Dual innervation may occur in a partially denervated muscle

INTRODUCTION

With a view to simplifying surgical techniques for selective laryngeal reinnervation, we addressed the question of whether it is feasible to receive additional innervation by a partially denervated muscle using an infrahyoid muscle model.

METHODS

In 90 rats (6 groups of 15), phrenic nerve transfer was used to reinnervate the sternothyroid muscle. In some cases, residual innervation by the original nerve was present. Three months later we performed electromyographic studies, contraction strength measurements, histologic assessment, and retrograde labeling.

RESULTS

Muscles reinnervated by the phrenic nerve had a greater "dual-response" rate (in terms of nerve latency, contraction strength, and retrograde labeling) than muscles in the control groups.

DISCUSSION

The phrenic nerve can impart its inspiratory properties to an initially denervated strap muscle-even when residual innervation is present. The preservation of contractile potential confirmed the feasibility of dual innervation in a previously injured muscle. Muscle Nerve 59:108-115, 2019.

Functional Remobilization Evaluation of the Paralyzed Vocal Cord by End-to-Side Neurorrhaphy in Rats

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the value of end-to-side neurorrhaphy to treat vocal cord paralysis.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective study evaluating the effects of end-to-side neurorrhaphy to treat vocal cord paralysis by means of fiberoptic laryngoscopy and nerve electromyography.

METHODS

Thirty Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into experimental group 1, experimental group 2, and a control group randomly. Right recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) was incised, and the distal end of the RLN was anastomosed to the right phrenic nerve by end-to-side neurorrhaphy in experimental group 1 or by end-to-end nerve anastomosis in experimental group 2, respectively. The adductor nerve branch of the right RLN was incised and anastomosed to the proximal end of the right ansa cervicalis nerve by end-to-end nerve anastomosis. Fiberoptic laryngoscopy and nerve electromyography were used to examine the vocal cord movement and nerve regeneration.

RESULTS

Three months after operation, this effect of end-to-side neurorrhaphy created a significant difference compared with the end-to-end nerve anastomosis (P < .05). The end-to-side neurorrhaphy did not lead to vocal cord movement compared with end-to-end nerve anastomosis.

CONCLUSION

Vocal cord paralysis cannot be treated by this microsurgical technique.

Experimental reinnervation of a strap muscle with a few roots of the phrenic nerve in rabbits

In order to compare application of the roots of the phrenic nerve to the ansa hypoglossi for laryngeal muscle neurotization, 1 or more roots from the phrenic nerve were implanted into the right sternothyroid (RST) muscle of rabbits (n = 36). Controls were intact animals (in which RST innervation is provided by the ansa; n = 6) and denervated ones (n = 6). At 66 +/- 2 days (mean +/- SE) after neurotization, during quiet breathing, inspiratory electromyographic activity and isometric contraction force were observed in all reinnervated RST muscles (n = 24). During maximal inspiratory effort, electromyographic activity and force increased. In animals reinnervated by the C4 root alone, forces (46.22 +/- 7.8 g) were significantly higher than in intact animals (10.83 +/- 5.0 g). Retrograde labeling proved the phrenic origin of the neurotization. Electromyography of the diaphragm was recorded. We conclude that in rabbits, neurotization of a strap muscle by 1 or 2 roots of the phrenic nerve allows inspiratory contraction, even during quiet breathing. Such inspiratory activity is not observed in sternothyroid muscles of intact animals innervated by the ansa hypoglossi.

Comparison of nerve banking techniques in delayed laryngeal reinnervation

Successful laryngeal transplantation will require adequate reinnervation of the larynx to allow phonation, coordinated swallowing, and respiration. A delay between laryngectomy and transplantation would be necessary in oncology patients because of the need for immunosuppression. In these patients, reinnervation of the donor organ would require "banking" and recovery of dormant recipient recurrent laryngeal nerves (RLNs). This pilot study was undertaken to compare the effectiveness of RLN storage using 1 of 2 techniques: 1) inserting the nerve into a muscle pocket or 2) anastomosing the proximal RLN stump to the ansa cervicalis. Six months following nerve transection and "banking," the proximal anterior branch of the RLN was reanastomosed to the distal anterior segment and the posterior branch was anastomosed directly to the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle. Tensionometry, image analysis, and electromyographic data were collected 1 year later. Results show reinnervation of adductors and abductors with both techniques. Banking of the RLN branches during total laryngectomy is effective and should permit delayed physiological reinnervation following laryngeal transplantation.

Cervical anatomy of phrenic nerve roots in the rabbit. European Group for Research on the Larynx

The cervical anatomy of the different nerve contributions that constitute the phrenic nerve (phrenic nerve roots and accessory phrenic nerve) were studied in rabbits. In 55 dissections, 6 main root arrangement types were observed. The roots that issued from the fourth and fifth cervical nerves (C4 and C5 roots) were constant. The C4 root was either short or long. The C6 root was at times absent, or sometimes double. An accessory phrenic nerve was present in 43% of the right and 28% of the left dissections. The distribution of the phrenic nerve roots often displayed left-right asymmetry. We conclude that a better knowledge of the cervical anatomy of the phrenic nerve is useful both in physiological studies involving diaphragm denervation and in experimental laryngeal reinnervation.

