Toxicological implications of polymorphic drug metabolism

Implications for future studies in humans

While an environmental link with cancer is widely accepted, its implications are not always understood. Because of the multistage nature of carcinogenesis, it is insufficient to study initiation only at the level of the 'target cell', since events before and after initiation may prove pivotal to neoplastic development. Estimates of the relative contributions of factors causing human cancer are briefly summarized. Tumours related to patterns of life style--including diet and behaviour--and individual susceptibility are discussed. It is in this group of tumours that metabolizing enzymes are probably most significant, especially for weak initiating stimuli, whether extrinsic or intrinsic. There are few epidemiological data available at present but future research can be suggested, to improve the definition in biochemical terms of individual susceptibility and effects of life style.

Cytochrome P450: what have we learned and what are the future issues?

The cytochrome P450 (P450) field came out of interest in the metabolism of drugs, carcinogens, and steroids, which remain major focal points. Over the years we have come to understand the P450 system components, the multiplicity of P450s, and many aspects of the regulation of the genes and also the catalytic mechanism. Many crystal structures are now becoming available. The significance of P450 in in vivo metabolism is appreciated, particularly in the context of pharmacogenetics. Current scientific issues involve posttranslational modification, gene regulation, component interactions, structures of P450 complexed with ligands, details of high-valent oxygen chemistry, the nature and influence of rate-limiting steps, greater details about some reaction steps, cooperativity, and the relevance of P450 variations to cancer risk. Some emerging research areas involve new methods of analysis of ligand interactions, roles of conformational changes linked to individual reaction steps, functions of orphan P450s, "molecular breeding" of new P450 functions and enhanced activity, and the utilization of P450s in chemical synthesis.

Genetically determined variability in acetylation and oxidation. Therapeutic implications

The clinical significance of two separate genetic polymorphisms which alter drug metabolism, acetylation and oxidation is discussed, and methods of phenotyping for both acetylator and polymorphic oxidation status are reviewed. Particular reference is made to the dapsone method, which provides a simple means of distinguishing fast and slow - and possibly intermediate - acetylators, and to the sparteine method which allows a clear separation of oxidation phenotypes. Although acetylation polymorphism has been known for some time, definite indications for phenotyping are few. It is doubtful whether acetylator phenotype makes a significant difference to the outcome in most isoniazid treatment regimens, and peripheral neuropathy from isoniazid in slow acetylators is easily overcome by pyridoxine administration. However, in comparison with rapid acetylators, slow acetylators receiving isoniazid have an increased susceptibility to phenytoin toxicity, and perhaps also to carbamazepine toxicity. It is also possible that rapid acetylators receiving isoniazid attain higher serum fluoride concentrations from enflurane and similar anaesthetics than do similarly treated slow acetylators. Thus, when drug interactions of these types are suspected, phenotyping for acetylator status may be advisable. If routine monitoring of serum procainamide and N-acetylprocainamide concentrations is practised, phenotyping of subjects prior to therapy with these agents should not be necessary. Although acetylator phenotype influences serum concentrations of hydralazine, when this drug is given in combination with other drugs acetylator phenotype has not been shown to influence the therapeutic response. Slow acetylator phenotype along with female gender and the presence of HLA-DR antigens appear to be risk factors in the development of hydralazine-induced systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Determination of acetylator phenotype may therefore help determine susceptibility to this adverse reaction. In the case of sulphasalazine, adult slow acetylators require a lower daily dose of the drug than fast acetylators in order to maintain ulcerative colitis in remission without significant side effects. It is therefore advisable to determine acetylator phenotype prior to sulphasalazine therapy. Work on the association of acetylation polymorphism with various disease states is also reviewed. It is possible that a higher incidence of bladder cancer is associated with slow acetylation phenotype - especially in individuals exposed to high levels of arylamines. The question as to whether idiopathic SLE is more common in slow acetylators remains unresolved. There appears to be no difference between fa

Genetically determined oxidation capacity and the disposition of debrisoquine

1 The disposition in urine of debrisoquine and its hydroxylated metabolites has been studied in subjects of the 'extensive metabolizer' (EM; n = 5) and 'poor metabolizer' (PM; n = 5) phenotypes. The 4-hydroxylation of debrisoquine by PM subjects following a 10 mg oral dose was capacity-limited and displayed significant dose-dependency over a range of 1-20 mg. In contrast, the EM subjects' ability to perform this metabolic oxidation did not deviate from first-order kinetics over a dose range of 10-40 mg. 2 The disposition of debrisoquine in plasma following a 10 mg oral dose has been studied in EM (n = 4) and PM (n = 3) subjects. Whilst PM subjects displayed significantly higher plasma levels of debrisoquine at all time points following 1 h post-dosing, and higher values for areas under the plasma concentration-time curve (EM: 105.6 +/- 7.0 ng ml-1 h; PM: 371.4 +/- 22.4 ng ml-1 h, 2P less than 0.0001), neither debrisoquine plasma half-life (EM: 3.0 +/- 0.5 h; PM: 3.3 +/- 0.4 h) nor renal clearance of the drug (EM: 152.8 +/- 30.3 ml min-1; PM: 137 +/- 4.5 ml min-1) displayed significant inter-phenotype differences. 3 The results of these investigations show that the phenotyping of individuals for debrisoquine oxidation status by means of a 'metabolic ratio' derived from a single 0-8 h urine sample has a sound kinetic basis. The kinetic differences between the two phenotypes would strongly suggest that the metabolic defect manifested in PM subjects is one of pre-systemic elimination capacity.

Antipyrine metabolism in relation to polymorphic oxidations of sparteine and debrisoquine

Thirty-five healthy subjects who had been classified as extensive or poor metabolizers of both sparteine and debrisoquine were given a single oral dose of antipyrine. Saliva concentration of antipyrine and urinary excretion of its three major oxidation metabolites were measured. All the parameters of antipyrine metabolism which were estimated had similar distributions in both the 28 EM and 7 PM genetic phenotypes defined by the metabolism of sparteine and debrisoquine. The clearance of antipyrine by the formation of 4-hydroxy-antipyrine and 3-hydroxy-antipyrine respectively were closely correlated (r = 0.83, P less than 0.001) and both were significantly higher in smokers than in non-smokers. Demethylation of antipyrine also seemed to be influenced by smoking, but not to a statistically significant extent. These findings confirm the influence of the environmental factor of smoking in antipyrine oxidative biotransformations.

Impaired oxidation of debrisoquine in patients with perhexiline neuropathy

The use of perhexiline maleate as an antianginal agent is occasionally associated with side effects, particularly neuropathy and liver damage. The reason why some individuals develop these toxic reactions is not clear, though some evidence suggests that they may result from impaired oxidative metabolism, due to genetic or hepatic factors, and consequential accumulation of the drug in toxic concentrations. Drug oxidation was measured with an oxidation phenotyping procedure in 34 patients treated with perhexiline, 20 of whom had developed neuropathy and 14 of whom had not. Most of the 20 patients with neuropathy, but not the unaffected patients, showed an impaired ability to effect metabolic drug oxidation. This impairment was independent of hepatic function, concurrent drug therapy, or tobacco or alcohol consumption. The fact that the ability to oxidise several drugs is genetically controlled points to a genetic susceptibility to developing neuropathy in response to perhexiline. Routine determination of the drug oxidation phenotype might lead to safer use of perhexiline by predicting patients who may be more at risk of developing a neuropathic reaction associated with its long-term use.