A structural model of transcription elongation

Major conformational changes occur during the transition from an initiation complex to an elongation complex by T7 RNA polymerase

To examine changes that occur during the transition from an initiation complex (IC) to an elongation complex (EC) in T7 RNA polymerase (RNAP), we used nucleic acid-protein cross-linking methods to probe interactions of the RNAP with RNA and DNA in a halted EC. As the RNA is displaced from the RNA-DNA hybrid approximately 9 bp upstream from the active site (at -9) it interacts with a region within the specificity loop (residues 744-750) and is directed toward a positively charged surface that surrounds residues Lys-302 and Lys-303. Surprisingly, the template and non-template strands of the DNA at the upstream edge of the hybrid (near the site where the RNA is displaced) interact with a region in the N-terminal domain of the RNAP (residues 172-191) that is far away from the specificity loop before isomerization (in the IC). To bring these two regions of the RNAP into proximity, major conformational changes must occur during the transition from an IC to an EC. The observed nucleic acid-protein interactions help to explain the behavior of a number of mutant RNAPs that are affected at various stages in the initiation process and in termination.

Shortening of RNA:DNA hybrid in the elongation complex of RNA polymerase is a prerequisite for transcription termination

Passage of E. coli RNA polymerase through an intrinsic transcription terminator, which encodes an RNA hairpin followed by a stretch of uridine residues, results in quick dissociation of the elongation complex. We show that folding of the hairpin disrupts the three upstream base pairs of the 8 bp RNA:DNA hybrid, a major stability determinant in the complex. Shortening the weak rU:dA hybrid from 8 nt to 5 nt causes dissociation of the complex. During termination, the hairpin does not directly compete for base pairing with the 8 bp hybrid. Thus, melting of the hybrid seems to result from spatial restrictions in RNA polymerase that couple the hairpin formation with the disruption of the hybrid immediately downstream from the stem. Our results suggest that a similar mechanism disrupts elongation complexes of yeast RNA polymerase II in vitro.

Lack of dependance of transcription-induced cytosine deaminations on protein synthesis

Transcription-induced mutations (TIM) is a phenomenon in Escherichia coli in which transcription promotes C to T and other mutations in a strand-specific manner. Because the processes of transcription and translation are coupled in prokaryotes and some models regarding creating a hypermutagenic state in E. coli require new protein synthesis, we tested the possibility that TIM was dependent on efficient synthesis of proteins. We used puromycin to reversibly inhibit protein synthesis and found that it had little effect on mRNA synthesis, plasmid copy-number or TIM. Our results show that TIM is not dependent on efficient translation of mRNA and this helps eliminate certain models concerning the mechanism underlying TIM.

The downstream DNA jaw of bacterial RNA polymerase facilitates both transcriptional initiation and pausing

Regulation of RNA polymerase during initiation, elongation, and termination of transcription is mediated in part by interactions with intrinsic regulatory signals encoded in the RNA and DNA that contact the enzyme. These interactions include contacts to an 8-9-bp RNA:DNA hybrid within the active-site cleft of the enzyme, contacts to the melted nontemplate DNA strand in the vicinity of the hybrid, contacts to exiting RNA upstream of the hybrid, and contacts to approximately 20 bp of duplex DNA downstream of the active site. Based on characterization of an amino acid substitution (G1161R) and a deletion (Delta1149-1190) in the jaw domain of the bacterial RNA polymerase largest subunit (beta'), we report here that contacts of the jaw domain to downstream DNA at the leading edge of the transcription complex contribute to regulation during all three phases of transcription. The results provide insight into the role of the jaw domain-downstream DNA contact in transcriptional initiation and pausing and suggest possible explanations for the previously reported isolation of the jaw mutants based on reduced ColEI plasmid replication.

Sequence-specific interaction of nascent antiterminator RNA with the zinc-finger motif of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

The N-terminal Zn-finger motif of the beta' subunit of RNA polymerase contains two pairs of invariant cysteines flanking a moderately well-conserved segment of 13 amino acids that is rich in basic residues. Previous work showed that replacement of certain Zn-finger residues prevented transcription antitermination in response to phage HK022 put sites. Nascent put RNA binds to and modifies transcribing polymerase, so that it becomes resistant to termination. To characterize the Zn finger further, we replaced each of the basic residues with alanine and determined the effects of the substitutions on termination, antitermination and cell viability. All the mutants were defective in put-mediated antitermination. The severity of the defect depended on the mutant and on the sequence of the upstream stem-loop of put RNA. Some, but not all, mutants distinguished between put variants that differed in this region. This suggests that the Zn-finger motif interacts directly and specifically with put RNA. All the mutants in the basic residues complemented a temperature-sensitive beta' mutant for cell growth at a non-permissive temperature, and those mutant enzymes that were tested transcribed and terminated normally in vitro on a template that lacked a put site.

Promoter clearance and escape in prokaryotes

Promoter escape is the last stage of transcription initiation when RNA polymerase, having initiated de novo phosphodiester bond synthesis, must begin to relinquish its hold on promoter DNA and advance to downstream regions (DSRs) of the template. In vitro, this process is marked by the release of high levels of abortive transcripts at most promoters, reflecting the high instability of initial transcribing complexes (ITCs) and indicative of the existence of barriers to the escape process. The high abortive initiation level is the result of the existence of unproductive ITCs that carry out repeated initiation and abortive release without escaping the promoter. The formation of unproductive ITCs is a widespread phenomenon, but it occurs to different extent on different promoters. Quantitative analysis of promoter mutations suggests that the extent and pattern of abortive initiation and promoter escape is determined by the sequence of promoter elements, both in the promoter recognition region (PRR) and the initial transcribed sequence (ITS). A general correlation has been found that the stronger the promoter DNA-polymerase interaction, the poorer the ability of RNA polymerase to escape the promoter. In gene regulation, promoter escape can be the rate-limiting step for transcription initiation. An increasing number of regulatory proteins are known to exert their control at this step. Examples are discussed with an emphasis on the diverse mechanisms involved. At the molecular level, the X-ray crystal structures of RNA polymerase and its various transcription complexes provide the framework for understanding the functional data on abortive initiation and promoter escape. Based on structural and biochemical evidence, a mechanism for abortive initiation and promoter escape is described.

