The costs of radiosurgical treatment: comparison between gamma knife and linear accelerator

Radiosurgical treatment can be carried out by means of a Gamma Knife or a Linear Accelerator. The Linear Accelerator may be either a single-purpose appliance, exclusively employed in radiosurgery, or an adapted appliance, which is used primarily for fractioned radiotherapy, and only additionally for radiosurgical purposes. The first alternative will be referred to briefly as a "dedicated Linac", the latter as an "adapted Linac". Cost accounting data for these alternatives will be discussed under three main categories: investment costs, operating costs, and finally staffing costs. Costs are only considered to the extent that this is necessary to facilitate a comprehensive cost comparison. Factors for which the costs remain the same or at least broadly the same will from the outset not be taken into consideration. These include, for instance, the costs of general or special administration, diagnosis, and image processing. The results and conclusions of this study therefore cannot be employed immediately in the evaluation of cost reimbursement schemes of the type carried out by agencies responsible for social insurance. Here, appropriate complete cost analyses especially for this purpose are required. The final comprehensive cost comparison reveals that the adapted Linac is the most favourable alternative with small annual quantities of patients. With larger numbers of patients the Gamma Knife represents the most favourable from a cost accounting angle. The dedicated Linac accordingly does not have a cost advantage for any of the examined numbers of patients. Clearly the lowest treatment costs per patient can be achieved by employing a Gamma Knife and using it to capacity.

[The photon therapy of subfoveal choroidal neovascularization in age-dependent macular degeneration. The results of a prospective study in 40 patients]

AIM

To determine the effect of external beam radiotherapy on subfoveal choroidal neovascularization in age-related macular degeneration.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between September 1995 and July 1996, 40 patients (9 males and 31 females; mean age 74 years, range 61 to 83 years) were included in a prospective study. Eight patients had classic, well-defined neovascularisations, 32 patients had occult lesions. Complete ophthalmic investigations included visual acuity contrast sensitivity as well as fluorescein and indocyanine green angiographic examinations prior to treatment and 1, 3, 6, and 12 months after radiotherapy. External beam radiotherapy (8-MV photons) was delivered with a total dose of 14.4 Gy in 8 fractions of 1.8 Gy per day (Figures 1 and 2). The field size averaged 5.5 x 4.5 cm.

RESULTS

No treatment related morbidity during or after treatment was obtained. After 6 months follow-up the visual acuity was improved in 2 (5%) patients and maintained at pretreatment level in 17 (42%) patients. However, 12 months post treatment a stable situation was found in 6 (15%) patients and a decrease in visual acuity in 34 (85%) patients (Table 1). The central visual fields deteriorated significantly from 16.5 decibel (dB) to 12.4 dB. The enlargement of exudates and neovascular membranes increased 5- to 7-fold. At 12 months after treatment, 3 (7.5%) patients stated that they had improved vision subjectively, 12 (30%) patients had no change and 25 (62.5%) patients suffered from subjective decrease in visual acuity.

CONCLUSIONS

Using a total dose of 14.4 Gy/1.8 Gy no difference concerning visual acuity and exudative changes in comparison to the natural history on age-related macular degeneration was obtained after 12 months. However, the results of multicenter studies are to be awaited.

Prognostic factors in patients with carcinoma of the uterine cervix treated with external beam irradiation and IR-192 high-dose-rate brachytherapy

PURPOSE

Prognostic factors in cancer of the cervix for patients treated with external beam irradiation (EBR) and low-dose-rate (LDR) brachytherapy have been characterized. However, despite the increasing use of high-dose-rate (HDR) intracavitary placements (ICP), few studies with adequate follow-up have analyzed prognostic factors. This study investigates pretreatment and treatment factors for their correlation with treatment outcome after EBR and HDR-ICP.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between September 1985 and December 1994, 181 patients with carcinoma of the cervix FIGO stages IB-IV received EBR and HDR brachytherapy. Hemoglobin (Hb) levels were maintained above a level of 11 g/dl during the treatment by transfusion. Patient age ranged from 34 to 84 years (median: 66). The median follow-up time for patients at risk is 69 months (range: 23-140). Pretreatment and treatment parameters analyzed to determine their prognostic value included age, FIGO stage, tumor size, tumor type and grade, pretreatment Hb level, number of HDR-ICP, total dose from HDR-ICP, overall dose to point A, and overall treatment time. Also evaluated was the prognostic value of enlarged lymph nodes noted on pretreatment CAT scan of the abdomen and pelvis. Endpoints studied in uni- and multivariate analyses were disease-specific survival (DSS), freedom from disease (FFD), pelvic control (PC), and probability of distant metastases (DM).

