Lung cancer patients' perceptions of informed consent documents

OBJECTIVE

To compare patients' perceptions and preferences of two different versions of informed consent documents.

METHODS

Patients eligible for a trial of palliative chemotherapy for lung cancer (N = 22) were randomly assigned to receive either an original consent document or a shortened version written for the present study. Semi-structured interviews were conducted after the patients had read the consent documents. The interviews were transcribed verbatim and analysed using qualitative content analysis.

RESULTS

Few differences between the two groups were found with respect to patients' assessment of the amount of content and the most important information in the documents. Information about disease and treatment seemed to be of most interest for the patients, while information about research aspects of the study such as financing, confidentiality and publishing (formalities) was judged to be of lesser relevance. Two patients who read the original document indicated that they treated the formalities as secondary.

CONCLUSION

Patients seemed to pay little attention to the research aspects, and thus risked to misunderstand the main point of the consent document.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

The structure of consent documents should clarify for the readers that they are asked to take part in research, and that participation is voluntary.

Prognostic significance of Ki-67/MIB-1 proliferation index in meningiomas

Even though tumor grade, subtype, and extent of resection are strong prognostic factors in human meningiomas, the growth of this tumor is still unpredictable, and additional prognostic markers are needed. Thus, immunohistochemical determination of proliferative activity using the Ki-67 equivalent antibody MIB-1 has gained increased attention. However, the reported prognostic significance of this marker in meningiomas is not fully clarified. The aim of this study was to investigate the prognostic role of MIB-1 proliferation index (PI) in a series of meningiomas comprising 23 benign, 17 atypical, and 9 anaplastic tumors. MIB- 1 PI increased with increasing tumor grade and discriminated significantly benign from atypical and anaplastic meningiomas whereas no difference was found between the latter two grades. However, due to the considerable overlap of PI values between the various grades, one should be circumspect before using this criterion for tumor grading. Furthermore, MIB-1 PIs were significantly higher in recurrent tumors compared with non-recurrent and a reliable MIB-1 PI cut-off value of 10% was established. This value, however, cannot automatically be adapted by other laboratories and must be regarded just as a guideline. In conclusion, MIB-1 PI appears as an important prognostic factor and should be used in combination with traditional histological criteria for malignancy in order to identify meningiomas with increased risk of recurrence.

[The chemical working environment among car painters in Bergen]

Official guidelines have been prepared for the working environment in Norwegian spraylacquering garages, in order to reduce the incidence of symptoms and diseases related to exposure to organic solvents. 11 garages were visited to see if the guidelines were being followed. All the sprayers (n = 28) were examined by questionnaire about the occurrence of acute symptoms connected to the central nervous system, the skin, the eyes and the airways during work, and about their use of personal protective equipment. All the garages had specially ventilated rooms for the lacquering procedure, and all the workers used personal respiratory protective equipment. The sprayers did not report more acute symptoms than a control group of office workers employed in the same companies.