Sensory attributes of coated tablets: Developing a formal lexicon and sensory wheel

The patient's sensory experience when taking an oral medicine is important in the assessment of its palatability, and acceptability. The aim of this study was to develop tools useful for standardisation of sensory assessment of coated tablets: a lexicon and a sensory wheel. Two randomised, double-blind sensory assessments were performed involving 83 and 52 heathy adult volunteers and two sets of coated tablets. By adapting the principles used by food sciences, a free-text description of conventional, bitter-tasting or tasteless, coated tablets was performed. In the first assessment, volunteers described the sensory attributes of the first set of tablets. The attributes collected were then validated using a second set of tablets in a separate study with different volunteers. The appropriateness and semantics of each sensory attribute was analysed. Twenty attributes most relevant for assessment of coated tablets were selected for the lexicon and associated with explicit definitions. A collection of all attributes that could possibly be triggered by coated tablets were organised in the form of a sensory wheel. This study provides a valuable insight into the sensory experience while taking a coated tablet and presents tools which can accelerate the development of palatable medicines.

Pericoronary adipose tissue density is associated with clinical disease activity in Takayasu arteritis and coronary arterial inflammation measured by 68Ga-DOTATATE PET in atherosclerosis

Background

Coronary artery disease (CAD) is an under-recognized complication of intense arterial inflammation in Takayasu arteritis (TAK). While pericoronary adipose tissue (PCAT) density is associated with arterial inflammation in CAD patients, this relationship has not previously been studied in TAK patients, nor directly compared with coronary arterial inflammation measured by 68Ga-DOTATATE positron emission tomography (PET).

Purpose

To compare PCAT density with clinical, biochemical and molecular imaging markers of inflammation in TAK and CAD patients.

Methods

PCAT density was quantified from computed tomography coronary angiography (CTCA) around each of the 17 coronary segments in patients with: (1) TAK and CAD, (2) atherosclerotic CAD, and (3) age and gender-matched healthy controls, using semi-automated software (Autoplaque). In TAK patients, PCAT density was compared to the Indian Takayasu Clinical Activity Score (ITAS) and high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (CRP). In CAD patients, PCAT density was compared to local arterial inflammation measured by coronary motion-frozen 68Ga-DOTATATE PET using image registration software (FusionQuant), and systemic (aortic) inflammation using 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) PET. Data was acquired either during routine clinical care or prior research that established 68Ga-DOTATATE as an experimental marker of arterial inflammation that binds macrophage somatostatin receptor-2 in atherosclerotic plaques (NCT02021188).

Results

60 patients were included (TAK, n=20; CAD, n=20; healthy, n=20). Non-calcified plaque burden (TAK: 95.2%; CAD: 90.4%, p<0.0001) and CRP (TAK: 25.2 ±SD 16.1 mg/L; CAD: 2.5 ±SD 1.7 mg/L, p=0.04) were greater in TAK than CAD patients.

PCAT density varied significantly among the three groups (median [IQR] TAK: −72.9 [−81.2 to -66.1] Hounsfield unit [HU]; CAD: −79.9 [−88.0 to −72.2]; healthy: −83.8 [−90.1 to −75.8] HU, p<0.0001). Figure: box-plot showing the distribution of PCAT values by group, with corresponding representative multiplanar reconstructed and cross-sectional CTCA images with surrounding PCAT density displayed by color table in left anterior descending arteries.

PCAT density was significantly associated with ITAS (r=0.61, p=0.004) and CRP (r=0.43, p=0.03) in TAK patients, and coronary 68Ga-DOTATATE maximum tissue-to-blood ratio (r=0.31, p<0.001) in CAD patients. PCAT density was not associated with aortic 18F-FDG uptake in CAD patients, nor subcutaneous (pre-sternal) adipose tissue density in either disease group. No significant patient-level confounders were identified using linear mixed-effects regression modelling.

Conclusion

PCAT density measured by CTCA is greater in TAK than CAD patients, and is associated with clinical and biochemical markers of disease activity in TAK, and coronary arterial inflammation measured by 68Ga-DOTATATE PET in CAD. PCAT could be a useful, easy to measure marker of coronary inflammation and disease activity in both TAK and CAD.

