Survey of the 2009 commercial optical biosensor literature

We took a different approach to reviewing the commercial biosensor literature this year by inviting 22 biosensor users to serve as a review committee. They set the criteria for what to expect in a publication and ultimately decided to use a pass/fail system for selecting which papers to include in this year's reference list. Of the 1514 publications in 2009 that reported using commercially available optical biosensor technology, only 20% passed their cutoff. The most common criticism the reviewers had with the literature was that "the biosensor experiments could have been done better." They selected 10 papers to highlight good experimental technique, data presentation, and unique applications of the technology. This communal review process was educational for everyone involved and one we will not soon forget.

Emerging role of surface plasmon resonance in fragment-based drug discovery

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) offers a method of biophysical fragment screening that is fast, efficient, cost effective and accurate. SPR is increasingly being adopted as a secondary assay to validate fragment hits. Recently, technical advances have resulted in the emergence of SPR as a primary screening methodology for fragment-based drug discovery. Moreover, SPR biosensor assays can be developed for a wide range of proteins, including membrane proteins, such as G-protein-coupled receptors. In this review, we discuss the advantages and limitations of SPR fragment screening including experimental consideration of reducing false positive and false negative rates to a minimum. We discuss how ligand efficiency can be used both as a method to eliminate false positives and to understand which fragments in a library may be a source of false negatives.

Fragment-based screening for inhibitors of PDE4A using enthalpy arrays and X-ray crystallography

Fragment-based screening has typically relied on X-ray or nuclear magnetic resonance methods to identify low-affinity ligands that bind to therapeutic targets. These techniques are expensive in terms of material and time, so it useful to have a higher throughput method to reliably prescreen a fragment library to identify a subset of compounds for structural analysis. Calorimetry provides a label-free method to assay binding and enzymatic activity that is unaffected by the spectroscopic properties of the sample. Conventional microcalorimetry is hampered by requiring large quantities of reagents and long measurement times. Nanocalorimeters can overcome these limitations of conventional isothermal titration calorimetry. Here we have used enthalpy arrays, which are arrays of nanocalorimeters, to perform an enzyme activity-based fragment screen for competitive inhibitors of phosphodiesterase 4A (PDE4A). Several inhibitors with K ( I ) <2 mM were identified and moved to X-ray crystallization trials. Although the co-crystals did not yield high-resolution data, evidence of binding was observed, and the chemical structures of the hits were consistent with motifs of known PDE4 inhibitors. This study shows how array calorimetry can be used as a prescreening method for fragment-based lead discovery with enzyme targets and provides a list of candidate fragments for inhibition of PDE4A.

Progress in the discovery of small-molecule inhibitors of bromodomain--histone interactions

Bromodomains are structurally conserved protein modules present in a large number of chromatin-associated proteins and in many nuclear histone acetyltransferases. The bromodomain functions as an acetyl-lysine binding domain and has been shown to be pivotal in regulating protein-protein interactions in chromatin-mediated cellular gene transcription, cell proliferation, and viral transcriptional activation. Structural analyses of these modules in complex with acetyl-lysine peptide ligands provide insights into the molecular basis for recognition and ligand selectivity within this epigenetic reader family. However, there are significant challenges in configuring assays to identify inhibitors of these proteins. This review focuses on the progress made in developing methods to identify peptidic and small-molecule ligands using biophysical label-free and biochemical approaches. The advantage of each technique and the results reported are summarized, highlighting the potential applicably to other reader domains and the caveats in translation from simple in vitro systems to a biological context.

Selectivity of kinase inhibitor fragments

A kinase-focused screening set of fragments has been assembled and has proved successful for the discovery of ligand-efficient hits against many targets. Here we present some of our general conclusions from this exercise. Notably, we present the first profiling results for literature fragments that have previously been used as starting points for optimization against individual kinases. We consider the importance of screening format and the extent to which selectivity is helpful in selecting fragments for progression. Results are also outlined for fragments targeting the DFG-out conformation and for atypical kinases such as PIM1 and lipid kinases.

