The value of the bone scan and bone marrow biopsy staging small cell lung cancer

Bone Marrow Biopsy in the Staging of Small Cell Lung Cancer

From April 1982 to December 1987, 71 patients with small cell lung cancer entered a randomized clinical trial, and underwent bone marrow biopsy (BMB) as part of staging procedures. We identified 8 patients (11 %) with bone marrow metastases, 6 with extensive disease independently of BMB, and 2 with extensive disease on the basis of the BMB only. BMB determined a change in the stage in only 3 % (2/71) of the cases. No differences were found in the hematological parameters of the patients with or without bone marrow metastases. The median survival of the patients with bone marrow involvement was the same (41 weeks) as those with extensive disease but without bone marrow involvement. We conclude that unilateral BMB without aspiration detects a substantial proportion of bone marrow metastases in patients with extensive disease. This fact does not worsen the prognosis. A small proportion of patients with apparently limited disease has bone marrow involvement. The technique therefore contributes, to a small extent, to the definition of the clinical stage of the disease. However, bone marrow involvement is an important data of natural history, and therefore new methods to better assess this peculiar site of the disease are needed.

Reevaluation of the Usefulness of Systematic Bone Scanning in Initial Staging and follow-up of Small Cell Lung Carcinoma, Taking into Account the Serum Levels of Neuron-Specific Enolase

The prescription of bone scans (BS) in the initial staging and follow-up of small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) is a traditional attitude. The availability of the serum neuron-specific enolase (NSE) assay and budget limitations led us to evaluate retrospectively, in 57 patients, the consequences of a more selective attitude, namely to perform BS only in those patients with abnormal serum NSE levels. Both BS and NSE assays were performed in 47 patients referred for initial staging of SCLC; NSE levels were normal in 8 but in 2 of these cases (25%) secondary bone localizations with great clinical significance were discovered at BS. During follow-up, 59 BS were performed in conjunction with NSE assays; 45 NSE levels were in the normal range whereas 17 (38%) corresponding BS were suggestive of bone metastases. In conclusion, due to the frequent occurrence of false-negative results in patients with bone metastases, serum NSE levels proved to be useless in the selection for BS of patients suffering from SCLC.

Small cell lung carcinoma: staging, imaging, and treatment considerations

Small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) is the most common primary pulmonary neuroendocrine malignancy and is characterized by a rapid doubling time and high growth fraction. Approximately 60%-70% of patients present with metastatic disease at the time of diagnosis, and their prognosis is poor. However, improved survival has been demonstrated when SCLC is diagnosed early and specific treatment strategies are used. A modified version of the Veterans Administration Lung Cancer Study Group (VALSG) staging system has traditionally been used to categorize SCLC as limited-stage or extensive-stage disease to guide therapy. However, the International Association for the Study of Lung Cancer has recommended that the current seventh edition of the American Joint Committee on Cancer tumor-node-metastasis staging system for lung cancer replace the VALSG system for staging of SCLC. Appropriate staging and patient management require knowledge of imaging manifestations of SCLC across multiple imaging modalities, the strengths and weaknesses of specific examinations, the correlation of these findings with the staging criteria used in clinical practice, and the impact of appropriate staging on patient treatment and survival. Computed tomography (CT) is primarily used to evaluate the primary tumor and the extent of intrathoracic disease. In recent years, however, 2-[fluorine-18]fluoro-2-deoxy-d-glucose positron emission tomography/CT has proved to be more accurate than conventional imaging in the staging of SCLC and can be used to guide therapy and assess treatment response.

Treatment of small cell lung cancer: Diagnosis and management of lung cancer, 3rd ed: American College of Chest Physicians evidence-based clinical practice guidelines

BACKGROUND

Small cell lung cancer (SCLC) is a lethal disease for which there have been only small advances in diagnosis and treatment in the past decade. Our goal was to revise the evidence-based guidelines on staging and best available treatment options.

METHODS

A comprehensive literature search covering 2004 to 2011 was conducted in MEDLINE, Embase, and five Cochrane databases using SCLC terms. This was cross-checked with the authors' own literature searches and knowledge of the literature. Results were limited to research in humans and articles written in English.

