Ca2+ binding in proteins of the calmodulin superfamily: cooperativity, electrostatic contributions and molecular mechanisms

The mechanism of complex formation between calmodulin and voltage gated calcium channels revealed by molecular dynamics

Calmodulin, a ubiquitous eukaryotic calcium sensor responsible for the regulation of many fundamental cellular processes, is a highly flexible protein and exhibits an unusually wide range of conformations. Furthermore, CaM is known to interact with more than 300 cellular targets. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation trajectories suggest that EF-hand loops show different magnitudes of flexibility. Therefore, the four EF-hand motifs have different affinities for Ca2+ ions, which enables CaM to function on wide range of Ca2+ ion concentrations. EF-hand loops are 2-3 times more flexible in apo CaM whereas least flexible in Ca2+/CaM-IQ motif complexes. We report a unique intermediate conformation of Ca2+/CaM while transitioning from extended to compact form. We also report the complex formation process between Ca2+/CaM and IQ CaM-binding motifs. Our results showed how IQ motif recognise its binding site on the CaM and how CaM transforms from extended to compact form upon binding to IQ motif.

Structural dynamics of calmodulin-ryanodine receptor interactions: electron paramagnetic resonance using stereospecific spin labels

We have used electron paramagnetic resonance, with rigid and stereospecific spin labels, to resolve structural states in calmodulin (CaM), as affected by binding of Ca and a CaM-binding peptide (RyRp) derived from the ryanodine receptor (RyR), the Ca channel that triggers muscle contraction. CaM mutants containing a pair of cysteines in the N-lobe and/or C-lobe were engineered and labeled with a stereospecifically bound bifunctional spin label (BSL). RyRp was synthesized with and without TOAC (a stereospecifically attached spin-labeled amino acid) substituted for a single amino acid near the N-terminus. Intramolecular DEER distance measurements of doubly-labeled BSL-CaM revealed that CaM exists in dynamic equilibrium among multiple states, consistent with open, closed, and compact structural models. Addition of RyRp shifted the equilibrium partially toward the compact state in the absence of Ca, and completely toward the compact state in the presence of Ca, supporting a conformational selection model. Inter-protein distance measurements show that Ca stabilizes the compact state primarily by inducing ordered binding of the CaM N-lobe to RyRp, while only slightly affecting the C-lobe. The results provide insight into the structural mechanism of CaM-mediated RyR regulation, while demonstrating the power of using two types of rigidly and stereospecifically bound spin labels.

Defining potential roles of Pb(2+) in neurotoxicity from a calciomics approach

Metal ions play crucial roles in numerous biological processes, facilitating biochemical reactions by binding to various proteins. An increasing body of evidence suggests that neurotoxicity associated with exposure to nonessential metals (e.g., Pb(2+)) involves disruption of synaptic activity, and these observed effects are associated with the ability of Pb(2+) to interfere with Zn(2+) and Ca(2+)-dependent functions. However, the molecular mechanism behind Pb(2+) toxicity remains a topic of debate. In this review, we first discuss potential neuronal Ca(2+) binding protein (CaBP) targets for Pb(2+) such as calmodulin (CaM), synaptotagmin, neuronal calcium sensor-1 (NCS-1), N-methyl-d-aspartate receptor (NMDAR) and family C of G-protein coupled receptors (cGPCRs), and their involvement in Ca(2+)-signalling pathways. We then compare metal binding properties between Ca(2+) and Pb(2+) to understand the structural implications of Pb(2+) binding to CaBPs. Statistical and biophysical studies (e.g., NMR and fluorescence spectroscopy) of Pb(2+) binding are discussed to investigate the molecular mechanism behind Pb(2+) toxicity. These studies identify an opportunistic, allosteric binding of Pb(2+) to CaM, which is distinct from ionic displacement. Together, these data suggest three potential modes of Pb(2+) activity related to molecular and/or neural toxicity: (i) Pb(2+) can occupy Ca(2+)-binding sites, inhibiting the activity of the protein by structural modulation, (ii) Pb(2+) can mimic Ca(2+) in the binding sites, falsely activating the protein and perturbing downstream activities, or (iii) Pb(2+) can bind outside of the Ca(2+)-binding sites, resulting in the allosteric modulation of the protein activity. Moreover, the data further suggest that even low concentrations of Pb(2+) can interfere at multiple points within the neuronal Ca(2+) signalling pathways to cause neurotoxicity.

