Integrated risk assessment and predictive value to humans of non-clinical repolarization assays

Sensitivity and Specificity of the In Vitro Guinea Pig Papillary Muscle Action Potential Duration for the Assessment of Drug-Induced Torsades De Pointes Liability in Humans

The ICH S7B document, which provides guidance for the preclinical cardiovascular evaluation of pharmaceutical new chemical entities (NCE), is essentially focused on drug-induced QT lengthening, a biomarker for the proarrhythmic adverse drug reaction, torsades de pointes (TdP). In 2005, this guidance recommended the IKr assay and the in vivo QT telemetry study as mandatory assays for detecting potential torsades de pointes liability and relegated the cardiac action potential (AP) assay as a follow-up study. The IKr assay has become a mandatory screening tool in the early development and safety assessment process. Using only the IKr assay as a go/no go decision arbiter is regrettable since, due to the low specificity of the model (positives that are false for proarrhythmia liability, e.g. verapamil), promising, safe NCEs may be inadvertently discarded. Inclusion of additional medium throughput assays should be performed early to confirm or balance the putatively unfavourable IKr result with positive discovery model output (Pugsley et al., J Pharmacol Toxicol Methods 60:24-27, 2009). In the present chapter, the predictive value of in vitro guinea pig papillary muscle action potential assay will be discussed in terms of sensitivity and specificity and compared to currently available preclinical models such as IKr/hERG assay, dog Purkinje fibre action potential and in vivo QT measurements in dog and cynomolgus monkey.

Computer-based prediction of the drug proarrhythmic effect: problems, issues, known and suspected challenges

It is likely that computer modelling and simulations will become an element of comprehensive cardiac safety testing. Their role would be primarily the integration and the interpretation of previously gathered data. There are still unanswered questions and issues which we list and describe below. They include sources of data used for the development of the models as well as data utilized as input information, which can come from the in vitro studies and the quantitative structure-activity relationship models. The pharmacokinetics of the drugs in question play a crucial role as their active concentration should be considered, yet the question remains where is the right place to assess it. The pharmacodynamic angle includes complications coming from multiple drugs (i.e. active metabolites) acting in parallel as well as the type of interaction with (potentially) multiple affected channels. Once established, the model and the methodology of its use should be further validated, optimistically against individual data reported at the clinical level as the physiological, anatomical, and genetic parameters play a crucial role in the drug-triggered arrhythmia induction. All the abovementioned issues should be at least considered and-hopefully-resolved, to properly utilize the mathematical models for a cardiac safety assessment.

Detection of QTc interval prolongation using jacket telemetry in conscious non-human primates: comparison with implanted telemetry

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

During repeat-dose toxicity studies, ECGs are collected from chemically or physically-restrained animals over a short timeframe. This is problematic due to cardiovascular changes caused by manual restraint stress and anesthesia, and limited ECG sampling. These factors confound data interpretation, but may be overcome by using a non-invasive jacket-based ECG collection (JET). The current study investigated whether a jacketed external telemetry system could detect changes in cardiac intervals and heart rate in non-human primates (NHPs), previously implanted with a PCT transmitter.

EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

Twelve male cynomolgus monkeys were treated weekly with vehicle or sotalol (8, 16, 32 mg kg⁻¹) p.o. ECGs were collected continuously for 24 hours, following treatment, over 4 weeks. A satellite group of six NHPs was used for sotalol toxicokinetics.

KEY RESULTS

Sotalol attained Cmax values 1-3 hours after dosing, and exhibited dose-proportional exposure. In jacketed NHPs, sotalol dose-dependently increased QT/QTc intervals, prolonged PR interval, and reduced heart rate. Significant QTc prolongation of 27, 54 and 76 msec was detected by JET after 8, 16, and 32 mg kg⁻¹ sotalol, respectively, compared with time-matched vehicle-treated animals. Overall, JET-derived PR, QT, QTc intervals, QRS duration, and heart rate correlated well with those derived from PCT.

CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS

The current findings clearly support the use of JET to quantify cardiac interval and rhythm changes, capable of detecting QTc prolongation caused by sotalol. JET may be a preferred method compared to restraint-based ECG because high-density ECG sampling can be collected in unstressed conscious monkeys, over several weeks.

