The Maryland aggregate pathology index: a deceased donor kidney biopsy scoring system for predicting graft failure

Peritransplant kidney biopsies: comparison of pathologic interpretations and practice patterns of organ procurement organizations

The preimplantation kidney biopsy affects utilization by diagnosing glomerulosclerosis, interstitial fibrosis (IF), arteriosclerosis, and arteriolar hyalinosis. Organ procurement organizations (OPOs) determine whether a donor warrants this biopsy and the donor hospital pathologists (DHPs) report on an OPO-specific pathology interpretation form. Biopsy slides from 40 deceased donor kidneys transplanted at our institution were used to compare interpretations between our transplant pathologist and the DHPs. Thirty-three of these kidneys also had post-perfusion biopsies (PPB). All 58 OPOs were queried for criteria used to request a preimplantation biopsy, and their pathology interpretation forms were also analyzed. The transplant and DHPs had substantial agreement for percent glomerulosclerosis with 75% of biopsies being interpreted within five percentage points. Concordance for IF was poor. The DHP rarely reported arterial pathology. Seventy percent of preimplantation and PPB were read similarly for glomerulosclerosis; concordance for other lesions was weaker. There were no cues for arterial disease on our OPO's pathology interpretation form. Criteria for obtaining a preimplantation biopsy lacked uniformity for the 21 OPOs with a self-generated policy. The pathology interpretation forms varied widely among the OPOs. Current OPO practices with regard to the preimplantation biopsy should be improved.

Clinical role of the renal transplant biopsy

Percutaneous needle core biopsy is the definitive procedure by which essential diagnostic and prognostic information on acute and chronic renal allograft dysfunction is obtained. The diagnostic value of the information so obtained has endured for over three decades and has proven crucially important in shaping strategies for therapeutic intervention. This Review provides a broad outline of the utility of performing kidney graft biopsies after transplantation, highlighting the relevance of biopsy findings in the immediate and early post-transplant period (from days to weeks after implantation), the first post-transplant year, and the late period (beyond the first year). We focus on how biopsy findings change over time, and the wide variety of pathological features that characterize the major clinical diagnoses facing the clinician. This article also includes a discussion of acute cellular and humoral rejection, the toxic effects of calcineurin inhibitors, and the widely varying etiologies and characteristics of chronic lesions. Emerging technologies based on gene expression analyses and proteomics, the in situ detection of functionally relevant molecules, and new bioinformatic approaches that hold the promise of improving diagnostic precision and developing new, refined molecular pathways for therapeutic intervention are also presented.

Pre-existing arteriosclerotic intimal thickening in living-donor kidneys reflects allograft function

BACKGROUND

Donor shortage is a serious problem worldwide and it is now debated whether kidneys from marginal donors are suitable for renal transplantation. Recent studies have shown that the findings of preimplantation kidney biopsy are useful to evaluate vasculopathy in the donated kidney, and may predict transplant outcomes in deceased- donor kidney transplantation. However, few studies have focused on the pathological findings of preimplantation biopsy in living-donor kidney transplantation. Therefore, we investigated whether arteriosclerotic vasculopathy in living-donor kidneys at the time of transplantation predicts the recipient's kidney function (allograft function) later in life.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed 75 consecutive adult living-donor kidney transplants performed at Kagawa University Hospital. Renal arteriosclerotic vasculopathy was defined according to the presence of fibrous intimal thickening in the interlobular artery.

RESULTS

Forty-one kidneys exhibited mild arteriosclerotic vasculopathy on preimplantation kidney biopsies. The decreases in estimated glomerular filtration rate after donation were similar in donors with or without renal arteriosclerotic vasculopathy. Pre-existing arteriosclerotic vasculopathy did not affect graft survival rate, patient survival rate or the incidence of complications. Recipients of kidneys with arteriosclerotic vasculopathy had lower allograft function at 1 and 3 years after transplantation than the recipients of arteriosclerosis-free kidneys with or without donor hypertension. In multivariate analysis, fibrous intimal thickening on preimplantation biopsy was predictive of reduced allograft function at 1 year after transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

The present study demonstrated that mild arteriosclerotic vasculopathy in the donated kidney is an important pathological factor that reflects future impaired function of renal allografts from marginal donors.

