Tolerance of normal tissue to therapeutic irradiation

In vivo dosimetry during external photon beam radiotherapy

In this critical review of the current practice of patient dose verification, we first demonstrate that a high accuracy (about 1-2%, 1 SD) can be obtained. Accurate in vivo dosimetry is possible if diodes and thermoluminescence dosimeters (TLDs), the main detector types in use for in vivo dosimetry, are carefully calibrated and the factors influencing their sensitivity are taken into account. Various methods and philosophies for applying patient dose verification are then evaluated: the measurement of each field for each fraction of each patient, a limited number of checks for all patients, or measurements of specific patient groups, for example, during total body irradiation (TBI) or conformal radiotherapy. The experience of a number of centers is then presented, providing information on the various types of errors detected by in vivo dosimetry, including their frequency and magnitude. From the results of recent studies it can be concluded that in centers having modern equipment with verification systems as well as comprehensive quality assurance (QA) programs, a systematic error larger than 5% in dose delivery is still present for 0.5-1% of the patient treatments. In other studies, a frequency of 3-10% of errors was observed for specific patient groups or when no verification system was present at the accelerator. These results were balanced against the additional manpower and other resources required for such a QA program. It could be concluded that patient dose verification should be an essential part of a QA program in a radiotherapy department, and plays a complementary role to treatment-sheet double checking. As the radiotherapy community makes the transition from the conventional two-dimensional (2D) to three-dimensional (3D) conformal and intensity modulated dose delivery, it is recommended that new treatment techniques be checked systematically for a few patients, and to perform in vivo dosimetry a few times for each patient for situations where errors in dose delivery should be minimized.

Optimized radiation therapy based on radiobiological objectives

In the broad field of radiation therapy optimization, both simple and complex problems have their origins in the interaction of the radiation beams with the biological structures of normal and malignant tissues of the human body. Therefore, it is no great surprise that many treatment optimization problems are best handled by the use of well-designed radiobiological models. The classic way of quantifying dose-response relations for tumors and normal tissues as well as their cross-correlation with each other and their dependence on the underlying genetic and molecular biology of the cell are first briefly reviewed. Radiobiological objective functions, such as the probability of achieving complication-free cure and its expectation value under influence of stochastic processes during the course of treatment, are defined and shown to solve many of the problems of radiation therapy planning. Finally, it is shown through the use of these quantifiers that, simply by introducing biologically optimal intensity modulated dose delivery, the treatment outcome can be improved by about 20% or more in cases with a complex spread of the disease. Once radiobiological optimal plans have been developed, they can be approximated by ordinary physical planning, but the biological objective functions are still needed to have a figure of merit for the quality of the treatment.

[Comparison of different 3-dimensional irradiation techniques in local radiotherapy of prostatic carcinoma]

PURPOSE

Four different three-dimensional planning techniques for localized radiotherapy of prostate cancer were compared with regard to dose homogeneity within the target volume and dose to organs at risk, dependent upon tumor stage.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Six patients with stage T1, 7 patients with stage T2 and 4 patients with stage T3 were included in this study. Four different 3D treatment plans (rotation, 4-field, 5-field and 6-field technique) were calculated for each patient. Dose was calculated with the reference point at the isocenter (100%). The planning target volume was encompassed within the 95% isodose surface. All the techniques used different shaped portal for each beam. Dose volume histograms were created and compared for the planning target volume and the organs at risk (33%, 50%, 66% volume level) in all techniques.

RESULTS

The 4 different three-dimensional planning techniques revealed no differences concerning dose homogeneity within the planning target volume. The dose volume distribution at organs at risk show differences between the calculated techniques. In our study the best protection for bladder and rectum in stage T1 and T2 was achieved by the 6-field technique. A significant difference was achieved between 6-field and 4-field technique only in the 50% volume of the bladder (p = 0.034), between the 6-field and rotation technique (all volume levels) and between 5-field and rotation technique (all volume levels). In stage T1, T2 6-field and 4-field technique in 50% (p = 0.033) and 66% (p = 0.011) of the rectum volume. In stage T3 a significant difference was not observed between the 4 techniques. The best protection of head of the femur was achieved by the rotation technique.

CONCLUSION

In the localized radiotherapy of prostate cancer in stage T1 or T2 the best protection for bladder and rectum was achieved by a 3D-planned conformal 6-field technique. If the seminal vesicles have been included in the target volume and in the case of large planning target volume other techniques should be taken for a better protection for organs at risk e. g. a 3D-planned 4-field technique box technique.

A dosimetric comparison of conventional vs conformal external beam irradiation of a stented coronary artery utilizing a new fluoroscopic imaging detector system

Purpose. To determine whether conformal external photon beam irradiation may prevent or reduce the rate of restenosis of a stented coronary artery following percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA). Optimal conformal external beam irradiation with limited cardiac dose requires adequate visualization of the stented vascular segment. With existing image intensifiers, identification of a coronary stent is poorly localized. We propose using an amorphous silicon panel detector to observe the movement of the stent during the cardiac cycle.

BACKGROUND

Long-term radiation-induced coronary complications can be minimized by: (a) reducing the radiation field sizes, (b) fractionating the total dose over several days, and (c) applying multiple treatment beams. Localization of the movement of the stent during the cardiac cycle may allow for the design of radiation fields that conform to the stented vessel segment. This scheme may permit gating the radiation beam on or off relative to movement of the stent within or outside the radiation fields, respectively.

METHODS

Using a new solid-state amorphous silicon planar detector, with a dynamic range of 12 bits, fluoroscopic images of a Palmaz-Schatz coronary stent were obtained. The stent was centered in a polystyrene phantom 20 cm thick and imaged using a 90-kVp, 3.5-ma, source-detector and source stent distances of 114 and 100 cm, respectively. With the solid-state silicon detector, the stent was identified in a single video frame (1/30 s). This fast image acquisition should allow for mapping the motion of the stent during the cardiac cycle. The stent movement during the cardiac cycle may then be correlated with the QRS complex in the electrocardiogram.

CONCLUSIONS

The localization of a coronary stent during the cardiac cycle under fluoroscopy permits delivery of small conformal external radiation fields to treat stented coronary arteries, while minimizing radiation dose to surrounding normal cardiac tissue and vasculature. The best selection of treatment beam angles will be provided by high resolution fluoroscopic images of the stented region obtained from different beam directions. The three-dimensional movement of the stent, indexed in time with the QRS complex, will provide an important measure for gating radiation beams for conformal treatment delivery.

Prediction of overall pulmonary function loss in relation to the 3-D dose distribution for patients with breast cancer and malignant lymphoma

PURPOSE

To predict the changes in pulmonary function tests (PFTs) 3-4 months after radiotherapy based on the three-dimensional (3-D) dose distribution and taking into account patient- and treatment-related factors.

METHODS

For 81 patients with malignant lymphoma and breast cancer, PFTs (VA, VC, FEV1 and TL,COc) were performed prior to and 3-4 months after irradiation and dose-effect relations for early changes in local perfusion, ventilation and air-filled fraction were determined using correlated CT and SPECT data. The 3-D dose distribution of each patient was converted into four different dose-volume parameters, i.e. the mean dose in the lung and three overall response parameters (ORPs, which represent the average local injury over the complete lung). ORPs were determined using the dose-effect relations for early changes in local perfusion, ventilation and air-filled fraction. Correlation coefficients were calculated between these dose-volume parameters and the changes in PFTs. In addition, the impact of the variables chemotherapy (MOPP/ABV and CMF), tamoxifen, smoking, age and gender on the relation between the mean lung dose and the relative changes in PFTs following radiotherapy was studied using multiple regression analysis.

