Dose-volume histograms

Pancreas size and volume on computed tomography in normal adults

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to evaluate quantitatively normal pancreatic morphology, size, and volume stratified by age and sex.

METHODS

Adults without known pancreatic disease underwent computed tomography (n = 249) were evaluated by linear pancreatic dimensions, volume determinations (summation of areas), and histograms. A subset was reread to evaluate interreader reliability. Ordinary least squares regression was used to model the average of each measurement as a function of sex and age.

RESULTS

Although increasing age was associated with a moderate decrease in pancreatic volume and in the size of the body and tail, the anteroposterior diameter of the head increased with age up to 71 years. Measurements of the head and total volume were smaller among women, but the body and tail showed no sex difference. Across all measurements, differences due to sex and age were smaller in magnitude than the random variation between subjects. Despite adhering to a detailed protocol, we observed both systematic and random differences between readers in performing the measurements.

CONCLUSIONS

Although size and volume of the normal pancreas in adults measured with multislice computed tomography are smaller among women and those who are older, the anteroposterior diameter of the head increases slightly throughout the majority of the age range.

Quantitative metrics for assessing plan quality

Despite many studies over the last 3 decades that have attempted to explicitly quantify the decision-making process for radiotherapy treatment plan evaluation, judgments of an individual plan's degree of quality are still largely subjective and can show inter- and intra-practitioner variability even if the clinical treatment goals are the same. Several factors conspire to confound the full quantification of treatment plan quality, including uncertainties in dose response of cancerous and normal tissue, the rapid pace of new technology adoption, and the human component of treatment planning. However, new developments in clinical informatics and automation are lowering the bar for developing and implementing quantitative metrics into the treatment planning process. This review discusses general strategies for using quantitative metrics in the treatment planning process and presents a case study in intensity-modulated radiation therapy planning whereby control was established on a variable system via such techniques.

Effect of bismuth breast shielding on radiation dose and image quality in coronary CT angiography

BACKGROUND

Coronary computed tomographic angiography (CCTA) is associated with high radiation dose to the female breasts. Bismuth breast shielding offers the potential to significantly reduce dose to the breasts and nearby organs, but the magnitude of this reduction and its impact on image quality and radiation dose have not been evaluated.

METHODS

Radiation doses from CCTA to critical organs were determined using metal-oxide-semiconductor field-effect transistors positioned in a customized anthropomorphic whole-body dosimetry verification phantom. Image noise and signal were measured in regions of interest (ROIs) including the coronary arteries.

RESULTS

With bismuth shielding, breast radiation dose was reduced 46%-57% depending on breast size and scanning technique, with more moderate dose reduction to the heart, lungs, and esophagus. However, shielding significantly decreased image signal (by 14.6 HU) and contrast (by 28.4 HU), modestly but significantly increased image noise in ROIs in locations of coronary arteries, and decreased contrast-to-noise ratio by 20.9%.

CONCLUSIONS

While bismuth breast shielding can significantly decrease radiation dose to critical organs, it is associated with an increase in image noise, decrease in contrast-to-noise, and changes tissue attenuation characteristics in the location of the coronary arteries.

Evaluation of a cumulative SUV-volume histogram method for parameterizing heterogeneous intratumoural FDG uptake in non-small cell lung cancer PET studies

PURPOSE

Standardized uptake values (SUV) are commonly used for quantification of whole-body [(18)F]fluoro-2-deoxy-D: -glucose (FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) studies. Changes in SUV following therapy, however, only provide a proper measure of response in case of homogeneous FDG uptake in the tumour. The purpose of this study was therefore to implement and characterize a method that enables quantification of heterogeneity in tumour FDG uptake.

METHODS

Cumulative SUV-volume histograms (CSH), describing % of total tumour volume above % threshold of maximum SUV (SUV(max)), were calculated. The area under a CSH curve (AUC) is a quantitative index of tumour uptake heterogeneity, with lower AUC corresponding to higher degrees of heterogeneity. Simulations of homogeneous and heterogeneous responses were performed to assess the value of AUC-CSH for measuring uptake and/or response heterogeneity. In addition, partial volume correction and image denoising was applied prior to calculating AUC-CSH. Finally, the method was applied to a number of human FDG scans.

RESULTS

Partial volume correction and noise reduction improved CSH curves. Both simulations and clinical examples showed that AUC-CSH values corresponded with level of tumour heterogeneity and/or heterogeneity in response. In contrast, this correspondence was not seen with SUV(max) alone. The results indicate that the main advantage of AUC-CSH above other measures, such as 1/COV (coefficient of variation), is the possibility to measure or normalize AUC-CSH in different ways.

CONCLUSION

AUC-CSH might be used as a quantitative index of heterogeneity in tracer uptake. In response monitoring studies it can be used to address heterogeneity in response.

Estimation of delivered dose in radiotherapy: the influence of registration uncertainty

We present a probabilistic framework to estimate the accumulated radiation dose and the corresponding dose uncertainty that is delivered to important anatomical structures, e.g. the primary tumor and healthy surrounding organs, during radiotherapy. The dose uncertainty we report is a direct result of uncertainties in the estimates of the deformation which aligns the daily cone-beam CT images with the planning CT. The accumulated radiation dose is an important measure to monitor during treatment, in particular to see if it significantly deviates from the planned dose which might indicate that either the patient was not properly positioned before treatment or that the anatomy has changed due to the treatment. In the case of the latter, the treatment plan should be adaptively changed to align with the current patient anatomy. We estimate the accumulated dose distribution, and its uncertainty, retrospectively on a dataset acquired during treatment of cancer in the neck and show the dose distributions in the form of dose volume histograms.

Dose-volume histogram quality assurance for linac-based treatment planning systems

Dose–volume histograms provide key information to radiation oncologists when they assess the adequacy of a patient treatment plan in radiation therapy. It is important therefore that all clinically relevant data be accurate. In this article we present the first quality assurance routine involving a direct comparison of planning system results with the results obtained from independent hand calculations. Given a known three-dimensional (3-D) structure such as a parallelepiped, a simple beam arrangement, and known physics beam data, a time-efficient and reproducible method for verifying the accuracy of volumetric statistics (DVH) from a radiation therapy treatment planning system (TPS) can be employed rapidly, satisfying the QA requirements for (TPS) commissioning, upgrades, and annual checks. Using this method, the maximum disagreement was only 1.7% for 6 MV and 1.3% for 18 MV photon energies. The average accuracy was within 0.6% for 6 MV and 0.4% for 18 MV for all depth-dose results. A 2% disagreement was observed with the treatment planning system DVH from defined volume comparison to the known structure dimensions.

