The value of sonohysterography combined with cytological analysis of the fluid retrieved from the endometrial cavity in predicting histological diagnosis

A new diagnostic test for endometrial cancer?: Cytology analysis of sonohysterography distention media

OBJECTIVE

During saline-infused sonohysterography (SIS), the distension fluid is typically discarded. If cytology analysis could identify those patients with endometrial cancer, many women would be spared from further procedures.

METHODS

Thirty consecutive patients with clinical stage I or II endometrial adenocarcinoma were prospectively recruited preoperatively. Saline-infused sonohysterography was performed by instilling 5 mL of saline, withdrawing and sending for analysis. Saline was reinfused until complete SIS images were obtained and sent separately for cytology.

RESULTS

Of the 30 women enrolled, SIS was technically successful in 29. Demographics included mean age (60.5 ± 6.99 years), body mass index (35.55 ± 8.18 kg/m), endometrioid histology (76%), and grade (grade 1, 67%). Prestudy diagnostic method included biopsy (70%), dilatation and curettage (17%), and hysteroscopy (10%). Adequate cytology specimens were obtained in 66% of the 5 mL flushes and 72% of the complete SIS collections. Of adequate specimens, the sensitivities to detect endometrial cancer for the 5-mL, complete, and combined fluid samples were 26% (95% confidence interval, 9%-51%), 36% (17%-59%), and 42% (22%-63%). Sensitivity based on the whole study sample (N = 30) was 33% (17%-53%). Statistical significance was not found in the association between a positive test and age, body mass index, grade, diagnostic method, or volume instilled or aspirated.

CONCLUSIONS

Most patients with early endometrial cancer can undergo SIS procedures with adequate cytology specimens obtained from distention media. However, the sensitivity is low, and refinements are necessary before utilizing as a diagnostic test. In cases with positive results, the patient may be able to avoid other costly and painful procedures.

Value of sonohysterography in preoperative assessment of myometrial invasion for patients with endometrial cancer

OBJECTIVE

The aims of this study were to compare the diagnostic performance of sonohysterography (SH) with that of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in estimation of myometrial invasion and to evaluate the influence of SH on peritoneal cytologic results for patients with endometrial cancer.

METHODS

Seventy-four patients with endometrial cancer were included. Sonohysterography and MRI were performed before surgery. All patients had complete staging procedures, including peritoneal cytologic analyses. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) were determined for SH and MRI.

RESULTS

The concordance rates of myometrial invasion for SH and MRI were 82.4% and 81.1%, respectively. The sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV for identification of deep myometrial invasion were 64.7%, 87.7%, 61.1%, and 89.3% on SH and 70.6%, 84.2%, 57.1%, and 90.6% on MRI. Two patients (2.7%) were found to have positive results for malignant cells on peritoneal cytologic analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

Sonohysterography appears to be a useful preoperative method for predicting myometrial invasion, comparable to MRI.

Endometrial directed biopsy during sonohysterography using the NiGo device: prospective study in women with abnormal uterine bleeding

OBJECTIVE

To determine the accuracy of sonohysterography (SHG), combined with sonography-guided biopsies that are performed by using the NiGo device, in the diagnosis of endometrial pathologies in women with abnormal uterine bleeding (AUB).

DESIGN

Prospective study.

SETTING

Outpatient clinic.

PATIENT(S)

One hundred sixteen women with AUB (55 postmenopausal and 61 premenopausal).

INTERVENTION(S)

Patients underwent transvaginal sonography and SHG; when an endometrial condition needing a biopsy was diagnosed, the biopsy was performed both by using the NiGo device (ASL 1, Imperia, Italy) and by using Pipelle.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Feasibility of SHG and endometrial biopsy by NiGo.

RESULT(S)

Sonohysterography was successfully performed by using the NiGo device in 87.4% of the cases (92.6% of premenopausal women and 81.5% of postmenopausal women). Seventy-eight (86.7%) women were judged to require endometrial biopsy; the NiGo device allowed obtaining an adequate biopsy for histological evaluation in 74 cases (94.9%). There was no statistically significant difference in efficacy between the NiGo and Pipelle in providing a specimen that was adequate for histological evaluation. Although no significant difference was observed in the histological diagnosis performed on the specimens obtained by the two techniques, NiGo allowed diagnosis of more focal lesions (simple hyperplasia, endometrial polyps, and myomas).

CONCLUSION(S)

The NiGo device allows an adequate biopsy for histological evaluation to be obtained during SHG in an outpatient setting.

