Variation in ophthalmic testing before cataract surgery. Results of a national survey of ophthalmologists

Long-term Safety and Ocular Hypotensive Efficacy Evaluation of Netarsudil Ophthalmic Solution: Rho Kinase Elevated IOP Treatment Trial (ROCKET-2)

PURPOSE

To evaluate netarsudil 0.02% ophthalmic solution in patients with open-angle glaucoma (OAG) and ocular hypertension (OHT).

DESIGN

Double-masked, randomized, multicenter, parallel-group, noninferiority clinical study.

METHODS

After a washout of all prestudy ocular hypotensive medications, 756 eligible patients with elevated IOP were randomized to receive netarsudil 0.02% once a day (q.d.) (251); netarsudil 0.02% twice a day (b.i.d.) (254); or timolol 0.5% b.i.d. (251) for 12 months, as well as a noninterventional Corneal Observation Study (COS) for patients manifesting cornea verticillata.

RESULTS

On treatment, mean IOP at 8:00 AM decreased from a baseline IOP of 22.5-22.6 mm Hg to 17.9-18.8 mm Hg, 17.2-18.0 mm Hg, and 17.5-17.9 mm Hg for netarsudil q.d., netarsudil b.i.d., and timolol, respectively, over 12 months. The most frequently reported adverse events (AEs) were ocular, with the most frequent ocular AE being conjunctival hyperemia, with an incidence of 61%, 66%, and 14%, respectively. The next most frequent AEs were corneal deposits (corneal verticillata), with an incidence of 26%, 25%, and 1%, respectively, and conjunctival hemorrhage (typically petechial), with an incidence of 20%, 19%, and 1%, respectively. All 3 AEs were generally scored as mild, with conjunctival hyperemia and/or hemorrhage appearing sporadically during the study. In the observational follow-up component of this study, there was no clinically meaningful impact of corneal verticillata on visual function in affected patients.

CONCLUSIONS

In this randomized, double-masked trial, once-daily dosing of netarsudil 0.02% was effective, consistently lowering IOP through 12 months, and was tolerated by the majority of patients.

A randomized, single-center study of equivalence of 2 intraocular lenses used in cataract surgery

PURPOSE

To compare the outcomes of 2 intraocular lenses (IOLs) for the treatment of age-related cataracts.

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized trial.

PARTICIPANTS

Patients with age-related cataracts were recruited and randomized to receive phacoemulsification and implantation of either the AcrySof SA60AT lens (Alcon, Inc, Fort Worth, TX) or the low-cost Tecsoft Flex lens (Fred Hollows Foundation, Tilganga, Nepal). A total of 300 patients were available for description and analysis (148 in the AcrySof group and 152 in the Tecsoft group).

METHODS

Patients underwent phacoemulsification and implantation of the AcrySof SA60AT lens or the Tecsoft Flex lens. They were followed up and examined at baseline, 1 week, 1 month, 6 months, and 12 months after cataract surgery.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Uncorrected distance visual acuity (UDVA), best-corrected distance visual acuity (BDVA), incidence of posterior capsule opacification (PCO), Visual Function Index questionnaire results, and safety of the implanted IOLs.

RESULTS

No significant difference (P>0.05) was found in UDVA and BDVA after surgery between the 2 groups. The equivalence test of the 95% confidence intervals showed that both lenses had an equal improvement of UDVA and BDVA as well as similar rates of PCO after cataract surgery. There was no significant difference between the 2 groups with regard to visual functioning or the incidence of adverse surgical events during (P>0.05) or after (P>0.05) the surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The Tecsoft Flex IOL is a low-cost suitable alternative that is similar to the AcrySof IOL in terms of safety and visual outcomes.

Long-term impact of treated congenital toxoplasmosis on quality of life and visual performance

BACKGROUND

Long-term evolution of congenital toxoplasmosis is not documented. We assessed the outcome of treated congenital toxoplasmosis in a cohort of adult individuals who had undergone ante- and postnatal treatment to provide information for pediatricians and parents on the evolution of the disease.