Estimate of organ radiation absorbed doses in clinical CT using the radiation treatment planning system

Organ absorbed doses in computed tomography (CT) scans can be measured with anatomical phantoms but not inside the human body. In this study, a straightforward method was investigated to estimate organ doses in clinical CT using the radiation treatment planning system (RTPS) and compared them with experimental results of photoluminescence dosemeters (PLD). In a heterogeneous phantom, the average difference between PLD and RTPS values were -5.0% for the body and 7.1% for the lung. Using CT data, organ doses in 30 clinical cases were then calculated. There was a significant inverse correlation between the calculated values of organ doses and body mass index (BMI, correlation coefficients (r) = -0.69 (whole body), -0.80 (right lung), -0.81 (left lung), -0.76 (spinal cord), -0.74 (vertebra bone), -0.74 (heart), and -0.79 (oesophagus), all p < 0.01). An RTPS can be a simple and useful tool for estimating equivalent doses inside the human body, during whole-body CT scans.

Radiobiological evaluation of the influence of dwell time modulation restriction in HIPO optimized HDR prostate brachytherapy implants

Purpose

One of the issues that a planner is often facing in HDR brachytherapy is the selective existence of high dose volumes around some few dominating dwell positions. If there is no information available about its necessity (e.g. location of a GTV), then it is reasonable to investigate whether this can be avoided. This effect can be eliminated by limiting the free modulation of the dwell times. HIPO, an inverse treatment plan optimization algorithm, offers this option. In treatment plan optimization there are various methods that try to regularize the variation of dose non-uniformity using purely dosimetric measures. However, although these methods can help in finding a good dose distribution they do not provide any information regarding the expected treatment outcome as described by radiobiology based indices.

Material and methods

The quality of 12 clinical HDR brachytherapy implants for prostate utilizing HIPO and modulation restriction (MR) has been compared to alternative plans with HIPO and free modulation (without MR). All common dose-volume indices for the prostate and the organs at risk have been considered together with radiobiological measures. The clinical effectiveness of the different dose distributions was investigated by calculating the response probabilities of the tumors and organs-at-risk (OARs) involved in these prostate cancer cases. The radiobiological models used are the Poisson and the relative seriality models. Furthermore, the complication-free tumor control probability, P₊ and the biologically effective uniform dose (D¯¯) were used for treatment plan evaluation and comparison.

Results

Our results demonstrate that HIPO with a modulation restriction value of 0.1-0.2 delivers high quality plans which are practically equivalent to those achieved with free modulation regarding the clinically used dosimetric indices. In the comparison, many of the dosimetric and radiobiological indices showed significantly different results. The modulation restricted clinical plans demonstrated a lower total dwell time by a mean of 1.4% that was proved to be statistically significant (p = 0.002). The HIPO with MR treatment plans produced a higher P₊ by 0.5%, which stemmed from a better sparing of the OARs by 1.0%.

Conclusions

Both the dosimetric and radiobiological comparison shows that the modulation restricted optimization gives on average similar results with the optimization without modulation restriction in the examined clinical cases. Concluding, based on our results, it appears that the applied dwell time regularization technique is expected to introduce a minor improvement in the effectiveness of the optimized HDR dose distributions.

Dosimetric performance of the new high-definition multileaf collimator for intracranial stereotactic radiosurgery

The objective was to evaluate the performance of a high-definition multileaf collimator (MLC) of 2.5 mm leaf width (MLC2.5) and compare to standard 5 mm leaf width MLC (MLC5) for the treatment of intracranial lesions using dynamic conformal arcs (DCA) technique with a dedicated radiosurgery linear accelerator. Simulated cases of spherical targets were created to study solely the effect of target volume size on the performance of the two MLC systems independent of target shape complexity. In addition, 43 patients previously treated for intracranial lesions in our institution were retrospectively planned using DCA technique with MLC2.5 and MLC5 systems. The gross tumor volume ranged from 0.07 to 40.57 cm3 with an average volume of 5.9 cm3. All treatment parameters were kept the same for both MLC-based plans. The plan evaluation was performed using figures of merits (FOM) for a rapid and objective assessment on the quality of the two treatment plans for MLC2.5 and MLC5. The prescription isodose surface was selected as the greatest isodose surface covering >or= 95% of the target volume and delivering 95% of the prescription dose to 99% of target volume. A Conformity Index (CI) and conformity distance index (CDI) were used to quantifying the dose conformity to a target volume. To assess normal tissue sparing, a normal tissue difference (NTD) was defined as the difference between the volume of normal tissue receiving a certain dose utilizing MLC5 and the volume receiving the same dose using MLC2.5. The CI and normal tissue sparing for the simulated spherical targets were better with the MLC2.5 as compared to MLC5. For the clinical patients, the CI and CDI results indicated that the MLC2.5 provides better treatment conformity than MLC5 even at large target volumes. The CI's range was 1.15 to 2.44 with a median of 1.59 for MLC2.5 compared to 1.60-2.85 with a median of 1.71 for MLC5. Improved normal tissue sparing was also observed for MLC2.5 over MLC5, with the NTD always positive, indicating improvement, and ranging from 0.1 to 8.3 for normal tissue receiving 50% (NTV50), 70% (NTV70) and 90% (NTV90) of the prescription dose. The MLC2.5 has a dosimetric advantage over the MLC5 in Linac-based radiosurgery using DCA method for intracranial lesions, both in treatment conformity and normal tissue sparing when target shape complexity increases.

A computational tool for the efficient analysis of dose-volume histograms from radiation therapy treatment plans

A Histogram Analysis in Radiation Therapy (HART) program was primarily developed to increase the efficiency and accuracy of dose–volume histogram (DVH) analysis of large quantities of patient data in radiation therapy research. The program was written in MATLAB to analyze patient plans exported from the treatment planning system (Pinnacle3) in the American Association of Physicists in Medicine/Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (AAPM/RTOG) format. HART‐computed DVH data was validated against manually extracted data from the planning system for five head and neck cancer patients treated with the intensity‐modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) technique. HART calculated over 4000 parameters from the differential DVH (dDVH) curves for each patient in approximately 10–15 minutes. Manual extraction of this amount of data required 5 to 6 hours. The normalized root mean square deviation (NRMSD) for the HART–extracted DVH outcomes was less than 1%, or within 0.5% distance‐to‐agreement (DTA). This tool is supported with various user‐friendly options and graphical displays. Additional features include optimal polynomial modeling of DVH curves for organs, treatment plan indices (TPI) evaluation, plan‐specific outcome analysis (POA), and spatial DVH (zDVH) and dose surface histogram (DSH) analyses, respectively. HART is freely available to the radiation oncology community.

PACS numbers: 87.53.‐j; 87.53.Tf; 87.53.Xd.