RESULTS

The mean lung dose proved to be the easiest parameter to predict the reduction in PFTs 3-4 months following radiotherapy. For all patients the relation between the mean lung dose and the changes in PFTs could be described with one regression line through the origin and a slope of 1% reduction in PFT for each increase of 1 Gy in mean lung dose. Smoking and CMF chemotherapy influenced the reduction in PFTs significantly for VA and TL,COc, respectively. Patients treated with MOPP/ABV prior to radiotherapy had lower pre-radiotherapy PFTs than other patient groups, but did not show further deterioration after radiotherapy (at 3-4 months).

CONCLUSIONS

The relative reduction in VA, VC, FEV1 and TL,COc 3-4 months after radiotherapy for breast cancer and malignant lymphoma can be estimated before radiotherapy based on the mean lung dose of each individual patient and taking into account the use of chemotherapy and smoking habits of the patient.

Radiotherapy planning techniques for thyroid cancer

External beam radiotherapy has a role in each histological type of thyroid cancer. For treatment confined to the thyroid bed, an antero--oblique wedged pair of beams is simple to apply. More frequently, however, the volume needs to include both sides of the neck and adequate dose must be given down to the level of the suprasternal notch, precluding use of lateral fields. Thus, anterior and posterior fields are usually necessary, extending from the tips of the mastoid processes or hyoid down to the carina and laterally to include both sides of the neck and supraclavicular fossae. The mandible and infraclavicular portions of both lungs are shielded, but there is no midline lead in the phase one volume. A mid-plane dose of 46 Gy given in 23 daily fractions results in an acceptable early radiation reaction and will avoid late damage to the spinal cord. Because of considerable variation of interplanar distance along the length of the volume, a lateral simulator film should be taken to determine the maximum cord dose. For most patients, a three-dimensional CT planned phase two volume will be required and should be determined prior to completing phase one. The optimum beam arrangement, usually incorporating conformal beam shaping assisted by use of a multileaf collimator, should avoid further dose to the cord. If there is additional dose to the spinal cord, this phase can be introduced before 46 Gy is reached.

A comparison of conventional and conformal radiotherapy of the oesophagus: work in progress

A retrospective treatment planning study was carried out in five patients to assess the effectiveness of conformal radiotherapy of the oesophagus. A two-phase conventional treatment plan was created for each patient, with a prescribed dose of 55 Gy. This plan was compared with a single-phase conformal plan consisting of the same field arrangement as the second phase of the conventional treatment, but with conformal blocks shaped to the beam's eye view of the planning target volume. A further comparison was made between the conventional plan and a two-phase plan using the same beam angles and weights as the conventional plan, but with conformal field shapes. The effectiveness of each treatment plan was assessed using dose--volume histograms and normal tissue complication probabilities for the lungs. On average, the single-phase conformal technique increased the mean lung dose from 22.5% (+/- 6.2 SD) of the prescribed dose to 29.5% (+/- 5.2 SD) compared with the conventional technique (p = 0.0001). This indicates that this technique did not offer any benefit in terms of reducing the risk of pneumonitis. However, the two-phase conformal technique reduced the mean lung dose from 22.5% (+/- 6.2 SD) of the prescribed dose to 19.8% (+/- 4.6 SD)(p = 0.03), showing that this technique should reduce the risk of pneumonitis. Further work is underway to study more patients and to investigate tumour control probability and dose escalation.

Improving dose homogeneity in routine head and neck radiotherapy with custom 3-D compensation

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Anatomic contour irregularity and tissue inhomogeneity can lead to significant radiation dose variation across the complex treatment volumes found in the head and neck (H&N) region. This dose inhomogeneity can routinely create focal hot or cold spots of 10-20% despite beam shaping with blocks or beam modification with wedges. Since 1992, we have implemented the routine use of 3-D custom tissue compensators fabricated directly from CT scan contour data obtained in the treatment position in order to improve dose uniformity in patients with tumors of the H&N.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between July 1992 and January 1997, 160 patients receiving comprehensive H&N radiotherapy had 3-D custom compensators fabricated for their treatment course. Detailed dosimetric records have been analyzed for 30 cases. Dose uniformity across the treatment volume and clinically relevant maximum doses to selected anatomic sub-sites were examined with custom-compensated, uncompensated and optimally-wedged plans.

RESULTS

The use of 3-D custom compensators resulted in an average reduction of dose variance across the treatment volume from 19+/-4% for the uncompensated plans to 5+/-2% with the use of 3-D compensators. Optimally-wedged plans were variable, but on average a 10+/-3% dose variance was noted. For comprehensive H&N treatment which encompassed the larynx within the primary field design, the peak doses delivered were reduced by 5-15% with 3-D custom compensation as compared to optimal wedging.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of 3-D custom tissue compensation can improve dose homogeneity within the treatment volume for H&N cancer patients. Maximum doses to clinically important structures which often receive greater than 105-110% of the prescribed dose are routinely reduced with the use of 3-D custom compensators. Improved dose uniformity across the treatment volume can reduce normal tissue complication profiles and potentially allow for delivery of higher total doses in an attempt to enhance locoregional tumor control.

[Radiotherapy for non-small-cell bronchial cancers: definitions of volumes, patient selection. Recommendations of the International Association for the Study of Lung Cancer (IASLC)]

Chemoradiation is the standard treatment of unresectable, locally advanced non-small cell lung cancer, with a mean dose of 60-66 Gy, excluding escalation dose schemes. The standard treated volume includes primary tumor, ipsilateral hilar and mediastinal nodes, supraclavicular and contralateral nodes as well, regardless of the node status. This work tries to answer the question of the optimal volume to be treated. Drainage routes analysis is in favor of large volumes, while toxicity analysis favors small volumes. Combined modality treatment may increase the observed toxicity. The optimal volume definition is difficult, and requires available conformal therapy tools. Patients selection is another important issue. A volume definition is then attempted, based on the IASLC (International Association for the Study of Lung Cancer) Annecy workshop experience, highlighting the interobservers discrepancies, and suggests basic recommendations to harmonize volume definition.

Radiation pneumonitis as a function of mean lung dose: an analysis of pooled data of 540 patients

PURPOSE

To determine the relation between the incidence of radiation pneumonitis and the three-dimensional dose distribution in the lung.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In five institutions, the incidence of radiation pneumonitis was evaluated in 540 patients. The patients were divided into two groups: a Lung group, consisting of 399 patients with lung cancer and 1 esophagus cancer patient and a Lymph./Breast group with 78 patients treated for malignant lymphoma, 59 for breast cancer, and 3 for other tumor types. The dose per fraction varied between 1.0 and 2.7 Gy and the prescribed total dose between 20 and 92 Gy. Three-dimensional dose calculations were performed with tissue density inhomogeneity correction. The physical dose distribution was converted into the biologically equivalent dose distribution given in fractions of 2 Gy, the normalized total dose (NTD) distribution, by using the linear quadratic model with an alpha/beta ratio of 2.5 and 3.0 Gy. Dose-volume histograms (DVHs) were calculated considering both lungs as one organ and from these DVHs the mean (biological) lung dose, NTDmean, was obtained. Radiation pneumonitis was scored as a complication when the pneumonitis grade was grade 2 (steroids needed for medical treatment) or higher. For statistical analysis the conventional normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) model of Lyman (with n=1) was applied along with an institutional-dependent offset parameter to account for systematic differences in scoring patients at different institutions.

RESULTS

The mean lung dose, NTDmean, ranged from 0 to 34 Gy and 73 of the 540 patients experienced pneumonitis, grade 2 or higher. In all centers, an increasing pneumonitis rate was observed with increasing NTDmean. The data were fitted to the Lyman model with NTD50=31.8 Gy and m=0.43, assuming that for all patients the same parameter values could be used. However, in the low dose range at an NTDmean between 4 and 16 Gy, the observed pneumonitis incidence in the Lung group (10%) was significantly (p=0.02) higher than in the Lymph./Breast group (1.4%). Moreover, between the Lung groups of different institutions, also significant (p=0.04) differences were present: for centers 2, 3, and 4, the pneumonitis incidence was about 13%, whereas for center 5 only 3%. Explicitly accounting for these differences by adding center-dependent offset values for the Lung group, improved the data fit significantly (p < 10(-5)) with NTD50=30.5+/-1.4 Gy and m=0.30+/-0.02 (+/-1 SE) for all patients, and an offset of 0-11% for the Lung group, depending on the center.