Designing a diverse high-quality library for crystallography-based FBDD screening

A well-chosen set of fragments is able to cover a large chemical space using a small number of compounds. The actual size and makeup of the fragment set is dependent on the screening method since each technique has its own practical limits in terms of the number of compounds that can be screened and requirements for compound solubility. In this chapter, an overview of the general requirements for a fragment library is presented for different screening platforms. In the case of the FBDD work at Johnson & Johnson Pharmaceutical Research and Development, L.L.C., our main screening technology is X-ray crystallography. Since every soaked protein crystal needs to be diffracted and a protein structure determined to delineate if a fragment binds, the size of our initial screening library cannot be a rate-limiting factor. For this reason, we have chosen 900 as the appropriate primary fragment library size. To choose the best set, we have developed our own mix of simple property ("Rule of 3") and "bad" substructure filtering. While this gets one a long way in terms of limiting the fragment pool, there are still tens of thousands of compounds to choose from after this initial step. Many of the choices left at this stage are not drug-like, so we have developed an FBDD Score to help select a 900-compound set. The details of this score and the filtering are presented.

Validation of an optical microplate label-free platform in the screening of chemical libraries for direct binding to a nuclear receptor

Optical microplate-based biosensors combine the advantages of label-free detection with industry-standard assay laboratory infrastructure and scalability. A plate-based label-free platform allows the same basic platform to be used to quantify molecular interactions of macromolecules and to screen and characterize drug-like small-molecule interactions. The ligand-binding domain of orphan estrogen-related nuclear receptor-γ (ERRγ) is utilized, as a model system of a challenging type of target, to illustrate the rapid development and utility of a range of biochemical assay formats on these biosensors. Formats in which either the domain, or a peptide derived from its cognate corepressor, RIP140, were immobilized were utilized. The direct binding of small drug molecules to the domain was characterized using immobilized domain. Subsequent addition of peptide distinguished whether compounds acted as either antagonists of peptide binding, or as agonists promoting a ternary complex. The format with peptide immobilized gave a more sensitive procedure for establishing the effect of compounds on the domain-peptide interaction. Using a direct-binding format, a diverse chemical library of 1,408 compounds in DMSO was screened for ability to bind to biosensors coated with ERRγ ligand-binding domain. Hits were then characterized using the other biosensor assay formats. The standard requirements for a full primary screening campaign were fulfilled by the acceptable hit-rate, quality-performance parameters, and throughput of the direct-binding assay format. Such a format allows direct screening of targets, such as orphan receptors, without the requirement for prior knowledge of a validated ligand.

Weak affinity chromatography as a new approach for fragment screening in drug discovery

Fragment-based drug design (FBDD) is currently being implemented in drug discovery, creating a demand for developing efficient techniques for fragment screening. Due to the intrinsic weak or transient binding of fragments (mM-μM in dissociation constant (K(D))) to targets, methods must be sensitive enough to accurately detect and quantify an interaction. This study presents weak affinity chromatography (WAC) as an alternative tool for screening of small fragments. The technology was demonstrated by screening of a selected 23-compound fragment collection of documented binders, mostly amidines, using trypsin and thrombin as model target protease proteins. WAC was proven to be a sensitive, robust, and reproducible technique that also provides information about affinity of a fragment in the range of 1 mM-10 μM. Furthermore, it has potential for high throughput as was evidenced by analyzing mixtures in the range of 10 substances by WAC-MS. The accessibility and flexibility of the technology were shown as fragment screening can be performed on standard HPLC equipment. The technology can further be miniaturized and adapted to the requirements of affinity ranges of the fragment library. All these features of WAC make it a potential method in drug discovery for fragment screening.

Toward high-throughput drug screening on a chip-based parallel affinity separation platform

High-throughput screening of compound libraries, including the study of fragments, has become one of the cornerstones in modern drug discovery research. During this process hits are defined that may be developed into valuable leads and eventually into possible drug candidates. In this paper, we have demonstrated that parallel zonal weak affinity chromatography in microcolumns on a chip offers a possible screening format for weakly binding ligands toward a protein target. We used albumin as a model system because this transport protein is well established as a binder (both weak and strong) for drug substances. Bovine serum albumin was immobilized on microparticulate diolsilica particles and then packed into a 24-channel cartridge, which served as the separation platform. Analysis of the obtained chromatograms yielded information about affinity even in the millimolar range. Employing this approach, thousands of substances can be screened in just a day. We feel confident that zonal affinity chromatography will provide a useful technology in the future for performing high-throughput screening.