The many conformational states of RNA polymerase elongation complexes and their roles in the regulation of transcription

Transcription is highly regulated both by protein factors and by specific RNA or DNA sequence elements. Central to this regulation is the ability of RNA polymerase (RNAP) to adopt multiple conformational states during elongation. This review focuses on the mechanism of transcription elongation and the role of different conformational states in the regulation of elongation and termination. The discussion centers primarily on data from structural and functional studies on Escherichia coli RNAP. To introduce the players, a brief introduction to the general mechanism of elongation, the regulatory proteins, and the conformational states is provided. The role of each of the conformational states in elongation is then discussed in detail. Finally, an integrated mechanism of elongation is presented, bringing together the panoply of experiments.

Rho-dependent termination and ATPases in transcript termination

Transcription factor Rho is a ring-shaped, homohexameric protein that causes transcript termination through actions on nascent RNAs that are coupled to ATP hydrolysis. The Rho polypeptide has a distinct RNA-binding domain (RNA-BD) of known structure as well as an ATP-binding domain (ATP-BD) for which a structure has been proposed based on homology modeling. A model is proposed in which Rho first makes an interaction with a nascent RNA on a C-rich, primarily single-stranded rut region of the transcript as that region emerges from the exit site of RNA polymerase. A subsequent step involves a temporary release of one subunit of the hexamer to allow the 3' segment of the nascent transcript to enter the central channel of the Rho ring. Actions of the Rho structure in the channel on the 3' segment that are coupled to ATP hydrolysis pull the RNA from its contacts with the template and RNA polymerase, thus causing termination of its synthesis.

Elongation by RNA polymerase II: structure-function relationship

RNA polymerase II is the eukaryotic enzyme that transcribes all the mRNA in the cell. Complex mechanisms of transcription and its regulation underlie basic functions including differentiation and morphogenesis. Recent evidence indicates the process of RNA chain elongation as a key step in transcription control. Elongation was therefore expected and found to be linked to human diseases. For these reasons, major efforts in determining the structures of RNA polymerases from yeast and bacteria, at rest and as active enzymes, were undertaken. These studies have revealed much information regarding the processes involved in transcription. Eukaryotic RNA polymerases and their homologous bacterial counterparts are flexible enzymes with domains that separate DNA and RNA, prevent the escape of nucleic acids during transcription, allow for extended pausing or "arrest" during elongation, allow for translocation of the DNA and more. Structural studies of RNA polymerases are described below within the context of the process of transcription elongation, its regulation and function.

Promoting elongation with transcript cleavage stimulatory factors

Transcript elongation by RNA polymerase is a dynamic process, capable of responding to a number of intrinsic and extrinsic signals. A number of elongation factors have been identified that enhance the rate or efficiency of transcription. One such class of factors facilitates RNA polymerase transcription through blocks to elongation by stimulating the polymerase to cleave the nascent RNA transcript within the elongation complex. These cleavage factors are represented by the Gre factors from prokaryotes, and TFIIS and TFIIS-like factors found in archaea and eukaryotes. High-resolution structures of RNA polymerases and the cleavage factors in conjunction with biochemical investigations and genetic analyses have provided insights into the mechanism of action of these elongation factors. However, there are yet many unanswered questions regarding the regulation of these factors and their effects on target genes.

RNA polymerase II transcription complexes may become arrested if the nascent RNA is shortened to less than 50 nucleotides

A significant fraction of RNA polymerase II transcription complexes become arrested when halted within a particular initially transcribed region after the synthesis of 23-32-nucleotide RNAs. If polymerases are halted within the same sequence at a promoter-distal location, they remain elongation-competent. However, when the RNAs within these promoter-distal complexes are truncated to between 21 and 48 nucleotides, many of the polymerases become arrested. The degree of the arrest correlates very well with the length of the RNA in both the promoter-proximal and -distal complexes. This effect is also observed when comparing promoter-proximal and promoter-distal complexes halted over a completely different sequence. The unusual propensity of many promoter-proximal RNA polymerase II complexes to arrest may therefore be recreated in promoter-distal complexes simply by shortening the nascent RNA. Thus, the transition to full elongation competence by RNA polymerase II is dependent on the synthesis of about 50 nt of RNA, and this transition is reversible. We also found that arrest is facilitated in promoter-distal complexes by the hybridization of oligonucleotides to the transcript between 30 and 45 bases upstream of the 3'-end.

Using mechanical force to probe the mechanism of pausing and arrest during continuous elongation by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase translocates along the DNA discontinuously during the elongation phase of transcription, spending proportionally more time at some template positions, known as pause and arrest sites, than at others. Current models of elongation suggest that the enzyme backtracks at these locations, but the dynamics are unresolved. Here, we study the role of lateral displacement in pausing and arrest by applying force to individually transcribing molecules. We find that an assisting mechanical force does not alter the translocation rate of the enzyme, but does reduce the efficiency of both pausing and arrest. Moreover, arrested molecules cannot be rescued by force, suggesting that arrest occurs by a bipartite mechanism: the enzyme backtracks along the DNA followed by a conformational change of the ternary complex (RNA polymerase, DNA and transcript), which cannot be reversed mechanically.