CONCLUSIONS

The mean lung dose, NTDmean, is relatively easy to calculate, and is a useful predictor of the risk of radiation pneumonitis. The observed dose-effect relation between the NTDmean and the incidence of radiation pneumonitis, based on a large clinical data set, might be of value in dose-escalating studies for lung cancer. The validity of the obtained dose-effect relation will have to be tested in future studies, regarding the influence of confounding factors and dose distributions different from the ones in this study.

Two case reports: carcinoma of the cervix and carcinoma of the endometrium treated with radiotherapy after previous irradiation for benign uterine bleeding

In the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s, low doses of radiotherapy were used to treat benign uterine bleeding. The cases of two women who received this form of therapy and later developed gynaecological malignancies and had high-dose pelvic radiotherapy are presented. A 76-year-old woman with an International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO) stage-IIB squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix received external beam radiotherapy and intra-uterine brachytherapy and a 77-year-old women with a FIGO stage-IB endometrial adenocarcinoma received adjuvant postoperative pelvic radiotherapy. Both women had a significant past history of low-dose-rate intra-uterine irradiation for dysfunctional uterine bleeding. Therefore the theoretical question of carcinogenesis was raised, and also the practical questions of what dose had previously been given and what further dose could be safely given with regard to normal tissue tolerance.

Plasma transforming growth factor beta1 as a predictor of radiation pneumonitis

PURPOSE

To investigate prospectively the utility of plasma transforming growth factor beta1 (TGFbeta1) as a marker for the development of symptomatic radiation pneumonitis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seventy-three patients with lung cancer treated with curative intent are reported herein. Plasma TGFbeta1 samples were obtained before, weekly during, and at each follow-up after radiation therapy (RT). TGFbeta1 was extracted using an acid/ethanol method. An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay was used to quantify plasma TGFbeta1 concentrations. The TGFbeta1 level at the end of RT was considered "normal" if it was both < or = 7.5 ng/ml and less than the pretreatment value. All patients were followed for at least 6 months, unless symptomatic pneumonitis developed sooner. Pneumonitis was defined by National Cancer Institute (NCI) common toxicity criteria.

RESULTS

Fifteen of the 73 patients (21%) developed symptomatic pneumonitis and the remaining 58 (79%) did not. A normal plasma TGFbeta1 by the end of RT, as defined above, was more common in patients who did not develop pneumonitis. A return of the plasma TGFbeta1 to normal accurately identified patients who would not develop pneumonitis with both a sensitivity and positive predictive value of 90%.

CONCLUSION

Plasma TGFbeta1 levels appear to be a useful means to identify patients at low risk for the development of pneumonitis from thoracic RT. Thus, monitoring of plasma TGFbeta1 levels may identify candidates for dose escalation studies in the treatment of lung cancer.

Regional dose response to pulmonary irradiation using a manual method

PURPOSE

To better understand the dose dependence of radiation therapy (RT)-induced changes in regional lung perfusion and tissue density, using a manual method to reduce inaccuracies that might be present in previously described automated methods.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Patients who were to receive RT for tumors in and around the thorax, wherein portions of healthy lung would be incidentally irradiated, were prospectively studied. Changes in regional perfusion and tissue density were assessed by comparison of pre- and post-RT single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), lung perfusion scans and computed tomography (CT) scans, respectively. The three-dimensional dose distribution was calculated on the pre-RT CT scan and correlated to the other scans via image registration. Study volumes were defined by hand and individually visualized on pre- and post-RT scans. The manually generated dose response data were compared to data generated using automated methods. The relationship between CT density and SPECT perfusion was also determined.

RESULTS

Thirteen patients with lung cancer were evaluated for changes in tissue density and 11 patients were evaluated for changes in regional perfusion at 12 months post-RT. In general, density increases with increasing regional dose, with marked changes at >60 Gy. Regional perfusion decreases with increasing regional dose. In the low dose regions, relative perfusion increases by 35% on average. Manually measured dose responses correlated well with those determined automatically. The relationship between regional perfusion and CT density indicates a wide range of perfusion over a narrow range of CT density, with markedly reduced perfusion at CT densities of > -600 and < -900 H.

CONCLUSIONS

The manually generated CT density dose response data broadly agree with data previously generated using automated methods. The manually generated perfusion dose response data are in fairly good agreement with automated data, lending credibility to the accuracy of the automated methods. Regional perfusion is markedly diminished where CT density is outside the range of normal lung tissue.

Evaluation of two dose-volume histogram reduction models for the prediction of radiation pneumonitis

PURPOSE

To evaluate the similarities between the mean lung dose and two dose-volume histogram (DVH) reduction techniques of 3D dose distributions of the lung.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

DVHs of the lungs were calculated from 3D dose distributions of patients treated for malignant lymphoma (44), breast cancer (42) and lung cancer (20). With a DVH reduction technique, a DVH is summarized by the equivalent uniform dose (EUD), a quantity which is directly related to the normal tissue complication probability (NTCP). Two DVH reduction techniques were used. The first was based on an empirical model proposed by Kutcher et al. (Kutcher, G.J., Burman, C., Brewster, M.S., Goitein, M. and Mohan, R. Histogram reduction method for calculating complication probabilities for three-dimensional treatment planning evaluations. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys. 21: 137-146, 1991), which needs a volume exponent n. Several values for n were tested. The second technique was based on a radiobiological model, the parallel functional subunit model developed by Niemierko et al. (Niemierko, A. and Goitein, M. Modeling of normal tissue response to radiation: the critical volume model. Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys. 25: 135-145, 1993) and Jackson et al. (Jackson, A., Kutcher, G.J. and Yorke, E.D. Probability of radiation-induced complications for normal tissues with parallel architecture subject to non-uniform irradiation. Med. Phys. 20: 613-625, 1993), for which a local dose-effect relation needed to be specified. This relation was obtained from an analysis of perfusion and ventilation SPECT data.

RESULTS

It can be shown analytically that the two DVH reduction techniques are identical, if the local dose-effect relation obeys a power-law relationship in the clinical dose range. Local dose-effect relations based on perfusion and ventilation SPECT data can indeed be fitted with a power-law relationship in the range 0-80 Gy, from which values of n = 0.8-0.9 were deduced. These correspond to the commonly used value of n = 0.87 for lung tissue and yielded EUDn=0.87 values which were almost identical to the mean lung doses. For other n values, for which no experimental data are present, differences exist between EUD and mean dose values. Six patients with malignant lymphoma (6/44) and none of the breast cancer patients (0/42) developed radiation pneumonitis. These cases occurred only at high values for the mean lung dose.

CONCLUSION

The two DVH reduction techniques are identical for lung and are very similar to mean dose calculations. The two techniques are also relatively similar for other model parameter values.

A little to a lot or a lot to a little: is NTCP always minimized in multiport therapy?

PURPOSE

We address the question of whether or not, for the same average (or integral) dose, a smaller uniform dose to an entire normal tissue structure always results in a lower normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) than does a proportionally larger dose to a partial volume of the same structure.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A recent compilation of NTCP data and two theoretical formulations of the dependence of NTCP on dose and partial volume irradiated-the Lyman probit equation and the binomial model-are used to examine this question. Both models fit equally well available NTCP data.

RESULTS

Empirical data indicate that for lung, kidney, and possibly liver (but not for esophagus, brain, or heart), given a fixed tumor dose and fixed integral dose, NTCP can be minimized by irradiating a partial volume fraction rather than the entire normal organ. The binomial model supports this interpretation, whereas the probit model predicts that for all organs uniform irradiation of the whole organ always results in the lowest possible NTCP.

