Early experience with the bioabsorbable anal fistula plug

Idiopathic fistula-in-ano

Fistula-in-ano is the most common form of perineal sepsis. Typically, a fistula includes an internal opening, a track, and an external opening. The external opening might acutely appear following infection and/or an abscess, or more insiduously in a chronic manner. Management includes control of infection, assessment of the fistulous track in relation to the anal sphincter muscle, and finally, definitive treatment of the fistula. Fistulotomy was the most commonly used mode of management, but concerns about post-fistulotomy incontinence prompted the use of sphincter preserving techniques such as advancement flaps, fibrin glue, collagen fistula plug, ligation of the intersphincteric fistula track, and stem cells. Many descriptive and comparative studies have evaluated these different techniques with variable outcomes. The lack of consistent results, level I evidence, or long-term follow-up, as well as the heterogeneity of fistula pathology has prevented a definitive treatment algorithm. This article will review the most commonly available modalities and techniques for managing idiopathic fistula-in-ano.

Developing minimally invasive surgery centers within kaiser permanente: the integrated multidisciplinary experience of los angeles

Minimally invasive surgical therapies are growing in type and volume of interventions. As one of the largest health delivery organizations in the US, Kaiser Permanente staff must be aware that the proliferation of these technologies has occurred in parallel within many surgical specialties, with a large variation in level of implementation between different regions and even within regions. In Los Angeles, we have developed the Minimally Invasive Surgery Center, encompassing a multidisciplinary, integrated approach. It unites the effort and expertise of many outstanding practitioners within the organization and consolidates the achievements of many surgical specialties. It also brings together the elements needed to provide the highest level of care to our patients in a safe, efficient, cost-effective environment, with minimal morbidity and best long-term outcome.

The anal fistula plug treatment compared with the mucosal advancement flap for cryptoglandular high transsphincteric perianal fistula: a double-blinded multicenter randomized trial

BACKGROUND

The anal fistula plug was developed as an alternative treatment for perianal fistulas.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to compare the anal fistula plug with the mucosal advancement flap for the treatment of high transsphincteric fistulas.

DESIGN

This study was a double-blinded, multicenter, randomized trial.

PATIENTS

Sixty patients with perianal fistulas were randomly assigned to receive an anal fistula plug or a mucosal advancement flap and were blinded for the type of treatment.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The outcome measures comprised the closure rate, postoperative pain, continence (colorectal functional outcome, Vaizey, and Wexner scores), and quality of life. Closure was determined by clinical examination by a surgeon blinded for the intervention.

RESULTS

At a follow-up of 11 months the recurrence rates were 71% (n = 22) in the anal fistula plug group and 52% (n = 15) in the mucosal advancement flap group, which was not significantly different. There were no significant differences in postoperative pain, in pre- and postoperative incontinence scores, soiling, and quality of life.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the anal fistula plug and advancement flap procedures are disappointing in the multicenter setting. There were no significant differences in recurrence, functional outcome, and quality of life between the plug and the advancement flap. Because the plug is simple to apply and minimally invasive, it can be considered as an initial treatment option for high transsphincteric fistulas.

Management of idiopathic anal fistula using cross-linked collagen: a prospective phase 1 study

AIM

Fibrin glue and porcine intestinal submucosa are used in novel sphincter-preserving techniques to heal anal fistulae. However, their success is highly variable and decreases with the length of follow up. The aim of this study was to assess the safety, feasibility and potential efficacy of another novel agent, cross-linked collagen, in two different physical formats, to heal anal fistulae.

METHOD

Prospectively recruited patients underwent symptom, continence and anal physiology assessments and magnetic resonance imaging. Patients with secondary tracts or acute sepsis were excluded. At operation, participants were randomized to receiving a solid collagen implant or collagen fibres suspended in fibrin glue. Follow up included repeat symptom, continence and physiological assessments at 3 months, and regular clinical review thereafter.

