Optimized reagents for immunopotency assays on mesenchymal stromal cells for clinical use

Multipotent mesenchymal stromal cells (MSC) offer new therapeutic opportunities based on their ability to modulate an imbalanced immune system. Immunomodulatory potency is typically demonstrated in vitro by measuring the presence of surrogate markers (i.e., indoleamine-2,3-dioxygenase, IDO; tumor necrosis factor receptor type 1, TNFR1) and/or functional assays in co-cultures (i.e., inhibition of lymphoproliferation, polarization of macrophages). However, the biological variability of reagents used in the latter type of assays leads to unreliable and difficult to reproduce data therefore making cross-comparison between batches difficult, both at the intra- and inter-laboratory levels. Herein, we describe a set of experiments aiming at the definition and validation of reliable biological reagents as a first step towards standardization of a potency assay. This approach is based on the co-culture of Wharton's jelly (WJ)-derived MSC and cryopreserved pooled peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Altogether, we successfully defined a robust and reproducible immunopotency assay based on previously described methods incorporating substantial improvements such as cryopreservation of multiple vials of pooled peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from 5 individual donors that enable a number of tests with same reagents, also reducing waste of PBMC from individual donors and therefore contributing to a more efficient and ethical method to use substances of human origin (SoHO). The new methodology was successfully validated using 11 batches of clinical grade MSC,WJ. Methods described here contribute to minimize PBMC donor variability while reducing costs, streamlining assay setup and convenience and laying the foundations for harmonization of biological reagents usage in standardized immunopotency assays for MSC. HIGHLIGHTS: • The use of pools of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) in potency assays contributes to robust and reproducible results, which is key in the assessment of mesenchymal stroma cells (MSC) potency for batch release. • Cryopreservation of PBMCs does not impact negatively on their activation and proliferation abilities. • Cryopreserved pools of PBMC constitutes convenient off-the-shelf reagents for potency assays. • Cryopreservation of pooled PBMCs from multiple donors is a way to reduce waste of donated PBMC and its associated costs, as well as reducing the impact of individual donor variability of substances of human origin (SoHO).

Development and qualification of cell-based relative potency assay for a human respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) mRNA vaccine

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is a leading cause of severe lower respiratory tract infections worldwide. A safe and effective RSV vaccine has been an elusive goal but recent advances in vaccine technology have improved the likelihood that a vaccine for the prevention of RSV could be licensed in near future. We have developed an RSV vaccine V171 consisting of four lipids and messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) encoding an engineered form of the RSV F protein stabilized in its prefusion conformation. The lipids form lipid nanoparticles (LNP) with mRNA encapsulated during process, which protects the mRNA from degradation and enables the mRNA to be delivered into mammalian cells. Once inside the cells, the mRNA then can be translated into RSV F protein and elicit both humoral and cellular immune responses. Preclinical results and Phase I clinical trial results indicate that this mRNA vaccine targeting RSV F protein is a promising RSV vaccine approach and should be further evaluated in clinical trials. We have developed a cell-based relative potency assay to support the Phase II development of this vaccine. Test articles and a reference standard are tested with serial dilutions in a 96-well plate pre-seeded with Hep G2 cells. Cells were incubated for 16-18 h after transfection and then permeabilized and stained with a human monoclonal antibody specific to RSV F protein, followed by a fluorophore-conjugated secondary antibody. The plate is then analyzed for percentage of transfected cells and relative potency of the test article is calculated by comparing its EC50 to that of a reference standard. This assay takes advantage of the fact that due to the inherent variability in biological test systems an absolute measure of potency is more variable than a measure of activity relative to a standard. Targeting testing relative potency range 25-250 %, our assay showed an R2 close to 1 for linearity, relative bias of 1.05-5.41 %, and intermediate precision of 11.0 %. The assay has been used for testing of process development samples, formulation development samples, as well as drug product intermediate (DPI) and drug product (DP) in support of Phase II development of our RSV mRNA vaccine.

Functional design of experiment for potency assay optimization and in-silico simulation

For biotherapeutic analytics, robust and reliable potency assays are required. Design of experiment (DoE) approaches are used to investigate the impact of multiple assay parameters. Currently, specific assay features (e.g., half effective concentration) are modelled independently from each other. A joint interpretation of several assay features is thus difficult. In our functional DoE approach, we use the functional relationship of the assay features to describe the sigmoidal dose-response curve. With the composed functional form, the direct impact of assay parameters on the dose-response curve shape was modelled. Moreover, a multivariate desirability was defined and used for assay optimization. We believe that functional modelling contributes to understanding the joint influence of assay parameters and helps to design robust biotherapeutic analytics.

From an in vivo to an in vitro relative potency (IVRP) assay to fully characterize a multicomponent O-antigen based vaccine against Shigella

Outer membrane vesicles (OMV) represent an innovative platform for the design of polysaccharide based vaccines. Generalized Modules for Membrane Antigens (GMMA), OMV released from engineered Gram-negative bacteria, have been proposed for the delivery of the O-Antigen, key target for protective immunity against several pathogens including Shigella. altSonflex1-2-3 is a GMMA based vaccine, including S. sonnei and S. flexneri 1b, 2a and 3a O-Antigens, with the aim to elicit broad protection against the most prevalent Shigella serotypes, especially affecting children in low-middle income countries. Here we developed an In Vitro Relative Potency assay, based on recognition of O-Antigen by functional monoclonal antibodies selected to bind the key epitopes of the different O-Antigen active ingredients, directly applied to our Alhydrogel-formulated vaccine. Heat-stressed altSonflex1-2-3 formulations were generated and extensively characterized. The impact of detected biochemical changes in in vivo and in vitro potency assays was assessed. The overall results showed how the in vitro assay can replace the use of animals, overcoming the inherently high variability of in vivo potency studies. The entire panel of physico-chemical methods developed will contribute to detect suboptimal batches and will be valuable to perform stability studies. The work on Shigella vaccine candidate can be easily extended to other O-Antigen based vaccines.