RESULTS

At 5 years the DSS, FFD, and PC rates for all patients were 60%, 58%, and 67%, respectively. The 5-year FFD by stage was: IB: 94%; II: 63%; IIIB: 43%; and IV: 0%. The PC rates were 94%, 66%, 59%, and 0%, respectively. In univariate analysis the prognostic factors identified for FFD were FIGO stage, tumor size, initial Hb level, and enlarged pelvic and/or paraaortic nodes (all: p < 0.0001). Age was inversely correlated with outcome (p = 0.0081). The 5-year FFD rates for tumors (< 3, > or = 3 < 6, > or = 6 cm) were 97%, 65%, and 24%; patients with initial Hb levels < or = 11g/dl had a FFD of 26% versus 69% for patients with levels > 11g/dl; and those with pelvic and/or paraaortal nodes > or = 1 cm had a survival of 32% versus 68% in patients with negative readings. The same factors were also prognostically significant for DSS, PC, and DM. Patients with persistent disease or pelvic failures had a significantly higher incidence of DM than patients in whom pelvic disease was controlled (p < 0.0001).Histological and treatment parameters including overall treatment time were not of prognostic significance for any of the endpoints studied. In multivariate analysis tumor size was the most powerful parameter for DSS, FFD, PC (p < 0.0001) and DM (p = 0.0001), followed by low initial Hb level (DSS: p = 0.0004, FFD: p = 0.0009, PC: p = 0.0012, DM: p = 0.0265), and enlarged pelvic and/or paraaortic nodes which were predictive for DSS (p = 0.0210) and DM (p = 0.0011).

CONCLUSION

This study confirms that prognostic factors for patients treated with HDR brachytherapy are similar to those reported in previous series that employed LDR brachytherapy. The significance of tumor size, pretreatment Hb level, and enlarged pelvic and/or paraaortic lymph nodes on CAT scan over FIGO stage of disease were demonstrated. Future prospective trials should be undertaken to confirm the validity of these factors and to elucidate their therapeutic implications.

Postoperative radiotherapy in radically resected non-small cell lung cancer

PURPOSE

To evaluate the value of adjuvant postoperative external-beam radiation (EBR) in patients with radically resected non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) pT1-3 pN0-2 compared to patients with resected NSCLC without adjuvant EBR.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In 155 patients (121 male, 34 female; mean age, 59 years) 105 lobectomies, 12 bilobectomies, and 38 pneumonectomies with radical lymph node dissection of the contralateral [corrected] side were performed. Postoperative staging was done according to the TNM system and was as follows: pT1 (n=38), pT2 (n=89), pT3 (n=28); pN0 (n=39), pN1 (n=67) and pN2 (n=49). Histopathologic study revealed 68 squamous cell carcinomas, 53 adenocarcinomas, 21 large cell carcinomas, 6 adenosquamous cell carcinomas, and 7 bronchioloalveolar cell carcinomas. All patients were randomly assigned into two treatment groups: 72 patients with no further treatment (control group), and 83 patients (EBR group) with adjuvant postoperative EBR of the bronchial stump and mediastinum (50 to 56 Gy, 8 or 23 MV photons, 2 Gy/d, 5 d/wk) beginning 4 to 6 weeks after surgery.

RESULTS

The overall 5-year survival rate (median observation time, 43 months) of all patients was 24.1% (EBR group, 29.7%; control group, 20.4%; p>0.05, not significant). The relative risk of the EBR group was 0.85 with a two-sided confidence interval of 0.66 to 1.09. The overall 5-year recurrence-free survival was 20.6% (EBR, 27.1%; control group, 15.6%; p=0.07). The relative risk of the EBR group was 0.80 with a confidence interval of 0.63 to 1.01. The rate of local recurrences at the bronchial stump and/or mediastinum was significantly smaller in the EBR group (n=5) than in the control group (n=17) (p<0.01). Multivariate analysis (chi2 test) demonstrated an independent influence of postoperative EBR on the incidence of local recurrences. The incidence of distant metastases was slightly but not significantly higher in patients without EBR (38 patients) compared to those who had EBR (32 patients).

CONCLUSION

High-dose postoperative EBR to the mediastinum significantly reduces the risk of local recurrence at the bronchial stump and/or mediastinum. Age, sex, histologic subtype, tumor size, surgical approach, or extent of lymph node involvement had no prognostic value--only postoperative EBR had an independent influence on the risk of local recurrence. The effect of postoperative EBR was on the verge of significance with respect to recurrence-free survival and showed the same tendency in overall survival, however with an attenuated relative risk.

