A base change in the catalytic core of the hairpin ribozyme perturbs function but not domain docking

Intrinsic Base-Pair Rearrangement in the Hairpin Ribozyme Directs RNA Conformational Sampling and Tertiary Interface Formation

Dynamic fluctuations in RNA structure enable conformational changes that are required for catalysis and recognition. In the hairpin ribozyme, the catalytically active structure is formed as an intricate tertiary interface between two RNA internal loops. Substantial alterations in the structure of each loop are observed upon interface formation, or docking. The very slow on-rate for this relatively tight interaction has led us to hypothesize a double conformational capture mechanism for RNA-RNA recognition. We used extensive molecular dynamics simulations to assess conformational sampling in the undocked form of the loop domain containing the scissile phosphate (loop A). We observed several major accessible conformations with distinctive patterns of hydrogen bonding and base stacking interactions in the active-site internal loop. Several important conformational features characteristic of the docked state were observed in well-populated substates, consistent with the kinetic sampling of docking-competent states by isolated loop A. Our observations suggest a hybrid or multistage binding mechanism, in which initial conformational selection of a docking-competent state is followed by induced-fit adjustment to an in-line, chemically reactive state only after formation of the initial complex with loop B.

Disparate HDV ribozyme crystal structures represent intermediates on a rugged free-energy landscape

The hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme is a member of the class of small, self-cleaving catalytic RNAs found in a wide range of genomes from HDV to human. Both pre- and post-catalysis (precursor and product) crystal structures of the cis-acting genomic HDV ribozyme have been determined. These structures, together with extensive solution probing, have suggested that a significant conformational change accompanies catalysis. A recent crystal structure of a trans-acting precursor, obtained at low pH and by molecular replacement from the previous product conformation, conforms to the product, raising the possibility that it represents an activated conformer past the conformational change. Here, using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET), we discovered that cleavage of this ribozyme at physiological pH is accompanied by a structural lengthening in magnitude comparable to previous trans-acting HDV ribozymes. Conformational heterogeneity observed by FRET in solution appears to have been removed upon crystallization. Analysis of a total of 1.8 µsec of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations showed that the crystallographically unresolved cleavage site conformation is likely correctly modeled after the hammerhead ribozyme, but that crystal contacts and the removal of several 2'-oxygens near the scissile phosphate compromise catalytic in-line fitness. A cis-acting version of the ribozyme exhibits a more dynamic active site, while a G-1 residue upstream of the scissile phosphate favors poor fitness, allowing us to rationalize corresponding changes in catalytic activity. Based on these data, we propose that the available crystal structures of the HDV ribozyme represent intermediates on an overall rugged RNA folding free-energy landscape.

Fluorescence tools to investigate riboswitch structural dynamics

Riboswitches are novel regulatory elements that respond to cellular metabolites to control gene expression. They are constituted of highly conserved domains that have evolved to recognize specific metabolites. Such domains, so-called aptamers, are folded into intricate structures to enable metabolite recognition. Over the years, the development of ensemble and single-molecule fluorescence techniques has allowed to probe most of the mechanistic aspects of aptamer folding and ligand binding. In this review, we summarize the current fluorescence toolkit available to study riboswitch structural dynamics. We fist describe those methods based on fluorescent nucleotide analogues, mostly 2-aminopurine (2AP), to investigate short-range conformational changes, including some key steady-state and time-resolved examples that exemplify the versatility of fluorescent analogues as structural probes. The study of long-range structural changes by Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is mostly discussed in the context of single-molecule studies, including some recent developments based on the combination of single-molecule FRET techniques with controlled chemical denaturation methods. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Riboswitches.

Effect of transition metal ions on the fluorescence and Taq-catalyzed polymerase chain reaction of tricyclic cytidine analogs

The cytosine analogs 1,3-diaza-2-oxophenothiazine (tC) and 1,3-diaza-2-oxophenoxazine (tCo) stand out among fluorescent bases due to their unquenched fluorescence emission in double-stranded DNA. Recently, we reported a method for the generation of densely tCo-labeled DNA by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) that relied on the use of the extremely thermostable Deep Vent polymerase. We have now developed a protocol that employs the more commonly used Taq polymerase. Supplementing the PCR with Mn(2+) or Co(2+) ions dramatically increased the amount of tCo triphosphate (dtCoTP) incorporated and, thus, enhanced the brightness of the PCR products. The resulting PCR products could be easily detected in gels based on their intrinsic fluorescence. The Mn(2+) ions modulate the PCR by improving the bypass of template tCo and the overall catalytic efficiency. In contrast to the lower fidelity during tCo bypass, Mn(2+) improved the ability of Taq polymerase to distinguish between dtCoTP and dTTP when copying a template dA. Interestingly, Mn(2+) ions hardly affect the fluorescence emission of tC(o), whereas the coordination of Co(2+) ions with the phosphate groups of DNA and nucleotides statically quenches tC(o) fluorescence with small reciprocal Stern-Vollmer constants of 10-300μM.