PCAT density is greater in TAK than CAD

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding source: Foundation. Main funding source(s): Wellcome Trust

The feasibility of a randomised control trial to assess physiotherapy against surgery for recurrent patellar instability

Background

Patellar instability is a relatively common condition that leads to disability and restriction of activities. People with recurrent instability may be given the option of physiotherapy or surgery though this is largely driven by clinician preference rather than by a strong evidence base. We sought to determine the feasibility of conducting a definitive trial comparing physiotherapy with surgical treatment for people with recurrent patellar instability.

Methods

This was a pragmatic, open-label, two-arm feasibility randomised control trial (RCT) with an embedded interview component recruiting across three NHS sites comparing surgical treatment to a package of best conservative care; ‘Personalised Knee Therapy’ (PKT). The primary feasibility outcome was the recruitment rate per centre (expected rate 1 to 1.5 participants recruited each month). Secondary outcomes included the rate of follow-up (over 80% expected at 12 months) and a series of participant-reported outcomes taken at 3, 6 and 12 months following randomisation, including the Norwich Patellar Instability Score (NPIS), the Kujala Patellofemoral Disorder Score (KPDS), EuroQol-5D-5L, self-reported global assessment of change, satisfaction at each time point and resources use.

Results

We recruited 19 participants. Of these, 18 participants (95%) were followed-up at 12 months and 1 (5%) withdrew. One centre recruited at just over one case per month, one centre was unable to recruit, and one centre recruited at over one case per month after a change in participant screening approach. Ten participants were allocated into the PKT arm, with nine to the surgical arm. Mean Norwich Patellar Instability Score improved from 40.6 (standard deviation 22.1) to 28.2 (SD 25.4) from baseline to 12 months.

Conclusion

This feasibility trial identified a number of challenges and required a series of changes to ensure adequate recruitment and follow-up. These changes helped achieve a sufficient recruitment and follow-up rate. The revised trial design is feasible to be conducted as a definitive trial to answer this important clinical question for people with chronic patellar instability.

Trial registration

The trial was prospectively registered on the International Standard Randomised Controlled Trial Number registry on the 22/12/2016 (reference number: ISRCTN14950321). http://www.isrctn.com/ISRCTN14950321

De Novo SOX6 Variants Cause a Neurodevelopmental Syndrome Associated with ADHD, Craniosynostosis, and Osteochondromas

SOX6 belongs to a family of 20 SRY-related HMG-box-containing (SOX) genes that encode transcription factors controlling cell fate and differentiation in many developmental and adult processes. For SOX6, these processes include, but are not limited to, neurogenesis and skeletogenesis. Variants in half of the SOX genes have been shown to cause severe developmental and adult syndromes, referred to as SOXopathies. We here provide evidence that SOX6 variants also cause a SOXopathy. Using clinical and genetic data, we identify 19 individuals harboring various types of SOX6 alterations and exhibiting developmental delay and/or intellectual disability; the individuals are from 17 unrelated families. Additional, inconstant features include attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), autism, mild facial dysmorphism, craniosynostosis, and multiple osteochondromas. All variants are heterozygous. Fourteen are de novo, one is inherited from a mosaic father, and four offspring from two families have a paternally inherited variant. Intragenic microdeletions, balanced structural rearrangements, frameshifts, and nonsense variants are predicted to inactivate the SOX6 variant allele. Four missense variants occur in residues and protein regions highly conserved evolutionarily. These variants are not detected in the gnomAD control cohort, and the amino acid substitutions are predicted to be damaging. Two of these variants are located in the HMG domain and abolish SOX6 transcriptional activity in vitro. No clear genotype-phenotype correlations are found. Taken together, these findings concur that SOX6 haploinsufficiency leads to a neurodevelopmental SOXopathy that often includes ADHD and abnormal skeletal and other features.

AB1023 CARDIAC MRI IN HYPERFERRITINAEMIC DISEASE STATES REVEALS MYOCARDIAL INFLAMMATION NOT IDENTIFIED BY ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY

Background:

Acutely unwell adult patients with hyperinflammatory hyperferritinaemic states are typically challenging to diagnose. Case series suggest that cardiac involvement may be common (up to 20%) but the phenotype has not been well characterised1.

The elevation of cardiac biomarkers suggests cardiac involvement, but are non-specific in acute illness. Cardiac MRI (CMR) offers the ability to characterise the myocardium and identify inflammation, and modern motion-corrected sequences now allow the assessment of patients who may struggle to breath-hold in the recovery from acute illness.

