How should we judge the efficacy of drug therapy in patients with chronic congestive heart failure? The insights of six blind men

Vasodilator therapy without converting-enzyme inhibition in congestive heart failure--usefulness and limitations

Despite a well-established rationale for pharmacologically induced arterial and venous vasodilatation in congestive heart failure, the clinical usefulness of long-term vasodilator therapy without concomitant converting-enzyme inhibition generally has been disappointing. With the exception of nitrates and, possibly, the combination of nitrates and hydralazine, the use of converting-enzyme inhibitors in many aspects appears preferable in the majority of patients. This article reviews the pathophysiology of inappropriate vasoconstriction in heart failure, the cellular mode of action of the various vasodilators, hemodynamic effects with respect to the peripheral site of action, clinical usefulness and limitations of different vasodilators, and the various determinants of clinical efficacy. Finally, an attempt is made to assess when and how to introduce vasodilator treatment with and without concomitant ACE inhibition.

Does digitalis work in chronic heart failure? The end of a 200-year-old controversy

Controlled trials using modern methods of assessment in well-defined groups of patients have now convincingly demonstrated that digitalis is an effective and well-tolerated drug in patients with chronic heart failure who have left ventricular systolic dysfunction. These encouraging findings concerning digitalis, however, should not be construed to suggest that the drug should be used alone in the treatment of heart failure. Digitalis cannot adequately control the fluid retention seen in most patients with chronic heart failure; diuretics should be added to maintain sodium balance. Digitalis has not been shown to prolong life in chronic heart failure; converting-enzyme inhibitors should be added to reduce morbidity and mortality. All three drugs should be used together in the management of patients with this disorder.

Value of New York Heart Association classification, radionuclide ventriculography, and cardiopulmonary exercise tests for selection of patients for congestive heart failure studies

To evaluate the necessity of an objective cardiopulmonary exercise test in the selection procedure of patients for heart failure studies, 50 patients with congestive heart failure New York Heart Association (NYHA) class II and III and a left ventricular ejection fraction less than 40% were subjected to a cardiopulmonary exercise test. The results of the exercise test were compared with the independent clinical estimation of NYHA class and data of measurements obtained at rest. The NYHA classification separated the patients with a mild to moderate impairment of aerobic capacity from patients with a moderate to severe impairment of aerobic capacity very well, but 32% of the NYHA class II patients had a near normal aerobic capacity, and 29% of the NYHA class III patients had a very severe impairment of aerobic capacity, more compatible with NYHA class IV. Only data from exercise measurements showed differences between groups. The determination of maximal aerobic capacity for an objective assessment of patients' performance at exercise is necessary for a proper selection procedure of patients for heart failure studies.

Vasodilator and inotropic drugs for the treatment of chronic heart failure: distinguishing hype from hope

During the past 10 years, more than 80 orally active vasodilator and inotropic agents have been tested in the clinical setting to evaluate their potential utility in the treatment of chronic heart failure. Although the initial reports of all of these drugs suggested that each represented a major therapeutic advance, only three agents--digoxin, captopril and enalapril--have produced consistent long-term hemodynamic and clinical benefits in these severely ill patients. Most of the other drugs that have been tested have not (to date) distinguished themselves from placebo therapy in large-scale, controlled trials, even though these agents produce hemodynamic effects that closely resemble those seen with digitalis and the converting-enzyme inhibitors. These observations suggest that the hemodynamic derangements that characteristically accompany the development of left ventricular dysfunction cannot be considered to be the most important pathophysiologic abnormality in chronic heart failure. Although cardiac contractility is usually depressed in this disease, positive inotropic agents do not consistently improve the clinical status of these patients. Similarly, although the systemic vessels are usually markedly constricted, drugs that ameliorate this vasoconstriction do not consistently relieve symptoms, enhance exercise capacity or prolong life. Hence, correction of the central hemodynamic abnormalities seen in heart failure may not necessarily provide a rational basis for drug development, and future advances in therapy are likely to evolve only by attempting to understand and modify the basic physiologic derangements in this disorder.