Monitoring and managing graft health in the kidney transplant recipient

Ongoing monitoring of kidney transplants is a widely accepted and practiced part of posttransplantation management. One reason to monitor is to evaluate whether the transplant is stable. The transplant community evaluates stability by checking kidney function. Despite problems with sensitivity and specificity, obtaining serial serum creatinine levels is the most common approach to assessing kidney function. Some programs supplement serial serum creatinine levels with surveillance kidney biopsies. Although not uniformly accepted as beneficial, surveillance biopsies are useful in select subsets of patients such as highly sensitized recipients. Recent biopsy studies shed light on which histopathology findings portend poor prognoses. The Long-Term Deterioration of Kidney Allograft Function Study (DeKAF) and similar studies that will prospectively evaluate therapeutic interventions should help the transplant community better define how to monitor and manage the kidney transplant optimally. In the meantime, Kidney Diseases: Improving Global Outcomes (KDIGO) provides an evidence-based approach toward monitoring and managing the kidney transplant.

Surveillance protocol kidney transplant biopsies: their evolving role in clinical practice

Protocol renal allograft biopsies at fixed time points from transplantation have aided research and provided insights into the pathogenesis of early and late allograft injury. Their role is evolving from research to a clinical management tool needed to detect subclinical pathology requiring treatment adjustment. They frequently reveal unexpected findings and influence therapy in the majority of patients. Detection of subclinical rejection (SCR) remains important despite declining prevalence with triple therapy, the evidence favors treatment, if found. Surveillance biopsies in steroid avoidance and calcineurin inhibitor (CNI) withdrawal programs provide an important safety net against the increased rates of late acute and SCR. Individualization of therapy in high-risk patients and safe reduction of immunosuppression in standard risk individuals becomes possible. Other potentially reversible chronic pathologies that may be detected, include chronic T-cell or antibody-mediated rejection, recurrent disease, BK virus-associated nephropathy, interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy and CNI nephrotoxicity, allowing modifications of therapy to limit ongoing graft injury. Biopsy is safe and inexpensive compared with costs of earlier graft failure and return to dialysis. This review summarizes current evidence on use of surveillance histology for the clinical practice of renal transplantation.

Significance of preimplantation analysis of kidney biopsies from expanded criteria donors in long-term outcome

BACKGROUND

The shortage of organs has led to expanding the criteria for donors. Histologic evaluations before transplantation may enable the identification of organs unsuitable for single implantation. The aim of this study was to evaluate the histologic findings as prognostic factors of allograft survival from expanded criteria donors (ECDs).

METHODS

We included a cohort of 136 single transplantations with kidneys from ECD and correlated the preimplantation pathologic findings with graft failure. Renal structures from ECD older (n=104) or younger (n=32) than 60 years were evaluated histologically for renal senescence and rated with a total histologic score. A multivariate Cox analysis was performed to identify predictors of graft failure.

RESULTS

Glomerulosclerosis was the most prevalent lesion in biopsies from donors older and younger than 60 years (P=0.002); interstitial fibrosis was more severe in biopsies from older donors (P=0.001); older donors showed a higher prevalence of tubular atrophy (P=0.022), and vascular compartment showed no significant differences. Kidney biopsy-based scoring system ranged from 0 to 15 points, indicating the presence of changes in the renal parenchyma. Biopsies with total histologic scores less than or equal to 5 showed significantly better 5-year graft survival than those with scores more than 5 (P<0.001). A preimplantation score more than 5 points remained an independent predictor of graft failure (hazard ratio 6.95; 95% confidence interval 1.57-30).

CONCLUSIONS

Histologic analysis of kidney biopsies before transplantation is a valuable tool for facilitating the selection of viable grafts from ECD donors. When the total score is more than 5, single kidney transplantation from ECD should not be recommended for patients similar to this study population.

Development and evaluation of a composite risk score to predict kidney transplant failure

BACKGROUND

Although risk factors for kidney transplant failure are well described, prognostic risk scores to estimate risk in prevalent transplant recipients are limited.

STUDY DESIGN

Development and validation of risk-prediction instruments.

SETTING & PARTICIPANTS

The development data set included 2,763 prevalent patients more than 12 months posttransplant enrolled into the LOTESS (Long Term Efficacy and Safety Surveillance) Study. The validation data set included 731 patients who underwent transplant at a single UK center.

PREDICTOR

Estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) and other risk factors were evaluated using Cox regression.

OUTCOME

Scores for death-censored and overall transplant failure were based on the summed hazard ratios for baseline predictor variables. Predictive performance was assessed using calibration (Hosmer-Lemeshow statistic), discrimination (C statistic), and clinical reclassification (net reclassification improvement) compared with eGFR alone.

