Evidence for the detrimental role of proteolysis during liver preservation in humans

Gentle in situ liver manipulation during organ harvest decreases survival after rat liver transplantation: role of Kupffer cells

BACKGROUND

The etiology of primary graft nonfunction and dysfunction is unknown but most likely involves Kupffer cell-dependent reperfusion injury. However, the donor operation and surgical technique may also have an effect on the outcome after transplantation. Because liver manipulation during harvest cannot be prevented completely with standard procedures, its effect on survival was assessed here.

METHODS

Donor livers were harvested from female Sprague-Dawley rats (200-230 g). Briefly, after minimal dissection during the first 12 min, livers were either manipulated gently or left alone for 13 subsequent minutes. At 25 min, all livers were perfused with cold University of Wisconsin solution via the portal vein, and transplantation was performed after cold storage (1 hr). In some rats, Kupffer cells were destroyed with gadolinium chloride or inactivated with dietary glycine before harvest. Survival, proteolytic activity in the rinse effluent, serum transaminases, trypan blue distribution to index microcirculation, and histology were compared.

RESULTS

In the nonmanipulated group, survival was 100% after transplantation; however, gentle manipulation decreased survival by 70%. Further, manipulation elevated transaminases fivefold and caused about 200% necrosis. At harvest, proteolytic activity and the time for trypan blue to distribute homogeneously were elevated three- to eightfold by manipulation. Gadolinium chloride and glycine prevented the effects of manipulation on all parameters studied.

CONCLUSION

These data indicate for the first time that brief, gentle manipulation of the donor liver has a marked detrimental effect on survival by priming or activating Kupffer cells. This may represent an important early event in pathogenesis, because Kupffer cells play an important role in primary graft nonfunction.

Enhanced liver calpain protease activity is a risk factor for dysfunction of human liver allografts

Our aim was to determine whether calpain protease activity is increased in liver tissue from allografts that have poor graft function postoperatively. Liver tissue was obtained from 36 patients at 1 hr after recirculation. The patients were divided into two groups: (1) 30 patients with good graft function; and (2) six patients with immediate poor graft function. Calpain protease activity was increased 1.6-fold in biopsy specimens from patients with immediate poor function as compared with those with excellent graft function. There was no difference between the two groups with regard to cold ischemic time for organ storage, donor age, recipient age, United Network for Organ Sharing status of the recipient, or fatty infiltration of the donor liver. In summary, enhanced calpain protease activity present in the liver 1 hr after reperfusion is a risk factor for graft dysfunction.

Reduction of proteolysis by venous-systemic oxygen persufflation during rat liver preservation and improved functional outcome after transplantation

An increase of cytosolic proteolytic activity during ischemic preservation and consecutive tissue degradation have recently been recognized as a major pathogenetic factor for liver injury during ischemia/reperfusion. In the present study, we propose a method for preventing proteolytic tissue disintegration, which results in improved recovery of the liver after transplantation. Livers were harvested from rats and stored for 24 hr at 4 degrees C in University of Wisconsin solution (group A). Others were additionally persufflated with gaseous oxygen via the inferior caval vein during this time (group B). At the end of ischemic preservation, proteolysis was confirmed in group A, with significantly elevated tissue levels of free alanine and free amino groups, whereas proteolysis was prevented in group B. After transplantation, the integrity of the graft was significantly improved in group B, in which there was a 50% reduction of plasma activities of alanine amino-transferase and a twofold increase in hepatic bile production after the onset of reperfusion, as compared with group A. Moreover, venous-systemic oxygen persufflation during cold preservation significantly attenuated the rise in plasma levels of malondialdehyde (MDA) after liver transplantation. In conclusion, venous-systemic oxygen persufflation during ischemic storage prevents tissue proteolysis and reduces parenchymal injury after transplantation in vivo; this technique may, thus, represent a useful adjunct in long-term liver preservation with University of Wisconsin solution.

Prediction of graft dysfunction by analysis of liver biopsies after cold storage

Failure of the hepatic allograft continues to be a serious life-threatening risk for the recipient. Because no effective method of extracorporeal support is available for these patients, early retransplantation is the only alternative that offers the potential for survival. The aim of this prospective analysis was to search for a predictor of primary non-function of hepatic allografts before reperfusion. From March to June 1993 we investigated 19 liver biopsies which were obtained during the preparation of the donor liver in the back table bath immediately before the implantation of the organ. All organs were preserved by UW solution. Biopsies were stored at -80 degrees C, the working-up process was started by dividing the biopsy into several portions for the determination of fat (petrol-ether extraction), water (weighing before thawing and after drying) and free amino acids (OPA-HPLC method). Graft function was categorized into three groups: (1) good function; (2) fair function; (3) primary non-function (PNF). In addition to known risk factors for delayed graft function such as a long stay of the donor in intensive care and a prolonged anhepatic period of the recipient, we were able to demonstrate that organs with malfunction had a higher fat and water content. Donor livers developing PNF showed a trend towards higher total and subdivided amino acids, which could be explained by the incapacity of the liver to utilize available substrates for gluconeogenesis.