Assessing TCR identity, knock-in efficiency, and potency for individualized TCR-T cell therapy

Advances in mass spectrometry, genome sequencing techniques, and bioinformatic strategies have accelerated the discovery of cancer-specific neoantigens. Tumors express multiple immunogenic neoantigens, and neoantigen-specific T cell receptors (TCRs) can be identified in peripheral blood's mononuclear cells in cancer patients. Therefore, individualized TCR-based therapies are a promising approach whereby multiple neoantigen-specific TCRs can be selected in each patient, potentially leading to a highly effective treatment for cancer patients. We developed three multiplex analytical assays to determine the quality attributes of the TCR-T cell drug product with a mixture of five engineered TCRs. The identity of each TCR was determined by two NGS-based methods, Illumina MiSeq and PacBio platforms. This approach not only confirms the expected TCR sequences but also differentiates them by their variable regions. The five individual TCR and total TCR knock-in efficiencies were measured by droplet digital PCR using specific reverse primers. A potency assay based on transfection of antigen-encoding-RNA was developed to assess the dose-dependent activation of T cells for each TCR by measuring the surface activation marker CD137 expression and cytokine secretion. This work provides new assays to characterize individualized TCR-T cell products and insights into quality attributes for the control strategy.

Establishment of certified reference material for the potency assay in yellow fever vaccine quality control, in accordance with International Standards Organization guidance

The attenuated yellow fever vaccine (YFV) is offered free of charge to the Brazilian population through the National Immunization Program (NIP). One of the specifications for quality control analyses of the vaccine is the potency determination. This test determines the number of plaque forming units (PFU) in Vero cells. In order to validate the results, the reference material (RM) is analysed in parallel with an established reference vaccine. The aim of this study was to establish certified RM for use as an internal control in the potency assay for the production chain of YFV. The candidate RM homogeneity and stability were determined, and characterized by a collaborative study for further certification. The RM was considered sufficiently homogeneous with average 4.68 log₁₀ IU/HD and stable at (-20 ± 10) ºC and (22.5 ± 2.5) ºC for 715 and 183 days, respectively. When reconstituted and stored in aliquots of 0.6 mL, it was stable at (-20 ± 10) ºC for eight days. But it was not stable at (5 ± 3) ºC for three days. In a collaborative study, two independents' laboratories gave an averaged value of 4.56 ± 0.030 log₁₀ IU/HD. After determining the expanded uncertainty of homogeneity, stability, and characterization, the certified RM lot: 195VFA020Z presented a property value of 4.56 ± 0.22 log₁₀ IU/HD. It was concluded that the new certified RM can be used in routine analysis of a YFV producer, since it has its property value established and it is stable. The possibility of using it in aliquots after reconstitution will also allow the RM to have a much longer shelf life.

Development and application of potency assays based on genetically modified cells for biological products

Potency assays are key to the development, registration, and quality control of biological products. Although previously preferred for clinical relevance, in vivo bioassays have greatly diminished with the advent of dependent cell lines as well as due to ethical concerns. However, for some products, the development of in vitro cell-based assay is challenging, or existing method has limitations such as tedious procedure or low sensitivity. The generation of genetically modified (GM) cell line with improved response to the analyte provides a scientific and promising solution. Potency assays based on GM cell lines are currently used for the quality control of biological products including cytokines, hormones, therapeutic antibodies, vaccines and gene therapy products. In this review, we have discussed the general principles of designing and developing GM cells-based potency assays, including identification of cellular signaling pathways and detectable biological effects, generation of responsive cell lines and constitution of test systems, based on the current research progress. In addition, the applications of some novel technologies and the common concerns regarding GM cells have also been discussed. The research presented in this review provides insights for the development and application of novel GM cells-based potency assays for biological products.

Validation of a rapid potency assay for cord blood stem cells using phospho flow cytometry: The IL-3-pSTAT5 assay

INTRODUCTION

Public cord blood banks (CBBs) are required to measure cord blood units (CBUs) potency before their release, allowing for the identification of units that may be unsuitable for haematopoietic transplantation. We have developed a rapid flow cytometry assay based on the measurement of STAT-5 phosphorylation of CD34+ stem cells in response to IL-3 stimulation.

METHOD

To adapt the assay from a research setting to its implementation within our CBB regulated operations, we proceded with a full method validation and a correlation comparison of the IL-3-pSTAT5 assay results with the colony-forming unit assay (CFU) results. A total of 60 CBUs cryopreserved in vials were analysed by flow cytometry to determine the sensitivity, specificity, intra-assay precision, robustness, reproducibility, and inter-laboratory agreement of the assay. The CFU assay was also done on the same samples for comparison purposes.

RESULTS

The assay threshold was established at 50% CD34+CD45+pSTAT5+, which provides a 100% sensitivity and a 98.3% specificity. An average intra-assay CV of 7.3% was determined. All results met our qualitative results acceptance criteria regarding the inter-user and inter-laboratory agreements, IL-3 stimulation time, post-thaw incubation delay and staining time. The IL-3-pSTAT5 assay results correlated well with the total CFU determined using the CFU assay (r²  = 0.82, n = 56).

CONCLUSION

This study shows that our rapid flow cytometry assay can be successfully validated and that the potency data obtained display good sensitivity, specificity and robustness. These results demonstrate the feasibility of implementing this assay within CBB operations, as a validated potency assay.