Metal toxicity and opportunistic binding of Pb(2+) in proteins

Lead toxicity is associated with various human diseases. While Ca(2+) binding proteins such as calmodulin (CaM) are often reported to be molecular targets for Pb(2+)-binding and lead toxicity, the effect of Pb(2+) on the Ca(2+)/CaM regulated biological activities cannot be described by the primary mechanism of ionic displacement (e.g., ionic mimicry). The focus of this study was to investigate the mechanism of lead toxicity through binding differences between Ca(2+) and Pb(2+) for CaM, an essential intracellular trigger protein with two EF-Hand Ca(2+)-binding sites in each of its two domains that regulates many molecular targets via Ca(2+)-induced conformational change. Fluorescence changes in phenylalanine indicated that Pb(2+) binds with 8-fold higher affinity than Ca(2+) in the N-terminal domain. Additionally, NMR chemical shift changes and an unusual biphasic response observed in tyrosine fluorescence associated with C-terminal domain sites EF-III and EF-IV suggest a single higher affinity Pb(2+)-binding site with a 3-fold higher affinity than Ca(2+), coupled with a second site exhibiting affinity nearly equivalent to that of the N-terminal domain sites. Our results further indicate that Pb(2+) displaces Ca(2+) only in the N-terminal domain, with minimal perturbation of the C-terminal domain, however significant structural/dynamic changes are observed in the trans-domain linker region which appear to be due to Pb(2+)-binding outside of the known calcium-binding sites. These data suggest that opportunistic Pb(2+)-binding in Ca(2+)/CaM has a profound impact on the conformation and dynamics of the essential molecular recognition sites of the central helix, and provides insight into the molecular toxicity of non-essential metal ions.

EF-hand protein dynamics and evolution of calcium signal transduction: an NMR view

Calcium signaling, one of the most widespread signaling mechanisms in cells, is generally carried out by EF-hand proteins, characterized by a helix-loop-helix motif paired in functional domains. EF-hand proteins may be viewed as molecular switches activated by calcium concentration transients. The EF-hand structural database has grown to a point where meaningful inferences on the functional conformational rearrangements upon calcium binding can be made by comparing a fair number of pairs of end points, i.e., the structures of the apo and calcium-bound forms. More compact descriptors of the movement associated with calcium binding, in terms of principal component analysis of the six interhelical angles, have also become available. Dynamic information obtained by NMR, also with the aid of calcium substitution with paramagnetic lanthanides, is shedding light on the intrinsic amplitude of the conformational degrees of freedom sampled by the various members of the EF-hand superfamily, as well as on the time scales of the motions. Particularly, NMR of lanthanide derivatives helps in capturing long time scale motions. Both static and dynamic pictures reveal a large variety of behaviors. It is increasingly recognized that the EF-hand machinery has differentiated its behavior during evolution in several ways, e.g., by modifying one of the loops, by undergoing a further duplication after the initial motif duplication that originated the functional domain, or by acquiring the ability to dimerize.

Dynamics of Ca2+-saturated calmodulin D129N mutant studied by multiple molecular dynamics simulations

Fifteen independent 1-nsec MD simulations of fully solvated Ca(2+) saturated calmodulin (CaM) mutant D129N were performed from different initial conditions to provide a sufficient statistical basis to gauge the significance of observed dynamical properties. In all MD simulations the four Ca(2+) ions remained in their binding sites, and retained a single water ligand as observed in the crystal structure. The coordination of Ca(2+) ions in EF-hands I, II, and III was sevenfold. In EF-hand IV, which was perturbed by the mutation of a highly conserved Asp129, an anomalous eightfold Ca(2+) coordination was observed. The Ca(2+) binding loop in EF-hand II was observed to dynamically sample conformations related to the Ca(2+)-free form. Repeated MD simulations implicate two well-defined conformations of Ca(2+) binding loop II, whereas similar effect was not observed for loops I, III, and IV. In 8 out of 15 MD simulations Ca(2+) binding loop II adopted an alternative conformation in which the Thr62 >C=O group was displaced from the Ca(2+) coordination by a water molecule, resulting in the Ca(2+) ion ligated by two water molecules. The alternative conformation of the Ca(2+) binding loop II appears related to the "closed" state involved in conformational exchange previously detected by NMR in the N-terminal domain fragment of CaM and the C-terminal domain fragment of the mutant E140Q. MD simulations suggest that conformations involved in microsecond exchange exist partially preformed on the nanosecond time scale.