Strategy for dose escalation using 3-dimensional conformal radiation therapy for lung cancer

Conformal radiotherapy (CRT) planning for lung cancer: analysis of intrathoracic organ motion during extreme phases of breathing

PURPOSE

Conformal radiotherapy beams are defined on the basis of static computed tomography acquisitions by taking into account setup errors and organ/tumor motion during breathing. In the absence of precise data, the size of the margins is estimated arbitrarily. The objective of this study was to evaluate the amplitude of maximum intrathoracic organ motion during breathing.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Twenty patients treated for non-small-cell lung cancer were included in the study: 10 patients at the Institut Curie with a personalized alpha cradle immobilization and 10 patients at Tenon Hospital with just the Posirest device below their arms. Three computed tomography acquisitions were performed in the treatment position: the first during free breathing and the other two during deep breath-hold inspiration and expiration. For each acquisition, the displacements of the various intrathoracic structures were measured in three dimensions.

RESULTS

Patients from the two centers were comparable in terms of age, weight, height, tumor site, and stage. In the overall population, the greatest displacements were observed for the diaphragm, and the smallest displacements were observed for the lung apices and carina. The relative amplitude of motion was comparable between the two centers. The use of a personalized immobilization device reduced lateral thoracic movements (p < 0.02) and lung apex movements (p < 0.02).

CONCLUSION

Intrathoracic organ movements during extreme phases of breathing are considerable. Quantification of organ motion is necessary for definition of the safety margins. A personalized immobilization device appears to effectively reduce apical and lateral displacement.

Radiation-induced pulmonary toxicity: a dose-volume histogram analysis in 201 patients with lung cancer

PURPOSE

To relate lung dose-volume histogram-based factors to symptomatic radiation pneumonitis (RP) in patients with lung cancer undergoing 3-dimensional (3D) radiotherapy planning.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between 1991 and 1999, 318 patients with lung cancer received external beam radiotherapy (RT) with 3D planning tools at Duke University Medical Center. One hundred seventeen patients were not evaluated for RP because of <6 months of follow-up, development of progressive intrathoracic disease making scoring of pulmonary symptoms difficult, or unretrievable 3D dosimetry data. Thus, 201 patients were analyzed for RP. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed to test the association between RP and dosimetric factors (i.e., mean lung dose, volume of lung receiving >or=30 Gy, and normal tissue complication probability derived from the Lyman and Kutcher models) and clinical factors, including tobacco use, age, sex, chemotherapy exposure, tumor site, pre-RT forced expiratory volume in 1 s, weight loss, and performance status.

RESULTS

Thirty-nine patients (19%) developed RP. In the univariate analysis, all dosimetric factors (i.e., mean lung dose, volume of lung receiving >or=30 Gy, and normal tissue complication probability) were associated with RP (p range 0.006-0.003). Of the clinical factors, ongoing tobacco use at the time of referral for RT was associated with fewer cases of RP (p = 0.05). These factors were also independently associated with RP according to the multivariate analysis (p = 0.001). Models predictive for RP based on dosimetric factors only, or on a combination with the influence of tobacco use, had a concordance of 64% and 68%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Dosimetric factors were the best predictors of symptomatic RP after external beam RT for lung cancer. Multivariate models that also include clinical variables were slightly more predictive.

The University of California, Irvine experience with tomotherapy using the Peacock system

Our institutional experience using the Peacock system for intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) is summarized. Over 100 patients were treated using this system, which is fitted to a Clinac 600C linac. Both cranial and extracranial lesions have been treated using this modality. Immobilization is achieved either with the Talon system for cranial sites or an Aquaplast cast. Target volumes up to 500 cm3 have been treated. Multiple lesions (up to 3) were treated in one setup. The range of dose/fractionation schemes used was 15 Gy/1 fx (radiosurgical treatment) - 80 Gy/40 fx. Dose validation studies were carried out using film and ion chamber dosimetry in a specially designed phantom. Optimal dose distributions were attainable using inverse treatment planning for IMRT delivery. These were found to encompass the target volumes accurately using dose validation phantom studies. Immobilization methods used were accurate to within 1 mm, as evidenced by daily portal films. IMRT using the Peacock system offers the advantage of delivery of conformal therapy to high doses safely and accurately. This provides the opportunity for dose escalation studies, retreatment of previously treated tumors, as well as treating multiple targets in one setup. The system may be fitted to a conventional linac without major modifications.

