Feasibility of virtual starshot analysis providing submillimeter radiation isocenter accuracy: A long-term multi-institutional analysis

Characterization of mechanical and radiation isocenter on an MR-guided radiotherapy (MRgRT) Linac

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

In the emerging paradigm of stereotactic radiosurgery being proposed for MR-guided radiotherapy (MRgRT), assessment of mechanical geometric accuracy is critical for the implementation of stereotactic delivery. We benchmarked the mechanical accuracy of an MR Linac system that lacks an onboard detector/array. Our mechanical tests utilize a half beam block (HBB) geometry that takes advantage of the sensitivity of a partially occluded detector.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Mechanical tests benchmarked the couch, MLC, and gantry geometric accuracy for an MR-Linac system. An HBB technique was used to irradiate an ionization chamber profiler (ICP) array with partial occlusion of individual detectors for characterization of MLC skew, beam divergence displacement, and RT isocenter localization. The sensitivity of the partially occluded detector's ICP-X (detector width) and ICP-Y (detector length) was characterized by displacing the detector relative to radiation isocenter by 0.2 mm increments, introduced through couch motion. The accuracy of the HBB ICP technique was verified with a starshot using radiochromic film, and the reproducibility was verified on a conventional C-arm Linac and compared to Winston-Lutz.

RESULTS

The sensitivity of the HBB technique as quantified through the dose difference normalized to open field as a function of displacement from RT isocenter was 6.4%/mm and 13.0%/mm for the ICP-X and ICP-Y orientation, respectively, due to the oblong detector orientation. Couch positional accuracy and sag was within ±0.1 mm. Maximum MLC positional displacement was 0.7 mm with mean MLC skew at 0.07°. The maximum beam divergence displacement was 0.03 mm. The gantry angle was within 0.1°. Independent verification of the RT isocenter localization procedure produced repeatable results.

CONCLUSION

This work serves for characterizing the mechanical and geometric radiation accuracy for the foundation of an MR-guided stereotactic radiosurgery program, as demonstrated with high sensitivity and independent validation.

Development and multi-institutional evaluation of a new phantom for verifying beam-positioning errors at off-isocenter positions

PURPOSE

Single-isocenter stereotactic radiotherapy for multiple brain metastases requires highly accurate treatment delivery at off-isocenter positions (off-iso). This study aimed to verify the beam-positioning errors at off-iso using a newly developed phantom tested at multiple institutions.

METHODS

The off-iso phantom comprised five stainless-steel balls with a 3-mm diameter placed at the center and at four peripheral positions on a diagonal line. Each ball was placed 3.5 cm apart along each of the three axes. Two patterns of the phantom setup were defined as 0° and 90° phantom rotations to evaluate the beam-positioning error, which is the distance between the center of the ball and the irradiated field on the electronic portal imaging device. Furthermore, the reproducibility of the beam-positioning errors was verified by evaluating their standard deviation (SD) at a single institution, which included five measurements for two treatment machines. The errors were evaluated at multiple institutions using eight treatment machines.

RESULTS

The measurement time from setup to image acquisition was approximately 20 min for two patterns. The SD of the beam-positioning errors in the reproducibility tests was 0.41 mm. In the multi-institutional evaluation, the beam-positioning error at the isocenter position was within 1.00 mm of the AAPM-RSS tolerance, with the exception of two linacs. The largest beam-positioning error (1.36 mm) was observed 7.5 cm away from the isocenter in three directions at a gantry angle of 180°.

CONCLUSIONS

The developed phantom can be applied as a new tool for establishing beam-positioning errors in single-isocenter stereotactic radiotherapy at off-isocenter positions.