A Highly Reactive Imidazolium-Bridged Dinucleotide Intermediate in Nonenzymatic RNA Primer Extension

Protocells and RNA Self-Replication

The general notion of an "RNA world" is that, in the early development of life on the Earth, genetic continuity was assured by the replication of RNA, and RNA molecules were the chief agents of catalytic function. Assuming that all of the components of RNA were available in some prebiotic locale, these components could have assembled into activated nucleotides that condensed to form RNA polymers, setting the stage for the chemical replication of polynucleotides through RNA-templated RNA polymerization. If a sufficient diversity of RNAs could be copied with reasonable rate and fidelity, then Darwinian evolution would begin with RNAs that facilitated their own reproduction enjoying a selective advantage. The concept of a "protocell" refers to a compartment where replication of the primitive genetic material took place and where primitive catalysts gave rise to products that accumulated locally for the benefit of the replicating cellular entity. Replication of both the protocell and its encapsulated genetic material would have enabled natural selection to operate based on the differential fitness of competing cellular entities, ultimately giving rise to modern cellular life.

Eighty routes to a ribonucleotide world; dispersion and stringency in the decisive selection

We examine the initial emergence of genetics; that is, of an inherited chemical capability. The crucial actors are ribonucleotides, occasionally meeting in a prebiotic landscape. Previous work identified six influential variables during such random ribonucleotide pooling. Geochemical pools can be in periodic danger (e.g., from tides) or constant danger (e.g., from unfavorable weather). Such pools receive Gaussian nucleotide amounts sporadically, at random times, or get varying substrates simultaneously. Pools use cross-templated RNA synthesis (5'-5' product from 5'-3' template) or para-templated (5'-5' product from 5'-5' template) synthesis. Pools can undergo mild or strong selection, and be recently initiated (early) or late in age. Considering >80 combinations of these variables, selection calculations identify a superior route. Most likely, an early, sporadically fed, cross-templating pool in constant danger, receiving ≥1 mM nucleotides while under strong selection for a coenzyme-like product, will host selection of the first encoded biochemical functions. Predominantly templated products emerge from a critical event, the starting bloc selection, which exploits inevitable differences among early pools. Favorable selection has a simple rationale; it is increased by product dispersion (SD/mean), by selection intensity (mild or strong), or by combining these factors as stringency, reciprocal fraction of pools selected (1/sf_sel). To summarize: chance utility, acting via a preference for disperse, templated coenzyme-like dinucleotides, uses stringent starting bloc selection to quickly establish majority encoded/genetic expression. Despite its computational origin, starting bloc selection is largely independent of specialized assumptions. This ribodinucleotide route to inheritance may also have facilitated 5'-3' chemical RNA replication.

Pyrophosphorylation via selective phosphoprotein derivatization

An important step in elucidating the function of protein post-translational modifications (PTMs) is gaining access to site-specifically modified, homogeneous samples for biochemical characterization. Protein pyrophosphorylation is a poorly characterized PTM, and here a chemical approach to obtain pyrophosphoproteins is reported. Photo-labile phosphorimidazolide reagents were developed for selective pyrophosphorylation, affinity-capture, and release of pyrophosphoproteins. Kinetic analysis of the reaction revealed rate constants between 9.2 × 10-3 to 0.58 M-1 s-1, as well as a striking proclivity of the phosphorimidazolides to preferentially react with phosphate monoesters over other nucleophilic side chains. Besides enabling the characterization of pyrophosphorylation on protein function, this work highlights the utility of phosphoryl groups as handles for selective protein modification for a variety of applications, such as phosphoprotein bioconjugation and enrichment.

Visualizing primer extension without enzymes

X-ray crystallography has been used to observe the synthesis of RNA in the absence of enzymes with atomic resolution.

Crystallographic observation of nonenzymatic RNA primer extension

The importance of genome replication has inspired detailed crystallographic studies of enzymatic DNA/RNA polymerization. In contrast, the mechanism of nonenzymatic polymerization is less well understood, despite its critical role in the origin of life. Here we report the direct observation of nonenzymatic RNA primer extension through time-resolved crystallography. We soaked crystals of an RNA primer-template-dGMP complex with guanosine-5′-phosphoro-2-aminoimidazolide for increasing times. At early times we see the activated ribonucleotides bound to the template, followed by formation of the imidazolium-bridged dinucleotide intermediate. At later times, we see a new phosphodiester bond forming between the primer and the incoming nucleotide. The intermediate is pre-organized because of the constraints of base-pairing with the template and hydrogen bonding between the imidazole amino group and both flanking phosphates. Our results provide atomic-resolution insight into the mechanism of nonenzymatic primer extension, and set the stage for further structural dissection and optimization of the RNA copying process.

