Theoretical Analysis of the Detailed Mechanism of Native Chemical Ligation Reactions

Förster Resonance Energy Transfer Assay for Investigating the Reactivity of Thioesters in Biochemistry and Native Chemical Ligation

Thioesters are considered to be "energy-rich" functional groups that are susceptible to attack by thiolate and amine nucleophiles while remaining hydrolytically stable at neutral pH, which enables thioester chemistry to take place in an aqueous medium. Thus, the inherent reactivity of thioesters enables their fundamental roles in biology and unique applications in chemical synthesis. Here, we investigate the reactivity of thioesters that mimic acyl-coenzyme A (CoA) species and S-acylcysteine modifications as well as aryl thioesters applied in chemical protein synthesis by native chemical ligation (NCL). We developed a fluorogenic assay format for the direct and continuous investigation of the rate of reaction between thioesters and nucleophiles (hydroxide, thiolate, and amines) under various conditions and were able to recapitulate previously reported reactivity of thioesters. Further, chromatography-based analyses of acetyl- and succinyl-CoA mimics revealed striking differences in their ability to acylate lysine side chains, providing insight into nonenzymatic protein acylation. Finally, we investigated key aspects of native chemical ligation reaction conditions. Our data revealed a profound effect of the tris-(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine (TCEP) commonly used in systems where thiol-thioester exchange occurs, including a potentially harmful hydrolysis side reaction. These data provide insight into the potential optimization of native chemical ligation chemistry.

Design and Evaluation of Ambiphilic Aryl Thiol-Iminium-Based Molecules for Organocatalyzed Thioacyl Aminolysis

Progress toward the design and synthesis of ambiphilic aryl thiol-iminium-based small molecules for organocatalyzed thioacyl aminolysis is reported. Here we describe the synthesis of a novel tetrahydroisoquinoline-derived scaffold, bearing both thiol and iminium functionalities, capable of promoting the transthioesterification and subsequent amine capture reactions necessary to achieve organocatalyzed thioacyl aminolysis. Model studies demonstrate the ability of this designed organocatalyst to deliver critical intermediates capable of undergoing these individual reactions necessary for the proposed process. Future design improvements and directions toward cysteine-independent organocatalyzed native chemical ligation are discussed.

Thioester deprotection using a biomimetic NCL approach

The reversibility of the thiol-thioester linkage has been broadly employed in many fields of biochemistry (lipid synthesis) and chemistry (dynamic combinatorial chemistry and material science). When the transthioesterification is followed by a S-to-N acyl transfer to give an amide bond, it is called Native Chemical Ligation (NCL), a high-yield chemoselective process used for peptide synthesis. Recently, we described thioglycolic acid (TGA) as a useful reagent for thioester deprotection both in solution and anchored to a solid-support under mild conditions. Inspired by NCL, in this work, we extended this approach and explored the use of 2-aminothiols for the deprotection of thiols bearing an acyl group. The best results were obtained using cysteamine or L-cysteine in an aqueous buffer pH 8 at room temperature for 30 min. The described approach was useful for S-acetyl, S-butyryl, and S-benzoyl heterocycles deprotection with yields up to 84%. Employing this methodology, we prepared six new analogs 2 of mercaptomethyl bisthiazolidine 1, a useful inhibitor of a wide-range of Metallo-β-Lactamases (MBLs). Compared with the previous methodologies (TGA polymer supported and TGA in solution), the biomimetic deprotection herein described presents better performance with higher yields, shorter reaction times, less time-consuming operations, easier setup, and lower costs.

Cleavage Off-Loading and Post-assembly-Line Conversions Yield Products with Unusual Termini during Biosynthesis

Piscibactins and photoxenobactins are metallophores and virulence factors, whose biosynthetic gene cluster, termed pxb, is the most prevalent polyketide synthase/non-ribosomal peptide synthetase hybrid cluster across entomopathogenic bacteria. They are structurally similar to yersiniabactin, which contributes to the virulence of the human pathogen Yersinia pestis. However, the pxb-derived products feature various chain lengths and unusual carboxamide, thiocarboxylic acid, and dithioperoxoate termini, which are rarely found in thiotemplated biosyntheses. Here, we characterize the pxb biosynthetic logic by gene deletions, site-directed mutagenesis, and isotope labeling experiments. Notably, we propose that it involves (1) heterocyclization domains with various catalytic efficiencies catalyzing thiazoline and amide/thioester bond formation and (2) putative C–N and C–S bond cleavage off-loading manners, which lead to products with different chain lengths and usual termini. Additionally, the post-assembly-line spontaneous conversions of the biosynthetic end product contribute to production titers of the other products in the culture medium. This study broadens our knowledge of thiotemplated biosynthesis and how bacterial host generate a chemical arsenal.

