Failure of immunologic reconstitution in a patient with the DiGeorge syndrome after fetal thymus transplantation

Thymus transplantation for DiGeorge Syndrome: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

DiGeorge syndrome (DGS) is a condition typically associated with athymia, parathyroid hypoplasia or aplasia, and congenital heart defects. Athymia in these patients causes severe immunodeficiency, causing high mortality and morbidity, often requiring thymic tissue transplantation. The present systematic review aims to consolidate the present evidence on thymus transplantation in DGS.

METHODS

An electronic literature search of five databases (PubMed, Medline, Scopus, EBSCOhost, and CINAHL) was performed from inception till September 2024. Relevant articles were selected, and data was extracted by two independent reviewers.

RESULTS

A total of 16 articles were included from an initial set of 1227 articles. Patients diagnosed with DGS in the included studies were predominantly male, and the age at which thymus transplantation was done typically varied from 0.8 to 26 months. Several patients had chromosome 22q11 hemizygosity. Thymic tissue was taken from tissues of pediatric patients undergoing cardiothoracic surgery. Pre-transplant medication included immunosuppressants with rabbit anti-thymocyte globulin (RATGAM) being frequently used alongside steroids and tacrolimus. This tissue was cultured and transplanted into the quadriceps muscle of the patients under general anesthesia. Thymopoiesis was well described in most patients with graft failures and rejections occurring rarely. Naive T-cell development was noted in almost all patients with clearance of infections in many cases. Common postoperative complications include sepsis, haemorrhage, gastrointestinal disturbances, among others. Mortality was uncommon but often associated with intracerebral hemorrhages and sepsis.

CONCLUSION

Thymus transplantation is a relatively safe and effective procedure in patients with DGS with athymia. Future research should explore the addition of allogenic parathyroid gland transplantation along with thymic tissue.

Current and Future Therapeutic Approaches for Thymic Stromal Cell Defects

Inborn errors of thymic stromal cell development and function lead to impaired T-cell development resulting in a susceptibility to opportunistic infections and autoimmunity. In their most severe form, congenital athymia, these disorders are life-threatening if left untreated. Athymia is rare and is typically associated with complete DiGeorge syndrome, which has multiple genetic and environmental etiologies. It is also found in rare cases of T-cell lymphopenia due to Nude SCID and Otofaciocervical Syndrome type 2, or in the context of genetically undefined defects. This group of disorders cannot be corrected by hematopoietic stem cell transplantation, but upon timely recognition as thymic defects, can successfully be treated by thymus transplantation using cultured postnatal thymic tissue with the generation of naïve T-cells showing a diverse repertoire. Mortality after this treatment usually occurs before immune reconstitution and is mainly associated with infections most often acquired pre-transplantation. In this review, we will discuss the current approaches to the diagnosis and management of thymic stromal cell defects, in particular those resulting in athymia. We will discuss the impact of the expanding implementation of newborn screening for T-cell lymphopenia, in combination with next generation sequencing, as well as the role of novel diagnostic tools distinguishing between hematopoietic and thymic stromal cell defects in facilitating the early consideration for thymus transplantation of an increasing number of patients and disorders. Immune reconstitution after the current treatment is usually incomplete with relatively common inflammatory and autoimmune complications, emphasizing the importance for improving strategies for thymus replacement therapy by optimizing the current use of postnatal thymus tissue and developing new approaches using engineered thymus tissue.

Replacing defective thymus function

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Transplantation of cultured postnatal allogeneic thymus has been successful for treating athymia, mostly associated with complete DiGeorge syndrome, for more than 20 years. Advances in molecular genetics provide opportunities for widening the range of athymic conditions that can be treated while advances in cell culture and organ/tissue regeneration may offer the prospect of alternative preparations of thymic tissue. There are potential broader applications of this treatment outside congenital athymia.

RECENT FINDINGS

At the same time as further characterization of the cultured thymus product in terms of thymic epithelial cells and lymphoid composition, preclinical studies have looked at de-novo generation of thymic epithelial cells from stem cells and explored scaffolds for delivering these as three-dimensional structures. In the era of newborn screening for T-cell lymphopaenia, a broadening range of defects leading to athymia is being recognized and new assays should allow differentiation of these from haematopoietic cell defects, pending their genetic/molecular characterization. Evidence suggests that the tolerogenic effect of transplanted thymus could be exploited to improve outcomes after solid organ transplantation.

SUMMARY

Thymus transplantation, the accepted standard treatment for complete DiGeorge syndrome is also appropriate for other genetic defects leading to athymia. Improved strategies for generating thymus may lead to better outcomes and broader application of this treatment.

Thymus Transplantation

Thymus transplantation was first attempted in the 1960s and 1970s using fetal thymus tissue [1, 2]. The results overall were disappointing [3–6]. In part the poor outcomes related to the lack of reagents needed to characterize and identify the patients into those who were truly athymic (complete DiGeorge anomaly) and those who had bone marrow stem cell problems (severe combined immunodeficiency). It is also possible that the fetal thymus tissue was too small to reconstitute a human infant [7]. The use of fetal thymus carried the risk of fatal graft versus host disease since mature T-cells can be found in the human thymus by the end of the first trimester [3]. By 1986, in a review of 26 infants treated with fetal thymus transplantation, 22 had died; the other 4 patients had achieved a 3-year survival [6].

Thymic reticulo-epithelial cells

The reticulo-epithelial (RE) cellular network of the thymic stromal cellular microenvironment plays a vital role in neuroendocrine regulation and lymphoid cell homing and development. Transmission electronmicroscopic observations have confirmed that there are four functional subtypes of medullar RE cells: undifferentiated; squamous; villous; and cystic. Immunocytochemical observations have shown that the secreted thymic hormones, thymosin alpha1 and thymopoietin (and its short form, thymopentin or TP5), are both produced by RE cells. Thymic RE cells also produce numerous cytokines, including IL-1 and -6, G-CSF, macrophage-CSF and GM-CSF that likely are important during the various stages of thymocyte activation and differentiation. The coexistence of pituitary hormone and neuropeptide secretion, such as growth hormone, prolactin, adrenocorticotopic hormone and thyroid-stimulating hormone, among many others, and the production of a number of interleukins and growth factors, as well as the expression of receptors for all, by the same RE cell, is an unique molecular biological phenomenon. The thymic RE cell network represents an important cellular and humoral microenvironment in the neuroendocrine homeopathic regulatory mechanisms of the multicellular organism.

Bone marrow transplantation in DiGeorge syndrome

A Hispanic infant girl with DiGeorge syndrome underwent successful bone marrow transplantation (BMT) at age 28 1/2 weeks. She had typical facies, a cardiac defect, hypoparathyroidism, severe T and B cell immunodeficiency, and low levels of facteur thymique serique (FTS). In vitro incubation of the peripheral blood lymphocytes with thymosin alpha 1 showed no increase in the number of T cells on two occasions. A fetal thymus for transplantation was not available, and further review of past experience with thymic cells or factors revealed inconsistent and incomplete responses. Because of the patient's worsening clinical and immunologic status, BMT was performed, with her histocompatible brother as donor. The patient has had a good clinical and immunologic response to BMT, with evidence of T cell engraftment, improved B cell function, and increased levels of serum FTS. This experience indicates that minimal thymic influence is necessary for successful BMT and that patients with DiGeorge syndrome with significant T cell deficiency may benefit from this treatment.