Dose and fractionation concepts in the primary radiotherapy of non-small cell lung cancer

At present, radiotherapy alone or in combination with chemotherapy offers the only chance of cure of medically inoperable or locally advanced unresectable non-small cell lung cancer. The radiobiological basis and clinical results of current dose and fractionation concepts in the primary radiotherapy of NSCLC are briefly reviewed. Whenever possible, focus is given to the results of randomized phase III trials. With the exception of early disease treated to doses higher than 60 Gy, the prognosis of inoperable localized NSCLC is very poor. Local recurrence is the major cause of failure after radiation therapy calling for intensified local treatment. Dose-escalation using conventional fractionation or moderate hypofractionation is promising but randomized trials are presently not available. Dose-escalated hyperfractionation theoretically offers advantages, however, there appears currently no strong evidence from randomized trials supporting this approach in NSCLC. The highly accelerated CHART regimen significantly improved survival by 9% compared to standard radiotherapy. Nevertheless, even when treated with CHART, about 80% of all patients will eventually develop local recurrence and 60% distant metastases. Many trials on combined radiochemotherapy have used radiotherapy regimens that are not optimal from a current perspective. Because of the high rate of both, local recurrence and distant metastases, future research should be directed to further intensify radiotherapy as well as to integrate such protocols with systemic treatment in carefully selected patients. Since toxicity is expected to increase, state-of-the-art 3D conformal radiation techniques need to be part of clinical trials testing such strategies.

Dose escalation in non-small-cell lung cancer using three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy: update of a phase I trial

PURPOSE

High-dose radiation may improve outcomes in non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC). By using three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy and limiting the target volume, we hypothesized that the dose could be safely escalated.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A standard phase I design was used. Five bins were created based on the volume of normal lung irradiated, and dose levels within bins were chosen based on the estimated risk of radiation pneumonitis. Starting doses ranged from 63 to 84 Gy given in 2.1-Gy fractions. Target volumes included the primary tumor and any nodes >or= 1 cm on computed tomography. Clinically uninvolved nodal regions were not included purposely. More recently, selected patients received neoadjuvant cisplatin and vinorelbine.

RESULTS

At the time of this writing, 104 patients had been enrolled. Twenty-four had stage I, four had stage II, 43 had stage IIIA, 26 had stage IIIB, and seven had locally recurrent disease. Twenty-five received chemotherapy, and 63 were assessable for escalation. All bins were escalated at least twice. Although grade 2 radiation pneumonitis occurred in five patients, grade 3 radiation pneumonitis occurred in only two. The maximum-tolerated dose was only established for the largest bin, at 65.1 Gy. Dose levels for the four remaining bins were 102.9, 102.9, 84 and 75.6 Gy. The majority of patients failed distantly, though a significant proportion also failed in the target volume. There were no isolated failures in clinically uninvolved nodal regions.

CONCLUSION

Dose escalation in NSCLC has been accomplished safely in most patients using three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy, limiting target volumes, and segregating patients by the volume of normal lung irradiated.

A quantitative treatment planning study evaluating the potential of dose escalation in conformal radiotherapy of the oesophagus

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

This study aims to evaluate the reduction in radiation dose to normal thoracic structures through the use of conformal radiotherapy techniques in the treatment of oesophageal cancer, and to quantify the resultant potential for dose escalation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Three different CT-derived treatment plans were created and compared for each of ten patients. A two-phase treatment with conventional straight-edged fields and standard blocks (CV2), a two-phase conformal plan (CF2), and a three-phase conformal plan where the third phase was delivered to the gross tumour only (CF3), were considered for each patient. Escalated dose levels were determined for techniques CF2 and CF3, which by virtue of the conformal field shaping, did not increase the mean lung dose. The resulting increase in tumour control probability (TCP) was estimated.

