Codon and amino-acid specificities of a transfer RNA are both converted by a single post-transcriptional modification

Triple aminoacylation specificity of a chimerized transfer RNA

We report here the rational design and construction of a chimerized transfer RNA with tripartite aminoacylation specificity. A yeast aspartic acid specific tRNA was transformed into a highly efficient acceptor of alanine and phenylalanine and a moderate acceptor of valine. The transformation was guided by available knowledge of the requirements for aminoacylation by each of the three amino acids and was achieved by iterative changes in the local sequence context and the structural framework of the variable loop and the two variable regions of the dihydrouridine loop. The changes introduced to confer efficient acceptance of the three amino acids eliminate aminoacylation with aspartate. The interplay of determinants and antideterminants for different specific aminoacylations, and the constraints imposed by the structural framework, suggest that a tRNA with an appreciable capacity for more than three efficient aminoacylations may be inherently difficult to achieve.

On concerted origin of transfer RNAs with complementary anticodons

Pairs of antiparallely oriented consensus tRNAs with complementary anticodons show surprisingly small numbers of mispairings within the 17-bp- long anticodon stem and loop region. Even smaller such complementary distances are shown by illegitimately complementary anticodons, i.e. those with allowed pairing between G and U bases. Accordingly, we suppose that transfer RNAs have emerged concertedly as complementary strands of primordial double helix-like RNA molecules. Replication of such molecules with illegitimately complementary anticodons might generate new synonymous codons for the same pair of amino acids. Logically, the idea of tRNA concerted origin dictates very ancient establishment of direct links between anticodons and the type of amino acids with which pre-tRNAs were to be charged. More specifically, anticodons (first of all, the 2nd base) could selectively target 'their' amino acids, reaction of acylating itself being performed by another non-specific site of pre-tRNA or even by another ribozyme. In all, the above findings and speculations are consistent to the hypercyclic concept (Eigen and Schuster, 1979), and throw new light on the genetic code origin and associated problems. Also favoring this idea are data on complementary codon usage patterns in different genomes.

The evolutionary change of the genetic code as restricted by the anticodon and identity of transfer RNA

The discovery of non-universal genetic codes in several mitochondria and nuclear systems during the part ten years has necessitated a reconsideration of the concept that the genetic code is universal and frozen, as was once believed. Here, the flexibility of the relationship between codons and amino acids is discussed on the basis of the distribution of non-universal genetic codes in various organisms insofar as has been observed to date. Judging from the result of recent investigations into tRNA identity, it would appear that the non-participation of the anticodon in recognition by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase has significantly influenced the variability of codons.

Anticodon bases C34 and C35 are major, positive, identity elements in Saccharomyces cerevisiae tRNA(Trp)

A single form of tRNA(Trp) exists in the yeast cytoplasm to respond to the unique codon, UGG, which specifies this amino acid. Mutations in the anticodon of the corresponding gene, which generate potential nonsense suppressor tRNAs, have been generated in vitro and tested in vivo for biological activity. The amber (C35U) and opal (C34U) suppressors show strong and weak activities respectively while the ochre suppressor (C34U,C35U) has no detectable biological activity. To understand the basis for these differences, a set of synthetic tRNA(Trp) genes has been constructed to permit in vitro, T7 RNA polymerase synthesis of transcripts corresponding to the normal and mutant tRNAs. Kinetic parameters for aminoacylation of these transcripts by purified, yeast, tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase have been measured and compared to values observed using the naturally occurring tRNA(Trp) as a substrate. The efficiency of aminoacylation is reduced by 40, 2000, and 30,000 fold by the C35U, C34U, and C34U,C35U mutations respectively. Interestingly, the C35U change affects only tRNA binding while C34U also alters catalytic efficiency. We conclude that both C34 and C35 are major identity elements in the recognition of tRNA(Trp) by its cognate synthetase. These differences in aminoacylation efficiency closely parallel the in vivo suppressor activities of the mutants.

Editing corrects mispairing in the acceptor stem of bean and potato mitochondrial phenylalanine transfer RNAs

Editing is a general event in plant mitochondrial messenger RNAs, but has never been detected in a plant mitochondrial transfer RNA (tRNA). We demonstrate here the occurrence of a tRNA editing event in higher plant mitochondria: in both bean and potato, the C encoded at position 4 in the mitochondrial tRNA(Phe)(GAA) gene is converted into a U in the mature tRNA. This nucleotide change corrects the mismatched C4-A69 base-pair which appears when folding the gene sequence into the cloverleaf structure and it is consistent with the fact that C to U transitions constitute the common editing events affecting plant mitochondrial messenger RNAs. The tRNA(Phe)(GAA) gene is located upstream of the single copy tRNA(Pro)(UGG) gene in both the potato and the bean mitochondrial DNAs. The sequences of potato and bean tRNA(Pro)(UGG) genes are colinear with the sequence of the mature bean mitochondrial tRNA(Pro)(UGG), demonstrating that this tRNA is not edited. A single copy tRNA(Ser)(GCU) gene was found upstream of the tRNA(Phe) gene in the potato mitochondrial DNA. A U6-U67 mismatched base-pair appears in the cloverleaf folding of this gene and is maintained in the mature potato mitochondrial tRNA(Ser)(GCU), which argues in favour of the hypothesis that the editing system of plant mitochondria can only perform C to U or occasionally U to C changes.

