Results of colectomy for diverticular disease of the colon

Impact of diverticular disease on hospital costs and activity

BACKGROUND

Diverticulosis is very common in the UK and patients with clinically significant diverticular disease present regularly to departments of surgery as acute emergencies or chronic problems. There are no national data on the hospital prevalence, clinical implications or financial impact of diverticular disease hence the extent of the clinical problem is as yet not quantified.

AIM

To detect the prevalence, clinical implications and financial impact of diverticular disease over a one year period in a large district hospital.

METHODS

Retrospective review of all patients treated for diverticular disease during one financial year. Clinical and cost analysis of inpatient and outpatient investigations, treatment and hospitalization.

RESULTS

A total of 148 patients were treated of whom 83 were admitted for more than 1 day, 55 of those were emergency admissions. Five of 83 admitted patients died (in-patient mortality 6%, peri-operative mortality 26.3%). There was a total number of 982 hospitalization days of which 94 Intensive Care Unit days and 68 High Dependency Unit days. Nineteen operations were performed (16 sigmoid colectomies, 1 oversewing of perforated sigmoid, 2 reversal of colostomy). The investigations generated were 48 colonoscopies, 77 flexible sigmoidoscopies, 77 Barium enemas, 2 CT scans and 34 ultrasound scans. A total number of 410 clinic appointments were generated. One year after discharge 134/148 (90.5%) patients were alive. The total cost of this activity was pound 465263 or 5.3% of the total annual budget for General Surgery. Seventy percent of the cost was bed-days expenses with ICU hospitalization accounting for 25% of the total cost.

CONCLUSION

Diverticular disease is a major cause of morbidity in a large district hospital and a significant burden on resources. More research should be done on prevention of complications and management in the community. The current methods of management do not appear to be cost-effective and attempts should be made to produce protocols for evidence-based, cost-efficient management of the disease. A UK national audit should be undertaken.

Atypical diverticular disease: surgical results

PURPOSE

Patients with diverticular disease may present with chronic symptoms but never develop diverticulitis. The purpose of this research was to review the outcome of surgical intervention in this subgroup of patients with atypical "smoldering" diverticular disease.

METHODS

Records of 930 patients who underwent sigmoid resection for diverticular disease during a ten-year period at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, were reviewed. Forty-seven patients (5 percent) fit our inclusion criteria for smoldering diverticular disease and underwent sigmoid colectomy with primary anastomosis. A minimum of 12 months of follow-up was completed in 68 percent of these patients.

RESULTS

Evidence of acute or chronic inflammatory changes was present in 76 percent of resected specimens. Complete resolution of symptoms occurred in 76.5 percent, with 88 percent being pain free.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that the diagnosis and presentation of atypical smoldering diverticular disease is an uncommon and poorly defined entity. However, sigmoid resection in this subgroup of patients is safe and is associated with resolution of symptoms in the majority of cases.

Smoking may be associated with complications in diverticular disease

BACKGROUND

The vast majority of people with diverticula remain asymptomatic or develop minor symptoms while a small group develop serious complications that are associated with significant morbidity and mortality rates. The aim was to identify any risk factors predisposing to complications.

METHODS

Eighty patients with diverticular disease were studied. Patients in group 1 (n = 45) with complications requiring hospitalization or surgery were compared with those in group 2 (n = 35) with asymptomatic diverticula or minor symptoms. Logistic regression analysis was performed.

RESULTS

No differences in epidemiological factors, concurrent and past medical and surgical conditions or chronic medication were detected between the two groups. Generalized disease was not associated with more complications than sigmoid disease. However, smoking seemed to be an independent factor predisposing to complications; the proportion of smokers in group 1 was significantly greater (24 of 45) than that in group 2 (ten of 35) (odds ratio 2.9, P = 0.028).

CONCLUSION

In patients with diverticular disease, smoking is associated with an increased risk of complications.

Colonic diverticula. When complications require surgery and when they don't

The value of a high-fiber diet in preventing and treating colonic diverticula is firmly established. Although the diagnosis of diverticulosis is usually made with colonoscopy or barium enema examination, computed tomography has become the test of choice during acute diverticulitis, when the diagnosis cannot be confidently made clinically. Recently developed surgical principles for diverticulitis include radiographically directed drainage with delayed operation for peridiverticular abscess, resection of the site of disease in patients with general peritonitis, and primary anastomosis in most cases requiring urgent intervention. Diverticulosis accompanied by abdominal pain or irregular bowel habits is by itself rarely an indication for surgery. Diverticular bleeding usually resolves spontaneously, but persistent bleeding can usually be successfully treated with segmental colectomy after localization of the bleeding site with colonoscopy or arteriography.

Surgery for diverticulitis in renal failure

Twenty-five patients were operated on at the Brigham and Women's Hospital for colonic diverticulitis complicating treated renal failure during the period 1951 to 1983. Twelve patients had functioning renal allografts (eight cadaver, four living-related); 13 were on dialysis therapy. Six patients had polycystic kidney disease. The majority of patients had acute abdominal pain. Four had histories of chronic abdominal pain; nondiagnostic exploratory laparotomies were performed on two of these patients, who developed localized tenderness. The overall mortality in this series was 28 percent, with sepsis being the most common cause of death. Six of seven patients who died had free colonic perforations at surgery. Mortality correlated with age, with six of 14 patients (43 percent) over age 50 dying, as compared with one of 11 patients (9 percent) under age 50. There was no correlation between survival rate and type of surgery performed, dose of prednisone or azathioprine used, or type of treatment received for renal failure.

Changing patterns in the surgical treatment of diverticular disease

This paper includes a brief historic summary of the surgical aspects of diverticular disease and of corresponding developments in the Massachusetts General Hospital from 1911 to the present. The 350 cases observed in 1974-1983 are compared with 338 seen in the previous decade. Major trends include a decrease in hospital admissions for diverticular disease but a sustained number of operations; increased severity of the disease in hospitalized patients manifested by an increased percentage of patients with immunosuppression or serious other diseases (p less than 0.001), an increased number with sepsis and general peritonitis (p less than 0.001); an increased percentage of cases with one-stage resection and anastomosis (p less than 0.02); in patients with general peritonitis, resection of the perforated segment at the time of the original operation was accompanied by the lowest mortality (p less than 0.02); incidental splenectomy appears to be dangerous, with three deaths in eight cases; and overall mortality in the last decade is 6.4%; for emergency cases 10.2%, for urgent 9.7%, and for elective cases 2.4%.

Conservative surgery for vesicocolic fistula

Vesicocolic fistula due to diverticular disease of the colon is conventionally treated by resection of the diseased bowel and closure of the vesical defect. Three cases are described in which separation of the viscera and simple suture of the vesical and colonic defects was carried out. A greater omental graft was interposed between the rectum and bladder. Two of the patients are well 12 and 26 months postoperatively. The third patient died a year postoperatively from a complication of her diverticular disease.