Interaction between responses in Purkinje cells evoked by climbing fibre impulses and parallel fibre volleys in the cat

Beyond "all-or-nothing" climbing fibers: graded representation of teaching signals in Purkinje cells

Arguments about the function of the climbing fiber (CF) input to the cerebellar cortex have fueled a rabid debate that started over 40 years ago, and continues to polarize the field to this day. The origin of the controversy can be traced back to 1969, the year David Marr published part of his dissertation work in a paper entitled “A theory of cerebellar cortex.” In Marr’s theory, CFs play a key role during the process of motor learning, providing an instructive signal that serves as a “teacher” for the post-synaptic Purkinje cells. Although this influential idea has found its way into the mainstream, a number of objections have been raised. For example, several investigators have pointed out that the seemingly “all-or-nothing” activation of the CF input provides little information and is too ambiguous to serve as an effective instructive signal. Here, we take a fresh look at these arguments in light of new evidence about the peculiar physiology of CFs. Based on recent findings we propose that at the level of an individual Purkinje cell, a graded instructive signal can be effectively encoded via pre- or post-synaptic modulation of its one and only CF input.

The periaqueductal grey modulates sensory input to the cerebellum: a role in coping behaviour?

The paths that link the periaqueductal grey (PAG) to hindbrain motor circuits underlying changes in behavioural responsiveness to external stimuli are unknown. A major candidate structure for mediating these effects is the cerebellum. The present experiments test this directly by monitoring changes in size of cerebellar responses evoked by peripheral stimuli following activation of the PAG. In 22 anaesthetized adult Wistar rats, climbing fibre field potentials were recorded from the C1 zone in the paramedian lobule and the copula pyramidis of the cerebellar cortex evoked, respectively, by electrical stimulation of the ipsilateral fore- and hindlimb. An initial and a late response were attributable to activation of Abeta and Adelta peripheral afferents respectively (hindlimb onset latencies 16.9 and 23.8 ms). Chemical stimulation at physiologically-identified sites in the ventrolateral PAG (a region known to be associated with hyporeactive immobility) resulted in a significant reduction in size of both the Abeta and Adelta evoked field potentials (mean reduction relative to control +/- SEM, 59 +/- 7.5 and 66 +/- 11.9% respectively). Responses evoked by electrical stimulation of the dorsal or ventral funiculus of the spinal cord were also reduced by PAG stimulation, suggesting that part of the modulation may occur at supraspinal sites (including at the level of the inferior olive). Overall, the results provide novel evidence of descending control into motor control centres, and provide the basis for future studies into the role of the PAG in regulating motor activity in different behavioural states and in chronic pain.

The origin of the complex spike in cerebellar Purkinje cells

Activation of the climbing fiber input powerfully excites cerebellar Purkinje cells via hundreds of widespread dendritic synapses, triggering dendritic spikes as well as a characteristic high-frequency burst of somatic spikes known as the complex spike. To investigate the relationship between dendritic spikes and the spikelets within the somatic complex spike, and to evaluate the importance of the dendritic distribution of climbing fiber synapses, we made simultaneous somatic and dendritic patch-clamp recordings from Purkinje cells in cerebellar slices. Injection of large climbing fiber-like synaptic conductances at the soma using dynamic clamp was sufficient to reproduce the complex spike, independently of dendritic spikes, indicating that neither a dendritic synaptic distribution nor dendritic spikes are required. Furthermore, we found that dendritic spikes are not directly linked to spikelets in the complex spike, and that each dendritic spike is associated with only 0.24 +/- 0.09 extra somatic spikelets. Rather, we demonstrate that dendritic spikes regulate the pause in firing that follows the complex spike. Finally, using dual somatic and axonal recording, we show that all spikelets in the complex spike are axonally generated. Thus, complex spike generation proceeds relatively independently of dendritic spikes, reflecting the dual functional role of climbing fiber input: triggering plasticity at dendritic synapses and generating a distinct output signal in the axon. The encoding of dendritic spiking by the post-complex spike pause provides a novel computational function for dendritic spikes, which could serve to link these two roles at the level of the target neurons in the deep cerebellar nuclei.