Molecular Mechanism of Protein Arginine Deiminase 2: A Study Involving Multiple Microsecond Long Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Peptidylarginine deiminase 2 (PAD2) is a Ca²⁺-dependent enzyme that catalyzes the conversion of protein arginine residues to citrulline. This kind of structural modification in histone molecules may affect gene regulation, leading to effects that may trigger several diseases, including breast cancer, which makes PAD2 an attractive target for anticancer drug development. To design new effective inhibitors to control activation of PAD2, improving our understanding of the molecular mechanisms of PAD2 using up-to-date computational techniques is essential. We have designed five different PAD2-substrate complex systems based on varying protonation states of the active site residues. To search the conformational space broadly, multiple independent molecular dynamics simulations of the complexes have been performed. In total, 50 replica simulations have been performed, each of 1 μs, yielding a total simulation time of 50 μs. Our findings identify that the protonation states of Cys647, Asp473, and His471 are critical for the binding and localization of the N-α-benzoyl-l-arginine ethyl ester substrate within the active site. A novel mechanism for enzyme activation is proposed according to near attack conformers. This represents an important step in understanding the mechanism of citrullination and developing PAD2-inhibiting drugs for the treatment of breast cancer.

Enabling Cysteine-Free Native Chemical Ligation at Challenging Junctions with a Ligation Auxiliary Capable of Base Catalysis

Ligation auxiliaries are used in chemical protein synthesis to extend the scope of native chemical ligation (NCL) beyond cysteine. However, auxiliary-mediated ligations at sterically demanding junctions have been difficult. Often the thioester intermediate formed in the thiol exchange step of NCL accumulates because the subsequent S→N acyl transfer is extremely slow. Here we introduce the 2-mercapto-2-(pyridin-2-yl)ethyl (MPyE) group as the first auxiliary designed to aid the ligation reaction by catalysis. Notably, the MPyE auxiliary provides useful rates even for junctions containing proline or a β-branched amino acid. Quantum chemical calculations suggest that the pyridine nitrogen acts as an intramolecular base in a rate-determining proton transfer step. The auxiliary is prepared in two steps and conveniently introduced by reductive alkylation. Auxiliary cleavage is induced upon treatment with TCEP/morpholine in presence of a Mn^II complex as radical starter. The synthesis of a de novo designed 99mer peptide and an 80 aa long MUC1 peptide demonstrates the usefulness of the MPyE auxiliary.

Theoretical study on reaction mechanism of phosphate-catalysed N-S acyl transfer of N-sulfanylethylanilide (SEAlide)

C-Terminally thioesterificated peptides are essential building blocks for chemical protein synthesis. To date, many acyl transfer auxiliaries have been developed to enable facile preparation of peptide thioesters. We previously developed an N-sulfanylethylanilide (SEAlide) auxiliary, which causes an N-S acyl transfer reaction upon addition of phosphate salt to convert a C-terminal amide to a thioester. The mechanism of how phosphate triggers the reaction is speculative, and the details are unknown. In this study, the mechanism by which phosphate promotes acyl transfer is discussed based on density functional theory (DFT) calculations and non-covalent interaction (NCI) analysis. As a result, although the notion that phosphate acts as an acid-base catalyst, as speculated in our previous study, was correct, it became clear that two competing reaction pathways exist: a previously proposed stepwise pathway and a concerted one. Furthermore, calculation was performed in the presence of various additives other than phosphate to uncover the effect of the additives on the stability of transition states.

Nitroxide-mediated polymerisation of thioacrylates and their transformation into poly(acrylamide)s

Nitroxide mediated polymers of thioacrylates can be transformed into poly(acrylamide)s.

A computational study on H2S release and amide formation from thionoesters and cysteine

The recognition of the biological activity of H2S has drawn much attention to the development of biocompatible H2S release reactions. Thiol-, particularly cysteine-triggered systems which mimic the enzymatic conversion of cysteine or homocysteine to H2S have been intensively reported recently. Herein, a density functional theory (DFT) study was performed to address the reaction mechanism of H2S release and potential amide bond formation from thionoesters and cysteine to gain deeper mechanistic insights. Three possible mechanisms were considered and we found that the one starting from the nucleophilic addition of the ionized mercapto of cysteine on thionoester to generate a dithioester intermediate (Path A) is kinetically favored over the others starting from the nucleophilic addition of the amine of cysteine to generate thionoamide intermediates (Paths B and C). Dithioester then undergoes intramolecular nucleophilic addition of an amine group and the rate-limiting water-assisted proton transfer to generate a cyclic thiol intermediate, and finally affords H2S and dihydrothiazole via water-assisted elimination. The hydrolysis of thionoamide or dihydrothiazole to produce amide is highly difficult under neutral conditions but is operative under strong basic conditions, which explains the experimental observation that dihydrothiazole rather than amide is the major product. Meanwhile, the ring opening reaction of the cyclic thiol intermediate to form the more stable thionoamide is detrimental to H2S release and becomes competitive under basic conditions.