The effect of interfraction prostate motion on IMRT plans: a dose-volume histogram analysis using a Gaussian error function model

The Gaussian error function model, containing pairs of error and complementary error functions, was used to carry out cumulative dose-volume histogram (cDVH) analysis on prostate intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) plans with interfraction prostate motion. Cumulative DVHs for clinical target volumes (CTVs) shifted in the anterior-posterior directions based on a 7-beam IMRT plan were calculated and modeled using the Pinnacle3 treatment planning system and a Gaussian error function, respectively. As the parameters in the error function model, namely, a, b and c were related to the shape of the cDVH curve, evaluation of cDVHs corresponding to the prostate motion based on the model parameters becomes possible as demonstrated in this study. It was found that deviations of the cDVH for the CTV were significant, when the CTV-planning target volume (PTV) margin was underestimated in the anterior-posterior directions, particularly in the posterior direction for a patient with relatively small prostate volume (39 cm3). Analysis of the cDVH for the CTV shifting in the anterior-posterior directions using the error function model showed that parameters a1,2, which were related to the maximum relative volume of the cDVH, changed symmetrically when the prostate was shifted in the anterior and posterior directions. This change was more significant for the larger prostate. For parameters b related to the slope of the cDVH, b1,2 changed symmetrically from the isocenter, when the CTV was within the PTV. This was different from parameters c (c1,2 are related to the maximum dose of the cDVH), which did not vary significantly with the prostate motion in the anterior-posterior directions and prostate volume. Using the patient data, this analysis validates the error function model, and further verified the clinical application of this mathematical model on treatment plan evaluations.

Exploring feature-based approaches in PET images for predicting cancer treatment outcomes

Accumulating evidence suggests that characteristics of pre-treatment FDG-PET could be used as prognostic factors to predict outcomes in different cancer sites. Current risk analyses are limited to visual assessment or direct uptake value measurements. We are investigating intensity-volume histogram metrics and shape and texture features extracted from PET images to predict patient's response to treatment. These approaches were demonstrated using datasets from cervix and head and neck cancers, where AUC of 0.76 and 1.0 were achieved, respectively. The preliminary results suggest that the proposed approaches could potentially provide better tools and discriminant power for utilizing functional imaging in clinical prognosis.

Dosimetric and anatomic indicators of late rectal toxicity after high-dose intensity modulated radiation therapy for prostate cancer

We seek to identify dosimetric and anatomic indicators of late rectal toxicity in prostate cancer patients treated with intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT). Data from 49 patients sampled from 698 patients treated for clinically localized prostate cancer at the Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center with IMRT to a dose of 81 Gy were analyzed. The end point of the study was late Grade 2 or worse rectal toxicity within 30 months of treatment. Dosimetric analysis was performed on the rectum surface in three dimensions and on two-dimensional dose maps obtained by flattening the rectum surface using a conformal mapping procedure. Several parameters including the percentage and absolute surface area of the rectum irradiated, mean dose as a function of location on the rectum, planning target volume (PTV) size and rectum size were analyzed for correlation to toxicity. Significance was set at p < 0.05 for a two-sided t-test. Correlation between absolute areas irradiated and toxicity was observed on both the rectum surface and flattened rectum. Patients with toxicity also received a significantly higher mean dose to the superior 25% of the rectum surface and 15% of the flattened rectum. PTV volume, PTV height, rectum surface area and average cross-sectional area were significantly larger in patients with toxicity. The conformal mapping procedure has potential utility for evaluating dose to the rectum and risk of toxicity. Late rectal toxicity was related to the irradiation of the upper part of the rectum and also to the absolute area irradiated, PTV size, and rectum size on the planning computed tomography (CT) scan.

Impact of PET on radiation therapy planning in lung cancer

The superiority of PET imaging to structural imaging in many cancers is rapidly transforming the practice of radiotherapy planning, especially in lung cancer. Although most lung cancers are potentially treatable with radiation therapy, only patients who have truly locoregionally confined disease can be cured by this modality. PET improves selection for high-dose radiation therapy by excluding many patients who have incurable distant metastasis or extensive locoregional spread. In those patients suitable for definitive treatment, PET can help shape the treatment fields to avoid geographic miss and minimize unnecessary irradiation of normal tissues. PET will allow for more accurately targeted dose escalation studies in the future and could potentially lead to better long-term survival.

Design and development of motorized multileaf collimator for telecobalt unit

A manual multileaf collimator developed for telecobalt unit was motorized to accomplish the easy movement of the leaves. The required field shaping using MLC could be achieved by either using template or display. The beam characteristics were investigated and then compared with those of customized blocks. The maximum interleaf leakage and the percentage of transmission measured at the depth of maximum ionization (0.5cm) were found to be 2.7% and 2.4%, respectively. The field shaping performed by the MLC was verified using film dosimetry. The comparative study of treatment plans of 3DCRT and IMRT between (60)Co beam and 6 MV beams was carried out. This MLC could be used as a substitute for conventional blocks in static fields, there by eliminating the effort and cost of fabricating customized blocks, the need for storage space for blocks and other practical difficulties during the process of the block making. It is also demonstrated that if a provision for IMRT delivery with MLC for (60)Co is made, could be a cost effective alternative to IMRT with 6 MV beam.

Incorporating PET information in radiation therapy planning

PET scanning, because of its impressive sensitivity and accuracy, is being incorporated into the standard staging workup for many cancers. These include lung cancer, lymphomas, head and neck cancers, and oesophageal cancers. PET often provides incremental information about the patient’s disease status, adding to the data obtained from structural imaging methods, such as, CT scan or MRI. PET commonly upstages patients into more advanced disease categories. Incorporation of PET information into the radiotherapy planning process has the potential to reduce the risks of geographic miss and can help minimise unnecessary irradiation of normal tissues. The best means of incorporating PET information into radiotherapy planning is uncertain, and considerable effort is being expended in this area of research.

Two-phase computerized planning of cryosurgery using bubble-packing and force-field analogy

BACKGROUND

Cryosurgery is the destruction of undesired tissues by freezing, as in prostate cryosurgery, for example. Minimally invasive cryosurgery is currently performed by means of an array of cryoprobes, each in the shape of a long hypodermic needle. The optimal arrangement of the cryoprobes, which is known to have a dramatic effect on the quality of the cryoprocedure, remains an art held by the cryosurgeon, based on the cryosurgeon's experience and "rules of thumb." An automated computerized technique for cryosurgery planning is the subject matter of the current paper, in an effort to improve the quality of cryosurgery.

METHOD OF APPROACH

A two-phase optimization method is proposed for this purpose, based on two previous and independent developments by this research team. Phase I is based on a bubble-packing method, previously used as an efficient method for finite element meshing. Phase II is based on a force-field analogy method, which has proven to be robust at the expense of a typically long runtime.

RESULTS

As a proof-of-concept, results are demonstrated on a two-dimensional case of a prostate cross section. The major contribution of this study is to affirm that in many instances cryosurgery planning can be performed without extremely expensive simulations of bioheat transfer, achieved in Phase I.

CONCLUSIONS

This new method of planning has proven to reduce planning runtime from hours to minutes, making automated planning practical in a clinical time frame.