RESULTS

In the development data set, 196 patients died and another 225 experienced transplant failure. eGFR, recipient age, race, serum urea and albumin levels, declining eGFR, and prior acute rejection predicted death-censored transplant failure. eGFR, recipient age, sex, serum urea and albumin levels, and declining eGFR predicted overall transplant failure. In the validation data set, 44 patients died and another 101 experienced transplant failure. The weighted scores comprising these variables showed adequate discrimination and calibration for death-censored (C statistic, 0.83; 95% CI, 0.75-0.91; Hosmer-Lemeshow χ(2)P = 0.8) and overall (C statistic, 0.70; 95% CI, 0.64-0.77; Hosmer-Lemeshow χ(2)P = 0.5) transplant failure. However, the scores failed to reclassify risk compared with eGFR alone (net reclassification improvements of 7.6% [95% CI, -0.2 to 13.4; P = 0.09] and 4.3% [95% CI, -2.7 to 11.8; P = 0.3] for death-censored and overall transplant failure, respectively).

LIMITATIONS

Retrospective analysis of predominantly cyclosporine-treated patients; limited study size and categorization of variables may limit power to detect effect.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the scores performed well regarding discrimination and calibration, clinically relevant risk reclassification over eGFR alone was not evident, emphasizing the stringent requirements for such scores. Further studies are required to develop and refine this process.

Post-transplant nuclear renal scans correlate with renal injury biomarkers and early allograft outcomes

BACKGROUND

Clinical- and histopathology-based scores are limited predictors of allograft outcome. In addition, more objective markers of early transplant function are needed to identify and validate biomarkers and predictive scores. We evaluated existing scores and transcriptome biomarkers of kidney injury as predictors of early transplant function measured by renal scan.

METHODS

Clinical, histopathologic and transcriptome data were collected in 143 consecutive kidney transplant recipients. A post-operative renal scan was performed within 48 h. Prediction scores for early outcomes were calculated.

RESULTS

Patients were stratified into three groups by renal scan: normal, mild-to-moderate or severe dysfunction. Kidneys with severe dysfunction were more often from deceased donors (P < 0.001), had greater HLA antigen mismatches (P < 0.001), were transplanted into older recipients (P = 0.040), had lower urine output during the first 8 h (P < 0.001), higher Day 7 serum creatinine (P < 0.001) and higher incidence of delayed graft function (P < 0.001). Clinical- and pathology-based scores did not discriminate between scan groups. In contrast, the overall transcriptome (P < 0.001) and transcripts of preselected acute kidney injury (AKI) genes were significantly different between the groups, with kidney injury molecule 1 (P = 0.001) and neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin (P = 0.002) being most highly expressed and genes associated with glutathione metabolism (GSTA1, 3 and 4) most down-regulated in kidneys with subsequent severe dysfunction.

CONCLUSIONS

Renal scans reflect early transplant function and allow for a more objective assessment of scores predicting early outcome and for identification of biomarkers. The study shows that transcript levels of AKI genes correlate better with renal scans than clinical- or histopathology-based scores.

Assessment of kidney organ quality and prediction of outcome at time of transplantation

The critical importance of donor organ quality, i.e., number of surviving nephrons, ability to withstand injury, and capacity for repair in determining short- and long-term outcomes is becoming increasingly clear. This review provides an overview of studies to assess donor kidney quality and subsequent transplant outcomes based on clinical pathology and transcriptome-based variables available at time of transplantation. Prediction scores using clinical variables function when applied to large data sets but perform poorly for the individual patient. Histopathology findings in pre-implantation or post-reperfusion biopsies help to assess structural integrity of the donor kidney, provide information on pre-existing donor disease, and can serve as a baseline for tracking changes over time. However, more validated approaches of analysis and prospective studies are needed to reduce the number of discarded organs, improve allocation, and allow prediction of outcomes. Molecular profiling detects changes not seen by morphology or captured by clinical markers. In particular, molecular profiles provide a quantitative measurement of inflammatory burden or immune activation and reflect coordinated changes in pathways associated with injury and repair. However, description of transcriptome patterns is not an end in itself. The identification of predictive gene sets and the application to an individualized patient management needs the integration of clinical and pathology-based variables, as well as more objective reference markers of transplant function, post-transplant events, and long-term outcomes.

Novel markers in zero-hour kidney biopsies indicate graft quality and clinical outcome

BACKGROUND

In renal transplantation, allograft biopsies provide valuable diagnostic information indicating adverse allograft outcome posttransplantation. To uncover novel candidate markers characteristic of subtle inflammation and immune activation present during the intraoperative period, we investigated messenger RNA (mRNA) gene expression profiles in renal zero biopsies.

METHODS

Transcription profiles from deceased donors (n=63) and living donors (n=26) were investigated for inflammation-associated markers in zero-hour biopsies by real-time reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction.

