Establishment of immunological competence in a child with congenital thymic aplasia by a graft of fetal thymus

Thymus transplantation for DiGeorge Syndrome: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

DiGeorge syndrome (DGS) is a condition typically associated with athymia, parathyroid hypoplasia or aplasia, and congenital heart defects. Athymia in these patients causes severe immunodeficiency, causing high mortality and morbidity, often requiring thymic tissue transplantation. The present systematic review aims to consolidate the present evidence on thymus transplantation in DGS.

METHODS

An electronic literature search of five databases (PubMed, Medline, Scopus, EBSCOhost, and CINAHL) was performed from inception till September 2024. Relevant articles were selected, and data was extracted by two independent reviewers.

RESULTS

A total of 16 articles were included from an initial set of 1227 articles. Patients diagnosed with DGS in the included studies were predominantly male, and the age at which thymus transplantation was done typically varied from 0.8 to 26 months. Several patients had chromosome 22q11 hemizygosity. Thymic tissue was taken from tissues of pediatric patients undergoing cardiothoracic surgery. Pre-transplant medication included immunosuppressants with rabbit anti-thymocyte globulin (RATGAM) being frequently used alongside steroids and tacrolimus. This tissue was cultured and transplanted into the quadriceps muscle of the patients under general anesthesia. Thymopoiesis was well described in most patients with graft failures and rejections occurring rarely. Naive T-cell development was noted in almost all patients with clearance of infections in many cases. Common postoperative complications include sepsis, haemorrhage, gastrointestinal disturbances, among others. Mortality was uncommon but often associated with intracerebral hemorrhages and sepsis.

CONCLUSION

Thymus transplantation is a relatively safe and effective procedure in patients with DGS with athymia. Future research should explore the addition of allogenic parathyroid gland transplantation along with thymic tissue.

Current and Future Therapeutic Approaches for Thymic Stromal Cell Defects

Inborn errors of thymic stromal cell development and function lead to impaired T-cell development resulting in a susceptibility to opportunistic infections and autoimmunity. In their most severe form, congenital athymia, these disorders are life-threatening if left untreated. Athymia is rare and is typically associated with complete DiGeorge syndrome, which has multiple genetic and environmental etiologies. It is also found in rare cases of T-cell lymphopenia due to Nude SCID and Otofaciocervical Syndrome type 2, or in the context of genetically undefined defects. This group of disorders cannot be corrected by hematopoietic stem cell transplantation, but upon timely recognition as thymic defects, can successfully be treated by thymus transplantation using cultured postnatal thymic tissue with the generation of naïve T-cells showing a diverse repertoire. Mortality after this treatment usually occurs before immune reconstitution and is mainly associated with infections most often acquired pre-transplantation. In this review, we will discuss the current approaches to the diagnosis and management of thymic stromal cell defects, in particular those resulting in athymia. We will discuss the impact of the expanding implementation of newborn screening for T-cell lymphopenia, in combination with next generation sequencing, as well as the role of novel diagnostic tools distinguishing between hematopoietic and thymic stromal cell defects in facilitating the early consideration for thymus transplantation of an increasing number of patients and disorders. Immune reconstitution after the current treatment is usually incomplete with relatively common inflammatory and autoimmune complications, emphasizing the importance for improving strategies for thymus replacement therapy by optimizing the current use of postnatal thymus tissue and developing new approaches using engineered thymus tissue.

Replacing defective thymus function

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Transplantation of cultured postnatal allogeneic thymus has been successful for treating athymia, mostly associated with complete DiGeorge syndrome, for more than 20 years. Advances in molecular genetics provide opportunities for widening the range of athymic conditions that can be treated while advances in cell culture and organ/tissue regeneration may offer the prospect of alternative preparations of thymic tissue. There are potential broader applications of this treatment outside congenital athymia.

RECENT FINDINGS

At the same time as further characterization of the cultured thymus product in terms of thymic epithelial cells and lymphoid composition, preclinical studies have looked at de-novo generation of thymic epithelial cells from stem cells and explored scaffolds for delivering these as three-dimensional structures. In the era of newborn screening for T-cell lymphopaenia, a broadening range of defects leading to athymia is being recognized and new assays should allow differentiation of these from haematopoietic cell defects, pending their genetic/molecular characterization. Evidence suggests that the tolerogenic effect of transplanted thymus could be exploited to improve outcomes after solid organ transplantation.

SUMMARY

Thymus transplantation, the accepted standard treatment for complete DiGeorge syndrome is also appropriate for other genetic defects leading to athymia. Improved strategies for generating thymus may lead to better outcomes and broader application of this treatment.