Gamma histograms for radiotherapy plan evaluation

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The technique known as the 'gamma evaluation method' incorporates pass-fail criteria for both distance-to-agreement and dose difference analysis of 3D dose distributions and provides a numerical index (gamma) as a measure of the agreement between two datasets. As the gamma evaluation index is being adopted in more centres as part of treatment plan verification procedures for 2D and 3D dose maps, the development of methods capable of encapsulating the information provided by this technique is recommended.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In this work the concept of gamma index was extended to create gamma histograms (GH) in order to provide a measure of the agreement between two datasets in two or three dimensions. Gamma area histogram (GAH) and gamma volume histogram (GVH) graphs were produced using one or more 2D gamma maps generated for each slice of the irradiated volume. GHs were calculated for IMRT plans, evaluating the 3D dose distribution from a commercial treatment planning system (TPS) compared to a Monte Carlo (MC) calculation used as reference dataset.

RESULTS

The extent of local anatomical inhomogenities in the plans under consideration was strongly correlated with the level of difference between reference and evaluated calculations. GHs provided an immediate visual representation of the proportion of the treated volume that fulfilled the gamma criterion and offered a concise method for comparative numerical evaluation of dose distributions.

CONCLUSIONS

We have introduced the concept of GHs and investigated its applications to the evaluation and verification of IMRT plans. The gamma histogram concept set out in this paper can provide a valuable technique for quantitative comparison of dose distributions and could be applied as a tool for the quality assurance of treatment planning systems.

Decomposition analysis of differential dose volume histograms

Dose volume histograms are a common tool to assess the value of a treatment plan for various forms of radiation therapy treatment. The purpose of this work is to introduce, validate, and apply a set of tools to analyze differential dose volume histograms by decomposing them into physically and clinically meaningful normal distributions. A weighted sum of the decomposed normal distributions (e.g., weighted dose) is proposed as a new measure of target dose, rather than the more unstable point dose. The method and its theory are presented and validated using simulated distributions. Additional validation is performed by analyzing simple four field box techniques encompassing a predefined target, using different treatment energies inside a water phantom. Furthermore, two clinical situations are analyzed using this methodology to illustrate practical usefulness. A comparison of a treatment plan for a breast patient using a tangential field setup with wedges is compared to a comparable geometry using dose compensators. Finally, a normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) calculation is refined using this decomposition. The NTCP calculation is performed on a liver as organ at risk in a treatment of a mesothelioma patient with involvement of the right lung. The comparison of the wedged breast treatment versus the compensator technique yields comparable classical dose parameters (e.g., conformity index approximately = 1 and equal dose at the ICRU dose point). The methodology proposed here shows a 4% difference in weighted dose outlining the difference in treatment using a single parameter instead of at least two in a classical analysis (e.g., mean dose, and maximal dose, or total dose variance). NTCP-calculations for the mesothelioma case are generated automatically and show a 3% decrease with respect to the classical calculation. The decrease is slightly dependant on the fractionation and on the alpha/beta-value utilized. In conclusion, this method is able to distinguish clinically important differences between treatment plans using a single parameter. This methodology shows promise as an objective tool for analyzing NTCP and doses in larger studies, as the only information needed is the dose volume histogram.

More optimal dose distributions for moving lung tumours: A planning study

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Target volumes for moving lung tumours encompass the full range of respiratory motion, increasing the risk of lung complications. Intensity modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) allows for more precise dose distributions. Distributions corresponding to the probability density function (PDF) of tumour motion may better spare lung yet deliver adequate target dose. The planning study purpose is to compare and evaluate different dose distributions on a moving lung tumour: (A) conformal RT (CRT) encompassing the full range of tumour motion, (B) CRT encompassing the modal tumour position only, and (C) an IMRT technique where the dose delivered corresponds to the tumour PDF.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A 5 cm diameter spherical target within a rectangular lung equivalent phantom was treated using a parallel-opposed pair technique with a 1.5 cm margin around the tumour (in the beam's eye view). Asymmetrical sinusoidal (superior-inferior) target movement (peak-trough = 3 cm) was simulated for different dose distributions (prescription dose = 60 Gy). Equivalent uniform dose (EUD) for the tumour and normal tissue complication probabilities (NTCPs) for radiation pneumonitis were evaluated.

RESULTS

The EUDs were 60.0, 48.5, and 57.9 Gy while the NTCPs were 5, 1, and 3% for cases A, B, and C, respectively (assuming survival fraction, SF(2)(Gy) = 0.5).

CONCLUSIONS

Since these results rely on unvalidated radiobiologic models, they must be interpreted cautiously. However, more optimized dose distributions for moving lung targets appear feasible and can reduce lung complications with only a negligible impact on the expected EUD and, thus, deserve further study.

Comparison of simulator-CT versus simulator fluoroscopy versus surface marking based radiation treatment planning: A prospective study by three-dimensional evaluation

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Field placement for Radiation Treatment Planning can be done based on the surface markings or simulator fluoroscopy or simulator with CT facilities. A prospective study was carried out to compare these three techniques of radiation treatment planning to quantitatively find out the difference in normal tissue dosages and target volume coverage in the three groups after three-dimensional evaluation.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The CT scans of 30 patients in the treatment position, taken on a Shimadzu SCT-3000 TF scanner at 1cm intervals, were transferred to Theraplan-500 three-dimensional radiation treatment planning computer. The normal tissues and target volumes (GTV and CTV) were outlined on all the CT slices as per (ICRU) Report no. 50. Three types of radiation treatment planning was done sequentially: Plan I-based on the surface markings alone, Plan II-based on simulator-fluoroscopy, and Plan III-based on Simulator-CT.

RESULTS

The mean dose to 95% of the clinical target volume (D95) was increased by 4.4 and 6.4% by Plans II and III as compared with Plan I. The mean dose to 3/3rd (D(3/3)) to all the critical organs was decreased by 6.6 and 8.4% by Plans II and III as compared to Plan I. The mean time, in simulator room, for field placement for Plans I-III was 6.2, 14.6 and 44 min, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Thus for adequate coverage of target volumes and sparing normal tissues, Simulator-CT based radiation treatment planning is the best method of radiation treatment planning though it is more time consuming.

Radiotherapeutic techniques for prostate cancer, dose escalation and brachytherapy

There is evidence to confirm a dose-response relationship in prostate cancer. The relative benefit is dependent on the clinical prognostic risk factors (T stage, Gleason score and presenting prostate-specific antigen [PSA]) being more favourable for intermediate-risk patients. Refinement of prognostic groups and clinical threshold parameters is ongoing. Escalation of dose in prostate radiotherapy using conventional techniques is limited by rectal tolerance. Substantial advances have been made in radiotherapy practice, such as the development of conformal radiotherapy (CFRT) and intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT). Randomised data support the value of CFRT in reducing rectal toxicity. IMRT can permit higher-dose escalation while still respecting known rectal tolerance thresholds. Brachytherapy is a recognised alternative for low-risk prostate cancer subgroups. New radiotherapeutic strategies for prostate cancer include pelvic nodal irradiation, exploiting the presumed low alpha/beta ratio in prostate cancer for hypofractionation and combining external beam with high-dose-rate brachytherapy boosts. New image-guided methodologies will enhance the therapeutic ratio of any radiotherapy technique or dose escalation programme by enabling more reliable and accurate treatment delivery for improved patient outcomes.

