Repair of site-specific double-strand breaks in a mammalian chromosome by homologous and illegitimate recombination

Homology-directed repair is a major double-strand break repair pathway in mammalian cells

Mammalian cells have been presumed to repair potentially lethal chromosomal double-strand breaks (DSBs) in large part by processes that do not require homology to the break site. This contrasts with Saccharomyces cerevisiae where the major DSB repair pathway is homologous recombination. Recently, it has been determined that DSBs in genomic DNA in mammalian cells can stimulate homologous recombination as much as 3 or 4 orders of magnitude, suggesting that homology-directed repair may play an important role in the repair of chromosomal breaks. To determine whether mammalian cells use recombinational repair at a significant level, we have analyzed the spectrum of repair events at a defined chromosomal break by using direct physical analysis of repair products. When an endonuclease-generated DSB is introduced into one of two direct repeats, homologous repair is found to account for 30-50% of observed repair events. Both noncrossover and deletional homologous repair products are detected, at approximately a 1:3 ratio. These results demonstrate the importance of homologous recombination in the repair of DSBs in mammalian cells. In the remaining observed repair events, DSBs are repaired by nonhomologous processes. The nonhomologous repair events generally result in small deletions or insertions at the break site, although a small fraction of events result in larger chromosomal rearrangements. Interestingly, in two insertions, GT repeats were integrated at one of the broken chromosome ends, suggesting that DSB repair can contribute to the spread of microsatellite sequences in mammalian genomes.

Identification, characterization, and genetic mapping of Rad51d, a new mouse and human RAD51/RecA-related gene

Homologous DNA recombination occurs in all organisms and is important for repair of DNA damage during mitosis. One of the critical genes for DNA repair and meiotic recombination in yeast is RAD51, and homologs of RAD51 have been identified in several species, including mouse and human. Here we describe a new RAD51-related mammalian gene, named Rad51d, identified by searching the EST database with the yeast RAD55 and human RAD51B/REC2 genes. A full-length 1.5-kb mouse cDNA clone that encodes a predicted 329-amino-acid protein was isolated. Rad51d mRNA was present in every mouse tissue examined. Four different transcript sizes were detected, one of which was specific to testis. Human cDNA clones that predicted 71% amino acid identity to the mouse protein were also isolated. Interestingly, the sequences of these human clones and of RT-PCR-derived products provided evidence for alternative splicing. These mRNAs are predicted to encode proteins that are truncated relative to the mouse and lack the ATP-binding motif characteristic of RecA-related proteins. Using an interspecific backcross mapping panel, Rad51d was mapped to mouse Chromosome 11, 48.5 cM from the centromere. By radiation hybrid mapping, the human ortholog RAD51D was mapped to chromosome 17q11, which is a region syntenic to mouse Chromosome 11. Due to its expression pattern and sequence similarity to other RAD51 family members, it is likely that Rad51d is part of a complex of proteins required for DNA repair and meiotic recombination.

Factors affecting inverted repeat stimulation of recombination and deletion in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Inverted DNA repeats are an at-risk motif for genetic instability that can induce both deletions and recombination in yeast. We investigated the role of the length of inverted repeats and size of the DNA separating the repeats for deletion and recombination. Stimulation of both deletion and recombination was directly related to the size of inverted repeats and inversely related to the size of intervening spacers. A perfect palindrome, formed by two 1.0-kb URA3-inverted repeats, increased intra- and interchromosomal recombination in the adjacent region 2,400-fold and 17,000-fold, respectively. The presence of a strong origin of replication in the spacer reduced both rates of deletion and recombination. These results support a model in which the stimulation of deletion and recombination by inverted repeats is initiated by a secondary structure formed between single-stranded DNA of inverted repeats during replication.

Double-strand break repair mediated by DNA end-joining

DNA double-strand breaks formed by ionizing irradiation or other stresses are repaired by homologous recombination or DNA end-joining. This review focuses on the mechanism of double-strand break repair mediated by DNA end-joining, in which many factors have recently been identified. After DNA double-strand breakage, DNA end-joining takes place between the DNA ends that have nonhomologous sequences or very short regions ofhomology. The broken DNA is repaired if the DNA end-joining occurs in the same molecule, while it causes chromosome aberrations such as deletions, insertions, translocations and inversions if it occurs between different molecules. Rad50 and its relatives, Ku-proteins, DNA ligase VI and silencing factors, are involved in DNA end-joining in yeast and mammalian cells. These findings led us to propose a model in which the formation of a heterochromatin-like complex at broken ends is an important element in DNA end-joining.

Endonuclease II of coliphage T4: a recombinase disguised as a restriction endonuclease?