Combining biophysical screening and X-ray crystallography for fragment-based drug discovery

Over the past decade, fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) has gained importance for the generation of novel ideas to inspire synthetic chemistry. In order to identify small molecules that bind to a target protein, multiple approaches have been utilized by various groups in the pharmaceutical industry and by academic groups. The combination of fragment screening by biophysical methods and in particular with surface plasmon resonance technologies (SPR) together with the visualization of the binding properties by X-ray crystallography offers a number of benefits. Screening by SPR identifies ligands for a target protein as well as provides an assessment of the binding properties with respect to affinity, stoichiometry, and specificity of the interaction. Despite the huge technology advances of the past years, X-ray crystallography is still a resource-intensive technology, and SPR binding data provides excellent measures to prioritize X-ray experiments and consequently enable a better success rate in obtaining structural information. Information on the chemical structures of fragments binding to a protein can be used to perform similarity searches in compound libraries in order to establish structure-activity relationships as well as to explore particular scaffolds. At Roche we have applied this workflow for a number of targets and the experiences will be outlined in this review.

Introduction to fragment-based drug discovery

Fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) has emerged in the past decade as a powerful tool for discovering drug leads. The approach first identifies starting points: very small molecules (fragments) that are about half the size of typical drugs. These fragments are then expanded or linked together to generate drug leads. Although the origins of the technique date back some 30 years, it was only in the mid-1990s that experimental techniques became sufficiently sensitive and rapid for the concept to be become practical. Since that time, the field has exploded: FBDD has played a role in discovery of at least 18 drugs that have entered the clinic, and practitioners of FBDD can be found throughout the world in both academia and industry. Literally dozens of reviews have been published on various aspects of FBDD or on the field as a whole, as have three books (Jahnke and Erlanson, Fragment-based approaches in drug discovery, 2006; Zartler and Shapiro, Fragment-based drug discovery: a practical approach, 2008; Kuo, Fragment based drug design: tools, practical approaches, and examples, 2011). However, this chapter will assume that the reader is approaching the field with little prior knowledge. It will introduce some of the key concepts, set the stage for the chapters to follow, and demonstrate how X-ray crystallography plays a central role in fragment identification and advancement.

Experimental Validation of a Fragment Library for Lead Discovery Using SPR Biosensor Technology

A new fragment library for lead discovery has been designed and experimentally validated for use in surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensor-based screening. The 930 compounds in the library were selected from 4.6 million commercially available compounds using a series of physicochemical and medicinal chemistry filters. They were screened against 3 prototypical drug targets: HIV-1 protease, thrombin and carbonic anhydrase, and a nontarget: human serum albumin. Compound solubility was not a problem under the conditions used for screening. The high sensitivity of the sensor surfaces allowed the detection of interactions for 35% to 97% of the fragments, depending on the target protein. None of the fragments was promiscuous (i.e., interacted with a stoichiometry ≥5:1 with all 4 proteins), and only 2 compounds dissociated slowly from all 4 proteins. The use of several targets proved valuable since several compounds would have been disqualified from the library on the grounds of promiscuity if fewer target proteins had been used. The experimental procedure allowed an efficient evaluation and exploration of the new fragment library and confirmed that the new library is suitable for SPR biosensor-based screening.

Fragment-Based Screening by Biochemical Assays

Fragment-based screening (FBS) has gained acceptance in the pharmaceutical industry as an attractive approach for the identification of new chemical starting points for drug discovery programs in addition to classical strategies such as high-throughput screening. There is the concern that screening of fragments at high µM concentrations in biochemical assays results in increased false-positive and false-negative rates. Here the authors systematically compare the data quality of FBS obtained by enzyme activity-based fluorescence intensity, fluorescence lifetime, and mobility shift assays with the data quality from surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) methods. The serine protease trypsin and the matrix metalloprotease MMP12 were selected as model systems. For both studies, 352 fragments were selected each. From the data generated, all 3 biochemical protease assay methods can be used for screening of fragments with low false-negative and low false-positive rates, comparable to those achieved with the SPR-based assays. It can also be concluded that only fragments with a solubility higher than the screening concentration determined by means of NMR should be used for FBS purposes. Extrapolated to 10,000 fragments, the biochemical assays speed up the primary FBS process by approximately a factor of 10 and reduce the protease consumption by approximately 10,000-fold compared to NMR protein observation experiments.