Use of photon fields with noncoincident isocenters to improve homogeneity of dose distribution

To compare changes in dose distribution in irregularly shaped volumes treated using fields with noncoincident isocenters compared with fields with coincident isocenters. The hypothesis was that use of fields with noncoincident isocenters would result in improved homogeneity of dose distribution. We chose to test the hypothesis in canine nasal tumors because of the increased dorsoventral thickness of the caudal compared with the rostral nasal cavity. Computed tomography images from eight dogs with nasal tumors were selected. A tissue-contouring program was used to outline contours, including the mandible as a normal tissue structure and the planning target volume (PTV), divided into a rostral and caudal volume. A traditional computerized treatment plan consisting of two parallel-opposed fields was constructed for each dog. A second treatment plan using a third caudally located field having a different isocenter was constructed for comparison. Dose-volume histograms were generated and compared for each contoured structure in both plans. In all dogs the use of noncoincident fields resulted in increased dose to the ethmoid region through the caudal field. Minimum dose in the caudal tumor PTV increased as well. At the same time, dose delivered to the mandible, prone to develop significant side effects, was lower in all dogs with the use of noncoincident fields, as it was possible to reduce the dose delivered from the ventral field. Use of photon fields with noncoincident isocenters can improve the dose distribution in irregularly shaped volumes in comparison with fields with coincident isocenters. Improved tumor dose distribution was achieved with the addition of a smaller field having a different isocenter.

Irradiation of the inguinal lymph nodes in patients of differing body habitus: A comparison of techniques and resulting normal tissue complication probabilities

The treatment of the inguinal lymph nodes with radiotherapy is strongly influenced by the body habitus of the patient. The effect of 7 radiotherapy techniques on femoral head doses was studied. Three female patients of differing body habitus (ectomorph, mesomorph, endomorph) were selected. Radiation fields included the pelvis and contiguous inguinal regions and were representative of fields used in the treatment of cancers of the lower pelvis. Seven treatment techniques were compared. In the ectomorph and mesomorph, normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) for the femoral heads was lowest with use of anteroposterior (AP) and modified posteroanterior (PA) field with inguinal electron field supplements (technique 1). In the endomorph, NTCP was lowest with use of AP and modified PA field without electron field supplements (technique 2) or a 4-field approach (technique 6). Technique 1 for ectomorphs and mesomorphs and techniques 2 and 6 for endomorphs were optimal techniques for providing relatively homogeneous dose distributions within the target area while minimizing the dose to the femoral heads.

Simultaneous optimization of beam orientations, wedge filters and field weights for inverse planning with anatomy-based MLC fields

As an alternative between manual planning and beamlet-based IMRT, we have developed an optimization system for inverse planning with anatomy-based MLC fields. In this system, named Ballista, the orientation (table and gantry), the wedge filter and the field weights are simultaneously optimized for every beam. An interesting feature is that the system is coupled to Pinnacle3 by means of the PinnComm interface, and uses its convolution dose calculation engine. A fully automatic MLC segmentation algorithm is also included. The plan evaluation is based on a quasi-random sampling and on a quadratic objective function with penalty-like constraints. For efficiency, optimal wedge angles and wedge orientations are determined using the concept of the super-omni wedge. A bound-constrained quasi-Newton algorithm performs field weight optimization, while a fast simulated annealing algorithm selects the optimal beam orientations. Moreover, in order to generate directly deliverable plans, the following practical considerations have been incorporated in the system: collision between the gantry and the table as well as avoidance of the radio-opaque elements of a table top. We illustrate the performance of the new system on two patients. In a rhabdomyosarcoma case, the system generated plans improving both the target coverage and the sparing of the parotide, as compared to a manually designed plan. In the second case presented, the system successfully produced an adequate plan for the treatment of the prostate while avoiding both hip prostheses. For the many cases where full IMRT may not be necessary, the system efficiently generates satisfactory plans meeting the clinical objectives, while keeping the treatment verification much simpler.

Automatic generation of anatomy-based MLC fields in aperture-based IMRT

We have developed an algorithm to automatically generate anatomy-based MLC fields. For each beam, a first field is adjusted to the projection of the target in a beam's eye view, allowing subsequent fields to be derived from this conformal field by removing the overlapping surface of each organ at risk, respectively. The projections are based on a surface sampling of the anatomical structures. On top of the MLC mechanical constraints, verification constraints are imposed on the MLC segments, in order to get reliable dosimetry using a commercial dose calculation engine. Thus, in each direction, the aperture's cross-section must be greater than a specified threshold, in our case 2 cm. Furthermore, junctions are not tolerated in order to avoid underdosage, for instance from the tongue-and-groove effect. The use of such MLC fields simplifies the verification process. The performance of the algorithm is illustrated for head and neck, thorax and prostate cases. Only a fraction of a second of CPU time is required to perform the segmentation for each beam.

A conceptual model integrating spatial information to assess target volume coverage for IMRT treatment planning

PURPOSE

We propose a model that integrates the spatial location of each voxel within a clinical target volume (CTV) to differentiate the merit of intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) plans with similar dose-volume histogram (DVH). This conceptual model is based on the hypothesis that various subregions within a given CTV that may carry different degree of risk in containing microscopic disease.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We hypothesize that a correlation between the probability of microscopic tumor extension and the risk of lymph node metastasis of a particular voxel point within CTV can be inferred based on its distance from the surface of radiographically evident gross disease. A preliminary observation was gathered from existing clinicopathologic data, and, based on these observations, a conceptual model for exponential-decay microscopic-extension probability function around primary tumor and linear function parameters relating the likelihood of lymph node metastasis to the distance from primary tumor was proposed. This model was generated to provide scoring functions to examine the merit of IMRT plans. To test the feasibility of this model, we generated two IMRT plans with similar and clinically acceptable DVH-based CTV coverage. Planning data were transferred to a data analysis software package (Matlab, The Mathworks Inc.). A 3D scoring function was calculated for each voxel inside the CTV. The adequacy of target coverage was evaluated by several novel approaches: 2D dose-volume scoring-function histograms (DVSH), the integral probability of relative residual tumor burden (RRTB), and tumor control probabilities (TCP) employing the scoring function as a pseudo-clonogen density distribution.