METHODS

We conducted a questionnaire study on 126 adults with congenital toxoplasmosis (mean age: 22.2 years; age range: 18-31 years) monitored regularly until the time of inclusion. The main outcome measures were quality of life (Psychological General Well-Being Index) and visual function (VF14 questionnaire), and the outcomes were correlated with disease-specific factors.

RESULTS

Of the 102 patients (80.9%) who were finally included in the study, 12 (11.8%) presented neurologic effects and 60 (58.8%) manifested ocular lesions; in the latter category, 13 individuals (12.7%) had reduced visual function. The overall global quality-of-life score (74.7 ± 14.2) was close to the expected normal range for the general population (73.7 ± 15.3). Overall, visual function was only slightly impaired (M = 97.3; 95% confidence interval, 95.8-98.8). Although disease-independent critical life circumstances were associated with a reduced Psychological General Well-Being Index, this index was not influenced by any of the clinical characteristics of congenital toxoplasmosis. Neurologic pathologies, reduced visual acuity, foveal location of the retinal lesion, and squinting contributed to decreased visual function at follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data reveal that treated congenital toxoplasmosis has little effect on the quality of life and visual function of the affected individuals. These encouraging findings may help to alleviate the anxiety of affected individuals and their parents.

An objective scatter index based on double-pass retinal images of a point source to classify cataracts

Purpose

To propose a new objective scatter index (OSI) based in the analysis of double-pass images of a point source to rank and classify cataract patients. This classification scheme is compared with a current subjective system.

Methods

We selected a population including a group of normal young eyes as control and patients diagnosed with cataract (grades NO2, NO3 and NO4) according to the Lens Opacities Classification System (LOCS III). For each eye, we recorded double-pass retinal images of a point source. In each patient, we determined an objective scatter index (OSI) as the ratio of the intensity at an eccentric location in the image and the central part. This index provides information on the relevant forward scatter affecting vision. Since the double-pass retinal images are affected by both ocular aberrations and intraocular scattering, an analysis was performed to show the ranges of contributions of aberrations to the OSI.

Results

We used the OSI values to classify each eye according to the degree of scatter. The young normal eyes of the control group had OSI values below 1, while the OSI for subjects in LOCS grade II were around 1 to 2. The use of the objective index showed some of the weakness of subjective classification schemes. In particular, several subjects initially classified independently as grade NO2 or NO3 had similar OSI values, and in some cases even higher than subjects classified as grade NO4. A new classification scheme based in OSI is proposed.

Conclusions

We introduced an objective index based in the analysis of double-pass retinal images to classify cataract patients. The method is robust and fully based in objective measurements; i.e., not depending on subjective decisions. This procedure could be used in combination with standard current methods to improve cataract patient surgery scheduling.

Principles of disability glare measurement: an ophthalmological perspective

Disability glare describes the loss of retinal image contrast as a result of intraocular light scatter, or straylight. It has increasingly important modern implications such as with cataract and refractive surgery or high-intensity lighting. However, its measurement has proven difficult despite many varying approaches. This article aims to explain the principles and problems associated with glare testing that are important for assessment and use of glare measures. After defining disability glare, this article discusses the importance of its measurement to current clinical practice. It explains the principles and mechanisms that underlie disability glare and its measurement. Finally, some examples of available glare tests are described to illustrate the principles discussed.

Capabilities of potential vision test measurements

PURPOSE

To determine the usefulness of a battery of potential vision tests (PVTs) including potential acuity meter (PAM), laser interferometer (LI), critical flicker/fusion frequency (CFF), superilluminated pinhole at distance (SPH(d)) and near (SPH(n)), and optimal reading speed (ORS) by their independence of the effects of cataracts and sensitivity to macular disease (MD).

SETTING

Department of Optometry, University of Bradford, Bradford and Leeds General Infirmary, Leeds, United Kingdom.

METHODS

Potential vision test measurements were determined in 76 patients with age-related cataract and no other eye disease, 52 patients with MD and clear ocular media, and 28 patients with normal, healthy eyes.

