The use of arthroscopic thermal capsulorrhaphy to treat internal impingement in baseball players

Does immobilization after radiofrequency-induced shrinkage influence the biomechanical properties of collagenous tissue? An in vivo rabbit study

BACKGROUND

Despite widespread use of radiofrequency-induced shrinkage of collagenous tissue, there have been no animal studies on the effects of postoperative immobilization on the biomechanical behavior of shrunken tissue.

PURPOSE

To examine the role of postoperative immobilization after radiofrequency-induced shrinkage, with special emphasis on the biomechanical properties of shrunken collagenous tissue.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

One patellar tendon of 66 New Zealand White rabbits was shrunk. Six rabbits were sacrificed immediately after surgery. Twenty rabbits were not immobilized, twenty were immobilized for 3 weeks, and twenty were immobilized for 6 weeks. The biomechanical parameters failure strength, stiffness, and relaxation were tested.

RESULTS

Nine weeks after surgery, biomechanical parameters were still low compared to control tendons. Shrunken tendons did not reach levels of normal tissue at any time after surgery, regardless of whether the animals had been immobilized. According to time-related development, all biomechanical parameters had the lowest levels 3 weeks after surgery. Immobilized tendons demonstrated a better and faster recovery than nonimmobilized tendons compared to the immediate postoperative level.

CONCLUSION

Postoperative immobilization supports recovery of biomechanical properties after shrinkage. Despite immobilization, biomechanical properties of shrunken tissue did not completely reach levels of normal tissue.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Careful rehabilitation is imperative after radiofrequency-induced shrinkage. This animal model supports an immobilization period of at least 6 weeks after surgery.

Isolated electrothermal capsulorrhaphy in overhand athletes

The purpose of this study was to determine the efficacy of arthroscopic electrothermal capsulorrhaphy for the treatment of instability in overhand athletes. Electrothermal capsulorrhaphy without labral repair was used to treat 20 symptomatic overhand athletes (15 baseball, 3 softball, and 2 volleyball). Nineteen patients were evaluated at a mean of 23 months. Overall Rowe results were 10 excellent, 4 good, 2 fair, and 3 poor, with a mean score of 82. The overall mean American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score was 85.7 (mean pain score, 42.2; mean score for activities of daily living, 43.5). Two failures (ten percent) required open shoulder stabilization. Ten athletes returned to their prior level of sport, three returned to a lower level, and six were unable to return to their sport. These preliminary results indicate that treatment of the overhand athlete with isolated electrothermal capsulorrhaphy is favorable but does not reproduce the success of open surgery. Overall recurrence and failure rates were high. Instability in overhand athletes may require something other than isolated electrothermal capsulorrhaphy to address laxity.

Arthroscopic repair of lateral ankle instability by using the thermal-assisted capsular shift procedure: a review of 4 cases

The purpose of this study is to determine the preliminary effectiveness of the thermal-assisted capsular shift procedure for treatment of chronic lateral ankle instability. A retrospective preoperative evaluation using a modified American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society's ankle scoring system was performed on 4 patients treated with the procedure. Patients were then contacted for a 6-month follow-up evaluation using the same scale. The mean preoperative score was 26 of 60 and the mean postoperative score was 51 of 60, a mean 25-point improvement. All 4 rated their satisfaction with the surgery as good or excellent and 3 of 4 stated they would have the surgery again if necessary. The thermal-assisted capsular shift procedure showed good to excellent early results in this small study group and offers the foot and ankle surgeon a minimally invasive surgical alternative for treatment of lateral ankle ligament instability.

Prospective evaluation of thermal capsulorrhaphy for shoulder instability: indications and results, two- to five-year follow-up

BACKGROUND

Thermal shrinkage of capsular tissue has recently been proposed as a means to address the capsular redundancy associated with shoulder instability. Although this procedure has become very popular, minimal peer-reviewed literature is available to justify its widespread use.

PURPOSE

To prospectively evaluate the efficacy of arthroscopic electrothermal capsulorrhaphy for the treatment of shoulder instability.

STUDY DESIGN

This nonrandomized prospective study evaluated the indications and results of thermal capsulorrhaphy in 84 shoulders with an average follow-up of 38 months.

METHODS

Patients were divided into three clinical subgroups: traumatic anterior dislocation (acute or recurrent), recurrent anterior anterior/inferior subluxation without prior dislocation, and multidirectional instability. Patients underwent arthroscopic thermal capsulorrhaphy after initial assessment, radiographs, and failure of a minimum of 3 months of nonoperative rehabilitation.