The Art of Stem Cell-Based Therapy

Potency assays represent crucial experiments at the hub of the comprehensive complexity surrounding cell therapy. Moreover, numerous factors beyond biological and scientific considerations are involved in achieving successful potency assays that fulfil regulatory authority approval for a new advanced therapy medicinal product. Though this can mean a frustratingly long period of discovery and development, progress in cell therapy is nowadays proceeding remarkably quickly, assisted by the potency assay rigorously placing emphasis on the need to critically analyse the key factor/s responsible for the therapeutic mechanism of action. History has shown that it can take many decades for there to be an improved understanding of a mechanism of action. Yet the chasing of precise targets has revolutionised medicine, with no clearer example than approaches to viral pandemics. The centuries involved in the eradication of smallpox have paved the way for an unprecedented pace of vaccine development for the Covid-19 pandemic. Such extraordinary accomplishments foster encouragement that similarly for stem cell-based therapy, our scientific knowledge will continue to improve apace. This chapter focuses on the art of experimentation and discovery, introducing potency assay requisites and numerous factors that can influence potency assay outcomes. A comprehensive understanding of potency assays and their development can hasten the provision of new cell therapies to help resolve burdensome diseases of unmet medical need.

Potency Assay Development: A Keystone for Clinical Use

Potency can be described as the quantitative measure of biological activity, that is, the ability of an Advanced Therapy Medicinal Product (ATMP) to elicit the intended effect necessary for clinical efficacy. Potency testing is part of the quality control strategy necessary for batch release and is required for market approval application of an ATMP. Thus, it is crucial to develop a reliable and accurate potency assay. As a prerequisite for potency assay development, it is essential to define the mode of action of the product and thereby also the relevant biological activity that should be measured. The establishment of a potency assay should be initiated already during early product development followed by its progressive implementation into an ATMP's manufacturing, quality control and release process. Potency testing is indispensable for clinical use with a wide range of applications. A potency assay is a valuable tool to determine the product's stability, detect the impact of changes in the manufacturing process on the product, demonstrate quality and manufacturing consistency from batch to batch, estimate clinical efficacy and define the effective dose. This chapter describes the requirements and challenges to be considered for potency assay development and the importance of a well-established potency assay for clinical use.

Optimising cell-based bioassays via integrated design of experiments (ixDoE) - A practical guide

For process optimisation Design of Experiments (DoE) has long been established as a more powerful strategy than a One Factor at a Time approach. Nevertheless, DoE is not widely used especially in the field of cell-based bioassay development although it is known that complex interactions often exist. We believe that biopharmaceutical manufacturers are reluctant to move beyond standard practices due to the perceived costs, efforts, and complexity. We therefore introduce the integrated DoE (ixDoE) approach to target a smarter use of DoEs in the bioassay setting, specifically in optimising resources and time. Where in a standard practice 3 to 4 separate DoEs would be performed, our ixDoE approach includes the necessary statistical inference from only a single experimental set. Hence, we advocate for an innovative, ixDoE approach accompanied by a suitable statistical analysis strategy and present this as a practical guide for a typical bioassay development from basic research to biopharmaceutical industry.

Functional in vitro models of the inhibitory effect of adipose tissue-derived stromal cells on lymphocyte proliferation: Improved sensitivity and quantification through flow cytometric analysis

As the interest in cell-based therapies continue to increase, so does the need for assays detailing potency and providing platforms for identifying mechanisms of action. For most clinical implications of mesenchymal stromal cells, the immunomodulatory effect is crucial. While the suppressive potential on lymphocyte proliferation is well-described in literature, reproducible and standardized assays to document and quantify it varies from research group to research group and between methodologies. The aim of the present study was to utilize flowcytometry to quantify proliferation and identify measurements to increase the assay sensitivity to treatment with adipose tissue-derived stromal cells (ASC). Lymphocyte proliferation was induced by the unspecific mitogen phytohemagglutinin or by alloreactivity towards an irradiated donor in a mixed lymphocyte reaction. Addition of ASC did not change the composition of T cells, B cells, NK cells, NKT cell types considerably; likewise, no increases in proliferation were observed upon inclusion of ASC, demonstrating that ASC does not evoke an additive response. On the contrary, the suppressive effect of ASC was documented. By applying different gating strategies and curve fitting, the sensitivity was increased, and dose-response relationships established. Flow cytometric evaluation allows for more detailed identification of the lymphocytes affected by ASC and constitute a significant asset in future unraveling of modes and mechanisms of action, as well as quantification of potency.

Potency assays for human adipose-derived stem cells as a medicinal product toward wound healing

In pre-clinical studies, human adipose-derived stem cells (hASCs) have shown great promise as a treatment modality for healing of cutaneous wounds. The advantages of hASCs are that they are relatively easy to obtain in large numbers from basic liposuctions, they maintain their characteristics after long-term in vitro culture, and they possess low immunogenicity, which enables the use of hASCs from random donors. It has been hypothesized that hASCs exert their wound healing properties by reducing inflammation, inducing angiogenesis, and promoting fibroblast and keratinocyte growth. Due to the inherent variability associated with the donor-dependent nature of ASC-based products, it appears necessary that the quality of the different products is prospectively certified using a set of most relevant potency assays. In this review, we present an overview of the available methodologies to assess the Mode and the Mechanism of Action of hASCs, specifically in the wound healing scenario. In conclusion, we propose a panel of potential potency assays to include in the future production of ASC-based medicinal products.

Extracellular miR-6723-5p could serve as a biomarker of limbal epithelial stem/progenitor cell population

BACKGROUND

Dysfunction or loss of limbal stem cells can result in limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD), a disease that cause corneal opacity, pain, and loss of vision. Cultivated limbal epithelial transplantation (CLET) can be used to restore stem cell niche homeostasis and replenish the progenitor pool. Transplantation has been reported with high success rate, but there is an unmet need of prognostic markers that correlate with clinical outcomes. To date, the progenitor content in the graft is the only parameter that has been retrospectively linked to success.

METHODS

In this study, we investigate extracellular micro RNAs (miRNAs) associated with stem/progenitor cells in cultivated limbal epithelial cells (cLECs). Using micro RNA sequencing and linear regression modelling, we identify a miRNA signature in cultures containing high proportion of stem/progenitor cells. We then develop a robust RNA extraction workflow from culture media to confirm a positive miRNA correlation with stem/progenitor cell proportion.

RESULTS

miR-6723-5p is associated with cultures containing high proportion of stem/progenitor cells, and is detected in the basal layer of corneal epithelium.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that miR-6723-5p could potentially serve as a stem/progenitor cell marker in cLECs.