RESULTS

Potential vision tests were independent of the degrading effects of cataract up to a visual acuity (VA) level of 20/200 or worse (CFF), 20/125 (ORS and SPH), and 20/40 (PAM and LI). A high degree of association was found between PVT scores and distance VA in the MD group for SPH(d) (r2 = 0.93), SPH(n) (r2 = 0.89), and PAM (r2 = 0.71). A moderate correlation was found for LI (r2 = 0.55), CFF (r2 = 0.50), and ORS (r2 = 0.45).

CONCLUSIONS

Potential acuity meter and LI showed very limited independence to moderate/dense cataracts and inaccurate predictions in patients with MD. Superilluminated pinhole was relatively unaffected by moderate/dense cataract and yet provided accurate predictions in the presence of MD and clear ocular media. Critical flicker/fusion frequency showed the greatest ability to bypass cataracts, although its ability to predict VA in patients with early MD was limited. The ORS was relatively unaffected by moderate/dense cataract, but its poor ability to predict VA in MD may limit its clinical suitability as a PVT.

Effects of cataract type and location on visual function: the Blue Mountains Eye Study

PURPOSE

To measure the effect of cataract type, severity and location on presenting, and best-corrected visual acuity, contrast sensitivity, and glare disability.

METHODS

In all, 3654 (82.4% participation rate) eligible noninstitutionalised residents aged 49 years or older, living in two postcode areas of the Blue Mountains, Australia, received detailed eye examinations including visual acuity, contrast sensitivity, and glare disability testing. Data from right eyes were analysed using multiple regression modelling.

RESULTS

The effect of age on visual acuity and contrast sensitivity only became evident in persons aged at least 60 years. Cataract severity was inversely related to visual acuity and contrast sensitivity. Late posterior subcapsular cataract caused the greatest reduction in visual acuity. Early grade cataract caused significant reduction in contrast sensitivity at intermediate and high spatial frequencies, but late grade cataract reduced contrast sensitivity across all spatial frequencies. There was insufficient study power to detect consistent significant effect of cataract on glare disability tests or cortical cataract location on visual function.

CONCLUSIONS

Age at least 60 years, cataract type, and cataract severity were principal determinants of visual acuity and contrast sensitivity in this study. Axial and superotemporally located cortical cataract had the greatest effect on visual function tests.

Reading performance depending on the type of cataract and its predictability on the visual outcome

PURPOSE

To investigate the influence of various types of cataract on reading performance in a standardized reading test setting.

SETTING

Department of Ophthalmology, University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria.

METHODS

The reading performance of 94 eyes with age-related cataract and normal macular function was evaluated with the Radner Reading Charts preoperatively and 4 weeks after cataract surgery. Distance visual acuity was tested with the ETDRS charts. Cataracts were graded using the Lens Opacities Classification System (LOCS) III, on which NO is nuclear opalescence and NC is nuclear color.

RESULTS

Patients with pure nuclear cataracts (LOCS III: NO/NC 2.1-5) achieved a normally high MRS (99.84% +/- 7.65% of their postoperative MRS): preoperative MRS(1): 190.6 +/- 30.74 words per minute (wpm); postoperative MRS(2): 191.21 +/- 29.36 wpm. Patients with mixed nuclear-cortical cataracts (LOCS III: NO/NC 2.1-5; C>2) preoperatively achieved 96.96% +/- 5.6% of their postoperative MRS (MRS(1): 175.77 +/- 31.54 wpm; MRS(2): 181.34 +/- 30.56 wpm). In dense nuclear cataracts (LOCS III: NO/NC>5), the MRS was significantly reduced, achieving only 72.64 +/- 19.19% of the postoperative MRS (MRS(1): 133.06 +/- 39.43 wpm; MRS(2): 185.76 +/- 40.18 wpm). In posterior subcapsular cataracts, the preoperative MRS (134.1 +/- 33.72 wpm) was significantly lower than postoperatively (191.14 +/- 27.08 wpm).

