Hemostatic effects of low-dose protamine following cardiopulmonary bypass

Does heparin rebound lead to postoperative blood loss in patients undergoing cardiac surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass?

BACKGROUND

Heparin rebound is a common observed phenomenon after cardiac surgery with CPB and is associated with increased postoperative blood loss. However, the administration of extra protamine may lead to increased blood loss as well. Therefore, we want to investigate the relation between heparin rebound and postoperative blood loss and the necessity to provide extra protamine to reverse heparin rebound.

METHODS

We searched PubMed, Cochrane, EMBASE, Google Scholar and Web of Science to review the question: "Does heparin rebound lead to postoperative blood loss in patients undergoing cardiac surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass." Combination of search words were framed within four major categories: heparin rebound, blood loss, cardiac surgery and cardiopulmonary bypass. All studies that met our question were included. Quality assessment was performed using the Cochrane risk of bias (RoB2) tool for randomized controlled trials and the risk of bias in non-randomized studies of intervention (ROBINS-I) for non-randomised trials.

RESULTS

4 randomized and 17 non-randomized studies were included. The mean incidence of heparin rebound was 40%. The postoperative heparin levels, due to heparin rebound, were often below or equal to 0.2 IU/mL. We could not demonstrate an association between heparin rebound and postoperative blood loss or transfusion requirements. However the quality of evidence was poor due to a broad variety of definitions of heparin rebound, measured by various coagulation tests and studies with small sample sizes.

CONCLUSION

The influence of heparin rebound on postoperative bleeding seems to be negligible, but might get significant in conjunction with incomplete heparin reversal or other coagulopathies. For that reason, it might be useful to get a picture of the entire coagulation spectrum after cardiac surgery, as can be done by the use of a viscoelastic test in conjunction with an aggregometry test.

Accurate protamine:heparin matching (not just smaller protamine doses) decreases postoperative bleeding in cardiac surgery; results from a high-volume academic medical center

BACKGROUND

A multidisciplinary Quality Assurance/Performance Improvement study to identify the incidence of "heparin rebound" in our adult cardiac surgical population instead detected a thromboelastometry pattern suggestive of initial protamine overdose in 34% despite Hepcon-guided anticoagulation management. Analysis of our practice led to an intervention that made an additional lower-range Hepcon cartridge available to the perfusionists.

METHODS

One year later, an IRB-approved retrospective study was conducted in >500 patients to analyze the effects of the intervention, specifically focusing on the impact of the initial protamine dose accuracy and 18-h mediastinal chest tube drainage (MCTd).

RESULTS

No differences were observed between group demographics, surgical procedures, duration of CPB or perioperative blood product transfusion. Both groups were managed using the same perfusion and anesthesia equipment, strategies, and protocols. The median initial protamine dose decreased by 19% (p < .001) in the intervention group (170 [IQR 140-220] mg; n = 295) versus the control group (210 [180-250] mg; n = 257). Mean 18-h MCTd decreased by 13% (p < .001) in the intervention group (405.15 ± 231.54 mL; n = 295) versus the control group (466.13 ± 286.73 mL; n = 257). Covariate-adjusted mixed effects model showed a significant reduction of MCTd in the intervention group, starting from hour 11 after surgery (group by time interaction p = .002).

CONCLUSION

Though previous investigators have associated lower protamine doses with less MCTd, this study demonstrates that more accurately matching the initial protamine dose to the remaining circulating heparin concentration reduces postoperative bleeding.