RESULTS

We observed a significant induction of the chemokine receptor 7 ligands [C-C motif] ligand 19/21 in the deceased donor group (P<0.001). Additionally, along with the induction of the activation marker CD69 (P<0.01), we further detected significant elevated mRNA levels of the inducible immunoproteasome subunits PSMB8, PSMB9, and PSMB10 (P<0.001, respectively). Candidate markers were further tested for posttransplantation clinical outcomes showing the potential to predict the development of delayed graft function, acute rejection, and renal function after 6 months. For instance, by combining mRNA gene expression profiles with clinical patient data, the analysis revealed high sensitivity (95%) and specificity (84%, area under the curve=0.93) for the prediction of acute rejection.

CONCLUSIONS

Zero-hour biopsies of renal allografts may provide useful information on subclinical pathological changes in the grafted kidney. The identification of CCL19/21 or PSMB8/9/10 makes these molecules particularly suitable as potential candidate targets for therapeutic interventions.

The prognostic value of frozen section preimplantation graft biopsy in the outcome of renal transplantation

INTRODUCTION

Preimplantation biopsy provides a window on the state of the renal allograft. In this study, the prognostic value of frozen section preimplantation graft biopsy was estimated and compared to regularly processed formalin-fixed biopsy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seventy-four renal allograft recipients were studied. The degree of glomerulosclerosis, acute tubular necrosis, interstitial fibrosis, arteriosclerosis, and arteriolosclerosis was rapidly estimated in frozen sections and correlated to the renal function in the immediate posttransplantation period and 3 months thereafter. The histological changes were also examined in paraffin-embedded sections.

RESULTS

The histological changes observed in rapidly processed frozen sections were comparable to those observed on regularly processed sections and their differences did not reach statistical significance. Glomerulosclerosis and arteriolosclerosis were underestimated, whereas acute tubular necrosis and interstitial fibrosis were overestimated, in the frozen sections compared to permanent ones, but those differences were not statistically significant. Immediate graft function was observed in 45 patients (61%). Delayed graft function was more frequently observed among recipients with donor age above 60 years (57% vs. 32%). Serum creatinine 3 months after transplantation was above 2 mg/dL in 33 recipients (44.5%) and was positively correlated to the degree of tubular necrosis (p = 0.04) and donor age (p = 0.03). Donor age was correlated to the degree of arteriolosclerosis (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Frozen section preimplantation biopsy gives reliable information for the situation of the graft that is related to the outcome of renal transplantation.

Histological assessment of pre-transplant kidney biopsies is reproducible and representative

AIMS

Histological examination of pre-transplant renal biopsy specimens can be used to select grafts from older donors after cardiac death (DCD) with a satisfactory transplant outcome. The aim was to determine whether such biopsy specimens can be reproducibly scored between pathologists and are representative of the whole kidney.

METHODS AND RESULTS

In renal biopsy specimens from DCD aged >or=60 years (n = 44), globally sclerosed glomeruli, vascular narrowing, tubular atrophy and interstitial fibrosis were scored by three independent pathologists according to the Pirani scoring system. Interobserver agreement on the sum of scores improved considerably with the introduction of a combined tubulo-interstitial scoring system (intraclass correlation coefficient increased from 0.38 to 0.64). In small needle biopsy specimens (n = 144) obtained at autopsy, estimates of the proportion of globally sclerosed glomeruli were more precise with increasing sample size. Reasonably precise estimates may be obtained from specimens with at least seven glomeruli.

CONCLUSIONS

It is feasible to implement pre-transplant renal biopsy specimen analysis as a selection criterion in clinical practice in order to accept kidneys from marginal donors for transplantation.

Analysis of preexisting baseline kidney lesions revealed by biopsy in living kidney donors: relationship with clinical parameters at the time of donation

Because the safety of living organ donors is essential, we have been performing donor kidney biopsy before donation in cases where decision-making regarding suitability is marginal. To clarify the degree to which pathological change in the kidney can be predicted on the basis of clinical data obtained non-invasively, we analyzed preexisting lesions found by one-h biopsy in 76 living kidney donors, and compared the findings with clinical parameters at the time of donation. Pathological change in living kidney donors was correlated to some extent with predonation clinical parameters including age, serum creatinine, estimated glomerular filtration rate and presence of hypertension, while the lesions influenced by glucose intolerance were not completely correlated with the results of oral glucose tolerance test. A follow-up study will be required to determine whether these mild histological findings at the time of donation influence long-term outcome in the donor.

Pathology: donor biopsy evaluation at time of renal grafting

How can we improve the diagnostic value of donor kidney graft biopsies and the management of renal transplant recipients? A recent study developed a morphologic scoring system -- the Maryland Aggregate Pathology Index -- to help predict long-term renal graft survival from preimplantation donor organ biopsy findings.