CONCLUSIONS

In contrast to what is commonly believed, this study suggests that for at least two normal tissues, namely lung and kidney, there may be situations where "a lot to a little" (i.e., fewer treatment ports) will result in higher tumor control probability and better treatment plan than "a little to a lot" (i.e., multifield treatment). This finding, which is independent of the binomial or probit models used here, depends only on the accuracy of the empirical NTCP data. It is also interesting to note that: a) lung and kidney are commonly classified as parallel tissues, while the others have more of a serial architecture; and b) the choice of the NTCP model can have a profound impact on treatment planning decisions.

Dose-effect relations for early local pulmonary injury after irradiation for malignant lymphoma and breast cancer

PURPOSE

To quantify the influence of treatment- and patient-related factors on the severity of early local pulmonary injury and to establish whether regional differences are present for local dose-effect relations for early radiation-induced pulmonary injury.

METHODS

Forty-two patients with malignant lymphoma and 40 breast cancer patients were examined prior to and 3 months after radiotherapy. The lymphoma patients were irradiated with mantle fields to an average dose of 38 Gy and the breast cancer patients were irradiated with internal mammary node fields with or without tangential breast fields to an average dose of 50 Gy. Dose-effect relations for local perfusion, ventilation and density changes were determined using correlated single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) and CT data. A multivariate analysis was performed to study the influence of irradiated volume, chemotherapy (CMF and MOPP/ABV), smoking, age and gender. In addition, dose-effect relations for different regions in the lung were determined.

RESULTS

A similar and almost linear increase of early functional changes as a function of radiation dose was observed for perfusion and ventilation, whereas the shape of the dose-effect relation and the magnitude of early structural changes were different for density. For the three end-points studied, regional differences in radiosensitivity could not be demonstrated. For the posterior lung region compared to the anterior lung region, however, a difference was observed, which could be attributed to a gravity-related effect in the measuring procedure. Local structural changes (density) were significantly smaller for smokers (P = 0.002) and young patients (P = 0.007), whereas the CMF chemotherapy regimen given after radiotherapy (P = 0.017) significantly increased the amount of functional changes (perfusion). The magnitude of local pulmonary changes was independent of the irradiated volume, the MOPP/ABV chemotherapy regimen and gender.

CONCLUSION

The dose-effect relations for early radiation-induced local pulmonary changes were independent of the irradiated volume, MOPP/ABV, gender and lung region. CMF, smoking and age influenced the magnitude of early pulmonary changes and should be taken into account in dose-escalation protocols.

[Late effects of radiations on the bladder]

Clinical effects of radiation on bladder are in relation with their effects on various tissus of this organ. The most important is the vessels. According to clinical models; it is possible to evaluate the different factors, especially the dose and the irradiated volume. The risk of complications rise with these two factors. Drugs used in bladder cancer don't seem to increase the risk of complications. The prevention of the late effects lies on the tissue protection and on the precise evaluation of the irradiated volume in view to reduce them.

[Late effects of ionizing radiations on the vulva, vagina and uterus]

Reporting and scoring complications after radiotherapy of gynaecological cancers is difficult because of the variety of treatment techniques involved. Use of an international classification is necessary to compare results obtained in series of patients treated in different institutions. An international group of experts designed in the early nineties the so-called French-Italian glossary. This classification of late effects is now completed with the new LENT SOMA scales. This paper contains details of these late changes, including their pathophysiology, clinical syndromes, potential treatment, and prevention.

[Late effects of radiations on the kidney]

Clinical radiation damage to the kidney are nowadays a rare event. Nevertheless, this organ is very sensitive to radiation and dose exceeding 15 Gy may induce severe and life threatening damage many years after the treatment. Prevention remains the best treatment through a precise localisation of the kidneys before any irradiation of the upper abdomen.

[Late effects of ionizing radiations on head and neck region tissues]

Numerous structures are included in the irradiated volume of patients presenting with head and neck cancer: skin, mucosa, bone, teeth, cartilage, muscles, salivary glands, etc. Curative intent treatment of such tumours requires aggressive approach which can lead to severe sequellae. These sequellae are in most cases dose-dependent and volume-dependent. However, an appropriate technique might decrease the severity of such sequellae. Details of these late changes are presented, including their pathophysiology, clinical syndromes, potential treatment, and prevention.

[Late effects of ionizing radiations on the thyroid gland]

The thyroid is the purest endocrine gland in the body and is likely to produce clinically significant abnormalities after external radiotherapy. Functional clinical modifications after direct irradiation exceeding 30 Gy are essentially related to hypothyroidism which may be clinically overt or subclinical with normal serum free thyroxine levels and high thyrotropin concentrations; the risk of hyperthyroidism, silent thyroiditis and Hashimoto's disease is also increased. Secondary hypothyroidism related to irradiation of the hypothalamus and the pituitary gland may arise with doses over 40-50 Gy following treatment for brain and nasopharyngeal tumors--Morphological glandular modifications induced by radiotherapy are responsible for the appearance of benign adenomas, more rarely cystic degenerations and specially well differentiated papillary or follicular carcinomas among children and adults. After irradiation during childhood for benign or malignant tumors, thyroid cancers are more frequent, higher for younger children, and the relative excess risk is increased from 15.6-to 53-fold; tumors can belatedly occur, more than 35 years after initial therapy. Thereby, in order to limit excess morbidity, it is evident that long term supervision with careful clinical and biological evaluations is necessary for patients who previously received neck, upper mediastinum and pituitary radiation therapy.

[Late effects of mammary radiotherapy on skin and subcutaneous tissues]

Late damages to the skin and subcutaneous tissues are almost inescapable because of the high skin doses required in the irradiation of breast tumours. While the clinical and histological descriptions date back to the first decades of the therapeutic use of ionising radiation, the recent advances in cellular and molecular biology have significantly contributed to the increased understanding of late skin injury mechanisms. In particular, sub-cutaneous fibrosis appears to be the partly reversible results of a continuous and self-maintained local process, possibly sensitive to therapeutic intervention. A second very active research avenue is the development of biologic assays potentially able to predict the probability of increased normal tissue injury after irradiation in individual patients. Such a test would allow the adaptation of the treatment modalities to the radiobiological behaviour of normal tissues. To date, these expectations have not been met. The quality of the irradiation and its modalities (total dose, fractionation, inter fraction interval) remain the main ways to achieve an optimal functional and cosmetic outcome.

[Late effects of radiations on the liver]

Until recently, the liver was classified as a radioresistant organ, although it is in fact highly radiosensitive. The realization that the whole liver could be treated safely only with low doses of radiation led to the conclusion that radiation therapy had an extremely limited role in the treatment of intrahepatic malignancies. A resurgence of interest has been observed with the advent of conformal radiotherapy and the introduction of bone marrow transplantation with total body irradiation. The radiation-induced liver disease, often called radiation hepatitis, is a syndrome characterized by the development of anicteric ascites, approximately 2 weeks to 4 months after hepatic irradiation. Immediate tolerance is generally surprisingly good, and the subacute radiation injury is followed by a complete asymptomatic healing, although the late lesions may be associated with signs of chronic radiation hepatitis. Radiation hepatitis must be distinguished from chemoradiation-induced-hepatitis occurring in patients undergoing bone marrow transplantation and total body irradiation. Both syndromes demonstrate the same pathological lesion: veno-occlusive disease. The main treatment for radiation hepatitis is diuretics, although soma advocate steroids for severe cases.

