Combinatorial blockade of calcineurin and CD28 signaling facilitates primary and secondary therapeutic gene transfer by adenovirus vectors in dystrophic (mdx) mouse muscles

Early administration of L-arginine in mdx neonatal mice delays the onset of muscular dystrophy in tibialis anterior (TA) muscle

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a genetic disorder that results in the absence of dystrophin, a cytoskeletal protein. Individuals with this disease experience progressive muscle destruction, which leads to muscle weakness. Studies have been conducted to find solutions for the relief of individuals with this disease, several of which have shown that utrophin, a protein closely related to dystrophin, when overexpressed in mdx neonatal mice (the murine model of DMD), is able to prevent the progressive muscle destruction observed in the absence of dystrophin. Furthermore, recent studies have shown that L‐arginine induces utrophin upregulation in adult mdx mice. We hypothesized that L‐arginine treatment also induces utrophin upregulation to prevent the development of muscle weakness in neonatal mdx mice. Hence, L‐arginine should also prevent progressive muscle destruction via utrophin upregulation in mdx neonatal mice. Mdx neonatal mice were injected intraperitoneally daily with 800 mg/kg of L‐arginine for 6 weeks, whereas control mice were injected with a physiological saline. The following experiments were performed on the tibialis anterior (TA) muscle: muscle contractility and resistance to mechanical stress; central nucleation and peripheral nucleation, utrophin, and creatine kinase quantification as well as a nitric oxide (NO) assay. Our findings show that early administration of L‐arginine in mdx neonatal mice prevents the destruction of the tibialis anterior (TA) muscle. However, this improvement was related to nitric oxide (NO) production rather than the expected utrophin upregulation.

The sustained expression of Cas9 targeting toxic RNAs reverses disease phenotypes in mouse models of myotonic dystrophy type 1

Myotonic dystrophy type I (DM1) is a multisystemic autosomal-dominant inherited human disorder that is caused by CTG microsatellite repeat expansions (MREs) in the 3' untranslated region of DMPK. Toxic RNAs expressed from such repetitive sequences can be eliminated using CRISPR-mediated RNA targeting, yet evidence of its in vivo efficacy and durability is lacking. Here, using adult and neonatal mouse models of DM1, we show that intramuscular or systemic injections of adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors encoding nuclease-dead Cas9 and a single-guide RNA targeting CUG repeats results in the expression of the RNA-targeting Cas9 for up to three months, redistribution of the RNA-splicing protein muscleblind-like splicing regulator 1, elimination of foci of toxic RNA, reversal of splicing biomarkers and amelioration of myotonia. The sustained reversal of DM1 phenotypes provides further support that RNA-targeting Cas9 is a viable strategy for treating DM1 and other MRE-associated diseases.

Therapeutic approaches to muscular dystrophy

Muscular dystrophies are a heterogeneous group of genetic disorders characterized by muscle weakness and wasting. Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is the most common and severe form of muscular dystrophy, and although the molecular mechanisms of the disease have been extensively investigated since the discovery of the gene in 1986, there is currently no effective treatment. However, new gene-based therapies have recently emerged with particular noted advances in using conventional gene replacement strategies, RNA-based technology and pharmacological approaches. While the proof of principle has been demonstrated in animal models, several clinical trials have recently been undertaken to investigate the feasibility of these strategies in patients. In particular, antisense-mediated exon skipping has shown encouraging results and holds promise for the treatment of dystrophic muscle. Here, we summarize the recent progress in therapeutic approaches to muscular dystrophies, with an emphasis on gene therapy and exon skipping for DMD.

Inhibition of monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 prevents diaphragmatic inflammation and maintains contractile function during endotoxemia

Introduction

Respiratory muscle weakness is common in sepsis patients. Proinflammatory mediators produced during sepsis have been implicated in diaphragmatic contractile dysfunction, but the role of chemokines has not been explored. This study addressed the role of monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1, also known as CCL2), in the pathogenesis of diaphragmatic inflammation and weakness during endotoxemia.

Methods

Mice were treated as follows (n = 6 per group): (a) saline, (b) endotoxin (25 μg/g IP), (c) endotoxin + anti-MCP-1 antibody, and (d) endotoxin + isotype control antibody. Muscles were also exposed to recombinant MCP-1 in vivo and in vitro. Measurements were made of diaphragmatic force generation, leukocyte infiltration, and proinflammatory mediator (MCP-1, IL-1α, IL-1β, IL-6, NF-κB) expression/activity.

Results

In vivo, endotoxin-treated mice showed a large decrease in diaphragmatic force, together with upregulation of MCP-1 and other cytokines, but without an increase in intramuscular leukocytes. Antibody neutralization of MCP-1 prevented the endotoxin-induced force loss and reduced expression of MCP-1, IL-1α, IL-1β, and IL-6 in the diaphragm. MCP-1 treatment of nonseptic muscles also led to contractile weakness, and MCP-1 stimulated its own transcription independent of NF-κB activation in vitro.

Conclusions

These results suggest that MCP-1 plays an important role in the pathogenesis of diaphragmatic weakness during sepsis by both direct and indirect mechanisms. We speculate that its immunomodulatory properties and ability to modify skeletal muscle function make MCP-1 a potential therapeutic target in critically ill patients with sepsis and associated respiratory muscle weakness.