Swing-gate model of nucleotide entry into the RNA polymerase active center

Each elementary step of transcription involves translocation of the 3' terminus of RNA in the RNA polymerase active center, followed by the entry of a nucleoside triphosphate. The structural basis of these transitions was studied using RNA-protein crosslinks. The contacts were mapped and projected onto the crystal structure, in which the "F bridge" helix in the beta' subunit is either bent or relaxed. Bending/relaxation of the F bridge correlates with lateral movements of the RNA 3' terminus. The bent conformation is sterically incompatable with the occupancy of the nucleotide site, suggesting that the switch regulates both the entry of substrates and the translocation of the transcript. The switch occurs as part of a cooperative transition of a larger structural domain that consists of the F helix and the supporting G loop.

Regulation by transcription attenuation in bacteria: how RNA provides instructions for transcription termination/antitermination decisions

Regulation of gene expression by premature termination of transcription, or transcription attenuation, is a common regulatory strategy in bacteria. Various mechanisms of regulating transcription termination have been uncovered, each can be placed in either of two broad categories of termination events. Many mechanisms involve choosing between two alternative hairpin structures in an RNA transcript, with the decision dependent on interactions between ribosome and transcript, tRNA and transcript, or protein and transcript. In other examples, modification of the transcription elongation complex is the crucial event. This article will describe and compare several of these regulatory strategies, and will cite specific examples to illustrate the different mechanisms employed.

Transcription termination and anti-termination in E. coli

Transcription termination in Escherichia coli is controlled by many factors. The sequence of the DNA template, the structure of the transcript, and the actions of auxiliary proteins all play a role in determining the efficiency of the process. Termination is regulated and can be enhanced or suppressed by host and phage proteins. This complex reaction is rapidly yielding to biochemical and structural analysis of the interacting factors. Below we review and attempt to unify into basic principles the remarkable recent progress in understanding transcription termination and anti-termination.

Activation of antibiotic biosynthesis by specified mutations in the rpoB gene (encoding the RNA polymerase beta subunit) of Streptomyces lividans

We found that the biosynthesis of actinorhodin (Act), undecylprodigiosin (Red), and calcium-dependent antibiotic (CDA) are dramatically activated by introducing certain mutations into the rpoB gene that confer resistance to rifampin to Streptomyces lividans 66, which produces less or no antibiotics under normal growth conditions. Activation of Act and/or Red biosynthesis by inducing mutations in the rpoB gene was shown to be dependent on the mutation's position and the amino acid species substituted in the beta-subunit of the RNA polymerase. Mutation analysis identified 15 different kinds of point mutations, which are located in region I, II, or III of the rpoB gene and, in addition, two novel mutations (deletion of nucleotides 1287 to 1289 and a double substitution at nucleotides 1309 and 1310) were also found. Western blot analyses and S1 mapping analyses demonstrated that the expression of actII-ORF4 and redD, which are pathway-specific regulatory genes for Act and Red, respectively, was activated in the mutants able to produce Act and Red. The ActIV-ORF1 protein (an enzyme for Act biosynthesis) and the RedD protein were produced just after the upregulation of ActII-ORF4 and RedZ, respectively. These results indicate that the mutation in the rpoB gene of S. lividans, resulting in the activation of Act and/or Red biosynthesis, functions at the transcription level by activating directly or indirectly the key regulatory genes, actII-ORF4 and redD. We propose that the mutated RNA polymerase may function by mimicking the ppGpp-bound form in activating the onset of secondary metabolism in STREPTOMYCES:

E. coli Transcription repair coupling factor (Mfd protein) rescues arrested complexes by promoting forward translocation

Transcription and DNA repair are coupled in E. coli by the Mfd protein, which dissociates transcription elongation complexes blocked at nonpairing lesions and mediates recruitment of DNA repair proteins. We show that Mfd influences the elongation state of RNA polymerase (RNAP); transcription complexes that have reverse translocated into the backtracked position, a potentially important intermediate in RNA proofreading and repair, are restored to the forward position by the activity of Mfd, and arrested complexes are rescued into productive elongation. Mfd may act through a translocase activity that rewinds upstream DNA, leading either to translocation or to release of RNA polymerase when the enzyme active site cannot continue elongation.

Crystal structure of a bacterial RNA polymerase holoenzyme at 2.6 A resolution

In bacteria, the binding of a single protein, the initiation factor sigma, to a multi-subunit RNA polymerase core enzyme results in the formation of a holoenzyme, the active form of RNA polymerase essential for transcription initiation. Here we report the crystal structure of a bacterial RNA polymerase holoenzyme from Thermus thermophilus at 2.6 A resolution. In the structure, two amino-terminal domains of the sigma subunit form a V-shaped structure near the opening of the upstream DNA-binding channel of the active site cleft. The carboxy-terminal domain of sigma is near the outlet of the RNA-exit channel, about 57 A from the N-terminal domains. The extended linker domain forms a hairpin protruding into the active site cleft, then stretching through the RNA-exit channel to connect the N- and C-terminal domains. The holoenzyme structure provides insight into the structural organization of transcription intermediate complexes and into the mechanism of transcription initiation.