[Biological mechanisms of late effects of ionizing radiations]

The daily practice of radiation oncology is increasingly influenced by the late tolerance of normal tissues. The treatment decision must be based on detailed arguments and the physician's duty to extensively inform his patients is emphasised every day. The incidence and severity of radiation-induced sequelae and late complications can be reduced by decreasing the total dose to the normal tissues, and by decreasing the dose protraction, provided that the interval between fractions remains longer than 6 to 8 hours. This approach yields a selective protection of late responding normal tissues, since tumours are less sensitive to the effects of fractionation. Despite its own limitations, the linear- quadratic model is nowadays the standard method to compare the biological effects of different radiation treatments.

[Late effects of ionizing radiations on central nervous system, spinal cord and peripheral nerves]

Despite the lack of characteristic features, demyelination is the dominant feature of radiation induced late effects observed in cerebral nervous system and spinal cord. Acute, subacute and chronic changes are described in terms of pathological, clinical and radiological observations. Brain necrosis in adults is rarely noted below 60 Gy in conventional fractionation, while imaging changes are observed with lower doses. The most widely observed dose limit for the spinal cord is 45 Gy, in the absence of dose modifying chemotherapy. Tumor progression may be hard to distinguish from radiochemotherapy effects. The potential protective role of hyperfractionation is not yet clearly established. Peripheral nerves late effects, although rare, are described.

[Predictive tests of response to radiotherapy. Assessment and perspectives in 1997]

The potential tailoring of radiotherapy modalities to the biological characteristics of individual tumours and normal tissues appears to be an exciting way to improve the therapeutic, ratio in radiation therapy patients. Numerous assays have been proposed to provide the clinician with the biological information necessary to predict the outcome after irradiation and to guide the treatment prescription, but none of them has made its way to daily practice. Major difficulties are due to the technical burden of the procedures, the poor characterization of the assayed cells, and, moreover, the high complexity of tumour and normal tissues biology. The present paper reviews the present status of the assessment of tumour cells radiosensitivity, proliferation and oxygenation. Research remains extremely active in the field of biological predictors of response to irradiation. Future steps forwards are expected from progress in the available technologies, (re-)discovery of apoptosis and investigation of normal tissue tolerance.

Comparative treatment planning between proton and x-ray therapy in esophageal cancer

PURPOSE

Conformal treatment planning with megavoltage x-rays and protons for five patients with esophageal cancer has been studied in an attempt to determine if there are advantages of using protons instead of x-rays.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

For each of the five patients, two different proton plans, one x-ray plan, and one mixed plan with x-rays and protons were made. A three-dimensional treatment planning system, TMS, was used. The evaluation of the different plans was made by applying the tumor control probability (TCP) model proposed by Nahum and Webb and the normal tissue complication (NTCP) model proposed by Lyman on the dose distributions in terms of dose-volume histograms (DVHs).

RESULTS

The comparison shows advantages of using protons instead of x-rays for all five patients. The dose-limiting organs at risk are the spinal cord, the lungs, and the heart, but the proton plans also spare the kidneys better than the x-ray plan does. At 5% NTCP in any risk organ, the calculated mean TCP value for the five patients is increased by an average of 20%-units (from 2 to 23%-units) with the best proton plan compared with x-rays only. However, if we assume maximally a 1% risk in the spinal cord and a total NTCP for the two lungs of 100%, the mean TCP value for the five patients is increased from 6 to 49% with the best proton plan compared with x-rays only. The corresponding figure for the mixed plan is 27%. These gains are relatively insensitive to variations within reasonable limits in the biological parameters.

CONCLUSIONS

Protons appear to have clear therapeutic advantages over conventional external radiotherapy when treating esophageal carcinoma.

Preoperative irradiation affects functional results after surgery for rectal cancer: results from a randomized study

PURPOSE

The Swedish Rectal Cancer Trial has unequivocally demonstrated that preoperative high-dose (5 x 5 Gy) radiotherapy reduces local failure rates and improves overall survival. This will have an impact on the primary treatment of rectal cancer. This study investigates the effect of preoperative high-dose radiotherapy on long-term bowel function in patients treated with anterior resection.

METHODS

A questionnaire was answered by 92 percent (203/220) of patients who were included in the Swedish Rectal Cancer Trial and who were alive after a minimum of five years. Thirty-two patients were excluded, mainly because of postoperative stomas and dementia, which left 171 for analysis.

RESULTS

Median bowel frequency per week was 20 in the irradiated group (n = 84) and 10 in the surgery-alone group (n = 87; P < 0.001). Incontinence for loose stools (P < 0.001), urgency (P < 0.001), and emptying difficulties (P < 0.05) were all more common after irradiation. Sensory functions such as "discrimination between gas and stool" and "ability to safely release flatus" did not, however, differ between groups. Thirty percent of the irradiated group stated that they had an impaired social life because of bowel dysfunction, compared with 10 percent of the surgery-alone group (P < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

The study indicates that high-dose radiotherapy influences long-term bowel function, thus emphasizing the need for finding predictive factors for local recurrence to exclude patients with a very high probability for cure with surgery alone and to use optimized radiation techniques.

Spinal cord dose from standard head and neck irradiation: implications for three-dimensional treatment planning

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Treatment with traditional standard field arrangements for patients with head and neck cancer rarely causes myelopathy. Often, initial treatment fields are reduced to avoid the spinal cord after 45 Gy has been delivered and the cord dose that is delivered by 'off-cord' fields is not calculated. To determine a conservative limit to set for the cord dose for conformally-planned field arrangements, the total spinal cord dose delivered with standard opposed lateral fields was evaluated.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Two types of treatment plans were evaluated for 10 patients enrolled on a parotid-sparing protocol for bilateral head and neck treatment, i.e. (1) standard opposed lateral fields, including large initial fields treating nodal volumes to 45 Gy, off-cord fields for an additional 25 Gy and electron nodal boost fields for an additional 5 Gy and (2) complex 3-D treatment planned field geometries with conformal dose distributions (actual treatment fields). Treatment fields for the protocol conformal plans were arranged so that the maximum cord dose was not to exceed 50 Gy. Dose-volume histograms for both types of planned treatments were analyzed. The maximum and minimum dose to the 1 cm3 cord volume receiving the highest dose were reported.

RESULTS

The maximum dose to the cord from the standard composite plans was on average 52 Gy, with a range of 48.9-55.9 Gy. This consisted of an additional 6.3 Gy (average) from the scatter and block transmission dose from the off-cord lateral fields above the prescribed 45 Gy. For the conformal plans, the maximum dose was on average 49.4 Gy (which is protocol criteria).

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

The maximum spinal cord dose of 50 Gy set as a dose constraint for 3-D treatment planning for conformal plans is a comparable dose to that given in standard opposed lateral head and neck treatments and has been determined to be a conservative spinal cord dose limit, which we have applied in our clinic.

Optimization of intensity modulated beams with volume constraints using two methods: cost function minimization and projections onto convex sets

For accurate prediction of normal tissue tolerance, it is important that the volumetric information of dose distribution be considered. However, in dosimetric optimization of intensity modulated beams, the dose-volume factor is usually neglected. In this paper we describe two methods of volume-dependent optimization for intensity modulated beams such as those generated by computer-controlled multileaf collimators. The first method uses a volume sensitive penalty function in which fast simulated annealing is used for cost function minimization (CFM). The second technique is based on the theory of projections onto convex sets (POCS) in which the dose-volume constraint is replaced by a limit on integral dose. The ability of the methods to respect the dose-volume relationship was demonstrated by using a prostate example involving partial volume constraints to the bladder and the rectum. The volume sensitive penalty function used in the CFM method can be easily adopted by existing optimization programs. The convex projection method can find solutions in much shorter time with minimal user interaction.

