Comparative study of the colchicine binding site and the assembly of fish and mammalian microtubule proteins

Large scale purification of brain tubulin with the modified Weisenberg procedure

This method is a modification of the initial procedure employed to purify tubulin from mammalian brain. It consists of tissue homogenization, elimination of cell membranes, ammonium sulfate fractionation, and batch anion exchange, followed by selective precipitation with magnesium chloride. Half gram of electrophoretically homogenous, active, concentrated calf brain tubulin is typically purified in 9 h, dialyzed overnight, and stored under liquid nitrogen. Prior to use the protein is equilibrated in the experimental buffer and its concentration measured. This tubulin preparation has been very extensively characterized. Frozen aliquots have been found to retain microtubule assembly activity after 10 yr of storage.

Microtubule interactions with chemically diverse stabilizing agents: thermodynamics of binding to the paclitaxel site predicts cytotoxicity

The interactions of microtubules with most compounds described as stabilizing agents have been studied. Several of them (lonafarnib, dicumarol, lutein, and jatrophane polyesters) did not show any stabilizing effect on microtubules. Taccalonolides A and E show paclitaxel-like effects in cells, but they were not able to modulate in vitro tubulin assembly or to bind microtubules, which suggests that other factors are involved in their cellular effects. The binding constants of epothilones, eleutherobin, discodermolide, sarcodictyins, 3,17beta-diacetoxy-2-ethoxy-6-oxo-B-homo-estra-1,3,5(10)-triene, and dictyostatin to the paclitaxel site; the critical concentrations of ligand-induced assembly; and their cytotoxicity in carcinoma cells have been measured, and correlations between these parameters have been determined. The inhibition of cell proliferation correlates better with the binding enthalpy change than with the binding constants, suggesting that large, favorable enthalpic contribution to the binding is desired to design paclitaxel site drugs with higher cytotoxicity.

Macromolecular accessibility of fluorescent taxoids bound at a paclitaxel binding site in the microtubule surface

The macromolecular accessibility of the paclitaxel binding site in microtubules has been investigated using a fluorescent taxoid and antibodies against fluorescein, which cannot diffuse into the microtubule lumen. The formation of a specific ternary complex of microtubules, Hexaflutax (7-O-{N-[6-(fluorescein-4'-carboxamido)-n-hexanoyl]-l-alanyl}paclitaxel) and 4-4-20 IgG (a monoclonal antibody against fluorescein) has been observed by means of sedimentation and electron microscopy methods. The kinetics of binding of the antibody to microtubule-bound Hexaflutax has been measured. The quenching of the observed fluorescence is fast (k+ 2.26 +/- 0.25 x 10(6) m(-1) s(-1) at 37 degrees C), indicating that the fluorescein groups of Hexaflutax are exposed to the outer solvent. The velocity of the reaction is linearly dependent on the antibody concentration, indicating that a bimolecular reaction is being observed. Another fluorescent taxoid (Flutax-2) bound to microtubules has also been shown to be rapidly accessible to polyclonal antibodies directed against fluorescein. A reduced rate of Hexaflutax quenching by the antibody is observed in microtubule-associated proteins containing microtubules or in native cellular cytoskeletons. It can be concluded that the fluorescent taxoids bind to an outer site on the microtubules that is shared with paclitaxel. Paclitaxel would be internalized in a further step of binding to reach the known luminal site, this step being blocked in the case of the fluorescent taxoids. Because the fluorescent ligands are able to induce microtubule assembly, binding to the outer site should be enough to induce assembly by a preferential binding mechanism.

Fast kinetics of Taxol binding to microtubules. Effects of solution variables and microtubule-associated proteins

The kinetics of Taxol association to and dissociation from stabilized microtubules has been measured by competition with the reference fluorescent derivative Flutax-1 (Diaz, J. F., Strobe, R., Engelborghs, Y., Souto, A. A., and Andreu, J. M. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275, 26265-26276). The association rate constant at 37 degrees C is k(+) = (3.6 +/- 0.1) x 10(6) m(-1) s(-1). The reaction profile is similar to that of the first step of Flutax-1 binding, which probably corresponds to the binding of the Taxol moiety. The rate constant of the initial binding of Flutax-1 is inversely proportional to the viscosity of the solution, which is compatible with a diffusion-controlled reaction. Microtubule-associated proteins bound to the microtubule outer surface slow down the binding of Flutax-1 and Flutax-2 10-fold. The binding site is fully accessible to Flutax-2 in native cytoskeletons of PtK2 cells; the observed kinetic rates of Flutax-2 microtubule staining and de-staining are similar to the reaction rates with microtubule associated proteins-containing microtubules. The kinetic data prove that taxoids bind directly from the bulk solution to an exposed microtubule site. Several hypotheses have been analyzed to potentially reconcile these data with the location of a Taxol-binding site at the model microtubule lumen, including dynamic opening of the microtubule wall and transport from an initial Taxol-binding site at the microtubule pores.