RESULTS

Twenty-nine of 43 entrants were eligible for inclusion. Thirteen patients received the collagen implant, and 16 collagen-fibrin glue. Three months postoperation, no patient experienced acute sepsis or continence disturbance, and sphincter function and integrity were unchanged. At 29 months, 12 of 15 (one lost to follow up) patients treated with collagen-fibrin glue were healed, compared with seven of 13 who received the implant.

CONCLUSION

In the short-to-medium term, both techniques are safe and equally effective. The results justify continued research into the use of biomaterials to heal anal fistulae.

Sphincter-preserving fistula management: what patients want

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to determine how patients with anal fistulas would rank clinical scenarios describing various management options for anal fistulas.

METHOD

A survey was administered to 74 consecutive patients with anal fistulas. On each survey, 10 clinical scenarios describing various treatment options for anal fistulas were scored from 1 (most likely to select) to 10 (least likely to select). Mean scores for each scenario were calculated and compared by use of a Student t test.

RESULTS

When combined, 74% of patients selected a sphincter-preserving technique as their primary choice compared with 26% who chose a fistulotomy (P < .0001). Compared with the highest ranking sphincter-preserving techniques, the mean scores of the scenarios involving a fistulotomy were significantly (P < .05) lower (less likely to select). The mean score of a traditional fistulotomy was the same as the mean score of a sphincter-preserving technique with a 50% success rate but no risk of diminished continence.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that the majority of patients with an anal fistula will select a sphincter-preserving technique to manage their fistula. This finding may indicate that, within limits, it is of greater importance for most patients to minimize their risk of diminished continence than to have a highly successful treatment strategy for their fistula.

The efficacy of anal fistula plug in fistula-in-ano: a systematic review

AIMS

To assess the efficacy of anal fistula plug (AFP) procedure for the treatment of fistula-in-ano especially the complex fistulas.

METHOD

The database of PUBMED, MEDLINE, SCOPUS, EMBASE and COCHRANE LIBRARY for the period 1995-2009 was searched. A systematic analysis was carried to evaluate the success rate of AFP procedure in fistula-in-ano.

RESULTS

A total of 25 studies were extracted and 12 (n = 317) were finally included in the systematic review. The follow-up period ranged from 3.5 to 12 months. The AFP procedure had a success rate (patient cure rate) ranging from 24% to 92%. In complex fistula-in-ano in prospective studies (8/12 studies), the success rate was 35-87%. The success rate in patients with Crohn's disease was 29-86%. The success rate in the patients with single tracts was 44-93% and in patients with multiple tracts, success ranged from 20% to 71%. The abscess formation/sepsis rate was 4-29% (11/108) and the plug extrusion rate was 4-41% (42/232-19%).

CONCLUSION

Anal fistula plug procedure has a success rate ranging from 24% to 92% in different studies. In prospective studies of complex fistula-in-ano, there was a moderate success rate of 35-87%. As AFP is associated with low morbidity and sepsis, it appears to be a safe procedure. Further randomized controlled trials studying objective parameters of fistula healing are needed to substantiate these findings.

Treatment of fistula-in-ano with the Surgisis(®) AFP(TM) anal fistula plug

OBJECTIVE

Closure of the fistula tract with an anal fistula plug has been reported to provide success rates as high as 80%. The purpose of this study was to evaluate our results with this new method.

METHOD

From June 2006 to September 2007, an anal fistula plug was used for the treatment of high transsphincteric fistulas. Success was defined as no residual leakage or abscess formation and closure of the external opening.

RESULTS

Fifteen patients (seven women), median age 46 years (range 32-58 years), were included in the study. Three had Crohn's disease, three had an anovulvar fistula and seven had undergone previous surgical-repair attempts. Three patients expelled the prosthesis on postoperative day 2, 5 and 7, respectively, and a second plug placement was followed by expulsion again. One patient developed an abscess that was noted on postoperative day 4. The fistula tract healed in 6/15 patients (40%) after 3 months and in 8/15 (53.3%) after 7 months. The success rate in Crohn's disease was 33%. No significant difference was found between patients with or without previous surgical repair.