Engineered adenovirus serotypes for overcoming anti-vector immunity

Adenovirus (Ad)-based gene transfer has been successfully utilised in gene therapy and vaccine applications. To date, an increasing number of human clinical trials utilise recombinant Ad-based vectors as a gene transfer platform. In particular, progress has been made recently in utilising Ad-based vectors as a vaccine platform in HIV, cancer immunotherapy approaches and in vaccination for other infections. Despite these successes, the scientific and bio-industrial communities have recently recognised that innate and pre-existing immunity against Ad vectors can constitute a serious obstacle to the development and application of this technology. It is essential to overcome vector-mediated immune responses, such as production of inflammatory cytokines and pre-existing immunity to Ad, because the induction of these responses not only shortens the period of gene expression but also leads to serious side effects. This review focuses on the biology of Ad infection and the approaches that are being adopted to overcome immunity against the Ad-based vectors.

A novel chimpanzee serotype-based adenoviral vector as delivery tool for cancer vaccines

The use of adenovirus (Ad) as vaccine vectors is hindered by pre-existing immunity to human Ads in most of the human population. In order to overcome this limitation, uncommon alternative Ad serotypes need to be utilized. In this study, an E1-E3 deleted recombinant Ad based on the chimpanzee serotype 3 (ChAd3) was engineered to express human carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) protein or rat neu extracellular/transmembrane domains (ECD.TM). ChAd3 vectors were tested in CEA transgenic (CEA.Tg) and BALB/NeuT mice, which show immunologic tolerance to these antigens. ChAd3 is capable of inducing an immune response comparable to that of hAd5 serotype-based vectors, thus breaking tolerance to tumor associated antigens (TAAs) and achieving anti-tumor effects. Of importance is that ChAd3 can overcome hAd5 pre-existing immunity and work in conjunction with DNA electroporation (DNA-EP) and other Ad vaccines based on common human serotypes.

Co-expression of sCD40LIg and CTLA4Ig mediated by adenovirus prolonged mouse skin allograft survival

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the role of simultaneous blockade of CD40/CD40L and B7/CD28 pathways in the immune tolerance via co-expression of sCD40LIg and CTLA4Ig mediated by replication-defective adenovirus.

METHODS

Ad-sCD40LIg-IRES(2)-CTLA4Ig, replication-defective adenovirus co-expressing sCD40LIg and CTLA4Ig, was constructed and identified. The co-expression of sCD40LIg and CTLA4Ig was evaluated with confocal laser scanning microscope and Western blotting. Skin transplantations of C57BL/6 to BALB/c mice were performed. PBS, Ad-Shuttle-CMV and Ad-sCD40LIg-IRES(2)-CTLA4Ig were administered. Skin graft survival was monitored and the mRNA expression of both genes was evaluated in the skin allografts.

RESULTS

Ad-sCD40LIg-IRES(2)-CTLA4Ig was constructed successfully and identified. The co-expression of sCD40LIg and CTLA4Ig was identified with confocal laser scanning microscopy and Western blotting. Compared to the skin graft mean survival time (MST) of non-treated group ((5.75+/-0.71) d) or Ad-Shuttle-CMV-treated group ((5.50+/-0.53) d), the skin graft MST was dramatically prolonged in the Ad-sCD40LIg-IRES(2)-CTLA4Ig-treated group ((16.38+/-1.19) d, P<0.001). The mRNA expression of both genes was detected.

CONCLUSION

Ad-sCD40LIg-IRES(2)-CTLA4Ig, a replication-defective adenovirus carrying genes encoding sCD40LIg and CTLA4Ig, was constructed. Simultaneous blockade of CD40/CD40L and B7/CD28 costimulatory pathway mediated by replication-defective adenovirus significantly prolonged skin allograft survival in mice.

Canine adenovirus vectors for lung-directed gene transfer: efficacy, immune response, and duration of transgene expression using helper-dependent vectors

A major hurdle to the successful clinical use of some viral vectors relates to the innate, adaptive, and memory immune responses that limit the efficiency and duration of transgene expression. Some of these drawbacks may be circumvented by using vectors derived from nonhuman viruses such as canine adenovirus type 2 (CAV-2). Here, we evaluated the potential of CAV-2 vectors for gene transfer to the respiratory tract. We found that CAV-2 transduction was efficient in vivo in the mouse respiratory tract, and ex vivo in well-differentiated human pulmonary epithelia. Notably, the in vivo and ex vivo efficiency was poorly inhibited by sera from mice immunized with a human adenovirus type 5 (HAd5, a ubiquitous human pathogen) vector or by human sera containing HAd5 neutralizing antibodies. Following intranasal instillation in mice, CAV-2 vectors also led to a lower level of inflammatory cytokine secretion and cellular infiltration compared to HAd5 vectors. Moreover, CAV-2 transduction efficiency was increased in vitro in human pulmonary cells and in vivo in the mouse respiratory tract by FK228, a histone deacetylase inhibitor. Finally, by using a helper-dependent CAV-2 vector, we increased the in vivo duration of transgene expression to at least 3 months in immunocompetent mice without immunosuppression. Our data suggest that CAV-2 vectors may be efficient and safe tools for long-term clinical gene transfer to the respiratory tract.