An operational RNA code for amino acids and possible relationship to genetic code

RNA helical oligonucleotides that recapitulate the acceptor stems of transfer RNAs, and that are devoid of the anticodon trinucleotides of the genetic code, are aminoacylated by aminoacyl tRNA synthetases. The specificity of aminoacylation is sequence dependent, and both specificity and efficiency are generally determined by only a few nucleotides proximal to the amino acid attachment site. This sequence/structure-dependent aminoacylation of RNA oligonucleotides constitutes an operational RNA code for amino acids. To a rough approximation, members of the two different classes of tRNA synthetases are, like tRNAs, organized into two major domains. The class-defining conserved domain containing the active site incorporates determinants for recognition of RNA mini-helix substrates. This domain may reflect the primordial synthetase, which was needed for expression of the operational RNA code. The second synthetase domain, which generally is less or not conserved, provides for interactions with the second domain of tRNA, which incorporates the anticodon. The emergence of the genetic from the operational RNA code could occur when the second domain of synthetases was added with the anticodon-containing domain of tRNAs.

An unusual RNA tertiary interaction has a role for the specific aminoacylation of a transfer RNA

The nucleotides in a tRNA that specifically interact with the cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase have been found largely located in the helical stems, the anticodon, or the discriminator base, where they vary from one tRNA to another. The conserved and semiconserved nucleotides that are responsible for the tRNA tertiary structure have been shown to have little role in synthetase recognition. Here we report that aminoacylation of Escherichia coli tRNA(Cys) depends on the anticodon, the discriminator base, and a tertiary interaction between the semiconserved nucleotides at positions 15 and 48. While all other tRNAs contain a purine at position 15 and a complementary pyrimidine at position 48 that establish the tertiary interaction known as the Levitt pair, E. coli tRNA(Cys) has guanosine -15 and -48. Replacement of guanosine -15 or -48 with cytidine virtually eliminates aminoacylation. Structural analyses with chemical probes suggest that guanosine -15 and -48 interact through hydrogen bonds between the exocyclic N-2 and ring N-3 to stabilize the joining of the two long helical stems of the tRNA. This tertiary interaction is different from the traditional base pairing scheme in the Levitt pair, where hydrogen bonds would form between N-1 and O-6. Our results provide evidence for a role of RNA tertiary structure in synthetase recognition.

Modification of tRNA as a regulatory device

Our knowledge of the different biological roles of tRNA modification has increased considerably in recent years. Not only have we learned about how modified nucleosides affect the performance of tRNA in translation, but also how they influence regulation of intermediary metabolism, antibiotics production, gene expression in eukaryotic viruses, cell division, cell-cycle control, u.v. sensitivity, and mutation frequency. This review summarizes our current understanding of the role of tRNA modification.

A 2-thiouridine derivative in tRNAGlu is a positive determinant for aminoacylation by Escherichia coli glutamyl-tRNA synthetase

Early investigations into the interaction between Escherichia coli glutamyl-tRNA synthetase (GluRS) and tRNAGlu have implicated the modified nucleoside 5-[(methylamino)methyl]-2-thiouridine in the first position of the anticodon as an important contact for efficient aminoacylation. However, the experimental methods employed were not sufficient to determine whether the interaction was dependent on the presence of the modification or simply involved other anticodon loop-nucleotides, now occluded from interaction with the synthetase. Unmodified E. coli tRNA(Glu), derived by in vitro transcription of the corresponding gene, is a poor substrate for GluRS, exhibiting a 100-fold reduction in its specificity constant (kcat/KM) compared to that of tRNA(Glu) prepared from an overproducing strain. Through the use of recombinant RNA technology, we created several hybrid tRNAs which combined sequences from the in vitro transcript with that of the native tRNA, resulting in tRNA molecules differing in modified base content. By in vitro aminoacylation of these hybrid tRNA molecules and of tRNAs with base substitutions at positions of nucleotide modification, we show conclusively that the modified uridine at position 34 in tRNA(Glu) is required for efficient aminoacylation by E. coli GluRS. This is only the second example of a tRNA modification acting as a positive determinant for interaction with its cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase.

Association of tRNA(Gln) acceptor identity with phosphate-sugar backbone interactions observed in the crystal structure of the Escherichia coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase-tRNA(Gln) complex

We isolated several mutants with nucleotide substitutions in alanine tRNA (tRNA(Ala)) that resulted in glutamine tRNA (tRNA(Gln)) acceptor identity in Escherichia coli. These substitutions were in three regions of tRNA structure not previously associated with tRNA(Gln) acceptor identity. Only the phosphate-sugar backbone moieties of these nucleotides interact with the enzyme in the previously determined X-ray crystal structure of the complex between tRNA(Gln) and glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase. We conclude that these sequence-dependent phosphate-sugar backbone interactions contribute to tRNA(Gln) identity, and argue that the interactions help communicate enzyme recognition of the anticodon to the acceptor end of the tRNA and the catalytic center of the enzyme.