RESULTS

Outcome measures included pain, recurrent instability, return to work/sports, and the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) Shoulder Assessment score. Overall results were excellent in 33 participants (39%), satisfactory in 20 (24%), and unsatisfactory in 31 (37%).

CONCLUSIONS

The high rate of unsatisfactory overall results (37%), documented with longer follow-up, is of great concern. The authors conclude that enthusiasm for thermal capsulorrhaphy should be tempered until further studies document its efficacy.

Arthroscopic management of the thrower's shoulder: internal impingement

Our understanding of internal impingement in the overhand athlete is an evolving body of knowledge. More recent improved understanding of the pathophysiology of events that leads to the spectrum of injury has caused us to refine our techniques of treatment. Improved surgical techniques and instrumentation have made refinement of our approach to treatment possible. Only time will tell whether the perceived understanding of these disorders, resulting in alteration of our treatment methods, is making our treatment outcomes more successful.

Electrothermal capsulorrhaphy in glenohumeral instability without Bankart tear

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to review the clinical results of electrothermal capsulorrhaphy (ETC) performed on 23 patients for the treatment of glenohumeral instability at an minimum follow-up of 2 years.

TYPE OF STUDY

Retrospective case series.

METHODS

Twenty-six patients with symptomatic unidirectional or multidirectional glenohumeral instability without Bankart tear were treated with ETC using a radiofrequency probe. No labral repairs were performed. A standard postoperative rehabilitation protocol was followed. Patients were evaluated with respect to motion, direction of instability, need for repeat surgery, return to overhand sports, and symptoms of pain and instability using various scores.

RESULTS

Twenty-three patients were available for follow-up evaluation at an average of 30 months. The overall average ASES and Rowe scores were 84.2 and 79.3, respectively. Recurrent instability requiring an open stabilization procedure occurred in 4 patients (17%), 2 with anterior and 2 with multidirectional instability. Seven of 14 overhead athletes (50%) reported inability to return to their previous level. According to Rowe scores, overall results were 11 excellent, 5 good, 4 fair, and 3 poor. No postoperative nerve complications occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

The ETC procedure was safely performed to treat glenohumeral instability without Bankart lesions. The recurrence rate is similar to that for other arthroscopic procedures but higher than for open surgery. In the absence of Bankart tear, patients with multidirectional instability and overhand athletes may require something other than an isolated ETC procedure to address instability. Long-term results of ETC are needed to better define its surgical indications.

Thermal-assisted capsular shrinkage of the glenohumeral joint in overhead athletes: a 15- to 47-month follow-up

STUDY DESIGN

Descriptive postoperative follow-up research.

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this investigation was to describe the return-to-competition rate and functional outcome of overhead athletes following arthroscopic thermal-assisted capsular shrinkage (TACS).

BACKGROUND

Traditional open procedures to correct instability in overhead athletes, such as capsulolabral repairs and capsular shifts, have produced less-than-favorable results, which have led to the development of TACS. Currently there are no long-term follow-up studies documenting the efficacy of this procedure in groups greater than 31 subjects or for a time period greater than 27 months.

METHODS AND MEASURES

Two hundred thirty-one consecutive overhead athletes who due to symptoms of hyperlaxity had previously undergone a TACS procedure from 1997 to 1999 were selected for inclusion in the study. During a 1-month period, 130 of these athletes (mean age +/- SD, 24 +/- 6 years; 113 male, 17 female) were contacted by phone for follow-up at a mean of 29.3 months postoperatively (range, 15.4-46.6 months). Of the 130, 105 participated in baseball (80 pitchers), 14 in softball, 4 in football (quarterbacks), 4 in tennis, and 3 in swimming. Fifty-four (42%) subjects were professional, 49 (38%) collegiate, 16 (12%) high school, and 11 (8%) recreational athletes. One hundred twenty-three of the 130 (95%) underwent 1 or more concomitant procedure(s) at the time of TACS. Most commonly performed were labral debridements (69%), rotator cuff debridements (65%), and superior labral repairs (35%). Subjects who returned to competition were retrospectively evaluated using a modified Athletic Shoulder Outcome Rating Scale to subjectively assess pain, strength and endurance, stability, intensity, and performance. Overall results were based on a 90-point scale with scores of 80 to 90 representing excellent, 60 to 79 good, 40 to 59 fair, and less than 40 poor results.