Prediction and modeling of effects on the QTc interval for clinical safety margin assessment, based on single-ascending-dose study data with AZD3839

Corrected QT interval (QTc) prolongation in humans is usually predictable based on results from preclinical findings. This study confirms the signal from preclinical cardiac repolarization models (human ether-a-go-go-related gene, guinea pig monophasic action potential, and dog telemetry) on the clinical effects on the QTc interval. A thorough QT/QTc study is generally required for bioavailable pharmaceutical compounds to determine whether or not a drug shows a QTc effect above a threshold of regulatory interest. However, as demonstrated in this AZD3839 [(S)-1-(2-(difluoromethyl)pyridin-4-yl)-4-fluoro-1-(3-(pyrimidin-5-yl)phenyl)-1H-isoindol-3-amine hemifumarate] single-ascending-dose (SAD) study, high-resolution digital electrocardiogram data, in combination with adequate efficacy biomarker and pharmacokinetic data and nonlinear mixed effects modeling, can provide the basis to safely explore the margins to allow for robust modeling of clinical effect versus the electrophysiological risk marker. We also conclude that a carefully conducted SAD study may provide reliable data for effective early strategic decision making ahead of the thorough QT/QTc study.

Recommendations for safety pharmacology evaluations of oligonucleotide-based therapeutics

This document was prepared by the Safety Pharmacology Subcommittee of the Oligonucleotide Safety Working Group (OSWG), a group of industry and regulatory scientists involved in the development and regulation of therapeutic oligonucleotides. The mission of the Subcommittee was to develop scientific recommendations for the industry regarding the appropriate scope and strategies for safety pharmacology evaluations of oligonucleotides (ONs). These recommendations are the consensus opinion of the Subcommittee and do not necessarily reflect the current expectations of regulatory authorities. 1) Safety pharmacology testing, as described in the International Conference on Harmonisation (ICH) S7 guidance, is as applicable to ONs as it is to small molecule drugs and biotherapeutics. 2) Study design considerations for ONs are similar to those for other classes of drugs. In general, as with other therapeutics, studies should evaluate the drug product administered via the clinical route. Species selection should ideally consider relevance of the model with regard to the endpoints of interest, pharmacological responsiveness, and continuity with the nonclinical development program. 3) Evaluation of potential effects in the core battery (cardiovascular, central nervous, and respiratory systems) is recommended. In general: a. In vitro human ether-a-go-go-related gene (hERG) testing does not provide any specific value and is not warranted. b. Emphasis should be placed on in vivo evaluation of cardiovascular function, typically in nonhuman primates (NHPs). c. Due to the low level of concern, neurologic and respiratory function can be assessed concurrently with cardiovascular safety pharmacology evaluation in NHPs, within repeat-dose toxicity studies, or as stand-alone studies. In the latter case, rodents are most commonly used. 4) Other dedicated safety pharmacology studies, beyond the core battery, may have limited value for ONs. Although ONs can accumulate in the kidney and liver, evaluation of functional changes in these organs, as well as gastrointestinal (GI) and unintended "pro-inflammatory" effects, may be best evaluated during repeat-dose toxicity studies. Broad receptor- or ligand-binding profiling has not historically been informative for most ON subclasses, but may have value for investigative purposes.

Drug attrition during pre-clinical and clinical development: understanding and managing drug-induced cardiotoxicity

Cardiovascular toxicity remains a major cause of concern during preclinical and clinical development as well as contributing to post-approval withdrawal of medicines. This issue is particularly relevant for anticancer drugs where, the significant improvement in the life expectancies of patients has dramatically extended the use and duration of drug therapies. Nevertheless, cardiotoxicity is also observed with other classes of drugs, including antibiotics, antidepressants, and antipsychotics. This article summarizes the clinical manifestations of drug-induced cardiotoxicity by various cancer chemotherapies and novel drugs for the treatment of other diseases. Furthermore, it presents on overview of biomarker and imaging techniques for the detection of drug-induced cardiotoxicity. Guidelines for the management of patients exposed to drugs with cardiotoxic potential are presented as well as a checklist for collecting information when a safety signal is observed in clinical trials to more effectively assess the risk of cardiotoxicity and manage patient safety.