Fluorescent taxoids as probes of the microtubule cytoskeleton

Microtubules are specifically and efficiently visualized with the new fluorescent taxoids 7-O-[N-(4'-fluoresceincarbonyl)-L-alanyl]taxol (FLUTAX) and 7-O-[N-(4'-tetramethylrhodaminecarbonyl)-L-alanyl]taxol (ROTAX). Similarly to taxol, FLUTAX and ROTAX are able to drive inactive GDP-liganded tubulin into microtubule assembly. One molecule of FLUTAX binds per alphabeta-tubulin dimer assembled, competing with taxol for the same microtubule binding site with an eightfold smaller relative affinity. FLUTAX-induced microtubule elongation is markedly Mg2+-dependent, encompassing the binding of one Mg2+ ion more per tubulin dimer polymerized than in the case of taxol. A small perturbation of the absorption spectrum of bound FLUTAX is consistent with a cationic microenvironment relative to the solution. The fluorescence anisotropy of FLUTAX increases by an order of magnitude upon binding to microtubules and time-resolved measurements indicate that the fluorescein moiety remains considerably mobile on a protein surface. The rate of labeling suggests that this is the outer microtubule wall. Alternatively, the microtubule lumen would be functional. FLUTAX- and ROTAX-induced microtubules, radial structures, and organized microtubule bundles are readily observed under the fluorescence microscope. Rapid and accurate visualization of native (or very mildly fixed) cytoplasmic and spindle microtubules of a variety of permeabilized cells is simply obtained with micromolar FLUTAX, with an advantage over immunofluorescence. In addition, FLUTAX labels the centrosomes of PtK2 cells more intensely than antibodies to alpha- or beta-tubulin, and co-localizing with antibodies to gamma-tubulin. Two brightly fluorescent spots, probably separating or duplicating centrioles, can be resolved in the centrosomes of interphase cells. This finding indicates that centrosomes may well be additional targets of action of taxoids. FLUTAX strongly labels microtubules near the spindle poles, as well as microtubules at the telophase spindle equator and the central part of the midbody in cytokinesis (instead of the dark zone frequently observed with immunofluorescence), suggesting a predominant interaction of FLUTAX with sites at which tubulin is newly polymerized. Nanomolar concentrations of FLUTAX also permit specific imaging of centrosomes, half-spindles and midbodies in growing U937 cells.

Identification of betaIII- and betaIV-tubulin isotypes in cold-adapted microtubules from Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua): antibody mapping and cDNA sequencing

Isolated microtubule proteins from the Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) assemble at temperatures between 8 and 30 degrees C. The cold-adaptation is an intrinsic property of the tubulin molecules, but the reason for it is unknown. To increase our knowledge of tubulin diversity and its role in cold-adaptation we have further characterized cod tubulins using alpha- and beta-tubulin site-directed antibodies and antibodies towards posttranslationally modified tubulin. In addition, one cod brain beta-tubulin isotype has been sequenced. In mammals there are five beta-tubulins (betaI, betaII, betaIII, betaIVa and betaIVb) expressed in brain. A cod betaIII-tubulin was identified by its electrophoretic mobility after reduction and carboxymethylation. The betaIII-like tubulin accounted for more than 30% of total brain beta-tubulins, the highest yield yet observed in any animal. This tubulin corresponds most probably with an additional band, designated beta(x), which was found between alpha- and beta-tubulins on SDS-polyacrylamide gels. It was found to be phosphorylated and neurospecific, and constituted about 30% of total cod beta-tubulin isoforms. The sequenced cod tubulin was identified as a betaIV-tubulin, and a betaIV-isotype was stained by a C-terminal specific antibody. The amount of staining indicates that this isotype, as in mammals, only accounts for a minor part of the total brain beta-tubulin. Based on the estimated amounts of betaIII- and betaIV-tubulins in cod brain, our results indicate that cod has at least one additional beta-tubulin isotype and that beta-tubulin diversity evolved early during fish evolution. The sequenced cod betaIV-tubulin had four unique amino acid substitutions when compared to beta-tubulin sequences from other animals, while one substitution was in common with Antarctic rockcod beta-tubulin. Residues 221, Thr to Ser, and 283, Ala to Ser, correspond in the bovine tubulin dimer structure to loops that most probably interact with other tubulin molecules within the microtubule, and might contribute to cold-adaptation of microtubules.