CONCLUSION

In our experience, this simple technique provided success rates of 40% at 3 months and 53% at 7 months.

Histological identification of epithelium in perianal fistulae: a prospective study

AIM

A procedure often performed following fistulotomy and advancement flap is curettage of the fistula tract after fistulotomy or after closing the internal opening. Epithelialization of the fistula tract might prevent closure of the fistula tract. The aim of this study was to assess the incidence and origin of epithelialization of the fistula tract in patients with perianal fistulae undergoing fistulotomy.

METHOD

Only patients with low perianal fistulae that were surgically treated by fistulotomy were included. Surgical biopsies were taken from the fistula tract from three different locations; on the proximal side at the internal opening, in the middle of the fistula tract and near the distal end close to the external opening.

RESULTS

In the study period, 18 patients with low perianal fistulae were included. In 15 of the 18 patients, squamous epithelium was found at least in one of the biopsies taken from the fistula tract. Epithelium was predominantly found near the internal opening. There was no relation between the duration of fistula complaints and the amount of epithelialization (P = 0.301). The amount of epithelium was not related to the presence of a history of fistula surgery (P = 1.000).

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrated epithelialization in the fistula tract in the majority of the patients surgically treated by fistulotomy for low perianal fistulae. Curettage of perianal fistulae must therefore be considered an essential step in the surgical treatment of perianal fistula.

Tract length predicts successful closure with anal fistula plug in cryptoglandular fistulas

PURPOSE

Collagen anal fistula plug treatment of transsphincteric fistulas produces variable results. The purpose of our study was to determine whether long-tract fistulas (>4 cm) correlated with successful closure.

METHODS

All patients undergoing transsphincteric cryptoglandular fistula repair with anal fistula plugs were enrolled in a prospective database. Patients with Crohn's disease were excluded. Fistula tract length was measured intraoperatively by subtracting the remaining plug length from the original plug size. All procedures used standardized techniques and postoperative care pathways. The primary outcome was complete fistula closure assessed through both postoperative outpatient visits and a follow-up telephone questionnaire.

RESULTS

Forty-one patients with 42 fistula tracks were enrolled over a 39-month period. Complete closure was achieved in 18 of 42 (43%) fistulas at a mean follow-up of 25 months. Closure was not associated with gender, age, tract location, duration of seton, or length of follow-up. Successful closure was significantly associated with increased tract length, because fistulas longer than 4 cm were nearly 3 times more likely to heal compared with shorter fistulas ((14/23, 61%) vs (4/19, 21%), P = .004; relative risk = 2.8; 95% CI 1.14-7.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Anal fistula plug repair of cryptoglandular anorectal fistulas is more successful for long-tract fistulas. Although the overall success is modest, limiting surgical indications to fistulas exceeding 4 cm may maximize benefits of the plug technique.

Randomized controlled trial of minimally invasive surgery using acellular dermal matrix for complex anorectal fistula

AIM: To compare the efficacy and safety of acellular dermal matrix (ADM) bioprosthetic material and endorectal advancement flap (ERAF) in treatment of complex anorectal fistula.

METHODS: Ninety consecutive patients with complex anorectal fistulae admitted to Anorectal Surgical Department of First Affiliated Hospital, Xinjiang Medical University from March 2008 to July 2009, were enrolled in this study. Complex anorectal fistula was diagnosed following its clinical, radiographic, or endoscopic diagnostic criteria. Under spinal anesthesia, patients underwent identification and irrigation of the fistula tracts using hydrogen peroxide. ADM was securely sutured at the secondary opening to the primary opening using absorbable suture. Outcomes of ADM and ERAF closure were compared in terms of success rate, fecal incontinence rate, anorectal deformity rate, postoperative pain time, closure time and life quality score. Success was defined as closure of all external openings, absence of drainage without further intervention, and absence of abscess formation. Follow-up examination was performed 2 d, 2, 4, 6, 12 wk, and 5 mo after surgery, respectively.