Enzymes speed up chemical reactions that are essential to life. Most enzymes are proteins, but some are molecules of ribonucleic acid or RNA. Like DNA, RNA is made from a chain of building blocks called nucleotides. In modern organisms, protein-based enzymes build RNAs by linking nucleotides together, while the building blocks of proteins are linked by an RNA-based enzyme at the heart of a structure called a ribosome. The earliest life on Earth most likely relied only on RNA-based enzymes, but during the emergence of life, scientists believe that RNA molecules must have replicated spontaneously before dedicated RNA-based enzymes had evolved.

How RNA could replicate without enzymes has been a puzzle for decades. Recently, scientists discovered a previously unsuspected chemical intermediate that forms during the process, and hypothesized that this molecule’s special structure is what enables the chemical reaction that adds new nucleotides to a growing strand of RNA.

To test this hypothesis, Zhang et al. diffused free RNA nucleotides into a crystalized complex containing template strands of RNA attached to short pieces of RNA called primers, which kick-start replication. Then, the crystals were frozen at various intervals and viewed using X-rays. This allowed Zhang et al. to observe the structural changes that occurred over time as the compounds reacted. The approach first revealed that the free nucleotides had paired with complementary nucleotides on the RNA template strands. Then, pairs of free nucleotides reacted with each other to form the intermediate. Finally, the intermediate reacted with the primer, forming a new bond that connects the RNA primer to one of the nucleotides of the intermediate, while the other nucleotide of the intermediate was released as a free nucleotide.

This experiment confirms that the specific structure of the intermediate molecule promotes RNA replication without help from enzymes. These findings will benefit chemists and biologists who study how RNA evolves and replicates. Future research building upon this work will deepen scientific understanding of the environmental conditions that were required for life to appear on Earth.

Evolutionary convergence in the biosyntheses of the imidazole moieties of histidine and purines

Background

The imidazole group is an ubiquitous chemical motif present in several key types of biomolecules. It is a structural moiety of purines, and plays a central role in biological catalysis as part of the side-chain of histidine, the amino acid most frequently found in the catalytic site of enzymes. Histidine biosynthesis starts with both ATP and the pentose phosphoribosyl pyrophosphate (PRPP), which is also the precursor for the de novo synthesis of purines. These two anabolic pathways are also connected by the imidazole intermediate 5-aminoimidazole-4-carboxamide ribotide (AICAR), which is synthesized in both routes but used only in purine biosynthesis. Rather surprisingly, the imidazole moieties of histidine and purines are synthesized by different, non-homologous enzymes. As discussed here, this phenomenon can be understood as a case of functional molecular convergence.

Results

In this work, we analyze these polyphyletic processes and argue that the independent origin of the corresponding enzymes is best explained by the differences in the function of each of the molecules to which the imidazole moiety is attached. Since the imidazole present in histidine is a catalytic moiety, its chemical arrangement allows it to act as an acid or a base. On the contrary, the de novo biosynthesis of purines starts with an activated ribose and all the successive intermediates are ribotides, with the key β-glycosidic bondage joining the ribose and the imidazole moiety. This prevents purine ribonucleotides to exhibit any imidazole-dependent catalytic activity, and may have been the critical trait for the evolution of two separate imidazole-synthesizing-enzymes. We also suggest that, in evolutionary terms, the biosynthesis of purines predated that of histidine.

Conclusions

As reviewed here, other biosynthetic routes for imidazole molecules are also found in extant metabolism, including the autocatalytic cyclization that occurs during the formation of creatinine from creatine phosphate, as well as the internal cyclization of the Ala-Ser-Gly motif of some members of the ammonia-lyase and aminomutase families, that lead to the MIO cofactor. The diversity of imidazole-synthesizing pathways highlights the biological significance of this key chemical group, whose biosyntheses evolved independently several times.