Objectives:

We report 3 patients who underwent CMR in the acute phase of illness with raised cardiac biomarkers.

Methods:

Case records of acutely ill patients with hyperferritinaemia from two major London centres were reviewed and cases who had undergone CMR in the acute phase of illness were identified.

Results:

3 cases were identified from a cohort of 22, we report CMR findings from differing aetiologies of hyperferritinaemic states:

Case 1: A female in her 60s presented acutely unwell with fever, swollen joints and salmon pink rash. Ferritin was raised at 50574ug/L (20-300ug/L), troponin I 384ng/L (<34ng/L) and Brain Natriuretic Peptide (BNP) 324ng/L (<159ng/L). Echocardiography was normal. However CMR with T2 mapping revealed several small areas of raised signal consistent with myocardial inflammation. A diagnosis of systemic Adult Onset Stills Disease (AOSD) was made. She received IV methylprednisolone and anakinra with normalisation of cardiac biomarkers.

Case 2: A male in his 20s with known SLE with associated end stage renal failure requiring transplant. He had a previous prolonged admission secondary to HLH. He presented with chest pain and concave shaped ST elevation on ECG. Troponin peak 2168ng/L, BNP 1334ng/L. Peak ferritin 1300ug/l.

He was initiated on colchicine for likely pericarditis. Echocardiography showed a dilated left ventricle and mildly increased wall thickness, but overall systolic function within normal limits.

CMR reported nodular patchy late gadolinium enhancement in the mid inferoseptum and inferior wall associated with areas of raised T2 mapping values. NM cardiac rest gated PET reported abnormal FDG uptake to the myocardium with sites including the apical inferior wall, apical RV insertion point and basal septal/anterior right ventricular walls. Features were deemed in keeping with active myocarditis.

He responded to colchicine with improved troponin, and was discharged with close follow up.

Case 3: A male in his 20s presented with septic shock attributed to meningococcal septicaemia requiring ITU admission. Troponin was elevated at >9000ng/L. Bloods demonstrated raised ferritin and features consistent with HLH were identified.

CMR reported elevated native myocardial T1/T2 signal of the lateral and mid-anterior walls in keeping with myocardial oedema. Pericardium adjacent to the anterolateral wall had elevated T1/T2 signal with hyperenhancement on delayed enhancement imaging. Tissue characterisation was in keeping with an acute myopericarditis process.

In addition to broad spectrum antibiotics to treat his underlying infection, he received therapy for HLH including methylprednisolone, anakinra and IVIG. He subsequently made a good recovery to treatment.

Conclusion:

CMR in acute illness with hyperferritinaemia reveals abnormal tissue characterisation with myocardial inflammation, even when echocardiography is normal. We suggest CMR may be a useful test to expand our understanding of hyperferritinaemic disease states.

References:

[1]M Gerfaud-Valentin et al. Myocarditis in Adult-Onset Still Disease. Medicine (Baltimore) 2014 Oct; 93(17): 280-289

Disclosure of Interests:

None declared

The complex genetic landscape of familial MDS and AML reveals pathogenic germline variants

The inclusion of familial myeloid malignancies as a separate disease entity in the revised WHO classification has renewed efforts to improve the recognition and management of this group of at risk individuals. Here we report a cohort of 86 acute myeloid leukemia (AML) and myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS) families with 49 harboring germline variants in 16 previously defined loci (57%). Whole exome sequencing in a further 37 uncharacterized families (43%) allowed us to rationalize 65 new candidate loci, including genes mutated in rare hematological syndromes (ADA, GP6, IL17RA, PRF1 and SEC23B), reported in prior MDS/AML or inherited bone marrow failure series (DNAH9, NAPRT1 and SH2B3) or variants at novel loci (DHX34) that appear specific to inherited forms of myeloid malignancies. Altogether, our series of MDS/AML families offer novel insights into the etiology of myeloid malignancies and provide a framework to prioritize variants for inclusion into routine diagnostics and patient management.

Clinical whole-genome sequencing from routine formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded specimens: pilot study for the 100,000 Genomes Project

PURPOSE

Fresh-frozen (FF) tissue is the optimal source of DNA for whole-genome sequencing (WGS) of cancer patients. However, it is not always available, limiting the widespread application of WGS in clinical practice. We explored the viability of using formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissues, available routinely for cancer patients, as a source of DNA for clinical WGS.