Expression and regulation of CC class chemokines in the dystrophic (mdx) diaphragm

In the murine (mdx) model of Duchenne muscular dystrophy, dystrophic changes are much more severe in the diaphragm than in limb muscles, and the diaphragm more closely resembles the human disease phenotype. Chemokines could play a central role in governing such phenotypic differences, as inflammation is an important disease modifier. Here we report that CC chemokine receptors (CCRs 1, 2, 3, 5) and ligands (macrophage inflammatory protein-1alpha, RANTES) are expressed at higher levels in dystrophic than in wild-type muscles across age groups (6, 12, and 24 wk). Moreover, chemokine ligand expression and muscle inflammation are significantly higher in dystrophic diaphragms than in limb muscles of the same animals. In vitro, CCR1 is constitutively expressed by cultured primary diaphragmatic myotubes. Stimulation of myotubes by proinflammatory cytokines (tumor necrosis factor-alpha, interleukin-1alpha, interferon-gamma) found within the in vivo dystrophic muscle environment, upregulates CCR1 in mdx and wild-type cultures, and also increases expression of its ligand RANTES to a significantly greater degree in the mdx group. Taken together, our results suggest that CC chemokines may play an important role in sustaining inflammation within the mdx diaphragm, which could help account for its more severe phenotype and also offer a target for therapeutic intervention in Duchenne patients.

Sustained Muscle Expression of Dystrophin from a High-Capacity Adenoviral Vector with Systemic Gene Transfer of T Cell Costimulatory Blockade

Adenoviral vector (Ad)-mediated gene delivery of normal, full-length dystrophin to skeletal muscle provides a promising strategy for the treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). However, cellular and humoral immune responses induced by vector gene transfer limit the application of this approach. Blockade of the costimulatory interaction between naïve T cells and antigen-presenting cells has proven to be a successful means to diminish immunity induced by gene transfer. In this study we explore the potential of supplementing dystrophin gene delivery to dystrophin-deficient Dmd mouse skeletal muscle with systemic gene delivery of CTLA4Ig and CD40Ig molecules to effect costimulatory blockade. We found that systemic administration of a high-capacity Ad (HC-Ad) vector carrying murine CTLA4Ig (AdmCTLA4Ig) either alone or codelivered with an HC-Ad vector carrying murine CD40Ig (AdmCD40Ig) provided sustained expression of recombinant full-length murine dystrophin from an HC-Ad vector carrying the dystrophin cDNA (AdmDys). The level of AdmDys vector genomes remained stable in animals cotreated with systemic delivery of vectors carrying molecules to block costimulation. In addition, muscle CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cell infiltrates and Th1 cytokine production by splenocytes were reduced. The production of neutralizing antibody against Ad vector was significantly inhibited in mice receiving systemic codelivery of both AdmCTLA4Ig and AdmCD40Ig, but not in the mice treated with AdmCTLA4Ig alone. The results suggested that coblockade of both CD28/B7 and CD40L/CD40 costimulatory pathways is required for effective inhibition of the Ad vector-induced humoral immune response in Dmd mice, whereas blockade of CD28/B7 alone by murine CTLA4Ig would be sufficient for prolonged dystrophin expression in treated muscle.

Porcine adenoviral vectors evade preexisting humoral immunity to adenoviruses and efficiently infect both human and murine cells in culture

Preexisting immunity against human adenoviruses (HAd) limits the efficiency of transduction of HAd vectors in humans. In addition, development of a vector-specific immune response after the first inoculation with a HAd vector further lowers vector uptake following readministration. We investigated the usefulness of porcine adenovirus serotype 3 (PAd3)-based vectors as a supplement to HAd vectors. Here we demonstrate that preexisting HAd-specific neutralizing antibodies in humans do not cross-neutralize PAd3. In order to generate E1A-deleted PAd3 vectors, an E1-complementing cell line of porcine origin was produced. E1A-deleted PAd3 vector expressing green fluorescent protein; GFP (PAd-GFP) and E1-deleted HAd5 vector expressing GFP (HAd-GFP) transduced human cell lines with comparable efficiencies. Both of these vectors efficiently transduced murine MT1A2 breast cancer cell line, while PAd-GFP transduced murine NIH 3T3 fibroblast cell line significantly better (P < 0.05) than HAd-GFP. These results suggest that PAd3 vectors would be promising supplement to HAd vectors as a delivery vehicle for recombinant vaccines and gene therapy applications.

CTLA4Ig delivered by high-capacity adenoviral vector induces stable expression of dystrophin in mdx mouse muscle

Adenoviral (Ad) vector-mediated gene delivery of normal, full-length dystrophin to skeletal muscle provides a promising strategy for the treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), an X-linked recessive, dystrophin-deficient muscle disease. Studies in animal models suggest that successful DMD gene therapy by Ad vector-mediated gene transfer would be precluded by cellular and humoral immune responses induced by vector capsid and transgene proteins. To address the immunity induced by Ad vector-mediated dystrophin gene delivery to dystrophic muscle, we developed high-capacity adenoviral (HC-Ad) vectors expressing mouse dystrophin driven by the muscle creatine kinase promoter (AdmDys) and mCTLA4Ig (AdmCTLA4Ig) individually, or together from one vector (AdmCTLA4Ig/mDys). We found stable expression of dystrophin protein in the tibialis anterior muscles of mdx mice, coinjected with AdmCTLA4Ig and AdmDys, or injected alone with AdmCTLA4Ig/mDys, whereas the expression of dystrophin protein in the control group coinjected with AdmDys and an empty vector decreased by at least 50% between 2 and 8 weeks after administration. Additionally, we observed reductions in Ad vector-induced Th1 and Th2 cytokines, Ad vector-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte activation and neutralizing anti-Ad antibodies in both experimental groups that received a mCTLA4Ig-expressing vector as compared to the control group. This study demonstrates that the coexpression of mCTLA4Ig and dystrophin in skeletal muscle provided by HC-Ad vector-mediated gene transfer can provide stable expression of dystrophin in immunocompetent, adult mdx mouse muscle and applies a potentially powerful strategy to overcome adaptive immunity induced by Ad vector-mediated dystrophin gene delivery toward the ultimate goal of treatment for DMD.