Identification of functional pathways for regenerative bioactivity of selected renal cells

Background

Selected renal cells (SRC) are in Phase II clinical trials as a kidney-sourced, autologous, tubular epithelial cell-enriched cell-based therapy for chronic kidney disease (CKD). In preclinical studies with rodent models of CKD, SRC have been shown to positively modulate key renal biomarkers associated with development of the chronic disease condition.

Methods

A comparative bioinformatic analysis of transcripts specifically enriched or depleted in SRC component sub-populations relative to the initial, biopsy-derived cell source was conducted.

Results

Outcomes associated with therapeutically relevant bioactivity from a systematic, genome-wide transcriptomic profiling of rodent SRC are reported. Key transcriptomic networks and concomitant signaling pathways that may underlie SRC mechanism of action as manifested by reparative, restorative, and regenerative bioactivity in rodent models of chronic kidney disease are identified. These include genes and gene networks associated with cell cycle control, transcriptional control, inflammation, ECM–receptor interaction, immune response, actin polymerization, regeneration, cell adhesion, and morphogenesis.

Conclusions

These data indicate that gene networks associated with development of the kidney are also leveraged for SRC regenerative bioactivity, providing evidence of potential mechanisms of action.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13287-022-02713-6.

Development and comparison of three cell-based potency assays for anti-respiratory syncytial virus monoclonal antibody

There is an increasing demand for monoclonal antibody (mAb) therapies to confer passive immunity against viral diseases. Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is the most common cause of bronchiolitis, lower respiratory tract infections, and hospitalization in infants. Currently, there is no RSV vaccine but a humanized mAb available for high risk infants. MK-1654 is a fully human mAb with YTE mutation in the fragment crystallizable (Fc) region to extend the half-life in circulation. It binds to a highly conserved epitope of RSV Fusion protein with high affinity and neutralizes RSV infection. A functional cell-based assay is a regulatory requirement for clinical development, commercial release, and stability testing of MK-1654. In this study, we have evaluated three RSV neutralization assays to test the potency of MK-1654, including an imaging-based virus reduction neutralization test (VRNT) and two reporter virus-based assays (RSV-GFP and RSV-NLucP). All three methods showed good dose response curves of MK-1654 with similar EC50 values. RSV-NLucP method was chosen for further development because it is simple and can be easily adapted to quality control testing laboratories. After optimization, the RSV-NLucP assay was pre-qualified with good linearity, relative accuracy, intermediate precision, and specificity, therefore suitable for a cell-based potency assay.

Assay of active pharmaceutical ingredients in drug products based on relative response factors: Instrumentation insights and practical considerations

Relative Response Factors (RRFs) can be used for quantitation of one compound against another and it is widely used for Impurity analysis of pharmaceutical products; however, the application in potency assay is limited. Through an extensive study shown in this paper, it can be concluded that using the "RRF methodology" for potency assay is much more challenging compared to impurity analysis, due to the much tighter criteria required for potency analysis. The effects of instrument settings, which are rarely discussed or recognized in current HPLC analytical method development and quality release testing, are discussed. These factors impact the RRF just as much as other commonly recognized HPLC parameters. The effects of UV detector settings, i.e. Slit Width, Step Width, Band Width, and Data Collection Module, have been explored. This phenomenon has been demonstrated using three compounds to observe the impact of their quantitation due to the significant RRF variations. Finally, principles to reduce RRF variations have been discussed, and practical considerations of RRF application to method development and method transfer are provided.

Cryopreservation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells for use in proliferation assays: First step towards potency assays

Investigational cell-based therapeutics are rapidly heading towards pivotal clinical trials. The premise is that the scientific rationale is well defined, and that product quality reflects exactly this. In vitro potency assays are necessary tools for evaluating cell products, and with potency assays comes high demands for standardization and reproducibility of the methods involved. For demonstrating principles of cell therapeutics for allogeneic use or with claimed immunosuppressive efficacies, assays involving peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) are critical. Establishment of a cryopreserved bank of PBMC favors standardization, as it allows repeated use of a single donor and simultaneous testing of several donors. The first step to fulfil such potential is to ensure optimum conditions for preservation of PBMC function, and secondly to design assays which heightens the reproducibility. Emphasis should be put on application of the assay. The objective of the present study was to establish a methodological foundation for cell therapeutics to be tested, and several aspects were factored in, including cell concentrations and partial changes of medium. PBMC were isolated and cryopreserved in six formulations of cryoprotective medium consisting of fetal bovine serum (90%, 60%, and 30%) in combination with dimethyl sulfoxide (10% or 5%). The proliferative capacity of the cryopreserved cells was assayed by labeling with carboxyfluorescein succinimidyl ester and stimulation by phytohemagglutinin or in mixed lymphocyte reactions, analyzed by flow cytometry. To counter an eventual lag phase post thaw, the assays were designed to include two durations and to explore the possibility of reducing cell numbers, two cell concentrations. Qualitative and quantitative aspects of the staining were affected by formulation as well as design, stressing the importance of basic optimization for assay development. We conclude that the established methods allow for optimized preservation of function and will serve as a platform for further development of robust functional assays.

Mesenchymal stem/stromal cell quality control: validation of mixed lymphocyte reaction assay using flow cytometry according to ICH Q2(R1)

Background

Mesenchymal stem/stromal cells (MSC) have immunomodulatory properties, studied in a wide range of diseases. Validated quality controls must confirm this activity in the context of clinical trials. This study presents a method’s validation, assessing MSC’s ability to inhibit lymphocyte proliferation, according to the ICH Q2 standard.