The anticodon triplet is not sufficient to confer methionine acceptance to a transfer RNA

Previous work suggested that the presence of the anticodon CAU alone was enough to confer methionine acceptance to a tRNA. Conversions of Escherichia coli nonmethionine tRNAs to a methionine-accepting species were obtained by substitutions reconstructing the whole methionine anticodon loop together with preservation (or introduction) of the acceptor stem base A73. We show here that the CAU triplet alone is unable to confer methionine acceptance when transplanted into a yeast aspartic tRNA. Both non-anticodon bases of the anticodon loop of yeast tRNA(Met) and A73 are required in addition to CAU for methionine acceptance. The importance of these non-anticodon bases in other CAU-containing tRNA frameworks was also established. These specific non-anticodon base interactions make a substantial thermodynamic contribution to the methionine acceptance of a transfer RNA.

Molecular mimicry in translational control of E. coli threonyl-tRNA synthetase gene. Competitive inhibition in tRNA aminoacylation and operator-repressor recognition switch using tRNA identity rules

We previously showed that: (i) E.coli threonyl-tRNA synthetase (ThrRS) binds to the leader of its mRNA and represses translation by preventing ribosome binding to its loading site; (ii) the translational operator shares sequence and structure similarities with tRNA(Thr); (iii) it is possible to switch the specificity of the translational control from ThrRS to methionyl-tRNA synthetase (MetRS) by changing the CGU anticodon-like sequence to CAU, the tRNA(Met) anticodon. Here, we show that the wild type (CGU) and the mutated (CAU) operators act as competitive inhibitors of tRNA(Thr) and tRNA(fMet) for aminoacylation catalyzed by E.coli ThrRS and MetRS, respectively. The apparent Kd of the MetRS/CAU operator complex is one order magnitude higher than that of the ThrRS/CGU operator complex. Although ThrRS and MetRS shield the anticodon- and acceptor-like domains of their respective operators, the relative contribution of these two domains differs significantly. As in the threonine system, the interaction of MetRS with the CAU operator occludes ribosome binding to its loading site. The present data demonstrate that the anticodon-like sequence is one major determinant for the identity of the operator and the regulation specificity. It further shows that the tRNA-like operator obeys to tRNA identity rules.

Affinity electrophoretic detection of primary amino groups in nucleic acids: application to modified bases of tRNA and to aminoacylation

Thiolation of primary amino groups in tRNA with the heterobifunctional reagent N-succinimidyl 3-(2-pyridyldithio)propionate gives rise to species which are retarded during electrophoresis in organomercury-containing polyacrylamide gels. Since such amino groups occur, as far as is known, only as part of the modified bases 3-(3-amino-3-carboxypropyl)uridine and N-2-(5-amino-5-carboxypentyl)cytidine or as the alpha-amino group of aminoacylated tRNAs, this extension of the principle of affinity electrophoresis can be used for the detection and analysis of a specific functional group in both single tRNA species and in a mixed population. The strength of the interaction may be quantified and provides information on the chemical environment/conformation of the derivatized bases.

The role of anticodon bases and the discriminator nucleotide in the recognition of some E. coli tRNAs by their aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

The T7 polymerase transcription system was used for in vitro synthesis of unmodified versions of the E. coli tRNA mutants that insert asparagine, cysteine, glycine, histidine, and serine. These tRNAs were used to qualitatively explore the role of some anticodon bases and the discriminator nucleotide in the recognition of tRNA by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. Coupled with data from earlier studies, these new results essentially complete a survey of all E. coli tRNAs with respect to the involvement of anticodon bases and the discriminator nucleotide in tRNA recognition. It is found that in the vast majority of tRNAs both of these elements are significant components of tRNA identity. This is not universally true, however. Anticodon sequences are unimportant in tRNA(Ser), tRNA(Leu), and tRNA(Ala) while the discriminator base is inconsequential in tRNA(Ser) and tRNA(Thr). The significance of these results for origin-of-life studies is discussed.

RNA binding determinant in some class I tRNA synthetases identified by alignment-guided mutagenesis

The N-terminal nucleotide binding folds of all 10 class I tRNA synthetases (RSs) contain characteristic conserved sequence motifs that define this class of synthetases. Sequences of C-terminal domains, which in some cases are known to interact with anticodons, are divergent. In the 676-amino acid Escherichia coli methionyl-tRNA synthetase (MetRS), interactions with the methionine tRNA anticodon are sensitive to substitutions at a specific location on the surface of the C-terminal domain of this protein of known three-dimensional structure. Although four class I synthetases of heterogeneous lengths and unknown structures are believed to be historically related to MetRS, pair-wise sequence similarities in the region of this RNA binding determinant are obscure. A multiple alignment of all sequences of three of these synthetases with all MetRS sequences suggested a location for the functional analog of the anticodon-binding site in these enzymes. We chose a member of this set for alignment-guided mutagenesis, combined with a functional analysis of mutant proteins. Substitutions within two amino acids of the site fixed by the multiple sequence alignment severely affected interactions with tRNA but not with ATP or amino acid. Multiple individual replacements at this location do not disrupt enzyme stability, indicating this segment is on the surface, as in the MetRS structure. The results suggest the location of an RNA binding determinant in each of these three synthetases of unknown structure.