Regenerative capacity of the dystrophic (mdx) diaphragm after induced injury

Duchenne muscular dystrophy is characterized by myofiber necrosis, muscle replacement by connective tissue, and crippling weakness. Although the mdx mouse also lacks dystrophin, most muscles show little myofiber loss or functional impairment. An exception is the mdx diaphragm, which is phenotypically similar to the human disease. Here we tested the hypothesis that the mdx diaphragm has a defective regenerative response to necrotic injury, which could account for its severe phenotype. Massive necrosis was induced in mdx and wild-type (C57BL10) mouse diaphragms in vivo by topical application of notexin, which destroys mature myofibers while leaving myogenic precursor satellite cells intact. At 4 h after acute exposure to notexin, >90% of diaphragm myofibers in both wild-type and mdx mice demonstrated pathological sarcolemmal leakiness, and there was a complete loss of isometric force-generating capacity. Both groups of mice showed strong expression of embryonic myosin within the diaphragm at 5 days, which was largely extinguished by 20 days after injury. At 60 days postinjury, wild-type diaphragms exhibited a persistent loss ( approximately 25%) of isometric force-generating capacity, associated with a trend toward increased connective tissue infiltration. In contrast, mdx diaphragms achieved complete functional recovery of force generation to noninjured values, and there was no increase in muscle connective tissue over baseline. These data argue against any loss of intrinsic regenerative capacity within the mdx diaphragm, despite characteristic features of major dystrophic pathology being present. Our findings support the concept that significant latent regenerative capacity resides within dystrophic muscles, which could potentially be exploited for therapeutic purposes.

Therapeutic gene transfer to dystrophic diaphragm by an adenoviral vector deleted of all viral genes

Duchenne muscular dystrophy is caused by defects in the dystrophin gene, and the mdx mouse is the most frequently employed genetic model of this disease. It is well known that different muscle groups do not respond in the same way to dystrophin deficiency. In particular, the mdx mouse diaphragm exhibits severe morphological and functional changes not found in other mdx muscles. Use of early generation adenoviral vectors to deliver genes to the diaphragm in immunocompetent mdx mice has been associated with substantial functional toxicity and a rapid loss of transgene expression. Here we determined the response to dystrophin gene replacement in the mdx diaphragm using a "gutted" adenoviral vector that contains the coding sequence of two full-length dystrophin genes and is deleted of most viral DNA sequences. At 1 wk postdelivery of the vector, 23.6 +/- 4% of total fibers in the injected diaphragm bundle expressed dystrophin at the sarcolemma, which remained stable over the study duration of 30 days without the need for continuous immunosuppression. Treated diaphragms showed a significantly improved resistance to the abnormal force deficits induced by high-stress muscle contractions, the latter being a functional hallmark of dystrophin-deficient muscle. This functional amelioration was achieved despite the presence of mildly increased inflammation (CD4+ and CD8+ lymphocytes) within the vector-treated diaphragms. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration that a viral vector can achieve reversal of functional abnormalities in the dystrophic diaphragm via therapeutic dystrophin gene transfer without the need for sustained immunosuppressive therapy.

Encapsulation of recombinant adenovirus into alginate microspheres circumvents vector-specific immune response

Pre-existing immunity against adenoviruses may compromise the efficacy of adenoviral vectors for vaccination and gene therapy. The purpose of this study was to determine whether encapsulation of adenovirus recombinants into biodegradable alginate microparticles could circumvent the vector-specific immune response. Mice were immunized either intranasally (i.n.) or intraperitoneally (i.p.) with human adenovirus type 5 (HAd5), resulting in the development of virus-specific antibodies. Immunized and nai;ve mice were inoculated with AdCA36lacZ (an E1-deleted HAd5 recombinant containing the bacterial beta-galactosidase (LacZ) gene), encapsulated (E) into alginate microparticles, or nonencapsulated (NE) ie, as a virus suspension. LacZ expression in animals immunized once (1x) or twice (2x) with HAd5 and subsequently inoculated with NE-AdCA36lacZ (NE-Z) was significantly (P<0.001) reduced compared to those levels observed in NE-Z inoculated nai;ve mice, suggesting that the immune response against the vector adversely affected transgene expression. In contrast, there was only slight reduction (P>0.05) in LacZ expression in mice immunized 1x or 2x with HAd5 that were subsequently inoculated with E-AdCA36lacZ (E-Z) compared to those levels obtained in E-Z inoculated nai;ve animals. Similar results were obtained with i.n. or i.p. inoculated animals. These results indicate that microencapsulation of recombinant adenovirus effectively circumvented the vector-specific immune response.

Gene transfer studies in animals: what do they really tell us about the prospects for gene therapy in DMD?