RESULTS

A two-phase conformal technique (CF2) reduced the volume of lung irradiated to 18 Gy from 19.7+/-11.8 (1 SD) to 17.1+/-12.3% (P=0.004), and reduced the normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) from 2.4+/-4.0 to 0.7+/-1.6% (P=0.02) for a standard prescribed dose of 55 Gy. Consequently, technique CF2 permitted a target dose of 59.1+/-3.2 Gy without increasing the mean lung dose. Technique CF3 facilitated a prescribed dose of 60.7+/-4.3 Gy to the target, the additional 5 Gy increasing the TCP from 53. 1+/-5.5 to 68.9+/-4.1%. When the spinal cord tolerance was raised from 45 to 48 Gy, technique CF3 allowed 63.6+/-4.l Gy to be delivered to the target, thereby increasing the TCP to 78.1+/-3.2%.

CONCLUSIONS

Conformal radiotherapy techniques offer the potential for a 5-10 Gy escalation in dose delivered to the oesophagus, without increasing the mean lung dose. This is expected to increase local tumour control by 15-25%.

Evaluation of microscopic tumor extension in non-small-cell lung cancer for three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy planning

PURPOSE

One of the most difficult steps of the three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy (3DCRT) is to define the clinical target volume (CTV) according to the degree of local microscopic extension (ME). In this study, we tried to quantify this ME in non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Seventy NSCLC surgical resection specimens for which the border between tumor and adjacent lung parenchyma were examined on routine sections. This border was identified with the naked eye, outlined with a marker pen, and the value of the local ME outside of this border was measured with an eyepiece micrometer. The pattern of histologic spread was also determined.

RESULTS

A total of 354 slides were examined, corresponding to 176 slides for adenocarcinoma (ADC) and 178 slides for squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). The mean value of ME was 2.69 mm for ADC and 1.48 mm for SCC (p = 0.01). The usual 5-mm margin covers 80% of the ME for ADC and 91% for SCC. To take into account 95% of the ME, a margin of 8 mm and 6 mm must be chosen for ADC and SCC, respectively. Aerogenous dissemination was the most frequent pattern observed for all groups, followed by lymphatic invasion for ADC and interstitial extension for SCC.

CONCLUSION

The ME was different between ADC and SCC. The usual CTV margin of 5 mm appears inadequate to cover the ME for either group, and it must be increased to 8 mm and 6 mm for ADC and SCC, respectively, to cover 95% of the ME. This approach is obviously integrated into the overall 3DCRT procedure and with other margins.

The physical parameters and molecular events associated with radiation-induced lung toxicity

Radiation therapy (RT) is frequently used to treat patients with tumors in and around the thorax. Clinical radiation pneumonitis is a common side effect, occurring in 5% to 20% of patients. Efforts to identify patients at risk for pneumonitis have focused on physical factors, such as dose and volume. Recently, the underlying molecular biological mechanisms behind RT-induced lung injury have come under study. Improved knowledge of the molecular events associated with RT-induced lung injury may translate into a better ability to individualized therapy. This review discusses our current understanding of the physical and molecular factors contributing to RT-induced pulmonary injury.

The impact of three-dimensional radiation on the treatment of non-small cell lung cancer

PURPOSE

Non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients with locally advanced unresectable disease have a grim prognosis. Radiotherapeutic strategies are necessary to improve the permanent eradication of thoracic disease. The poor results achieved with conventional external beam radiation therapy reflect in part, the inadequacy of such therapy in achieving its primary objective of achieving local control. The impact of three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy (3-DCRT) on local disease eradication and its potential role in improving survival is assessed.

DESIGN

This review addresses aspects of the software and hardware technology of 3-DCRT, the clinical and technical aspects of target volume definition, the use of 3-DCRT to predict radiation pneumonitis, strategies for dose escalation in NSCLC, and analyses the clinical results to date.