EndoII shares with restriction endonucleases the property of cleaving foreign DNA while leaving the endonuclease-encoding genome intact, ensuring the survival of one DNA species in the cell. In addition, in vivo EndoII cleaves a specific DNA sequence and cleavage is context dependent. These context effects extend over at least 1000 bp, largely limiting cleavage to once within this distance. Like homing endonucleases, in vivo EndoII recognizes a long, asymmetric and degenerate consensus sequence which has two distinct parts. Recognition of one part of the consensus sequence involves base-specific bonds, and recognition of the other involves sequence-dependent helical structure. EndoII fulfills an obvious short-term survival role in ensuring the dominance of phage DNA in an infected cell, but may also have a long-term evolutionary role, producing gene-size fragments of foreign DNA to be enrolled in the phage genetic repertoire.

Interstitial deletions and intrachromosomal amplification initiated from a double-strand break targeted to a mammalian chromosome

Interstitial deletions of tumour suppressor genes and amplification of oncogenes are two major manifestations of chromosomal instability in tumour cells. The development of model systems allowing the study of the events triggering these processes is of major clinical importance. Using the properties of the I-SceI nuclease to introduce a localized double-strand break (DSB) in a mammalian chromosome carrying its target sequence, we demonstrate here that both types of mutations can be initiated by non-conservative DSB repair pathways. In our system, I-SceI activity dissociates a transfected gpt gene from its promoter, allowing the isolation of gpt- clones. Our results show that intrachromatid single-strand annealing events occur frequently, giving rise to interstitial deletions not accompanied by other chromosomal rearrangements. We also observed that, when present in the cells, extrachromosomal DNA molecules are integrated preferentially at the broken locus. Taking advantage of the insertion of the I-SceI recognition sequence telomeric to and close to the dihydrofolate reductase gene, we show that a less frequent outcome of I-SceI activity is the initiation of cycles of intrachromosomal amplification of this marker, from breaks at a site merging with the enzyme target.

Gene conversion tracts from double-strand break repair in mammalian cells

Mammalian cells are able to repair chromosomal double-strand breaks (DSBs) both by homologous recombination and by mechanisms that require little or no homology. Although spontaneous homologous recombination is rare, DSBs will stimulate recombination by 2 to 3 orders of magnitude when homology is provided either from exogenous DNA in gene-targeting experiments or from a repeated chromosomal sequence. Using a gene-targeting assay in mouse embryonic stem cells, we now investigate the effect of heterology on recombinational repair of DSBs. Cells were cotransfected with an endonuclease expression plasmid to induce chromosomal DSBs and with substrates containing up to 1.2% heterology from which to repair the DSBs. We find that heterology decreases the efficiency of recombinational repair, with 1.2% sequence divergence resulting in an approximately sixfold reduction in recombination. Gene conversion tract lengths were examined in 80 recombinants. Relatively short gene conversion tracts were observed, with 80% of the recombinants having tracts of 58 bp or less. These results suggest that chromosome ends in mammalian cells are generally protected from extensive degradation prior to recombination. Gene conversion tracts that were long (up to 511 bp) were continuous, i.e., they contained an uninterrupted incorporation of the silent mutations. This continuity suggests that these long tracts arose from extensive degradation of the ends or from formation of heteroduplex DNA which is corrected with a strong bias in the direction of the unbroken strand.

Triplex-directed modification of genes and gene activity

Oligonucleotides offer enormous potential for manipulating gene function in cells and, as such, constitute a promising new class of pharmaceutical agents. Oligonucleotides that form triple helices (triplexes) at specific DNA sequences in defined genes can be used to reduce transcription selectively, to introduce site-specific mutations or to stimulate gene-specific targeted recombination.

Recombination-dependent deletion formation in mammalian cells deficient in the nucleotide excision repair gene ERCC1

Nucleotide excision repair proteins have been implicated in genetic recombination by experiments in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Drosophila melanogaster, but their role, if any, in mammalian cells is undefined. To investigate the role of the nucleotide excision repair gene ERCC1, the hamster homologue to the S. cerevisiae RADIO gene, we disabled the gene by targeted knockout. Partial tandem duplications of the adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (APRT) gene then were constructed at the endogenous APRT locus in ERCC1- and ERCC1+ cells. To detect the full spectrum of gene-altering events, we used a loss-of-function assay in which the parental APRT+ tandem duplication could give rise to APRT- cells by homologous recombination, gene rearrangement, or point mutation. Measurement of rates and analysis of individual APRT- products indicated that gene rearrangements (principally deletions) were increased at least 50-fold, whereas homologous recombination was affected little. The formation of deletions is not caused by a general effect of the ERCC1 deficiency on gene stability, because ERCC1- cell lines with a single wild-type copy of the APRT gene yielded no increase in deletions. Thus, deletion formation is dependent on the tandem duplication, and presumably the process of homologous recombination. Recombination-dependent deletion formation in ERCC1- cells is supported by a significant decrease in a particular class of crossover products that are thought to arise by repair of a heteroduplex intermediate in recombination. We suggest that the ERCC1 gene product in mammalian cells is involved in the processing of heteroduplex intermediates in recombination and that the misprocessed intermediates in ERCC1- cells are repaired by illegitimate recombination.