Transformation of the kinematic characteristics of a precise movement after a change in a spatial task

The central mechanism of motor programming was studied using a model of precise horizontal flexion of the arm at the elbow joint. Training was performed in the dark to ensure that formation of the motor program was based predominantly on the use of proprioceptive afferentation. The target was not demonstrated before training: subjects determined the angle of arm flexion during training, the moment at which the target position was reached being identified by a brief LED flash. Subjects had to perform the movement as quickly and accurately as possible. The amplitude, speed, and accuracy of the movement were measured in real time. The ten subjects were divided into two groups for initial training to precise movements, using two different protocols: flexion of the elbow to 70 degrees and to 55 degrees . At the second stage of the experiment, each subject's initial target position was suddenly changed (from 70 degrees to 55 degrees and vice versa). Training was continued until a stable accuracy in the new conditions was achieved (with errors of no more than 5% of the specified amplitude). The nature of the transformation in the kinematics of the precise movement in response to the change in the single task parameter illuminated the fundamental principle of organization of the supraspinal motor command for movements of this type. For both specified flexion amplitudes, the ratio between the acceleration and deceleration phases of the movement were identical during the period of skill fixation. On average, 70% of the total amplitude of flexion was accounted for by the acceleration phase and 30% by the deceleration phase. Adaptation of the precise movement to changes in the specified horizontal elbow flexion angle (i.e., re-achievement of the required movement accuracy in the changed conditions) during rearrangement was completed by inversion of these values. According to the results of previous studies, the most informative measure for analysis of the dynamics of the controlling central command was the acceleration of the movement. In terms of current concepts of the mechanism of motor control, the acceleration plateau can be regarded as mirroring long-term depression--the voltage plateau in Purkinje cells and motoneurons. Data processing involved calculation of the integral acceleration in both phases of the movement in relation to the angle of flexion (phase plots). These data underlie our understanding of the mechanism of transformation of movement kinematics responsible for the formation of a new central command.

Pathological alterations of the climbing fibres of the cerebellum in vascular dementia: a Golgi and electron microscope study

The climbing fibres originating from the inferior olivary nucleus act as a powerful excitation on the Purkinje cells of the cerebellar cortex that may play a substantial role in the motor performances and the learning of new motor skills. In vascular dementia the existent vascular alterations may induce many hypoxic or ischemic phenomena, among the others, in the olivocerebellar system affecting the climbing fibres in their way to the molecular layer of the cerebellar cortex. In autopsy cases of vascular dementia, the application of silver impregnation technique and electron microscopy revealed a substantial decrease of the number of the climbing fibres in the cortex of the vermis, the flocculus and the cerebellar hemispheres. The presynaptic varicosities and the synaptic terminals of the climbing fibres on the Purkinje cell dendrites were decreased in number and moreover were characterized by a marked poverty of synaptic vesicles. The synaptic cleft was mostly abnormal and wider than 20 nm. Mitochondrial abnormalities, such as elongated mitochondria with disruption of the cristae were seen in the terminal branches of the climbing fibre arborization as well as in the presynaptic components. The blood capillaries demonstrated a considerable thickness of the basal membrane and perivascular astrocytic proliferation, whereas the tight junctions between the endothelial cells were ultrastructurally intact. We would hypothesize that the morphological and morphometric alterations of the climbing fibres of the cerebellar cortex in cases of vascular dementia might be associated with the frequently noticed difficulty in the performance of fine and skilful movements by the patients.

Targeted calretinin expression in granule cells of calretinin-null mice restores normal cerebellar functions

Ca2 binding proteins such as calretinin, characterized by the presence of EF-hand motifs that bind Ca2+ ions, are involved in the shaping of intraneuronal Ca2+ fluxes. In the cerebellar cortex, information processing tightly relies on variations in intracellular Ca2+ concentration in Purkinje and granule cells. Calretinin-deficient (Cr-/-) mice present motor discoordination, suggesting cellular and network cerebellar dysfunctions. To determine the cell specificity of these alterations, we constructed transgenic Cr-/- mice exhibiting a selective reexpression of calretinin in granule cells through the promoter function of the GABAA receptor alpha6 subunit gene. Normal granule cell excitability and wild-type Purkinje cell firing behavior in awake mice were restored while the emergence of high-frequency oscillations was abolished. Behavioral analysis of these calretinin-rescue mice revealed that normal motor coordination was restored as compared with Cr-/- mice. These results demonstrate that calretinin is required specifically in granule cells for correct computation in the cerebellar cortex and indicate that the finetuning of granule cell excitability through regulation of Ca2+ homeostasis plays a crucial role for information coding and storage in the cerebellum.