RESULTS

Initially investigators compared the best treatment techniques devised with conventional planning techniques to those devised with 3-DCRT. These analyses showed that 3-DCRT had the potential to deliver high dose radiation (>70 Gy) with minimal underdosing and with a concomitant relative sparing of normal tissues. This technical demonstration of enhanced therapeutic ratio is the basis for the evolving clinical utilization of 3-DCRT for NSCLC. Software and hardware developments continue to develop and have the potential to solve evolving clinical issues. Dose-volume-histograms have been used to accurately quantify lung dose and derived parameters have the potential to predict the risk of pneumonitis for individual patients before treatment. Initial clinical results have been promising and strategies for further dose escalation are emerging.

CONCLUSION

Preliminary experience has resulted in promising survival following three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy alone for locally advanced NSCLC. More follow-up and experience will determine late toxicity, maximum dose, and efficacy of dose escalation with three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy. Strategies should be developed to integrate this modality into the combined treatment of locally advanced non-small cell lung cancer.

The deep inspiration breath-hold technique in the treatment of inoperable non-small-cell lung cancer

PURPOSE

Conventional radiotherapeutic techniques are associated with lung toxicity that limits the treatment dose. Motion of the tumor during treatment requires the use of large safety margins that affect the feasibility of treatment. To address the control of tumor motion and decrease the volume of normal lung irradiated, we investigated the use of three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy (3D-CRT) in conjunction with the deep inspiration breath-hold (DIBH) technique.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In the DIBH technique, the patient is initially maintained at quiet tidal breathing, followed by a deep inspiration, a deep expiration, a second deep inspiration, and breath-hold. At this point the patient is at approximately 100% vital capacity, and simulation, verification, and treatment take place during this phase of breath-holding.

RESULTS

Seven patients have received a total of 164 treatment sessions and have tolerated the technique well. The estimated normal tissue complication probabilities decreased in all patients at their prescribed dose when compared to free breathing. The dose to which patients could be treated with DIBH increased on average from 69.4 Gy to 87.9 Gy, without increasing the risk of toxicity.

CONCLUSIONS

The DIBH technique provides an advantage to conventional free-breathing treatment by decreasing lung density, reducing normal safety margins, and enabling more accurate treatment. These improvements contribute to the effective exclusion of normal lung tissue from the high-dose region and permit the use of higher treatment doses without increased risks of toxicity.

Factors predicting severe radiation pneumonitis in patients receiving definitive chemoradiation for lung cancer

PURPOSE

To identify factors that may predict for severe radiation pneumonitis or pneumonopathy (RP), we reviewed a set of simple, commonly available characteristics.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Medical records of 148 lung cancer patients with good performance status (ECOG 0-1) treated definitively with chemoradiation from 6/92-6/98 at the University of Pennsylvania were reviewed. Actuarial survival and the crude rate of severe radiation pneumonitis were determined as a function of several variables. Potential predictive factors examined included age, gender, histology, stage, pulmonary function, performance status (0 vs. 1), weight loss, tumor location, radiation dose, initial radiation field size, chemotherapy regimen, and timing of chemotherapy. Univariate analysis (log-rank test) was performed for each variable. Multivariate analysis was performed using linear regression.

RESULTS

Median survival for the entire cohort was 14.7 months. Four patients were inevaluable for pneumonitis due to early death from progressive disease. Of the remaining 144 evaluable patients, 12 (8.3%) experienced severe RP. The most significant factor predicting for severe RP was performance status (p < 0.003). The risk of severe RP was 16% for PS-1 patients vs. 2% for PS-0 patients. Women were significantly more likely to develop severe RP than men (p = 0.01). Among 67 patients for whom pre-radiation therapy pulmonary function data were available, forced expiratory volume of the lung in 1 second (FEV(1)) was also significant (p = 0. 03). No patient suffering severe RP had a pretreatment FEV(1) > 2.0 liters. The median radiation dose was 59.2 Gy and median initial radiation field size was 228 cm(2). Neither radiotherapy factor predicted for RP. Other factors studied, including chemotherapy drugs, and schedule, also were not significant predictors of severe RP.