RESULTS: No patient was lost to follow-up. The overall success rate was 82.22% (37/45) 5.7 mo after surgery. ADM dislodgement occured in 5 patients (11.11%), abscess formation was found in 1 patient, and fistula recurred in 2 patients. Of the 13 patients with recurrent fistula using ERAF, 5 (11.11%) received surgical drainage because of abscess formation. The success rate, postoperative pain time and closure time of ADM were significantly higher than those of ERAF (P < 0.05). However, no difference was observed in fecal incontinence rate and anorectal deformity rate after treatment with ADM and ERAF.

CONCLUSION: Closure of fistula tract opening with ADM is an effective procedure for complex anorectal fistula. ADM should be considered a first line treatment for patients with complex anorectal fistula.

Long-term outcomes with the use of bioprosthetic plugs for the management of complex anal fistulas

PURPOSE

This study was undertaken to determine the long-term outcomes of patients whose anal fistulas were managed by use of bioprosthetic plugs.

METHOD

A retrospective analysis was performed of all patients whose anal fistula was managed by use of a bioprosthetic plug between May 2005 and September 2006, who had a minimum of 1 year of follow-up since their last treatment. Patients whose fistulas were clinically healed were offered MRI to confirm healing of the fistula.

RESULTS

The bioprosthetic fistula plug was used to treat an anal fistula in 63 patients with clinical healing of the fistula in 51 (81%). Multivariate analysis showed that tobacco smoking, posterior fistula, and history of previous failure of the bioprosthetic plug was predictive of failure of the bioprosthetic plug. Eight patients with clinical healing after a minimum of 1 year since their last treatment underwent MRI. No evidence of residual fistula tract or fluid in the area of the previous fistula was found in 6 (75%) of these patients.

CONCLUSION

Bioprosthetic plugs are effective for the long-term closure of complex fistulas-in-ano. Randomized clinical trials comparing bioprosthetic plugs with other sphincter-preserving methods for fistula management need to be conducted to further determine the role of bioprosthetics in the management of anal fistulas.

A retrospective review of chronic anal fistulae treated by anal fistulae plug

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to analyse the efficacy of the anal fistulae plug (Cook Surgisis AFP) for the management of complex anal fistulae.

METHOD

A review of patients with anal fistulae treated using Cook Surgisis AFP between October 2005 and 2007 was undertaken. Patient's demographics, fistulae aetiology and success rates were recorded.

RESULTS

Thirty-three patients underwent 49 plug insertions. The median age was 44.4 years; 18 females. The fistulae aetiology was cryptoglandular in 61% and Crohn's disease in 39%. The median follow up 221.5 days (range 44-684). Twenty-one patients had previous failed surgery. Twenty-eight patients had draining setons in situ at time of plug placement. The overall success rate was 8/32 patients (25%). Two of the 22 Crohn's fistulae healed (9.1%) and 9/26(34.6%) cryptoglandular fistulae healed. The reasons for failure were sepsis in 87% and plug dislodgement in 13%. Significant predictor factors for improved outcome were African-Americans patients (P = 0.009), and presence of seton (P = 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Anal fistulae plug was associated with a lower success rate than previously reported. Septic complications were the main reason for failure.

Perianal fistulae in Crohn's Disease: current and future approaches to treatment

: affecting sphincter integrity and continence. Traditional surgical and medical approaches are not without their limitations and may result in either comorbidity, such as fecal incontinence, or incomplete healing of the fistulae. Over the last 2 decades these limitations have led to a paradigm shift toward the use of biomaterials, and more recently cell-based therapies, which have met with variable degrees of success. This review discusses the traditional and current methods of treatment, as well as emerging and possible alternative approaches that may improve fistula healing.