RESULTS

Incorporating parameters for the risk of containing microscopic disease in each voxel into the scoring function algorithm, 2D DVSHs, RRTBs, integral RRTBs, and TCPs were computed. On each axial image, an RRTB map could locate the regions at greatest risk. These scoring functions were able to differentiate the merit of CTV coverage of clinically different IMRT plans but having very similar DVHs; one with cold spots centrally located over the gross tumor, and the other with more acceptable cold spots on the periphery of the CTV further away from the gross tumor volume.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrated the feasibility and potential utility of an IMRT scoring method derived from this conceptual modeling approach. These methods are capable of ranking treatment plans with similar DVH profiles but different underdosed regions within the target. We will examine the accuracy of model parameters by performing tumor-specific image-pathologic correlation studies. Upon validation of these parameters, incorporating this scoring function model into plan optimization may have the potential to avoid underdosing subvolumes within CTV that harbor a higher likelihood of microscopic disease.

Biological-effective versus conventional dose volume histograms correlated with late genitourinary and gastrointestinal toxicity after external beam radiotherapy for prostate cancer: a matched pair analysis

BACKGROUND

To determine whether the dose-volume histograms (DVH's) for the rectum and bladder constructed using biological-effective dose (BED-DVH's) better correlate with late gastrointestinal (GI) and genitourinary (GU) toxicity after treatment with external beam radiotherapy for prostate cancer than conventional DVH's (C-DVH's).

METHODS

The charts of 190 patients treated with external beam radiotherapy with a minimum follow-up of 2 years were reviewed. Six patients (3.2%) were found to have RTOG grade 3 GI toxicity, and similarly 6 patients (3.2%) were found to have RTOG grade 3 GU toxicity. Average late C-DVH's and BED-DVH's of the bladder and rectum were computed for these patients as well as for matched-pair control patients. For each matched pair the following measures of normalized difference in the DVH's were computed: (a) deltaAUC = (Area Under Curve [AUC] in grade 3 patient--AUC in grade 0 patient)/(AUC in grade 0 patient) and (b) deltaV60 = (Percent volume receiving = 60 Gy [V60] in grade 3 patient--V60 in grade 0 patient)/(V60 in grade 0 patient).

RESULTS

As expected, the grade 3 curve is to the right of and above the grade 0 curve for all four sets of average DVH's--suggesting that both the C-DVH and the BED-DVH can be used for predicting late toxicity. deltaAUC was higher for the BED-DVH's than for the C-DVH's--0.27 vs 0.23 (p = 0.036) for the rectum and 0.24 vs 0.20 (p = 0.065) for the bladder. deltaV60 was also higher for the BED-DVH's than for the C-DVH's--2.73 vs 1.49 for the rectum (p = 0.021) and 1.64 vs 0.71 (p = 0.021) for the bladder.

CONCLUSIONS

When considering well-established dosimetric endpoints used in evaluating treatment plans, BED-DVH's for the rectum and bladder correlate better with late toxicity than C-DVH's and should be considered when attempting to minimize late GI and GU toxicity after external beam radiotherapy for prostate cancer.

Analysis of factors predictive of success or complications in arteriovenous malformation radiosurgery

OBJECTIVE

This study was undertaken to determine which factors were statistically predictive of radiological and clinical outcomes in the radiosurgical treatment of arteriovenous malformations (AVMs).

METHODS

The computerized dosimetric and clinical data for 269 patients were reviewed. The AVM nidus was hand-contoured on successive enhanced computed tomographic slices through the nidus, to allow detailed determinations of nidus volume, target miss, normal brain tissue treated, dose conformality, and dose gradient. In addition, a number of patient and treatment factors, including Spetzler-Martin grade, presenting symptoms, dose, number of isocenters, radiological outcome, and clinical outcome, were subjected to multivariate analysis.

RESULTS

Two hundred twenty-five patients were treated with radiosurgery for the first time, and 44 patients underwent radiosurgical retreatment. One hundred forty-three patients had AVMs located in or near "eloquent" brain areas and 126 patients did not. Seventy patients demonstrated preoperative neurological findings related to the AVM and 199 did not. Twenty-six patients had previously undergone endovascular treatment and 10 patients had previously undergone surgical treatment of their AVMs. Of the 269 patients studied, 228 experienced no complication, 10 (3.7%) experienced a transient radiation-induced complication, 3 (1%) experienced a permanent radiation-induced complication, and 28 (10%) experienced posttreatment hemorrhage.

CONCLUSION

None of the analyzed factors was predictive of hemorrhage after radiosurgery in this study. The 12-Gy volume was predictive of permanent radiation-induced complications. Eloquent AVM location and 12-Gy volume were correlated with the occurrence of transient radiation-induced complications. Better conformality was correlated with a reduced incidence of transient complications. Lower Spetzler-Martin grades, higher doses, and steeper dose gradients were correlated with radiological success.

Radiotherapy alone in technically operable, medically inoperable, early-stage (I/II) non-small-cell lung cancer

PURPOSE

To investigate the effectiveness of high-dose, curative radiotherapy (RT) given alone in technically operable, but medically inoperable, patients with early-stage (I-II) non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Computerized and manual searches were done to identify published reports dealing with curative RT for NSCLC. Relevant studies were identified and the information provided therein was extracted regarding patient and treatment characteristics, treatment outcome, and various pretreatment and treatment-related factors influencing outcome, as well as toxicity and quality-of-life issues.

RESULTS

Although a large variation of pretreatment and treatment characteristics was noted in the available studies, a median survival time of >30 months and a 5-year survival rate of up to 30% had been achieved. Accumulated experience seems to suggest that doses of at least 65 Gy with standard fractionation, or its equivalent when altered fractionation is used, are necessary for control of NSCLC. Smaller tumors seem to have a favorable prognosis, and the issue of elective nodal RT continues to be controversial. Analyses of patterns of failure have clearly identified local failure as the predominant pattern. Although a number of potential pretreatment patient- and tumor-related prognostic factors have been examined, none has been shown to clearly influence survival. Toxicity was usually low, but very high doses (e.g., 80 Gy) given with a conventional approach may carry a risk of an excessive rate of side effects.

CONCLUSION

High-dose, curative RT is an effective treatment modality in technically operable, but medically inoperable, patients with early-stage NSCLC.

Future directions for cryosurgery computer treatment planning

Computer treatment planning for cryosurgery is an area of research and development that will greatly assist the practicing physician and will promote improved quality assurance for clinical procedures. Good planning and precision image-guided treatment delivery are complementary in achieving an optimal treatment outcome. State-of-the-art cryosurgery treatment planning systems are at an early stage of development in comparison with radiation treatment planning systems for external beams. Using 30 years of progress in the area of radiation treatment planning as a guide, this article presents a summary of the avenues for research and development in cryosurgery treatment planning that are likely to accelerate the practical application of precision cryosurgery to a broad spectrum of anatomical sites. Emphasis is placed on prostate cryosurgery, imaging techniques, and recommendations for manufacturers of these systems. Optimization of the clinical procedure in the planning stage using mathematical algorithms to define the positioning and operation of cryoprobes is discussed.