There is a pressing need to develop new therapeutic approaches to Duchenne muscular dystrophy, an X-linked fatal disease primarily affecting skeletal and cardiac muscle. Gene therapy is an approach that has attracted much interest since the description of the Duchenne muscular dystrophy gene and its mutations in 1987. Since 1990 numerous reporter and dystrophin gene transfer studies have been conducted on muscles of animals but mostly in mice. Experimental protocols have ranged from germ-line gene transfer (via the production of transgenics) to somatic gene transfer studies using viral or non-viral vectors. But what have we actually learned from such studies that can be applied to patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy? Various dystrophin, utrophin and integrin recombinant cDNAs have been shown to prevent the development of muscular dystrophy in transgenic dystrophic (mdx) mice. Somatic gene transfer prior to the onset of pathology have been shown to prevent the development of the muscular dystrophy in the mdx mouse but the data is less convincing for the beneficial effects of somatic gene transfer following the establishment of pathology. The time of onset and the course of the disease differ substantially between mouse and man and raise concerns about the applicability of gene therapy in man where the disease manifests in utero and the progression is more severe. The other major concern relates to uncertainty over the efficiency of the different vectors in man, particularly as many patients are likely to have encountered the infectious forms of the viruses that are proposed as vectors.

Strategies for muscle-specific targeting of adenoviral gene transfer vectors

Currently, adenoviral transfer of therapeutic genes such as dystrophin is hampered by low transduction efficiency of adult skeletal muscle. This is largely due to the lack of appropriate virus attachment receptors on the myofiber surface. Recent studies in transgenic mice revealed that upregulation of Coxsackie- and adenovirus receptor improves gene transfer efficiency by approximately ten-fold. Conversely, the vector load that needed to be administered to achieve sufficient gene transfer could be lowered significantly. Reduced viral vector loads may help to control virally mediated toxicity and immunogenicity. To date, there are no drugs or methods known to increase Coxsackie- and adenovirus receptor expression in skeletal muscle that would be easily applicable in humans. However, alternative strategies such as vector retargeting are currently being investigated that may allow for an increase in binding of adenoviral vectors to skeletal muscle. Recent experiments have shown that directed mutagenesis of the adenoviral fiber knob allows for a significant reduction in Coxsackie- and adenovirus receptor binding and for introduction of a new binding domain. Therefore, vector retargeting towards efficient and specific infection of skeletal muscle may be achieved by directed genetic alteration of adenoviral capsid proteins.

Systemic delivery of a high-capacity adenoviral vector expressing mouse CTLA4Ig improves skeletal muscle gene therapy

Adenoviral vectors (AdV) are promising vectors for gene transfer of skeletal muscle. To alleviate humoral and cellular immune responses that limit successful gene transfer, the present study determined the route of administration of AdmCTLA4Ig (an adenovirus that encodes a fusion protein of mouse cytotoxic T lymphocyte-associated protein 4 (CTLA4) and the Fc protion of immunoglobulin G (IgG), CTLA4Ig) that provided optimal AdV-mediated immunosuppression. AdmCTLA4Ig was administered either intramuscularly (i.m.), intravenously (i.v.), or in the footpad (f.p.) of mice that simultaneously received an i.m. injection of an AdV encoding enhanced green fluorescent protein (AdEGFP). EGFP expression in muscle and serum levels of CTLA4Ig were higher in the i.v. and f.p. groups than the i.m. group 30 days after treatment. The i.v. and f.p. groups showed lower levels of CD4(+) and CD8(+) T-cell infiltration and decreased interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) and interleukin 2 (IL-2) production by splenocytes. The T helper cell (Th) 2 cytokine, interleukin 4 (IL-4), was increased 30 days after treatment in the i.v. group. Neutralizing antibodies to AdV were lower in the i.v. and f.p. groups, whereas total antibodies to AdV and EGFP were lower only in the f.p. group. Our results suggest that the optimal route of administration of AdmCTLA4Ig is i.v., providing at least 2 months of stable transgene expression in muscle. The inhibition of the cellular immune response, especially the Th1 response, appeared to play a critical role in prolonging transgene expression. These results suggest that AdV-mediated delivery of targeted immune suppression will be a useful adjunct to muscle gene delivery.

Dangerous liaisons: the role of "danger" signals in the immune response to gene therapy

Recent studies in gene transfer suggest that the innate immune system plays a significant role in impeding gene therapy. In this review, we examine factors that might influence the recruitment and activation of the innate system in the context of gene therapy. We have adopted a novel model of immunology that contends that the immune system distinguishes not between self and nonself, but between what is dangerous and what is not dangerous. In taking this perspective, we provide an alternative and complementary insight into some of the failures and successes of current gene therapy protocols.

Forced myofiber regeneration promotes dystrophin gene transfer and improved muscle function despite advanced disease in old dystrophic mice

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is caused by defects in the dystrophin gene. In young dystrophic mdx mice, immature regenerating myofibers represent the principal substrate for adenovirus vector (AdV)-mediated dystrophin gene transfer. However, in DMD patients immature regenerating myofibers are generally sparse. Such a situation also exists in old mdx mice, which may represent a more realistic model. Therefore, here we have used old mdx mice (of 14- to 17 months of age) to test the hypothesis that one-time administration of a myonecrotic agent can transiently re-establish a population of immature myofibers susceptible to AdV-mediated dystrophin gene transfer. This strategy led to upregulation of the coxsackie/adenovirus attachment receptor by means of induction of regenerating myofibers, significantly augmented AdV-mediated dystrophin gene expression, and enhanced force-generating capacity. In addition, it led to an increased resistance to contraction-induced injury compared with untreated controls. The latter protective effect was positively correlated with the number of dystrophin-expressing myofibers (r=0.83, P<0.05). Accordingly, the risk:benefit ratio associated with the sequential use of forced myofiber regeneration and AdV-mediated dystrophin gene transfer was favorable in old mdx mice despite advanced disease. These findings have implications for the potential applicability of AdV-mediated gene therapy to DMD and other muscle diseases in which immature regenerating myofibers are lacking.