Anorectal abscess and fistula-in-ano: evidence-based management

The management of anorectal abscess and anal fistula has changed markedly with time. Invasive methods with high resulting rates of incontinence have given way to sphincter-sparing methods that have a much lower associated morbidity. There has been an increase in reports in the medical literature describing the success rates of the varying methods of dealing with this condition. This article reviews the various methods of treatment and evidence supporting their use and explores advances that may lead to new therapies.

Ligation of the intersphincteric fistula tract: an effective new technique for complex fistulas

INTRODUCTION

The management of complex fistulas is difficult. Maintaining continence while achieving durable fistula closure is the goal of surgical management. This study describes our experience with a novel sphincter-sparing technique called the ligation of the intersphincteric fistula tract, which involves ligation and division of the fistula tract in the intersphincteric space.

METHODS

All patients from July 2007 to December 2008 with trans- or suprasphincteric fistula treated with the procedure were prospectively followed. Procedures were performed by surgeons with fellowship training in a referral center. Demographic data, comorbidities, previous repair attempts, and postoperative data were collected.

RESULTS

A total of 39 patients underwent a ligation of the intersphincteric fistula tract during a 17-month period. Median age was 49 years. A total of 29 patients (74%) had previous attempts at repair, with a median of 2 failed repairs. Follow-up data were available in 90% (35 of 39). Median follow-up was 20 weeks. Successful fistula closure was achieved in 57% of the patients (20 of 35). Median time to failure was 10 weeks (range, 2-38 weeks). No patient reported any subjective decrease in continence after the procedure.

CONCLUSION

Ligation of the intersphincteric fistula tract is a new sphincter-sparing procedure for complex transsphincteric fistula. The success rate is comparable with other sphincter-preserving techniques. Importantly, it appeared to effectively preserve continence. Adding safe, muscle-sparing surgical options to our armamentarium for dealing with transsphincteric fistula is essential. Additionally, the procedure is easy to learn and has very low cost. Long-term follow-up and randomized, controlled trials are necessary to assess efficacy and durability.

Outcomes after fistulotomy: results of a prospective, multicenter regional study

PURPOSE

This study aimed to determine the outcomes and healing rate after fistula surgery across a broad spectrum of colorectal practices.

METHODS

A prospective, multicenter outcomes registry was created by the New England Regional Chapter of The American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons. All consecutive patients undergoing surgical treatment of an anal fistula by a participating surgeon from October 1, 2007 to September 30, 2008, were entered. Demographics, fistula characteristics including Parks' classification, smoking history, previous vaginal deliveries, diagnosis of Crohn's disease, Fecal Incontinence Severity Index, and operations performed were noted. A follow-up datasheet recorded postoperative complications, healing at one and three months, and postoperative continence scores. Factors associated with healing and treatment success were compared by use of Fisher's exact test.

RESULTS

Twenty-five surgeons at 13 hospitals entered 245 patients (162 male, 83 female) in the registry. Seventy-five patients had recurrent fistulas, 51 had multiple tracts, 62 were smokers, and 24 had Crohn's disease. The overall healing rate was 19.5% at one month and 63.2% at three months. Female gender (P = 0.04) and recurrent fistula (P = 0.03) were associated with nonhealing, and 28.4% of patients required additional surgery. The best healing rate was associated with fistulotomy (87%), whereas a plug had the worst healing rate (32%, P = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical treatment of an anal fistula is associated with a substantial risk of nonhealing at three months. Fistulotomy had a high success rate, whereas the bioprosthetic plug had the lowest success rate. Multicenter studies comparing treatment options for similar fistulas are needed.

Fibrin glue in the treatment of anal fistula: a systematic review

Background

New sphincter-saving approaches have been applied in the treatment of perianal fistula in order to avoid the risk of fecal incontinence. Among them, the fibrin glue technique is popular because of its simplicity and repeatability. The aim of this review is to compare the fibrin glue application to surgery alone, considering the healing and complication rates.