Comparison of methods for calculating rectal dose after (125)I prostate brachytherapy implants

PURPOSE

To compare several different methods of calculating the rectal dose and examine how accurately they represent rectal dose surface area measurements and, also, their practicality for routine use.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

This study comprised 55 patients, randomly selected from 295 prostate brachytherapy patients implanted at the Vancouver Cancer Center between 1998 and 2000. All implants used a nonuniform loading of 0.33 mCi (NIST-99) 125I seeds and a prescribed dose of 144 Gy. Pelvic CT scans were obtained for each patient approximately 30 days after implantation. For the purposes of calculating the rectal dose, several structures were contoured on the CT images: (1) a 1-mm-thick anterior rectal wall, (2) the anterior half rectum, and (3) the whole rectum. Point doses were also obtained along the anterior rectal surface. The thin wall contour provided a surrogate for a dose-surface histogram (DSH) and was our reference standard rectal dose measurement. Alternate rectal dose measurements (volume, surface area, and length of rectum receiving a dose of interest [DOI] of > or =144 Gy and 216 Gy, as well as point dose measures) were calculated using several methods (VariSeed software) and compared with the surrogate DSH measure (SA(DOI)).

RESULTS

The best correlation with SA(144 Gy) was the dose volumes (whole or anterior half rectum) (R = 0.949). The length of rectum receiving > or =144 Gy also correlated well with SA(144 Gy) (R > or =0.898). Point dose measures, such as the average and maximal anterior dose, correlated poorly with SA(144 Gy) (R < or =0.649). The 216-Gy measurements supported these results. In addition, dose-volume measurements were the most practical (approximately 6 min/patient), with our surrogate DSH the least practical (approximately 20 min/patient).

CONCLUSION

Dose-volume measurements for the whole or anterior half rectum, because they were the most practical measures and best represented the DSH measurements, should be considered a standard method of reporting the rectal dose when calculating the DSH is not practical. Average or maximal anterior rectal doses are not reliable indicators of surface area dosimetry.

Inclusion of geometric uncertainties in treatment plan evaluation

PURPOSE

To correctly evaluate realistic treatment plans in terms of absorbed dose to the clinical target volume (CTV), equivalent uniform dose (EUD), and tumor control probability (TCP) in the presence of execution (random) and preparation (systematic) geometric errors.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The dose matrix is blurred with all execution errors to estimate the total dose distribution of all fractions. To include preparation errors, the CTV is randomly displaced (and optionally rotated) many times with respect to its planned position while computing the dose, EUD, and TCP for the CTV using the blurred dose matrix. Probability distributions of these parameters are computed by combining the results with the probability of each particular preparation error. We verified the method by comparing it with an analytic solution. Next, idealized and realistic prostate plans were tested with varying margins and varying execution and preparation error levels.

RESULTS

Probability levels for the minimum dose, computed with the new method, are within 1% of the analytic solution. The impact of rotations depends strongly on the CTV shape. A margin of 10 mm between the CTV and planning target volume is adequate for three-field prostate treatments given the accuracy level in our department; i.e., the TCP in a population of patients, TCP(pop), is reduced by less than 1% due to geometric errors. When reducing the margin to 6 mm, the dose must be increased from 80 to 87 Gy to maintain the same TCP(pop). Only in regions with a high-dose gradient does such a margin reduction lead to a decrease in normal tissue dose for the same TCP(pop). Based on a rough correspondence of 84% minimum dose with 98% EUD, a margin recipe was defined. To give 90% of patients at least 98% EUD, the planning target volume margin must be approximately 2.5 Sigma + 0.7 sigma - 3 mm, where Sigma and sigma are the combined standard deviations of the preparation and execution errors. This recipe corresponds accurately with 1% TCP(pop) loss for prostate plans with clinically reasonable values of Sigma and sigma.

CONCLUSION

The new method computes in a few minutes the influence of geometric errors on the statistics of target dose and TCP(pop) in clinical treatment plans. Too small margins lead to a significant loss of TCP(pop) that is difficult to compensate for by dose escalation.

Vascular morphometric changes after radioactive stent implantation: a dose-response analysis

OBJECTIVES

The goal of this study was to evaluate the dose-dependency of morphometric changes in the coronary arterial wall after radioactive stenting.

BACKGROUND

Radioactive stents have been found to reduce intrastent intimal hyperplasia (IIH) but lead to a characteristic type of restenosis occurring predominantly at the stent edges.

METHODS

Fifteen patients underwent intravascular ultrasound (IVUS) examination after implantation of a P-32 radioactive stent and at the six-month follow-up. The post-stent IVUS measurements on seven predefined locations of each lesion were subjected to a computer algorithm for the development of dose-volume histograms (DVH). Thus, we derived the radiation doses delivered to at least 10% and 90% of the adventitia (DV10, DV90). The IIH and vascular remodeling at follow-up were correlated with the doses in each segment.

RESULTS

The IIH was most pronounced at the stent edges and lowest in the stent-body, whereas we detected a significant expansive remodeling within the stent body. The delivered doses correlated with a decreased IIH (r = 0.52, p < 0.001 for DV10 and r = 0.62, p < 0.001 for DV90) and with expansive remodeling (r = 0.48, p = 0.009 for DV10 and r = 0.50, p = 0.006 for DV90). A DV10 >90 Gy or a DV90 >15 Gy reduced IIH and induced expansive remodeling. Plaque growth was not reduced by radioactive stents.

CONCLUSIONS

The DVH analysis reveals a dose-dependent increase of external elastic lamina area behind radioactive stents, whereas plaque growth is not reduced but inverted into an outward direction from the stent. A DV10 >90 Gy or a DV90 >15 Gy results in a beneficial long-term outcome after radioactive stenting.

A comparison of intravascular source designs based on the beta particle emitter 114mIn/114In. Line source versus stepping source

BACKGROUND

Catheter-based intravascular brachytherapy (IVB) sources of the next generation will have to meet high demands in terms of miniaturization, flexibility, safety, reliability, costs and versatility. The radionuclide pair 114mIn/114In (half-life 49.51 days, maximum beta energy 2.0 MeV, average beta energy 0.78 MeV) is an attractive beta emitter for application in such a source.

METHODS

Since metallic indium is unfit for the manufacture of a brachytherapy source, the feasibility, safety and dosimetric properties of a design concept comprising a linear array of ceramic In2O3 spheres within a thin-walled, superelastic Ni/Ti capsule are investigated.

RESULTS

Neutron activation of enriched In2O3 spheres yields a specific activity sufficiently high for the manufacture of a stepping source, keeping treatment times limited to a few minutes. Although 114mIn/114In also emits some gamma radiation, the effective doses received by members of the medical staff are an order of magnitude lower than those received from fluoroscopy. The dose distributions about a 40-mm line source and a 5-mm stepping source (outer diameter 0.36 mm) are calculated using MCNP4C. Dose-volume histograms (DVHs) are calculated for the line source (centered and noncentered) and the stepping source (centered) using the geometry of a human coronary artery.