Helicity of alpha(404-451) and beta(394-445) tubulin C-terminal recombinant peptides

We have investigated the solution conformation of the functionally relevant C-terminal extremes of alpha- and beta-tubulin, employing the model recombinant peptides RL52alpha3 and RL33beta6, which correspond to the amino acid sequences 404-451(end) and 394-445(end) of the main vertebrate isotypes of alpha- and beta-tubulin, respectively, and synthetic peptides with the alpha-tubulin(430-443) and beta-tubulin(412-431) internal sequences. Alpha(404-451) and beta(394-445) are monomeric in neutral aqueous solution (as indicated by sedimentation equilibrium), and have circular dichroism (CD) spectra characteristic of nearly disordered conformation, consistent with low scores in peptide helicity prediction. Limited proteolysis of beta(394-445) with subtilisin, instead of giving extensive degradation, resulted in main cleavages at positions Thr409-Glu410 and Tyr422-Gln423-Gln424, defining the proteolysis resistant segment 410-422, which corresponds to the central part of the predicted beta-tubulin C-terminal helix. Both recombinant peptides inhibited microtubule assembly, probably due to sequestration of the microtubule stabilizing associated proteins. Trifluoroethanol (TFE)-induced markedly helical CD spectra in alpha(404-451) and beta(394-445). A substantial part of the helicity of beta(394-445) was found to be in the CD spectrum of the shorter peptide beta(412-431) with TFE. Two-dimensional 1H-NMR parameters (nonsequential nuclear Overhauser effects (NOE) and conformational C alphaH shifts) in 30% TFE permitted to conclude that about 25% of alpha(404-451) and 40% of beta(394-451) form well-defined helices encompassing residues 418-432 and 408-431, respectively, flanked by disordered N- and C-segments. The side chains of beta(394-451) residues Leu418, Val419, Ser420, Tyr422, Tyr425, and Gln426 are well defined in structure calculations from the NOE distance constraints. The apolar faces of the helix in both alpha and beta chains share a characteristic sequence of conserved residues Ala,Met(+4),Leu(+7),Tyr(+11). The helical segment of alpha(404-451) is the same as that described in the electron crystallographic model structure of alphabeta-tubulin, while in beta(394-451) it extends for nine residues more, supporting the possibility of a functional coil --> helix transition at the C-terminus of beta-tubulin. These peptides may be employed to construct model complexes with microtubule associated protein binding sites.

Changes in microtubule protofilament number induced by Taxol binding to an easily accessible site. Internal microtubule dynamics

We have investigated the accessibility of the Taxol-binding site and the effects of Taxol binding on the structures of assembled microtubules. Taxol and docetaxel readily bind to and dissociate from microtubules, reaching 95% ligand exchange equilibrium in less than 3 min under our solution conditions (microtubules were previously assembled from GTP-tubulin, GTP-tubulin and microtubule-associated proteins, or GDP-tubulin and taxoid). Microtubules assembled from purified tubulin with Taxol are known to have typically one protofilament less than with the analogue docetaxel and control microtubules. Surprisingly, Taxol binding and exchange induce changes in the structure of preformed microtubules in a relatively short time scale. Cryoelectron microscopy shows changes toward the protofilament number distribution characteristic of Taxol or docetaxel, with a half-time of approximately 0.5 min, employing GDP-tubulin-taxoid microtubules. Correspondingly, synchrotron x-ray solution scattering shows a reduction in the mean microtubule diameter upon Taxol binding to microtubules assembled from GTP-tubulin in glycerol-containing buffer, with a structural relaxation half-time of approximately 1 min. These results imply that microtubules can exchange protofilaments upon Taxol binding, due to internal dynamics along the microtubule wall. The simplest interpretation of the relatively fast taxoid exchange observed and labeling of cellular microtubules with fluorescent taxoids, is that the Taxol-binding site is at the outer microtubule surface. On the contrary, if Taxol binds at the microtubule lumen in agreement with the electron crystallographic structure of tubulin dimers, our results suggest that the inside of microtubules is easily accessible from the outer solution. Large pores or moving lattice defects in microtubules might facilitate the binding of taxoids, as well as of possible endogenous cellular ligands of the inner microtubule wall.