Dystrophin expression in muscle following gene transfer with a fully deleted ("gutted") adenovirus is markedly improved by trans-acting adenoviral gene products

Helper-dependent adenoviruses (HDAd) are Ad vectors lacking all or most viral genes. They hold great promise for gene therapy of diseases such as Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), because they are less immunogenic than E1/E3-deleted Ad (first-generation Ad or FGAd) and can carry the full-length (Fl) dystrophin (dys) cDNA (12 kb). We have compared the transgene expression of a HDAd (HDAdCMVDysFl) and a FGAd (FGAdCMV-dys) in cell culture (HeLa, C2C12 myotubes) and in the muscle of mdx mice (the mouse model for DMD). Both vectors encoded dystrophin regulated by the same cytomegalovirus (CMV) promoter. We demonstrate that the amount of dystrophin expressed was significantly higher after gene transfer with FGAdCMV-dys compared to HDAdCMVDysFl both in vitro and in vivo. However, gene transfer with HDAdCMVDysFl in the presence of a FGAd resulted in a significant increase of dystrophin expression indicating that gene products synthesized by the FGAd increase, in trans, the amount of dystrophin produced. This enhancement occurred in cell culture and after gene transfer in the muscle of mdx mice and dystrophic golden retriever (GRMD) dogs, another animal model for DMD. The E4 region of Ad is required for the enhancement, because no increase of dystrophin expression from HDAdCMVDysFl was observed in the presence of an E1/E4-deleted Ad in vitro and in vivo. The characterization of these enhancing gene products followed by their inclusion into an HDAd may be required to produce sufficient dystrophin to mitigate the pathology of DMD by HDAd-mediated gene transfer.

Local high-capacity adenovirus-mediated mCTLA4Ig and mCD40Ig expression prolongs recombinant gene expression in skeletal muscle

Multiple forms of muscular dystrophy are due to the absence of cytoskeletal muscle proteins that normally protect the integrity of muscle cells. The lack of any adequate treatments for these devastating diseases propels research toward the development of strategies for gene delivery to skeletal muscle. High-capacity adenoviral vectors (HC-AdV) devoid of all viral coding sequences have been developed to avoid expression of viral proteins by the gene therapy vector. However, the capsid proteins that are an essential component of the input viral vector and any residual helper virus in the vector preparation could induce an immune response. Furthermore, the therapeutic protein provided by a gene transfer vector presents the potential to induce an immune response in a patient who does not express a normal cellular protein due to genetic mutation. Therefore, we hypothesize that some immune suppression will be required with therapeutic gene delivery designed for the treatment of patients with inherited muscle diseases. In this study, we constructed and rescued three HC-AdVs expressing murine CTLA4Ig, murine CD40Ig, or both. The backbone vector without a gene insert was rescued as a negative control vector. The production of relevant proteins from each vector was determined in vitro. In vivo function of each of the immunosuppressant vectors was assayed by co-injection with an enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP)-expressing first-generation adenoviral vector (AdEGFP) into the tibialis anterior muscle of C57BL/10 mice. Higher levels of muscle EGFP expression were observed in animals receiving an immunosuppressant vector. Furthermore, the production of total anti-AdV and anti-EGFP antibodies was reduced in mice treated with each of the three immunosuppressant vectors. A second intramuscular administration of AdEGFP alone 4 weeks after the initial co-injection was successful in all immunosuppressant vector-treated groups, but not in the negative control vector-treated group. All groups had a high antibody response to adenoviral proteins after the second injection of AdEGFP alone, indicating that the initial co-injection did not tolerize against vector capsid antigens.

Differential effects of dystrophin and utrophin gene transfer in immunocompetent muscular dystrophy (mdx) mice

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a fatal disease caused by defects in the gene encoding dystrophin. Dystrophin is a cytoskeletal protein, which together with its associated protein complex, helps to protect the sarcolemma from mechanical stresses associated with muscle contraction. Gene therapy efforts aimed at supplying a normal dystrophin gene to DMD muscles could be hampered by host immune system recognition of dystrophin as a "foreign" protein. In contrast, a closely related protein called utrophin is not foreign to DMD patients and is able to compensate for dystrophin deficiency when overexpressed throughout development in transgenic mice. However, the issue of which of the two candidate molecules is superior for DMD therapy has remained an open question. In this study, dystrophin and utrophin gene transfer effects on dystrophic muscle function were directly compared in the murine (mdx) model of DMD using E1/E3-deleted adenovirus vectors containing either a dystrophin (AdV-Dys) or a utrophin (AdV-Utr) transgene. In immunologically immature neonatal animals, AdV-Dys and AdV-Utr improved tibialis anterior muscle histopathology, force-generating capacity, and the ability to resist injury caused by high-stress contractions to an equivalent degree. By contrast, only AdV-Utr was able to achieve significant improvement in force generation and the ability to resist stress-induced injury in the soleus muscle of immunocompetent mature mdx animals. In addition, in mature mdx mice, there was significantly greater transgene persistence and reduced inflammation with utrophin compared to dystrophin gene transfer. We conclude that dystrophin and utrophin are largely equivalent in their intrinsic abilities to prevent the development of muscle necrosis and weakness when expressed in neonatal mdx animals with an immature immune system. However, because immunity against dystrophin places an important limitation on the efficacy of dystrophin gene replacement in an immunocompetent mature host, the use of utrophin as an alternative to dystrophin gene transfer in this setting appears to offer a significant therapeutic advantage.