CONCLUSION

The results show that a centered stepping source with optimized dwell times delivers the most homogenous dose within the target volume.

[Physical and methodological aspects of multimodality imaging and principles of treatment planning in 3D conformal radiotherapy]

The recent evolutions of the imaging modalities, the dose calculation models, the linear accelerators and the portal imaging permit to improve the quality of the conformal radiation therapy treatment planning. With DICOM protocols, the acquired imaging data coming from different modalities are treated by performant image fusion algorithms and yield more precise target volumes and organs at risk. The transformation of the clinical target volumes (CTV) to planning target volumes (PTV) can be realised using advanced probabilistic techniques based on clinical experience. The treatment plans evaluation is based on the dose volume histograms. Their precision and clinical relevance are improved by the multi-modality imaging and the advanced dose calculation models. The introduction of the inverse planning systems permitting to realise modulated intensity radiation therapy generates highly conformal dose distributions. All the previously cited complex techniques require the application of rigorous quality assurance programs.

Dose–volume histograms based on serial intravascular ultrasound: a calculation model for radioactive stents

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Radioactive stents are under investigation for reduction of coronary restenosis. However, the actual dose delivered to specific parts of the coronary artery wall based on the individual vessel anatomy has not been determined so far. Dose-volume histograms (DVHs) permit an estimation of the actual dose absorbed by the target volume. We present a method to calculate DVHs based on intravascular ultrasound (IVUS) measurements to determine the dose distribution within the vessel wall.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ten patients were studied by intravascular ultrasound after radioactive stenting (BX Stent, P-32, 15-mm length) to obtain tomographic cross-sections of the treated segments. We developed a computer algorithm using the actual dose distribution of the stent to calculate differential and cumulative DVHs. The minimal target dose, the mean target dose, the minimal doses delivered to 10 and 90% of the adventitia (DV10, DV90), and the percentage of volume receiving a reference dose at 0.5 mm from the stent surface cumulated over 28 days were derived from the DVH plots. Results were expressed as mean+/-SD.

RESULTS

The mean activity of the stents was 438+/-140 kBq at implantation. The mean reference dose was 111+/-35 Gy, whereas the calculated mean target dose within the adventitia along the stent was 68+/-20 Gy. On average, DV90 and DV10 were 33+/-9 Gy and 117+/-41 Gy, respectively. Expanding the target volume to include 2.5-mm-long segments at the proximal and distal ends of the stent, the calculated mean target dose decreased to 55+/-17 Gy, and DV 90 and DV 10 were 6.4+/-2.4 Gy and 107+/-36 Gy, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The assessment of DVHs seems in principle to be a valuable tool for both prospective and retrospective analysis of dose-distribution of radioactive stents. It may provide the basis to adapt treatment planning in coronary brachytherapy to the common standards of radiotherapy.

Définition automatique de l’isodose de prescription pour les irradiations stéréotaxiques de malformations artérioveineuses

PURPOSE

To evaluate dosimetric consequences generated by the automatic definition based on lesion coverage of prescription isodose. A clinical series of 124 arteriovenous malformations was analysed. Plan quality was quantified by the standard deviation of the differential dose volume histogram calculated in the lesion.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We define two quantitative protocols based on lesion coverage for the automatic definition of prescription isodose using a volumetric definition of coverage (90% of lesion volume), and an isodose-based definition proposed by RTOG (prescription isodose equals minimum isodose in the lesion divided by 0.9).

RESULTS

We have evaluated the plans obtained for these two protocols, calculating several dose-volume indices. These indices are presented as a function of dose-volume histogram standard deviation in order to quantify the consequences of their variations for this representative series of plans. The margin our team tolerates is such that the sum of underdosed lesion and overdosed healthy tissues factors remains lower than one. Protocol based on volumetric coverage gives results situated within this margin. Protocol based on RTOG definition produces conformation indices that could be greater than 1.

CONCLUSION

The absolute dose would be decided taking into account examined dose-volume indices and clinical data. A protocol for automatic definition of prescription isodose using volumetric lesion coverage seems to be more judiciously adapted to arteriovenous malformation conformal plans in stereotactic conditions because of variations observed in the overdosage of healthy tissues.

Treatment planning using a dose-volume feasibility search algorithm

PURPOSE

An approach to treatment plan optimization is presented that inputs dose--volume constraints and utilizes a feasibility search algorithm that seeks a set of beam weights so that the calculated dose distributions satisfy the dose--volume constraints. In contrast to a search for the "best" plan, this approach can quickly determine feasibility and point out the most restrictive of the predetermined constraints.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The cyclic subgradient projection (CSP) algorithm was modified to incorporate dose--volume constraints in a treatment plan optimization schema. The algorithm was applied to determine beam weights for several representative three-dimensional treatment plans.

RESULTS

Using the modified CSP algorithm, we found that either a feasible solution to the dose--volume constraint problem was found or the program determined, after a predetermined set of iterations was performed, that no feasible solution existed for the particular set of dose--volume constraints. If no feasible solution existed, we relaxed several of the dose--volume constraints and were able to achieve a feasible solution.

CONCLUSION

Feasibility search algorithms can be used in radiation treatment planning to generate a treatment plan that meets the dose--volume constraints established by the radiation oncologist. In the absence of a feasible solution, these algorithms can provide information to the radiation oncologist as to how the dose--volume constraints may be modified to achieve a feasible solution.

Tumour dosimetry in human liver following hepatic yttrium-90 microsphere therapy

Radiation dose distributions arising from intrahepatic arterial infusion of 90Y microspheres have been investigated. Tissue samples from normal liver, the tumour periphery and tumour centre were taken from a patient following infusion of 3 GBq of 32 microm diameter resin microspheres labelled with 90Y as treatment for an 80 mm diameter metastatic liver tumour. The measured microsphere distributions in three dimensions were used to calculate radiation dose patterns. Although microspheres concentrated in the tumour periphery, heterogeneous doses were delivered to all tissues. Within the tumour periphery average doses ranged from 200 Gy to 600 Gy with minimum doses between 70 Gy and 190 Gy. The average and minimum doses for the tumour centre sample were 6.8 Gy and 3.7 Gy respectively. In the normal liver sample the average dose was 8.9 Gy with a minimum dose of 5 Gy. Less than 1% of the normal liver tissue volume received more than 30 Gy, the level above which complications have resulted for whole liver exposure using external beam radiotherapy. These calculations suggest that preferential deposition of microspheres in the well-vascularized periphery of large tumours will lead to a high proportion of the tumour volume receiving a therapeutic dose, with most of the normal liver tissue being spared substantial damage.