Copying of Mixed-Sequence RNA Templates inside Model Protocells

The chemical replication of RNA inside fatty acid vesicles is a plausible step in the emergence of cellular life. On the primitive Earth, simple protocells with the ability to import nucleotides and short oligomers from their environment could potentially have replicated and retained larger genomic RNA oligonucleotides within a spatially defined compartment. We have previously shown that short 5'-phosphoroimidazolide-activated "helper" RNA oligomers enable the nonenzymatic copying of mixed-sequence templates in solution, using 5'-phosphoroimidazolide-activated mononucleotides. Here, we report that citrate-chelated Mg2+, a catalyst of nonenzymatic primer extension, enhances fatty acid membrane permeability to such short RNA oligomers up to the size of tetramers, without disrupting vesicle membranes. In addition, selective permeability of short, but not long, oligomers can be further enhanced by elevating the temperature. The ability to increase the permeability of fatty acid membranes to short oligonucleotides allows for the nonenzymatic copying of RNA templates containing all four nucleotides inside vesicles, bringing us one step closer to the goal of building a protocell capable of Darwinian evolution.

Nucleic acids: function and potential for abiogenesis

The emergence of functional cooperation between the three main classes of biomolecules - nucleic acids, peptides and lipids - defines life at the molecular level. However, how such mutually interdependent molecular systems emerged from prebiotic chemistry remains a mystery. A key hypothesis, formulated by Crick, Orgel and Woese over 40 year ago, posits that early life must have been simpler. Specifically, it proposed that an early primordial biology lacked proteins and DNA but instead relied on RNA as the key biopolymer responsible not just for genetic information storage and propagation, but also for catalysis, i.e. metabolism. Indeed, there is compelling evidence for such an 'RNA world', notably in the structure of the ribosome as a likely molecular fossil from that time. Nevertheless, one might justifiably ask whether RNA alone would be up to the task. From a purely chemical perspective, RNA is a molecule of rather uniform composition with all four bases comprising organic heterocycles of similar size and comparable polarity and pK a values. Thus, RNA molecules cover a much narrower range of steric, electronic and physicochemical properties than, e.g. the 20 amino acid side-chains of proteins. Herein we will examine the functional potential of RNA (and other nucleic acids) with respect to self-replication, catalysis and assembly into simple protocellular entities.

Enzyme-free genetic copying of DNA and RNA sequences

The copying of short DNA or RNA sequences in the absence of enzymes is a fascinating reaction that has been studied in the context of prebiotic chemistry. It involves the incorporation of nucleotides at the terminus of a primer and is directed by base pairing. The reaction occurs in aqueous medium and leads to phosphodiester formation after attack of a nucleophilic group of the primer. Two aspects of this reaction will be discussed in this review. One is the activation of the phosphate that drives what is otherwise an endergonic reaction. The other is the improved mechanistic understanding of enzyme-free primer extension that has led to a quantitative kinetic model predicting the yield of the reaction over the time course of an assay. For a successful modeling of the reaction, the strength of the template effect, the inhibitory effect of spent monomers, and the rate constants of the chemical steps have to be determined experimentally. While challenges remain for the high fidelity copying of long stretches of DNA or RNA, the available data suggest that enzyme-free primer extension is a more powerful reaction than previously thought.

Structural Rationale for the Enhanced Catalysis of Nonenzymatic RNA Primer Extension by a Downstream Oligonucleotide

Nonenzymatic RNA primer extension by activated mononucleotides has long served as a model for the study of prebiotic RNA copying. We have recently shown that the rate of primer extension is greatly enhanced by the formation of an imidazolium-bridged dinucleotide between the incoming monomer and a second, downstream activated monomer. However, the rate of primer extension is further enhanced if the downstream monomer is replaced by an activated oligonucleotide. Even an unactivated downstream oligonucleotide provides a modest enhancement in the rate of reaction of a primer with a single activated monomer. Here we study the mechanism of these effects through crystallographic studies of RNA complexes with the recently synthesized nonhydrolyzable substrate analog, guanosine 5'-(4-methylimidazolyl)-phosphonate (ICG). ICG mimics 2-methylimidazole activated guanosine-5'-phosphate (2-MeImpG), a commonly used substrate in nonenzymatic primer extension experiments. We present crystal structures of primer-template complexes with either one or two ICG residues bound downstream of a primer. In both cases, the aryl-phosphonate moiety of the ICG adjacent to the primer is disordered. To investigate the effect of a downstream oligonucleotide, we transcribed a short RNA oligonucleotide with either a 5'-ICG residue, a 5'-phosphate or a 5'-hydroxyl. We then determined crystal structures of primer-template complexes with a bound ICG monomer sandwiched between the primer and each of the three downstream oligonucleotides. Surprisingly, all three oligonucleotides rigidify the ICG monomer conformation and position it for attack by the primer 3'-hydroxyl. Furthermore, when GpppG, an analog of the imidazolium-bridged intermediate, is sandwiched between an upstream primer and a downstream helper oligonucleotide, or covalently linked to the 5'-end of the downstream oligonucleotide, the complex is better preorganized for primer extension than in the absence of a downstream oligonucleotide. Our results suggest that a downstream helper oligonucleotide contributes to the catalysis of primer extension by favoring a reactive conformation of the primer-template-intermediate complex.

