Characterization of follicles in girls and young women with Turner syndrome who underwent ovarian tissue cryopreservation

Navigating fertility dilemmas across the lifespan in girls with Turner syndrome-a scoping review

BACKGROUND

Girls with Turner syndrome (TS) lack a partial or complete sex chromosome, which causes an accelerated decline of their ovarian reserve. Girls have to deal with several dilemmas related to their fertility, while only a limited number of them are referred to a fertility specialist and counselled about options of family planning on time.

OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE

This scoping review provides an update of the literature on fertility in girls with TS throughout their lifespan and aims to propose a clinical practice guideline on fertility in TS.

SEARCH METHODS

Databases of PubMed, Embase, and Web of science were searched using the following key terms: Turner syndrome, fertility, puberty, pregnancy, sex-hormones, karyotype, fertility preservation, assisted reproductive techniques, and counselling, alongside relevant subject headings and synonymous terms. English language articles published since 2007 were critically reviewed. Pregnancies after using donated oocytes and data about girls with TS with Y-chromosomal content were excluded.

OUTCOMES

This search identified 1269 studies of which 120 were extracted for the review. The prevalence of natural conception ranged from 15% to 48% in women with 45,X/46,XX, 1% to 3% in women with 45,X, and 4% to 9% in women with other TS karyotypes. When assessing a girl's fertility potential, it was crucial to determine the karyotype in two cell lines, because hidden mosaicism may exist. In addition to karyotype, assessment of anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) played a significant role in estimating ovarian function. Girls with AMH above the detection limit were most likely to experience spontaneous thelarche, menarche, and ongoing ovarian function during the reproductive lifespan. Fertility preservation became more routine practice: vitrification of oocytes was reported in 58 girls with TS and a median of five oocytes were preserved per stimulation. Ovarian tissue cryopreservation has demonstrated the presence of follicles in approximately 30% of girls with TS, mostly in girls with mosaic-TS, spontaneous puberty, and AMH above the detection limit. Although girls and their parents appreciated receiving counselling on fertility in TS, only one in ten girls with TS received specialized counselling. Unfamiliarity with fertility preservation techniques or uncertainties regarding the eligibility of a girl for fertility preservation constituted barriers for healthcare professionals when discussing fertility with girls with TS.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS

There currently is a high demand for fertility preservation techniques in girls with TS. A reliable prognostic model to determine which girls with TS might benefit from fertility preservation is lacking. Only a minority of these girls received comprehensive fertility counselling on the full spectrum of fertility, including uncertainties of fertility preservation, pregnancy risks, and alternatives, such as adoption. Fertility preservation could be a viable option for girls with TS. However, the question remains whether enough oocytes can be obtained for a realistic prospect of a live birth. It is important that girls and parents are empowered with the necessary information to make a well-informed decision.

Successful pregnancy rates amongst patients undergoing ovarian tissue cryopreservation for non-malignant indications: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Ovarian tissue cryopreservation (OTC) is a fertility preservation method that has been clinically applied for almost 30 years. Studies specifically evaluating patients presenting with non-malignant indications for OTC and their subsequent pregnancy rates are limited.

OBJECTIVE

To summarise the evidence on the rates of successful pregnancy amongst women who have undergone OTC for non-malignant indications.

METHODS

A systematic review with meta-analysis (PROSPERO registration CRD42022307925) was conducted to investigate the pregnancy outcomes of patients who have undergone ovarian tissue cryopreservation for non-malignant indications. Articles published in EMBASE and Ovid MEDLINE before October 2022 were screened for inclusion based on the following criteria: original human studies pertaining to OTC with a defined non-malignant cohort and pregnancy outcomes. The successful pregnancy rates were pooled with a random-effects model of double-arcsine transformed proportions. Sensitivity analysis involved pooling the results of studies with a low risk of bias after being assessed with NIH tools.

RESULTS

The database search retrieved 3,225 results, of which 16 were included in the meta-analysis. The pooled successful pregnancy rate was 23.52 % (16 studies, 95 % CI 6.48 to 44.79 %). When subgroup analysis of study types was performed, the successful pregnancy rate was higher amongst case series (47.02 %, 9 studies, 95 % CI 6.98 to 89.00 %) than cohort studies (14.64 %, 7 studies, 95 % CI 3.59 to 29.78 %). Sensitivity analysis limited to studies at low risk of bias revealed a similar pooled successful pregnancy rate of 23.35 % (12 studies, 95 % CI 2.50 to 51.96 %).

CONCLUSIONS

Approximately one quarter of women who underwent OTC for non-malignant indications had a successful pregnancy. These findings are clinically important for fertility preservation counselling by providing greater evidence for more informed care.

Oocyte cryopreservation with in vitro maturation for fertility preservation in girls at risk for ovarian insufficiency

PURPOSE

To assess the feasibility and outcomes of oocyte cryopreservation with in vitro maturation (IVM) in post-pubertal girls undergoing fertility preservation (FP) for primary ovarian insufficiency (POI) risk.

METHODS

Ovarian stimulation was performed with an antagonist protocol or progesterone priming. Ultrasound monitoring was performed transabdominally. Oocytes were retrieved transvaginally under IV sedation. Immature oocytes were subjected to IVM for up to 36 h. All MII oocytes were vitrified. The main outcome measure was the total number of mature oocytes cryopreserved. The secondary outcome was the increase in the mature oocyte yield after IVM.

RESULTS

Indications for FP included mosaic Turner syndrome (mTS; n = 10), malignancy (n = 3), and POI risk (n = 2). The mean ± SD age, antral follicle count (AFC), and AMH levels were 14.2 ± 1.4 years, 8 ± 5.2 and 1.3 ± 1.3 ng/mL. In girls with mTS, the ovarian reserve was low for age (AFC 7.4 ± 4.7 and AMH 1.4 ± 1.6 ng/mL). Oocyte cryopreservation was possible in all girls with a range of 1-27 mature oocytes obtained, even in those who were previously exposed to chemotherapy or with low ovarian reserve, and no surgical complications were encountered. After IVM, the median mature oocyte yield increased significantly from 7.5 to 10.5 (p = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Oocyte cryopreservation appears to be feasible and safe in girls as young as 12 years of age at risk for POI The utility of IVM increases the yield of cryopreserved mature oocytes. Prior exposure to chemotherapy or low ovarian reserve should not be an automatic reason to exclude these girls from FP consideration.

TurnerFertility trial: fertility preservation in young girls with Turner syndrome by freezing ovarian cortex tissue-a prospective intervention study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate which girls with Turner syndrome (TS) could benefit from fertility preservation by ovarian tissue cryopreservation on the basis of karyotype, puberty status, and hormonal data.

DESIGN

Prospective intervention study; participants were included between 2018 and 2020.

SETTING

Tertiary hospital in the Netherlands.

PATIENTS

In total, 106 girls with TS aged between 2 and 18 years were included. Girls with minor X chromosome deletions, Y chromosomal content, active infections, or contraindications for surgery were excluded.

INTERVENTION

A laparoscopic unilateral ovariectomy was performed to obtain ovarian cortical tissue for cryopreservation. One tissue fragment per participant was used to determine the number of follicles per ovary by serial sectioning and staining. Chromosome analysis was performed on lymphocytes and buccal cells. A blood sample was taken before the ovariectomy for hormonal analysis.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The presence of follicles in ovarian cortex tissue from girls with TS in relation to karyotype, puberty status, and hormonal data.

RESULTS

A unilateral ovariectomy was performed on 93 girls with TS. Complications after surgery occurred in 5 girls, including luxation of psychological symptoms in 2 girls. In 13 (14%) girls, a 46,XX cell line was found in buccal cells that was absent in lymphocytes. Follicles were observed in 30 (32%) of the 93 girls and were found mainly in girls with a 46,XX cell line in lymphocytes or buccal cells (Phi coefficient = 0.55). Spontaneous onset of puberty (Phi coefficient = 0.59), antimüllerian hormone (AMH; point-biserial correlation [r] = 0.82), inhibin B (r = 0.67), and follicle-stimulating hormone (r = -0.46) levels were also correlated strongly with the presence of follicles. Furthermore, AMH levels had a significant correlation with the number of follicles per ovary (r = 0.66).

CONCLUSION

Favorable predictive markers for the presence of follicles included either a 46,XX cell line, spontaneous onset of puberty, or a combination of measurable AMH and normal follicle-stimulating hormone levels. Karyotyping of two peripheral cell lines in girls with TS is recommended to reveal hidden mosaicisms. Ovarian tissue cryopreservation should be offered with caution in a research setting to those with a sufficient ovarian reserve, considering the significant loss of follicles after ovarian tissue cryopreservation and autotransplantation. Physicians should pay attention to the mental health of the girls during the whole process.

CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

Trial registration number: NCT03381300- Preservation of Ovarian Cortex Tissue in Girls With Turner Syndrome - Full Text View - ClinicalTrials.gov. Registered on: December 21, 2017. First patient recruited on January 1, 2018.

Reference standards for follicular density in ovarian cortex from birth to sexual maturity

RESEARCH QUESTION

Are age-normalized reference values for human ovarian cortical follicular density adequate for tissue quality control in fertility preservation?

DESIGN

Published quantitative data on the number of follicles in samples without known ovarian pathology were converted into cortical densities to create reference values. Next, a sample cohort of 126 girls (age 1-24 years, mean ± SD 11 ± 6) with cancer, severe haematological disease or Turner syndrome were used to calculate Z-scores for cortical follicular density based on the reference values.

RESULTS

No difference was observed between Z-scores in samples from untreated patients (0.3 ± 3.5, n = 30) and patients treated with (0.5 ± 2.9, n = 48) and without (0.1 ± 1.3, n = 6) alkylating chemotherapy. Z-scores were not correlated with increasing cumulative exposure to cytostatics. Nevertheless, Z-scores in young treated patients (0-2 years -2.1 ± 3.1, n = 10, P = 0.04) were significantly lower than Z-scores in older treated patients (11-19 years, 2 ± 1.9, n = 15). Samples from patients with Turner syndrome differed significantly from samples from untreated patients (-5.2 ± 5.1, n = 24, P = 0.003), and a Z-score of -1.7 was identified as a cut-off showing good diagnostic value for identification of patients with Turner syndrome with reduced ovarian reserve. When this cut-off was applied to other patients, analysis showed that those with indications for reduced ovarian reserve (n = 15) were significantly younger (5.9 ± 4.2 versus 10.7 ± 5.9 years, P = 0.004) and, when untreated, more often had non-malignant haematologic diseases compared with those with normal ovarian reserve (n = 24, 100% versus 19%, P = 0.009).

CONCLUSION

Z-scores allow the estimation of genetic- and treatment-related effects on follicular density in cortical tissue from young patients stored for fertility preservation. Understanding the quality of cryopreserved tissue facilitates its use during patient counselling. More research is needed regarding the cytostatic effects found in this study.

Ovarian stimulation and oocyte cryopreservation in females with cancer

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

We reviewed the most recent developments including the safety and effectiveness data and success rates in individualized ovarian stimulation protocols for adult and postpubertal females with cancer.

RECENT FINDINGS

In women with breast cancer, aromatase inhibitor- and tamoxifen-supplemented stimulation protocols increase the margin of safety by limiting estrogen exposure. The outcomes of ovarian stimulation appear similar between cancer and noncancer populations, even with the recently developed random-start protocols, which allow initiation of ovarian stimulation anytime during the menstrual cycle. Based on lower anti-Mullerian hormone levels and primordial follicle density, carriers of BRCA pathogenic variants ( BRCApv ) have decreased ovarian reserve in comparison to women without those variants and may lose larger portion of their ovarian reserve post chemotherapy. Oocyte cryopreservation is also emerging as a suitable fertility preservation approach for selected postpubertal girls as young as 12 years of age.

SUMMARY

Individualized ovarian stimulation approaches combined with improvements in cryopreservation techniques increased the success and safety margin to preserve fertility with oocyte freezing. Women with BRCApv , on the other hand, may be at disadvantage as they have lower ovarian reserve and may lose larger portion of their ovarian reserve post chemotherapy compared to women who do not carry these variants.

Evaluation of ovarian reserve in young females with non-iatrogenic ovarian insufficiency to establish criteria for ovarian tissue cryopreservation

RESEARCH QUESTION

Can ovarian reserve parameters predict the outcome of ovarian tissue cryopreservation (OTCP) in patients ≤18 years with non-iatrogenic premature ovarian insufficiency (POI)?

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort analysis carried out in a single tertiary hospital between August 2010 and January 2020. Thirty-seven patients ≤18 years with non-iatrogenic POI (27 with Turner syndrome, six with POI of unknown aetiology, three with galactosemia and one with blepharophimosis, ptosis, epicanthus inversus syndrome) were included. Three parameters were used to evaluate ovarian reserve: anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH), follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) and transabdominal antral follicle count. Fertility preservation (most commonly OTCP) was offered if ovarian reserve was diminished and one or more parameters was positive. Follicles were counted in ovarian samples obtained at the time of OTCP.

RESULTS

Ovarian reserve was diminished in 34 patients and 19 of them had one or more positive parameter. Fourteen (11 aged ≥12 years and 3 aged <12) underwent OTCP, one (14 years old) underwent ovarian stimulation and oocyte cryopreservation and four declined fertility preservation. Follicles were detected in 11 of 14 patients who underwent OTCP with one or more positive parameters (79%), and in all those (100%) who had two or three positive parameters. The median number of follicles was 27 (range 5-64) and 48 (range 21-75) in patients ≥12 years and those <12 years, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This study shows that if OTCP is performed in patients with one or more positive parameters of ovarian activity, a 79% positive predictive value is achieved for the detection of follicles. The incorporation of this criterion for OTCP will minimize the risk of harvesting ovarian tissue with a low number of follicles.

Ovarian stimulation and oocyte cryopreservation in females and transgender males aged 18 years or less: a systematic review

Background

Fertility preservation is an important healthcare focus in the paediatric and adolescent population when gonadotoxic treatments are required. Ovarian stimulation (OS) resulting in oocyte cryopreservation is a well-established fertility preservation option in the adult population. It's utility, however, is little known in young patients. The purpose of this review was to synthesise the available literature on OS in patients ≤18 years old, to identify gaps in current research and provide suggestions for future research directions.

Methods

Using PRISMA guidelines, a systematic review of the literature was performed for all relevant full-text articles published in English in Medline, Embase, the Cochrane Library and Google Scholar databases. The search strategy used a combination of subject headings and generic terms related to the study topic and population. Two reviewers independently screened studies for eligibility, extracted data and assessed the risk of bias. Characteristics of the studies, objectives and key findings were extracted and summarised in a narrative synthesis.

Results

Database search and manual review identified 922 studies, 899 were eliminated based on defined exclusion criteria. Twenty-three studies were included and comprised 468 participants aged ≤18 years who underwent OS (median 15.2, range 7-18 years old). Only three patients were premenarchal, and four patients were on treatment to suppress puberty. Patients had OS for a broad range of indications including oncology treatment, transgender care and Turner syndrome. A total of 488 cycles of OS were completed, with all but 18 of these cycles (96.3%) successfully resulting in cryopreserved mature oocytes (median 10 oocytes, range 0-35). Fifty-three cycles (9.8%) were cancelled. Complications were rare (<1%). One pregnancy was reported from a female who had OS aged 17 years old.

Conclusion

This systematic review demonstrates that OS and oocyte cryopreservation is achievable in young females however there are only a few cases in the literature describing OS in premenarcheal children or those who have suppressed puberty. There is little proof that OS can lead to pregnancy in adolescents, and no proof that this can be achieved in premenarchal girls. Therefore it should be regarded as an innovative procedure for adolescents and experimental for premenarcheal girls.

Systematic review registration

https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=265705, identifier CRD42021265705.

Individuals with numerical and structural variations of sex chromosomes: interdisciplinary management with focus on fertility potential

Diagnosis and management of individuals who have differences of sex development (DSD) due to numerical or structural variations of sex chromosomes (NSVSC) remains challenging. Girls who have Turner syndrome (45X) may present with varying phenotypic features, from classical/severe to minor, and some remain undiagnosed. Boys and girls who have 45,X/46,XY chromosomal mosaicism may have Turner syndrome-like features and short stature; therefore, unexplained short stature during childhood requires karyotype analysis in both sexes, particularly if characteristic features or atypical genitalia are present. Many individuals with Klinefelter syndrome (47XXY) remain undiagnosed or are only diagnosed as adults due to fertility problems. Newborn screening by heel prick tests could potentially identify sex chromosome variations but would have ethical and financial implications, and in-depth cost-benefit analyses are needed before nationwide screening can be introduced. Most individuals who have NSVSC have lifelong co-morbidities and healthcare should be holistic, personalized and centralized, with a focus on information, psychosocial support and shared decision-making. Fertility potential should be assessed individually and discussed at an appropriate age. Oocyte or ovarian tissue cryopreservation is possible in some women who have Turner syndrome and live births have been reported following assisted reproductive technology (ART). Testicular sperm cell extraction (TESE) is possible in some men who have 45,X/46,XY mosaicism, but there is no established protocol and no reported fathering of children. Some men with Klinefelter syndrome can now father a child following TESE and ART, with multiple reports of healthy live births. Children who have NSVSC, their parents and DSD team members need to address possibilities and ethical questions relating to potential fertility preservation, with guidelines and international studies still needed.