CT-simulator based brachytherapy planner: seed localization and incorporation of biological considerations

Radiation dose prescription, interpretation, and planning can be problematic for brachytherapy due to high spatial heterogeneity, varying and various dose rates, absence of superimposed calculated isodose distributions onto affected tissues, and lack of dose volume histograms. A new treatment planner has been developed to reduce these limitations in brachytherapy planning. The PC-based planning system uses a CT-simulator to sequentially scan the patient to generate orthogonal images (to localize seed positions) and subsequently axially scan the patient. This sequential scanning procedure avoids using multiple independent patient scans, templates, external frames, or fiducial markers to register the reconstructed seed positions with patient contours. Dose is computed after assigning activity to (low dose rate) Ir192, linear Cs137, or I125 seeds or dwell times (high dose rate) to the Ir192 source. The planar isodose distribution is superimposed onto axial, coronal, or sagittal views of the tissues following image reconstruction. The treatment plan computes (1) direct and cumulative volume dose histograms for individual tissues, (2) the average, standard deviation, and coefficient of skewness of the dose distribution within individual tissues, (3) an average (over all tissue pixels) survival probability (S) and average survival dose DASD for a given radiation treatment, (4) normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) delivered to a given tissue. All four computed quantities account for dose heterogeneity. These estimates of the biological response to radiation from laboratory-based studies may help guide the evaluation of the prescribed low- or high-dose rate therapy in retrospective and prospective clinical studies at a number of treatment sites.

The need for accurate target and dose specifications in conventional and conformal radiation therapy--an introduction

The need for accurate target and dose in radiotherapy based on new demands for accuracy is discussed in Supplement No. 10, 1997 to Acta Oncologica volume 36 by P. Aaltonen et al. 'Specification of Dose Delivery in Radiation Therapy' which is distributed along with this issue. In the present paper a short summary is presented.

A gradient inverse planning algorithm with dose-volume constraints

An inverse planning algorithm for determining the intensity-modulated beams that will most closely generate a desired dose distribution is presented. The algorithm is three-dimensional and does not explicitly depend on beam energies and modalities. It allows a single prescription dose or a window of acceptable doses to be specified for the target, with additional constraints to account for under- or over-dosing. For the protection of organs at risk, it provides maximum-dose and dose-volume constraints. The latter apply to the entire volume of the organ exposed to the corresponding dose levels. Several levels of each type of constraint, with varying penalty weights, may be specified for each organ. The objective function that serves as the measure of the goodness of the solution is of the least-squares type and is minimized using conjugate gradient methods. Typical clinical cases involving 40,000 points and 4000 rays to be determined require about 10 min of CPU time on a DEC AlphaStation. Results are presented for two clinical sites, prostate and lung. The optimization algorithm yielded plans that featured higher target dose homogeneity, compared with the human planner's plan, while selectively sparing more of the normal organs at the desired dose regions.

A three-field arc technique (3-FAT) for treating prostate cancer

PURPOSE

We have previously designed two external beam radiotherapy techniques for treating prostate cancer. The seven-field, coplanar fixed beam technique resulted in dose distributions that were superior to other coplanar plans studied. The other technique using bilateral blocked arcs produced slightly higher doses to normal tissues but was far simpler to execute. We combined aspects of both these plans to produce a technique that was less complicated yet resulted in an improved dose distribution, i.e., to improve dose delivery to the clinical target volume (CTV) while minimizing doses to the rectum, bladder, and femoral heads.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Twenty patients, previously treated at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) with radiotherapy for adenocarcinoma of the prostate, were studied. Each patient was treated with an immobilizer, urethrogram, and a preplanning CT scan. A previously employed, seven-field, coplanar, fixed beam technique was compared with a newly designed three-field, arc technique (3-FAT). This 3-FAT was designed using two equally weighted rotational beams, with nonuniform blocks, beginning in the lateral gantry position and spanning anteriorly 35 degrees. The two beams became noncoplanar by turning the table 20 degrees, bringing the patient's feet toward the gantry (inferior oblique arcs). An anterior inferior oblique (AIO), angled 20 degrees to the inferior of anterior was included for 10% of the daily treatment. Dose-volume histograms (DVH) were used to evaluate doses to adjacent critical structures. The dose to each critical structure was averaged and tabulated for the 20 patients. In addition, we compared normalized doses to adjacent structures using 3-FAT and seven-coplanar, fixed beams vs. a technique using four noncoplanar, fixed beams.

RESULTS

The three-field arc technique produced favorable dose distributions for the rectum, bladder, and femoral heads. Compared to the seven-field plan, employing the 3-FAT resulted in a 13% lower dose to 40% of the rectum, and 25% lower dose to 40% of the bladder. Compared to the four-field plan, employing the 3-FAT resulted in a 23% lower dose to 40% of the rectum, and 1% decrease in dose to 40% of the bladder. The three-field arc technique reduced the dose delivered to 40% of the femoral heads by approximately 45% when compared to the other techniques. Compared to other standard treatment techniques, the improvement in dose distribution was even greater.

CONCLUSIONS

The 3-FAT represents a technical improvement in the treatment of cancer of the prostate and seminal vesicles by minimizing the dose delivered to adjacent critical structures. The 3-FAT can incorporate the advances of multileaf collimation and digitally reconstructed radiographs to deliver treatment with cost effectiveness and technological efficiency.

The relevance of transforming growth factor beta 1 in pulmonary injury after radiation therapy

The maximum dose of radiation which can be delivered to a tumor is limited by the tolerance of the surrounding normal tissues. The ability to identify patients at high or low risk of injury from radiation therapy might enable the clinician to tailor radiation doses in order to maximize efficacy and minimize risk. The cytokine transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGF beta 1) has been implicated in the development of normal tissue injury after irradiation in several organs, including the lung. Herein, the evidence supporting the role of TGF beta 1 in radiation-induced lung injury is reviewed. Using the treatment of non-small cell lung cancer as a model, we also discuss how it may be possible to identify patients at risk for this complication using measurements of plasma TGF beta 1, and how this information may be used in the future to adjust doses of radiation in the treatment of lung cancer.

[Risk factors of late complications after interstitial 192Ir brachytherapy in cancers of the oral cavity]

Brachytherapy has confirmed its prevailing role in conservative treatment of oral cavity carcinomas. To describe late toxicity in long-term surviving patients, comparisons with other series are necessary. Study of series of patients implanted for floor of the mouth or mobile tongue shows the need for more detailed data. Dental prophylaxy and lead protection of the mandibule, good indications and techniques of brachytherapy are necessary to avoid late complications. Some treatment factors have proved to be of good prognosis for late complications through multivariate analysis of large series treated with lr 192 wires, using the Paris system, eg, dose rate lower than 0.5 or 0.7 Gy/h, intersource spacing smaller than 1.2 or 1.5 cm, treated surface less than 12 cm2, lineic activity less than 1.5 mCi/cm, less than 1 cm diameter hyperdose, and use of mandibular lead protections. Tumor volume and location to the floor of mouth lead to higher risk of complications. Knowledge of treatment-related factors is important, with the development of new afterloading projectors allowing to control the dose rate and correct small inhomogeneities. High-dose rate exclusive brachytherapy is not recommended. More precise and reproducible classification should be used to report complications in series leading to publications in the future, thus allowing to compare results, reduce complication rates and improve the quality of life.

Partial volume rat lung irradiation: an evaluation of early DNA damage

PURPOSE

1. To investigate early DNA damage induced in rat lung cells following single-dose, partial-volume irradiation (lung base and lung apex). 2. To determine the variation in DNA damage in different lung regions. 3. To investigate the possible mechanisms associated with early DNA damage after lung irradiation.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The whole lung or the upper or lower half of the entire lung of Sprague-Dawley rats was exposed to 10 Gy 60Co gamma rays. The animals were sacrificed at various times up to 42 h after irradiation. A trypsin-digested lung cell suspension was prepared and cells that attached to slides in the initial 24-h period were then grown in the presence of culture medium with cytochalasin-B for a further 72 h. Radiation-induced DNA damage was quantified in the cells (primarily fibroblasts) from both irradiated and unirradiated lung regions by using a well-characterized micronucleus assay.