Investigation of mechanism of drug-induced cardiac injury and torsades de pointes in cynomolgus monkeys

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Drug candidates must be thoroughly investigated for their potential cardiac side effects. During the course of routine toxicological assessment, the compound RO5657, a CCR5 antagonist, was discovered to have the rare liability of inducing torsades de pointes (polymorphic ventricular arrhythmia) in normal, healthy animals. Studies were conducted to determine the molecular mechanism of this arrhythmia.

EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

Toxicological effects of repeat dosing were assessed in naïve monkeys. Cardiovascular effects were determined in conscious telemetry-implanted monkeys (repeat dosing) and anaesthetized instrumented dogs (single doses). Mechanistic studies were performed in guinea-pig isolated hearts and in cells recombinantly expressing human cardiac channels.

KEY RESULTS

In cynomolgus monkeys, RO5657 caused a low incidence of myocardial degeneration and a greater incidence of ECG abnormalities including prolonged QT/QTc intervals, QRS complex widening and supraventricular tachycardia. In telemetry-implanted monkeys, RO5657 induced arrhythmias, including torsades de pointes and in one instance, degeneration to fatal ventricular fibrillation. RO5657 also depressed both heart rate (HR) and blood pressure (BP), with no histological evidence of myocardial degeneration. In the anaesthetized dog and guinea-pig isolated heart studies, RO5657 induced similar cardiovascular effects. RO5657 also inhibited Kv11.1 and sodium channel currents.

CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS

The molecular mechanism of RO5657 is hypothesized to be due to inhibition of cardiac sodium and Kv11.1 potassium channels. These results indicate that RO5657 is arrhythymogenic due to decreased haemodynamic function (HR/BP), decreased conduction and inhibition of multiple cardiac channels, which precede and are probably the causative factors in the observed myocardial degeneration.

How can we improve our understanding of cardiovascular safety liabilities to develop safer medicines?

Given that cardiovascular safety liabilities remain a major cause of drug attrition during preclinical and clinical development, adverse drug reactions, and post-approval withdrawal of medicines, the Medical Research Council Centre for Drug Safety Science hosted a workshop to discuss current challenges in determining, understanding and addressing 'Cardiovascular Toxicity of Medicines'. This article summarizes the key discussions from the workshop that aimed to address three major questions: (i) what are the key cardiovascular safety liabilities in drug discovery, drug development and clinical practice? (ii) how good are preclinical and clinical strategies for detecting cardiovascular liabilities? and (iii) do we have a mechanistic understanding of these liabilities? It was concluded that in order to understand, address and ultimately reduce cardiovascular safety liabilities of new therapeutic agents there is an urgent need to: • Fully characterize the incidence, prevalence and impact of drug-induced cardiovascular issues at all stages of the drug development process. • Ascertain the predictive value of existing non-clinical models and assays towards the clinical outcome. • Understand the mechanistic basis of cardiovascular liabilities; by addressing areas where it is currently not possible to predict clinical outcome based on preclinical safety data. • Provide scientists in all disciplines with additional skills to enable them to better integrate preclinical and clinical data and to better understand the biological and clinical significance of observed changes. • Develop more appropriate, highly relevant and predictive tools and assays to identify and wherever feasible to eliminate cardiovascular safety liabilities from molecules and wherever appropriate to develop clinically relevant and reliable safety biomarkers.

Innovation in safety pharmacology testing

This issue of the Journal of Pharmacological and Toxicological Methods (JPTM) is themed. It is the eighth in a series, arising from the Annual Safety Pharmacology Society (SPS) meeting. The SPS is now in its 10th year as an independent branch of biological sciences (distinct from pharmacology and toxicology) and is the primary forum for driving advances in safety pharmacology. The theme of the meeting and this journal issue is innovation, and the focus is non-clinical safety assessment of new chemical entity (NCEs). The content is informed by regulatory guidance documents (S7A and S7B) prior to first in human (FIH) studies. The manuscripts cover a broad spectrum of safety pharmacology topics from theory to practice, with interrogation of state-of-the-art techniques, and profiling of methods that are in development for safety assessment. Philosophical and strategic issues are addressed, with consideration of the use of novel methods for population pharmacokinetic (PK) analysis, abuse liability, electrocardiogram (ECG) analysis algorithms, in vitro cardiac slice preparations, human pluripotent stem cells, and a brief discussion regarding the assessment of changes in the QRS complex of the ECG indicative of drug-induced blockade of cardiac sodium channels. Safety pharmacology methods continue to evolve.