Methods

MSC were co-cultured with CellTrace™ Violet-labeled Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) coming from a bank of ten donors, at seven different ratios for 7 days. Cell trace violet PBMC bank was validated in parallel. Flow cytometry analysis was used to obtain the division percentage of T cells. The percentage of inhibition of lymphocyte proliferation by MSC, for each ratio X, was calculated using the formula: Ratio × percentage of inhibition = (control percentage of division—ratio × percentage of division)/control percentage of division. The inhibition percentage of lymphocyte proliferation function of co-culture ratios was represented in a line graph. The corresponding area under the curve was calculated, representing MSC’s ability to inhibit lymphocyte proliferation.

Results

Two cell trace violet PBMC banks were compared for bank validation. When compared using four different MSC samples coming each from a different donor, their area under the curve did not show any statistical differences and were correlated. Moreover, the stability of one cell trace violet PBMC bank was confirmed up to 509 days of storage.

Analytical parameters were investigated for method validation. Analysis of repeatability and reproducibility respectively showed a standard deviation of 6.1% and 4.6%. The assay was robust regarding PBMC, as no statistical differences were found between inhibitory activities when testing three adjacent concentrations of PBMC. Still, attention is needed on MSC quantity as it can influence results. Linearity was evaluated: the percentage of inhibition of lymphocyte proliferation function of co-culture ratios was linear on the exploited range. Finally, the assay measurement range allowed to differentiate MSC presenting different inhibition activities.

Conclusion

This quantification method displayed low analytical variability and no inter-bank variability of PBMC. However, MSC quantification should be checked before co-culture to reduce variability. Therefore, it could be used for the qualification of MSC batches’ immunomodulatory activity.

Biolayer Interferometry-based FcγRIIa binding assay for a therapeutic antibody with strong effector function

FcγRIIa receptor binding is part of the mechanism of action for many therapeutic antibodies. AlphaScreen® technology and Biolayer Interferometry (BLI) are often used to assess protein-protein interactions. Recently we demonstrated that the presence of aggregates in samples significantly increased binding potency values in AlphaScreen®-based FcRn binding assays, sometimes masking the loss of potency. Even bigger effect of aggregates was observed in an AlphaScreen®-based FcγRIIa binding assay for a monoclonal antibody with strong effector function. To resolve this issue a novel BLI-based FcγRIIa binding assay was developed and qualified. The assay measures association binding responses and calculates the binding potency of the samples relative to the standard using Parallel Line Analysis. The method overcomes interference of aggregates present in the samples, distinguishes different Fc glycosylation patterns, and is stability-indicating. It can be used for sample characterization, drug product release and stability testing.

Development of homogeneous plasmonic potency assay using gold nanoparticle immunocomplexes

We evaluated the use of gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) platform in a homogenous assay for a potency measurement of a therapeutic monoclonal antibody (mAb). The recombinant human ligand protein to the therapeutic mAb was immobilized on AuNPs via functionalized self-assembled monolayers. Binding of the mAb to ligand lead to plasmonic signals that were detected faster in a homogeneous assay than the conventional enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). In this study, we demonstrated that the AuNP-based homogeneous plasmonic immunoassay (HPI) generated comparable potency values of a therapeutic mAb to a conventional binding ELISA in relatively shorter assay time and steps. Binding HPI can be potentially implemented as a potency assay for therapeutic mAbs in quality control laboratories.

A Binding Potency Assay for Pritumumab and Ecto-Domain Vimentin

Pritumumab, a natural human IgG1kappa mAb, was isolated from the regional lymph node of a patient with cervical cancer. This antibody has been reported to bind the cytoskeletal protein vimentin, and to cell surface expressed vimentin referred to as ecto-domain vimentin (EDV). Here, we report details of the development of a potency of binding assay for pritumumab as a prerequisite before pursuing clinical trials. The enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to detect antibody-binding antigen can serve as a potency assay for release of manufactured samples to be used in clinical studies. Several layers of controls for this assay along with suitability testing for reagents and components of the assay must be developed before the assay can be incorporated for stability testing and release of manufatured samples.

Development and pre-validation of a quantitative multi-dose serological assay for potency testing of inactivated rabies vaccines for human use

It is mandatory to ensure the quality of biological products used in the prevention of rabies, a zoonosis with nearly 100% lethality. Fifteen million people receive post-exposure prophylaxis yearly. The vaccine batches are assessed by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) test which has several disadvantages such as significant variability and animal welfare issues. The estimation of immunogenicity based on titration of neutralizing antibodies (NA) is not applied to the human vaccine yet. Despite this, a satisfactory concentration of NA (0.5 IU/ml) can be used as a predictor of the clinical efficacy and for estimating rabies vaccine potency. The objective of this study was to develop and pre-validate a Serological Potency Test (SPT) using the modified Rapid Fluorescent Focus Inhibition Test (mRFFIT) to determine the potency of rabies vaccines for human use, demonstrating its relevance and reliability. The results show good agreement between the potencies determined by the SPT and the NIH test. The assay was able to distinguish between potent and sub-potent lots of vaccines. The results demonstrated that SPT is a viable candidate for validation and inclusion in pharmacopeias as a reduction and refinement for the NIH test.

Stability enhancement of clinical grade multipotent mesenchymal stromal cell-based products

Background

Successful delivery of cell-based therapeutics into patients is compromised by their short shelf-life upon release from production facilities due to the living nature of the active component that rapidly loses viability, and therefore its properties. In this context, the use of appropriate additives may contribute to the stabilisation of the cellular component within specifications for a longer time until administration.

Results

In the present study, we evaluated the effect of different formulations on the stability of viability, identity, and potency of clinical grade multipotent mesenchymal stromal cells in suspension, both electrolyte solution and protein content were found to impact on their shelf-life. Particularly cryopreservation of cells in a Plasmalyte 148 supplemented with 2% (w/v) AlbIX (a yeast-derived recombinant albumin) and 10% (v/v) dimethyl sulfoxide, and final formulation post-thawing in Plasmalyte 148 supplemented with 2% (w/v) AlbIX enabling prolonged stability from 24 h up to 72 h in optimal conditions. Further investigation on the mechanisms of action involved revealed a delay of apoptosis progression into late stage when AlbIX was present.