RNA intramolecular dynamics by single-molecule FRET

Investigation of single RNA molecules using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) is a powerful approach to investigate dynamic and thermodynamic aspects of the folding process of a given RNA. Its application requires interdisciplinary work from the fields of chemistry, biochemistry, and physics. The present work gives detailed instructions on the synthesis of RNA molecules labeled with two fluorescent dyes interacting by FRET, as well as on their investigation by single-molecule fluorescence spectroscopy.

Use of fluorescence spectroscopy to elucidate RNA folding pathways

This overview unit discusses fluorescence spectroscopy as a tool for studying RNA folding. Ribozymes and oligonucleotides can be labeled with a fluorescent probe and analyzed to give information about both slow and fast kinetic processes with real-time data acquisition. The unit discusses the advantages and disadvantages of various pendant probes and nucleotide analogs, the analytical methods that can be used, instrument setup, control experiments, and a variety of kinetic experiments that can be performed, such as determination of rate constants.

Probing RNA structural dynamics and function by fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)

Biological function of RNA is often mediated by cyclic switching between several (meta-)stable arrangements of tertiary structure. Fluorophore labeling of RNA offers a unique view into these folding and conformational switching events, since a fluorescence signal is sensitive to its molecular environment and can be continuously monitored in real time to produce kinetic rate information. This unit focuses on the practical implications of using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) to probe RNA structural dynamics and function. FRET is a particularly powerful fluorescence technique since, in addition to kinetic data, it provides insights into the structural basis of a conformational rearrangement. Protocols describe how to postsynthetically label RNA for FRET and how to acquire and analyze FRET data. Support protocols describe methods for deprotecting synthetic RNA and for purifying RNA by gel electrophoresis and HPLC. Considerations for selecting appropriate RNA, fluorophores, and labeling strategies are discussed in detail in the commentary.

Focus on function: single molecule RNA enzymology

The ability of RNA to catalyze chemical reactions was first demonstrated 25 years ago with the discovery that group I introns and RNase P function as RNA enzymes (ribozymes). Several additional ribozymes were subsequently identified, most notably the ribosome, followed by intense mechanistic studies. More recently, the introduction of single molecule tools has dissected the kinetic steps of several ribozymes in unprecedented detail and has revealed surprising heterogeneity not evident from ensemble approaches. Still, many fundamental questions of how RNA enzymes work at the molecular level remain unanswered. This review surveys the current status of our understanding of RNA catalysis at the single molecule level and discusses the existing challenges and opportunities in developing suitable assays.

Mutational inhibition of ligation in the hairpin ribozyme: substitutions of conserved nucleobases A9 and A10 destabilize tertiary structure and selectively promote cleavage

The hairpin ribozyme acts as a reversible, site-specific endoribonuclease that ligates much more rapidly than it cleaves cognate substrate. While the reaction pathway for ligation is the reversal of cleavage, little is known about the atomic and electrostatic details of the two processes. Here, we report the functional consequences of molecular substitutions of A9 and A10, two highly conserved nucleobases located adjacent to the hairpin ribozyme active site, using G, C, U, 2-aminopurine, 2,6-diaminopurine, purine, and inosine. Cleavage and ligation kinetics were analyzed, tertiary folding was monitored by hydroxyl radical footprinting, and interdomain docking was studied by native gel electrophoresis. We determined that nucleobase substitutions that exhibit significant levels of interference with tertiary folding and interdomain docking have relatively large inhibitory effects on ligation rates while showing little inhibition of cleavage. Indeed, one variant, A10G, showed a fivefold enhancement of cleavage rate and no detectable ligation, and we suggest that this property may be uniquely well suited to intracellular targeted RNA cleavage applications. Results support a model in which formation of a kinetically stable tertiary structure is essential for ligation of the hairpin ribozyme, but is not necessary for cleavage.

Site-specific variations in RNA folding thermodynamics visualized by 2-aminopurine fluorescence

The fluorescent base analogue 2-aminopurine (2-AP) is commonly used to study specific conformational and protein binding events involving nucleic acids. Here, combinations of steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy of 2-AP were employed to monitor conformational transitions within a model hairpin RNA from diverse structural perspectives. RNA substrates adopting stable, unambiguous secondary structures were labeled with 2-AP at an unpaired base, within the loop, or inside the base-paired stem. Steady-state fluorescence was monitored as the RNA hairpins made the transitions between folded and unfolded conformations using thermal denaturation, urea titration, and cation-mediated folding. Unstructured control RNA substrates permitted the effects of higher-order RNA structures on 2-AP fluorescence to be distinguished from stimulus-dependent changes in intrinsic 2-AP photophysics and/or interactions with adjacent residues. Thermodynamic parameters describing local conformational changes were thus resolved from multiple perspectives within the model RNA hairpin. These data provided energetic bases for construction of folding mechanisms, which varied among different folding-unfolding stimuli. Time-resolved fluorescence studies further revealed that 2-AP exhibits characteristic signatures of component fluorescence lifetimes and respective fractional contributions in different RNA structural contexts. Together, these studies demonstrate localized conformational events contributing to RNA folding and unfolding that could not be observed by approaches monitoring only global structural transitions.

