Domain-Swapping Design by Polyproline Rod Insertion

Unravelling the amyloid aggregation mechanism of the sweet protein Monellin: Insights from circular permutated mutants

Protein amyloid aggregates, once regarded solely as pathological hallmarks of human neurodegenerative diseases, have recently gained attention for their potential in biotechnological applications. Among others, MNEI and its variants, initially developed as single-chain derivatives of the sweet protein monellin, also serve as valuable models for studying protein fibrillary aggregation. In this work, we have characterized three circular permutated mutants of MNEI obtained joining the N- and C-termini of MNEI with linkers of different length and restoring the splitting of the polypeptide chain of native monellin. All proteins are well folded but have a different propensity to form oligomeric structures in solution and aggregation rates comparable to or faster than MNEI, as indicated by Thioflavin-T binding assays. Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) studies indicate that only Perm1, the mutant with the longest linker, forms fibrillar aggregates. X-ray structures of the mutants show that they crystallize as domain-swapped dimers. Molecular dynamics study highlights potential hot spots controlling the ordered aggregation process of Perm1. Our data support the idea that the formation of a domain-swapped dimer does not favour the formation of fibrillar aggregates and highlight circular permutation as a valuable tool to build nanostructured biomaterials.

Insights into mechanisms and significance of domain swapping from emerging examples in the Mog1p/PsbP-like fold

Three-dimensional (3D) domain swapping in proteins occurs when identical polypeptide chains exchange structural elements to form a homo-oligomeric protein. Domain swapping can play a regulatory role for certain oligomeric proteins and has been implicated in deleterious protein aggregation. Here, we examine recently reported 3D domain swapping in proteins that contain the Mog1p/PsbP-like fold, which is a small fold found in non-enzymatic proteins that participate in a variety of distinct cellular processes. This fold was initially identified from structures of the yeast Mog1p protein, which regulates nuclear protein transport in eukaryotes, and PsbP proteins, which are part of photosystem II in plants, green algae, and cyanobacteria. The core structural element of the Mog1p/PsbP-like fold is an α-β-α sandwich that contains a 6- or 7-stranded antiparallel β-sheet. Additionally, most Mog1p/PsbP-like proteins contain an N-terminal β-hairpin that interacts with the α-β-α sandwich. Interestingly, domain-swapped dimers can form by exchange of this N-terminal β-hairpin in certain proteins. We discuss biochemical mechanisms and explore the functional significance of domain-swapping in the formation of an interaction interface in homo-dimers that bind a protein target. Lastly, we examine domain swapping between 2 tandem Mog1p/PsbP-like domains in a multidomain protein. In summary, this review provides recent examples of domain-swapping in proteins containing the Mog1p/PsbP-like fold and highlights general roles for domain-swapping in facilitating protein-protein interactions and in the evolution of multidomain proteins.

Strand-Swapped SH3 Domain Dimer with Superoxide Dismutase Activity

The design of metalloproteins allows us to better understand metal complexation in proteins and the resulting function. In this study, we incorporated a Cu2+-binding site into a natural protein domain, the 58 amino acid c-Crk-SH3, to create a miniaturized superoxide dismutase model, termed SO1. The resulting low complexity metalloprotein was characterized for structure and function by circular dichroism and UV spectroscopy as well as EPR spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography. The miniprotein was found to be a strand-swapped dimer with an unusual coupled binuclear Type 2-like copper center in each protomer. SO1-Cu was found to be SOD-active with an activity only 1 order of magnitude lower than that of natural SOD enzymes and 1 to 2 orders of magnitude higher than that of other low-complexity SOD protein models of similar size. This serendipitous design provides us with a new structural template for future designs of binuclear metalloproteins with different metal ions and functions.

Hydrogen bonding patterns and cooperativity in polyproline II helical bundles

Hydrogen bond cooperativity (HBC) plays an important role in stabilizing protein assemblies built by α-helices and β-sheets, the most common secondary structures. However, whether HBC exists in other types of protein secondary structures such as polyproline II (PPII) helices remains unexplored. This is intriguing, since PPII systems as assembling blocks are continuously emerging across multiple fields. Here, using a combination of computational chemistry tools and molecular modeling corroborated by experimental observables, we characterize the distinct H-bonding patterns present in PPII helical bundles and establish that HBC stabilizes intermolecular PPII helices as seen in other protein assemblies such as amyloid fibrils. In addition to cooperative interactions in canonical CO···HN H-bonds, we show that analogous interactions in non-canonical CO···HαCα H-bonds are relevant in Gly-rich PPII bundles, thus compensating for the inability of glycine residues to create hydrophobic cores. Our results provide a mechanistic explanation for the assembly of these bundles.