CONCLUSIONS

In contrast to dense nuclear cataracts and posterior subcapsular cataracts, the preoperative reading speed of patients with pure nuclear or nuclear-cortical cataracts was normal at large print sizes. The preoperative evaluation of reading acuity and speed with standardized reading tests can therefore be used to estimate the postoperative reading performance in the latter 2 types of cataract.

Quality care and practice variation: the roles of practice guidelines and public profiles

Goals of the quality-of-care initiative are to improve the structure, process, and outcome of health care. The effectiveness of methods to improve quality have been largely unverified. Most methods are costly to implement and time-consuming to perform; some threaten professional autonomy. The characteristic feature of modern medicine that fuels the debate over quality is the variation in the delivery of health care. This review examines the "variation phenomenon" in medicine and the roles that practice guidelines and physician profiling have in improving health care, in general, and for adult cataract, in particular.

Potential acuity meter results in cataract patients

PURPOSE

To determine the ability of the potential acuity meter (PAM) to predict potential visual acuity through lenticular opacities in a group of cataract patients without significant other ocular pathology.

METHODS

This prospective study undertook PAM measurements on each eye of 84 subjects during preoperative hospital visits to either A Scan or Primary Care clinics. PAM results were compared to best corrected visual acuity findings obtained at least 6 weeks post-cataract extraction.

RESULTS

Comparison of PAM result to visual outcome showed poor correlation (rho = 0.41, P = 0.0005). Using predictive estimates, 49% of subjects' PAM results underestimated visual outcome as determined by a difference of greater than 2 Snellen acuity lines in these results. Factors such as preoperative vision level, cataract type and pupil dilation did not significantly influence the predictive power of the PAM. Preoperative pinhole results were also correlated with visual outcome (rho = 0.42, P = 0.0006). Vison in the fellow eye of subjects with 6/9 or better was correlated to the PAM result indicating a moderate to good predictive power in 'normal' eyes.

CONCLUSIONS

PAM results were considered to be poor for a clinical test. The results of this study indicate that this instrument has only a limited usefulness as part of the standard preoperatve examination in patients undergoing cataract extraction.

Use of vision tests in clinical decision making about cataract surgery: results of a national survey

AIM

To provide information on the use of vision tests in clinical decision making about cataract surgery in the UK.

METHOD

A questionnaire survey was mailed to 703 consultant ophthalmologists.

RESULTS

A response rate of 70% was obtained. Monocular distance visual acuity was the only visual function that was tested routinely by all surgeons. Supplementary use of contrast sensitivity and glare testing was low. Many surgeons (35%) were willing to consider surgery at acuity levels better than 6/9 and a small but substantial number (12%) indicated that they did not use an acuity criterion. Being prepared to consider surgery at relatively good levels of acuity was not associated with more common use of other tests of vision.

CONCLUSION

Many UK surgeons are prepared to consider cataract extraction at relatively good levels of visual acuity and use other vision tests infrequently.

Health, medicine, and ophthalmology: facing the facts and paying the piper LVI Edward Jackson Memorial Lecture

PURPOSE

To describe the sources of tension within the health care system and methods for pursuing their solution.

METHODS

Presentation of observations pertinent to patient, provider, and payer perspectives relevant to the cost, delivery, and quality of care and their impact on health.

RESULTS

Societal forces, not just wealth, are major determinants of both health and the costs of health care.

CONCLUSIONS

Tensions created by rising health care costs in the face of finite societal resources will increase in the years ahead. These can be resolved only by realizing new efficiencies in care, and prioritizing, through an explicit process, the care that is to be provided.

Assessment of potential macular function using a color saturation discrimination test in eyes with cataract

PURPOSE

To study the efficacy of a color saturation discrimination test (CSDT) in assessing potential macular function in eyes with cataract.

SETTING

Yamanashi Medical University and Nirasaki City Hospital, Yamanashi, Japan.