Striking effects of coupling mutations in the acceptor stem on recognition of tRNAs by Escherichia coli Met-tRNA synthetase and Met-tRNA transformylase

We measured kinetic parameters in vitro and directly analyzed aminoacylation and formylation levels in vivo to study recognition of Escherichia coli initiator tRNA mutants by E. coli Met-tRNA synthetase and Met-tRNA transformylase. We show that, in addition to the anticodon sequence, mutations in the "discriminator" base A73 also affect aminoacylation. An A73----U change has a small effect, but a change to G73 or C73 significantly lowers Vmax/Kappm for in vitro aminoacylation and leads to appreciable accumulation of uncharged tRNA in vivo. Significantly, coupling of the G73 mutation with G72, a neighboring-base mutation, results in a tRNA essentially uncharged in vivo. Coupling of C73 and U73 mutations with G72 does not have such an effect. Elements crucial for Met-tRNA transformylase recognition of tRNAs are located at the end of the acceptor stem. These elements include a weak base pair or a mismatch between nucleotides (nt) 1 and 72 and base pairs 2.71 and 3.70. The natures of nt 1 and 72 are less important than the fact that they do not form a strong Watson-Crick base pair. Interestingly, the negative effect of a C.G base pair between nt 1 and 72 is suppressed by mutation of the neighboring nucleotide A73 to either C73 or U73. The presence of C73 or U73 could destabilize the C1.G72 base pair at the end of an RNA helix. Thus, in some tRNAs, the discriminator base could affect stability of the base pair between nt 1 and 72 and thereby the structure of tRNA at the end of the acceptor stem.

Involvement of the size and sequence of the anticodon loop in tRNA recognition by mammalian and E. coli methionyl-tRNA synthetases

The rates of the cross-aminoacylation reactions of tRNAs(Met) catalyzed by methionyl-tRNA synthetases from various organisms suggest the occurrence of two types of tRNA(Met)/methionyl-tRNA synthetase systems. In this study, the tRNA determinants recognized by mammalian or E. coli methionyl-tRNA synthetases, which are representative members of the two types, have been examined. Like its prokaryotic counterpart, the mammalian enzyme utilizes the anticodon of tRNA as main recognition element. However, the mammalian cytoplasmic elongator tRNA(Met) species is not recognized by the bacterial synthetase, and both the initiator and elongator E. coli tRNA(Met) behave as poor substrates of the mammalian cytoplasmic synthetase. Synthetic genes encoding variants of tRNAs(Met), including the elongator one from mammals, were expressed in E. coli. tRNAs(Met) recognized by a synthetase of a given type can be converted into a substrate of an enzyme of the other type by introducing one-base substitutions in the anticodon loop or stem. In particular, a reduction of the size of the anticodon loop of cytoplasmic mammalian elongator tRNA(Met) from 9 to 7 bases, through the creation of an additional Watson-Crick pair at the bottom of the anticodon stem, makes it a substrate of the prokaryotic enzyme and decreases its ability to be methionylated by the mammalian enzyme. Moreover, enlarging the size of the anticodon loop of E. coli tRNA(Metm) from 7 to 9 bases, by disrupting the base pair at the bottom of the anticodon stem, renders the resulting tRNA a good substrate of the mammalian enzyme, while strongly altering its reaction with the prokaryotic synthetase. Finally, E. coli tRNA(Metf) can be rendered a better substrate of the mammalian enzyme by changing its U33 into a C. This modification makes the sequence of the anticodon loop of tRNA(Metf) identical to that of cytoplasmic initiator tRNA(Met).

Characterization of the chromosomal aac(6')-Ic gene from Serratia marcescens

The DNA sequence of the chromosomal aac(6')-Ic gene from Serratia marcescens, which had been previously cloned (H. M. Champion, P. M. Bennett, D. A. Lewis, and D. S. Reeves, J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 22:587-596, 1988) was determined. High-pressure liquid chromatographic analysis of extracts prepared from Escherichia coli carrying the chromosomal aac(6')-Ic gene on a plasmid confirmed the presence of 6'-N-acetyltransferase activity in this strain, which was suggested by the aminoglycoside resistance profile. DNA sequence analysis of the cloned 2,057-bp PstI fragment revealed several regions of homology to previously characterized sequences from GenBank, including the rpoD and tRNA-2 genes of E. coli. Subcloning experiments confirmed the coding sequence of the aac(6')-Ic gene to be at positions 1554 to 1992. The predicted amino acid sequence of the AAC(6')-Ic protein suggested that it was the third member of a family of AAC(6') proteins which included a coding region identified between the aadB and aadA genes of Tn4000 and an AAC(6') protein encoded by pUO490, which was isolated from Enterobacter cloacae. Primer extension analysis suggested that the -35 region of the aac(6')-Ic promoter overlapped a large palindromic sequence which may be involved in the regulation of the aac(6')-Ic gene. Hybridization experiments utilizing a restriction fragment from the aac(6')-Ic gene showed that all S. marcescens organisms carried this gene whether or not the AAC(6')-I resistance profile was expressed. Organisms other than Serratia spp. did not hybridize to this probe.

Small RNA helices as substrates for aminoacylation and their relationship to charging of transfer RNAs

RNA microhelices that reconstruct the acceptor stems of transfer RNAs can be aminoacylated. The anticodon-independent aminoacylation is sequence-specific and suggests a relationship between amino acids and nucleotide sequences which is different from that of the classical genetic code. The specific aminoacylation of RNA microhelices also suggests a highly differentiated adaptation of the structures of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases to sequences in the acceptor stems of transfer RNAs.