Synthesis of a Nonhydrolyzable Nucleotide Phosphoroimidazolide Analogue That Catalyzes Nonenzymatic RNA Primer Extension

We report the synthesis of guanosine 5′-(4-methylimidazolyl)phosphonate (ICG), the third member of a series of nonhydrolyzable nucleoside 5′-phosphoro-2-methylimidazolide (2-MeImpN) analogues designed for mechanistic studies of nonenzymatic RNA primer extension. The addition of a 2-MeImpN monomer to a primer is catalyzed by the presence of a downstream activated monomer, yet the three nonhydrolyzable analogues do not show catalytic effects under standard mildly basic primer extension conditions. Surprisingly, ICG, which has a pK_a similar to that of 2-MeImpG, is a modest catalyst of nonenzymatic primer extension at acidic pH. Here we show that ICG reacts with 2-MeImpC to form a stable 5′–5′-imidazole-bridged guanosine-cytosine dinucleotide, with both a labile nitrogen–phosphorus and a stable carbon–phosphorus linkage flanking the central imidazole bridge. Cognate RNA primer–template complexes react with this GC-dinucleotide by attack of the primer 3′-hydroxyl on the activated N–P side of the 5′-5′-imidazole bridge. These observations support the hypothesis that 5′–5′-imidazole-bridged dinucleotides can bind to cognate RNA primer–template duplexes and adopt appropriate conformations for subsequent phosphodiester bond formation, consistent with our recent mechanistic proposal that the formation of activated 5′–5′-imidazolium-bridged dinucleotides is responsible for 2-MeImpN-driven primer extension.

A Mechanistic Explanation for the Regioselectivity of Nonenzymatic RNA Primer Extension

A working model of nonenzymatic RNA primer extension could illuminate how prebiotic chemistry transitioned to biology. All currently known experimental reconstructions of nonenzymatic RNA primer extension yield a mixture of 2'-5' and 3'-5' internucleotide linkages. Although long seen as a major problem, the causes of the poor regioselectivity of the reaction are unknown. We used a combination of different leaving groups, nucleobases, and templating sequences to uncover the factors that yield selective formation of 3'-5' internucleotide linkages. We found that fast and high yielding reactions selectively form 3'-5' linkages. Additionally, in all cases with high 3'-5' regioselectivity, Watson-Crick base pairing between the RNA monomers and the template is observed at the extension site and at the adjacent downstream position. Mismatched base-pairs and other factors that would perturb the geometry of the imidazolium bridged intermediate lower both the rate and regioselectivity of the reaction.

A Kinetic Model of Nonenzymatic RNA Polymerization by Cytidine-5'-phosphoro-2-aminoimidazolide

The nonenzymatic polymerization of RNA may have enabled copying of functional sequences during the origin of life. Recent progress utilizing 5′-phosphoro-2-aminoimidazole activation has reinvigorated the possibility of using nonenzymatic RNA polymerization for copying arbitrary sequences. However, the reasons why 2-aminoimidazole (AI) is a superior activation group remain unclear. Here we report that the predominant mechanism of polymerization using cytidine-5′-phosphoro-2-aminoimidazolide (Cp*) involves a 2-aminoimidazolium-bridged dinucleotide (Cp*pC) intermediate. To explore the role of this intermediate, we first identify and quantify four reactions involving the synthesis and breakdown of Cp*pC that occur in the absence of the primer–template duplex. We then analyze the dependence of the rate of polymerization on the concentration of the Cp*pC intermediate in the presence and absence of the competitive inhibitor Cp. We also show that the contribution of the monomer Cp* to the polymerization rate is negligible under our primer extension conditions. Finally, we use the experimentally determined rate constants of these reactions to develop a kinetic model that helps explain the changing rate of nonenzymatic RNA polymerization over time. Our model accounts for the concentration of Cp*pC formed by Cp* under primer extension conditions. The model does not completely account for the decline in polymerization rate observed over long times, which indicates that additional important inhibitory processes have not yet been identified. Our results suggest that the superiority of 2-aminoimidazole over the traditional 2-methylimidazole activation is mostly due to the higher level of accumulation of the imidazolium-bridged intermediate under primer extension conditions.