Kinetic studies and structural models of the association of E. coli sigma(70) RNA polymerase with the lambdaP(R) promoter: large scale conformational changes in forming the kinetically significant intermediates

The kinetics of interaction of Esigma(70) RNA polymerase (R) with the lambdaP(R) promoter (P) were investigated by filter binding over a broad range of temperatures (7.3-42 degrees C) and concentrations of RNA polymerase (1-123 nM) in large excess over promoter DNA. Under all conditions examined, the kinetics of formation of competitor-resistant complexes (I(2), RP(o)) are single-exponential with first order rate constant beta(CR). Interpretation of the polymerase concentration dependence of beta(CR) in terms of the three step mechanism of open complex formation yields the equilibrium constant K(1) for formation of the first kinetically significant intermediate (I(1)) and the forward rate constant (k(2)) for the conformational change converting I(1) to the second kinetically significant intermediate I(2): R + P-->(K(1))<--I(1)(k(2))-->I(2). Use of rapid quench mixing allows K(1) and k(2) to be individually determined over the entire temperature range investigated, previously not possible at this promoter using manual mixing. Given the large (>60 bp) interface formed in I(1), its relatively small binding constant K(1) at 37 degrees C at this [salt] (approximately 6 x 10(6) M(-1)) strongly argues that binding free energy is used to drive large-scale structural changes in polymerase and/or promoter DNA or other coupled processes. Evidence for coupling of protein folding is provided by the large and negative activation heat capacity of k(a)[DeltaC(o,++)(a)= -1.5(+/-0.2)kcal K(-1)], now shown to originate directly from formation of I(1) [DeltaC(o)(1)= -1.4(+/-0.3)kcal K(-1)] rather than from the formation of I(2) as previously proposed. The isomerization I(1)-->I(2) exhibits relatively slow kinetics and has a very large temperature-independent Arrhenius activation energy [E(act)(2)= 34(+/-2)kcal]. This kinetic signature suggests that formation of the transition state (I(1)-I(2)++ involves large conformational changes dominated by changes in the exposure of polar and/or charged surface to water. Structural and biochemical data lead to the following hypotheses to interpret these results. We propose that formation of I(1) involves coupled folding of unstructured regions of polymerase (beta, beta' and sigma(70)) and bending of promoter DNA (in the -10 region). We propose that interactions with region 2 of sigma(70) and possibly domain 1 of beta induce a kink at the -11/-12 base pairs of the lambdaP(R) promoter which places the downstream DNA (-5 to +20) in the jaws of the beta and beta' subunits of polymerase in I(1). These early interactions of beta and beta' with the DNA downstream of position -5 trigger jaw closing (with coupled folding) and subsequent steps of DNA opening.

Views of transcription initiation

Initiation of transcription is the first step in gene expression and a major point of regulation. Recent structural studies reveal the nature of the initiating complex and suggest new ways of accomplishing the processes required for initiation.

Structural basis of transcription initiation: RNA polymerase holoenzyme at 4 A resolution

The crystal structure of the initiating form of Thermus aquaticus RNA polymerase, containing core RNA polymerase (alpha2betabeta'omega) and the promoter specificity sigma subunit, has been determined at 4 angstrom resolution. Important structural features of the RNA polymerase and their roles in positioning sigma within the initiation complex are delineated, as well as the role played by sigma in modulating the opening of the RNA polymerase active-site channel. The two carboxyl-terminal domains of sigma are separated by 45 angstroms on the surface of the RNA polymerase, but are linked by an extended loop. The loop winds near the RNA polymerase active site, where it may play a role in initiating nucleotide substrate binding, and out through the RNA exit channel. The advancing RNA transcript must displace the loop, leading to abortive initiation and ultimately to sigma release.

Using disulfide bond engineering to study conformational changes in the beta'260-309 coiled-coil region of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase during sigma(70) binding

RNA polymerase of Escherichia coli is the sole enzyme responsible for mRNA synthesis in the cell. Upon binding of a sigma factor, the holoenzyme can direct transcription from specific promoter sequences. We have previously defined a region of the beta' subunit (beta'260-309, amino acids 260 to 309) which adopts a coiled-coil conformation shown to interact with sigma(70) both in vitro and in vivo. However, it was not known if the coiled-coil conformation was maintained upon binding to sigma(70). In this work, we engineered a disulfide bond within beta'240-309 that locks the beta' coiled-coil region in the coiled-coil conformation, and we show that this "locked" peptide is able to bind to sigma(70). We also show that the locked coiled-coil is capable of inducing a conformational change within sigma(70) that allows recognition of the -10 nontemplate strand of DNA. This suggests that the coiled-coil does not adopt a new conformation upon binding sigma(70) or upon recognition of the -10 nontemplate strand of DNA.

Transcription termination: primary intermediates and secondary adducts

In living organisms, stable elongation complexes of RNA polymerase dissociate at specific template positions in a process of transcription termination. It has been suggested that the dissociation is not the immediate cause of termination but is preceded by catalytic inactivation of the elongation complex. In vitro reducing ionic strength can be used to stabilize very unstable and catalytically inactive complex at the point of termination; the previous biochemical characterization of this complex has led to important conclusions regarding termination mechanism. Here we analyze in detail the complexes formed between DNA template, nascent RNA, and Escherichia coli RNA polymerase during transcription through the tR2 terminator of bacteriophage lambda. At low ionic strength, the majority of elongation complexes fall apart upon reaching the terminator. Released RNA and DNA efficiently rebind RNA polymerase (RNAP) and form binary RNAP.RNA and RNAP.DNA complexes, which are indistinguishable from binary complexes obtained by direct mixing of the purified nucleic acids and the enzyme. A small fraction of elongation complexes that reach termination point escapes dissociation because RNA polymerase has backtracked from the terminator to an upstream DNA position. Thus, transcription elongation to a terminator site produces no termination intermediates that withstand dissociation in the time scale appropriate for biochemical studies.

The transcriptional regulator RfaH stimulates RNA chain synthesis after recruitment to elongation complexes by the exposed nontemplate DNA strand

The transcriptional regulatory protein RfaH controls expression of several operons that encode extracytoplasmic components in bacteria. Regulation by RfaH occurs during transcript elongation and depends on a 5'-proximal, transcribed nucleic acid sequence called ops that induces transcriptional pausing in vitro and in vivo. We report that RfaH recognizes RNA polymerase transcribing RfaH-regulated operons by interacting with the ops sequence in the exposed nontemplate DNA strand of ops-paused transcription complexes. Although RfaH delays escape from the ops pause, once escape occurs, RfaH enhances elongation by suppressing pausing and rho-dependent termination without apparent involvement of other accessory proteins. This activity predicts a cumulative antitermination model for RfaH's regulation of ops-containing operons in vivo.