Central and regional hemodynamic effects of oral enoximone in congestive heart failure: a double-blind, placebo-controlled study

Twelve patients with congestive heart failure underwent a double-blind, placebo-controlled study for the purpose of examining the central and regional hemodynamic effects of first-dose (1 and 2 mg/kg) oral enoximone, a new phosphodiesterase III inhibitor. Enoximone augmented cardiac output, generally through a positive chronotropic response. Indices of left ventricular contractility, specifically stroke volume, delta P/delta t, fractional shortening rate, and the duration of the preejection period, were only modestly enhanced by enoximone. At 2 mg/kg, systemic vascular resistance fell below baseline values without affecting systemic blood pressure; these parameters were not altered by the 1 mg/kg dose. Both pulmonary artery pressure and pulmonary vascular resistance dropped below baseline and below placebo control for the 2 mg/kg dose. Enoximone at 2 mg/kg lowered right and left heart filling pressures below baseline. Examination of regional hemodynamic responses to both doses demonstrated a reduction in limb vascular resistance and an increase in limb blood flow proportional to the concomitant increase in cardiac output. Renal and hepatic-splanchnic blood flow and vascular resistances were not altered by enoximone. First-dose oral enoximone (1 and 2 mg/kg) alters hemodynamics in heart failure by predominant vasodilatation, particularly of limb-musculoskeletal and pulmonary vascular beds, some positive chronotropism, and modest positive inotropism.

Physiologic mechanisms governing hemodynamic responses to positive inotropic therapy in patients with dilated cardiomyopathy

Clinical trials in patients with dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) have shown a wide disparity in the hemodynamic responses to positive inotropic therapy. In addition, the response of the failing left ventricle to positive inotropic agents reflects the net interaction of multiple factors, including the magnitude of contractile abnormality and compensatory mechanisms. In the current study, left ventricular geometry, loading conditions, and contractile state were assessed in 13 patients with nonischemic DCM with the use of simultaneous high-fidelity pressure measurements and echocardiographic recordings. Comparisons were made with echocardiographic and calibrated carotid pulse data acquired in nine age-matched normal subjects. The patients with DCM were divided according to the left ventricular end-diastolic wall thickness-to-dimension ratio into groups with "appropriate" hypertrophy (i.e., less than or equal to 2 SDs from mean normal; n = 5; group 1) and "inadequate" hypertrophy (i.e., greater than 2 SDs from mean normal; n = 8; group 2). Age, New York Heart Association functional class, left ventricular wall mass index, and left ventricular end-diastolic pressure and dimension were similar for the DCM groups. Baseline left ventricular afterload (defined as circumferential end-systolic wall stress, sigma es) was 168% and 203% greater than normal in groups 1 and 2, respectively. The administration of the beta-adrenoceptor agonist dobutamine decreased left ventricular afterload by 12% in the normal subjects and by 10% in group 1 patients, while augmenting afterload by 5% in group 2 patients. The latter response occurred despite a 17% fall in systemic vascular resistance. Overall left ventricular performance, as assessed by the rate-corrected mean velocity of fiber shortening (Vcfc), was related to left ventricular afterload (i.e., sigma es). The resultant sigma es -Vcfc relationship, a sensitive measure of left ventricular contractility, was determined over a wide range of afterload conditions generated by methoxamine (normal subjects) or nitroprusside (DCM). Baseline left ventricular contractile state was 61% of normal for group 1 and 44% of normal for group 2. The contractile response to dobutamine infusion was 52% of normal for group 1 and only 22% of normal for group 2. Thus, positive inotropic therapy with dobutamine in patients with DCM is limited by (1) an attenuated contractile response and (2) elevated left ventricular afterload, which may be augmented further during its administration.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Sustained hemodynamic improvement during long-term therapy with levodopa in heart failure: role of plasma catecholamines

Long-term therapy with oral sympathomimetic amines in patients with heart failure has been limited by the eventual development of diminished pharmacologic efficacy. However, a previous investigation in five subjects with heart failure suggested that long-term ingestion of levodopa, which is decarboxylated endogenously to dopamine, produces a sustained improvement in cardiac function. In the present study, levodopa was administered orally (1.5 to 2.0 g) to 14 patients with heart failure while hemodynamic responses and plasma catecholamines were monitored. Initially, an increase in cardiac index and stroke volume index was accompanied by a decline in systemic vascular resistance, mean pulmonary capillary wedge pressure and mean right atrial pressure. Heart rate and mean arterial pressure were unchanged. Plasma concentrations of dopamine rose substantially after drug ingestion and correlated significantly with changes in cardiac index (r = 0.73, p less than 0.05). After 12 weeks of treatment with levodopa, the changes in cardiac index, stroke volume index, systemic vascular resistance and plasma dopamine levels persisted (n = 12 patients). Moreover, a significant decrease occurred in the heart rate at rest. Although there was an initial tendency for plasma norepinephrine concentrations to increase, a return to control levels was documented after long-term treatment. Thus, tolerance to the hemodynamic actions of levodopa did not develop during long-term administration of the drug. The hemodynamic responses observed can be ascribed to the activation of beta 1-adrenoceptors and dopamine1 receptors by dopamine generated from levodopa. The dopamine2 activity of dopamine does not appear to be responsible for the improvement in cardiac performance produced by levodopa.