What Do Patients Think About Physicians' Conflicts of Interest?: Watching Transparency Evolve

A Guide to Industry Payments and an Algorithm for Their Management

BACKGROUND

The Open Payments database was created to increase transparency of industry payment relationships within medicine. The current literature often examines only 1 year of the database. In this study, the authors use 5 years of data to show trends among industry payments to plastic surgeons from 2014 to 2018. In addition, the authors lay out the basics of conflict-of-interest reporting for the new plastic surgeon. Finally, the authors suggest an algorithm for the responsible management of industry relationships.

METHODS

This study analyzed nonresearch payments made to plastic surgeons from January 1, 2014, to December 31, 2018. Descriptive statistics were calculated using R Statistical Software and visualized using Tableau.

RESULTS

A total of 304,663 payments totaling $140,889,747 were made to 8148 plastic surgeons; 41 percent ($58.28 million) was paid to 50 plastic surgeons in the form of royalty or license payments. With royalties excluded, average and median payments were $276 and $25. The average yearly total per physician was $2028. Of the 14 payment categories, 95 percent of the total amount paid was attributable payments in one of six categories. Seven hundred thirty companies reported payments to plastic surgeons from 2014 to 2018; 15 companies (2 percent) were responsible for 80 percent ($66.34 million) of the total sum paid. Allergan was responsible for $24.45 million (29.6 percent) of this amount.

CONCLUSIONS

Although discussions on the proper management of industry relationships continue to evolve, the data in this study illustrate the importance of managing industry relationships. The simple guidelines suggested create a basis for managing industry relationships in the career of the everyday plastic surgeon.

Industry Payments by Allergan, Inc to Plastic Surgery and Related Specialties in 2018

In 2014, payments to medical providers from drug/device manufacturers were made public through the Open Payments Database. Although previous studies have used the Open Payments Database to describe relationships between specialties and industry, few have evaluated specific companies and the effect of their contributions. As a large contributor to industry payments in plastic surgery, Allergan, Inc represents a significant source of potential financial conflicts of interest in the field. In this study, we aimed to describe the quantity, type, and specific products associated with Allergan's payments to both plastic surgeons and physicians of other specialties. In 2018, Allergan paid a total of $48,484,163 in 397,225 payments to 90,386 physicians. Psychiatry and neurology received $11,867,861 in payments, the largest of any specialty, whereas internal medicine received the largest number of individual payments. Plastic surgeons made the most per physician ($3025). Most payments made to plastic surgeons were categorized as "gifts." Payments made in relation to Botox were predominantly made to neurologists, whereas most payments attributed to Natrelle breast implants were made to plastic surgeons (74.4%). Surprisingly, 18.2% of Natrelle payments were made to family medicine physicians. Further study is needed to fully understand the implications of the financial contributions revealed in this study.