Physiologic Motion after Laryngeal Nerve Reinnervation: A New Method

In this study a new method of reinnervation for unilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis was performed in canines, producing physiologic vocal fold motion in each of a small series of animals. During the procedure the left anterior division of the recurrent laryngeal nerve was reinnervated with axons from the thyroarytenoid branch of the contralateral recurrent laryngeal nerve. The posterior branch of the left recurrent laryngeal nerve was divided and sutured to the ansa cervicalis to maintain tone in the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle. In all four animals, the right distal vocalis stump was reinnervated with an ansa cervicalis nerve branch. After 3 months physiologic vocal fold motion and electromyographic activity could be demonstrated during mechanical stimulation of the supraglottis (adduction) and during tracheostomy obstruction (abduction). Acoustic data revealed improvement of jitter, shimmer, signal-to-noise ratio, and vocal efficiency in reinnervated animals compared with paralyzed canines before treatment, although the results lacked statistical significance. This approach to the rehabilitation of unilateral vocal fold paralysis is discussed. (Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1997;116:466–74.)

A functional evaluation of ansa cervicalis nerve transfer for unilateral vocal cord paralysis: future directions for laryngeal reinnervation

There are a variety of methods for treating unilateral vocal cord paralysis, but to date there are few objective studies that evaluate the functional results of nerve transfer from the ansa cervicalis. Six dogs underwent unilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve section with immediate reanastamosis to the sternothyroid branch of the ansa cervicalis. After 5 to 6 months, measurements of vocal efficiency and acoustic parameters, videolaryngoscopy, videostroboscopy, and evoked electromyography were performed. Identical measurements were made in eight control dogs during normal electrically induced phonation and a simulated unilateral recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis. Histologic analysis of both vocalis muscles, recurrent laryngeal nerves, ansa cervicalis, and the ansa-recurrent laryngeal nerve anastamosis site was performed. Evidence of reinnervation was found in all of the animals that underwent nerve transfer. The vocal efficiency and acoustic quality after ansa cervicalis nerve transfer were dependent on the degree of electrical stimulation from the transferred nerve to the reinnervated cord during phonation. In the absence of electrical stimulation to the nerve transfer, physiologic vocal cord motion could not be elicited from the reinnervated cord.

Selective reinnervation of the abductor and adductor muscles of the canine larynx after recurrent nerve paralysis

Functional rehabilitation of the larynx after unilateral vocal cord paralysis was attempted in the dog by selective reinnervation of the laryngeal muscles. The intralaryngeal branches of the right recurrent nerve were dissected. The adductor branch was anastomosed with the ansa cervicalis; the abductor branch was anastomosed with the trunk of the phrenic nerve either within the larynx or through the recurrent nerve, the adductor branch of which was sectioned. Results could be analyzed in seven dogs: mobility of the vocal cord was checked, and electromyography, stimulation of the nerves, and histologic studies were performed. Functional reinnervation of both the adductor and abductor muscles was obtained in only one case, with good abduction. Adduction was recorded in five cases. False-positive results emphasize the necessity of collecting several types of data before concluding that functional reinnervation has been accomplished. The reliability of the procedure can and must be improved.

Laryngeal synkinesis: its significance to the laryngologist

Basic research and surgical cases have shown that the injured recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) may regenerate axons to the larynx that inappropriately innervate both vocal cord adductors and abductors. Innervation of vocal cord adductor muscles by those axons that depolarize during inspiration is particularly devastating to laryngeal function, since it produces medial vocal cord movement during inspiration. Many patients thought to have clinical bilateral vocal cord paralysis can be found to have synkinesis on at least one side. This will make the glottic airway smaller, particularly during inspiration, than would true paralysis of all the intrinsic laryngeal muscles. Patients with bilateral vocal cord paralysis should undergo laryngeal electromyography. If inspiratory innervation of the adductor muscles is present, simple reinnervation of the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle will fail. The adductor muscles also must be denervated by transection of the adductor division of the regenerated RLN.

Phrenic nerve graft for bilateral vocal cord paralysis

For bilateral vocal cord paralysis, the phrenic nerve graft procedure has been used in five patients. Data from four of these patients suggest that the technique may in some way improve the glottic airway without long-term diaphragmatic paralysis. No patient to date has demonstrated visible inspiratory vocal cord abduction however. The mechanism of action, if any, is unclear at this time, and we have no electromyographic nor other physiologic data to confirm that true posterior cricoarytenoid muscle reinnervation has taken place.