Turner syndrome: fertility counselling in childhood and through the reproductive lifespan

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The potential for fertility in Turner syndrome has improved in recent years. Understanding of associated risks and approaches is important for the care of girls and women with this condition. This review focuses on reproductive health, fertility options and appropriate counselling for women with Turner syndrome and their families.

RECENT FINDINGS

Women with Turner syndrome have rapidly declining ovarian function beginning in utero . Therefore, counselling regarding fertility concerns should begin at a young age and involve discussion of options, including ovarian tissue cryopreservation, oocyte preservation and use of nonautologous oocytes. Clinical guidance on fertility management and pregnancy risk assessment based on karyotype, associated comorbidities and fertility is still not fully data driven. Realistic expectations regarding reproductive options and associated outcomes as well as the need for multidisciplinary follow-up during pregnancy are crucial to the ethical and safe care of these patients.

SUMMARY

Fertility care in women with Turner syndrome is evolving as current management techniques improve and new approaches are validated. Early counselling and active management of fertility preservation is critical to ensure positive and well tolerated reproductive outcomes.

The Changing Face of Turner Syndrome

Turner syndrome (TS) is a condition in females missing the second sex chromosome (45,X) or parts thereof. It is considered a rare genetic condition and is associated with a wide range of clinical stigmata, such as short stature, ovarian dysgenesis, delayed puberty and infertility, congenital malformations, endocrine disorders, including a range of autoimmune conditions and type 2 diabetes, and neurocognitive deficits. Morbidity and mortality are clearly increased compared with the general population and the average age at diagnosis is quite delayed. During recent years it has become clear that a multidisciplinary approach is necessary toward the patient with TS. A number of clinical advances has been implemented, and these are reviewed. Our understanding of the genomic architecture of TS is advancing rapidly, and these latest developments are reviewed and discussed. Several candidate genes, genomic pathways and mechanisms, including an altered transcriptome and epigenome, are also presented.

Role of apoptosis and autophagy in ovarian follicle pool decline in children and women diagnosed with benign or malignant extra-ovarian conditions

STUDY QUESTION

Which biological mechanisms are responsible for physiological ovarian reserve decline owing to aging, or pathological follicle depletion triggered by inflammation or a pro-oxidant environment throughout a woman's lifetime?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Ovarian follicle pool size is modulated by both apoptosis and autophagy, the first responsible for its physiological decline over time and increasing in the event of prior chemotherapy in children, and the latter playing a major role in physiological ovarian follicle pool diminution before puberty.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Among the different pathways of controlled cell death, apoptosis and autophagy are implicated in follicle loss. Apoptosis participates in eliminating damaged follicles, such as those impaired by chemotherapy (CHT), but its involvement in physiological age-related follicle decline is less well understood. Autophagy has proved crucial in follicle quiescence maintenance in murine models, but its contribution to human follicle pool modulation is still unclear.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

This retrospective study included 84 patients with benign or malignant extra-ovarian conditions aged between 1 and 35 years, with ovarian tissue stored for histological analyses at the time of cryopreservation (between 2012 and 2021) at a tertiary care center.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Ovarian fragments were used for the following analyses: hematoxylin and eosin staining for follicle count and classification; cleaved caspase-3 immunostaining to identify follicle apoptosis; and microtubule-associated proteins 1A/1B light chain 3B immunolabeling to detect follicle autophagy. Transmission electron microscopy was also carried out to investigate ultrastructural features of oocytes and granulosa cells. All analyses stratified patients by age, menarchal status (premenarchal = 32; postmenarchal = 52), potentially gonadotoxic CHT before cryopreservation (n = 14), presence of endometriosis and use of hormonal treatment.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Premenarchal patients had a larger follicle pool in terms of total follicle density [mean, range 4979.98 (342.2-21789) versus 918.8 (26.18-3983), P < 0.001], but higher rates of morphologically abnormal [8.52 (0-25.37)% versus 3.54 (0-17.5)%, P < 0.001] and atretic [15.8 (0‒31.85)% versus 10.6 (0-33.33)%, P < 0.01] follicles than postmenarchal subjects. Apoptosis rates did not change with increasing age [27.94 (0-93.2)% in prepubertal subjects and 29.5 (0-100)% in postpubertal subjects], but autophagic follicles were around 10 times more common in premenarchal than postmenarchal subjects [10.21 (0-62.3)% versus 1.34 (0-25)%, P < 0.001], playing a crucial role in age-related follicle decline and elimination of 'abnormal' follicles, that are rarely seen after menarche. The impact of diagnosis and previous CHT varied according to age. In premenarchal patients with previous CHT, significantly more apoptotic [40.22 (0-100)% versus 26.79 (0-87)%, P < 0.05] and fewer abnormal [3.84 (0-10-76)% versus 9.83 (0-25.37)%, P < 0.01] follicles were detected than in subjects with no CHT prior to ovarian tissue cryopreservation, suggesting a direct effect on follicle elimination, especially of those with abnormalities. In postmenarchal subjects with previous CHT, quiescent follicle rates were lower than in patients with no CHT before tissue freezing [71.57 (0-100)% versus 85.89 (50-100)%, P < 0.05], suggesting accelerated follicle activation and growth. Moreover, increased autophagic activity was observed in the event of a cancer diagnosis compared to benign conditions after puberty [26.27 (0-100)% versus 9.48 (0-29.41)%, respectively, P < 0.05].

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

The impact of specific CHT protocols could not be investigated since the group of patients with previous CHT was highly heterogeneous.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

This study yields a deeper understanding of regulation of the follicle pool decline, showing for the first time that both apoptosis and autophagy pathways are involved in physiological follicle depletion, the latter being crucial before puberty. Moreover, our data showed a different response to non-physiological damage according to age, with higher apoptosis rates only in premenarchal subjects with previous CHT, confirming that this pathway is activated by drugs known to induce DNA damage in oocytes, such as alkylating agents, but not by cancer itself.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This study was supported by grants from the Fonds National de la Recherche Scientifique de Belgique (F.R.S.-FNRS/FRIA FC29657 awarded to L.C., CDR J.0063.20 and grant 5/4/150/5 awarded to M.M.D.), grants from the Fondation contre le Cancer (grant 2018-042 awarded to A.Ca.), the Fondazione Comunitaria del Varesotto and Provincia di Varese ('Amalia Griffini' Fellowship in Gynecology and Obstetrics awarded to A.Ce.), Fonds Spéciaux de Recherche, Fondation St Luc and donations from the Ferrero family. The authors have no competing interests to declare.

TRIAL REGISTRAION NUMBER

N/A.

Ovarian dysfunction in women with Turner syndrome

Ovarian dysfunction is one of the most common features of women with Turner syndrome. In these women, oocyte apoptosis is markedly accelerated from the early stage of fetal life. Reduction in the number of germ cells disturbs primordial follicle development and thereby leads to the formation of streak gonads. There are three possible causes of accelerated germ cell loss in 45,X ovaries. First, chromosomal pairing failure due to X chromosomal aneuploidy is believed to induce meiotic arrest. Indeed, it has been suggested that the dosage of the X chromosome is more critical for the survival of the oocytes than for other cells in the ovary. Second, impaired coupling between oocytes and granulosa cells may also contribute to germ cell apoptosis. Previous studies have shown that 45,X ovaries may tend to lose tight junctions which are essential for intercellular interactions. Lastly, ovarian dysfunction in women with Turner syndrome is partly attributable to the reduced dosage of several genes on the X chromosome. Specifically, BMP15, PGRMC1, and some other genes on the X chromosome have been implicated in ovarian function. Further studies on the mechanisms of ovarian dysfunction are necessary to improve the reproductive outcomes of women with Turner syndrome.

