Winning isn't everything: Guilt proneness and competitive vs. non-competitive motivation

OBJECTIVE

Guilt proneness is associated with both high motivation to succeed and enhanced concern for others. However, in competition, achieving success requires harming others' interests, which demotivates guilt-prone individuals. Given the prevalence of competition in social and professional life, we examine the relation between guilt proneness, general motivation, and competitive motivation.

METHOD

Two experiments and two laboratory studies (N = 1735) measured guilt proneness, general motivation, and competitive motivation, and their effects on competitive preferences and choices. Study settings included students' choice of playing a game individually vs. competitively (Study 1), physicians' likelihood to seek residency in medical fields characterized by high competitiveness (Study 2), amateur athletes' preferences between inclusive and win-oriented team strategies (Study 3), and online workers' evaluations of a hypothetical scenario (Study 4).

RESULTS

Guilt proneness was related positively to general motivation, but negatively to competitive motivation. Guilt proneness, indirectly through lower competitive motivation, predicted a lower likelihood of pursuing competitive paths and preference for non-competitive strategies. Emphasizing prosocial aspects of competitiveness attenuated these effects.

CONCLUSIONS

Guilt proneness is related to high general motivation but to a lower desire to win. Guilt-prone individuals strive for excellence, but through non-competitive paths, whereas people with lower guilt proneness prefer competing.

[Ovarian drilling by fertiloscopy: feasibility, results and predictive values]

OBJECTIVES

The aims of this study were to assess the effectiveness of the ovarian drilling, compare the techniques by fertiloscopy or by laparoscopy, and search for prognostic factors of success.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This retrospective study focused on 154 ovarian drilling carried out between June 1998 and December 2010 where the drilling has been proposed after failure of the clomifene and before stimulation by FSH among PCOS patients.

RESULTS

The post-drilling ovulation rate is 62%. The spontaneous on-going pregnancy rate is 31% and the total pregnancy rate scalable including secondary stimulation is 58%. No significant difference was found between laparoscopy and the fertiloscopy. The peroperative complications in fertiloscopy were more frequent but without consequences and 20% of the fertiloscopy had to be converted to laparoscopy, half of them for complications and half of them for technical difficulties. The only found preoperative predictors of success are an euthyroidy that increases the chances of pregnancy in general (including the side stimulation) and a lower FSH levels. However, it appears that the chances of pregnancy in FSH stimulation are dramatically decreased if the drilling did not induce ovulation versus the cases where it induced ovulation but no pregnancy (28.8% versus 58.1%, P<0.003).

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

Fertiloscopy results are comparable with those of laparoscopy, which suggests an advantage to this technique in terms of cost, comfort, and length of hospital stay. No usable in practice patient selection criteria could be highlighted. The study suggests that the absence of ovulation after drilling may be a direct indication for IVF.

[Health-related quality of life in women operated on by surgical anti-incontinence procedures: comparison of three techniques]

OBJECTIVES

To assess the health-related quality of life (Contilife) after three surgical anti-incontinence procedures (Tension-Free Vaginal Tape [TVT], Transobturator Vaginal Tape [TOT], and Transobturator Vaginal Tape [TVT-O]).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We performed a prospective analysis of 90 women (30 TVT, 30 TOT, 30 TVT-0) with genuine stress incontinence pre- and postoperatively at 18 months. The objective cure rate was determined by clinical and urodynamic examination and the subjective cure rate by the Contilife questionnaire.

RESULTS

Prior to surgery, patients complained more of effort activities, followed by global well-being. Postoperatively, all domains improved significantly without statistical difference between the three groups and 90% of the patients would advise the intervention to one of their friends.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

Surgical outcomes vary greatly depending on the methodology of the study. Health-related quality of life seems paramount to decide time of surgery and to evaluate postoperatory results. We have chosen the Contilife questionnaire because of its scientific and clinical validity, reliability, responsiveness and linguistic validation. These results confirm that TVT/TOT/TVT-O procedures are a safe and effective surgical method and that they significantly improved health-related quality of life.