Conformational flexibility of bacterial RNA polymerase

The structure of Escherichia coli core RNA polymerase (RNAP) was determined by cryo-electron microscopy and image processing of helical crystals to a nominal resolution of 15 A. Because of the high sequence conservation between the core RNAP subunits, we were able to interpret the E. coli structure in relation to the high-resolution x-ray structure of Thermus aquaticus core RNAP. A very large conformational change of the T. aquaticus RNAP x-ray structure, corresponding to opening of the main DNA/RNA channel by nearly 25 A, was required to fit the E. coli map. This finding reveals, at least partially, the range of conformational flexibility of the RNAP, which is likely to have functional implications for the initiation of transcription, where the DNA template must be loaded into the channel.

Sequence requirements for terminators and antiterminators in the T box transcription antitermination system: disparity between conservation and functional requirements

The T box transcription termination control system is used in Gram-positive bacteria to regulate expression of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase and other amino acid-related genes. Readthrough of a transcriptional terminator located in the leader region of the target gene is dependent on a specific interaction between the nascent leader transcript and the cognate uncharged tRNA. This interaction is required for formation of an antiterminator structure in the leader, which prevents formation of a competing transcriptional terminator stem-loop. The antiterminators and terminators of genes in this family are highly conserved in both secondary structure and primary sequence; the antiterminator contains the T box sequence, which is the most highly conserved leader element. These conserved features were investigated by phylogenetic and mutational analysis. Changes at highly conserved positions in the bulge and in the helix above the bulge reduced function, while alteration of other positions that were as much as 96% conserved did not have a major effect. The disparity between sequence conservation and function may be due to the requirement for maintaining base pairing in both the antiterminator and terminator structures.

Structure-based analysis of RNA polymerase function: the largest subunit's rudder contributes critically to elongation complex stability and is not involved in the maintenance of RNA-DNA hybrid length

Analysis of multisubunit RNA polymerase (RNAP) structures revealed several elements that may constitute the enzyme's functional sites. One such element, the 'rudder', is formed by an evolutionarily conserved segment of the largest subunit of RNAP and contacts the nascent RNA at the upstream edge of the RNA-DNA hybrid, where the DNA template strand separates from the RNA transcript and re-anneals with the non-template strand. Thus, the rudder could (i) maintain the correct length of the RNA-DNA hybrid; (ii) stabilize the nascent RNA in the complex; and (iii) promote or maintain localized DNA melting at the upstream edge of the bubble. We generated a recombinant RNAP mutant that lacked the rudder and studied its properties in vitro. Our results demonstrate that the rudder is not required for establishment of the upstream boundary of the transcription bubble during promoter complex formation, nor is it required for separation of the nascent RNA from the DNA template strand or transcription termination. Our results suggest that the rudder makes critical contributions to elongation complex stability through direct interactions with the nascent RNA.

Structural organization of bacterial RNA polymerase holoenzyme and the RNA polymerase-promoter open complex

We have used systematic fluorescence resonance energy transfer and distance-constrained docking to define the three-dimensional structures of bacterial RNA polymerase holoenzyme and the bacterial RNA polymerase-promoter open complex in solution. The structures provide a framework for understanding sigma(70)-(RNA polymerase core), sigma(70)-DNA, and sigma(70)-RNA interactions. The positions of sigma(70) regions 1.2, 2, 3, and 4 are similar in holoenzyme and open complex. In contrast, the position of sigma(70) region 1.1 differs dramatically in holoenzyme and open complex. In holoenzyme, region 1.1 is located within the active-center cleft, apparently serving as a "molecular mimic" of DNA, but, in open complex, region 1.1 is located outside the active center cleft. The approach described here should be applicable to the analysis of other nanometer-scale complexes.

The interaction between sigmaS, the stationary phase sigma factor, and the core enzyme of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

BACKGROUND

The RNA polymerase holoenzyme of Escherichia coli is composed of a core enzyme (subunit structure alpha2betabeta') associated with one of the sigma subunits, required for promoter recognition. Different sigma factors compete for core binding. Among the seven sigma factors present in E. coli, sigma70 controls gene transcription during the exponential phase, whereas sigmaS regulates the transcription of genes in the stationary phase or in response to different stresses. Using labelled sigmaS and sigma70, we compared the affinities of both sigma factors for core binding and investigated the structural changes in the different subunits involved in the formation of the holoenzymes.

RESULTS

Using native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, we demonstrate that sigmaS binds to the core enzyme with fivefold reduced affinity compared to sigma70. Using iron chelate protein footprinting, we show that the core enzyme significantly reduces polypeptide backbone solvent accessibility in regions 1.1, 2.5, 3.1 and 3.2 of sigmaS, while increasing the accessibility in region 4.1 of sigmaS. We have also analysed the positioning of sigmaS on the holoenzyme by the proximity-dependent protein cleavage method using sigmaS derivatives in which FeBABE was tethered to single cysteine residues at nine different positions. Protein cutting patterns are observed on the beta and beta' subunits, but not alpha. Regions 2.5, 3.1 and 3.2 of sigmaS are close to both beta and beta' subunits, in agreement with iron chelate protein footprinting data.

CONCLUSIONS

A comparison between these results using sigmaS and previous data from sigma70 indicates similar contact patterns on the core subunits and similar characteristic changes associated with holoenzyme formation, despite striking differences in the accessibility of regions 4.1 and 4.2.