METHODS

In this prospective study of 200 consecutive eyes with cataract, the thresholds of color saturation discrimination on 6 hues were measured with the CSDT. The CSDT program was run on a personal computer and cathode-ray tube color monitor. The preoperative CSDT scores and postoperative visual acuities were compared. In addition, preoperative laser interferometry (LI) and postoperative CSDT were performed on selected patients and the results compared with their preoperative CSDT results.

RESULTS

Patients who had a CSDT score of 11 or more had a significantly lower postoperative visual acuity (P < .0001). The prevalence of neuroretinal abnormality postoperatively increased with the preoperative CSDT score. The CSDT score was not correlated with preoperative visual acuity (P = 1409). Cataract severity had little influence on the CSDT score. The preoperative results of the CSDT and Ll were correlated with the postoperative acuity, with the correlation coefficient being stronger with the CSDT (r = -0.338 and 0.276 for CSDT and Ll, respectively).

CONCLUSION

The CSDT was effective in evaluating neuroretinal pathology and predicting postoperative acuity.

Functional complaints, visual acuity, spatial contrast sensitivity, and glare disability in preoperative and postoperative cataract patients

PURPOSE

To quantify cataract patients' functional visual complaints and correlate them with their objective glare disability and spatial contrast sensitivity (SCS) scores.

SETTING

Sir Mortimer B. Davis Jewish General Hospital. Montreal, Quebec, Canada.

METHODS

Thirty patients scheduled for cataract surgery with a visual acuity of 20/70 or better at the time of patient selection and no other ocular pathology were evaluated objectively and subjectively for visual function preoperatively and within 3 months postoperatively. Objective measures of SCS and visual acuity in the presence and absence of glare were obtained with the Optec 3000 vision tester. Subjective visual function was evaluated with the Activities of Daily Vision Scale (ADVS), a questionnaire that evaluates patients' visual function by assessing the degree of difficulty they experience in performing tasks involving distance vision, near vision, and glare conditions.

RESULTS

Preoperatively, patients had decreased visual acuity and SCS in the presence of glare. The ADVS scores were correlated with visual performance. Postoperatively, there was a statistically significant improvement in all dependent measures (i.e., visual acuity and SCS in the presence of glare) as well as in the subjective report of visual performance assessed by the ADVS.

CONCLUSION

Spatial contrast sensitivity, glare disability, and the ADVS questionnaire should be considered as adjuncts to visual acuity testing in evaluating certain cataract patients.

Effectiveness of cataract surgery in Barcelona, Spain site results of an international study. Barcelona I-PORT investigators. International Patient Outcomes Research Team

OBJECTIVES

To describe the impact of cataract surgery on visual function and health status in terms of clinical indicators as well as perceived health and functional capacity, and to identify patient characteristics and differences in clinical management that might affect outcomes.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Observational longitudinal study of a cohort of 218 patients aged 50 or older undergoing first eye cataract surgery. Patients were evaluated pre- and postoperatively by clinical examinations (visual acuity [VA], ocular and medical comorbidity) and standardized telephone interviews. Main outcome measures included: the VF-14 Visual Function Index, the Cataract Symptom Score (CSS), the Sickness Impact Profile (SIP), and global measures of patients' trouble and satisfaction with vision.

RESULTS

Significant improvement in all outcomes measures were observed at 4 months postoperatively (P < 0.001). However, the proportion of improved patients varied according to the outcome considered: VA (87%), CSS (72%), VF-14 (62%), and SIP (38%). Patient characteristics associated with higher a level of improvement were: worse preoperative visual function (VA, CSS, VF-14) (P < 0.001), less ocular comorbidity (P < 0.05), less postoperative complications (P < 0.05) and better preoperative general health status (SIP) (P < 0.01). The differences in clinical management were not associated with the outcomes (effectiveness) of surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

A large proportion of patients benefit from cataract surgery, the greatest gain corresponding to visual function rather than to general health status. Since effectiveness of surgery is unrelated to operative procedures, less costly practices (i.e., day case surgery and loco-regional anesthesia) should be promoted.