METHODS

We conducted a prospective study using DNAs from matched FF, FFPE, and peripheral blood germ-line specimens collected from 52 cancer patients (156 samples) following routine diagnostic protocols. We compared somatic variants detected in FFPE and matching FF samples.

RESULTS

We found the single-nucleotide variant agreement reached 71% across the genome and somatic copy-number alterations (CNAs) detection from FFPE samples was suboptimal (0.44 median correlation with FF) due to nonuniform coverage. CNA detection was improved significantly with lower reverse crosslinking temperature in FFPE DNA extraction (80 °C or 65 °C depending on the methods). Our final data showed somatic variant detection from FFPE for clinical decision making is possible. We detected 98% of clinically actionable variants (including 30/31 CNAs).

CONCLUSION

We present the first prospective WGS study of cancer patients using FFPE specimens collected in a routine clinical environment proving WGS can be applied in the clinic.

Consensus on BCR-ABL1 reporting in chronic myeloid leukaemia in the UK

For patients with chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML), treatment guidelines recommend monitoring response to treatment with tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) by testing the BCR‐ABL1 fusion gene transcript level using reverse transcriptase quantitative polymerase chain reaction. Despite recent efforts to standardise protocols for BCR‐ABL1 testing, some variability remains among laboratories in the UK regarding the techniques used and the approach to reporting results. This increases the risk of misinterpretation of results by both clinicians and patients. An expert panel met to discuss current issues surrounding BCR‐ABL1 testing in the UK and to develop guidance for laboratories, with emphasis on the optimal approach to reporting laboratory results. Topics included the minimum required information to include in the laboratory report, units of measurement, test sensitivity and BCR‐ABL1 transcript variants. To aid communication between laboratories and clinics, standard forms were generated that could be used by (i) clinics when submitting samples to laboratories, and (ii) laboratories when reporting results to clinics. Standardising the way in which BCR‐ABL1 test results are reported from laboratories to clinics should help to improve communication, interpretation of results and patient care.

Surgery for constipation: systematic review and practice recommendations: Results II: Hitching procedures for the rectum (rectal suspension)

AIM

To assess the outcomes of rectal suspension procedures (forms of rectopexy) in adults with chronic constipation.

METHOD

Standardised methods and reporting of benefits and harms were used for all CapaCiTY reviews that closely adhered to PRISMA 2016 guidance. Main conclusions were presented as summary evidence statements with a summative Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine (2009) level.

RESULTS

Eighteen articles were identified, providing data on outcomes in 1238 patients. All studies reported only on laparoscopic approaches. Length of procedures ranged between 1.5 to 3.5 h, and length of stay between 4 to 5 days. Data on harms were inconsistently reported and heterogeneous, making estimates of harm tentative and imprecise. Morbidity rates ranged between 5-15%, with mesh complications accounting for 0.5% of patients overall. No mortality was reported after any procedures in a total of 1044 patients. Although inconsistently reported, good or satisfactory outcome occurred in 83% (74-91%) of patients; 86% (20-97%) of patients reported improvements in constipation after laparoscopic ventral mesh rectopexy (LVMR). About 2-7% of patients developed anatomical recurrence. Patient selection was inconsistently documented. As most common indication, high grade rectal intussusception was corrected in 80-100% of cases after robotic or LVMR. Healing of prolapse-associated solitary rectal ulcer syndrome occurred in around 80% of patients after LVMR.

CONCLUSION

Evidence supporting rectal suspension procedures is currently derived from poor quality studies. Methodologically robust trials are needed to inform future clinical decision making.

Surgery for constipation: systematic review and practice recommendations: Results III: Rectal wall excisional procedures (Rectal Excision)

AIM

To assess the outcomes of rectal excisional procedures in adults with chronic constipation.

METHOD

Standardised methods and reporting of benefits and harms were used for all CapaCiTY reviews that closely adhered to PRISMA 2016 guidance. Main conclusions were presented as summary evidence statements with a summative Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine (2009) level.