Conclusions

The use of optimal formulations for each cell type of interest is crucial to extend the shelf life of cell-based pharmaceuticals and contribute to solve logistical challenges. We demonstrated that the use of Plasmalyte 148 supplemented with 2% (w/v) AlbIX resulted in superior stability of multipotent mesenchymal stromal cells without affecting their identity and multipotency.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12967-018-1659-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Optimisation of a potency assay for the assessment of immunomodulative potential of clinical grade multipotent mesenchymal stromal cells

Clinical use of multipotent Mesenchymal Stromal Cell (MSC)-based medicinal products requires their production in compliance with Good Manufacturing Practices, thus ensuring that the final drug product meets specifications consistently from batch to batch in terms of cell viability, identity, purity and potency. Potency relates to the efficacy of the medicine in its target clinical indication, so adequate release tests need to be defined and validated as quality controls. Herein we report the design and optimisation of parameters affecting the performance of an in vitro cell-based assay for assessing immunomodulatory potential of clinical grade MSC for human use, based on their capacity to inhibit proliferation of T lymphocytes under strong polyclonal stimuli. The resulting method was demonstrated to be reproducible and relatively simple to execute. Two case studies using clinical grade MSC are presented as examples to illustrate the applicability of the methodology described in this work.

Development and implementation of tPA clot lysis activity assay using ACL TOP™ hemeostasis testing system in QC laboratories

This report describes the design, development, validation and long-term performance of tPA clot lysis activity assay using Advanced Chemistry Line Total Operational Performance (ACL TOP)™ Homeostasis Testing System. The results of the study demonstrated robust and stable performance of the analytical method. The accuracy of the assay, expressed by percent recovery is 98-99%. The intermediate precision and repeatability precision, expressed as Relative Standard Deviation (RSD), was 3% and less than 2% respectively. The validated range is from 70% to 130% of the target potency of 5.8 × 10⁵ IU/mg. The linearity of this range, expressed in correlation coefficient, is 0.997. After the assay is transferred to a QC laboratory, the assay retained high accuracy and precision with a success rate of >99%.

Interlaboratory study for the establishment of Brazilian Bothrops Reference Venom and Antivenom for potency evaluation of Bothrops antivenom

A collaborative study was performed for the establishment of the 5th lot of Brazilian Bothrops Reference Venom and the 1st lot of Brazilian Bothrops Reference Antivenom. All Brazilian manufacturers of Antibothrops Immunoglobulins and the National Control Laboratory participated of the study. The declared potency of the 5th lot of the Bothrops Reference Venom is 40.29 μg/0.5 ml, and the potency of the 1st lot of Bothrops Reference Antivenom is 6.51 mg/ml. For the potency evaluation of Bothrops Reference Venom the inter assay precision (gCV) was 3.25% in lab 01; 3.51% in INCQS; 4.71% in lab 03 and 25.11% in lab 02, and the inter laboratory precision was 13.76%. The intra assay precision of Bothrops Reference Antivenom determinations was 4.38% in INCQS; 8.47% in lab 02; 10.51% in lab 03 and 20.05% in lab 01. The inter assay precision was 3.51% in INCQS; 9.65% in lab 02; 18.03% in lab 01 and 20.23% in lab 03. The inter laboratory precision was 15.85%. Despite the high number of invalid results (55.6% for the pharmacopoeial method and 69.4% for the proposed method) the parallel line assay, have better inter laboratorial precision (gCV = 16.62%) than the pharmacopoeial potency assay (gCV = 38.28%).

Immunocapture isotope dilution mass spectrometry in response to a pandemic influenza threat

As a result of recent advances in mass spectrometry-based protein quantitation methods, these techniques are now poised to play a critical role in rapid formulation of pandemic influenza vaccines. Analytical techniques that have been developed and validated on seasonal influenza strains can be used to increase the quality and decrease the time required to deliver protective pandemic vaccines to the global population. The emergence of a potentially pandemic avian influenza A (H7N9) virus in March of 2013, prompted the US public health authorities and the vaccine industry to initiate production of a pre-pandemic vaccine for preparedness purposes. To this end, we evaluated the feasibility of using immunocapture isotope dilution mass spectrometry (IC-IDMS) to evaluate the suitability of the underlying monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies (mAbs and pAbs) for their capacity to isolate the H7 hemagglutinin (HA) in this new vaccine for quantification by IDMS. A broad range of H7 capture efficiencies was observed among mAbs tested by IC-IDMS with FR-545, 46/6, and G3 A533 exhibiting the highest cross-reactivity capabilities to H7 of A/Shanghai/2/2013. MAb FR-545 was selected for continued assessment, evaluated by IC-IDMS for mAb reactivity against H7 in the H7N9 candidate vaccine virus and compared with/to reactivity to the reference polyclonal antiserum in allantoic fluid, purified whole virus, lyophilized whole virus and final detergent-split monovalent vaccine preparations for vaccine development. IC-IDMS assessment of FR-545 alongside IC-IDMS using the reference polyclonal antiserum to A/Shanghai/2/2013 and with the regulatory SRID method showed strong correlation and mAb IC-IDMS could have played an important role in the event a potential surrogate potency test was required to be rapidly implemented.