The journey from discoveries in fundamental immunology to cancer immunotherapy

Recent advances in cancer immunotherapy have directly built on 50 years of fundamental and technological advances that made checkpoint blockade and T cell engineering possible. In this review, we intend to show that research, not specifically designed to bring relief or cure to any particular disease, can, when creatively exploited, lead to spectacular results in the management of cancer. The discovery of thymus immune function, T cells, and immune surveillance bore the seeds for today's targeted immune interventions and chimeric antigen receptors.

Immunodeficiency in DiGeorge Syndrome and Options for Treating Cases with Complete Athymia

The commonest association of thymic stromal deficiency resulting in T-cell immunodeficiency is the DiGeorge syndrome (DGS). This results from abnormal development of the third and fourth pharyngeal arches and is most commonly associated with a microdeletion at chromosome 22q11 though other genetic and non-genetic causes have been described. The immunological competence of affected individuals is highly variable, ranging from normal to a severe combined immunodeficiency when there is complete athymia. In the most severe group, correction of the immunodeficiency can be achieved using thymus allografts which can support thymopoiesis even in the absence of donor-recipient matching at the major histocompatibility loci. This review focuses on the causes of DGS, the immunological features of the disorder, and the approaches to correction of the immunodeficiency including the use of thymus transplantation.

Immunological aspects of 22q11.2 deletion syndrome

Chromosome 22q11 deletion is the most common chromosomal deletion syndrome and is found in the majority of patients with DiGeorge syndrome and velo-cardio-facial syndrome. Patients with CHARGE syndrome may share similar features. Cardiac malformations, speech delay, and immunodeficiency are the most common manifestations. The immunological phenotype may vary widely between patients. Severe T lymphocyte immunodeficiency is rare-thymic transplantation offers a new approach to treatment, as well as insights into thymic physiology and central tolerance. Combined partial immunodeficiency is more common, leading to recurrent sinopulmonary infection in early childhood. Autoimmunity is an increasingly recognized complication. New insights into pathophysiology are reviewed.

Unrelated partially matched lymphocyte infusions in a patient with complete DiGeorge/CHARGE syndrome

We present an infant with cDGS overlapping with CHARGE syndrome, who suffered from T-cell deficiency treated with screened healthy DLI from an unrelated donor (8/10 match). The first dose of DLI (1.1 x 10(6) CD3+/kg) was administered at the age of six months, the second one (0.9 x 10(6) CD3+/kg) 36 days later. No conditioning was employed, GvHD prophylaxis consisting of CsA was used only during the second infusion. Since day+10 after the first DLI, split chimerism showing T-cell engraftment has been documented. Proliferative response to PHA was detected on day+145. The treatment was complicated by severe acute GvHD (grade II-III) after the first DLI and prolonged chronic liver cholestatic GvHD developing after the second DLI. Vigorous EBV proliferation four wk after the second DLI was accompanied by peripheral expansion of CD8+ donor cells. The patient, 26-months old, is clinically well and has slowly started to gain his developmental milestones. We believe that infusions of small doses of DLI from an unrelated donor represent a potentially helpful therapeutic option in patients with cDGS/CHARGE phenotype.

Complete DiGeorge anomaly in the absence of neonatal hypocalcemia and velofacial and cardiac defects

We report an atypical case of complete DiGeorge (DG) anomaly that presented initially exclusively as severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID). The child had severe infections at diagnosis, in keeping with the SCID phenotype; however, normal lymphocyte counts and immunoglobulin levels were noted at admission, which delayed diagnosis. Importantly, the child presented without neonatal hypocalcemia or velofacial or cardiac abnormalities at the time of diagnosis, which masked underlying DG. This case outlines the difficulties in making the diagnosis of SCID in a timely manner and illustrates the variation in presentation of the 22q11.2 deletion syndrome. There should be a high index of suspicion for primary immunodeficiency among children with severe infections and, because management may vary, DG anomaly should be considered in the differential diagnosis of T- B+ natural killer+ SCID.

Thymic transplantation for complete DiGeorge syndrome: medical and surgical considerations

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Complete DiGeorge syndrome results in the absence of functional T cells. Our program supports the transplantation of allogeneic thymic tissue in infants with DiGeorge syndrome to reconstitute immune function. This study reviews the multidisciplinary care of these complex infants.

METHODS

From 1991 to 2001, the authors evaluated 16 infants with complete DiGeorge syndrome. All infants received multidisciplinary medical and surgical support. Clinical records for the group were reviewed.