Marking the start site of RNA polymerase III transcription: the role of constraint, compaction and continuity of the transcribed DNA strand

The effects of breaks in the individual strands of an RNA polymerase III promoter on initiation of transcription have been examined. Single breaks have been introduced at 2 bp intervals in a 24 bp segment that spans the transcriptional start site of the U6 snRNA gene promoter. Their effects on transcription are asymmetrically distributed: transcribed (template) strand breaks downstream of bp-14 (relative to the normal start as +1) systematically shift the start site, evidently by disrupting the normal mechanism that measures distance from DNA-bound TBP. Breaks placed close to the normal start site very strongly inhibit transcription. Breaks in the non-transcribed strand generate only minor effects on transcription. A structure-based model interprets these observations and explains how the transcribed strand is used to locate the transcriptional start site.

Multisubunit RNA polymerases

Transcription of the genetic information in all cells is carried out by multisubunit RNA polymerases (RNAPs). Comparison of the crystal structures of a bacterial and a eukaryotic RNAP reveals a conserved core that comprises the active site and a multifunctional clamp. Together with a further structure of eukaryotic RNAP bound to DNA and RNA, these results elucidate many aspects of the transcription mechanism, including initiation, elongation, nucleotide addition, processivity and proofreading.

Promoter clearance by T7 RNA polymerase. Initial bubble collapse and transcript dissociation monitored by base analog fluorescence

Footprinting, fluorescence, and x-ray structural information from the initial, promoter-bound complex of T7 RNA polymerase describes the very beginning of the initiation of transcription, whereas recent fluorescence and biochemical studies paint a preliminary picture of an elongation complex. The current work focuses on the transition from an initially transcribing, promoter-bound complex to an elongation complex clear of the promoter. Fluorescence quenching is used to follow the melted state of the DNA bubble, and a novel approach using a locally mismatched fluorescent base analog reports on the local structure of the heteroduplex. Fluorescent base analogs placed at positions -2 and -1 of the promoter indicate that this initially melted, nontranscribed region remains melted as the polymerase translocates through to position +8. In progressing to position +9, this region of the DNA bubble begins to collapse. Probes placed at positions +1 and +2 of the template strand indicate that the 5' end of the RNA remains in a heteroduplex as the complex translocates to position +10. Subsequent translocation leads to sequential dissociation of the first 2 bases of the RNA. These results show that the initially transcribing complex bubble can reach a size of up to 13 base pairs and a maximal heteroduplex length of 10 base pairs. They further indicate that initial bubble collapse precedes dissociation of the 5' end of the RNA.

Strong natural pausing by RNA polymerase II within 10 bases of transcription start may result in repeated slippage and reextension of the nascent RNA

We find that immediately following transcript initiation, RNA polymerase II pauses at several locations even in the presence of relatively high (200 microM) levels of nucleoside triphosphates. Strong pauses with half-lives of >30 s were observed at +7, +18/19, and about +25 on the template used in these experiments. We show that the strong pause at +7, after the synthesis of 5'-ACUCUCU, leads to repeated cycles of upstream slippage of the RNA-DNA hybrid followed by re-pairing with the DNA and continued RNA synthesis. The resulting transcripts are 2, 4, and 6 bases longer than predicted by the template sequence. Slippage is efficient when transcription is primed with the +1/+2 (ApC) dinucleotide, and it occurs at even higher levels with the +2/+3 primer (CpU). Slippage can occur at high levels with ATP initiation, but priming with CpA (-1/+1) supports very little slippage. This latter result is not simply an effect of transcript length at the point of pausing. Slippage can also occur with a second template on which the polymerase can be paused after synthesizing ACUCU. Slippage is not reduced by an ATP analog that blocks promoter escape, but it is inhibited by substitution of 5Br-U for U in the RNA. Our results reveal an unexpected flexibility of RNA polymerase II ternary complexes during the very early stage of transcription, and they suggest that initiation at different locations within the same promoter gives rise to transcription complexes with different properties.

T7 promoter release mediated by DNA scrunching

Transcription initiation includes a phase in which short transcripts dissociate from the transcription complex and the polymerase appears not to move away from the promoter. During this process DNA may scrunch within the complex or the polymerase may transiently break promoter contacts to transcribe downstream DNA. Promoter release allowing extended downstream movement of the polymerase may be caused by RNA-mediated disruption of promoter contacts, or by limits on the amount of DNA that can be scrunched. Using exonuclease and KMnO4 footprinting of T7RNAP transcription complexes we show that the DNA scrunches during progression through initial transcription. To determine whether promoter release is determined by RNA length or by the amount of DNA scrunched, we compared release at promoters where the polymerase is forced to initiate at +2 with those where it initiates at +1. For RNAs of identical length, release is greater when more DNA is scrunched. Release is inhibited when a nick introduced into the template relieves the strain of scrunching. DNA scrunching therefore makes an important contribution to T7 promoter release.

Control of intrinsic transcription termination by N and NusA: the basic mechanisms

Intrinsic transcription termination plays a crucial role in regulating gene expression in prokaryotes. After a short pause, the termination signal appears in RNA as a hairpin that destabilizes the elongation complex (EC). We demonstrate that negative and positive termination factors control the efficiency of termination primarily through a direct modulation of hairpin folding and, to a much lesser extent, by changing pausing at the point of termination. The mechanism controlling hairpin formation at the termination point relies on weak protein interactions with single-stranded RNA, which corresponds to the upstream portion of the hairpin. Escherichia coli NusA protein destabilizes these interactions and thus promotes hairpin folding and termination. Stabilization of these contacts by phage lambda N protein leads to antitermination.