RESULTS

One hundred thirteen out of 130 subjects (87%) returned to competition. Mean (+/-SD) time from surgery to return to competition was 8.4 +/- 4.6 months. Mean outcome score for all subjects was 79/90; 75 (66%) subjects had excellent, 24 (21%) good, 11 (10%) fair, and 3 (3%) poor result. The mean outcome score for males was 80/90 and for females was 70/90.

CONCLUSIONS

The majority of overhead athletes (87%) successfully returned to competition following a TACS procedure with good-to-excellent long-term outcomes (88%). Based on the results of this study, TACS of the glenohumeral joint is a viable option for overhead athletes with pathological instability.

Diagnosis and Management of the Painful Shoulder. Part 2: Examination, Interpretation, and Management

Diagnosis, interpretation and subsequent management of shoulder pathology can be challenging to clinicians. Because of its proximal location in the schlerotome and the extensive convergence of afferent signals from this region to the dorsal horn of the spinal cord, pain reference patterns can be broadly distributed to the deltoid, trapezius, and or the posterior scapular regions. This pain behavior can make diagnosis difficult in the shoulder region, as the location of symptoms may or may not correspond to the proximity of the pain generator. Therefore, a thorough history and reliable physical examination should rest at the center of the diagnostic process. Effective management of the painful shoulder is closely linked to a tissue-specific clinical examination. Painful shoulder conditions can present with or without limitations in passive and or active motion. Limits in passive motion can be classified as either capsular or noncapsular patterns. Conversely, patients can present with shoulder pain that demonstrates no limitation of motion. Bursitis, tendopathy and rotator cuff tears can produce shoulder pain that is challenging to diagnose, especially when they are the consequence of impingement and or instability. Numerous nonsurgical measures can be implemented in treating the painful shoulder, reserving surgical interventions for those patients who are resistant to conservative care.

The disabled throwing shoulder: spectrum of pathology Part I: pathoanatomy and biomechanics

PROLOGUE: Several years ago, when we began to question microinstability as the universal cause of the disabled throwing shoulder, we knew that we were questioning a sacrosanct tenet of American sports medicine. However, we were comfortable in our skepticism because we were relying on arthroscopic insights, clinical observations, and biomechanical data, thereby challenging unverified opinion with science. In so doing, we assembled a unified concept of the disabled throwing shoulder that encompassed biomechanics, pathoanatomy, kinetic chain considerations, surgical treatment, and rehabilitation. In developing this unified concept, we rejected much of the conventional wisdom of microinstability-based treatment in favor of more successful techniques (as judged by comparative outcomes) that were based on sound biomechanical concepts that had been scientifically verified. Although we have reported various components of this unified concept previously, we have been urged by many of our colleagues to publish this information together in a single reference for easy access by orthopaedic surgeons who treat overhead athletes. We are grateful to the editors of Arthroscopy for allowing us to present our view of the disabled throwing shoulder. Part I: Pathoanatomy and Biomechanics is presented in this issue. Part II: Evaluation and Treatment of SLAP Lesions in Throwers will be presented in the May-June issue. Part III: The "SICK" Scapula, Scapular Dyskinesis, the Kinetic Chain, and Rehabilitation will be presented in the July-August issue. We hope you find it thought-provoking and compelling.

Anterior cruciate ligament rupture after thermal treatment in a canine model

BACKGROUND

The use of radiofrequency energy to treat damaged anterior cruciate ligaments is gaining popularity. However, complete rupture of the ligament after treatment has been reported.

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effect of thermal energy applied arthroscopically to normal, intact anterior cruciate ligaments in mature dogs.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

Monopolar radiofrequency energy was applied to the normal anterior cruciate ligament of 1 knee in 18 dogs. The contralateral anterior cruciate ligament (also normal) was sham treated. Force-plate gait analysis was performed preoperatively and at 4, 8, 12, 16, 26, and 36 weeks after surgery. Anterior cruciate ligament rupture was detected by a sudden onset of nonweightbearing and a positive drawer sign.

RESULTS

All treated ligaments ruptured approximately 55 days after surgery (mean, 55 days; standard error, 1.6).