Models and Biomarkers for Ovarian Ageing

The human ovarian reserve is defined by the number of non-growing follicles (NGFs) in the ovary, with the age-related decline in NGF population determining age at menopause for healthy women. In this chapter, the concept of ovarian reserve is explored in detail, with a sequence of models described that in principle allow any individual to be compared to the general population. As there is no current technology that can count the NGFs in a living ovary, we move our focus to biomarkers for the ovarian reserve. Using serum analysis and ultrasound it is possible to measure anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH), follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH), and ovarian volume (OV) and to count numbers of antral follicles (AFC). These are compared, with ovarian volume being the closest to a true biomarker for a wide range of ages and with AMH and AFC being the most popular for post-pubertal and pre-menopausal ages. The study of genetic and subcellular biomarkers for the ovarian reserve has produced less concrete results. Recent advances are described and compared in terms of limitations and potential. The chapter concludes with an overview of the future study indicated by our current knowledge and by current controversy in the field.

Questions concerning fertility preservation during transition in girls with Turner syndrome: review of the literature

Loss of fertility is one of the most important concerns facing Turner syndrome (TS) patients as they transition into adult health care. Due to the limited and rapidly decreasing ovarian reserve, many TS patients require fertility preservation (FP) techniques to preserve their reproductive potential until they are ready to pursue procreation. One has to also remember about the additional risks connected with pregnancy in TS patients. In order to determine the optimal time for introducing FP techniques and decrease the chance of an unnecessary intervention, markers and procedures assessing ovarian reserve have been developed. The exposure to potential cardiovascular complications should be determined before FP to avoid unnecessary procedures in patients with potential contraindications to pregnancy. The aim of the present review is to answer the following three questions important for successful preservation of fertility and safe pregnancy in TS: which markers of ovarian reserve should be used as selection criteria for FP? Which methods of FP are the safest and most effective? Are there any cardiovascular contraindications to FP? For each of those questions, separate literature searches have been conducted. A total of 86 articles have been included in this review: 34 for the first question, 35 for the second, and 17 for the third. Ovarian reserve markers and cardiovascular contraindications to pregnancy should be established before FP; hoverer, there are no unambiguous indicators as to which patients should be disqualified from the FP and more evidence is needed in this subject.

A predictive model of the effect of therapeutic radiation on the human ovary

Radiation to the female pelvis as part of treatment for cancer predisposes young women to develop Premature Ovarian Insufficiency (POI). As the human female is born with their full complement of non-growing follicles which decline in an exponential fashion until the menopause, the age at which POI occurs is dependent on the age of the patient at treatment and the dose received by the ovary. A model that predicts the age at which POI occurs for a known dose at a known age will aid counselling patients on their fertility risk. Patients deemed to be at high risk of POI may be considered to be good candidates for established fertility preservation techniques. An updated and externally validated model of the age-related decline in human ovarian reserve was combined with the best available estimate of the median lethal dose LD₅₀ for the human ovary. Using known age at diagnosis and posited radiotherapy treatment plan to estimate the dose to the least-affected ovary, we use an age-related model of the decline in ovarian reserve to generate a personalized age prediction of premature ovarian insufficiency. Our algorithm is available as an online calculator which graphs model outputs to inform discussions around survivor fertility. We report four example cases across different ages and diagnoses, each with two carefully designed photon and proton treatment plans. The treatment options are compared in terms of remaining fertile lifespan for the survivor. International oncology guidelines now mandate the consideration of later fertility when reviewing treatment options for children diagnosed with cancer. Our calculator (https://sites.cs.st-andrews.ac.uk/radiosensitivity), and the underlying algorithm and models, allow detailed predictions of the impact of various radiotherapy plans on fertility. These patient-specific data enhance pre-treatment discussions around post-treatment fertility and fertility preservation.

Why Turner patients with 45, X monosomy should not be excluded from fertility preservation services

In this case report, we highlight the practical dilemma, i.e. to perform ovarian tissue cryopreservation surgery in a 45, X Turner Syndrome patient or not, by reporting on the presence of follicles in a 13-year-old female diagnosed with 45, X monosomy and an unmeasurable anti-müllerian hormone serum level. We compare our results with previous research, highlight the challenges we faced in this case and provide recommendations for daily practice. Hereby, we demonstrate that excluding certain subgroups of Turner Syndrome patients (e.g. monosomy patients, and/or girls with an anti-müllerian hormone level below 2.0 ng/l) may be premature, especially based on the current state of published research data. This practical example of a challenging dilemma in the counselling of Turner Syndrome patients for fertility preservation is of interest for clinicians involved in fertility counselling and Turner Syndrome care.

Turner Syndrome and Fertility

Turner syndrome (TS) is tightly associated with hypergonadotropic hypogonadism and ovarian dysgenesis, typically resulting in infertility in the great majority of patients. Therefore females with TS are usually treated with female sex steroids from 11-12 years of age until the normal age of natural menopause of around 53-54 years of age. Infertility is rated among females with TS as a distressing concern and a detractor from a good quality of life. Options for motherhood for females with TS has expanded during recent years. Originally, only adoption was an option, unless of course for the small minority of TS females that still has ovarian function and are capable of achieving pregnancy through normal means. Oocyte donation has become the mainstream option in many countries and seems to work well, especially if patients have been treated with optimal estrogen and gestagen for a prolonged time before the intervention. It comes with an increased risk of cardiovascular complications and TS oocyte donation pregnancies are viewed as high risk pregnancies necessitating increased vigilance. Oocyte cryopreservation of own oocytes is also becoming an option in a select group of TS and has special challenges. Ovarian tissue cryopreservation is a promising new techniques that has been applied successfully in children with cancer. Currently, several trials are running around the world evaluating this techniques in TS. The genetics and genomics behind the ovarian dysgenesis seen in TS is not understood, but new studies have elucidated global changes in DNA methylation and RNA expression in blood from persons with TS and it is likely that similar changes are present in the ovaries. We still, however, need more thorough research to fully uncover the genetic background of ovarian failure in TS. Gene expression studies and methylation analysis from ovarian TS tissues still needs to be performed.

The use of oocyte cryopreservation for fertility preservation in patients with sex chromosome disorders: a case series describing outcomes

PURPOSE

Characterize outcomes among adolescents and young adults (AYAs) with sex chromosome disorders (SCDs) after oocyte cryopreservation (OC) consultation.

METHODS

Retrospective case series of all AYA (< 25 years) patients with SCDs seen for OC consultation from 2011 to 2019 at a large, urban, academic fertility center. All AYA patients with an SCD seen for OC consult in the study time period were reviewed and included. Data collected included patient age, SCD type, number of patients who attempted OC, number of cycles attempted, and cycle outcomes.

RESULTS

Twenty-two patients were included: 9 with Turner syndrome, 12 with mosaic Turner syndrome, and 1 with 47,XXX. Mean age at consult was 14.7 ± 3.5 years. Fourteen patients elected for OC: 5 with Turner syndrome, 8 with mosaic Turner syndrome, and 1 47,XXX who pursued 31 OC cycles total. Of those 14 patients, 10 underwent retrieval, 9 froze oocytes, and 8 froze mature (MII) oocytes. Seven patients underwent > 1 cycle and 7 had ≥ 1 cancelation. 3/3 patients who pursued cycles after 1st cancelation never got to retrieval. Age, SCD type, and baseline FSH did not predict ability to freeze MIIs. One patient returned after OC and attempted 4 ovulation induction cycles and 2 IVF cycles; all were canceled for low response.

CONCLUSIONS

AYA patients with SCDs have a high risk of poor response and cycle cancelation but the majority froze MIIs. Thus, setting expectations is important. A larger sample size is needed to evaluate possible clinical predictors of success.

First live birth after fertility preservation using vitrification of oocytes in a woman with mosaic Turner syndrome

PURPOSE

To report the case of a young woman diagnosed with Turner syndrome (TS) who achieved a live birth using her own oocytes that had been vitrified for fertility preservation.

METHODS

A 25-year-old woman with mosaic (45,X/46,XX) TS was referred for fertility preservation (FP) counseling. Serum anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH) level was normal (6.4 µg/L). In view of the unpredictable rate of follicle loss in TS individuals, she requested FP and underwent two cycles of ovarian stimulation (OS) for oocyte cryopreservation (OoC) using a GnRH antagonist protocol and recombinant follicle stimulating hormone (rFSH), 200-250 IU daily for 8 resp. 12 days.

RESULTS

In total, 29 metaphase II oocytes (MII) were vitrified after OS. After conceiving spontaneously and achieving a live birth, she returned to the clinic five years after OoC with a desire for pregnancy using in vitro fertilization (IVF) of her cryopreserved oocytes and preimplantation genetic testing (PGT-A). All 29 MII oocytes were thawed; 23 oocytes survived (79.3%) and were inseminated with partner sperm using intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). Thirteen oocytes were fertilized resulting in three good quality blastocysts which were vitrified after trophectoderm biopsy for PGT-A using array-CGH. Two blastocysts were found to be euploid. One was thawed and transferred to the uterus using a HRT priming protocol. An uneventful pregnancy occurred. The patient delivered a healthy baby girl weighing 3490 g at 40 weeks of gestation.