Cation-specific structural accommodation within a catalytic RNA

Metal ions facilitate the folding of the hairpin ribozyme but do not participate directly in catalysis. The metal complex cobalt(III) hexaammine supports folding and activity of the ribozyme and also mediates specific internucleotide photocrosslinks, several of which retain catalytic ability. These crosslinks imply that the active core structure organized by [Co(NH3)6]3+ is different from that organized by Mg2+ and that revealed in the crystal structure [Rupert, P. B., and Ferre-D'Amare, A. R. (2001) Nature 410, 780-786] (1). Residues U+2 and C+3 of the substrate, in particular, adopt different conformations in [Co(NH3)6]3+. U+2 is bulged out of loop A and stacked on residue G36, whereas the nucleotide at position +3 is stacked on G8, a nucleobase crucial for catalysis. Cleavage kinetics performed with +2 variants and a C+3 U variant correlate with the crosslinking observations. Variants that decreased cleavage rates in magnesium up to 70-fold showed only subtle decreases or even increases in observed rates when assayed in [Co(NH3)6]3+. Here, we propose a model of the [Co(NH3)6]3+-mediated catalytic core generated by MC-SYM that is consistent with these data.

Pyrrolo-C as a fluorescent probe for monitoring RNA secondary structure formation

Pyrrolo-C (PC), or 3-[beta-D-2-ribofuranosyl]-6-methylpyrrolo[2,3-d]pyrimidin-2(3H)-one, is a fluorescent analog of the nucleoside cytidine that retains its Watson-Crick base-pairing capacity with G. Due to its red-shifted absorbance, it can be selectively excited in the presence of natural nucleosides, making it a potential site-specific probe for RNA structure and dynamics. Similar to 2-aminopurine nucleoside, which base-pairs with uridine (or thymidine), PC's fluorescence becomes reversibly quenched upon base-pairing, most likely due to stacking interactions with neighboring bases. To test its utility as an RNA probe, we examined PC's fluorescent properties over a wide range of ionic strengths, pH, organic cosolvents, and temperatures. Incorporation of PC into a single-stranded RNA results in an approximately 60% reduction of fluorescence intensity, while duplex formation reduces the fluorescence by approximately 75% relative to the free ribonucleoside. We find that the fluorescence intensity of PC is only moderately affected by ionic strength, pH, and temperature, while it is slightly enhanced by organic cosolvents, making it a versatile probe for a broad range of buffer conditions. We demonstrate two applications for PC: fluorescent measurements of the kinetics of formation and dissociation of an RNA/DNA complex, and fluorescent monitoring of the thermal denaturation of the central segment of an RNA duplex. Taken together, our data showcase the potential of pyrrolo-C as an effective fluorescent probe to study RNA structure, dynamics, and function, complementary to the popular 2-aminopurine ribonucleoside.

In vitro selection of second site revertants analysis of the hairpin ribozyme active site

We have used in vitro genetics to evaluate the function and interactions of the conserved base G8 in the hairpin ribozyme catalytic RNA. Second site revertant selection for a G8X mutant, where X is any of the other three natural nucleobases, yielded a family of second site suppressors of the G8U mutant, but not of G8C or G8A, indicating that only G and U can be tolerated at position 8 of the ribozyme. This result is consistent with recent observations that point to the functional importance of G8 N-1 in the chemistry of catalysis by this ribozyme reaction. Suppression of the G8U mutation was observed when changes were made directly across loop A from the mutated base at substrate position +2 or positions +2 and +3 in combination. The same changes made in the context of the natural G8 sequence resulted in a very large drop in activity. Thus, the G8U mutation results in a change in specificity of the ribozyme from 5'-N / GUC-3' to 5'-N / GCU-3'. The results presented imply that G8 interacts directly with U+2 during catalysis. We propose that this interaction favors the correct positioning of the catalytic determinants of G8. The implications for the folding of the ribozyme and the catalytic mechanism are discussed.

Folding and catalysis by the VS ribozyme

The VS ribozyme is a 154 nt self-cleaving RNA molecule that can be divided into a trans-acting five-helix ribozyme and stem-loop substrate. The structure of the ribozyme is organised by two three-way helical junctions, the structure of which has been determined by a combination of comparative gel electrophoresis and fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments. From this, the overall global architecture of the ribozyme has been deduced. The substrate is then thought to dock into the cleft formed between helices II and VI, where it makes a close interaction with the loop containing A730. The A730 loop is the probable active site of the ribozyme, and A756 within it is a strong candidate to play a direct role in the transesterification chemistry, possibly by general acid-base catalysis.