Experiments in laryngeal reinnervation

Laryngeal reinnervation surgical procedures were performed in 26 dogs. Nineteen animals comprise the data reported in this thesis. Two different operative procedures were investigated, the ansa hypoglossi neuromuscular pedicle in 5 dogs, and the split phrenic nerve graft in 14 dogs. The studies were designed to evaluate whether either procedure resulted in inspiratory abduction of the vocal cord: and, if so, the mechanism by which abduction was produced. Five dogs in Experiment 1 demonstrated similar results from the ansa hypoglossi neuromuscular pedicle procedure. Apparent vocal cord abduction was seen during hyperpnea from airway obstruction, but was abolished by superior laryngeal nerve transection, or detachment of the sternothyroid muscle. None of the nerves in the neuromuscular pedicles was electrically excitable. Fourteen dogs in Experiment 2 underwent the split phrenic nerve graft operation. Vocal cord abduction, synchronized with inspiration, was noted in 5 animals. Two dogs had inspiratory abduction in quiet respiration. Electromyography, nerve action potentials, endoscopic motion pictures, and histologic study confirmed that posterior cricoarytenoid muscle reinnervation had occurred via the nerve graft from the phrenic nerve. Vocal cord abduction and electromyographic activity in the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle were abolished by transection of the nerve graft or the phrenic nerve. Conclusions of the study include the following: 1. The neuromuscular pedicle procedure does not result in reinnervation of the posterior cricoarytenoid muscle the pedicle's nerve and muscle block. 2. The phrenic procedure may result in reinnervation of the posterior cricoarytenoid via the nerve graft, and inspiratory abduction of the paralyzed vocal cord. Failure of the phrenic procedure to produce reinnervation appeared to be due to a. recurrent laryngeal nerve regeneration, or b. avulsion of the nerve graft due to swallowing and other laryngeal movements.

Regeneration of the recurrent laryngeal nerve

Ten dogs underwent exploration and section of the right recurrent laryngeal nerve. A segment was removed and both stumps were ligated. Reoperation at three months and again at 15 months revealed neural regeneration through the ligated site and reconstitution of the distal nerve in seven of the eight dogs surviving the 15-month period. This strong regenerative capability of the recurrent laryngeal nerve may explain recurrences of spastic dysphonia after nerve section. It is recommended that patients be advised of the possibility for return of the spasms. Investigators should always note whether the recurrent laryngeal nerve has regained stimulability in reporting results of experimental laryngeal paralysis and reinnervation.

Horseradish peroxidase studies in animals with neuromuscular transpositions

Horseradish peroxidase (HRP) is used to trace axonal connections from the motor end-plate to the driving neuron. This technique has confirmed that the neurons activating the sternothyroid muscle are located in the cervical spinal cord, while those controlling the posterior cricoarytenoid (PCA) are found in the nucleus ambiguus ipsilaterally. Eight rabbits underwent a sternothyroid ansa pedicle implantation to the PCA at the time of sectioning the recurrent laryngeal nerve ipsilaterally. After two months, four of these animals received HRP injections into the previously implanted PCA. Brainstem staining HRP did not reveal any retrograde transport to the motor neurons that were known to control the sternothyroid. Possible for the failure of retrograde transport are discussed.

Laryngeal reinnervation using the split-phrenic nerve-graft procedure

A new operative procedure for reinnervation of the paralyzed larynx is described. Initial successes in a series of animals have shown that use of the split-phrenic nerve-graft procedure results in functional abduction of the paralyzed vocal cord, while preserving innervation to the diaphragm. Electromyography, microlaryngoscopic movies, chest fluoroscopic examination, and nerve compound action potential recordings were all used to document these findings. This procedure appears to have several advantages over the neuromuscular pedicle operation described by Tucker.

Reconstruction of laryngeal function for recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis: historical view, advancement of latest investigations and a preliminary experiment

Historical investigations of the functional restoration for recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis are reviewed and some advancement in recent studies are introduced. A preliminary experiment is reported in which the ansa hypoglossi and the sternothyroid muscle pedicle was implanted into the denervated posterior cricoarytenoid muscle in dogs. From these experiments we have concluded that the ansa hypoglossi and sternothyroid muscle pedicle, which has been shown to transmit efferent inspiratory bursts, is capable of restoring function to the paralyzed posterior cricoarytenoid muscle in some dogs.

Reinnervation of the unilaterally paralyzed larynx

Because of early success with reinnervation of the abductor musculature of bilaterally paralyzed larynges, experimental work and ultimately surgery in human patients has been undertaken to endeavor to apply the same basic concept to reinnervation of the unilaterally paralyzed larynx. A nerve-muscle pedicle is obtained from the omohyoid muscle in a manner identical to that previously reported. The lower 50% of the thyroid ala is carefully removed outside the perichondrial envelope and the lateral fibers of the thyroarytenoideus muscle (major laryngeal adductor) is exposed. The previously repaired nerve-muscle pedicle is inserted into this muscle to complete the procedure. The procedure has been undertaken in nine cases to date where the degree of posterior glottic chink, usually because of a concomitant superior nerve paralysis, was felt to be too great to be adequately managed by Teflon injection. Some degree of spontaneous return of adduction was accomplished in all nine cases.