CONCLUSIONS

Pretreatment performance status, gender, and FEV(1) are significant predictors of severe radiation pneumonopathy, at least when using conventional radiation fields and doses. Complex radiation dose-volume algorithms that attempt to predict lung complication probabilities should probably incorporate these simply obtained clinical parameters.

The rationale and use of three-dimensional radiation treatment planning for lung cancer

Treatment of lung cancer with conventional radiation therapy is associated with suboptimal local tumor control and poor long-term survival. Poor local tumor control may result from inaccurate tumor targeting, failure to satisfactorily conform to dose distribution with the target volume, and/or inadequate radiation doses. Three-dimensional treatment planning is a radiotherapy technique that provides more accurate dose targeting via the direct transfer of three-dimensional anatomic information from diagnostic scans into the planning process. This technology can assist treatment planning by providing dose-volume histograms, an estimation of normal tissue complication probabilities, and facilitate dose escalation. Preliminary clinical studies suggest that this is a feasible approach worthy of additional study. The three-dimensional tools provide new opportunities to better understand radiation-induced changes in pulmonary function.

Dose escalation of chart in non-small cell lung cancer: is three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy really necessary?

PURPOSE

To evaluate, preclinically, the potential for dose escalation of continuous, hyperfractionated, accelerated radiation therapy (CHART) for non small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC), we examined the strategy of omission of elective nodal irradiation with and without the application of three-dimensional conformal radiation technology (3DCRT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

2D, conventional therapy plans were designed according to the specifications of CHART for 18 patients with NSCLC (Stages Ib, IIb, IIIa, and IIIb). Further plans were generated with the omission of elective nodal irradiation (ENI) from the treatment portals (2D minus ENI plans [2D-ENI plans]). Both sets were inserted in the patient's planning computed tomographies (CTs). These reconstructed plans were then compared to alternative, three-dimensional treatment plans which had been generated de novo, with the omission of ENI: 3D minus elective nodal irradiation (3D-ENI plans). Dose delivery to the planning target volumes (PTVs) and to the organs at risk were compared between the 3 sets of corresponding plans. The potential for dose escalation of each patient's 2D-ENI and 3D-ENI plan beyond 54 Gy, standard to CHART, was also determined.

RESULTS

PTV coverage was suboptimal in the 2D CHART and the 2D-ENI plans. Only in the 3D-ENI plans did 100% of the PTV get > or = 95% of the dose prescribed (i.e., 51.5 Gy [51.3-52.2]). Using 3D-ENI plans significantly reduced the dose received by the spinal cord, the mean and median doses to the esophagus and the heart. It did not significantly reduce the lung dose when compared to 2D-ENI plans. Escalation of the dose (minimum > or = 1 Gy) with optimal PTV coverage was possible in 55.5% of patients using 3D-ENI, but was possible only in 16.6% when using the 2D-ENI planning strategy.

CONCLUSIONS

3DCRT is fundamental to achieving optimal PTV coverage in NSCLC. A policy of omission of elective nodal irradiation alone (and using 2D technology) will not achieve optimal PTV coverage or dose escalation. 3DCRT with omission of ENI can achieve true escalation of CHART in 55.5% of tumors, depending on their site and N-stage.

Alternating radiotherapy and chemotherapy for inoperable Stage III non-small-cell lung cancer: long-term results of two Phase II GOTHA trials. Groupe d'Oncologie Thoracique Alpine

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVE

To report on two consecutive Phase II cooperative trials in which we evaluated the combination of alternating hyperfractionated accelerated radiotherapy and cisplatin-based chemotherapy in inoperable Stage III non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

PATIENTS & METHODS

Between February 1986 and September 1989, 65 patients were entered in the first trial (GOTHA I), and between December 1989 and October 1992 67 were enrolled in the second trial (GOTHA II). In both protocols, radiotherapy (RT) was administered twice daily, at 6 h intervals, 5 days a week, to a total dose of 63 Gy in 42 fractions of 1.5 Gy. RT was given during weeks 2, 3, 6, and 7, over an elapsed time of 6 weeks. In GOTHA I, three cycles of cisplatin, 60 mg/m2 day 1, mitomycin, 8 mg/m2 day 1, and vindesin 3 mg/m2 day 1 and the first day of the following week, were given during weeks 1, 5, and 9; in GOTHA II, cisplatin 70 mg/m2 day 1 and vinblastin 5 mg/m2 day 1 and the first day of the following week were given during weeks 1, 5, 9, 13, 17, and 21.