Circumvention of vector-specific neutralizing antibody response by alternating use of human and non-human adenoviruses: implications in gene therapy

To determine whether non-human adenovirus-specific antibodies are cross-neutralizing, rabbit and mouse anti-human adenovirus type 5 (HAd5), anti-bovine adenovirus type 3 (BAd3), and anti-porcine adenovirus type 3 (PAd3) sera were used in cross-virus neutralization assays. Adenovirus neutralizing antibodies were found to be virus-specific, suggesting that virus neutralizing epitope differs significantly in HAd5, BAd3, and PAd3. To further investigate whether immunity to an HAd5-derived vector could be circumvented by the use of non-human adenoviruses in vivo, mice were first immunized either intranasally or intraperitoneally with HAd5, BAd3, PAd3, or BAd3 + PAd3, and after development of adenovirus-specific antibodies, animals were inoculated with the HAd5 recombinant (AdCA36lacZ) containing the bacterial beta-galactosidase gene under the control of murine cytomegalovirus immediate-early promoter. Virus-inoculated animals developed virus-specific IgG and IgA antibodies. LacZ expression in animals initially primed with HAd5 was significantly reduced (P < 0.05), suggesting that the immune response against the vector could prevent the transgene expression following subsequent inoculation of the same vector, whereas LacZ expression in mice initially primed with BAd3, PAd3, or BAd3 + PAd3 was significantly higher (P > 0.05) than that obtained in HAd5-primed animals. Our results suggest that HAd5-, BAd3-, or PAd3-based vectors may be used sequentially for human gene therapy or vaccine production as a means to avoid immunity to the vector.

Readministration of adenovirus vector in nonhuman primate lungs by blockade of CD40-CD40 ligand interactions

The interaction between CD40 on B cells and CD40 ligand (CD40L) on activated T cells is important for B-cell differentiation in T-cell-dependent humoral responses. We have extended our previous murine studies of CD40-CD40L in adenoviral vector-mediated immune responses to rhesus monkeys. Primary immune responses to adenoviral vectors and the ability to readminister vector were studied in rhesus monkeys in the presence or absence of a transient treatment with a humanized anti-CD40 ligand antibody (hu5C8). Adult animals were treated with hu5C8 at the time vector was instilled into the lung. Immunological analyses demonstrated suppression of adenovirus-induced lymphoproliferation and cytokine responses (interleukin-2 [IL-2], gamma interferon, IL-4, and IL-10) in hu5C8-treated animals. Animals treated with hu5C8 secreted adenovirus-specific immunoglobulin M (IgM) levels comparable to control animals, but did not secrete IgA or develop neutralizing antibodies; consequently, the animals could be readministered with adenovirus vector expressing alkaline phosphatase. A second study was designed to examine the long-term effects on immune functions of a short course of hu5C8. Acute hu5C8 treatment resulted in significant and prolonged inhibition of the adenovirus-specific humoral response well beyond the time hu5C8 effects were no longer significant. These studies demonstrate the potential of hu5C8 as an immunomodulatory regimen to enable administration of adenoviral vectors, and they advocate testing this model in humans.

Modulation of Starling forces and muscle fiber maturity permits adenovirus-mediated gene transfer to adult dystrophic (mdx) mice by the intravascular route

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) and other inherited myopathies lead to progressive destruction of most skeletal muscles in the body, including those responsible for maintaining respiration. DMD is a fatal disorder caused by defects in the dystrophin gene. Recombinant adenovirus vectors (AdV) are considered a promising means for therapeutic delivery of a functional dystrophin gene to DMD muscles. If AdV-mediated dystrophin gene replacement in DMD is to be successful, development of a systemic delivery method for targeting the large number of diseased muscles will be required. In this study we investigated two major factors preventing efficient AdV-mediated gene transfer to skeletal muscles of adult animals after intravascular AdV administration: (1) an inability of AdV particles to breach the endothelial barrier and enter into contact with myofibers, and (2) a relatively nonpermissive myofiber population for AdV infection due at least in part to insufficient levels of the coxsackie/adenovirus attachment receptor (CAR). On the basis of established principles governing the transendothelial flux of macromolecules, we further hypothesized that an alteration in Starling forces (increased hydrostatic and decreased osmotic pressures) within the intravascular compartment would facilitate AdV transendothelial flux via convective transport. In addition, experimental muscle regeneration was employed to increase the prevalence of immature myofibers in which CAR expression is upregulated. Here we report that by employing the above-described strategy, high-level heterologous reporter gene expression was achievable in hindlimb muscles of normal rats as well as dystrophic (mdx) mice (genetic homolog of DMD) after a single intraarterial injection of AdV. Microsphere studies confirmed enhanced transport into muscle of fluorescent tracer particles in the size range of AdV, and there was a high concordance between CAR upregulation and myofiber transduction after intraarterial AdV delivery. Furthermore, in mdx mice examined 10 days after intraarterial AdV delivery, the aforementioned procedures had no adverse effects on the force-generating capacity of targeted muscles. These findings have implications for eventual AdV-mediated gene therapy of generalized skeletal muscle diseases such as DMD using a systemic intraarterial delivery approach.