CONCLUSIONS

We report the first live birth achieved using cryopreserved oocytes in a woman diagnosed with mosaic TS. Cryopreservation of oocytes after ovarian stimulation is a realistic option for FP in selected post menarche individuals with mosaic TS. Whether PGT-A may reduce the risk of pregnancy loss in TS has to be confirmed by further studies.

Clinical Utility of Anti-Mullerian Hormone in Pediatrics

CONTEXT

Anti-Mullerian hormone (AMH) was originally described in the context of sexual differentiation in the male fetus but has gained prominence now as a marker of ovarian reserve and fertility in females. In this mini-review, we offer an updated synopsis on AMH and its clinical utility in pediatric patients.

DESIGN AND RESULTS

A systematic search was undertaken for studies related to the physiology of AMH, normative data, and clinical role in pediatrics. In males, AMH, secreted by Sertoli cells, is found at high levels prenatally and throughout childhood and declines with progression through puberty to overlap with levels in females. Thus, serum AMH has clinical utility as a marker of testicular tissue in males with differences in sexual development and cryptorchidism and in the evaluation of persistent Mullerian duct syndrome. In females, serum AMH has been used as a predictive marker of ovarian reserve and fertility, but prepubertal and adolescent AMH assessments need to be interpreted cautiously. AMH is also a marker of tumor burden, progression, and recurrence in germ cell tumors of the ovary.

CONCLUSIONS

AMH has widespread clinical diagnostic utility in pediatrics but interpretation is often challenging and should be undertaken in the context of not only age and sex but also developmental and pubertal stage of the child. Nonstandardized assays necessitate the need for assay-specific normative data. The recognition of the role of AMH beyond gonadal development and maturation may usher in novel diagnostic and therapeutic applications that would further expand its utility in pediatric care.

Ovarian tissue cryopreservation for a 3-year-old girl with Mosaic Turner syndrome in China: First case report and literature review

BACKGROUND

Although it cannot be predicted accurately which young females will develop premature ovarian insufficiency (POI) following chemotherapy or irradiation, patients at high risk of POI should be offered ovarian tissue cryopreservation (OTC). Our ovarian tissue cryobank is the first center in China. OTC was firstly performed on a 3-year-old girl with mosaic Turner syndrome (TS) in China. We report this case and present a literature review about TS girls' fertility preservation (FP).

CASE PRESENTATION

Karyotype analysis of umbilical cord blood showed that the girl was diagnosed with TS, 45,X [19]/46,XX [81]. The girl was a 3-year-old girl when her parents would like OTC to preserve fertility. No abnormality was found in the reproductive system, abdominal and cardiac ultrasound, spinal X-ray, and bone age. She was treated with growth hormone (GH) one year ago because of her short stature. GH has been discontinued now. Because of the high risk of POI, OTC was planned. The hormone level before OTC was FSH 4.27 IU/L, LH 0.00 IU/L, E2 < 11.80 pg/ml, AMH 1.06 ng/ml. Pelvic ultrasound showed that the size of the bilateral ovaries was 1.6 cm×0.7-0.8 cm, no enlarged follicles were found, and the maximum diameter of follicles was 0.2-0.37 cm. Ovarian tissue for OTC was taken from the whole right ovary by laparoscopic surgery, and the antral follicles could be seen in ovarian tissue preparation. Sixteen ovarian cortical slices were cryopreserved by slow freezing, with an average of 1380 follicles in round cortical tissue with a diameter of 2 mm, and the follicular density was about 440/mm³. The ovarian tissue from 10 children with non-TS was cryopreserved in our center, the median age was 5 (range 2-8) years old, and the median number of follicles was 766 (range 163-2250) per 2 mm biopsy. The follicles number in this girl were within normal range.

CONCLUSION

TS patients should be evaluated early in childhood to benefit from FP. For highly selected young females with mosaic TS, if the endocrine evaluation does not indicate POI and other health problems do not rule out future pregnancy, it seems reasonable to consider OTC as an FP option.

Fertility Preservation: How to Preserve Ovarian Function in Children, Adolescents and Adults

Chemotherapy, pelvic radiotherapy and ovarian surgery have known gonadotoxic effects that can lead to endocrine dysfunction, cessation of ovarian endocrine activity and early depletion of the ovarian reserve, causing a risk for future fertility problems, even in children. Important determinants of this risk are the patient’s age and ovarian reserve, type of treatment and dose. When the risk of premature ovarian insufficiency is high, fertility preservation strategies must be offered to the patient. Furthermore, fertility preservation may sometimes be needed in conditions other than cancer, such as in non-malignant diseases or in patients seeking fertility preservation for personal reasons. Oocyte and/or embryo vitrification and ovarian tissue cryopreservation are the two methods currently endorsed by the American Society for Reproductive Medicine, yielding encouraging results in terms of pregnancy and live birth rates. The choice of one technique above the other depends mostly on the age and pubertal status of the patient, and personal and medical circumstances. This review focuses on the available fertility preservation techniques, their appropriateness according to patient age and their efficacy in terms of pregnancy and live birth rates.

Adolescent Fertility Preservation: Where Do We Stand Now

Adolescence is a period of flux for many body systems. While fertility potential typically increases after menarche, there are diseases where the opposite occurs and fertility preservation options need to be considered early. In cases of cancer, options vary by pubertal status and can include ovarian tissue cryopreservation, oocyte cryopreservation, sperm cryopreservation, and testicular tissue cryopreservation. Much remains to be learned about fertility and preservation options in those with differences in sexual development (DSDs); however, depending on the form of DSD, fertility preservation may not be necessary. Similarly, traditional fertility counseling in children with galactosemia may need to be changed, as data suggest that fertility rates attributed to other causes of premature ovarian insufficiency may not be as applicable to this disease. Adolescents with Turner's syndrome are at high risk for premature ovarian failure; therefore, it is important to consider options as early as possible since ovarian reserves are depleted quickly. On the other hand, transgender and gender diverse adolescents may even be able to undergo fertility preservation after starting hormone therapy. In all cases, there are additional ethical components including technical/surgical risks in childhood, offering experimental therapies without creating false hope and evaluating children's consent and assent capabilities that must be considered.

Accelerated loss of oogonia and impaired folliculogenesis in females with Turner syndrome start during early fetal development

STUDY QUESTION

How are germ cell numbers and initiation of folliculogenesis affected in fetal Turner syndrome (TS) ovaries?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Germ cell development was severely affected already in early second trimester pregnancies, including accelerated oogonia loss and impaired initiation of primordial follicle formation in TS ovaries, while the phenotype in TS mosaic ovaries was less severe.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Females with TS are characterized by premature ovarian insufficiency (POI). This phenotype is proposed to be a consequence of germ cell loss during development, but the timing and mechanisms behind this are not characterized in detail. Only few studies have evaluated germ cell development in fetal TS and TS mosaic ovaries, and with a sparse number of specimens included per study.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

This study included a total of 102 formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded fetal ovarian tissue specimens. Specimens included were from fetuses with 45,X (N = 42 aged gestational week (GW) 12-20, except one GW 40 sample), 45,X/46,XX (N = 7, aged GW 12-20), and from controls (N = 53, aged GW 12-42) from a biobank (ethics approval # H-2-2014-103).