Methods

We performed a systematic review searching for published randomized and controlled clinical trials without any language restriction by using electronic databases. All these studies were assessed as to whether they compared conventional surgical treatment versus fibrin glue treatment in patients with anal fistulas, in order to establish both the efficacy and safety of each treatment. We used Review Manager 5 to conduct the review.

Results

The healing rate is higher in those patients who underwent the conventional surgical treatment (P = 0,68), although the treatment with fibrin glue gives no evidence of anal incontinence (P = 0,08). Furthermore two subgroup analyses were performed: fibrin glue in combination with intra-adhesive antibiotics versus fibrin glue alone and anal fistula plug versus fibrin glue. In the first subgroup there were not differences in healing (P = 0,65). Whereas in the second subgroup analysis the healing rate is statistically significant for the patients who underwent the anal fistula plug treatment instead of the fibrin glue treatment (P = 0,02).

Conclusion

In literature there are only two randomized controlled trials comparing the conventional surgical management versus the fibrin glue treatment in patients with anal fistulas. Although from our statistical analysis we cannot find any statistically significant result, the healing rate remains higher in patients who underwent the conventional surgical treatment (P = 0,68), and the anal incontinence rate is very low in the fibrin glue treatment group (P = 0,08). Anyway the limited collected data do not support the use of fibrin glue. Moreover, in our subgroup analysis the use of fibrin glue in combination with intra-adhesive antibiotics does not improve the healing rate (P = 0.65), whereas the anal fistula plug treatment compared to the fibrin glue treatment shows good results (P = 0,02), although the poor number of patients treated does not lead to any statistically evident conclusion. This systematic review underlines the need of new RCTs upon this issue.

To plug or not to plug: a cost-effectiveness analysis for complex anal fistula

BACKGROUND

Complex anal fistulas are unsuitable for fistulotomy because of the risk of fecal incontinence. The anal fistula plug (AFP) has demonstrated fistula healing without sphincter division. This study aims to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of the AFP compared to the endoanal advancement flap (EAAF) as an alternative sphincter-preserving option for complex anal fistulas.

METHODS

The study included 24 patients who underwent treatment for complex anal fistulas. Healing and complication rates of a prospective cohort of AFP patients (n=12) were compared to a retrospective cohort of patients who underwent EAAF (n=12). Cost data were collected after validated healthcare reporting standards. A cost-effectiveness analysis was performed, including extensive modeling of fistula healing rates.

RESULTS

Both cohorts (12 AFP patients and 12 EAAF patients) had similar patient demographics and fistula characteristics. Fistula healing was achieved in 50% (5/12) of AFP patients and 33% (4/12) of EAAF patients (P=.680). Median clinical follow-up was 28 weeks for the AFP patients and 14 weeks for the EAAF patients, whereas median recurrence time was 17.6 weeks (range, 0.4-43.9) and 12.6 weeks (range, 2-34.3), respectively. Use of the AFP instead of the EAAF saved $1,588 (95% confidence interval [CI], $1,211-$1,965; P<.0001), and 1.5 hospital days per healed fistula (P=.0002). This cost-saving effect persisted and amounted to $825 (95% CI, $133-$1,517; P=.022) when the cost estimates were adjusted for the reduction in the hospital length of stay. Extensive modeling over a large range of fistula healing rates confirmed the cost-effectiveness of the AFP.

CONCLUSION

The AFP is a cost-saving procedure for complex anal fistulas compared to the EAAF.

Surgical treatment of complex anal fistulas with the anal fistula plug: a prospective, multicenter study

PURPOSE

This study was designed to analyze the efficacy of the Surgisis Anal Fistula Plug for the closure of transsphincteric anorectal fistulas.