The Molecular Mechanism of Substrate Recognition and Catalysis of the Membrane Acyltransferase PatA from Mycobacteria

Glycolipids play a central role in a variety of important biological processes in all living organisms. PatA is a membrane acyltransferase involved in the biosynthesis of phosphatidyl-myo-inositol mannosides (PIMs), key structural elements, and virulence factors of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. PatA catalyzes the transfer of a palmitoyl moiety from palmitoyl-CoA to the 6-position of the mannose ring linked to the 2-position of inositol in PIM₁/PIM₂. We report here the crystal structure of PatA in the presence of 6-O-palmitoyl-α-d-mannopyranoside, unraveling the acceptor binding mechanism. The acceptor mannose ring localizes in a cavity at the end of a surface-exposed long groove where the active site is located, whereas the palmitate moiety accommodates into a hydrophobic pocket deeply buried in the α/β core of the protein. Both fatty acyl chains of the PIM₂ acceptor are essential for the reaction to take place, highlighting their critical role in the generation of a competent active site. By the use of combined structural and quantum-mechanics/molecular-mechanics (QM/MM) metadynamics, we unravel the catalytic mechanism of PatA at the atomic-electronic level. Our study provides a detailed structural rationale for a stepwise reaction, with the generation of a tetrahedral transition state for the rate-determining step. Finally, the crystal structure of PatA in the presence of β-d-mannopyranose and palmitate suggests an inhibitory mechanism for the enzyme, providing exciting possibilities for inhibitor design and the discovery of chemotherapeutic agents against this major human pathogen.

Thioester functional polymers

Inspired by the uniqueness and ubiquity of thioesters in nature, much attention has been paid to thioester functionalized materials, yielding applications ranging from responsive polymers to bioconjugates and (bio)degradable polymers.

Computational study of the mechanism of amide bond formation via CS2-releasing 1,3-acyl transfer

A systematic computational study on CS₂-releasing 1,3-acyl transfer was performed for the first time and provided deeper mechanistic insights.

Aromatic thiol-mediated cleavage of N-O bonds enables chemical ubiquitylation of folded proteins

Access to protein substrates homogenously modified by ubiquitin (Ub) is critical for biophysical and biochemical investigations aimed at deconvoluting the myriad biological roles for Ub. Current chemical strategies for protein ubiquitylation, however, employ temporary ligation auxiliaries that are removed under harsh denaturing conditions and have limited applicability. We report an unprecedented aromatic thiol-mediated N–O bond cleavage and its application towards native chemical ubiquitylation with the ligation auxiliary 2-aminooxyethanethiol. Our interrogation of the reaction mechanism suggests a disulfide radical anion as the active species capable of cleaving the N–O bond. The successful semisynthesis of full-length histone H2B modified by the small ubiquitin-like modifier-3 (SUMO-3) protein further demonstrates the generalizability and compatibility of our strategy with folded proteins.

Chemical approaches to site-specifically ubiquitylate a target protein allow investigation of the biochemical effects of this modification, but they often destabilize the protein. Here, the authors report on a synthetic conjugation strategy that leads to protein ubiquitylation in non-denaturing conditions.

Nonclassical Routes for Amide Bond Formation

The present review offers an overview of nonclassical (e.g., with no pre- or in situ activation of a carboxylic acid partner) approaches for the construction of amide bonds. The review aims to comprehensively discuss relevant work, which was mainly done in the field in the last 20 years. Organization of the data follows a subdivision according to substrate classes: catalytic direct formation of amides from carboxylic and amines ( section 2 ); the use of carboxylic acid surrogates ( section 3 ); and the use of amine surrogates ( section 4 ). The ligation strategies (NCL, Staudinger, KAHA, KATs, etc.) that could involve both carboxylic acid and amine surrogates are treated separately in section 5 .

Mechanism for the enhanced reactivity of 4-mercaptoprolyl thioesters in native chemical ligation

Ring-strain-precluded strategy benefiting from entropy effects and n → π* orbital interaction, enhances the reactivity of C-terminal prolyl thioesters in NCL.

Applications of Chemical Ligation in Peptide Synthesis via Acyl Transfer

The utility of native chemical ligation (NCL) in the solution or solid phase synthesis of peptides, cyclic peptides, glycopeptides, and neoglycoconjugates is reviewed. In addition, the mechanistic details of inter- or intra-molecular NCLs are discussed from experimental and computational points of view.

Patchwork protein chemistry: a practitioner's treatise on the advances in synthetic peptide stitchery

With the study of peptides and proteins at the heart of many scientific endeavors, the omics era heralded a multitude of opportunities for chemists and biologists alike. Across the interface with life sciences, peptide chemistry plays an indispensable role, and progress made over the past decades now allows proteins to be treated as molecular patchworks stitched together through synthetic tailoring. The continuous elaboration of sophisticated strategies notwithstanding, Merrifield's solid-phase methodology remains a cornerstone of chemical protein design. Although the non-practitioner might misjudge peptide synthesis as trivial, routine, or dull given its long history, we comment here on its many advances, obstacles, and prospects from a practitioner's point of view. While sharing our perspectives through thematic highlights across the literature, this treatise provides an interpretive overview as a guide to novices, and a recap for specialists.

Peptide ligations accelerated by N-terminal aspartate and glutamate residues

A novel application of intramolecular base catalysis confers enhanced reaction rates for aminolysis ligations between peptide thioesters and peptides bearing N-terminal aspartate or glutamate residues. The broad scope of this process and its application in the total synthesis of the diabetes drug exenatide is demonstrated.