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

The number of OCT4 positive germ cells/mm2, follicles (primordial and primary)/mm2 and cPARP positive cells/mm2 were quantified in fetal ovarian tissue from TS, TS mosaic and controls following morphological and immunohistochemical analysis.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

After adjusting for gestational age, the number of OCT4+ oogonia was significantly higher in control ovaries (N = 53) versus 45,X ovaries (N = 40, P < 0.001), as well as in control ovaries versus 45,X/46,XX mosaic ovaries (N = 7, P < 0.043). Accordingly, the numbers of follicles were significantly higher in control ovaries versus 45,X and 45,X/46,XX ovaries from GW 16-20 with a median range of 154 (N = 11) versus 0 (N = 24) versus 3 (N = 5) (P < 0.001 and P < 0.015, respectively). The number of follicles was also significantly higher in 45,X/46,XX mosaic ovaries from GW 16-20 compared with 45,X ovaries (P < 0.005). Additionally, the numbers of apoptotic cells determined as cPARP+ cells/mm2 were significantly higher in ovaries 45,X (n = 39) versus controls (n = 15, P = 0.001) from GW 12-20 after adjusting for GW.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

The analysis of OCT4+ cells/mm2, cPARP+ cells/mm2 and follicles (primordial and primary)/mm2 should be considered semi-quantitative as it was not possible to use quantification by stereology. The heterogeneous distribution of follicles in the ovarian cortex warrants a cautious interpretation of the exact quantitative numbers reported. Moreover, only one 45,X specimen and no 45,X/46,XX specimens aged above GW 20 were available for this study, which unfortunately made it impossible to assess whether the ovarian folliculogenesis was delayed or absent in the TS and TS mosaic specimens.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

This human study provides insights about the timing of accelerated fetal germ cell loss in TS. Knowledge about the biological mechanism of POI in girls with TS is clinically useful when counseling patients about expected ovarian function and fertility preservation strategies.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This work was supported by the International Center for Research and Research Training in Endocrine Disruption of Male Reproduction and Child Health (EDMaRC).

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

N/A.

Hormonal response in patients transplanted with cryopreserved ovarian tissue is independent of whether freezing was performed in childhood or adulthood

PURPOSE

This study evaluated the concentrations of hormones resulting from the transplantation of ovarian tissue (OTT) in relation to whether the tissue was frozen at a time close to puberty or above the age of 19 years.

METHODS

Six girls and adolescents (aged 9-14 years) who underwent ovarian tissue cryopreservation (OTC) were followed after transplantation in adulthood. After OTT, the women were followed via regular blood samples to evaluate the concentrations of FSH, LH, oestradiol and AMH. Twenty-three women undergoing OTT (aged 19-36 years at the time of OTC) were included as a reference group. All of the women had postmenopausal levels of gonadotropins at the time of transplantation.

RESULTS

The return of FSH and LH to normal premenopausal concentrations in adult women transplanted with ovarian tissue that was frozen at a time close to puberty was similar to the profiles in women from the reference group. Serum AMH levels were below the detection limit (via the Roche Elecsys assay) in many samples, but four out of six young girls showed measurable concentrations. Oestradiol similarly increased in the first 12 weeks following transplantation, after which it tended to be higher in women having frozen tissue in adulthood.

CONCLUSIONS

Ovarian tissue that was excised from girls at a time close to puberty, after which it was frozen and transplanted in adulthood, interacts with pituitary tissue in a similar manner to ovarian tissue that is frozen from adult women. Follicles located in the ovarian tissue from young girls are equally sensitive to gonadotropin stimulation as follicles from adult women when exposed to postmenopausal levels of gonadotropins. This result indicates that it is not the ovaries that require maturation to sustain full reproductive potential but rather proper FSH and LH stimulation. Moreover, these results support the continued use of OTC in young women.

Effects of Er:YAG laser treatment on re-vascularization and follicle survival in frozen/thawed human ovarian cortex transplanted to immunodeficient mice

PURPOSE

The huge loss of ovarian follicles after transplantation of frozen/thawed ovarian tissue is considered a major drawback on the efficacy of the procedure. Here we investigate whether Er:YAG laser treatment prior to xenotransplantation can improve re-vascularization and subsequently follicle survival in human ovarian tissue.

METHODS

A total of 99 frozen/thawed human ovarian cortex pieces were included of which 72 pieces from 12 woman were transplanted to immunodeficient mice. Tissues from each woman were included in both an 8-day and an 8-week duration study and treated with either full-beam laser (L1) or fractionated laser (L2), or served as untreated controls. Vascularization of the ovarian xenografts were evaluated after 8 days by qPCR and murine Cd31 immunohistochemical analysis. Follicle densities were evaluated histologically 8 weeks after xenografting.

RESULTS

Gene expression of Vegf/VEGF was upregulated after L1 treatment (p=0.002, p=0.07, respectively), whereas Angpt1, Angpt2, Tnf-α, and Il1-β were significantly downregulated. No change in gene expression was found in Cd31/CD31, ANGPT1, ANGPT2, ANGTPL4, XBP1, or LRG1 after any of the laser treatments. The fraction of Cd31 positive cells were significantly reduced after L1 and L2 treatment (p<0.0001; p=0.0003, respectively), compared to controls. An overall negative effect of laser treatment was detected on follicle density (p=0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Er:YAG laser treatment did not improve re-vascularization or follicle survival in human ovarian xenografts after 8 days and 8 weeks grafting, respectively. However, further studies are needed to fully explore the potential angiogenic effects of controlled tissue damage using different intensities or lasers.

International consensus: ovarian tissue cryopreservation in young Turner syndrome patients: outcomes of an ethical Delphi study including 55 experts from 16 different countries

STUDY QUESTION

What is the standpoint of an international expert panel on ovarian tissue cryopreservation (OTC) in young females with Turner syndrome (TS)?

SUMMARY ANSWER

The expert panel states that OTC should be offered to young females with TS, but under strict conditions only.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

OTC is already an option for preserving the fertility of young females at risk of iatrogenic primary ovarian insufficiency (POI). Offering OTC to females with a genetic cause of POI could be the next step. One of the most common genetic disorders related to POI is TS. Due to an early depletion of the ovarian reserve, most females with TS are confronted with infertility before reaching adulthood. However, before offering OTC as an experimental fertility preservation option to young females with TS, medical and ethical concerns need to be addressed.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

A three-round ethical Delphi study was conducted to systematically discuss whether the expected benefits exceed the expected negative consequences of OTC in young females with TS. The aim was to reach group consensus and form an international standpoint based on selected key statements. The study took place between February and December 2018.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Anonymous panel selection was based on expertise in TS, fertility preservation or medical ethics. A mixed panel of 12 gynaecologists, 13 (paediatric) endocrinologists, 10 medical ethicists and 20 patient representatives from 16 different countries gave consent to participate in this international Delphi study. In the first two rounds, experts were asked to rate and rank 38 statements regarding OTC in females with TS. Participants were offered the possibility to adjust their opinions after repetitive feedback. The selection of key statements was based on strict inclusion criteria.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

A total of 46 participants completed the first Delphi round (response rate 84%). Based on strict selection criteria, six key statements were selected, and 13 statements were discarded. The remaining 19 statements and two additional statements submitted by the expert panel were re-evaluated in the second round by 41 participants (response rate 75%). The analysis of the second survey resulted in the inclusion of two additional key statements. After the approval of these eight key statements, the majority of the expert panel (96%) believed that OTC should be offered to young females with TS, but in a safe and controlled research setting first, with proper counselling and informed consent procedures, before offering this procedure in routine care. The remaining participants (4%) did not object but did not respond despite several reminders.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

The anonymous nature of this study may have led to lack of accountability. The selection of experts was based on their willingness to participate. The fact that not all panellists took part in all rounds may have resulted in selection bias.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

This international standpoint is the first step in the global acceptance of OTC in females with TS. Future collaborative research with a focus on efficacy and safety and long-term follow-up is urgently needed. Furthermore, we recommend an international register for fertility preservation procedures in females with TS.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

Unconditional funding (A16-1395) was received from Merck B.V., The Netherlands. The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

Fertility issues and pregnancy outcomes in Turner syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To study fertility issues and pregnancy outcomes in Turner syndrome (TS).

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

Not applicable.

PATIENT(S)

One hundred fifty-six TS patients, median age 32 years, 23 mosaic 45,X/46,XX, 45,X/47,XXX, 45,X/46,XX/47,XXX.

INTERVENTION(S)

None.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Fertility choices, spontaneous pregnancy, and oocyte donation (OD) outcomes. Conditions associated with aortic dissection and poor pregnancy outcomes at preconception were considered. Pregnancy-related aortic dimension changes and the long-term impact of pregnancy on TS-related comorbidities were assessed.

RESULTS(S)

In all, 13.5% had spontaneous pregnancies, resulting in a pregnancy with live birth in 18 patients (37 newborns); 16% considered OD, one adopted, and one underwent fertility preservation. Spontaneous pregnancy predictive factors were a karyotype with a second or third cell line with more than one X and spontaneous menarche. In all, 47.6% had miscarriages, two experienced preeclampsia, and two had gestational diabetes. One daughter was diagnosed with TS in adulthood. Seven of 14 who attempted OD had a pregnancy with live birth; two of seven had gestational diabetes; 64.3% attempting OD had risk factors associated with poor pregnancy outcomes, including four who had double embryo transfer. Cardiac status at preconception was evaluated in 12 of 25 women who had a pregnancy. The aortic diameters during pregnancy increased. The aortic growth at sinuses was 0.51 ± 0.71 mm/year and at ascending aorta 0.67 ± 0.67 mm/year, reaching a significant difference at sinuses compared with the growth in nulliparous TS. Among women who had a pregnancy, none experienced aortic dissection during and in the years after pregnancy.