Imaging parallel fiber and climbing fiber responses and their short-term interactions in the mouse cerebellar cortex in vivo

A major question in the study of cerebellar cortical function is how parallel fiber and climbing fiber inputs interact to shape information processing. Emphasis has been placed on the long-term effects due to conjunctive stimulation of climbing fibers and parallel fibers. Much less emphasis has been placed on short-term interactions and their spatial nature. To address this question the responses to parallel fiber and climbing fiber inputs and their short-term interaction were characterized using optical imaging with Neutral Red in the anesthetized mouse in vivo. Electrical stimulation of the cerebellar surface evoked an increase in fluorescence consisting of a transverse optical beam. The linear relationship between the optical responses and stimulus parameters, high spatial resolution and close coupling to the electrophysiological recordings show the utility of this imaging methodology. The majority of the optical response was due to activation of postsynaptic alpha-amino-3-hydroxyl-5-methyl-4-isoxazole propionate (AMPA) and metabotropic glutamate receptors with a minor contribution from the presynaptic parallel fibers. Stimulation of the inferior olive evoked parasagittal bands that were abolished by blocking AMPA glutamate receptors. Conjunctive stimulation of the cerebellar surface and inferior olive resulted in inhibition of the climbing fiber evoked optical responses. This lateral inhibition of the parasagittal bands extended out from both sides of an activated parallel fiber beam and was mediated by GABA(A) but not GABA(B) receptors. One hypothesized role for lateral inhibition of this type is to spatially focus the interactions between parallel fiber and climbing fiber input on Purkinje cells. In summary optical imaging with Neutral Red permitted visualization of cerebellar cortical responses to parallel fiber and climbing fiber activation. The GABA(A) dependent lateral inhibition of the climbing fiber evoked parasagittal bands by parallel fiber stimulation shows that cerebellar interneurons play a short-term role in shaping the responses of Purkinje cells to climbing fiber input.

'New' functions for 'old' proteins: the role of the calcium-binding proteins calbindin D-28k, calretinin and parvalbumin, in cerebellar physiology. Studies with knockout mice

Calretinin (CR), calbindin D-28k (CB) and parvalbumin (PV) belong to the large family of EF-hand calcium-binding proteins, which comprises more than 200 members in man. Structurally these proteins are characterized by the presence of a variable number of evolutionary well-conserved helix-loop-helix motives, which bind Ca2+ ions with high affinity. Functionally, they fall into two groups: by interaction with target proteins, calcium sensors translate calcium concentrations into signaling cascades, whereas calcium buffers are thought to modify the spatiotemporal aspects of calcium transients. Although CR, CB and PV are currently being considered calcium buffers, this may change as we learn more about their biology. Remarkable differences in their biophysical properties have led to the distinction of fast and slow buffers and suggested functional specificity of individual calcium buffers. Evaluation of the physiological roles of CR, CB and PV has been facilitated by the recent generation of mouse strains deficient in these proteins. Here, we review the biology of these calcium-binding proteins with distinct reference to the cerebellum, since they are particularly enriched in specific cerebellar neurons. CR is principally expressed in granule cells and their parallel fibres, while PV and CB are present throughout the axon, soma, dendrites and spines of Purkinje cells. PV is additionally found in a subpopulation of inhibitory interneurons, the stellate and basket cells. Studies on deficient mice together with in vitro work and their unique cell type-specific distribution in the cerebellum suggest that these calcium-binding proteins have evolved as functionally distinct, physiologically relevant modulators of intracellular calcium transients. Analysis of different brain regions suggests that these proteins are involved in regulating calcium pools critical for synaptic plasticity. Surprisingly, a major role of any of these three calcium-binding proteins as an endogenous neuroprotectant is not generally supported.

Role of climbing fibers in determining the spatial patterns of activation in the cerebellar cortex to peripheral stimulation: an optical imaging study

The spatial patterns of activation in the rat cerebellar cortex evoked by ipsilateral face stimulation were mapped using optical imaging based on the pH sensitive dye, Neutral Red. The aims of the study were to characterize the optical responses evoked by peripheral stimulation and test the hypothesis that the resultant parasagittal banding is due to climbing fiber activation. In the anesthetized rat Crus I and II of the cerebellar cortex were stained with Neutral Red. Epi-fluorescent changes produced by a train of stimuli (5-10s and 4-20 Hz) to the ipsilateral face were monitored in time using a fast, high resolution charge-coupled device camera. The patterns of activation were quantified using a two-dimensional fast Fourier transform analysis that removed signals with high spatial frequencies and minimized the contribution of horizontal structural elements (i.e. blood vessels). The dominant spatial pattern of activation evoked by face stimulation was that of parasagittal bands. The bands were highly frequency-dependent and were elicited most strongly by stimulus frequencies in the range of 6-8 Hz. There was a large fall-off in the response for frequencies above and below. The optical signal evoked by face stimulation built up over a period of 10s and then gradually decayed. Within a folium the individual parasagittal bands exhibited some frequency and temporal specificity. Stimulation of the contralateral inferior olive also resulted in the activation of parasagittal bands with characteristics similar to the bands evoked by face stimulation, including a preferred stimulus frequency which peaked at 10 Hz. Injection of lidocaine into the contralateral inferior olive blocked the parasagittal bands evoked by ipsilateral face stimulation, while control injections of saline had no effect. The results confirm that a parasagittal banding pattern is a dominant feature of the functional architecture of the cerebellar cortex. The parasagittal banding pattern observed with Neutral Red is due primarily to the activation of climbing fiber afferents. The frequency tuning of the responses, with the preference for peripheral stimuli of 6-8 Hz, is in agreement with previous findings that the inferior olive is inherently rhythmic. These observations support the hypothesis that inferior olivary neurons are dynamically coupled into groups that activate parasagittal bands of Purkinje cells in the cerebellar cortex. The frequency tuning also supports the hypothesis that the climbing fiber system is involved with timing. Activation of this afferent system may require stimuli with appropriate frequency content and stimuli synchronized to the rhythmicity of the inferior olive.