Heparin Rebound: An In-Depth Review

The common conception of "heparin rebound" invokes heparin returning to circulation in the postoperative period after apparently adequate intraoperative reversal with protamine. This is believed to portend increased postoperative bleeding and provides the rationale for administering additional empiric doses of protamine in response to prolonged coagulation tests and/or bleeding. However, the relevant literature of the last 60+ years provides only a weak level of evidence that "rebounded" heparin itself is a significant etiology of postoperative bleeding after cardiac surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass. Notably, many of the most frequently cited heparin rebound investigators ultimately concluded that although exceedingly low levels of heparin activity could be detected by anti-Xa assay in some (but not all) patients postoperatively, there was no correlation with actual bleeding. An understanding of the literature requires a careful reading of the details because the investigators lacked standardized definitions for "heparin rebound" and "adequate reversal" while studying the phenomenon with significantly different experimental methodologies and laboratory tests. This review was undertaken to provide a modern understanding of the "heparin rebound" phenomenon to encourage an evidence-based approach to postoperative bleeding. Literature searches were conducted via PubMed using the following MeSH terms: heparin rebound, heparin reversal, protamine, platelet factor 4, and polybrene. Relevant English language articles were reviewed, with subsequent references obtained from the internal citations. Perspective is provided for both those who use HepCon-guided management and those who do not, as are practical recommendations for the modern era based on the published data and conclusions of the various investigators.

Is a fixed low-dose protamine better at reducing postoperative bleeding in off pump coronary artery bypass grafting?

CONTEXT

Protamine is used ubiquitously in all cardiac surgeries for reversal of heparin. Risk of postoperative bleeding is increased with inadequate heparin reversal or due to anticoagulant side effects of protamine; hence, it is important to dose protamine properly. This study compares 80% protamine dose with full dose on postoperative bleeding and transfusion needs in OPCAB.

AIMS

The aim of our study was to find whether lower dose of protamine could reduce postoperative bleeding and need for blood product transfusions in off pump coronary artery bypass grafting as compared to the regular dose of protamine.

SETTINGS AND DESIGN

This was a double-blinded randomised controlled trial where patients posted for off pump CABG meeting the inclusion criteria were included in the study.

METHODS AND MATERIAL

Ninety patients were randomised to two groups, group F receiving full dose of protamine of 1 mg per mg heparin used, and group L received 0.8 mg per mg. Postoperative activated clotting time, bleeding at 1 h, 4 h, 24 h and total drainage till drains removal and blood product transfusion requirements were noted.Statistical analysis used: SPSS software.

RESULTS

Both groups were matched in demographics, preoperative cessation of heparin and aspirin and platelet counts. Both groups received equal heparin dose, activated clotting time before protamine, activated clotting time post protamine in OT and ICU were equal as were the conduits used. There was no significant difference between the groups in post-operative drainage over time or in the need for blood product transfusions.

CONCLUSIONS

Eighty per cent of the dose of protamine can adequately reverse the heparin used during off pump cardiac surgery without any increase in incidence of postoperative bleeding or need for blood product transfusions.

Heparin monitoring during cardiac surgery. Part 2: calculating the overestimation of heparin by the activated clotting time

Activated clotting time (ACT) values were converted to heparin concentration, enabling an assessment of the accuracy of the ACT and a quantification of the prolongation imposed by bypass. Blood samples were obtained from 42 adult cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) patients before and during bypass surgery. Samples were analysed for ACT (HemoTec ACT) and anti-factor Xa (anti-Xa) plasma heparin concentration. The mean heparin concentration calculated before bypass was an accurate reflection of plasma heparin; however, calculated values rose to around 170% of anti-Xa values upon connection to bypass. By adjusting for this rise, for 95% of cases the calculated heparin concentration would vary between 0.60 and 1.65 times anti-Xa values. Without accounting for artificial prolongation or individual sensitivities, the ACT may give values between 0.8 and 3.0 times that indicated by the anti-Xa assay. When both individual heparin sensitivities and the effects of bypass are considered, the ACT may provide a more suitable indication of heparin levels; however, typical use may overestimate heparin up to threefold.

Reversal of heparin after cardiac surgery: protamine titration using a statistical model

OBJECTIVE

To establish a statistical model for determination of protamine dose in conjunction with cardiopulmonary bypass.

DESIGN

Prospective.