The anti-initial transcribed sequence, a portable sequence that impedes promoter escape, requires sigma70 for function

The anti-sequence, a portable element extending from +1 to +15 of the transcript, is sufficient to prevent promoter escape from a variety of strong final sigma70 promoters. We show here that this sequence does not function with even the strongest final sigma32 promoter. Moreover, a particular class of substitutions in final sigma70 that disrupt interaction between Region 2.2 of final sigma70 and a coiled-coiled motif in the beta'-subunit of RNA polymerase antagonizes the function of the anti-element. This same group of mutants prevents lambdaQ-mediated anti-termination at the lambdaP(R') promoter. At this promoter, interaction of final sigma70 with the non-template strand of the initial transcribed sequence (ITS) is required to promote the pause prerequisite for anti-termination. These mutants prevent pausing because they are defective in this recognition event. By analogy, we suggest that interaction of final sigma70 with the non-template strand of the anti-ITS is required for function of this portable element, thus explaining why neither final sigma32 nor the Region 2.2 final sigma70 mutants mediate anti-function. Support for the analogy with the lambdaP(R') promoter comes from preliminary experiments suggesting that the anti-ITS, like the lambdaP(R') ITS, is bipartite.

Phenotypic characterization of a comprehensive set of bicyclomycin-resistant mutants

A comprehensive set of bicyclomycin-resistant mutants of transcription termination protein Rho has been characterized in Escherichia coli by in vivo and in vitro assays. Several of the mutant Rho proteins have functional defects. Strains with either the L208R or the S266A mutation in the bacterial chromosome have a higher intracellular concentration of the Rho protein than strains containing a wild-type copy of the rho gene. Strains carrying the L187R, L208R or S266A mutations in the chromosome also have a mutant phenotype; a plasmid-located arabinose promoter is constitutively de-repressed in these strains. The L208R and S266A mutant strains also have a rate of growth defect. When the S266A mutation is located on a high-copy plasmid, the mutant grows more slowly than a wild-type strain. In contrast to the majority of the bicyclomycin-resistant mutants, these two mutants show clear phenotypic differences from wild-type cells. These differences are also seen in vitro. In vitro transcription termination by RhoL208R and RhoS266A is defective at the lambda tR1 terminator, but can be enhanced by NusG. These functionally defective Rho mutations have been located near the putative catalytic site on a model of Rho based on the F1-ATPase. This indicates that this region of the Rho molecule is crucial for Rho function. The crucial region overlaps the putative bicyclomycin-binding site, suggesting an explanation for the efficacy of bicyclomycin as an antibiotic.

Completion of RNA synthesis by viral RNA replicases

How the 5'-terminus of the template affects RNA synthesis by viral RNA replicases is poorly understood. Using short DNA, RNA and RNA-DNA chimeric templates that can direct synthesis of replicase products, we found that DNA templates tend to direct the synthesis of RNA products that are shorter by 1 nt in comparison to RNA templates. Template-length RNA synthesis was also affected by the concentration of nucleoside triphosphates, the identity of the bases at specific positions close to the 5'-terminus and the C2'-hydroxyl of a ribose at the third nucleotide from the 5'-terminal nucleotide. Similar requirements are observed with two bromoviral replicases, but not with a recombinant RNA-dependent RNA polymerase. These results begin to define the interactions needed for the viral replicase to complete synthesis of viral RNA.

Promoter clearance by RNA polymerase II is an extended, multistep process strongly affected by sequence

We have characterized RNA polymerase II complexes halted from +16 to +49 on two templates which differ in the initial 20 nucleotides (nt) of the transcribed region. On a template with a purine-rich initial transcript, most complexes halted between +20 and +32 become arrested and cannot resume RNA synthesis without the SII elongation factor. These arrested complexes all translocate upstream to the same location, such that about 12 to 13 bases of RNA remain in each of the complexes after SII-mediated transcript cleavage. Much less arrest is observed over this same region with a second template in which the initially transcribed region is pyrimidine rich, but those complexes which do arrest on the second template also translocate upstream to the same location observed with the first template. Complexes stalled at +16 to +18 on either template do not become arrested. Complexes stalled at several locations downstream of +35 become partially arrested, but these more promoter-distal arrested complexes translocate upstream by less than 10 nt; that is, they do not translocate to a common, far-upstream location. Kinetic studies with nonlimiting levels of nucleoside triphosphates reveal strong pausing between +20 and +30 on both templates. These results indicate that promoter clearance by RNA polymerase II is at least a two-step process: a preclearance escape phase extending up to about +18 followed by an unstable clearance phase which extends over the formation of 9 to 17 more bonds. Polymerases halted during the clearance phase translocate upstream to the preclearance location and arrest in at least one sequence context.

Prediction of rho-independent transcriptional terminators in Escherichia coli

A new algorithm called RNAMotif containing RNA structure and sequence constraints and a thermodynamic scoring system was used to search for intrinsic rho-independent terminators in the Escherichia coli K-12 genome. We identified all 135 reported terminators and 940 putative terminator sequences beginning no more than 60 nt away from the 3'-end of the annotated transcription units (TU). Putative and reported terminators with the scores above our chosen threshold were found for 37 of the 53 non-coding RNA TU and for almost 50% of the 2592 annotated protein-encoding TU, which correlates well with the number of TU expected to contain rho-independent terminators. We also identified 439 terminators that could function in a bi-directional fashion, servicing one gene on the positive strand and a different gene on the negative strand. Approximately 700 additional termination signals in non-coding regions (NCR) far away from the nearest annotated gene were predicted. This number correlates well with the excess number of predicted 'orphan' promoters in the NCR, and these promoters and terminators may be associated with as yet unidentified TU. The significant number of high scoring hits that occurred within the reading frame of annotated genes suggests that either an additional component of rho-independent terminators exists or that a suppressive mechanism to prevent unwanted termination remains to be discovered.