RESULTS

When the lungs were removed at 16-18 h after whole-lung irradiation, about 0.85 micronuclei (MN) per binucleate cell (BNC) were observed in the lung cells of the irradiated animals, compared to 0.02 MN/BNC in the lung cells of the controls. When only the lung base was irradiated, the frequency of micronuclei was 0.85 MN/BNC compared to 0.43 MN/BNC observed in cells from the irradiated lung apex. Of particular interest was the finding that the unirradiated lung apex also showed a large frequency of micronuclei (0.43 MN/BNC) after the irradiation of the lung base, whereas the unirradiated lung base showed only a marginal (approximately 2-fold) increase relative to the spontaneous frequency following irradiation of the lung apex. The changes in the frequency of micronuclei varied with the time at which the lungs were removed from the rats for early times, but had stabilized by 18 h after irradiation. Normal (unirradiated) cells grown in filtered or unfiltered conditioned media obtained from irradiated cell cultures showed an insignificant marginal increase in the number of micronuclei relative to the spontaneous frequency. Lung cells obtained from the lung base or the lung apex of healthy controls and irradiated separately in vitro showed no regional differences in the induction of micronuclei. Cells from the lungs of rats injected with superoxide dismutase, within 1 h prior to irradiation of the lung base, and processed 16-18 h after irradiation showed a reduction in the number of MN in the shielded lung apex, indicating the possible involvement of oxygen radicals.

CONCLUSIONS

These data indicate that cells in the lung base sustain more DNA damage than those in the lung apex when either region is irradiated; however, when the whole lung, is irradiated, the lung damage observed is similar in the two regions. Also, out-of-field effects are observed for the lung apex but not the lung base. Possible mechanisms include a clastogenic (chromosome damaging) factor produced in the plasma following irradiation and/or the production of oxygen radicals by activated lymphocytes/monocytes. The partial blocking of the DNA damage, observed in the unirradiated lung apex following irradiation of the lung base, by superoxide dismutase, suggests that oxygen radicals are involved in this out-of-field effect. These radicals are likely produced as a result of the induction of inflammatory cytokines, such as tumor necrosis factor (TNF) and interleukin-1 (IL-1) by the irradiation. The reason for the lack of an out-of-field effect in the lung base when the lung apex is irradiated is unknown, but may be due to the greater volume of lung irradiated in the lower lung field, because this is likely to affect the level of cytokines produced. Alternatively, it may reflect cytokines produced as a result of the partial liver irradiation that occurs with the lower lung field.

Comparison of radiosurgery treatment modalities based on complication and control probabilities

PURPOSE

The relative efficacy of Gamma Knife, Linac, and Proton treatment modalities for stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) was investigated on the basis of normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) and tumor control probability (TCP), calculated for representative test cases.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Five radiosurgery patient cases were selected to cover a range of treatment-planning situations from small spherical volumes to large irregular volumes. A target volume consisting of contours drawn on CT transverse slices was prepared for each case. Plans were developed using the three treatment modalities for each case, with the objective of encompassing the target as closely as possible with a prescription isodose line and minimizing dose to normal tissue, within the constraints of current clinical practice. Dose-volume histograms (DVH) were calculated for the target and for normal tissue, and these histograms were used to calculate NTCP and TCP values for each plan.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Differences in NTCP and TCP values were found to depend on treatment modality, size, shape, and location of the target, the amount of effort devoted to treatment planning, and the complexity of the plan.

Abutting orthogonal electron and photon beams in the head and neck region using asymmetrical photon beam edges

Irradiation of target volumes within the ethmoid sinus and nasal cavity region has, at our institution, been performed using one anterior electron beam, abutted to two opposing lateral photon beams, in order to exclude the orbit from the irradiated volume. However, this technique give rise to larger dose hetereogeneities within the target volume, as well as undesired hot spots in the chiasma region. To reduce the inhomogenious distribution, we have introduced asymmetrical photon beam edges to broaden the penumbra of the two opposing photon beams resembling the dose gradient of the perpendicular electron beam. The achieved reduction in dose heterogeneity, measured from the differential dose-volume-histogram, is in the order of 30-40% when applying the asymmetrical abutting technique compared with the conventional two opposing photon beam technique. As demonstrated by calculating the tumour control probability (TCP), the increase in dose homogeneity within the target volume, may be of clinical significance.

[The inhalation versus systemic prevention of pneumonitis during thoracic irradiation]

BACKGROUND

Pneumonitis is a typical subacute reaction of healthy bronchial tissue to thoracic irradiation. The purpose of the present trial was to show whether prophylactic application of steroids in the course of and following radiotherapy would reduce the incidence of pneumonitis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Fifty-seven patients receiving thoracic irradiation for bronchial carcinoma were assigned to 2 therapeutic groups; half of the patients were given 10 mg of oral prednisolone per day, while the other half received daily inhalative beclomethasone. All patients were evaluated for radiographic signs of pneumonitis. Thirty-two patients received additional investigations for pulmonary diffusion capacity of carbon monoxide.

RESULTS

The overall incidence of pneumonitis was 17.6% (10/57 patients). Neither total radiation dose nor mode of fractionation did significantly contribute to the incidence of pneumonitis. Those patients showing a pulmonary diffusion capacity for carbon monoxide of less than 60% prior to radiotherapy had a significantly higher risk of developing pneumonitis (4/7) than patients with a higher diffusion capacity (3/25, p = 0.026). In follow-up period we did not see significant changes in diffusion capacity neither with patients who developed pneumonitis nor with those patients showing no evidence of pulmonary injury. Comparing the chest X-ray there were less radiographic changes consistent with pneumonitis in the inhalative beclomethasone (2/28) than in the oral prednisolone group (8/29, p = 0.045).

DISCUSSION

In order to reduce the incidence of pneumonitis in patients receiving thoracic irradiation we support a continuous application of steroids in the course of and following radiotherapy. The inhalative use of beclomethasone has proved to be superior to oral prednisolone due to better local efficacy and decreased unwanted side effects.

Mucosal changes of the free jejunal graft in response to radiotherapy

BACKGROUND

Microvascular free jejunal transfer was employed for reconstruction of pharyngeal defect resulting from circumferential resection of the hypopharynx. Postoperative radiotherapy to the neck might affect the graft, but this information was lacking. The mucosal changes of the jejunum in response to radiation were identified in this prospective study.

METHODS

Normal jejunal mucosa was obtained at operation, and endoscopic jejunal mucosal biopsies were taken during and at completion of radiotherapy. Endoscopic biopsies were repeated at 1, 3, 6, 12, and 24 months afterwards. All jejunal biopsies were subjected to histologic and scanning electron microscopic (SEM) examinations. Nine patients had a complete set of biopsy while 5 other patients who received no radiotherapy also went through a similar sequence of biopsies as controls.

RESULTS

Histologic examination showed mucosal edema and extensive blunting of jejunal villi at the completion of radiotherapy. Increased fibrosis with focal loss of glands was noticed at 3 months after radiotherapy, and this remained throughout the 2-year period. SEM revealed patchy loss of microvilli at completion and at 1 month after radiotherapy, but this feature was not apparent in biopsies taken at 3 months onwards, showing that it was only a transient event.

CONCLUSIONS

Transient responses and persistent changes of jejunal mucosa to radiotherapy were identified and characterized. The presence of these mucosal lesions was not associated with any clinically significant adverse effect in the graft up to 2 years postradiotherapy.

[3-Dimensional irradiation planning in brain tumors. The advantages of the method and the clinical results]

PURPOSE

Radiotherapy became an important component in the treatment of brain gliomas. The aim of this study is to analyse several advantages of the three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy in comparison with a two-dimensional conventional technique and to present the clinical results of 43 patients with brain gliomas treated according to a three-dimensional planning.