METHODS

Patients with single transsphincteric anorectal fistulas were prospectively enrolled. Setons were used in all tracts for at least eight weeks before surgery. Continence, surgical variables, complications, and healing rates were recorded. Surgery was performed in a standardized manner. The fistula tract and external opening were debrided, the tract was irrigated, and the plug was placed. The external opening was left open. Success was defined as the absence of drainage and closure of the external opening. Follow-up examinations were performed at 2 days, 2, 4, 6, and 12 weeks, and 6 and 12 months after surgery.

RESULTS

Sixty patients were enrolled. Seventeen patients were smokers, and ten had diabetes mellitus. The mean surgical time was 23 (range, 13-50) minutes; no morbidity occurred. The overall success rate after 12 months was 62%. Nineteen fistulas recurred, and four fistulas never completely healed. The success rate was significantly lower in smokers and diabetics. Two patients had a plug dislodgement, and plugs were successfully replaced. No change in continence was observed.

CONCLUSION

Because there is still no standard for the treatment of high transsphincteric fistulas and because recurrence rates are high for all procedures performed, new techniques are needed for this complex disease. Our success rate of 62% is promising because this technique can be used as a first approach to close the fistula tract without destruction of the sphincter muscle.

[Anorectal disease: past, present, future]

Over the last decade, therapeutic approaches of anorectal disorders have been profoundly modified by new drugs, new procedures and functional considerations. In fact, the primary goals of these procedures emphasize minimal invasive approaches. Less functional postoperative complaints are often preferred over a radical efficacy. As compared to haemorrhoidectomy, haemorrhoidopexy procedure is today advocated to reduce postoperative care and complaints. As compared to lateral sphincterotomy, nitrates and botulinum toxin represent a second line therapy of chronic anal fissure to avoid faecal incontinence. As compared to fistulotmy, both glue and plug may be used to treat a high tract fistulae for the same reasons.

Randomized clinical trial of anal fistula plug versus endorectal advancement flap for the treatment of high cryptoglandular fistula in ano

BACKGROUND

The aim of this randomized study was to compare the results of anal fistula plug and endorectal advancement flap in the treatment of high fistula in ano of cryptoglandular origin.

METHODS

Consecutive patients with high trans-sphincteric fistula in ano of cryptoglandular aetiology were randomized to treatment with either an anal fistula plug or endorectal advancement flap. Patients agreed to participate in a follow-up programme, which included scheduled visits at 2, 4, 8, 12 and 24 weeks and at 1 year after surgery. The primary endpoint was effectiveness in fistula healing. Recurrence was defined as the presence of an abscess arising in the same area, or obvious evidence of fistulation.

RESULTS

A large number of recurrences in the fistula plug group led to premature closure of the trial. After 1 year, fistula recurrence was noted in 12 of 15 patients treated with an anal fistula plug compared with two of 16 treated with an endorectal advancement flap (relative risk 6.40 (95 per cent confidence interval 1.70 to 23.97); P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Contrary to other published studies, an anal fistula plug was associated with a low rate of fistula healing, particularly in patients with a history of fistula surgery.

Preliminary results on efficacy in closure of transsphincteric and rectovaginal fistulas associated with Crohn's disease using new biomaterials

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

It was the aim of this prospective study to analyze the efficacy of the Surgisis AFP anal fistula plug and the Surgisis mesh for the closure of complex fistulas in Crohn's disease.

METHODS

All patients with perianal Crohn's disease suffering from transsphincteric and rectovaginal fistulas who underwent surgery using the Surgisis anal fistula plug or the Surgisis mesh were prospectively enrolled in this study. Inclusion criteria included transsphincteric single-tract fistulas and rectovaginal fistulas. Surgery was performed using a standardized technique, including irrigation of the fistula tract, placement and internal fixation of the Surgisis anal fistula plug, and combined transanal/transvaginal excision of rectovaginal fistula with transvaginal placement of the mesh. Success was defined as closure of both internal and external (perianal or vaginal) openings, absence of drainage without further intervention, and absence of abscess formation. Follow-up information was obtained from clinical examination 3, 6, 9, and 12 months postoperatively.