CONCLUSIONS

Although monopolar radiofrequency energy may have some potential in the treatment of lax anterior cruciate ligaments, in the application described here the result was a highly predictable deterioration and rupture of all treated anterior cruciate ligaments.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

On the basis of these findings, we strongly recommend that strict selection and application criteria be used when considering use of this modality on anterior cruciate ligaments that are stretched or partially disrupted, or both. Use of this modality should be followed by adherence to a highly conservative rehabilitation protocol.

Influence of postoperative immobilization on tendon length after radiofrequency-induced shrinkage. An in vivo rabbit study

BACKGROUND

Despite the widespread use of radiofrequency-induced shrinkage of collagenous tissues, there have been no animal studies on the effects of postoperative immobilization after such treatment.

PURPOSE

To examine the effects of postoperative immobilization after radiofrequency energy treatment, with special emphasis on any tissue length increases.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

The right patellar tendon of 60 New Zealand White rabbits was shrunk with a radiofrequency probe. Tendon length was measured intraoperatively before and after shrinkage and via radiographs immediately postoperatively and at 3, 6, and 9 weeks. Twenty rabbits were not immobilized, 20 were immobilized for 3 weeks, and 20 were immobilized for 6 weeks.

RESULTS

In the nonimmobilized limbs, the tendon length increased 34.9% at 3 weeks and another 2.5% at 6 weeks, versus 11.2% at 3 weeks and 6.6% at 6 weeks in the immobilized limbs. Ten of the 20 rabbits that were immobilized for 6 weeks were sacrificed at 9 weeks and were found to have a further length increase of 10.8%. At 9 weeks, the tendons of this group were no longer significantly shorter than the tendons from rabbits that had not been immobilized.

CONCLUSIONS

Careful postoperative rehabilitation is imperative after radiofrequency-induced shrinkage. Without protection, exposure to normal physiologic loads places the shrunken tissue at risk of stretching out beyond the preshrinkage length.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Shrunken tissue is at risk of stretching out after radiofrequency-induced shrinkage.

The vascular anatomy of the glenohumeral capsule and ligaments: an anatomic study

BACKGROUND

A detailed description of the vascular anatomy of the shoulder capsule is lacking, yet surgical procedures may put this capsular blood supply at risk. We hypothesized that a hypovascular area is present in the capsule. The purpose of the present study was to describe the vascular anatomy of the human glenohumeral capsule and ligaments and its relevance to surgical treatment of the shoulder.

METHODS

In twenty-four fresh adult cadaveric shoulders, the axillary artery proximal to the thoracoacromial branch and the suprascapular artery were injected with India ink. The specimens were sectioned and then cleared with a modified Spalteholz technique.

RESULTS

The glenohumeral capsule demonstrates consistent arterial contributions from the anterior circumflex, posterior circumflex, circumflex scapular, and suprascapular arteries. The arterial supply is centripetal in nature. The contributing vessels enter the capsule both laterally and medially and arborize toward the middle of the capsule. The rotator cuff provides additional blood supply to the capsule through perforating vessels. The dominant capsular vessels run horizontally and form intracapsular anastomoses via vertical branches. The anterior and posterior bands of the inferior glenohumeral ligament complex are vascularized by adjacent parallel vessels. In five of twelve specimens, a hypovascular zone was located near the humeral insertion of the anterior aspect of the capsule. In these five specimens, there was an associated hypovascular zone in the underlying capsule.

CONCLUSION

The glenohumeral capsule is a well-vascularized structure with direct predictable contributions from four named arteries. These arteries send branches that enter the capsule superficially and from the periphery. These dominant vessels run horizontally toward the midcapsule and to deeper layers of the capsule. Vessels originating from the rotator cuff provide additional blood supply to the capsule.

Thermal capsular shrinkage in the throwing athlete

The role of thermal capsular shrinkage in treating various forms of pathology continues to evolve. The addition of thermal capsular shrinkage to the treatment regimen of standard pathologies in the thrower's shoulder has increased the rate of return to play even at the highest levels. Our data indicate an approximate 20% improvement in the rate of return to play with the addition of thermal capsular shrinkage to traditional treatments. These data represent relatively short-term follow-up. Longer duration of follow-up and increased numbers of patients will further enable us to make recommendations regarding the future use of this technology. As our understanding of the pathology that occurs in the thrower's shoulder continues to improve, so too will our understanding of the effect of applying thermal energy to the joint capsule.