RESULTS

The staging classification should include both the old Veterans Administration staging classification of limited stage (LS) and extensive stage (ES), as well as the new seventh edition American Joint Committee on Cancer/International Union Against Cancer staging by TNM. The use of PET scanning is likely to improve the accuracy of staging. Surgery is indicated for carefully selected stage I SCLC. LS disease should be treated with concurrent chemoradiotherapy in patients with good performance status. Thoracic radiotherapy should be administered early in the course of treatment, preferably beginning with cycle 1 or 2 of chemotherapy. Chemotherapy should consist of four cycles of a platinum agent and etoposide. ES disease should be treated primarily with chemotherapy consisting of a platinum agent plus etoposide or irinotecan. Prophylactic cranial irradiation prolongs survival in those individuals with both LS and ES disease who achieve a complete or partial response to initial therapy. To date, no molecularly targeted therapy agent has demonstrated proven efficacy against SCLC.

CONCLUSION

Evidence-based guidelines are provided for the staging and treatment of SCLC. LS-SCLC is treated with curative intent with 20% to 25% 5-year survival. ES-SCLC is initially responsive to standard treatment, but almost always relapses, with virtually no patients surviving for 5 years. Targeted therapies have no proven efficacy against SCLC.

Comparison of diagnostic ability between (99m)Tc-MDP bone scan and (18)F-FDG PET/CT for bone metastasis in patients with small cell lung cancer

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to compare the diagnostic ability of (18)F-fluorodeoxyglucose ((18)F-FDG) positron emission tomography/computed tomography (PET/CT) with that of (99m)Tc-methylene diphosphonate ((99m)Tc-MDP) bone scan for bone metastasis in staging patients with small cell lung cancer (SCLC).

METHODS

Ninety-five patients with SCLC who underwent both (18)F-FDG PET/CT and (99m)Tc-MDP bone scan for initial staging work-up were retrospectively enrolled. All (18)F-FDG PET/CT and bone scan images were visually assessed. Bone metastasis was confirmed by histopathological results and all available clinical information.

RESULTS

Of 95 patients with SCLC, metastatic bone lesions were found in 30 patients, and 84 metastatic lesions were evaluated on a lesion-basis analysis. The sensitivity of (18)F-FDG PET/CT was 100 % on a per-patient basis and 87 % on a per-lesion basis, and there was no false-positive lesion on PET/CT images. In contrast, the sensitivity of the bone scan was 37 % on a per-patient basis and 29 % on a per-lesion basis. The bone scan showed 11 false-positive lesions. The bone scan detected two metastatic lesions that were not detected by PET/CT, which were outside the region scanned by PET/CT. On follow-up bone scan, 21 lesions that were not detected by the initial bone scan but were detected by PET/CT were newly detected.

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with SCLC, (18)F-FDG PET/CT showed higher detection rate of bone metastasis than (99m)Tc-MDP bone scan. Thus, (18)F-FDG PET/CT can replace bone scan in staging patients with SCLC.

Staging and imaging of small cell lung cancer

Small cell lung cancer (SCLC) has been primarily classified as limited or extensive, with limited stage confined to the primary tumor and regional lymph nodes. In the future, the TNM staging system should be integrated into the classification of SCLC. The appropriate staging work-up for patients with SCLC has traditionally included contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CT) scans of the chest and abdomen, bone scan, and magnetic resonance imaging or CT scan of the brain. Recent data suggest that positron emission tomography can improve both staging accuracy and treatment planning in patients with SCLC. Treatment for limited-stage SCLC consists of chemotherapy plus radiotherapy, and such therapy can cure 20-25% of patients. Extensive-stage SCLC is incurable, but chemotherapy can improve quality of life and prolong life.

Recent advances in bone marrow scanning

Interest in bone marrow scanning has been renewed as the result of the development of radiopharmaceuticals for evaluating specific aspects of bone marrow anatomy, physiology and pathology. This article provides a brief review of bone marrow structure, blood flow and function essential to the understanding of basic principles of bone marrow radionuclide imaging. The prospects and limitations of imaging haematopoietic bone marrow in man using indium 111 chloride, technetium-99m (99mTc)-labelled microcolloid or 99mTc-labelled monoclonal antigranulocytic and antimyelocytic antibodies are discussed in more detail. The technical aspects of bone marrow scintigraphy are presented. Results of more recent studies evaluating bone marrow scanning in circulatory, inflammatory and in systemic haematological disorders are summarized. Special attention is paid to the concept of bone marrow micrometastases and its implications for the follow-up of patients with malignant tumours. Recent results suggest that immunoscintigraphy of bone marrow may provide a novel and sensitive approach for establishing the presence and extent of bone marrow infiltration.

