Engineering ear constructs with a composite scaffold to maintain dimensions

Total reconstruction of the auricle: our experiences on indications and recent techniques

INTRODUCTION

Auricular reconstruction is a great challenge in facial plastic surgery. With the advances in surgical techniques and biotechnology, different options are available for consideration. The aim of this paper is to review the knowledge about the various techniques for total auricular reconstruction based on the literature and our experience.

METHODS

Approximately 179 articles published from 1980 to 2013 were identified, and 59 articles were included. We have focused on the current status of total auricular reconstruction based on our personal experience and on papers of particular interest, published within the period of review. We have also included a prospective view on the tissue engineering of cartilage.

RESULTS

Most surgeons still practice total auricular reconstruction by employing techniques developed by Brent, Nagata, and Firmin with autologous rib cartilage. Within the last years, alloplastic frameworks for reconstruction have become well established. Choosing the reconstruction techniques depends mainly on the surgeon's preference and experience. Prosthetic reconstruction is still reserved for special conditions, even though the material is constantly improving. Tissue engineering has a growing potential for clinical applicability.

CONCLUSION

Auricular reconstruction still receives attention of plastic/maxillofacial surgeons and otolaryngologists. Even though clinical applicability lags behind initial expectations, the development of tissue-engineered constructs continues its potential development.

Ovine Model for Auricular Reconstruction

Objectives:

We developed a large animal model for auricular reconstruction with engineered cartilage frameworks and evaluated the performance of porous polyethylene auricular implants in this model.

Methods:

Eighteen high-density porous polyethylene auricular frameworks were implanted subcutaneously in the infra-auricular areas of 9 sheep. The implants were harvested 17 weeks later for gross and histologic examination. The perioperative and postoperative courses were carefully documented.

Results:

Five implants became exposed, and 2 implants needed to be removed at 7 weeks. Additionally, 1 infected implant was removed at 2 weeks. Seromas developed in 2 implants because of drain failures and were drained successfully during the first postoperative week. There were no other surgical site complications. The remaining 10 implants had an acceptable cosmetic appearance at 17 weeks.

Conclusions:

The perioperative complication rate in the ovine porous polyethylene auricular implant model was higher than that reported for auricular reconstructions in humans. The implant exposures were likely caused by ischemia and excessive stress on the thin overlying skin, because vascularized flap coverage was not used. The histologic findings were comparable to the results reported for other animal models. This large animal model is appropriate for auricular reconstruction experiments, including engineered constructs.

Successful creation of tissue-engineered autologous auricular cartilage in an immunocompetent large animal model

Tissue-engineered cartilage has historically been an attractive alternative treatment option for auricular reconstruction. However, the ability to reliably generate autologous auricular neocartilage in an immunocompetent preclinical model should first be established. The objectives of this study were to demonstrate engineered autologous auricular cartilage in the immunologically aggressive subcutaneous environment of an immunocompetent animal model, and to determine the impact of in vitro culture duration of chondrocyte-seeded constructs on the quality of neocartilage maturation in vivo. Auricular cartilage was harvested from eight adult sheep; chondrocytes were isolated, expanded in vitro, and seeded onto fibrous collagen scaffolds. Constructs were cultured in vitro for 2, 6, and 12 weeks, and then implanted autologously in sheep and in control nude mice for 6 and 12 weeks. Explanted tissue was stained with hematoxylin and eosin, safranin O, toluidine blue, collagen type II, and elastin. DNA and glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) were quantified. The quality of cartilage engineered in sheep decreased with prolonged in vitro culture time. Superior cartilage formation was demonstrated after 2 weeks of in vitro culture; the neocartilage quality improved with increased implantation time. In nude mice, neocartilage resembled native sheep auricular cartilage regardless of the in vitro culture length, with the exception of elastin expression. The DNA quantification was similar in all engineered and native cartilage (p>0.1). All cartilage engineered in sheep had significantly less GAG than native cartilage (p<0.02); significantly more GAG was observed with increased implantation time (p<0.02). In mice, the GAG content was similar to that of native cartilage and became significantly higher with increased in vitro or in vivo durations (p<0.02). Autologous auricular cartilage was successfully engineered in the subcutaneous environment of an ovine model using expanded chondrocytes seeded on a fibrous collagen scaffold after a 2-week in vitro culture period.

Design of composite scaffolds and three-dimensional shape analysis for tissue-engineered ear

Engineered cartilage is a promising option for auricular reconstruction. We have previously demonstrated that a titanium wire framework within a composite collagen ear-shaped scaffold helped to maintain the gross dimensions of the engineered ear after implantation, resisting the deformation forces encountered during neocartilage maturation and wound healing. The ear geometry was redesigned to achieve a more accurate aesthetic result when implanted subcutaneously in a nude rat model. A non-invasive method was developed to assess size and shape changes of the engineered ear in three dimensions. Computer models of the titanium framework were obtained from CT scans before and after implantation. Several parameters were measured including the overall length, width and depth, the minimum intrahelical distance and overall curvature values for each beam section within the framework. Local curvature values were measured to gain understanding of the bending forces experienced by the framework structure in situ. Length and width changed by less than 2%, whereas the depth decreased by approximately 8% and the minimum intrahelical distance changed by approximately 12%. Overall curvature changes identified regions most susceptible to deformation. Eighty-nine per cent of local curvature measurements experienced a bending moment less than 50 µN-m owing to deformation forces during implantation. These quantitative shape analysis results have identified opportunities to improve shape fidelity of engineered ear constructs.

