these proprioception characteristics.

Nerve supply of anterior cruciate ligaments and of cryopreserved anterior cruciate ligament allografts: a new method for the differentiation of the nervous tissues

We investigated the nerve supply of anterior cruciate ligaments ((ACLs) and of cryopreserved bone-ACL-bone allografts in a rabbit model with immunohistochemical methods to establish the distribution pattern of the nervous tissues and to determine the reinnervation rate of ACL allografts. The ACL is innervated by three different classes of nerve fibre: (1) fibres of large diameter, characterized by neurofilament immunoreactivity, which are fast-conducting mechanoreceptive sensory afferents; (2) fibres of small diameter, characterized by substance P-immunoreactivity, which are slow-conducting nociceptive sensory afferents; and (3) sympathetic efferent vasomotor fibres, characterized by their immunoreactivity to the rate-limiting enzyme of noradrenaline synthesis, tyrosine hydroxylase. The ACLs showed numerous fibres of all three nerve classes; as specialised sensory nerve endings only Ruffini corpuscles were observed. All nerve fibres were located subsynovially, none within the collagen core of the ligament itself. No nerve fibres were detected in the ACL allografts at 3 and 6 weeks. Sparse fibres were detected at 12 weeks, while the 24-, 36- and 52-week specimens showed plenty of all three fibre types. No mechanoreceptors were found in the ACL allografts. To our knowledge, this method for the first time allows a differentiation of the nerve fibres of ACLs and ACL allografts into three different nerve fibre classes with known neurophysiological functions.