PATIENTS AND METHOD

Between January 1994 and December 1995, 43 patients with malignant brain gliomas (WHO III and IV) were treated in our department according to a three-dimensional treatment planning. The patients received a total irradiation dose of 60 Gy, 2 Gy/day, 5 days/week. The rate of survival was analysed in relation with the known prognostical factors: histology, Karnofsky index, age, resection status. In 10 patients a three-dimensional treatment planning was compared with a conventional two-dimensional planning: the volume of the normal brain tissue irradiated to high dose levels (95% isodose) and the normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) for the brain by Kutcher and Lyman were comparatively analysed.

RESULTS

The survival rate for the whole group was 14 months. The histology of the tumor, age, Karnofsky index and resection status were important prognostical factors. The three-dimensional planning allows a 15 to 20% reduction in the volume of normal brain tissue irradiated to high dose levels (95% isodose). The NTCP is significantly lower using the three-dimensional technique (range 0.03% to 13%), in comparison with the two-dimensional conventional technique (range 0.1% to 26%). The value of NTCP increases with tumor volume.

CONCLUSIONS

Concerning the tumor control and survival rate, the three-dimensional treatment planning shows no advantages compared to the standard conventional methods. The main advantage of the three-dimensional treatment planning is the possibility to spare normal brain tissue. The possibility to integrate mathematical models in the evaluation of the therapy could give this technique new dimensions.

Hyperthermia may decrease the development of telangiectasia after radiotherapy

CASE REPORT

A patient with recurrent breast cancer was reirradiated twice on adjacent fields with a time interval of 9 months. The first time she was treated with reirradiation alone, the second time with reirradiation plus hyperthermia. The reirradiation schedule for both fields was 8 x 4 Gy in 4 weeks. Both fields overlapped partly with the field of postoperative radiotherapy, which was applied 57 and 66 months earlier to a total dose of 40.5 Gy.

RESULTS

During the 52 to 61 months follow-up, a remarkable difference in telangiectasia development, between the parts of the reirradiation fields overlapping with the primary radiotherapy field, became apparent. Telangiectasia was observed 9 months after treatment with reirradiation alone and progressed to confluent in 47 months after treatment. In the reirradiation plus hyperthermia area, the maximum observed telangiectasia was slight until 52 months after treatment.

DISCUSSION

The difference in the development of telangiectasia between these fields cannot be explained by differences in any of the known radiation treatment related prognostic factors. A protective effect by hyperthermia has been suggested by Haveman and coworkers, who have shown experimentally that heat treatment leads to enhanced proliferation of endothelial cells, thereby inducing a fast repopulation and replacement of X-ray damaged cells.

CONCLUSION

This difference in telangiectasia formation is an interesting observation. Whether such a protective effect of hyperthermia is of general relevance has to become clear from more extensive clinical studies.

The effect of carbon fibre inserts on the build-up and attenuation of high energy photon beams

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The use of new materials in radiotherapy requires an investigation of the effects of these materials on the relevant beam parameters. The high strength and low density of carbon fibre suggest an excellent material for table inserts with minimal attenuation, without changing the skin sparing effect in the build-up zone.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this paper three different carbon fibre plates and two conventionally table top materials are studied in Co-60, 6 MV and 23 MV photon beams.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

From depth dose measurements it is clear that the dose in the build-up zone is influenced in the qualities of the beams. The mutual differences for the three carbon plates are minimal. For Co-60 the depth of the maximum dose is decreased by carbon from 5 to 2 mm and the surface dose is increased from 18 to 76%. For 6 and 23 MV the surface dose is increased from 21 to 52% and 20 to 32%, respectively, as well as the dose in the build-up region. A transmission of 99% was measured for two carbon plates out of three in Co-60 and for one out of three in 6 MV.

Target volume definition in radiation therapy

Target volume definition in radiation therapy is a broad field of interdisciplinary research. We give a brief history of clinical research in this field and outline some remarkable steps which led to the well-defined target volume concepts. The challenges in target volume definition for high-precision conformal radiation therapy are discussed, and possibilities of improving target volume definition, such as the integration of modern imaging modalities and the use of computer-based systems to support the radiation oncologist are indicated, as well as novel techniques for increasing the accuracy of patient positioning. All these tools should be evaluated with regard to their potential for increasing the therapeutic ratio and, as appropriate, should be implemented in clinical practice. However, target volume definition is a complex process influenced by many factors, currently under investigation. While questions remain in this field, and the impact of the influencing factors is not defined, the process of target volume definition should remain the subject of clinical research.

Tumor bed brachytherapy with a mesh template: an accessible alternative to intraoperative radiotherapy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Locally advanced and recurrent malignancies often require adjuvant radiotherapy to achieve tumor control. We report our experience with a technique that uses an intraoperatively placed mesh template for the delivery of radiotherapy.

METHODS

from 1988 to 1996, 14 patients were treated with tumor bed brachytherapy using this mesh technique. Sites of involvement included the head and neck region (n = 6), abdomen/pelvis (n = 4), retroperitoneum (n = 3), and the lower extremity (n = 1). During surgery, plastic catheters were evenly placed within a mesh template (Vicryl or Marlex), which was positioned in the tumor bed. The catheters were afterloaded with radioactive sources once the final pathology had been determined and the patient required limited nursing care. Radiation dose was titrated to the surgico-pathologic findings (e.g., margin status).

RESULTS

All of the patients tolerated the procedure without experiencing acute or chronic sequelae. The median survival time was 13 months. Local control was achieved in 11 of 13 evaluable patients, with an actuarial local control of 82% at 6 months.

CONCLUSION

Tumor bed brachytherapy with a mesh implant is a practical technique to improve tumor control and warrants further investigation.

Physical and biological predictors of changes in whole-lung function following thoracic irradiation

PURPOSE

To develop methods of predicting the pulmonary consequences of thoracic irradiation (RT) by prospectively studying changes in pulmonary function following RT.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

100 patients receiving incidental partial-lung irradiation during treatment of tumors in or adjacent to the thorax had whole-lung function assessed via symptoms and pulmonary function tests (PFTs: FEV1-forced expiratory volume 1 s; DLCO-diffusion capacity) before and repeatedly 6-48 months following RT. All had computed tomography-based three-dimensional (3D) dose calculations with lung density heterogeneity corrections for dose-volume histogram (DVH) and normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) calculations. Functional DVHs (DVfH) based on SPECT (single photon emission computed tomography) lung perfusion scans, and serial transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta1) levels were available in 50 and 48 patients, respectively. The incidence and severity of changes in whole-lung function were correlated with clinical, physical, and biological factors. Exploratory statistical analyses were performed using chi-square, Pearson correlations, logistic regression, and multiple linear regression.

RESULTS

RT-induced symptoms developed in 21 patients. In the overall group, the single best predictor for the development of symptoms was the NTCP (p < 0.05). Pre-RT PFTs alone were less predictive (p = 0.1 for FEV1, p = 0.08 for DLCO). A multivariate model based on pre-RT DLCO and CT-based NTCP was strongly predictive for the development of symptoms (p < 0.001). NTCPs based on SPECT-derived DVf Hs and TGF-beta1 levels did not appear to provide additional predictive value. The presence or absence of pulmonary symptoms was correlated with the decline in PFT 6 months following RT (p < 0.05). In the overall group, the degree of decline in PFTs was not well correlated with any of the dose-volume variables considered. In patients with "good" pre-RT PFTs, there was a relationship between the percent reduction in PFT and dose-volume parameters such as the percent of lung volume receiving > 30 Gy (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The extent of alteration in whole-lung function (symptoms or PFT changes) appears to be related to both dose-volume and pre-RT PFT parameters. The data suggest that no one variable is likely to be an adequate predictor and that multivariate predictive models will be needed. Additional studies are underway to develop better predictive models that consider physical factors such as the DVH and regional perfusion, as well as biological/clinical factors such as pre-RT PFTs and TGF-beta1.