Endocavitary Ir-192 radiation and laser treatment for palliation of obstructive rectal cancer

Endoscopic laser therapy (ELT) either alone or combined with endocavitary Ir-192 radiation is performed for advanced, inoperable rectal cancer and when patients are ineligible for surgery due to severe concomitant medical illness. During the period from January 1984 to January 1997 we treated 81 patients (51 males, 30 females). Sixty-seven patients had ELT only using a ND-Yag Laser system. Twenty-five patients (average age: 80.5 years) were ineligible for surgery (Group I). Forty-two patients (74.1 years) had an advanced locally inoperable tumour (Group II). Fourteen patients (76.5 years) underwent a combined therapeutic regime with endocavitary Ir-192 afterloading following ELT (Group III). Adequate desobliteration was achieved in 100% (groups I and III) and 97% (group II) of the patients. The average interval to aftertreatment was 8.4 weeks in group I and 9.4 weeks in group II, compared to 11.5 weeks in group III. Serious complications (perianal abscess, rectovaginal fistula) occurred in 3.7%, minor complications (laser-induced bleedings, unclear fever) in 12.3%. All laser-induced bleedings could be dealt with using laser therapy. The frequency of treatment was governed by tumour mass and the patient's survival. The results suggest that additional endocavitary radiation significantly prolongs the maintenance of normal bowel function compared with laser therapy alone.

Carcinoma of the cervix: analysis of complications after primary external beam radiation and Ir-192 HDR brachytherapy

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

There is still a concern that the use of HDR brachytherapy might result in an increase of late tissue damage. This restrospective study evaluates the incidence and severity of late complications in patients with carcinoma of the cervix who underwent combined external beam radiation (EBR) and Ir-192 HDR brachytherapy and attempts to identify pretreatment and treatment parameters correlating with late complications.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Between 1985 and 1992, 161 patients with carcinoma of the cervix (FIGO stages IB-IVB) received EBR to the pelvis (ave, max. dose 48.8 Gy) followed by 1-6 Ir-192 HDR placements (median 2). Doses to point A ranged from 8.5 to 38.7 Gy (median 17 Gy). Parameters examined included age, diabetes, obesity, history of inflammatory bowel disease or diverticulitis, prior surgery, hemoglobin level, FIGO stage, EBR dose, technique and daily dose fraction, number of HDR treatments and total dose to point A, maximum doses to bladder and rectum delivered by brachytherapy and cumulative dose to point A. Median follow-up for all patients was 37 months. Complications were rated using an in-house scoring system and according to the French-Italian Glossary (FIG).

RESULTS

Actuarial 5-year survival was 93%, 57%, 46%, and 0% for stages IB, II, IIIB, and IV, respectively. Of 161 patients, 11% developed moderate and 3.7% severe sequelae (FIG: 2.5%, 3.7%). Since some patients experienced more than one complication, the overall incidence was 13.6% and 4.9% (FIG: 3.1%, 4.9%) with respective 5-year actuarial rates of 14% and 5% for moderate, and 2% and 8% for severe bowel and genitourinary tract complications (FIG: 3.5%, 0, and 2%, 8%). All severe bowel complications occurred within 1.5 years whereas urinary tract sequelae continued to develop throughout the follow-up period. FIGO stage was associated with a significant increase in late sequelae (P = 0.015). Analysis of the remaining pretreatment and treatment parameters failed to reveal any statistically significant correlation with moderate or severe sequelae.

CONCLUSION

In our series using HDR brachytherapy, complication and survival rates were comparable with other series employing either LDR or HDR procedures. Of all parameters analysed, stage of disease was the only parameter significantly correlated with complications in univariate and multivariate analysis.

"Adjuvant" external radiation of the mediastinum in radically resected non-small cell lung cancer

OBJECTIVE

The effect of postoperative external beam radiation in MO non-small cell lung cancer resected with curative intention was evaluated in a randomized trial.

METHODS

In 155 patients (121 males, 34 females; mean age: 59 years) 105 lobectomies, 12 bilobectomies and 38 pneumonectomies with radical lymph node dissection to the contralateral side were carried out. Histology revealed squamous cell (n = 68), adeno- (n = 53), large cell (n = 21), adenosquamous (n = 6) or bronchioloalveolar type (n = 7) carcinomas. The pathologic stages T1 (n = 38), T2 (n = 89), T3 (n = 28); NO (n = 39), N1 (n = 67), and N2 (n = 49) were evenly distributed between the two treatment groups: group A (72 patients) had no further oncologic treatment, while group B (83 patients) had external beam radiation to the mediastinum (50-56 Gy, 8 or 23 MeV photons, 2 Gy/day, 5 days a week) beginning 4 weeks after the operation.