β-Strand-mediated Domain-swapping in the Absence of Hydrophobic Core Repacking

Domain swapping is a process wherein a portion of a protein is exchanged with its counterpart in another copy of the molecule, resulting in the formation of homo-oligomers with concomitant repacking of a hydrophobic core. Here, we report domain swapping triggered upon modifying a β-hairpin sequence within a single-layer β-sheet (SLB) of a model protein, OspA that did not involve the formation of a reorganized hydrophobic core. The replacement of two β-hairpin sequences with a Gly-Gly and shorteing of a β-hairpin resulted in a protein that formed two distinct crystal structures under similar conditions: one was monomeric, similar to the parental molecule, whereas the other was a domain-swapped dimer, mediated by an intermolecular β-sheet in the SLB portion. Based on the dimer interface structure, we replaced the Gly-Gly sequence with three-residue sequences that enable the formation of a consecutive intermolecular β-sheet, including the Cys-Thr-Cys sequence that formed a stable disulfide-linked dimer. These results provide new insights into protein folding, evolution, and the designability of protein structure.

Use of 3D domain swapping in constructing supramolecular metalloproteins

Supramolecules, which are formed by assembling multiple molecules by noncovalent intermolecular interactions instead of covalent bonds, often show additional properties that cannot be exhibited by a single molecule. Supramolecules have evolved into molecular machines in the field of chemistry, and various supramolecular proteins are responsible for life activities in the field of biology. The design and creation of supramolecular proteins will lead to development of new enzymes, functional biomaterials, drug delivery systems, etc.; thus, the number of studies on the regulation of supramolecular proteins is increasing year by year. Several methods, including disulfide bond, metal coordination, and surface-surface interaction, have been utilized to construct supramolecular proteins. In nature, proteins have been shown to form oligomers by 3D domain swapping (3D-DS), a phenomenon in which a structural region is exchanged between molecules of the same protein. We have been studying the mechanism of 3D-DS and utilizing 3D-DS to construct supramolecular metalloproteins. Cytochrome c forms cyclic oligomers and polymers by 3D-DS, whereas other metalloproteins, such as various c-type cytochromes and azurin form small oligomers and myoglobin forms a compact dimer. We have also utilized 3D-DS to construct heterodimers with different active sites, a protein nanocage encapsulating a Zn-SO₄ cluster in the internal cavity, and a tetrahedron with a designed building block protein. Protein oligomer formation was controlled for the 3D-DS dimer of a dimer-monomer transition protein. This article reviews our research on supramolecular metalloproteins.

Experimental and theoretical study on converting myoglobin into a stable domain-swapped dimer by utilizing a tight hydrogen bond network at the hinge region

Various factors, such as helical propensity and hydrogen bonds, control protein structures. A frequently used model protein, myoglobin (Mb), can perform 3D domain swapping, in which the loop at the hinge region is converted to a helical structure in the dimer. We have previously succeeded in obtaining monomer–dimer equilibrium in the native state by introducing a high α-helical propensity residue, Ala, to the hinge region. In this study, we focused on another factor that governs the protein structure, hydrogen bonding. X-ray crystal structures and thermodynamic studies showed that the myoglobin dimer was stabilized over the monomer when keeping His82 to interact with Lys79 and Asp141 through water moleclues and mutating Leu137, which was located close to the H-bond network at the dimer hinge region, to a hydrophilic amino acid (Glu or Asp). Molecular dynamics simulation studies confirmed that the number of H-bonds increased and the α-helices at the hinge region became more rigid for mutants with a tighter H-bond network, supporting the hypothesis that the myoglobin dimer is stabilized when the H-bond network at the hinge region is enhanced. This demonstrates the importance and utility of hydrogen bonds for designing a protein dimer from its monomer with 3D domain swapping.

The tight H-bond network enhanced the helices at the hinge region and stabilized the myoglobin dimer, providing a unique example of using H-bonds in the design of a dimeric protein through 3D domain swapping.

Human Cellular Retinol Binding Protein II Forms a Domain-Swapped Trimer Representing a Novel Fold and a New Template for Protein Engineering

Domain-swapping is a mechanism for evolving new protein structure from extant scaffolds, and has been an efficient protein-engineering strategy for tailoring functional diversity. However, domain swapping can only be exploited if it can be controlled, especially in cases where various folds can coexist. Herein, we describe the structure of a domain-swapped trimer of the iLBP family member hCRBPII, and suggest a mechanism for domain-swapped trimerization. It is further shown that domain-swapped trimerization can be favored by strategic installation of a disulfide bond, thus demonstrating a strategy for fold control. We further show the domain-swapped trimer to be a useful protein design template by installing a high-affinity metal binding site through the introduction of a single mutation, taking advantage of its threefold symmetry. Together, these studies show how nature can promote oligomerization, stabilize a specific oligomer, and generate new function with minimal changes to the protein sequence.