CONCLUSION(S)

This study highlights the importance of a TS-dedicated multidisciplinary management of pregnancy, before and during pregnancy and in the postpartum period.

In vitro growth and maturation of primordial follicles and immature oocytes

Cryopreservation of ovarian tissue to preserve the fertility of girls and young women at high risk of sterility is now widely practiced. Pieces of cryopreserved ovarian cortex can be thawed and autografted to restore fertility, but because of the risks of reintroduction of the cancer, transplantation may not be possible for girls and women with blood-borne leukemias or cancers with a high risk of ovarian metastasis. Cryopreserved ovarian tissue contains mainly primordial follicles but also provides access to immature oocytes from small antral follicles, which may be matured in vitro to provide an additional source of mature oocytes. So in cases in which transplantation is contraindicated, fertility restoration could be safely achieved in the laboratory either by in vitro maturation (IVM) of oocytes aspirated from growing follicles or by the complete in vitro growth (IVG) and maturation (IVM) of primordial follicles to produce fertile metaphase II (MII) oocytes. The development of IVM and IVG methods to support all stages of oocytes available within ovarian tissue will maximize the potential for all patients undergoing fertility preservation.

Fertility preservation for genetic diseases leading to premature ovarian insufficiency (POI)

PURPOSE

The current review aims to summarize the data available concerning the applicability of fertility preservation techniques to genetic conditions at risk of premature ovarian insufficiency (POI).

METHODS

A literature review through the PubMed Database was carried out.

RESULTS

About 10% of cases of POI is related to genetic diseases. The most frequent conditions associated with POI are Turner syndrome and fragile X pre-mutation; mutation of BRCA 1-2 genes and several other mutations and genetic syndromes have recently been highlighted, although they rarely occur. If a diagnosis is issued before POI onset, counseling on currently available fertility preservation techniques is advisable. In case of spontaneous menarche (this can occur variably depending on the mutation) established techniques like embryo or oocyte cryopreservation can be proposed, even if, in some cases, their effectiveness may be reduced by ovarian alterations connected to the mutation. Ovarian tissue cryopreservation has recently been defined as an established medical procedure for fertility preservation in young cancer patients and may be an option for prepubertal patients. However, it is still experimental in special populations with genetic diseases causing POI. New innovative experimental techniques, like in vitro maturation of immature oocytes (IVM) and vitro activation (IVA) of immature follicles on ovarian tissue, have shown limited but encouraging data and they will be probably available in the near future. For a correct risk-benefit evaluation, the following aspects should be considered: actual knowledge about the pathology-specific efficacy of the various techniques, the average age of onset of POI, the possible risks associated with the procedure in relation to the underlying pathology, the probability of spontaneous conception, as well as the health implications of a possible future pregnancy..

CONCLUSIONS

Fertility preservation techniques represent a crucial opportunity for patients with genetic risk of POI. Early diagnosis increases the chances to apply these techniques. No specific recommendations concerning fertility preservation for each genetic pathology are available, and clinicians should first counsel the patient and her relatives about known risks and benefits of the available techniques, both those established and those considered as experimental.

Disorders of Sex Development: Classification, Review, and Impact on Fertility

In this review, the elements included in both sex determination and sex differentiation are briefly analyzed, exposing the pathophysiological and clinical classification of disorders or anomalies of sex development. Anomalies in sex determination without sex ambiguity include gonadal dysgenesis, polysomies, male XX, and Klinefelter syndrome (dysgenesis and polysomies with a female phenotype; and sex reversal and Klinefelter with a male phenotype). Other infertility situations could also be included here as minor degrees of dysgenesis. Anomalies in sex determination with sex ambiguity should (usually) include testicular dysgenesis and ovotesticular disorders. Among the anomalies in sex differentiation, we include: (1) males with androgen deficiency (MAD) that correspond to those individuals whose karyotype and gonads are male (XY and testes), but the phenotype can be female due to different hormonal abnormalities. (2) females with androgen excess (FAE); these patients have ovaries and a 46,XX karyotype, but present varying degrees of external genital virilization as a result of an enzyme abnormality that affects adrenal steroid biosynthesis and leads to congenital adrenal hyperplasia; less frequently, this can be caused by iatrogenia or tumors. (3) Kallman syndrome. All of these anomalies are reviewed and analyzed herein, as well as related fertility problems.

The indication for fertility preservation in women with Turner syndrome should not only be based on the ovarian reserve but also on the genotype and expected future health status

Fertility preservation in women with Turner syndrome is highly controversial. Some strongly recommend freezing of ovarian tissue at a young age, others do not. The controversy is partly due to different perspectives and professions. Biologists prefer to freeze young ovaries with high follicle density, reproductive physicians want to avoid risky operations and iatrogenic infertility by removing one ovary, and cardiologists and obstetricians warn against the risks of later pregnancies. Accordingly, fertility preservation in young women with Turner syndrome is more than just the freezing of ovarian tissue or oocytes. Fertility preservation requires a balanced decision considering the conservation of fertility, the protection of reproductive health, and future health consequences. Therefore, fertility preservation strategies should be based not only on the individual ovarian reserve but also on the genotype and the expected cardiac health status to decide what is the best option: to freeze tissue or alternatively to wait and see.

Premature ovarian insufficiency: an International Menopause Society White Paper

The aim of this International Menopause Society White Paper on premature ovarian insufficiency (POI) is to provide the latest information regarding this distressing condition. The impact of POI has far-reaching consequences due to its impact on general, psychological, and sexual quality of life, fertility prospects, and long-term bone, cardiovascular, and cognitive health. Progress in fully understanding the etiology, diagnosis, and optimal management options has been slow thus far due to the complexity of the condition and fragmented research. Recent advances in epidemiological and genetic research have improved our understanding of this condition and randomized prospective trials are being planned to determine the intervention strategies, which will optimize quality of life and long-term well-being. The International Menopause Society has commissioned a number of experts at the forefront of their specialty to define the state of the art in the understanding of this condition, to advise on practical management strategies, and to propose future research strategies. It is hoped that a global task force will subsequently be convened in order to formulate a consensus statement across key societies, to accelerate date collection and analysis of a global POI registry, and to facilitate progress in the key defined areas of research.

Recent advances in understanding primary ovarian insufficiency

Primary ovarian insufficiency (POI) is an uncommon yet devastating occurrence that results from a premature depletion of the ovarian pool of primordial follicles. Our understanding of both putative and plausible mechanisms underlying POI, previously considered to be largely "idiopathic", has been furthered over the past several years, largely due to advances in the field of genetics and through expansion of translational models for experimental research. In this review, our goal is to familiarize the multidisciplinary readers of the F1000 platform with the strides made in the field of reproductive medicine that hold both preventative and therapeutic implications for those women who are at risk for or who have POI.

Preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy in patients with partial X monosomy using their own oocytes: is this a suitable indication?

OBJECTIVE

To describe the outcome of preimplantation genetic testing (PGT-A) using their own oocytes in patients with mosaic Turner Syndrome (MTS). The impact of the assisted reproduction technique (ART) performed (PGT-A or oocyte donation) and the type of absence of the X chromosome (total or partial) were considered.

DESIGN

Retrospective observational multicenter study.

SETTING

University-affiliated private in vitro fertilization center.

PATIENT(S)

Fifty-six patients with MTS with whom 65 ovarian stimulation cycles for PGT-A (fluorescence in situ hybridization/arrays-next generation sequencing) were performed. The study included 90 women with MTS and 20 women with pure Turner Syndrome (PTS) who underwent 140 and 25 oocyte donation (OD) cycles, respectively.

INTERVENTION(S)

In vitro fertilization for PGT-A (fluorescence in situ hybridization/arrays-next generation sequencing) or OD.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE (S)

Reproductive outcome and feto-maternal outcomes.

RESULTS

The live birth rate (LBR) per embryo transfer in patients with MTS tended to be higher in OD 37.7% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 29.3-46.1) than that observed for PGT-A 22.5% (95% CI 7.8-38.2), and the cumulative LBR (CLBR), with 77.6% vs. 43.3%, respectively. Likewise, the LBR per patient was significant when comparing PGT-A vs. OD, with 12.5% (95 CI 3.9-21.1) vs. 51.1% (40.7-61.4), respectively. While focusing on the X chromosome, partial MTS (PTS), we found significant differences in the CLBR per embryo transfer, with 77.6% vs. 29.2%, and also in the LBR per patient: 51.1% (40.7-61.4) in MTS vs. 15% (95 CI 0.0-30.1) in PTS.