Self-splicing introns in tRNA genes of widely divergent bacteria

The organization of eukaryotic genes into exons separated by introns has been considered as a primordial arrangement but because it does not exist in eubacterial genomes it may be that introns are relatively recent acquisitions. A self-splicing group I intron has been found in cyanobacteria at the same position of the same gene (that encoding leucyl transfer RNA, UAA anticodon) as a similar group I intron of chloroplasts, which indicates that this intron predates the invasion of eukaryotic cells by cyanobacterial endosymbionts. But it is not clear from this isolated example whether introns are more generally present in different genes or in more diverse branches of the eubacteria. Many mitochondria have intron-rich genomes and were probably derived from the alpha subgroup of the purple bacteria (or Proteobacteria), so ancient introns might also have been retained in these bacteria. We describe here the discovery of two small (237 and 205 nucleotides) self-splicing group I introns in members of two proteobacterial subgroups, Agrobacterium tumefaciens (alpha) and Azoarcus sp. (beta). The introns are inserted in genes for tRNA(Arg) and tRNA(Ile), respectively, after the third anticodon nucleotide. Their occurrence in different genes of phylogenetically diverse bacteria indicates that group I introns have a widespread distribution among eubacteria.

The T-loop region of animal mitochondrial tRNA(Ser)(AGY) is a main recognition site for homologous seryl-tRNA synthetase

Recognition sites of bovine mitochondrial serine tRNA specific for condons AGY [tRNA(Ser) (AGY)] by the cognate mitochondrial seryl-tRNA synthetase were studied using a range of tRNA(Ser)(AGY) variants which were obtained by the in vitro transcription of synthetic tRNA genes with T7 RNA polymerase. Base replacements in the anticodon and discriminator sites did not affect serine acceptance. However, deletion and/or replacement in the T-loop region completely deprived the variants of their charging activities. Point mutation experiments in this region also showed that the adenosine residue in the middle of the T-loop (position 58), which is involved in tertiary interaction between the T-loop and the truncated D-arm [de Bruijn and Klug, 1983] played a significant role in the recognition process by the synthetase.

In vitro study of E.coli tRNA(Arg) and tRNA(Lys) identity elements

Various tRNA transcripts were constructed to study the identity elements of E.coli tRNA(Arg) and tRNA(Lys). Exchange of the anticodon of the major tRNA(Arg) from ACG to either CCG or CCU did not result in a significant loss of arginine acceptor activity, whereas not only that to UUU but also that to ACA or ACC decreased the activity. Base substitutions and deletion at A20 also impaired the arginine charging activity by over 50-fold. Arginine charging activity was introduced by either substitution of the anticodon from UAC to ACG in tRNA(Val) or from UUU to UCU in tRNA(Lys). Only a single base substitution at the third position of tRNA(Trp) anticodon (CCA) from A to G also gave rise to arginine charging activity, which was elevated to a comparable level to that of the tRNA(Arg) transcript by an additional A20 insertion. Base substitutions of the major tRNA(Arg) at the discriminator position into pyrimidines led to a decrease by factors of three to four. These data show that the third letter of the anticodon G36 or U36 besides the second letter C35 and the A20 in the variable pocket is responsible for the arginine acceptor identity, to which the discriminator base A73 or G73 contributes in an auxiliary fashion. In contrast to the arginine system, the transcript with the wild-type tRNA(Lys) sequence showed only 140-fold lower lysine charging activity than the native tRNA(Lys), suggesting the involvement of base modifications in recognition. Replacement of the anticodon UUU with not only UCU and UAC but also UUA and UUC seriously affected the lysine acceptor activity, and those with GUU and UUG also decreased by factors of 17 and 5, respectively. Introduction of UUU into the anticodons conferred lysine charging activity upon both tRNA(Val) and tRNA(Arg). Substitution of the discriminator base A73 by any of the other bases decreased the lysine acceptor activity by a factor of ten. These results indicate the involvements of all the three bases of the anticodon and A at the discriminator position in lysine specific aminoacylation.

Identity determinants of E. coli threonine tRNA

To investigate the identity determinants of E. coli threonine tRNA, various transcripts were prepared by in vitro transcription system with T7 RNA polymerase. Substitutions of the anticodon second letter G35 and the third letter U36 to other nucleotides led to a remarkable decrease of threonine charging activity. Charging experiments with a series of anticodon-deletion transcripts also suggest the importance of the G35U36 sequence. A mutation at either the G1-C72 or C2-G71 base pair in the acceptor stem seriously affected the threonine charging activity. These results indicate that the second and third positions of the anticodon and the first and second base pairs in the acceptor stem are the recognition sites of E. coli tRNA(THR) for threonyl-tRNA synthetase. Discriminator base, A73, is not involved in threonine charging activity.

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase-induced cleavage of tRNA

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases interact with their cognate tRNAs in a highly specific fashion. We have examined the phenomenon that upon complex formation E. coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase destabilizes tRNA(Gln) causing chain scissions in the presence of Mg2+ ions. The phosphodiester bond cleavage produces 3'-phosphate and 5'-hydroxyl ends. This kind of experiment is useful for detecting conformational changes in tRNA. Our results show that the cleavage is synthetase-specific, that mutant and wild-type tRNA(Gln) species can assume a different conformation, and that modified nucleosides in tRNA enhance the structural stability of the molecule.