SETTING

University hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Ninety consecutive cardiac surgical patients.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

A series of clinically oriented variables were introduced into a statistical model for projection of the protamine dose after cardiopulmonary bypass. The following significant predictors were identified using multivariable regression analysis: The patient's body surface area, the administered dose of heparin, heparin clearance, and the preoperative platelet count. The statistical model projected the protamine dose within 3±23 mg of the point-of-care test used as reference.

CONCLUSION

Protamine dosing based on statistical modeling represents an alternative to point-of-care tests.

Protamine sulfate down-regulates thrombin generation by inhibiting factor V activation

Protamine sulfate is a positively charged polypeptide widely used to reverse heparin-induced anticoagulation. Paradoxically, prospective randomized trials have shown that protamine administration for heparin neutralization is associated with increased bleeding, particularly after cardiothoracic surgery with cardiopulmonary bypass. The molecular mechanism(s) through which protamine mediates this anticoagulant effect has not been defined. In vivo administration of pharmacologic doses of protamine to BALB/c mice significantly reduced plasma thrombin generation and prolonged tail-bleeding time (from 120 to 199 seconds). Similarly, in pooled normal human plasma, protamine caused significant dose-dependent prolongations of both prothrombin time and activated partial thromboplastin time. Protamine also markedly attenuated tissue factor-initiated thrombin generation in human plasma, causing a significant decrease in endogenous thrombin potential (41% +/- 7%). As expected, low-dose protamine effectively reversed the anticoagulant activity of unfractionated heparin in plasma. However, elevated protamine concentrations were associated with progressive dose-dependent reduction in thrombin generation. To assess the mechanism by which protamine mediates down-regulation of thrombin generation, the effect of protamine on factor V activation was assessed. Protamine was found to significantly reduce the rate of factor V activation by both thrombin and factor Xa. Protamine mediates its anticoagulant activity in plasma by down-regulation of thrombin generation via a novel mechanism, specifically inhibition of factor V activation.

Rapid disappearance of protamine in adults undergoing cardiac operation with cardiopulmonary bypass

BACKGROUND

Despite long use of protamine in cardiac operations, neither protamine concentrations nor pharmacokinetics have been reported in patients.

METHODS

Twenty-eight patients (age, 26 to 80 years) undergoing various cardiac surgical procedures gave their consent to receive 250 mg of protamine sulfate administered intravenously by an infusion pump during 5 minutes. Protamine was administered at the usual intraoperative time after separation from cardiopulmonary bypass for reversal of heparin. Timed arterial blood samples were obtained after protamine infusion. Blood plasma was subjected to solid-phase extraction and high-performance liquid chromatography. Total (free + heparin-bound) protamine concentration versus time data were subjected to pharmacokinetic modeling.

RESULTS

Twenty-six patients completed the study. Total plasma protamine concentrations declined rapidly. Model-independent pharmacokinetic analysis revealed median (range) values as follows: volume of distribution, 5.4 L (0.82 to 34 L); clearance, 1.4 L/min (0.61 to 3.8 L/min); and half-life, 4.5 min (1.9 to 18 min). Schwarz-Bayesian criterion identified a two-compartment exponential model with adjustment for weight in the central compartment volume of distribution as performing better than other compartmental or Michaelis-Menten models.

CONCLUSIONS

Protamine has a very short (approximately 5 minutes) half-life after a single 250-mg dose in adult patients. This short half-life could underlie recurrent anticoagulation after initial apparent reversal of heparin.