Prebiotic stereoselective synthesis of purine and noncanonical pyrimidine nucleotide from nucleobases and phosphorylated carbohydrates

According to a current "RNA first" model for the origin of life, RNA emerged in some form on early Earth to become the first biopolymer to support Darwinism here. Threose nucleic acid (TNA) and other polyelectrolytes are also considered as the possible first Darwinian biopolymer(s). This model is being developed by research pursuing a "Discontinuous Synthesis Model" (DSM) for the formation of RNA and/or TNA from precursor molecules that might have been available on early Earth from prebiotic reactions, with the goal of making the model less discontinuous. In general, this is done by examining the reactivity of isolated products from proposed steps that generate those products, with increasing complexity of the reaction mixtures in the proposed mineralogical environments. Here, we report that adenine, diaminopurine, and hypoxanthine nucleoside phosphates and a noncanonical pyrimidine nucleoside (zebularine) phosphate can be formed from the direct coupling reaction of cyclic carbohydrate phosphates with the free nucleobases. The reaction is stereoselective, giving only the β-anomer of the nucleotides within detectable limits. For purines, the coupling is also regioselective, giving the N-9 nucleotide for adenine as a major product. In the DSM, phosphorylated carbohydrates are presumed to have been available via reactions explored previously [Krishnamurthy R, Guntha S, Eschenmoser A (2000) Angew Chem Int Ed 39:2281-2285], while nucleobases are presumed to have been available from hydrogen cyanide and other nitrogenous species formed in Earth's primitive atmosphere.

The Narrow Road to the Deep Past: In Search of the Chemistry of the Origin of Life

The sequence of events that gave rise to the first life on our planet took place in the Earth's deep past, seemingly forever beyond our reach. Perhaps for that very reason the idea of reconstructing our ancient story is tantalizing, almost irresistible. Understanding the processes that led to synthesis of the chemical building blocks of biology and the ways in which these molecules self-assembled into cells that could grow, divide and evolve, nurtured by a rich and complex environment, seems at times insurmountably difficult. And yet, to my own surprise, simple experiments have revealed robust processes that could have driven the growth and division of primitive cell membranes. The nonenzymatic replication of RNA is more complicated and less well understood, but here too significant progress has come from surprising developments. Even our efforts to combine replicating compartments and genetic materials into a full protocell model have moved forward in unexpected ways. Fortunately, many challenges remain before we will be close to a full understanding of the origin of life, so the future of research in this field is brighter than ever!

Insight into the mechanism of nonenzymatic RNA primer extension from the structure of an RNA-GpppG complex

The nonenzymatic copying of RNA templates with imidazole-activated nucleotides is a well-studied model for the emergence of RNA self-replication during the origin of life. We have recently discovered that this reaction can proceed through the formation of an imidazolium-bridged dinucleotide intermediate that reacts rapidly with the primer. To gain insight into the relationship between the structure of this intermediate and its reactivity, we cocrystallized an RNA primer-template complex with a close analog of the intermediate, the triphosphate-bridged guanosine dinucleotide GpppG, and solved a high-resolution X-ray structure of the complex. The structure shows that GpppG binds the RNA template through two Watson-Crick base pairs, with the primer 3'-hydroxyl oriented to attack the 5'-phosphate of the adjacent G residue. Thus, the GpppG structure suggests that the bound imidazolium-bridged dinucleotide intermediate would be preorganized to react with the primer by in-line S_N2 substitution. The structures of bound GppG and GppppG suggest that the length and flexibility of the 5'-5' linkage are important for optimal preorganization of the complex, whereas the position of the 5'-phosphate of bound pGpG explains the slow rate of oligonucleotide ligation reactions. Our studies provide a structural interpretation for the observed reactivity of the imidazolium-bridged dinucleotide intermediate in nonenzymatic RNA primer extension.