Recent evidence for evolution of the genetic code

The genetic code, formerly thought to be frozen, is now known to be in a state of evolution. This was first shown in 1979 by Barrell et al. (G. Barrell, A. T. Bankier, and J. Drouin, Nature [London] 282:189-194, 1979), who found that the universal codons AUA (isoleucine) and UGA (stop) coded for methionine and tryptophan, respectively, in human mitochondria. Subsequent studies have shown that UGA codes for tryptophan in Mycoplasma spp. and in all nonplant mitochondria that have been examined. Universal stop codons UAA and UAG code for glutamine in ciliated protozoa (except Euplotes octacarinatus) and in a green alga, Acetabularia. E. octacarinatus uses UAA for stop and UGA for cysteine. Candida species, which are yeasts, use CUG (leucine) for serine. Other departures from the universal code, all in nonplant mitochondria, are CUN (leucine) for threonine (in yeasts), AAA (lysine) for asparagine (in platyhelminths and echinoderms), UAA (stop) for tyrosine (in planaria), and AGR (arginine) for serine (in several animal orders) and for stop (in vertebrates). We propose that the changes are typically preceded by loss of a codon from all coding sequences in an organism or organelle, often as a result of directional mutation pressure, accompanied by loss of the tRNA that translates the codon. The codon reappears later by conversion of another codon and emergence of a tRNA that translates the reappeared codon with a different assignment. Changes in release factors also contribute to these revised assignments. We also discuss the use of UGA (stop) as a selenocysteine codon and the early history of the code.

Overlapping nucleotide determinants for specific aminoacylation of RNA microhelices

A seven-base pair microhelix that recapitulates a glycine transfer RNA (tRNA) acceptor helix can be specifically aminoacylated with glycine. A single base pair and the single-stranded discriminator base near the attachment site are essential for aminoacylation. These nucleotide sequence elements, and those in microhelices that can be charged with histidine and alanine, occur in the same positions and therefore overlap. Studies on a systematic set of sequence variants showed that no microhelix could be charged with more than one amino acid. Also, none of the three cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) gave a detectable amount of aminoacylation of the CCA trinucleotide that is common to the 3' ends of all tRNAs, showing that the specific acceptor stem nucleotide bases confer aminoacylation. An analysis of the relative contributions of these microhelices to overall tRNA recognition indicated that their interaction with aaRSs constitutes a substantial part of the recognition of the whole tRNAs.

Conformational rigidity of specific pyrimidine residues in tRNA arises from posttranscriptional modifications that enhance steric interaction between the base and the 2'-hydroxyl group

In order to elucidate roles of the 2'-O-methylation of pyrimidine nucleotide residues of tRNAs, conformations of 2'-O-methyluridylyl(3'----5')uridine (UmpU), 2'-O-methyluridine 3'-monophosphate (Ump), and 2'-O-methyluridine (Um) in 2H2O solution were analyzed by one- and two-dimensional proton NMR spectroscopy and compared with those of related nucleotides and nucleoside. As for UpU and UmpU, the 2'-O-methylation was found to stabilize the C3'-endo form of the 3'-nucleotidyl unit (Up-/Ump-moiety). This stabilization of the C3'-endo form is primarily due to an intraresidue effect, since the conformation of the 5'-nucleotidyl unit (-pU moiety) was only slightly affected by the 2'-O-methylation of the 3'-nucleotide unit. In fact even for Up and Ump, the 2'-O-methylation significantly stabilizes the C3'-endo form by 0.8 kcal/.mol-1. By contrast, for nucleosides (U and Um), the C3'-endo form is slightly stabilized by 0.1 kcal/.mol-1. Accordingly, the stabilization of the C3'-endo form by the 2'-O-methylation is primarily due to the steric repulsion among the 2-carbonyl group, the 2'-O-methyl group and the 3'-phosphate group in the C2'-endo form. For some tRNA species, 2-thiolation of pyrimidine residues is found in positions where the 2'-O-methylation is found for other tRNA species.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Enzymatic aminoacylation of sequence-specific RNA minihelices and hybrid duplexes with methionine

RNA hairpin helices whose sequences are based on the acceptor stems of alanine and histidine tRNAs are specifically aminoacylated with their cognate amino acids. In these examples, major determinants for the identities of the respective tRNAs reside in the acceptor stem; the anticodon and other parts of the tRNA are dispensable for aminoacylation. In contrast, the anticodon is a major determinant for the identity of a methionine tRNA. RNA hairpin helices and hybrid duplexes that reconstruct the acceptor-T psi C stem and the acceptor stem, respectively, of methionine tRNA were investigated here for aminoacylation with methionine. Direct visualization of the aminoacylated RNA product on an acidic polyacrylamide gel by phosphor imaging demonstrated specific aminoacylation with substrates that contained as few as 7 base pairs. No aminoacylation with methionine was detected with several analogous RNA substrates whose sequences were based on noncognate tRNAs. While the efficiency of aminoacylation is reduced by orders of magnitude relative to methionine tRNA, the results establish that specific aminoacylation with methionine of small duplex substrates can be achieved without the anticodon or other domains of the tRNA. The results, combined with earlier studies, suggest a highly specific adaptation of the structures of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases to the acceptor stems of their cognate tRNAs, resulting in a relationship between the nucleotide sequences/structures of small RNA duplexes and specific amino acids.