High-fidelity tissue engineering of patient-specific auricles for reconstruction of pediatric microtia and other auricular deformities

Introduction

Autologous techniques for the reconstruction of pediatric microtia often result in suboptimal aesthetic outcomes and morbidity at the costal cartilage donor site. We therefore sought to combine digital photogrammetry with CAD/CAM techniques to develop collagen type I hydrogel scaffolds and their respective molds that would precisely mimic the normal anatomy of the patient-specific external ear as well as recapitulate the complex biomechanical properties of native auricular elastic cartilage while avoiding the morbidity of traditional autologous reconstructions.

Methods

Three-dimensional structures of normal pediatric ears were digitized and converted to virtual solids for mold design. Image-based synthetic reconstructions of these ears were fabricated from collagen type I hydrogels. Half were seeded with bovine auricular chondrocytes. Cellular and acellular constructs were implanted subcutaneously in the dorsa of nude rats and harvested after 1 and 3 months.

Results

Gross inspection revealed that acellular implants had significantly decreased in size by 1 month. Cellular constructs retained their contour/projection from the animals' dorsa, even after 3 months. Post-harvest weight of cellular constructs was significantly greater than that of acellular constructs after 1 and 3 months. Safranin O-staining revealed that cellular constructs demonstrated evidence of a self-assembled perichondrial layer and copious neocartilage deposition. Verhoeff staining of 1 month cellular constructs revealed de novo elastic cartilage deposition, which was even more extensive and robust after 3 months. The equilibrium modulus and hydraulic permeability of cellular constructs were not significantly different from native bovine auricular cartilage after 3 months.

Conclusions

We have developed high-fidelity, biocompatible, patient-specific tissue-engineered constructs for auricular reconstruction which largely mimic the native auricle both biomechanically and histologically, even after an extended period of implantation. This strategy holds immense potential for durable patient-specific tissue-engineered anatomically proper auricular reconstructions in the future.

Human auricular tissue engineering in an immunocompetent animal model

BACKGROUND

Tissue engineering has the potential to provide ear-shaped cartilaginous constructs in the near future. Previous attempts to engineer human ear-shaped constructs mimicked human shape and characteristics but were done in immunocompromised animal models.

OBJECTIVES

The authors design and evaluate a novel, 3-dimensional (3D) cell-copolymer construct resembling a human ear that was subsequently implanted in an immunocompetent rabbit model.

MATERIALS

Mesenchymal progenitor cells that were obtained from perichondrium and chondrium of a rabbit auricular cartilaginous site were expanded in vitro to chondrocytes and seeded onto biodegradable alginate and silk polymer ear-shaped scaffolds. After implantation in the back of 6 immunocompetent rabbits for 8 weeks, cell/scaffold constructs were harvested and analyzed in terms of size, shape, and histology.

RESULTS

Data from this study suggest that auricular mesenchymal progenitor cells derived from rabbit perichondrium and chondrium are suitable for development of tissue-engineered human ear models with retention over time of 3D construct architecture. Gross morphology revealed that the silk alginate scaffold diminished slightly the size dimensions but maintained shape and flexibility. Histological analysis showed formation of cartilage tissue along with type II collagen and proteoglycan extracellular matrix components of the silk alginate construct.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates for the first time that it is possible to engineer an ear cartilage construct that resembles the human ear not only in shape but also in size and flexibility in a real test model. This study also confirms that the association of silk, alginate, and perichondrium and chondrium mesenchymal cells is a reliable method to produce an engineered auricular cartilage construct. Further long-term research needs to be done to confirm these observations.

Molecular fabrications of smart nanobiomaterials and applications in personalized medicine

Recent advances in nanotechnology adequately address many of the current challenges in biomedicine. However, to advance medicine we need personalized treatments which require the combination of nanotechnological progress with genetics, molecular biology, gene sequencing, and computational design. This paper reviews the literature of nanoscale biomaterials described to be totally biocompatible, non-toxic, non-immunogenic, and biodegradable and furthermore, have been used or have the potential to be used in personalized biomedical applications such as drug delivery, tissue regeneration, and diagnostics. The nanobiomaterial architecture is discussed as basis for fabrication of novel integrated systems involving cells, growth factors, proteins, cytokines, drug molecules, and other biomolecules with the purpose of creating a universal, all purpose nanobiomedical device for personalized therapies. Nanofabrication strategies toward the development of a platform for the implementation of nanotechnology in personalized medicine are also presented. In addition, there is a discussion on the challenges faced for designing versatile, smart nanobiomaterials and the requirements for choosing a material with tailor made specifications to address the needs of a specific patient.

The tissue-engineered auricle: past, present, and future

The reconstruction, repair, and regeneration of the external auricular framework continue to be one of the greatest challenges in the field of tissue engineering. To replace like with like, we should emulate the native structure and composition of auricular cartilage by combining a suitable chondrogenic cell source with an appropriate scaffold under optimal in vitro and in vivo conditions. Due to the fact that a suitable and reliable substitute for auricular cartilage has yet to be engineered, hand-carved autologous costal cartilage grafts and ear-shaped porous polyethylene implants are the current treatment modalities for auricular reconstruction. However, over the last decade, significant advances have been made in the field of regenerative medicine and tissue engineering. A variety of scaffolds and innovative approaches have been investigated as alternatives to using autologous carved costal cartilage or porous polyethylene implants. A review of recent developments and the current state of the art and science is presented, focusing on scaffolds, cell sources, seeding densities, and mechanical characteristics of tissue-engineered auricular cartilage.