Sonohysterographic endometrial sampling and hysteroscopic endometrial biopsy: a comparative study

OBJECTIVES

To compare the quantity and quality of endometrial tissue sampled at saline contrast sonohysterography (SCSH) with that obtained by directed endometrial biopsy by operative hysteroscopy in patients with diffusely thickened and/or inhomogeneous endometrium at SCSH. A secondary aim was a comparison of the extent of procedure-related pain.

METHODS

One hundred and twenty-eight patients with diffusely thickened (> 4 mm) and/or inhomogeneous endometrium at SCSH were prospectively recruited. Endometrial sampling was performed at the end of SCSH using the same 4.7-mm intrauterine catheter that had been used for saline instillation. These samples were compared to directed endometrial biopsies obtained with the guidance of an office 5-mm hysteroscope. After hysteroscopy, an extended guided curettage was performed under general anesthesia, providing specimens that were considered the gold standard for histological diagnosis. Endometrial specimen area (mm(2)), histologic concordance and procedure related pain (10-cm VAS) were compared for the two techniques.

RESULTS

The median age of 88 pre- and of 40 post-menopausal patients was 41 (interquartile range, 34-48) years and 57 (interquartile range, 52-67) years, respectively. The median area of endometrial specimen obtained by SCSH was 25.1 (interquartile range, 12.4-52.3) mm(2) and was not significantly different from that obtained by hysteroscopy (16.9 (interquartile range, 10.0-52.7) mm(2)). The K values of the two different techniques for typical hyperplasia (n = 61) and for premalignant and malignant lesions (n = 26) were 0.91 and 0.94, respectively. Procedure-related pain was not significantly different between pre- and postmenopausal patients for both sampling techniques.

CONCLUSIONS

SCSH with sampling proved to be as good as and as tolerable as hysteroscopic biopsy in cases with diffusely thickened and/or inhomogeneous endometrium. Both these imaging and biopsy techniques should be considered a reliable outpatient procedure in the management of patients with abnormal uterine bleeding. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

A new technique to obtain endometrial directed biopsy during sonohysterography: the NiGo device

The primary goal of the clinical evaluation of abnormal uterine bleeding is to establish a specific diagnosis in the most efficient and least invasive manner possible. Hysteroscopy (HS) allows physicians to obtain directed biopsy in addition to direct visualization of the uterine cavity and lesions, but often requires ambulatory surgery centers and some anesthesia, or can potentially result in significant patient discomfort. Sonohysterography (SHG) is less invasive than HS but does not allow a histologic sample. A new technique, called the Nicoletti-Gorlero (NiGo) device, was developed and evaluated to obtain histologic results during SHG. This study is a prospective, observational evaluation between the NiGo device technique and standard HS to obtain endometrial samples. The NiGo device was used to obtain an endometrial sample during SHG in 18 women. In a subsequent session, HS was performed to verify the results. From January 2005 through November 2005 both procedures (SHG + biopsy and HS) were performed on 18 patients. The SHG procedures using the NiGo forcep were performed successfully on 15 out of 18 women, and the endometrial sample was obtained in 14 out of 15 patients. In one patient, the endometrial biopsy obtained provided too little tissue to accomplish histologic evaluation. All 13 pathologic results obtained with the NiGo device were identical with those subsequently obtained with HS. The office-based HS procedure was not successful in two women; in these women, an HS procedure performed in the operating room was necessary. The NiGo device technique allows the physician to obtain sonographic-guided biopsies of the entire endometrium during SHG. The technique is less invasive compared with HS. In our small series, there were no complications during the procedure.

Sonohysterography: a prospective survey of results and complications in 81 patients

PURPOSE

To evaluate the sonohysterography (SHG) for the diagnosis of intrauterine abnormalities and describe complications and failure rate.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective survey on 81 patients, (44 patients with menometrorrhagia, 30 with postmenopausal bleeding and 7 with infertility) was conducted. Histopathology and clinical survey, if sonohysterography was normal, were the gold standards.

RESULTS

Pathology has been performed in 55 cases. There were four failures (cervical stenosis), one severe complication (endometritis), one pelvic pain. Sensitivity and specificity of sonography were 56 and 83%; for sonohysterography 88 and 98%; and for hysteroscopy 78 and 97%. Sonohysterography was accurate for the diagnosis of the submucous myoma component.

CONCLUSION

Sonohysterography is available in uterine pathology, easy, safe and cheap, but sonographists and patients should be informed of the little risks of such examination technique.