A Novel Lack-of-Fit Assessment as a System Suitability Test for Potency Assays

Bioassay data analysis is used to determine the potency of protein therapeutics. To properly determine potency, the experimental data need to be fitted to a model that adequately describes the observed dose-response relationship. Typical models include 4-parameter logistic curve fits, 5-parameter logistic curve fits or parallel line analysis. Lack-of-fit assessment can be used as a measure of potency assay system suitability to ensure appropriate closeness of the chosen model fit to the experimental data. We present a novel lack-of-fit approach that overcomes the shortcomings of previously described lack-of-fit tests, such as the conventional analysis of variance (ANOVA) F-test and the lack-of-fit sum of squares test. Simulation studies and examples are used to assess the performance of the new lack-of-fit test. The results show that the described lack-of-fit approach can effectively reject poorly fitted data while retaining well-fitted data, and has advantages in potency assay applications where instrument-to-instrument variability in absolute readout is expected.LAY ABSTRACT: Potency assays are analytical procedures used for characterization as well as release and stability analysis in drug development and for approved products. Dose-response data generated from a drug sample and a well-characterized reference standard are evaluated to determine the potency of the drug sample relative to the reference standard. In order to obtain a potency determination, dose-response data need to be fitted to a proper model that adequately describes the observed dose-response relationship. There are different options described to assess the goodness-of-fit of the data. One approach is the goodness-of-fit assessment based on F-test. This approach compares the lack-of-fit error (representing the discrepancy between observed data and fitted curve) to the pure error (representing the random noise between replicate measurement) to determine if the observed lack-of-fit error can be attributed to random noise. A limitation of goodness of fit assessments via F-test lies in its propensity to penalize precise data (small lack-of-fit error can be considered significantly high if the assay has exceptionally low pure error) and accept undesirable noisy data (large undesirable lack-of-fit error can be considered insignificant due to large pure error). An alternative approach based on lack-of-fit sum of squares is only applicable to certain types of assays where the magnitude of measurements is consistent across different instruments given that the lack-of-fit sum of squares will increase when the magnitude of the assay signal measurements increase, even if the relative magnitude of assay data versus fitted curve remains the same. We introduce here a novel approach that overcomes the limitations of F-test and sum of squares-based approaches. This new approach will effectively reject poor data and retain good data, and it is independent of differences in absolute readout across instruments.

Replacing antibodies with modified DNA aptamers in vaccine potency assays

Vaccine in vitro potency assays are vital regulatory tests that are used to confirm the presence and concentration of an antigen of interest in a form that directly or indirectly relates to protective activity in patients. Current assays come in many forms, but they almost exclusively use antibody reagents for selective detection of the target antigen. Antibodies provide specific recognition of vaccine antigens but also exhibit drawbacks such as stability limitations, cost, and lot-to-lot variation, which can make it challenging to maintain the reagent throughout the lifetime of the vaccine. We explored replacing antibodies with aptamers. Aptamers are macromolecules, such as nucleic acids, which can bind to their targets with high specificity and affinity, similar to that of antibodies. Some of the advantages of using aptamers over antibodies is that aptamers can be more stable, smaller, less expensive to produce, synthesized in vitro, and logistically easier to supply throughout the multi-decade lifespan of a commercial vaccine. We created modified DNA aptamers against the common vaccine carrier protein, CRM₁₉₇. Several aptamers were discovered and one was chosen for further characterization. The binding kinetics of the aptamer revealed an off-rate 16-fold slower than anti-CRM₁₉₇ antibodies used for comparison. The aptamers were more sensitive than available antibodies in some assay formats and comparable in others. The aptamer epitope was mapped to the receptor-binding domain of CRM₁₉₇, a site adjacent to a known antibody binding site. These data address some key aspects for a path forward in replacing antibodies with aptamers for use as critical reagents in vaccine assays. We further highlight the possibility of using nucleic acid reagents to develop next generation potency assays.

Development of a surrogate potency assay to determine the angiogenic activity of Stempeucel®, a pooled, ex-vivo expanded, allogeneic human bone marrow mesenchymal stromal cell product

BACKGROUND

Mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) have emerged as a more beneficial alternative to conventional therapy and may offer a potential cure for unmet medical needs. MSCs are known to possess strong immunomodulatory and anti-inflammatory properties. Moreover, they promote angiogenesis and tissue regeneration through the secretion of trophic factors. For these reasons, the past decade witnessed a sharp increase in the number of clinical trials conducted with stem cells for various vascular diseases requiring angiogenesis. In this study, we evaluated the in vitro angiogenic potency of Stempeucel®, which is an allogeneic pooled human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stromal cell (phBMMSC) product. We previously established the safety of Stempeucel® in our pre-clinical studies, and clinical trials conducted for critical limb ischaemia and acute myocardial infarction.

METHODS

Because the proposed mechanism of action of phBMMSCs is mainly through the secretion of pro-angiogenic cytokines, we developed a surrogate potency assay by screening various batches of large-scale expanded phBMMSCs for the expression of angiogenic factors and cytokines through gene expression and growth factor analyses, followed by in vitro functional assays.

RESULTS

The well characterized angiogenic vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) was selected and quantified in twenty six manufactured batches of phBMMSCs to establish consistency following the United States Food and Drug Administration recommendations. According to recommendations 21 CFR 211.165(e) and 211.194(a)(2), we also established and documented the specificity and reproducibility of the test methods employed through validation. Moreover, we also attempted to elucidate the mechanism of action of the cell population to ensure appropriate biological activity. The functional role of VEGF has been established through in vitro angiogenic assays and a dose-dependent correlation was observed with in vitro functional results.

CONCLUSIONS

The data generated from this study suggest the selection of VEGF as a single surrogate marker to test the angiogenic potency of phBMMSCs. Our study reports the quantification of VEGF in twenty six batches of large-scale manufactured phBMMSCs, and a concentration-dependent correlation of secreted VEGF to endothelial cell functions of migration, proliferation and tube formation, in the conditioned medium obtained from nine phBMMSC batches. To our cognizance, this is the first study in which a single angiogenic factor (VEGF) has been qualified as a surrogate potency marker through all three in vitro functional assays to determine the angiogenic potency of the phBMMSC population.

A Co-culture Assay to Determine Efficacy of TNF-α Suppression by Biomechanically Induced Human Bone Marrow Mesenchymal Stem Cells

The beneficial effects of mesenchymal stem cell (MSC)-based cellular therapies are believed to be mediated primarily by the ability odansf MSCs to suppress inflammation associated with chronic or acute injury, infection, autoimmunity, and graft-versus-host disease. To specifically address the effects of frictional force caused by blood flow, or wall shear stress (WSS), on human MSC immunomodulatory function, we have utilized microfluidics to model WSS at the luminal wall of arteries. Anti-inflammatory potency of MSCs was subsequently quantified via measurement of TNF-α production by activated murine splenocytes in co-culture assays. The TNF-α suppression assay serves as a reproducible platform for functional assessment of MSC potency and demonstrates predictive value as a surrogate assay for MSC therapeutic efficacy.