Cellular immune responses of healthy individuals to intradermal administration of an E1-E3- adenovirus gene transfer vector

In animals, Ad-mediated gene transfer initiates anti-Ad host immune responses that vary, depending on vector design, dose, host, and transgene. To begin to understand whether the anti-Ad vector responses in humans simulate those in animals, Ad(GV)CD.10, an E1-E3- Ad5 vector encoding the E. coli cytosine deaminase gene, was administered by the intradermal route to six normal individuals (8 x 10(7) to 8 x 10(9) particle units, each dose administered to two sites; n = 2 per group). No adverse events were observed. Polymerase chain reaction/Southern analysis demonstrated vector genome in the skin through 28 days in all individuals except one of two at the lowest dose. Local induration, independent of vector dose and baseline systemic anti-Ad5 neutralizing antibodies, developed in all subjects (6 to 17 mm, peak by day 3). Biopsies revealed a mild to moderate T cell (CD3+, CD4+, CD8+), B cell, and macrophage infiltrate at day 3, all decreased by day 28. Langerhans cells accumulated primarily in the papillary dermis. The day 3 cellular response was dose independent. On day 28, CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes and macrophages showed dose dependency. There was minimal systemic Ad5-specific lymphocyte proliferation induced by Ad vector administration in three individuals studied, and no Ad5-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (evaluated in two subjects) could be detected. Thus, intradermal administration of an E1-E3- Ad vector to normal subjects induces mild/moderate local cellular responses, even in Ad-immunized individuals. These observations provide a baseline to determine if these human anti-Ad vector host responses can be circumvented by using "stealth" vectors and/or immunosuppression.

Immune responses to adenovirus and adeno-associated virus in humans

Vectors based on human adenovirus (Ad) and adeno-associated virus (AAV) are being evaluated for human gene therapy. The response of the host to the vector, in terms of antigen-specific immunity, will play a substantial role in clinical outcome. We have surveyed cohorts of normal subjects and cystic fibrosis patients for pre-existing immunity to these viruses, caused by naturally acquired infections. A number of humoral and cellular assays to adenovirus serotype 5 (Ad5) and adeno-associated virus serotype 2 (AAV2) were performed from serum and peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Virtually all subjects had Ig to Ad5 although only 55% of these antibodies neutralized virus (NAB). Approximately two of three patients demonstrated CD4+ T cells that proliferated to Ad antigens of which most were of the TH1 subset, based on cytokine secretion. A substantially different pattern of immune responses was observed to AAV2. Although virtually all patients had Ig to AAV2, most of these antibodies were not neutralizing (32% NAB) and only 5% of patients had peripheral blood lymphocytes that proliferated in response to AAV2 antigens. These studies demonstrate marked heterogeneity in pre-existing immunity to Ad5 and AAV2 in human populations. The impact of these findings on outcome following gene therapy will require further study.

Ovine adenovirus vectors overcome preexisting humoral immunity against human adenoviruses in vivo

Recombinant human adenoviruses (hAd) have become widely used as tools to achieve efficient gene transfer. However, successful application of hAd-derived vectors in clinical trials is limited due to immunological and potential safety problems inherent in their human origin. In this study, we describe a recombinant ovine adenovirus (OAV) as an alternative vector for gene transfer in vivo. In contrast to an hAd vector, the OAV vector was not neutralized by human sera. An OAV vector which contained the cDNA of the human alpha1-antitrypsin (hAAT) gene linked to the Rous sarcoma virus promoter was generated and administered systemically to mice. The level and duration of hAAT gene expression was similar to that achieved with an hAd counterpart in both immunocompetent and immunodeficient mice. However, the tissue distribution of the OAV vector differed from that observed for hAd vectors in that the liver was not the dominant target. Significantly, we demonstrated efficient gene transfer with the OAV vector into mice immunized with hAd vectors and vice versa. We also confirm that the immune response to a transgene product can prevent its functional expression following sequential application of a vector. Our results suggest a possible solution to endemic humoral immunity against currently used hAd vectors and should therefore have an impact on the design of improved gene therapy protocols utilizing adenovirus vectors.

Adenovirus-mediated utrophin gene transfer mitigates the dystrophic phenotype of mdx mouse muscles

Utrophin is a close homolog of dystrophin, the protein whose mutations cause Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). Utrophin is present at low levels in normal and dystrophic muscle, whereas dystrophin is largely absent in DMD. In such cases, the replacement of dystrophin using a utrophin gene transfer strategy could be more advantageous because utrophin would not be a neoantigen. To establish if adenovirus (AV)-mediated utrophin gene transfer is a possible option for the treatment of DMD, an AV vector expressing a shortened version of utrophin (AdCMV-Utr) was constructed. The effect of utrophin overexpression was investigated following intramuscular injection of this AV into mdx mice, the mouse model of DMD. When the tibialis anterior (TA) muscles of 3- to 5-day-old animals were injected with 5 microl of AdCMV-Utr (7.0 x 10(11) virus/ml), an average of 32% of fibers were transduced and the transduction level remained stable for at least 60 days. The presence of utrophin restored the normal histochemical pattern of the dystrophin-associated protein complex at the cell surface and resulted in a reduction in the number of centrally nucleated fibers. The transduced fibers were largely impermeable to the tracer dye Evans blue, suggesting that utrophin protects the surface membrane from breakage. In vitro measurements of the force decline in response to high-stress eccentric contractions demonstrated that the muscles overexpressing utrophin were more resistant to mechanical stress-induced injury. Taken together, these data indicate that AV-mediated utrophin gene transfer can correct various aspects of the dystrophic phenotype. However, a progressive reduction in the number of transduced fibers was observed when the TA muscles of 30- to 45-day-old mice were injected with 25 microl of AdCMV-Utr. This reduction coincides with a humoral response to the AV and transgene, which consists of a hybrid mouse-human cDNA.