A new preclinical biomarker for risk of Torsades de Pointes: drug-induced reduction of the cardiac electromechanical window

Evaluation of new therapeutic agents for their potential to cause QT interval prolongation and drug-induced ventricular arrhythmia, like Torsades de Pointes (TdP), is a critical activity during drug development. The QT interval has been used as a surrogate biomarker to assess ventricular repolarization effects caused by drug-induced blockade of cardiac repolarizing currents, mainly IKr, but is imperfect in predicting proarrhythmia. Evidence suggests that left ventricular mechanical dysfunction may also contribute to ventricular arrhythmias; thus, electrical and mechanical alterations may have a role in drug-induced TdP. The electromechanical window (EMw) represents the time difference between the end of electrical systole (i.e. the QT interval) and the completion of ventricular relaxation (i.e. the QLVPend interval), and appears to be a new potential biomarker for TdP risk. A reduction in the EMw (to negative values) has now been shown to be associated with the onset of TdP in an anaesthetized dog model of long QT1 syndrome. Therefore, the EMw represents a novel indicator of TdP risk that may add predictive value beyond assay of drug-induced QT interval prolongation.

Utility of positive controls in assessing assay sensitivity in ICH S7B and ICH E14 guidance for evaluation of QT/QTc interval prolongation

Positive controls have often been used in nonclinical and clinical cardiovascular safety studies to evaluate the study's assay sensitivity with respect to drug-induced prolongation of the QT interval of the electrocardiogram (ECG). If the study is able to detect such QT prolongation by the control, then a finding of negative QT effect of comparable size for the test drug will constitute evidence that the test drug does not in fact prolong the QT interval by the amount of regulatory concern. Current regulatory guidance regarding QT interval prolongation includes ICH S7B (nonclinical) and ICH E14 (clinical). However, the underlying null hypothesis settings of the two documents are quite different. This paper quantitatively evaluates the utility of positive controls in nonclinical and clinical studies in which a test drug and a positive control are simultaneously assessed in a study. The results show that positive controls, when powered at 80%, can be beneficial in 58% of nonclinical QT studies with Prob(S)=0.8; when powered at 90%, positive controls can be beneficial 73% of clinical QT studies with Prob(S)=0.9, where Prob(S) represents the probability of success with no QT risk at the stage of development.

Value of non-clinical cardiac repolarization assays in supporting the discovery and development of safer medicines

Non-clinical QT-related assays aligned to the pharmaceutical drug discovery and development phases are used in several ways. During the early discovery phases, assays are used for hazard identification and wherever possible for hazard elimination. The data generated enable us to: (i) establish structure-activity relationships and thereby; (ii) influence the medicinal chemistry design and provide tools for effective decision making; and provide structure-activity data for in silico predictive databases; (iii) solve problems earlier; (iv) provide reassurance for compound or project to progress; and (v) refine strategies as scientific and technical knowledge grows. For compounds progressing into pre-clinical development, the 'core battery' QT-related data enable an integrated risk assessment to: (i) fulfil regulatory requirements; (ii) assess the safety and risk-benefit for compound progression to man; (iii) contribute to defining the starting dose during the phase I clinical trials; (iv) influence the design of the phase I clinical trials; (v) identify clinically relevant safety biomarkers; and (vi) contribute to the patient risk management plan. Once a compound progresses into clinical development, QT-related data can be applied in the context of risk management and risk mitigation. The data from 'follow-up' studies can be used to: (i) support regulatory approval; (ii) investigate discrepancies that may have emerged within and/or between non-clinical and clinical data; (iii) understand the mechanism of an undesirable pharmacodynamic effect; (iv) provide reassurance for progression into multiple dosing in humans and/or large-scale clinical trials; and (v) assess drug-drug interactions. Based on emerging data, the integrated risk assessment is then reviewed in this article, and the benefit-risk for compound progression was re-assessed. Project examples are provided to illustrate the impact of non-clinical data to support compound progression throughout the drug discovery and development phases, and regulatory approval.