Molecular characterization of a mouse genomic element mobilized by advanced glycation endproduct modified-DNA (AGE-DNA)

BACKGROUND

DNA modified by advanced glycation endproducts (AGEs) undergoes a high frequency of insertional mutagenesis. In mouse lymphoid cells, these mutations are due in part to the transposition of host genomic elements that contain a DNA region homologous to the Alu family of repetitive elements. One particular 853 bp insertion, designated INS-1, was identified previously as a DNA element common to plasmids recovered from multiple, independent lymphoid cell transfections.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

To characterize the genomic origin of this element, we used a 281-bp region of non-Alu-containing INS-1 sequence, designated. CORE, as a probe in Southern hybridization and for screening a bacteriophage mouse genomic DNA library. The resultant clones were sequenced and localized within the mouse genome.

RESULTS

Two distinct genomic clones of 15 kB and 17 kB in size were isolated. A 522-bp unique region common to INS-1 and corresponding to the CORE sequence was identified in each clone. In both cases, CORE was found to be surrounded by repetitive DNA sequences: a 339-bp MT repeat at the 5' end, and a 150-bp B1 repeat at the 3' end. The CORE sequence was localized to mouse chromosome 1.

CONCLUSIONS

These studies revealed that the CORE region of INS is present in low copy number but is associated with known repetitive DNA elements. The presence of these repetitive elements may facilitate the transposition of CORE by recombination or other, more complex rearrangement events, and explain in part the origin of AGE-induced insertional mutations.

Chromosomal double-strand breaks induce gene conversion at high frequency in mammalian cells

Double-strand breaks (DSBs) stimulate chromosomal and extrachromosomal recombination and gene targeting. Transcription also stimulates spontaneous recombination by an unknown mechanism. We used Saccharomyces cerevisiae I-SceI to stimulate recombination between neo direct repeats in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell chromosomal DNA. One neo allele was controlled by the dexamethasone-inducible mouse mammary tumor virus promoter and inactivated by an insertion containing an I-SceI site at which DSBs were introduced in vivo. The other neo allele lacked a promoter but carried 12 phenotypically silent single-base mutations that create restriction sites (restriction fragment length polymorphisms). This system allowed us to generate detailed conversion tract spectra for recipient alleles transcribed at high or low levels. Transient in vivo expression of I-SceI increased homologous recombination 2,000- to 10,000-fold, yielding recombinants at frequencies as high as 1%. Strikingly, 97% of these products arose by gene conversion. Most products had short, bidirectional conversion tracts, and in all cases, donor neo alleles (i.e., those not suffering a DSB) remained unchanged, indicating that conversion was fully nonreciprocal. DSBs in exogenous DNA are usually repaired by end joining requiring little or no homology or by nonconservative homologous recombination (single-strand annealing). In contrast, we show that chromosomal DSBs are efficiently repaired via conservative homologous recombination, principally gene conversion without associated crossing over. For DSB-induced events, similar recombination frequencies and conversion tract spectra were found under conditions of low and high transcription. Thus, transcription does not further stimulate DSB-induced recombination, nor does it appear to affect the mechanism(s) by which DSBs induce gene conversion.

Highly conservative reciprocal translocations formed by apparent joining of exchanged DNA double-strand break ends

Chromosomal translocations induced by ionizing radiation and radiomimetic drugs are thought to arise by incorrect joining of DNA double-strand breaks. To dissect such misrepair events at a molecular level, large-scale, bleomycin-induced rearrangements in the aprt gene of Chinese hamster ovary D422 cells were mapped, the breakpoints were sequenced, and the original non-aprt parental sequences involved in each rearrangement were recovered from nonmutant cells. Of seven rearrangements characterized, six were reciprocal exchanges between aprt and unrelated sequences. Consistent with a mechanism involving joining of exchanged double-strand break ends, there was, in most cases, no homology between the two parental sequences, no overlap in sequences retained at the two newly formed junctions, and little or no loss of parental sequences (usually Collapse

Key Words

• bleomycin
• nonhomologous recombination
• dna repair
• dna end-joining
• gene rearrangements

Collapse

MESH Headings

• Adenine Phosphoribosyltransferase/genetics
• Animals
• Base Sequence
• Bleomycin/pharmacology
• CHO Cells
• Cricetinae
• DNA Damage
• Free Radicals
• Gene Rearrangement
• In Situ Hybridization, Fluorescence
• Molecular Sequence Data
• Mutagenesis
• Mutagens/pharmacology
• Recombination, Genetic
• Sequence Analysis, DNA
• Translocation, Genetic

Collapse

Grants

• R01 CA040615 NCI NIH HHS
• HD33527 NICHD NIH HHS
• CA40615 NCI NIH HHS

Collapse

Affiliation(s)

P Wang Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology, Medical College of Virginia, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA 23298, USA
R H Zhou
Y Zou
C K Jackson-Cook
L F Povirk

Collapse

Collaborators Collapse

DNA repair: RAD alert

Mammalian homologues of two important yeast genes involved in DNA double-strand break repair and recombination, RAD51 and RAD54, have been isolated. Knock-out mutations of the genes in mice reveal both reassuring similarities to, and surprising differences from, the analogous mutant phenotypes in yeast.