RESULTS

Four infants died without receiving a thymic transplantation, and 12 children survived to transplantation. The mean age at time of transplantation was 2.7 months (range, 1.1 to 4.4 months). All 16 infants had significant comorbidity including congenital heart disease (16 of 16), hypocalcemia (14 of 16), gastroesophageal reflux disease or aspiration (13 of 16), CHARGE complex (4 of 16), and other organ involvement (14 of 16). Nontransplant surgical procedures included central line placement (15 of 16), fundoplication or gastrostomy (10 of 16), cardiac repair (10 of 16), bronchoscopy or tracheostomy (6 of 16), and other procedures (12 of 16). Complications were substantial, and 5 of the 12 transplanted infants died of nontransplant-related conditions. All surviving infants have immune reconstitution, with follow-up from 2 to 10 years.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the transplantation of thymic tissue can restore immune function in infants with complete DiGeorge syndrome, these children have substantial comorbidity. Care of these children requires coordinated multidisciplinary support.

T-cell immune constitution after peripheral blood mononuclear cell transplantation in complete DiGeorge syndrome

Complete DiGeorge syndrome (cDGS) is a congenital disorder characterized by typical facies, thymic aplasia, susceptibility to infections, hypoparathyroidism and conotruncal cardiac defect. Fetal thymus or post-natal thymus tissue transplantations and human leucocyte antigen (HLA)-genoidentical bone marrow transplantations were followed in a few cases by immune reconstitution. More recently, a peripheral blood mononuclear cell transplantation (PBMCT) was performed with an HLA-genoidentical donor and followed by a partial T-cell engraftment and immune reconstitution. We report a boy with cDGS, without cardiac defect, who suffered recurrent severe infections. At the age of 4 years, he underwent PBMCT from his HLA-genoidentical sister. He received no conditioning regimen, but graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) prophylaxis was with oral cyclosporin A and mycophenolate mofetil. Toxicity was mild, with grade I acute GVHD. The patient is currently 2.5 years post-PBMCT with excellent clinical performances. Mixed chimaerism can only be observed on the T-cell population (50% donor T cells). T-lymphocyte count fluctuated (CD3 more than 400 x 10(6)/l at d 84 and CD4 more than 200 x 10(6)/l at d 46). Exclusive memory phenotype T cells and absence of new thymic emigrants suggest expansion of infused T cells. T-cell mitogen and tetanus antigen responses normalized a few months after transplantation. After immunizations, specific antibodies were produced. PBMCT from an HLA identical sibling could be an efficient treatment of immune deficiency in cDGS.

Transplantation of thymus tissue in complete DiGeorge syndrome

BACKGROUND

The DiGeorge syndrome is a congenital disorder that affects the heart, parathyroid glands, and thymus. In complete DiGeorge syndrome, patients have severely reduced T-cell function.

METHODS

We treated five infants (age, one to four months) with complete DiGeorge syndrome by transplantation of cultured postnatal thymus tissue. Follow-up evaluations included immune phenotyping and proliferative studies of peripheral-blood mononuclear cells plus biopsy of the thymus allograft. Thymic production of new T cells was assessed in peripheral blood by tests for T-cell-receptor recombination excision circles, which are formed from excised DNA during the rearrangement of T-cell-receptor genes.

RESULTS

After the transplantation of thymus tissue, T-cell proliferative responses to mitogens developed in four of the five patients. Two of the patients survived with restoration of immune function; three patients died from infection or abnormalities unrelated to transplantation. Biopsies of grafted thymus in the surviving patients showed normal morphologic features and active T-cell production. In three patients, donor T cells could be detected about four weeks after transplantation, although there was no evidence of graft-versus-host disease on biopsy or at autopsy. In one patient, the T-cell development within the graft was demonstrated to accompany the appearance of recently developed T cells in the periphery and coincided with the onset of normal T-cell function. In one patient, there was evidence of thymus function and CD45RA+CD62L+ T cells more than five years after transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

In some infants with profound immunodeficiency and complete DiGeorge syndrome, the transplantation of thymus tissue can restore normal immune function. Early thymus transplantation - before the development of infectious complications - may promote successful immune reconstitution.

Normalization of the peripheral blood T cell receptor V beta repertoire after cultured postnatal human thymic transplantation in DiGeorge syndrome

Complete DiGeorge syndrome is an immunodeficiency disease characterized by thymic aplasia and the absence of functioning peripheral T cells. A patient with this syndrome was transplanted with cultured postnatal human thymic tissue. Within 5 weeks of transplantation, flow cytometry, T cell receptor V beta sequence analysis, and cell function studies showed the presence of oligoclonal populations of nonfunctional clonally expanded peripheral T cells that were derived from pretransplantation T cells present in the skin. However, at 3 months posttransplantation, a biopsy of the transplanted thymus showed normal intrathymic T cell maturation of host T cells with normal TCR V beta expression on thymocytes. By 9 months postransplantation, peripheral T cell function was restored and the TCR V beta repertoire became polyclonal, coincident with the appearance of normal T cell function. These data suggest that the transplanted thymus was responsible for the establishment of a new T cell repertoire via thymopoiesis in the chimeric thymic graft.