An introduction to QT interval prolongation and non-clinical approaches to assessing and reducing risk

Owing to its association with Torsades de Pointes, drug-induced QT interval prolongation has been and remains a significant hurdle to the development of safe, effective medicines. Genetic and pharmacological evidence highlighting the pivotal role the human ether-a-go-go-related gene (hERG) channel was a critical step in understanding how to start addressing this issue. It led to the development of hERG assays with the rapid throughput needed for the short timescales required in early drug discovery. The resulting volume of hERG data has fostered in silico models to help chemists design compounds with reduced hERG potency. In early drug discovery, a pragmatic approach based on exceeding a given potency value has been required to decide when a compound is likely to carry a low QT risk, to support its progression to late-stage discovery. At this point, the in vivo efficacy and metabolism characteristics of the potential drug are generally defined, as well its safety profile, which includes usually a dog study to assess QT interval prolongation risk. The hERG and in vivo QT data, combined with the likely indication and the estimated free drug level for efficacy, are put together to assess the risk that the potential drug will prolong QT in man. Further data may be required to refine the risk assessment before making the major investment decisions for full development. The non-clinical data are essential to inform decisions about compound progression and to optimize the design of clinical QT studies.

New Trends in Cancer Therapy: Targeting Ion Channels and Transporters

The expression and activity of different channel types mark and regulate specific stages of cancer establishment and progression. Blocking channel activity impairs the growth of some tumors, both in vitro and in vivo, which opens a new field for pharmaceutical research. However, ion channel blockers may produce serious side effects, such as cardiac arrhythmias. For instance, Kv11.1 (hERG1) channels are aberrantly expressed in several human cancers, in which they control different aspects of the neoplastic cell behaviour. hERG1 blockers tend to inhibit cancer growth. However they also retard the cardiac repolarization, thus lengthening the electrocardiographic QT interval, which can lead to life-threatening ventricular arrhythmias. Several possibilities exist to produce less harmful compounds, such as developing specific drugs that bind hERG1 channels in the open state or disassemble the ion channel/integrin complex which appears to be crucial in certain stages of neoplastic progression. The potential approaches to improve the efficacy and safety of ion channel targeting in oncology include: (1) targeting specific conformational channel states; (2) finding ever more specific inhibitors, including peptide toxins, for channel subtypes mainly expressed in well-identified tumors; (3) using specific ligands to convey traceable or cytotoxic compounds; (4) developing channel blocking antibodies; (5) designing new molecular tools to decrease channel expression in selected cancer types. Similar concepts apply to ion transporters such as the Na⁺/K⁺ pump and the Na⁺/H⁺ exchanger. Pharmacological targeting of these transporters is also currently being considered in anti-neoplastic therapy.

Reducing QT liability and proarrhythmic risk in drug discovery and development

Drug-induced torsades de pointes (TdP), a rare, life-threatening, polymorphic, ventricular tachycardia associated with prolongation of the QT interval, has been the main safety reason for the withdrawal of medicines from clinical use over the last decade. Most often, drugs that prolong the action potential and delay ventricular repolarization do so through blockade of outward (repolarizing) currents, predominantly the rapid delayed rectifying potassium current, I(Kr). While QT interval prolongation is not a safety concern per se, in a small percentage of people, it has been associated with TdP, which either spontaneously terminates or degenerates into ventricular fibrillation. Furthermore, recent data suggest that shortening of the QT interval may also be a new safety issue waiting to surface. This review article summarizes the presentations given at a symposium entitled 'Reducing QT liability and proarrhythmic risk in drug discovery and development', which was part of the Federation of the European Pharmacological Societies congress, Manchester, UK, 13-17 July 2008. The objective of this symposium was to assess the effects of implementing the latest regulatory guidance documents (International Conference on Harmonization S7A/B and E14), as well as new scientific and technical trends on the ability of the pharmaceutical industry to reduce and manage the QT liability and associated potential proarrhythmic risk, and contribute to the discovery and development of safer medicines. This review outlines the key messages from communications presented at this symposium and attempts to highlight some of the key challenges that remain to be addressed.