CONCLUSION(S)

Oocyte donation is the best reproductive option in females with Turner Syndrome with or without mosaicisms. Nevertheless, PGT-A is a valid therapeutic option in patients with MTS using their own oocytes, and OD should not necessarily be directly recommended.

Disorders of Sex Development-Novel Regulators, Impacts on Fertility, and Options for Fertility Preservation

Disorders (or differences) of sex development (DSD) are a heterogeneous group of congenital conditions with variations in chromosomal, gonadal, or anatomical sex. Impaired gonadal development is central to the pathogenesis of the majority of DSDs and therefore a clear understanding of gonadal development is essential to comprehend the impacts of these disorders on the individual, including impacts on future fertility. Gonadal development was traditionally considered to involve a primary 'male' pathway leading to testicular development as a result of expression of a small number of key testis-determining genes. However, it is increasingly recognized that there are several gene networks involved in the development of the bipotential gonad towards either a testicular or ovarian fate. This includes genes that act antagonistically to regulate gonadal development. This review will highlight some of the novel regulators of gonadal development and how the identification of these has enhanced understanding of gonadal development and the pathogenesis of DSD. We will also describe the impact of DSDs on fertility and options for fertility preservation in this context.

Progress in Fertility Preservation Strategies in Turner Syndrome

Growth retardation and gonadal dysgenesis are two of the most important clinical manifestations of Turner syndrome (TS). As premature ovarian failure generally occurs early in life in women with TS, these patients should be counseled and evaluated as early as possible for discussion of optimal and individualized fertility preservation strategies. Infertility seriously affects the quality of life of women with TS. For those who have ovarian reserve, the theoretical options for future fertility in TS patients include cryopreservation of oocytes, ovarian tissues, and embryos. For those who have already lost their ovarian reserve, oocyte or embryo donation, gestational surrogacy, and adoption are strategies that allow fulfillment of desire for parenting. This review describes the etiologies of infertility and reviews the fertility preservation strategies for women with TS.

Consequences of β-Thalassemia or Sickle Cell Disease for Ovarian Follicle Number and Morphology in Girls Who Had Ovarian Tissue Cryopreserved

Women with β-thalassemia (BT) and sickle cell disease (SCD) have a high risk of infertility and premature ovarian insufficiency. Different fertility preserving strategies, including ovarian tissue cryopreservation (OTC) and oocyte cryopreservation has been considered, and healthy babies have been born after successful OTC and transplantation. We evaluated follicle number and follicle health in ovarian tissue from a cohort of BT and SCD patients who underwent OTC before the age of 18 years. Patients undergoing OTC from 2002 to 2019 were included. A total of 14 girls and adolescents with BT and four with SCD, aged 2.8-17.4 years at OTC were included together with a reference group of 43 girls and adolescents with non-anemia diseases considered to have normal ovaries aged 0.6-17.9 years at OTC. Ovarian follicle density was measured in cortex biopsies and compared to the reference group. Expression of proteins associated with follicular health was evaluated using immunohistochemistry. Follicles were detected in the ovarian cortex biopsies from all patients with BT and SCD. The follicle densities were within the 95% prediction interval of the reference group in all cases. A similar expression of six proteins essential for follicular health was detected using immunohistochemistry in BT, SCD, and references. OTC should be considered an option for young girls and adolescents with BT and SCD.

TurnerFertility trial: PROTOCOL for an observational cohort study to describe the efficacy of ovarian tissue cryopreservation for fertility preservation in females with Turner syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the occurrence of live birth in women with Turner syndrome (TS) after ovarian tissue cryopreservation in childhood followed by auto transplantation in adulthood and to find reliable prognostic markers for estimating the ovarian reserve in girls with TS in the future.

SETTING

An observational cohort study with long-term follow-up in a tertiary fertility clinic in the Netherlands. Patients recruitment between January 2018 and December 2021.

PARTICIPANTS

100 females aged 2 through 18 years with classical Turner (ie, 45,X0) or Turner variants (ie, 45,X mosaicism or structural anomalies). Girls with Y chromosomal content, minor X deletions with marginal impact on fertility, active HIV, hepatitis B or hepatitis C infection, and/or an absolute contra indication for surgery, anaesthesia or future pregnancy will be excluded.

INTERVENTIONS

Ovarian cortical tissue will be harvested by performing a unilateral oophorectomy via laparoscopic approach. Ovarian cortex fragments will be prepared and cryopreserved. One fragment per patient will be used to determine follicular density by conventional histology, and to perform fluorescence in situ hybridisation analysis of ovarian cells. Routine chromosome analysis will be performed on both lymphocytes and buccal cells. A blood sample will be taken for hormonal analysis and all subjects will undergo a transabdominal ultrasound to determine the uterine and ovarian size. Patient characteristics, pregnancy rates and pregnancy outcomes will be collected from the patient's medical record.

ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION

The study protocol has been approved by the Central Committee on Research Involving Human Subjects in November 2017 (CCMO NL57738.000.16).

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

NCT03381300.

Fertility preservation in Turner syndrome: Karyotype does not predict ovarian response to stimulation

OBJECTIVE

Turner syndrome (TS) is responsible for gonadal dysgenesis with high risk of premature ovarian insufficiency. Little is known about fertility preservation (FP) strategies is this population.

DESIGN

Data from women with TS consulting with a fertility specialist in our FP centre from 2014 to 2018 were retrospectively collected.

MEASUREMENT

Total number of mature oocytes cryopreserved using vitrification.

PATIENTS

Nine women with TS were referred. Three women with different karyotypes underwent controlled ovarian stimulation (COS) for oocyte vitrification. Mean age at TS diagnosis was 13.7 years [9-20]. Mean referral delay between TS diagnosis and fertility consultation was 9.7 years [7-14]. First counselling for FP was provided at 23.7 years [18-28]. Mean AMH serum level prior to COS was 53.8 pmol/L [3.6-95].

RESULTS

All three women succeeded in obtaining cryopreserved oocytes with a mean number of 15.3 per woman [9-20] and 9.2 per COS cycle [2-20]. Ovarian response to COS was unexpectedly remarkable for the woman with a complete 45,X monosomy. Procedure was well tolerated for all women. None of them have used oocytes for in vitro fertilization yet.

CONCLUSIONS

Independently of karyotype, antral follicular count, AMH and FSH levels seemed to be reliable predictive markers of oocyte cryopreservation success. In a monosomic TS woman, cryptic ovarian mosaicism could explain a successful ovarian response to stimulation with a high number of retrieved oocytes. In case of spontaneous menarche, TS adolescents should be referred during transition to adulthood for FP counselling to avoid referral delay and limit time-related diminished ovarian reserve.

Time to consider ovarian tissue cryopreservation for girls with Turner's syndrome: an opinion paper

Turner’s syndrome (TS) is the most common sex chromosome abnormality in women. In addition to short stature and gonadal dysgenesis, it is associated with cardiac and renal anomalies. Due to rapid follicular atresia, the majority of women with TS suffer from primary ovarian insufficiency around puberty. Thus far, donor oocyte conception has been the key fertility option for these women. With advancing technology, ovarian tissue cryopreservation (OTCP) has emerged as a clinically justifiable option especially for pre-pubertal girls with cancer. Recently published results following the use of cryopreserved ovarian tissue are reassuring. It would be prudent to consider the extension of these technological and scientific advances to other conditions, such as TS, where accelerated follicular atresia is suspected. It is possible to obtain competent oocytes from cryopreserved ovaries of girls with TS provided the ovaries were preserved before ovarian failure. However, it is a complex decision whether and when to offer OTCP as a fertility preservation (FP) option for girls with TS. The rate of decline in fertility is variable in girls with TS and can be more complex in cases with mosaicism. On the other hand, OTCP has shown some promising results in patients with cancer, which can potentially be replicated in TS and other benign indications of patients at risk of premature ovarian failure. There are proven psychological and clinical benefits of FP. Thus, an argument could be made for offering OTCP to these patients to endow these girls with the option of having biological fertility using this innovative technology. Ethical, clinical and psychological dilemmas should be considered, discussed and addressed before considering such a novel approach. We believe that the time has come to start this discussion and open this avenue of FP for girls with TS.