Identification and characterization of acidic mammalian chitinase inhibitors

Acidic mammalian chitinase (AMCase) is a member of the glycosyl hydrolase 18 family (EC 3.2.1.14) that has been implicated in the pathophysiology of allergic airway disease such as asthma. Small molecule inhibitors of AMCase were identified using a combination of high-throughput screening, fragment screening, and virtual screening techniques and characterized by enzyme inhibition and NMR and Biacore binding experiments. X-ray structures of the inhibitors in complex with AMCase revealed that the larger more potent HTS hits, e.g. 5-(4-(2-(4-bromophenoxy)ethyl)piperazine-1-yl)-1H-1,2,4-triazol-3-amine 1, spanned from the active site pocket to a hydrophobic pocket. Smaller fragments identified by FBS occupy both these pockets independently and suggest potential strategies for linking fragments. Compound 1 is a 200 nM AMCase inhibitor which reduced AMCase enzymatic activity in the bronchoalveolar lavage fluid in allergen-challenged mice after oral dosing.

[Fragment screening using surface plasmon resonance optical biosensor technology]

A surface plasmon resonance (SPR) optical biosensor is a label-free biophysical device which can detect molecular interaction in real time. SPR is an emerging technology for fragment screening, the first step in fragment-based drug discovery. Low levels of protein consumption and the ability to detect interactions with K(d) as low as mM make this technology particularly attractive. Inherently small SPR responses due to fragment binding had been an issue but, owing to well-established experimental protocols, such responses have become readily detectable. Medium-throughput instruments are now on the market from several manufacturers that enable complete screening of a library with several thousand compounds within a few days. In fragment screening, test compounds are injected at a high concentration because of the low affinity expected for small molecules, making it likely that many false positives arise from non-specific binding to an unrelated part of the target protein. Such false positives have to be eliminated by a well-designed assay cascade so as to select true hits which can then be subjected to X-ray crystallization to obtain detailed structural information. SPR-based direct binding assays have to be developed with a sufficient binding capacity and good reproducibility with a Z'-factor larger than 0.6. In selecting hit candidates from fragment primary screens, the shape of sensorgrams, binding stoichiometry and response level to reference proteins when available must be carefully evaluated. The selected compounds from primary screening need to be further examined in terms of dose-dependence and binding competition against tight binding reference compounds to ensure that they bind to the designated site of the target protein.

Fragment screening by surface plasmon resonance

Fragment-based drug discovery is a validated approach for the discovery of drug candidates. However, the weak affinity of fragment compounds requires highly sensitive biophysical techniques, such as nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) or X-ray crystallography, to identify hits. Thus the advantages of screening small fragment libraries are partly offset by the high cost of biophysical analyses. Here we present a method for biosensor-based fragment screening using surface plasmon resonance (SPR). In order to reduce the false positive detection rate we present a novel method of data analysis that incorporates multiple referencing with ligand efficiency. By implementing all necessary steps for assay design, data analysis and interpretation, SPR-based fragment screening has potential to eliminate all nonspecific (false positive) binders. Therefore, given the advantages of low protein consumption, rapid assay development and kinetic and thermodynamic validation of hits, SPR can be considered as a primary screening technology for fragment-based drug discovery.

Review article: high-throughput affinity-based technologies for small-molecule drug discovery

High-throughput affinity-based technologies are rapidly growing in use as primary screening methods in drug discovery. In this review, their principles and applications are described and their impact on small-molecule drug discovery is evaluated. In general, these technologies can be divided into 2 groups: those that detect binding interactions by measuring changes to the protein target and those that detect bound compounds. Technologies detecting binding interactions by focusing on the protein have limited throughput but can reveal mechanistic information about the binding interaction; technologies detecting bound compounds have very high throughput, some even significantly higher than current high-throughput screening technologies, but offer limited information about the binding interaction. In addition, the appropriate use of affinity-based technologies is discussed. Finally, nanotechnology is predicted to generate a significant impact on the future of affinity-based technologies.