RESULTS

With a minimum follow-up of 3 years, the 1-, 2-, 5-, and 8-year overall survival probability was 56% (95% CI 47-64%), 27% (20-35%), 12% (7-18%) and 9% (3-16%), respectively, with a median survival of 13.6 months (11.4-16.8). Median follow-up for survivors was 6 years (3.3-9.9). There were no survival differences between Stages IIIA and IIIB (p = 0.84), performance status 0, 1, 2 (p = 0.87), sex (p = 0.45) or between the two treatment protocols. At this time, 14 patients are alive, and 118 have died: 102 from NSCLC, 4 from acute toxicity, 2 from secondary surgery, 4 from other medical causes, and 6 from unknown causes. Correlation between response and long-term survival was poor, since of the 24 patients who survived 3 years or more, only 6 (25%) were classified as having a complete response; the remainder having either a partial response (11, 46%), no change (6, 25 %), or "progressive disease" (1, 4 %). First site of relapse was local in 31% of these cases, distant in 43%, local and distant in 15 %, and unknown in 11%. Main grade 3-4 acute toxicities were nausea-vomiting (17%), mucositis (15%), leukopenia (41%), and thrombocytopenia (11%). Eight patients presented with grade 3-4 symptomatic lung radiation pneumopathy.

CONCLUSION

Based on this experience with 132 patients, this combination of alternated RT and chemotherapy (CT) for inoperable Stage III NSCLC is feasible with acceptable toxicity, and long-term results suggest a gain in survival when compared to those obtained with conventional RT alone. However, the still high local and distant failure rates indicate that both local and systemic therapies need to be improved.

Interstitial laser photocoagulation of normal lung parenchyma in rats

BACKGROUND

Management of peripheral lung tumours may be risky in patients with poor lung function or in the elderly. A new possibility is interstitial laser photocoagulation (ILP) in which tumours are gently coagulated using thin laser fibres placed percutaneously under radiological guidance. This could have a useful palliative role in selected patients, but to be safe the effects on normal lung parenchyma must first be understood. This paper describes the creation and healing of ILP lesions in the normal rat lung.

METHODS

ILP was performed using single laser fibres placed percutaneously in the left lung of normal rats under general anaesthetic with radiological guidance (laser power 1-3 W at 805 nm, treatment time 250-1000 s). The lesion size and healing were studied in rats killed at times from three days to six months after treatment, the bursting pressure was measured, and any complications noted.

RESULTS

Zones of necrosis up to 12 mm in diameter were produced, the size depending on the laser power and treatment time. Histological examination showed typical thermal effects with complete healing with fibrosis by two months. The effect was very localised with remarkably little effect on the structure and function of the rest of the lung. Adverse effects in the lung parenchyma only occurred if the ILP lesion involved the hilar vessels or the oesophagus, causing pulmonary congestion and perforation, respectively. Pneumothorax was seen in 6% of cases.

CONCLUSIONS

ILP with a single fibre can produce a localised zone of necrosis in normal lung parenchyma which heals safely and which has little effect on the rest of the lung. Further study of this technique using multiple fibres in a larger animal model is warranted to see if it is feasible and safe to produce a large enough volume of necrosis to be of value in the treatment of small peripheral lung tumours in patients who are unsuitable for surgery or palliative radiotherapy.