Bone marrow examination in small cell lung cancer--when is it indicated?

To assess the usefulness of bone marrow (BM) examination performed as part of the staging procedure in SCLC, 137 patients with this neoplasm were studied. At diagnosis, BM was infiltrated in 23 patients (17%) and in 5 of them (22%) it was the only metastatic site. BM examination changed the previously given stage in 9% of the patients who were supposed to have limited disease before this test was performed. BM involvement correlated with a higher frequency of bone (p less than 0.05) and liver (p less than 0.01) metastasis. Correlations were found neither with blood or serum biochemistry disturbances nor with postchemotherapy haematologic toxicity. The BM positive patients had a survival rate similar to those with extensive disease but without BM infiltration. We conclude that BM examination should be performed only when no other metastatic sites have been found after a complete staging study.

The value of bone marrow biopsy in breast cancer at the time of first relapse. A prospective study

The value of bone marrow biopsy (BMB) in advanced breast cancer at the time of first relapse was studied in a prospective manner. Bone marrow biopsy was performed in 142 consecutive unselected metastatic patients: 129 at the time of first recurrence, and 13 in patients with metastases at the time of first diagnosis. Overall, BMB was positive in 32 patients (23%). In the group with negative bone x-ray, it was positive in two patients of 84 (2%); both of them had doubtful scan. In the group with positive x-ray, BMB resulted positive in 30 of 58 (52%). There was a significant correlation between number of bone segments radiologically involved and BMB positivity rate, ranging from 15% in the patients with only one, to 68% in those with more than three sites involved (P = 0.02). Patients with x-ray evidence of metastases in the pelvis had significantly higher rate of BMB positivity (67% versus 32%; P = 0.02). The median survival time from the first relapse was 153 weeks in BMB-negative cases and 149 in positive ones. Considering only the patients with demonstration of bone invasion obtained with either or both x-ray and BMB, 34/62 patients had positive BMB (55%). In these cases BMB was found more often positive in patients 50 years or younger than in patients older than 50 years (80% versus 47%; P = 0.05); the median survival time was longer, but not significantly, in BMB-positive patients than in negative ones (149 weeks versus 119; P = 0.3). The authors conclude that BMB is not required in common restaging procedure when both bone survey and scan are negative. Bone marrow biopsy results are more often positive in younger patients and survival is not negatively affected by bone marrow invasion as diagnosed by BMB.

The value of bone marrow biopsy in breast cancer at time of diagnosis. A prospective study

Bone marrow biopsies (BMB) were performed in 173 consecutive unselected breast cancer patients at the time of diagnosis to define the value of this diagnostic tool in the initial staging of mammary carcinoma. In a group of 160 patients with a negative standard staging work-up, BMB was positive in two (1%). Both of them had negative x-ray but bone scan was positive in one and doubtful in the other. Bone marrow biopsy was positive in 31% of 13 additional patients with metastatic disease and in 44% of the nine among them with radiologically involved skeleton. These results exclude that BMB is able to discover micrometastatic foci of neoplastic disease. Its positivity appears strictly correlated with that of bone x-ray and scan. Based on the results of this prospective study, BMB is not required when both bone survey and scan are negative, but could be useful in clarifying diagnostic doubts of skeletal involvement.

Bone marrow evaluation in small cell carcinoma of the lung

Bone marrow examination is commonly included in the staging of small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC). We reviewed marrow samples of 103 patients. Marrow examination was mainly performed by unilateral or bilateral biopsy of iliac crests, using a Jamshidi needle. Only 6 of 97 evaluable cases (6.2 per cent) were positive for marrow metastases at staging, and in 3 cases (3 per cent) bone marrow was the only metastatic site. No focal metastases were found in additional sections made from the blocks of negative samples. In our experience bone marrow biopsy was of little value in staging SCLC. Bilateral biopsy plus aspirate, with the addition of more sophisticated staining techniques might, however, provide a higher yield of positive marrow involvement.