Dynamic protein interactions in the bacteriophage T4 replisome

The bacteriophage T4 DNA replisome is a complex dynamic system employing a variety of proteins to orchestrate the synthesis of DNA on both the leading and lagging strands. Assembly of the protein complexes responsible for DNA synthesis and priming requires the coordination of transient biomolecular interactions. This interplay of proteins has been dissected through the use of small molecules including fluorescent probes and crosslinkers, enabling the development of a complex dynamic structural and kinetic model for DNA polymerase holoenzyme assembly and primosome formation.

De novo initiation of viral RNA-dependent RNA synthesis

RNA viruses use several initiation strategies to ensure that their RNAs are synthesized in appropriate amounts, have correct termini, and can be translated efficiently. Many viruses with genomes of single-stranded positive-, negative-, and double-stranded RNA initiate RNA synthesis by a de novo (primer-independent) mechanism. This review summarizes biochemical features and variations of de novo initiation in viral RNA replication.

Translocation of sigma(70) with RNA polymerase during transcription: fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay for movement relative to DNA

Using fluorescence resonance energy transfer, we show that, in the majority of transcription complexes, sigma(70) is not released from RNA polymerase upon transition from initiation to elongation, but, instead, remains associated with RNA polymerase and translocates with RNA polymerase. The results argue against the presumption that there are necessary subunit-composition differences, and corresponding necessary mechanistic differences, in initiation and elongation. The methods of this report should be generalizable to monitor movement of any molecule relative to any nucleic acid.

Isolation and characterization of sigma(70)-retaining transcription elongation complexes from Escherichia coli

sigma(70) subunit is thought to be released from the core RNA polymerase (RNAP) upon the transition from initiation to elongation or shortly afterward. Here, we identify a population of RNAP from E. coli that retains sigma(70) throughout elongation. The relative amount of this population appears to depend on cellular growth and reaches its maximum during the stationary phase. The proportion of sigma(70)-retaining elongation complexes (EC-sigma(70)) is invariant with various promoters or distances from the transcription start site. EC-sigma(70) responds to pauses, intrinsic terminators, and the elongation factor NusA similarly to EC without sigma(70). However, EC-sigma(70) has a substantially higher ability to support multiple rounds of transcription at certain promoters, suggesting its profound role in gene expression and regulation in bacteria.

Roles of RNA:DNA hybrid stability, RNA structure, and active site conformation in pausing by human RNA polymerase II

Human RNA polymerase II recognizes a strong transcriptional pause signal in the initially transcribed region of HIV-1. We report the use of a limited-step transcription assay to dissect the mechanism underlying recognition of and escape from this HIV-1 pause. Our results suggest that the primary determinant of transcriptional pausing is a relatively weak RNA:DNA hybrid that triggers backtracking of RNA polymerase II along the RNA and DNA chains and displaces the RNA 3' OH from the active site. In contrast, two alternative RNA secondary structures, TAR and anti-TAR, are not required for pausing and affect it only indirectly, rather than through direct interaction with RNA polymerase II. TAR accelerates escape from the pause, but anti-TAR inhibits formation of TAR prior to pause escape. The behavior of RNA polymerase II at a mutant pause signal supports a two-step, non-equilibrium mechanism in which the rate-determining step is a conformational change in the enzyme, rather than the changes in nucleic-acid base-pairing that accompany backtracking.

Binding of the initiation factor sigma(70) to core RNA polymerase is a multistep process

The interaction of RNA polymerase and its initiation factors is central to the process of transcription initiation. To dissect the role of this interface, we undertook the identification of the contact sites between RNA polymerase and sigma(70), the Escherichia coli initiation factor. We identified nine mutationally verified interaction sites between sigma(70) and specific domains of RNA polymerase and provide evidence that sigma(70) and RNA polymerase interact in at least a two-step process. We propose that a cycle of changes in the interface of sigma(70) with core RNA polymerase is associated with progression through the process of transcription initiation.

A genetic look at the active site of RNA polymerase III

rpc160-112, a mutant of the RNA polymerase III active site, is corrected in vivo by six second-site mutants obtained by random mutagenesis. These mutants introduce single-site amino acid replacements at the two large subunits of the enzyme. The mutated motifs are conserved in RNA polymerases I and II and, for some of them, in the bacterial enzyme, thus delineating key elements of the active site in eukaryotic RNA polymerases.

A coiled-coil from the RNA polymerase beta' subunit allosterically induces selective nontemplate strand binding by sigma(70)

For transcription to initiate, RNA polymerase must recognize and melt promoters. Selective binding to the nontemplate strand of the -10 region of the promoter is central to this process. We show that a 48 amino acid (aa) coiled-coil from the beta' subunit (aa 262--309) induces sigma(70) to perform this function almost as efficiently as core RNA polymerase itself. We provide evidence that interaction between the beta' coiled-coil and region 2.2 of sigma(70) promotes an allosteric transition that allows sigma(70) to selectively recognize the nontemplate strand. As the beta' 262--309 peptide can function with the previously crystallized portion of sigma(70), nontemplate recognition can be reconstituted with only 47 kDa, or 1/10 of holoenzyme.

Structural basis of transcription: RNA polymerase II at 2.8 angstrom resolution

Structures of a 10-subunit yeast RNA polymerase II have been derived from two crystal forms at 2.8 and 3.1 angstrom resolution. Comparison of the structures reveals a division of the polymerase into four mobile modules, including a clamp, shown previously to swing over the active center. In the 2.8 angstrom structure, the clamp is in an open state, allowing entry of straight promoter DNA for the initiation of transcription. Three loops extending from the clamp may play roles in RNA unwinding and DNA rewinding during transcription. A 2.8 angstrom difference Fourier map reveals two metal ions at the active site, one persistently bound and the other possibly exchangeable during RNA synthesis. The results also provide evidence for RNA exit in the vicinity of the carboxyl-terminal repeat domain, coupling synthesis to RNA processing by enzymes bound to this domain.