Mutants of Escherichia coli initiator tRNA that suppress amber codons in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and are aminoacylated with tyrosine by yeast extracts

We recently described mutants of Escherichia coli initiator tRNA that suppress amber termination codons (UAG) in E. coli. These mutants have changes in the anticodon sequence (CAU----CUA) that allow them to read the amber codon and changes in the acceptor stem that allow them to bind to the ribosomal aminoacyl (A) site. We show here that a subset of these mutants suppress amber codons in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and that they are aminoacylated with tyrosine by yeast extracts. Analysis of a number of mutants as substrates for yeast tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase has led to identification of the C1.G72 base pair and the discriminator base A73, conserved in all eukaryotic cytoplasmic and archaebacterial tyrosine tRNAs, as being important for recognition. Our results suggest that the C1.G72 base pair and the discriminator base, in addition to the anticodon nucleotides previously identified [Bare, L.A. & Uhlenbeck, O.C. (1986) Biochemistry 25, 5825-5830] as important in yeast tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase recognition, may comprise the critical identity determinants in yeast tyrosine tRNA.

Identity determinants of E. coli tryptophan tRNA

The first base pair of the acceptor stem A1-U72 and the discriminator base G73, as well as the anticodon nucleotides, characterize the tryptophan tRNA in E. coli. To determine the contribution of these nucleotides to the tryptophan acceptor activity, various transcripts of E. coli tryptophan tRNA mutants were constructed. Substitutions of the discriminator base G73, which is conserved within prokaryotic tryptophan tRNAs, impaired aminoacylation with tryptophan. Substitutions of other purine-pyrimidine pairs for A1-U72 revealed that only U72 weakly contributed to recognition by tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase. The E. coli aspartic acid tRNA transcript introducing the tryptophan anticodon CCA showed almost the same tryptophan charging activity as the tryptophan tRNA transcript possessing a G1-C72 base pair. Only a low activity was detected in the mutant tryptophan tRNA transcript possessing a set of G1-C72 and A73, which is observed in eukaryotic tryptophan tRNAs. These results indicate that the anticodon and G73 are major identity determinants of tryptophan tRNA in E. coli, whereas the A1-U72 base pair is only a weak recognition element.

Mutant enzymes and tRNAs as probes of the glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase: tRNA(Gln) interaction

This paper focuses on several aspects of the specificity of mutants of Escherichia coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase (GlnRS) and tRNA(Gln). Temperature-sensitive mutants located in glnS, the gene for GlnRS, have been described previously. The mutations responsible for the temperature-sensitive phenotype were analyzed, and pseudorevertants of these mutants isolated and characterized. The nature of these mutations is discussed in terms of their location in the three-dimensional structure of the tRNA(Gln).GlnRS complex. In order to characterize the specificity of the aminoacylation reaction, mutant tRNA(Gln) species were synthesized with either a 2'-deoxy AMP or 3'-deoxy AMP as their 3'-terminal nucleotide. Subsequent assays for aminoacylation and ATP/PPi exchange activity established the esterification of glutamine to the 2'-hydroxyl of the terminal adenosine; there is no glutaminylation of the 3'-OH group. This correlates with the classification of GlnRS as a class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase. Mutations in tRNA(Gln) are discussed which affect the recognition of GlnRS and the current concept of glutamine identity in E coli is reviewed.

Novel anticodon composition of transfer RNAs in Micrococcus luteus, a bacterium with a high genomic G + C content. Correlation with codon usage

The number and relative amount of isoacceptor tRNAs for each amino acid in Micrococcus luteus, a Gram-positive bacterium with high genomic G + C content, have been determined by sequencing their anticodon loop and its adjacent regions and by selective labelling of tRNAs. Thirty-one tRNA species with 29 different anticodon sequences have been detected. All the tRNAs have G or C at the anticodon first position except for tRNA(ICGArg) and tRNA(NGASer), in response to the abundant usage of NNC and NNG codons. No tRNA with the anticodon UNN capable of translating codon NNA has been detected, in accordance with a very low or zero usage of NNA codons. The relative amount of isoacceptor tRNAs for an amino acid determined by selective labelling strongly correlates with usage of the corresponding codons. On the basis of these and other observations in this and other eubacterial species, we conclude that the relative amount and anticodon composition of isoacceptor tRNA species are flexible, and their changes are mainly adaptive phenomena that have been primarily affected by codon usage, which in turn is affected by directional mutation pressure.

Binding of the anticodon domain of tRNA(fMet) to Escherichia coli methionyl-tRNA synthetase

A stem and loop RNA domain carrying the methionine anticodon (CAU) was designed from the tRNA(fMet) sequence and produced in vitro. This domain makes a complex with methionyl-tRNA synthetase (Kd = 38(+/- 5) microM; 25 degrees C, pH 7.6, 7 mM-MgCl2). The formation of this complex is dependent on the presence of the cognate CAU anticodon sequence. Recognition of this RNA domain is abolished by a methionyl-tRNA synthetase mutation known to alter the binding of tRNA(Met).