RESULTS

Forty-seven studies were identified, providing data on outcomes in 8340 patients. Average length of procedures was 44 min and length of stay (LOS) was 3 days. There was inadequate evidence to determine variations in procedural duration or LOS by type of procedure. Overall morbidity rate was 16.9% (0-61%), with lower rates observed after Contour Transtar procedure (8.9%). No mortality was reported after any procedures in a total of 5896 patients. Although inconsistently reported, good or satisfactory outcome occurred in 73-80% of patients; a reduction of 53-91% in Longo scoring system for obstructive defecation syndrome (ODS) occurred in about 68-76% of patients. The most common long-term adverse outcome is faecal urgency, typically occurring in up to 10% of patients. Recurrent prolapse occurred in 4.3% of patients. Patients with at least 3 ODS symptoms together with a rectocoele with or without an intussusception, who have failed conservative management, may benefit from a rectal excisional procedure.

CONCLUSION

Rectal excisional procedures are safe with little major morbidity. It is not possible to advise which excisional technique is superior from the point of view of efficacy, peri-operative variables, or harms. Future study is required.

Surgery for constipation: systematic review and clinical guidance: Paper 1: Introduction & Methods

AIM

This manuscript provides the introduction and detailed methodology used in subsequent reviews to assess the outcomes of surgical interventions with the primary intent of treating chronic constipation in adults and to develop recommendations for practice.

METHOD

PRISMA guidance was adhered to throughout. A literature search was performed in public databases between January 1960 and February 2016. Studies that fulfilled strictly-defined PICOS (patients, interventions, controls, outcome, and study design) criteria were included. The process involved two groups of participants: (i): 'a clinical guidance group' of 18 UK experts (including junior support) who performed the systematic reviews and produced summary evidence statements (SES) based strictly on data synthesis in each review. The same group then produced prototype graded practice recommendations (GPRs) based on coalescence of SES and expert opinion; (ii): a European Consensus group of 18 ESCP (European Society of Coloproctology) nominated experts from nine European countries evaluated the appropriateness of each prototype GPR based on published RAND/UCLA methodology.

RESULTS

An overview of the search results is provided in this manuscript. A total of 156 studies from 307 full text articles (from 2551 initially screened records) were included, providing data on procedures characterized by: (i) colonic resection (n = 40); (ii) rectal suspension (n = 18); (iii) rectal wall excision (n = 44); (iv) rectovaginal septum reinforcement (n = 47); (v) sacral nerve stimulation (n = 7). The overall quality of evidence was poor with 113/156 (72.4%) studies providing only Oxford level IV evidence. The best evidence was extracted for rectal excisional procedures, where the majority of studies were Oxford level I or II. The five subsequent reviews provide a total of 99 SES (reflecting perioperative variables, efficacy, harms and prognostic variables) that contributed to 100 prototype GPRs covering patient selection, procedural considerations and patient counselling. The final manuscript details the 85/100 GPRs that were deemed appropriate by European Consensus (remaining 15 were all uncertain) and future research recommendations.

CONCLUSION

This manuscript and the following 6 papers suggest that the evidence base for surgical management of chronic constipation is currently poor although some expert consensus exists on best practice. Further studies are required to inform future commissioning of treatments and of research funding.

Surgery for constipation: systematic review and practice recommendations: Results I: Colonic resection

AIM

To assess the outcomes of colectomy in adults with chronic constipation (CC).

METHOD

Standardised methods and reporting of benefits and harms were used for all CapaCiTY reviews that closely adhered to PRISMA 2016 guidance. Main conclusions were presented as summary evidence statements (SES) with a summative Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine (2009) level.

RESULTS

Forty articles were identified, providing data on outcomes in 2045 patients. Evidence was derived almost exclusively from observational studies, the majority of which concerned colectomy and ileorectal anastomosis (CIRA) rather than other procedural variations. Average length of stay (LOS) ranged between 7-15 days. Although inconsistent, laparoscopic surgery may be associated with longer mean operating times (210 vs 167 min) and modest decreases in LOS (10-8 days). Complications occurred in approximately 24% of patients. Six (0.4%) procedure-related deaths were observed. Recurrent episodes of small bowel obstruction occurred in about 15% (95%CI: 10-21%) of patients in the long-term, with significant burden of re-hospitalisation and frequent recourse to surgery. Most patients reported a satisfactory or good outcome after colectomy but negative long-term functional outcomes persist in a minority of patients. The influence of resection extent, anastomotic configuration and method of access on complication rates remains uncertain. Available evidence weakly supports selection of patients with an isolated slow-transit phenotype.