Impaired motor coordination and Purkinje cell excitability in mice lacking calretinin

In the cerebellum, the parallel fiber-Purkinje cell synapse can undergo long-term synaptic plasticity suggested to underlie motor learning and resulting from variations in intracellular calcium concentration ([Ca2+]i). Ca2+ binding proteins are enriched in the cerebellum, but their role in information processing is not clear. Here, we show that mice deficient in calretinin (Cr-/-) are impaired in tests of motor coordination. An impairment in Ca2+ homeostasis in Cr-/- Purkinje cells was supported by the high Ca2+-saturation of calbindin-D28k in these cells. The firing behavior of Purkinje cells is severely affected in Cr-/- alert mice, with alterations of simple spike firing rate, complex spike duration, and simple spike pause. In contrast, in slices, transmission at parallel fiber- or climbing fiber-Purkinje cell synapses is unaltered, indicating that marked modifications of the firing behavior in vivo can be undetectable in slice. Thus, these results show that calretinin plays a major role at the network level in cerebellar physiology.

Analysis of spontaneous electrical activity in cerebellar Purkinje cells acutely isolated from postnatal rats

Whole-cell patch recording techniques were used to analyze spontaneous electrical activity in cerebellar Purkinje cells acutely isolated from postnatal rats. Spontaneous activity was present in 65% of the cells examined, and it included simple and complex firing patterns which persisted under conditions that eliminated residual or reformed synaptic contacts. Under voltage clamp, both spontaneous and quiescent cells displayed similar voltage-dependent conductances. Inward current was carried by Na+ through tetrodotoxin (TTX)-sensitive channels and by Ca2+ through P-type and T-type Ca channels. P-type current was present in all cells examined. T-type current was found in <50%, and it did not correlate with spontaneous activity. We found no evidence of a transient (A-type) potassium current or hyperpolarization-activated cationic current in either spontaneous or quiescent cells. Spontaneous activity did correlate with a lower activation threshold of the Na current, resulting in substantial overlap of the activation and inactivation curves. TTX reduced the holding current of spontaneous cells clamped between -50 and -30 mV, consistent with the presence of a Na "window" current. We were unable, however, to measure a persistent component of the Na current using voltage steps, a result which may reflect the complex gating properties of Na channels. An Na window current could provide the driving force underlying spontaneous activity, as well as plateau potentials, in Purkinje cells.

Spatial synaptic integration in Purkinje cell dendrites

Synaptic integration occurs within a framework of synaptic connections, and cell type-specific, intrinsic and transmitter-gated ion channels. These components are differentially distributed over the somato-dendritic membrane. Recent results from Purkinje cells and pyramidal cells exemplify some of these mechanisms of spatial synaptic integration. This paper focusses on the cerebellar Purkinje cell. In these neurons, the amplitude and distribution of single climbing fibre and parallel fibre EPSP-evoked Ca2+ influx were regulated by the transient outward, IA-like current in the distal (spiny) dendrites. The synaptically evoked Ca2+ influx was graded from a local response involving only a few terminal spiny dendrites to a propagated Ca2+ spike. The climbing fibre-evoked Ca2+ influx in the spiny dendrites was finely graded by parallel fibre-induced depolarization. Climbing fibre and parallel fibre-evoked Ca2+ influx elicited a short lasting afterhyperpolarization that affected subsequent dendritic Ca2+ influx. In addition, inhibitory synaptic input controlled dendritic Ca2+ influx. Interaction between information from different sources along the dendrites is thus controlled by intrinsic potassium conductances and IPSPs. Different electrophysiological properties are found in the cerebellar neurons. Thus, Golgi cells, stellate cells and granule cells seem to integrate on a shorter intrinsic timescale than do Purkinje cells, the output neuron of the cerebellar cortex. The specific mechanisms by which different types of presynaptic neurons specifically innervate a given dendritic compartment remain to be elucidated, but recent results provide some experimental evidence of a differential distribution of cell adhesion molecules between the axonal and the somato-dendritic membrane, suggesting one mechanism contributing to the ordered distribution of synapses during synaptogenesis.