Establishment of an animal challenge model as a potency assay for an inactivated Enterovirus Type 71 vaccine

Enterovirus 71 (EV71) belongs to the Enterovirus genus of the Picornaviridae family, and its occurrence in Asia is associated with hand-foot-and-mouth disease (HFMD), leading to death in some cases, in young children. An effective EV71 vaccine is therefore urgently needed. In this study, we established a two-step EV71 vaccine potency model. Intraperitoneal injections in 2-day-old suckling mice were used to establish the LD50 of EV71 B4, B5, C2, C4, and C5 subgenotypes. Only C4 caused hind limb paralysis in mice (LD50: 2.62 ± 0.45). EV71 VP1 protein was identified in the brain tissues at histology. In the second phase of the model, 3-week-old female ICR mice received one primary and two boosting i.p. injections of formalin-inactivated EV71 B4 and C4 vaccine. Immunized serum was neutralized in vitro with EV71 C4 and applied to the murine challenge model. The C4 vaccine-immunized serum exhibited the highest protective titre (ED50 = 114.6), while the B4 immunized serum had the weakest protective titre (ED50 = 34.3). Additionally, human plasma and intravenous immunoglobulin displayed significant protection in the neutralization assay. Our results could facilitate candidate EV71 vaccine immunogenicity and efficacy evaluations, and may help establish reference EV71 antisera in the future.

A signaling-enhanced chimeric receptor to activate the ICOS pathway in T cells

Activation of the inducible costimulator (ICOS) signaling pathway in T cells is difficult to assess with bioassays, because most T cell lines do not constitutively express ICOS. Additionally, engagement of ICOS by its natural ligand B7 related protein 1 (B7RP1) is insufficient to elicit ICOS signaling, but requires simultaneous costimulation of the T cell receptor (TCR) to be effective. Here we describe a genetically engineered human T cell line that expresses a chimeric receptor (ICOS-CD3) consisting of full-length human ICOS fused at its C-terminal end to the cytoplasmic domain of human CD3 zeta. When engaged by B7RP1, ICOS-CD3 initiated signaling independently of TCR costimulation and induced substantially more IL-2 secretion in Jurkat T cells compared to wildtype ICOS. We demonstrate that this signaling-enhanced chimeric receptor can be used in simple and sensitive bioassays to detect bioactive B7RP1, anti-B7RP1 drugs, and the presence of corresponding neutralizing anti-drug antibodies.

Development of a sensitive potency assay to measure the anti-proliferation effect of an anti-HER2 antibody

For therapeutic antibodies that inhibit the growth of cancer cells, proliferation assays that measure cell number changes after the antibody treatment are often used to determine the potency of the antibody. Two of the most commonly used non-radioactive readout systems for proliferation assays, the ATP bioluminescence assay and the fluorescent dye Alamar Blue assay, were initially tested as potency assays an anti-HER2 antibody. Due to the slow growth of the target cells, these assays only produced less than 3-fold difference after 5 days of antibody treatment. BrdU incorporation-based proliferation assay, which differentiates proliferating cells from arrested cells, was developed, and showed superior sign-to-background ratio. Colorimetric, chemiluminescent, and DELFIA readouts were compared for BrdU incorporation assays, and DELFIA-based assay was further optimized using a Design of Experiment (DoE) approach. The final DELFIA-based BrdU incorporation assay demonstrated superior signal-to-background ratio, robustness, accuracy, and precision, and represented significant improvement over traditional proliferation assays.

Development and validation of a novel cell-based assay for potency determination of human parathyroid hormone (PTH)

Parathyroid hormone (PTH) is the primary regulator of serum calcium homeostasis and plays a major role in bone metabolism. Its actions are mediated via the PTH1 receptor (PTH1R) resulting in adenylate cyclase activation and consequently production of cyclic adenosine mono-phosphate (cAMP). The latter stimulates cellular metabolic pathways. This study describes the development, validation and applications of a novel cell-based potency assay for PTH using HEK293 cells over-expressing PTH1R. PTH concentration-dependent cAMP formation in these cells was quantitatively analyzed employing time-resolved fluorescence technology (TR-FRET). The optimized assay was precise, reproducible and exhibited a high sensitivity to PTH with a limit of quantification in the low picogram range. The potencies of differently manufactured PTH1-34 peptides, as well as a full-length variant (PTH1-84), were all accurately measured. Since PTH activity is inhibited by neutralizing antibodies against PTH, the assay was adapted to detect and measure neutralizing antibodies in human serum. Thus, applications of this novel cell-based PTH potency assay were extended to immunogenicity testing of PTH preparations in non-clinical and clinical settings.

Development of a serology-based assay for efficacy evaluation of a lactococcicosis vaccine in Seriola fish

Lactococcicosis is an infection caused by the bacterium Lactococcus garvieae and creates serious economic damage to cultured marine and fresh water fish industries. The use of the assay currently applied to evaluate the potency of the lactococcicosis vaccine is contingent upon meeting specific parameters after statistical analysis of the percent survival of the vaccinated yellowtail or greater amberjack fish after challenge with a virulent strain of L. garvieae. We found that measuring the serological response with a quantitative agglutinating antibody against the L. garvieae antigen (phenotype KG+) was an effective method of monitoring the potency of lactococcicosis vaccines. Vaccinated fish had significantly higher antibody titers than control fish when the L. garvieae Lg2-S strain was used as an antigen. Furthermore, the titer of the KG + agglutinating antibody was correlated with vaccine potency, and the cut-off titer was determined by comparing the data with those from the challenge test. An advantage of the proposed serology-based potency assay is that it will contribute to reduced numbers of animal deaths during vaccine potency evaluations.