Glare disability and contrast sensitivity before and after cataract surgery

PURPOSE

To determine whether brightness-induced glare decreases spatial contrast sensitivity and visual acuity in preoperative cataract patients with functional visual complaints and to compare preoperative with postoperative results.

SETTING

Sir Mortimer B. Davis Jewish General Hospital, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.

METHODS

Twenty patients with a visual acuity of 20/70 or better at the time of chart selection and no other ocular pathology who were referred for cataract surgery were evaluated with the Optec 3000 vision tester to assess contrast sensitivity and visual acuity in the presence and absence of glare. Testing was done preoperatively and 1 and 3 months postoperatively.

RESULTS

An analysis of variance indicated that there were statistically significant double interactions between the preoperative/postoperative and glare/no-glare variables and between the preoperative/postoperative and spatial frequency variables. Postoperatively, visual acuity and contrast sensitivity improved to within normal limits. There were no statistically significant differences in visual acuity and spatial contrast sensitivity between 1 and 3 months postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

Spatial contrast sensitivity and glare testing provided objective assessment of patients who had good visual acuity yet also had functional complaints.

Site of service, anesthesia, and postoperative practice patterns for oculoplastic and orbital surgeries

PURPOSE

Variations in physician practice patterns, particularly with reference to cost-intensive resource utilization, are increasingly being scrutinized. However, little information is currently available regarding physician practice patterns for oculoplastic surgery.

METHODS

The authors surveyed members of the American Society of Ophthalmic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery regarding their most common site of service, type of anesthesia, and first postoperative week of follow-up for 15 selected eyelid, lacrimal, and orbital procedures.

RESULTS

The majority of eyelid and lacrimal surgeries are currently performed on an out-patient basis (hospital out-patient, ambulatory surgery center, or office), typically using local anesthesia, with or without sedation. Regional differences were noted. Physicians in western states showed a greater tendency toward office-based surgery for procedures such as blepharoplasty and ptosis repair. Orbital procedures were performed more frequently as a hospital inpatient surgery, under general anesthesia. Patterns of follow-up within the first postoperative week varied considerably for most procedures. Compared with admitting practices in 1987, an obvious trend toward out-patient surgery was noted.

CONCLUSION

Variations in practice patterns will assume greater importance as the pressure for cost-containment increases. Total costs are affected by physician choices for site of service and type of anesthesia. This study allows surgeons who perform oculoplastic procedures to compare their practices with a national group specializing in such surgery. Further outcome-oriented studies are needed to develop practice guidelines for "preferred patterns" of care.

Cataract surgery in one eye or both. A billion dollar per year issue

PURPOSE

To measure the relative effect of cataract surgery in the second eye compared with the first eye on functional impairment, satisfaction, and vision problems.

METHODS

Seventy-five randomly selected ophthalmologists in three cities in the United States were enrolled in a National Study of Cataract Outcomes. They, in turn, referred eligible, sequential patients scheduled for first-eye cataract surgery. Interviews were conducted at enrollment, 4 months after first-eye surgery, and 12 months after first-eye surgery. An attempt was made to conduct a special, preoperative interview of those patients scheduled to undergo second-eye surgery before the 4-month interview. Each interview included administration of the VF-14 (a 14-item questionnaire that assessed visual function), as well as questions about symptoms possibly related to cataract, "trouble with vision," and satisfaction with vision.

RESULTS

Seven hundred seventy-two patients were enrolled in the study, and interview data to 12 months were obtained from 669 (86%) patients. Of these patients, 243 (36%) underwent cataract extraction in the second eye during the 12-month period of observation. Overall, subjects who underwent cataract surgery in both eyes during the 12-month period had 61% greater improvement in VF-14 score (P < 0.001), 27% more decline in trouble with vision (P < 0.001), and 24% greater improvement in satisfaction with vision (P < 0.001) compared with those who underwent surgery in only one eye.

CONCLUSIONS

Cataract surgery in the second eye of patients with bilateral cataract is associated with clinical and statistically significant improvement in functional impairment, trouble with vision, and satisfaction with vision.