RESULTS

Within the observation period, a total of 16 procedures were performed. After a mean follow-up of 9 months and 1 patient lost to follow-up, the overall success rate was 75%. For transsphincteric fistulas, the success rate was 77%, whereas it was 66% in rectovaginal fistulas associated with Crohn's disease. All 4 patients with failure had reoperation. Rate of stoma reversal in those patients who had fecal diversion was 66%. No deterioration of continence was documented.

CONCLUSION

The short-term success rates are promising. Further analysis is needed to explain the definite role of this technique in comparison with traditional surgical techniques.

Histologic analysis of acellular dermal matrix in the treatment of anal fistula in an animal model

BACKGROUND

Human acellular dermal matrix (ADM) has been used successfully for the treatment of severe burns, ureter support, and abdominal wall reconstruction. This study was designed to evaluate the mechanism of ADM in the closure of anal fistula in an experimental porcine model.

STUDY DESIGN

The fistula-in-ano model was created in the porcine model and treated with ADM in 14 animals. Fistula specimens were obtained at hours 12 and 24 and on days 3, 7, 14, 28, 60. Hematoxylin and eosin staining, Masson trichrome staining, and immunohistochemical staining for alpha smooth muscle actin and matrix metalloproteinase 9 were performed.

RESULTS

The cell density increased from hour 12 to day 7 and decreased from day 7 to day 28 (p < 0.001). Mature vessels stained with alpha smooth muscle actin were identified at day 7. Alpha smooth muscle actin-positive myofibroblasts were found in clusters at the edge of the ADM at day 7. The density of vessels (p < 0.001) and myofibroblasts (p < 0.001) increased from day 7 to day 14. The density of matrix metalloproteinase 9 increased from hour 12 to day 7 and decreased from day 14 to day 60 (p < 0.001). Partially organized bundles of muscle were found by day 60.

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest that ADM is a reasonable new option for closure of anal fistulas. Anal fistulas begin to heal as early as 12 hours, and day 7 may be an important time point to judge whether the fistula healed preliminarily or not. The ability of ADM to become vascularized and remodeled by autologous cells may be advantageous for anal fistula healing.

Treatment of transsphincteric anal fistulas by endorectal advancement flap or collagen fistula plug: a comparative study

PURPOSE

In this study we compared the outcomes of patients with complex cryptoglandular fistulas treated by endorectal advancement flap or anal fistula plug.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of patients with transsphincteric anal fistulas treated by endorectal advancement flap or anal fistula plug from January 1996 through April 2007. Patients with noncryptoglandular fistulas or insufficient follow-up were excluded. Results were obtained with a combination of chart reviews, mailed questionnaire, and phone interviews. Success was defined as a closed external opening in absence of symptoms at a minimal follow-up time of six months.

RESULTS

Forty-three patients had an endorectal advancement flap and 37 patients had an anal fistula plug procedure. The two cohorts were comparable for age, gender, smoking status, fistula type, and previous failed treatments. The success rate was 63 percent in the endorectal advancement flap group and 32 percent in the anal fistula plug group (P = 0.008), after a mean follow-up of 56 (range, 6-136) months for endorectal advancement flap and 14 (range, 6-22) months for anal fistula plug.

CONCLUSIONS

The current study indicates that the endorectal advancement flap provides a higher success rate than the anal fistula plug. Randomized trials are needed to further elucidate the efficacy and potential functional benefit of the anal fistula plug in the treatment of complex anal fistulas.

Acellular extracellular matrix anal fistula plug: results in high fistula-in-ano awaited

Song et al have reported a 100% success rate of acellular extracellular matrix (AEM) anal fistula plug in low fistula-in-ano. The results with this product in high fistula-in-ano are keenly awaited.