Activity of HDV ribozymes to trans-cleave HCV RNA

AIM: To explore whether HDV ribozymes have the ability to trans-cleave HCV RNA.

METHODS: Three HDV genomic ribozymes were designed and named RzC1, RzC2 and RzC3. The substrate RNA contained HCV RNA 5’-noncoding region and 5'-fragment of C region (5'-NCR-C). All the ribozymes and HCV RNA 5'-NCR-C were obtained by transcription in vitro from their DNA templates, and HCV RNA 5'-NCR-C was radiolabelled at its 5’-end. Under certain pH, temperature, appropriate concentration of Mg²⁺ and deionized formamide, these ribozymes were respectively or simultaneously mixed with HCV RNA 5'-NCR-C and reacted for a certain time. The trans-cleavage reaction was stopped at different time points, and the products were separated with polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE), displayed by autoradiography. Percentage of trans-cleaved products was measured to indicate the activity of HDV ribozymes.

RESULTS: RzC1 and RzC2 could trans-cleave 26% and 21.8% of HCV RNA 5'-NCR-C under our reaction conditions with 2.5 mol•L^-1 deionized formamide respectively. The percentage of HCV RNA 5'-NCR-C trans-cleaved by RzC1, RzC2 or combined usage of the three ribozymes increased with time, up to 24.9%, 20.3% and 37.3% respectively at 90 min point. Almost no product from RzC3 was observed.

CONCLUSION: HDV ribozymes are able to trans-cleave specifically HCV RNA at certain sites under appropriate conditions, and combination of several ribozymes aiming at different target sites can trans-cleave the substrate more efficiently than using only one of them.

In the fluorescent spotlight: global and local conformational changes of small catalytic RNAs

RNA is a ubiquitous biopolymer that performs a multitude of essential cellular functions involving the maintenance, transfer, and processing of genetic information. RNA is unique in that it can carry both genetic information and catalytic function. Its secondary structure domains, which fold stably and independently, assemble hierarchically into modular tertiary structures. Studies of these folding events are key to understanding how catalytic RNAs (ribozymes) are able to position reaction components for site-specific chemistry. We have made use of fluorescence techniques to monitor the rates and free energies of folding of the small hairpin and hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozymes, found in satellite RNAs of plant and the human hepatitis B viruses, respectively. In particular, fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) has been employed to monitor global conformational changes, and 2-aminopurine fluorescence quenching to probe for local structural rearrangements. In this review we illuminate what we have learned about the reaction pathways of the hairpin and HDV ribozymes, and how our results have complemented other biochemical and biophysical investigations. The structural transitions observed in these two small catalytic RNAs are likely to be found in many other biological RNAs, and the described fluorescence techniques promise to be broadly applicable.

Rescue of an abasic hairpin ribozyme by cationic nucleobases: evidence for a novel mechanism of RNA catalysis

The hairpin ribozyme catalyzes a reversible phosphodiester cleavage reaction. We examined the roles of conserved nucleobases in catalysis using an abasic ribozyme rescue strategy. Loss of the active site G8 nucleobase reduced the cleavage rate constant by 350-fold while loss of A9 and A10 nucleobases reduced activity less than 10-fold. Certain heterocyclic amines restored partial activity when provided in solution to the variant lacking G8. Heterocyclic amines that were capable of rescue shared the exocyclic amine and cyclic amide in common with the Watson-Crick hydrogen bonding face of guanine. In contrast to the shallow pH dependence of unmodified ribozyme activity, rescue activity increased sharply with decreasing pH. These results support a novel model for RNA catalysis in which a cationic nucleobase contributes electrostatic stabilization to negative charge developing in the transition state.

Spermine supports catalysis of hairpin ribozyme variants to differing extents

Because of the ability to cleave RNA substrates in trans, the hairpin ribozyme has great potential for therapeutic application. Activity of a three-stranded version of the minimal truncated form is enhanced by the presence of the polyamine spermine. Since spermine is the most abundant polyamine in eucariots, improved prospects for the hairpin ribozyme as therapeutic agent were predicted. We have found that not all hairpin ribozyme variants accept spermine equally well as counter-ion. Particularly the two-stranded versions commonly used for therapeutic studies show rather decreased activity when spermine is present. We have investigated a number of hairpin ribozyme derivatives regarding their ability to carry out spermine supported catalysis. Among the studied structures a two-stranded reverse-joined hairpin ribozyme displayed the highest cleavage rates in a synergistic mixture of magnesium ions and spermine. The specific features of this ribozyme along with its potential for in vivo application are discussed.