An audit of 3D treatment planning facilities and practice in the UK

The availability and use of 3D treatment planning facilities in the UK was investigated by questionnaire. Fifty-eight of the 62 UK radiotherapy centres responded (94%). There was considerable variation in the facilities available and in the manner in which they were used. Although 36 centres (62%) have the facilities to undertake complex, non-coplanar treatment planning, only 12 did so on a regular basis. More surprising was the inconsistent implementation of coplanar CT planning. It is suggested that we need to work towards reaching a consensus on best practice in radiotherapy planning. This will require the creation of systems for guidance and further training of the various staff involved.

Promising survival with three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy for non-small cell lung cancer

PURPOSE

Local failure is a major obstacle to the cure of locally advanced non small-cell lung cancer. Three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy (3-DCRT) selects optimal treatment parameters to increase dose to tumor and reduce normal tissue dose, potentially representing an enhancement of the therapeutic ratio of radiation therapy for lung cancer. We performed this analysis of 45 non-small cell lung cancer patients treated with 3-DCRT alone, to evaluate the ability of computer derived lung dose volume histograms to predict serious pulmonary toxicity, to assess the feasibility of this approach, and to examine the resulting survival.

METHODS

There were 28 males (62%) and 17 females (38%). The median age was 65 (range: 38-82). Tumor stage was Stage I/II in 13%, IIIa in 42%, and IIIb in 44%. The histology was squamous in 44%, adenocarcinoma in 36%, and other non-small cell histologies in the others. Only 47% of patients. had combined favorable prognostic factors (i.e. KPS < or = 80, and < or = 5% wt. loss). The median dose of radiation to gross disease was 70.2 Gy (range: 52.2-72 Gy) delivered in fractions of 1.8 Gy, 5 days per week.

RESULTS

Seven patients did not complete 3-DCRT due to disease progression outside the port. Follow-up data are mature: the median follow up of the 6 survivors is 43.5 months (35-59). Thoracic progression occurred in 46%. Median survival (all 45 patients.) is 15.7 months and survival is 32% at 2 years and 12% at 59 months. Pulmonary toxicity > or = grade 3 occurred in 9% of patients. Dose volume histograms were available in 31 patients and showed a correlation between risk of pulmonary toxicity and indices of dose to lung parenchyma. Grade 3 or higher pulmonary toxicity occurred in 38% (3/8) of patients with > 30% of lung volume receiving > or = 25 Gy, versus 4% (1/23) of patients with < or = 30% lung receiving > or = 25 Gy (P = 0.04). Grade 3 or higher pulmonary toxicity occurred in 29% (4/14) of patients with a predicted pulmonary normal tissue complication probability of 12% or higher versus 0% (0/17) in patients with a predicted probability of less than 12% (P = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite adverse prognostic criteria median survival is encouraging and may be higher than some combined modality approaches. Dose volume histogram parameters may be useful to determine the maximum dose for individual patients and thereby permit avoidance of toxicity.

Three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy in bronchogenic carcinoma: considerations for implementation

Lung cancer continues to be a major health problem worldwide. In spite of significant technological and scientific medical progress, the final outcome of this disease is still dismal. Except for a small percentage of patients with early stage who undergo complete surgical resection, local control continues to be disappointingly low. In a recent report by Arriagada et al. (Arriagada R, Le Chevalier T, Quoix E, Rufie P, de Cremoux H, Douillard J-Y, Tarayre M, Pignon, J-P, LaPlanche, A. Effect of chemotherapy on locally advanced non-small cell lung carcinoma: a randomized study of 353 patients. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 1991; 20:1183-1190), biopsy proven local control by RT alone was only 17%. This team also found that the addition of combination chemotherapy, although it has decreased distant metastasis, has not had any impact on local control. There are some indications in the literature to suggest that higher doses of radiation to the target volume (tumor) may result in improved local control in inoperable non-small cell lung cancer. This temptation for increasing dose to target volume, however, should not result in inappropriate normal tissue side-effects and complications. Three-dimensional (3D) conformal radiation therapy has shown a significant potential for improving radiation treatment planning in several sites, both for tumor coverage and sparing normal tissue. Using this technology, progress in uncomplicated locoregional control of lung cancer may become a reality. The following is a review of literature and analysis of the currently available information on this subject.