The pharmacokinetics and cardiovascular effects of a single intravenous dose of protamine in normal volunteers

Despite its long use in clinical medicine, protamine concentrations and pharmacokinetics in humans have not been reported. The occasional reoccurrence of anticoagulation after protamine reversal of heparin led us to hypothesize that protamine plasma concentrations decrease rapidly. We developed a method for the measurement of protamine in plasma. Eighteen fit volunteers gave their consent to receive 0.5 mg/kg protamine sulfate administered IV by an infusion pump over 10 min. Heart rate, mean arterial blood pressure, and cardiac output, all measured noninvasively, were recorded and blood samples obtained during and after protamine infusion. Blood plasma was subjected to solid-phase extraction and high-performance liquid chromatography. The administration of protamine was associated with no significant changes in heart rate, mean arterial blood pressure, or cardiac output. Plasma protamine concentrations decreased rapidly, becoming nondetectable within approximately 20 min. Protamine elimination differed significantly between men and women: men had significantly larger areas under the concentration versus time curve. Model-independent pharmacokinetic analysis revealed median (range) values as follows: volume of distribution at steady state, 12.3 (6.9--63.1) L; clearance, 2.2 (1.1--12.1) L/min; and t1/2, 7.4 (5.9--9.3) min. Concentration versus time plots revealed an atypical pattern inconsistent with usual exponential models. The Schwartz-Bayesian criterion identified a one-compartment Michaelis-Menten model and a two-compartment exponential model with irreversible binding as performing better than conventional one- or two-compartmental exponential models; however, performance errors were large with both Michaelis-Menten and exponential models. All models described rapid decreases in protamine blood concentrations.

IMPLICATIONS

We developed a method for measurement of protamine in human blood. In volunteers, protamine concentrations decreased rapidly after administration. The rapid disappearance of protamine from the circulation, as defined by a median half-life of 7.4 min, could contribute to cases of "heparin rebound" after initial adequate reversal of heparin.

The effects of heparin, protamine, and heparin/protamine reversal on platelet function under conditions of arterial shear stress

Platelet dysfunction contributes to blood loss after cardiopulmonary bypass. This study examined the antiplatelet effects of heparin, protamine, and varying heparin/protamine ratios in an in vitro physiologic model and further elucidated the mechanism of the antiplatelet and anticoagulant effects of protamine. We used the Clot Signature Analyzer (CSA(TM)), a system that analyzes coagulation in flowing whole blood, to test two aspects of platelet function, with different concentrations of heparin and protamine, under conditions simulating arterial flow: collagen-induced thrombus formation (CITF) under moderate shear and high shear platelet activation, platelet hemostasis time (PHT). In addition, platelet aggregometry, celite activated clotting time (Hepcon(TM) ACT), prothrombin time (PT), and partial thromboplastin time (PTT) were measured. Both PHT and the CITF were prolonged by heparin at 20 microg/mL, protamine at 20 and 40 microg/mL, and heparin/protamine ratios of 1:1 and 1:2, but not at 1:1.5. The Hepcon ACT was prolonged by heparin 20 microg/mL and protamine alone at 20 and 40 microg/mL, was normal at a ratio of 1:1, and was prolonged at 1:1.5 and 1:2. Protamine 80 microg/mL prolonged the PT and PTT. Dependency on thrombin, protein kinase C activation, and nonspecific charge effects were examined. The direct thrombin inhibitor D-phenylalanyl-L-prolyl-L-arginyl-chloromethyl ketone prolonged the PHT and ACT, but not the CITF, whereas the polycationic molecules polyarginine and polylysine prolonged the CITF, but not the PHT. The effect of protamine on the PTT, but not PT, could be shortened by the addition of excess phospholipid. Therefore, heparin inhibits both high shear collagen-independent and moderate shear collagen-dependent platelet activation; however, the latter is not mediated by its antithrombin activity. Protamine's antithrombin effect may explain its inhibition of platelet activation at high shear stress. Protamine's nonspecific charge effects are more important for inhibiting moderate shear collagen-induced platelet activation.

IMPLICATIONS

This study suggests that protamine reversal of heparin's antiplatelet effect occurs within a narrow window because of the direct antiplatelet effects of protamine. Antithrombin effects may explain the inhibition of shear activation of platelets by both heparin and protamine. Nonspecific charge effects of protamine may explain the inhibition of collagen platelet activation in the presence of medium shear.