RESULTS

The overall 5-year survival rate of the whole collective was 24.1% without any significant difference between the radiotherapy group B (29.7%) and the control group A (20.4%) (log-rank test: P > 0.05). The overall 5-year recurrence-free survival rate was 20.1%, with no difference between groups B and A (radiotherapy: 22.7, controls: 15.6%, long-rank test: P > 0.05). There was no difference in the incidence of distant metastases (external beam radiation: n = 32; controls: n = 38). The rate of local recurrences at the bronchial stump or in the mediastinum, however, was significantly reduced in the radiotherapy group (n = 5) compared with 17 in the controls (P < 0.01 chi-square test). A multivariate analysis confirmed the independent influence of postoperative radiotherapy on the incidence of local recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

External radiation of the mediastinum in radically resected non-small cell lung cancer reduces the risk of local recurrence, but has no influence on distant metastastic spread and overall survival.

Ammonia production from hippurate by the rat kidney in vitro

Hippurate is known to be synthesized from benzoate and glycine in the liver and kidney. It takes part in renal ammoniagenesis by modulating the activity of gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase (gamma GT). Due to its chemical structure, however, hippurate might also serve as a substrate of renal ammoniagenesis. Hippurate may yield ammonia either having been cleaved by hippuricase or by Erlenmeyer's reaction after condensation with an aldehyde. In order to elucidate the possibility of hippurate being a substrate of renal ammoniagenesis, experiments were carried out on cortical kidney slices and on isolated tubular segments of the rat. The incubation medium (pH 7.1) was enriched with 10 mmol/l hippurate spiked with 15N-hippurate, some of the known competitive inhibitors of hippuricase, acivicin and different aldehydes. Factors known to affect hippuricase or gamma GT did not interfere with renal ammonia production. Glyceraldehyde (up to 1.0 mmol/l) but not glycerate had a stimulating effect, especially on the ammoniagenesis from hippurate. In normal rats fed a vegetarian diet, 1% of the added 15N moiety was found to be 15NH3. Renal 15NH3 production was significantly greater if, prior to the experiments, the animals were either acidotic or had a reduced renal mass or were fed animal proteins. These results indicate that hippurate may, to a certain extent, serve as substrate for ammoniagenesis.

Evaluating intraoperative radiation therapy (IORT) and external beam radiation therapy (EBRT) in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Five years experience

A pilot study on intraoperative radiation therapy (IORT) combined with external beam radiation therapy (EBRT) in nonresectable non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) was performed in 31 patients (mean age: 66.2 years, range: 51-80; 10 anatomically and functionally, 21 functionally, nonresectable; 20 squamous-cell, 11 adenocarcinoma). The tumor was exposed by lateral thoracotomy and a staging lymph node dissection was performed (final staging 7 T1, 16 T2, 8 T3; 11 nodal positive). Ten to 20 Gy IORT (energy: 7-20 MeV electrons) were delivered to the tumor. Unilateral continuous positive airway pressure ventilation of the diseased lung was used to reduce the amount of healthy lung tissue in the IORT port and to minimize the ventilatory movement. Secondary collimation and direct shielding of radio-sensitive structures within the IORT port by aluminium sheets were used to further reduce collateral damage. Four weeks after IORT, 46 Gy EBRT (2 Gy/day 5 times a week; 8-23 MeV photons) were administered to the mediastinum and to the tumor-bearing area on an outpatient basis. In nodal positive cases the mediastinal dose was increased to 56 Gy. Twenty-three patients were evaluable. In 13 complete, in 8 partial (50-97% regression) and in 2 minor response has been achieved. Five patients experienced a recurrence (local only: 2; local and distant: 1; distant only: 2). Twelve patients died of underlying cardio-respiratory disorders within 6 to 25 months after IORT; 7 died of cancer. The overall 5-year survival rate including the incidental deaths is 14.7%. The recurrence-free survival rate is 53.2%.

Iridium-192 high dose rate brachytherapy combined with external beam irradiation in non-resectable oesophageal cancer

Forty-eight patients with non-resectable cancer of the oesophagus and oesophagogastric junction (group A: Stage I/II: n = 32; group B: Stage III/IV: n = 16) underwent intralumenal iridium-192 high dose-rate afterloading brachytherapy (5-7 Gy/session, total dose 5-21 Gy, mean 12.4 Gy) and external beam irradiation (Karnofsky > or = 80%: 50-60 Gy/2 Gy per day; Karnofsky 60%-79%: 30 Gy/3 per day). Prolonged satisfactory palliation (intake of at least semi-solid food) was demonstrated in 96% of patients. The mean survival for group A was 19.1 months and that for group B 6.9 months, with a 12-month survival rate of 66% for group A and 0% for group B (P < 0.001). Local tumour response and complication rate were significantly dose related with a predicted response rate of 70.5% and a complication rate of 50% at extrapolated response dose (ERD) 129.3 GY3 (Gy at alpha/beta = 3).