Factors affecting survival in allogeneic bone marrow transplantation

From 1979 to 1988, 82 allogeneic and 2 syngeneic bone marrow transplants (BMT) were performed in 78 patients (age range 13-49 years) with the following diagnoses: acute myelogenous leukemia (AML) (21 patients); acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) (15 patients); chronic myelocytic leukemia in chronic, accelerated, or blastic phase (CML-CP, AP or BC) (25 patients); myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS) (1 patient); multiple myeloma (MM) (1 patient); Hodgkin's disease (HD) (1 patient); diffuse poorly differentiated lymphoma (DPDL) (1 patient); aplastic anemia (AA) (13 patients). Univariant analyses were carried out to determine factors of importance in predicting outcome. AML patients receiving transplants in remission had 12/19 (63%) survivors. Only one of seven ALL patients receiving transplants in remission survives free of disease, and none of eight patients receiving transplants in relapse survived. Six ALL patients relapsed. In CML, 6 of 16 (40%) patients receiving transplants in CP survive; two of nine patients (22%) in AP or BC survive. Of the 13 aplastic anemias, 8 (62%) survive. Graft-vs.-host disease (GVHD) was evaluated in 75 patients, 24 of 33 (73%) who developed GVHD died, compared to 24 of 44 (55%) who did not develop GVHD. Of the 30 patients given the combination of methotrexate (MTX) plus cyclosporine (CSP), only 23% developed GVHD, compared to 58% of those not given the combination. Interstitial pneumonia (IP) occurred in 16 patients and was fatal in 15. The introduction of daily acyclovir and weekly intravenous gamma globulin in 1985 was associated with little reduction in the frequency of IP (from 20% to 18%). However, survival increased from 21% to 47%.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

DiGeorge syndrome with hypogammaglobulinaemia: a patient with excess suppressor T cell activity treated with fetal thymus transplantation

A male infant with DiGeorge syndrome had hypogammaglobulinaemia with a normal number of B cells. CD3(+) T cells were reduced and the CD4(+)/CD8(+) ratio was reversed. Proliferative responses of T cells to mitogens and to allogeneic cells were low. The pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-induced B cell differentiation assay revealed a higher than normal suppressor T cell activity. This suggests that some T cells had differentiated into functionally mature cells resulting in an imbalance of regulatory T cell functions and that excess suppressor activity might play a role in hypogammaglobulinaemia. Fetal thymus transplantation improved both cellular and humoral immunity. The patient's susceptibility to viral and bacterial infections, proliferative response of T cells and serum Ig concentration returned to normal. The excess suppressor activity seen before transplantation disappeared. Hypocalcaemia did not improve. These results show that fetal thymus transplantation was effective not only in reconstituting cellular immunity but also in normalizing the imbalance of regulatory T cell functions in this patient with DiGeorge syndrome.

An evolution of therapy for mucocutaneous candidiasis

Chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis is a relatively uncommon form of candida infection, and can be found in patients with primary deficiencies of their immune systems. When such infection occurs in patients with non-lethal immune deficiences defects of chemotaxis or cellular immunity can be found. In addition, significant endocrinopathies may occur, particularly involving the parathyroid and adrenal glands. A number of therapies have been devised for the treatment of chronic candidiasis, and have included both local and systemic medications. The most useful of these in the past have included the polyene antibiotics -- most notably, nystatin and amphotericin B. Antifungal activity has also been demonstrated clinically with the use of 5-fluorocytosine (a fluorinated pyramidine) and clotrimazole (a synthetic imidazole derivative). However, long-term therapy with medication has been required, and re-emergence of symptomatic infection has occurred when medications have been stopped. More recently, immune reconstitution with transfer factor has been employed in the treatment of patients who have been found to be anergic to candida. Such treatment in conjunction with chemotherapy has indicated that effective patient remissions can be obtained in those patients who develop and maintain cell-mediated immunity to candida. Twelve patients with chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis are profiled. Sites of involvement in the head and neck included the skin and hair (9), ears (9), nose (4) and throat (12). One patient had candida laryngitis, while five patients had evidence for esophageal disease. Of this latter group, one (a 5-year old boy) developed esophageal stenosis which required gastrostomy and retrograde esophageal dilatations. Nine patients were found to be anergic to candida. In these patients, systemic chemotherapy (as amphotericin B or 5-fluorocytosine) was used to induce remissions of disease and transfer factor was given to induce reactivity to candida. By so doing, topical or oral medications (utilizing miconazole, clotrimazole and nystatin) were found to suffice in maintaining effective local control of infection.

