Randomized comparison of interferon alpha and hydroxyurea with hydroxyurea monotherapy in chronic myeloid leukemia (CML-study II): prolongation of survival by the combination of interferon alpha and hydroxyurea

Chronic myeloid leukemia in the elderly: long-term results from randomized trials with interferon alpha

Chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) in older patients has not been studied well. To assess the long-term outcome of older patients with Philadelphia- and/or BCR-ABL-positive CML, 199 patients aged >/=60 years representing 23% of 856 patients enrolled in the German randomized CML-studies I (interferon alpha (IFN) vs hydroxyurea (HU) vs busulfan (BU) and II (IFN+HU vs HU alone) were analyzed after a median observation time of 7 years. In all, 45 patients were treated with Bu, 63 with HU, and 91 with IFN. The 5-year survival was 38% in patients >/=60 years and 47% in patients <60 years (P<0.001). Whereas 5-year survival in chemotherapy-treated older patients was inferior to that in younger patients (33 vs 46%, P=0.006 for HU and 29 vs 38%, P=0.042 for Bu), no significant survival difference could be verified in IFN-treated patients (46 vs 53%, P=0.077). Calculation of age-adjusted, relative survival confirmed these results. Adverse effects of IFN were similar in both age groups, but IFN dosage to achieve treatment goals was lower in older patients. We conclude that the course of CML is not different in the elderly. They require lower IFN doses, achieve the same hematologic and cytogenetic response rates and the same survival advantage at comparable toxicity.

Current CML therapy: progress and dilemma

Rarely has progress in treatment of leukemia been as dramatic and convincing as with the BCR-ABL tyrosine kinase inhibitor imatinib.(1) Imatinib induces remissions of CML as fast as hydroxyurea, achieves rates of cytogenetic remissions that by far exceed those induced by interferon alpha and has a toxicity profile as favourable as that of hydroxyurea and much superior to that of interferon alpha.(2) In addition, the causal approach of this new drug, which may well serve as a model for new treatment modalities in other neoplasias is reassuring.