Common and Potentially Prebiotic Origin for Precursors of Nucleotide Synthesis and Activation

We have recently shown that 2-aminoimidazole is a superior nucleotide activating group for nonenzymatic RNA copying. Here we describe a prebiotic synthesis of 2-aminoimidazole that shares a common mechanistic pathway with that of 2-aminooxazole, a previously described key intermediate in prebiotic nucleotide synthesis. In the presence of glycolaldehyde, cyanamide, phosphate and ammonium ion, both 2-aminoimidazole and 2-aminooxazole are produced, with higher concentrations of ammonium ion and acidic pH favoring the former. Given a 1:1 mixture of 2-aminoimidazole and 2-aminooxazole, glyceraldehyde preferentially reacts and cyclizes with the latter, forming a mixture of pentose aminooxazolines, and leaving free 2-aminoimidazole available for nucleotide activation. The common synthetic origin of 2-aminoimidazole and 2-aminooxazole and their distinct reactivities are suggestive of a reaction network that could lead to both the synthesis of RNA monomers and to their subsequent chemical activation.

Enhanced Nonenzymatic RNA Copying with 2-Aminoimidazole Activated Nucleotides

Achieving efficient nonenzymatic replication of RNA is an important step toward the synthesis of self-replicating protocells that may mimic early forms of life. Despite recent progress, the nonenzymatic copying of templates containing mixed sequences remains slow and inefficient. Here we demonstrate that activating nucleotides with 2-aminoimidazole results in superior reaction kinetics and improved yields of primer extension reaction products. This new leaving group significantly accelerates monomer addition as well as trimer-assisted RNA primer extension, allowing efficient copying of a variety of short RNA templates with mixed sequences.

Downstream Oligonucleotides Strongly Enhance the Affinity of GMP to RNA Primer-Template Complexes

Origins of life hypotheses often invoke a transitional phase of nonenzymatic template-directed RNA replication prior to the emergence of ribozyme-catalyzed copying of genetic information. Here, using NMR and ITC, we interrogate the binding affinity of guanosine 5'-monophosphate (GMP) for primer-template complexes when either another GMP, or a helper oligonucleotide, can bind downstream. Binding of GMP to a primer-template complex cannot be significantly enhanced by the possibility of downstream monomer binding, because the affinity of the downstream monomer is weaker than that of the first monomer. Strikingly, GMP binding affinity can be enhanced by ca. 2 orders of magnitude when a helper oligonucleotide is stably bound downstream of the monomer binding site. We compare these thermodynamic parameters to those previously reported for T7 RNA polymerase-mediated replication to help address questions of binding affinity in related nonenzymatic processes.

Unusual Base-Pairing Interactions in Monomer-Template Complexes

Many high-resolution crystal structures have contributed to our understanding of the reaction pathway for catalysis by DNA and RNA polymerases, but the structural basis of nonenzymatic template-directed RNA replication has not been studied in comparable detail. Here we present crystallographic studies of the binding of ribonucleotide monomers to RNA primer-template complexes, with the goal of improving our understanding of the mechanism of nonenzymatic RNA copying, and of catalysis by polymerases. To explore how activated ribonucleotides recognize and bind to RNA templates, we synthesized an unreactive phosphonate-linked pyrazole analogue of guanosine 5'-phosphoro-2-methylimidazolide (2-MeImpG), a highly activated nucleotide that has been used extensively to study nonenzymatic primer extension. We cocrystallized this analogue with structurally rigidified RNA primer-template complexes carrying single or multiple monomer binding sites, and obtained high-resolution X-ray structures of these complexes. In addition to Watson-Crick base pairing, we repeatedly observed noncanonical guanine:cytidine base pairs in our crystal structures. In most structures, the phosphate and leaving group moieties of the monomers were highly disordered, while in others the distance from O3' of the primer to the phosphorus of the incoming monomer was too great to allow for reaction. We suggest that these effects significantly influence the rate and fidelity of nonenzymatic RNA replication, and that even primitive ribozyme polymerases could enhance RNA replication by enforcing Watson-Crick base pairing between monomers and primer-template complexes, and by bringing the reactive functional groups into closer proximity.