CONCLUSION

Colectomy for CC may benefit some patients but at the cost of substantial short- and long-term morbidity. Current evidence is insufficient to guide patient or procedural selection.

Surgery for constipation: systematic review and practice recommendations: Results IV: Recto-vaginal reinforcement procedures

AIM

To assess the outcomes of recto-vaginal reinforcement procedures in adults with chronic constipation.

METHOD

Standardised methods and reporting of benefits and harms were used for all CapaCiTY reviews that closely adhered to PRISMA 2016 guidance. Main conclusions were presented as summary evidence statements with a summative Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine (2009) level.

RESULTS

Forty-three articles were identified, providing data on outcomes in 3346 patients. Average length of procedures ranged between 20 and 169 min, and length of stay between 1 and 15 days. Complications typically occurred after 7-17% of procedures (range 0-61%). Post-operative bleeding was uncommon (0-4%) as well as haematoma or sepsis (0-2%). Fistulation did not occur in most studies. Two procedure-related deaths were observed for 3209 patients. Although inconsistent, 78% of patients reported a satisfactory or good outcome, with 30-50% experiencing reduced symptoms of straining, incomplete emptying or reduced vaginal digitation. About 17% of patients developed anatomical recurrence. Considering measures of harm and global satisfaction rating scales, there was insufficient evidence to prefer one type of procedure over another. There was no evidence to support better outcomes based on selection of patients with a particular size or grade of rectocoele.

CONCLUSION

Evidence supporting recto-vaginal reinforcement procedures is currently derived from observational studies and comparisons, with only one high quality study. Large trials are needed to inform future clinical decision making.

Surgery for constipation: systematic review and practice recommendations: Graded practice and future research recommendations

AIM

This manuscript forms the final of seven that address the surgical management of chronic constipation (CC) in adults. The content coalesces results from the five systematic reviews that precede it and of the European Consensus process to derive graded practice recommendations (GPR).

METHODS

Summary of review data, development of GPR and future research recommendations as outlined in detail in the 'introduction and methods' paper.

RESULTS

The overall quality of data in the five reviews was poor with 113/156(72.4%) of included studies providing only level IV evidence and only four included level I RCTs. Coalescence of data from the five procedural classes revealed that few firm conclusions could be drawn regarding procedural choice or patient selection: no single procedure dominated in addressing dynamic structural abnormalities of the anorectum and pelvic floor with each having similar overall efficacy. Of one hundred 'prototype' GPRs developed by the clinical guideline group, 85/100 were deemed 'appropriate' based on the independent scoring of a panel of 18 European experts and use of RAND-UCLA consensus methodology. The remaining 15 were all deemed uncertain. Future research recommendations included some potential RCTs but also a strong emphasis on delivery of large multinational high-quality prospective cohort studies.

CONCLUSION

While the evidence base for surgery in CC is poor, the widespread European consensus for GPRs is encouraging. Professional bodies have the opportunity to build on this work by supporting the efforts of their membership to help convert the documented recommendations into clinical guidelines.

Surgery for constipation: systematic review and practice recommendations: Results V: Sacral Nerve Stimulation

AIM

To assess the outcomes of sacral nerve stimulation in adults with chronic constipation.

METHOD

Standardised methods and reporting of benefits and harms were used for all CapaCiTY reviews that closely adhered to PRISMA 2016 guidance. Main conclusions were presented as summary evidence statements with a summative Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine (2009) level.

RESULTS

Seven articles were identified, providing data on outcomes in 375 patients. Length of procedures and length of stay was not reported. Data on harms were inconsistently reported and heterogeneous, making estimates of harm tentative and imprecise. Morbidity rates ranged between 13 and 34%, with overall device removal rate between 8 and 23%. Although inconsistently reported, pooled treatment success was typically 57-87% for patients receiving permanent implants, although there was significant variation between studies. Patient selection was inconsistently documented. No conclusions could be drawn regarding particular phenotypes that responded favourably or unfavourably to sacral nerve stimulation.

CONCLUSION

Evidence supporting sacral nerve stimulation is derived from poor quality studies. Three methodologically robust trials are have reported since this review and all have all urged greater caution.