Thymosin therapy in the DiGeorge syndrome

Reconstruction of the T-cell immune defect in patients with the DiGeorge syndrome has been accomplished in the past by fetal thymus transplantation. Because of the risk of fatal graft-versus-host reaction with fetal thymus transplantation in patients with abnormal T-cell immunity, we have examined the effects of a thymus tissue extract, thymosin fraction 5, on the in vitro and in vivo immune function in children with the DiGeorge syndrome. T-cell numbers were increased with thymosin F5 in vitro in three of five patients. T-cell number and function was improved in three of four patients treated with thymosin F5 in vivo. Spontaneous improvement in the immune function of these patients cannot be excluded. These results suggest, however, that further trials with thymosin F5 therapy may be indicated in patients with the DiGeorge syndrome.

Fetal thymus transplantations in severe combined immunodeficiency

Two brothers with severe combined immunodeficiency were treated with repeated transplantations of fetal thymus tissue. The first patient was not treated until he was critically ill, and the intramuscular transplants had no effect. He died at 11 months of age of overwhelming pneumonia. At postmortem examination a transplanted thymus seemed viable. In the second patient an intramuscular transplant had no effect, but three subsequent intraperitoneal transplants led to transient increase in circulating T lymphocytes with a concomitant fall in B lymphocytes. The results suggested an additive effect of each transplant. However, delayed hypersensitivity skin tests and in vitro mitogen responses were not influenced. Initially, transfer factor was given, and fetal liver was administered intraperitoneally together with the last thymic transplant. Neither of these measures had any observed effect, and this patient, similarly, died of pneumonia at nearly 12 months of age.

Immunity to Candida albicans induced by Listeria monocytogenes

Immunity to Candida albicans was studied in Swiss-Webster white female mice. Lethal and sublethal infections with C. albicans did not enhance immunity to a subsequent Listeria monocytogenes challenge. Mice sensitized to L. monocytogenes and then challenged with C. albicans intravenously were able to reduce the population of C. albicans in their kidneys after being boosted (rechallenged) with L. monocytogenes. However, the acquired cellular immunity so induced was very short-lived. Both C. albicans-sensitized and nonsensitized control mice showed an immediate-type and delayed-type skin test response to the cell wall antigen(s) of C. albicans but not to the cytoplasmic antigen(s). There did not appear to be any correlation between increase in skin test response and progression of the candida infection in mice.

Effect of transfer factor on lymphocyte function in anergic patients

Dialyzable transfer factor, obtained from frozen-thawed peripheral blood leukocytes from a single donor, was given to five anergic patients with chronic mucocutaneous candidiasis. Studies of immunological responses including delayed cutaneous hypersensitivity, in vitro antigen-induced thymidine incorporation, and production of macrophage migration inhibition factor (MIF) were conducted both before and after injection of transfer factor. Before transfer factor, none of the patients had delayed skin responses to any of the natural antigens studied. Their lymphocytes did not produce MIF after exposure to antigens in vitro and only one patient showed increased thymidine incorporation when his lymphocytes were cultured with candida and streptokinase-streptodornase (SK-SD). After injection of transfer factor, four patients developed delayed skin responses to antigens to which the donor was sensitive; no recipient reacted to an antigen to which the donor was nonreactive. Lymphocytes from recipients produced MIF when cultured with antigens that evoked positive delayed skin tests. Only one patient developed antigen-induced lymphocyte transformation and this response occurred only intermittently. Attempts to sensitize three of the patients with the contact allergen, chlorodinitrobenzene, both before and after transfer factor, were unsuccessful. The fifth patient, a 9-yr old boy with an immunologic profile similar to the Nezelof syndrome, did not become skin test-reactive or develop positive responses to the in vitro tests. These findings suggest that transfer factor acts on the immunocompetent cells that respond to antigens with lymphokine production, but has little, if any, effect on cells that respond to antigens by blastogenesis. The failure to sensitize the subjects with chlorodinitrobenzene illustrates the specificity of the immunologic effects of transfer factor, and implies that it does not function through nonspecific, adjuvant-like mechanisms. Failure of transfer factor to produce positive skin tests or MIF production in a patient with Nezelof's syndrome may be evidence that lymphokine-producing cells are thymus derived.