Electrothermal assisted shoulder capsulorraphy--monopolar

Monopolar electrothermal stabilization of the shoulder shows considerable promise as a treatment alternative in athletes and patients with recurrent instability. Range of motion is preserved, recovery is faster than with open procedures, there is little disruption or alteration of inherent anatomy, and, most importantly, results at 2 years appear comparable to other surgical procedures in high-demand populations. The procedure is technically easy to perform, and the complication rate is low. Success depends on surgeon's understanding of the applications of RF energy, the use of proper surgical technique, careful patient selection, attention to the rehabilitation program, and the patient's compliance with postoperative protocol. Long-term follow-up is necessary to determine if results for this procedure deteriorate over time, especially in patients with multidirectional instability.

Anterior cruciate ligament thermal shrinkage

Heat has been used as a therapeutic form of treatment in the field of medicine since ancient times. Electrothermal energy delivered by radiofrequency has the advantages of being able to be used by even the casual arthroscopist and being relatively inexpensive. One of the expanded uses is treating ligament laxity, including the anterior cruciate.

Future trends in thermal energy

Current research is focusing on the parameters that affect tissue response to thermal energy. A clearer understanding of the interaction between thermal delivery systems, technique, and tissue response will allow for advancement. The future use of thermal energy in orthopedics depends on continued basic science and clinical research to ensure safe and efficacious results.

The unstable shoulder in the adolescent athlete

Shoulder dislocation and subluxation occur frequently in athletes, with peaks in the second and sixth decades. The majority of traumatic dislocations are in the anterior direction. The most frequent complication of shoulder dislocation is recurrence--a complication that occurs much more often in the adolescent population. The dynamic (muscular) and static (predominantly capsuloligamentous and labral) restraints to shoulder instability are now well defined. Recent surgical procedures for shoulder instability have become less interventional and have focused on restoring disrupted static restraints. The aim of rehabilitation is to enhance the dynamic muscular and proprioceptive restraints to shoulder instability.

Results of arthroscopic treatment of posterosuperior glenoid impingement in tennis players

Twenty-eight tennis players with symptomatic posterosuperior glenoid impingement limiting their participation underwent arthroscopic debridement of the supraspinatus tendon and glenoid lesions associated with this diagnosis after nonoperative treatment had failed. The dominant extremity was affected in all patients; the patients' average age was 26.9 years. Eighteen patients participated at the highest level of competition for their age, and the remaining patients participated at the intermediate level. Patients were evaluated at an average of 45.7 months after surgery by physical examination, an activities questionnaire, a subjective result questionnaire, and a questionnaire regarding their return to activity. Postoperatively, the patients averaged 26.9 of 30 possible points on the activities questionnaire. Twenty-three of the patients were subjectively satisfied with the surgical result. Twenty-two patients had returned to tennis. Despite their return, 20 of the 22 patients reported some persistent pain with participation. To our knowledge, this is the first report detailing the results of operative treatment for posterosuperior glenoid impingement in a population limited to tennis players. Even though the results are encouraging in terms of the high number of patients returning to tennis, the effects of this persistent pain with activity, although diminished in severity, on long-term participation is unknown.

Radiofrequency electrothermal shrinkage of the anterior cruciate ligament

The efficacy of electrothermal collagen shrinkage in the treatment of patients with anterior cruciate ligament laxity was evaluated. Eighteen patients who had continuity of the anterior cruciate ligament but had symptomatic laxity were treated with arthroscopic electrothermal shrinkage of the anterior cruciate ligament using a monopolar radiofrequency probe. The mean length of follow-up in patients whose stability was maintained was 20.5 months. Seven of the patients had undergone previous reconstruction, four with patellar tendon graft and three with quadrupled hamstring tendon graft. Laxity was chronic in nine patients and acute in nine. The KT-1000 arthrometer results at 1 month postoperatively revealed decreased anterior excursion, with an average side-to-side difference of 1.9 mm. However, 11 patients had a failed result at an average 4.0 months. Of the seven patients with successful results, six had native ligaments and had been treated for acute laxity and one had a patellar tendon graft and had been treated for chronic laxity. Even with the short-term follow-up in our study, it is evident that thermal shrinkage using radiofrequency technology has limited application for patients with anterior cruciate ligament laxity. Although it may be useful in treating patients with an acutely injured native anterior cruciate ligament, further study is needed to see if the ligament stretches out over time or is at increased risk of reinjury.