Identity elements of Escherichia coli tRNA(Ala)

Studies using the T7 transcription system revealed that the discriminator base A73 and the G20 in the variable pocket play important roles in the Escherichia coli alanine tRNA identity. The C60 in the T-loop, which is unique to alanine tRNA, was not found to be crucial for alanine identity. Anticodon replacement into the valine anticodon UAC did not decrease alanine charging activity, and no alanine charging activity was detected in the mutant valine tRNA possessing the alanine anticodon UGC.

Identity determinants of E. coli tRNA(Val)

In order to study the identity elements of valine tRNA, various transcripts of E. coli valine tRNA mutants were constructed. Both mutations at the second letter A35 of the anticodon and at the discriminator base A73 seriously damaged valine charging activity. Mutations at either the G3-C70 or U4-A69 base pairs in the acceptor stem also affected the activity. Only one nucleotide substitution of the second letter G35 of the anticodon with A35 brought an 18% valine charging activity into alanine tRNA, which acquired an almost full charging activity with valine by introducing an additional change at those two base pairs in the acceptor stem. These results indicate that the second letter A35 of the anticodon, discriminator base and acceptor stem are involved in recognition by valyl-tRNA synthetase.

A single base pair dominates over the novel identity of an Escherichia coli tyrosine tRNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The Escherichia coli su+3 tyrosine tRNA was shown recently to be a leucine-specific tRNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This finding raises the possibility that some determinants for tRNA identity in E. coli may be different in S. cerevisiae. To investigate whether the fungal system is sensitive to the major determinant for alanine acceptance in E. coli, a single G3 . U70 base pair was introduced into the acceptor helix of the su+3 tyrosine tRNA. This substitution converts the identity of the E. coli suppressor in S. cerevisiae from leucine to alanine. Thus, as in E. coli, G3 . U70 is a strong determinant for alanine acceptance that can dominate over other features in a tRNA that might be recognized by alternative charging enzymes.

Origin of genetically encoded protein synthesis: a model based on selection for RNA peptidation

The difficulty in explaining the origin of genetic coding centres on the need to identify selective advantages that could account for the synthesis of peptidyl-tRNA, the essential intermediate in genetically programmed translation. It is resolved by a recognition of the functional advantages derivable from the post-transcriptional addition of peptide cofactors to RNA apo-catalysts. This enables the formulation of a theory for the origin of the genetic encoding of protein synthesis by RNA.

Anticodon-dependent aminoacylation of a noncognate tRNA with isoleucine, valine, and phenylalanine in vivo

An assay based on the initiation of protein synthesis in Escherichia coli has been used to explore the role of the anticodon in tRNA identity in vivo. Mutations were introduced into the initiator tRNA to change the wild-type anticodon from CAU (methionine) to GAU (isoleucine), GAC (valine), and GAA (phenylalanine), where each derivative differs from the preceding by a single base change in the anticodon (underlined). These changes were sufficient to cause the mutant tRNAs to be aminoacylated by the corresponding aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases based on the amino acid inserted into protein from complementary initiation codons. Construction of additional single base anticodon variants (GUU, GGU, GCC, GUC, GCA, and UAA) showed that all three anticodon bases specify isoleucine and phenylalanine identity and that both the middle and the third anticodon bases are important for valine identity in vivo.

A single base pair dominates over the novel identity of an Escherichia coli tyrosine tRNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The Escherichia coli su+3 tyrosine tRNA was shown recently to be a leucine-specific tRNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This finding raises the possibility that some determinants for tRNA identity in E. coli may be different in S. cerevisiae. To investigate whether the fungal system is sensitive to the major determinant for alanine acceptance in E. coli, a single G3 . U70 base pair was introduced into the acceptor helix of the su+3 tyrosine tRNA. This substitution converts the identity of the E. coli suppressor in S. cerevisiae from leucine to alanine. Thus, as in E. coli, G3 . U70 is a strong determinant for alanine acceptance that can dominate over other features in a tRNA that might be recognized by alternative charging enzymes.

Site-specific creation of uridine from cytidine in apolipoprotein B mRNA editing

Human apolipoprotein (apo) B mRNA is edited in a tissue specific reaction, to convert glutamine codon 2153 (CAA) to a stop translation codon. The RNA editing product templates and hybridises as uridine, but the chemical nature of this reaction and the physical identity of the product are unknown. After editing in vitro of [32P] labelled RNA, we are able to demonstrate the production of uridine from cytidine; [alpha 32P] cytidine triphosphate incorporated into RNA gave rise to [32P] uridine monophosphate after editing in vitro, hydrolysis with nuclease P1 and thin layer chromatography using two separation systems. By cleaving the RNA into ribonuclease T1 fragments, we show that uridine is produced only at the authentic editing site and is produced in quantities that parallel an independent primer extension assay for editing. We conclude that apo B mRNA editing specifically creates a uridine from a cytidine. These observations are inconsistent with the incorporation of a uridine nucleotide by any polymerase, which would replace the alpha-phosphate and so rule out a model of endonucleolytic excision and repair as the mechanism for the production of uridine. Although transamination and transglycosylation remain to be formally excluded as reaction mechanisms our results argue strongly in favour of the apo B mRNA editing enzyme as a site-specific cytidine deaminase.