Rational Design, Synthesis, and Biological Evaluation of Lactam-Bridged Gramicidin A Analogues: Discovery of a Low-Hemolytic Antibacterial Peptide

Synthetic peptide scaffolds as ion channels and molecular carriers

Transmembrane ion exchange controls biological functions and is essential for life. Over the years, a great variety of nature-inspired artificial ion channels and carriers have been synthesized to control and promote ion exchange across biological membranes. In this context, peptides emerged as ideal scaffolds for synthetic ion channels due to their biocompatibility, accessibility and chemical versatility. Peptides have already shown their potential for the construction of a range of synthetic ion transporters either alone or in combination with other molecular scaffolds. Among the great diversity of peptide-based ion transporters, we can find key examples of single-molecule and supramolecular transmembrane ion channels and ionophores. Peptide scaffolds have also found great potential for the transmembrane delivery of biomolecular cargos such as nucleic acids and proteins. This review covers some of the most relevant advances in the peptide-based ion transport field from the last few years.

Effects of Calcium Ions on the Antimicrobial Activity of Gramicidin A

Gramicidin A (gA) is a linear antimicrobial peptide that can form a channel and specifically conduct monovalent cations such as H+ across the lipid membrane. The antimicrobial activity of gA is associated with the formation of hydroxyl free radicals and the imbalance of NADH metabolism, possibly a consequence caused by the conductance of cations. The ion conductivity of gramicidin A can be blocked by Ca2+ ions. However, the effect of Ca2+ ions on the antimicrobial activity of gA is unclear. To unveil the role of Ca2+ ions, we examined the effect of Ca2+ ions on the antimicrobial activity of gramicidin A against Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus). Results showed that the antimicrobial mechanism of gA and antimicrobial activity by Ca2+ ions are concentration-dependent. At the low gA concentration (≤1 μM), the antimicrobial mechanism of gA is mainly associated with the hydroxyl free radical formation and NADH metabolic imbalance. Under this mode, Ca2+ ions can significantly inhibit the hydroxyl free radical formation and NADH metabolic imbalance. On the other hand, at high gA concentration (≥5 μM), gramicidin A acts more likely as a detergent. Gramicidin A not only causes an increase in hydroxyl free radical levels and NAD+/NADH ratios but also induces the destruction of the lipid membrane composition. At this condition, Ca2+ ions can no longer reduce the gA antimicrobial activity but rather enhance the bacterial killing ability of gramicidin A.

Discovery of gramicidin A analogues with altered activities by multidimensional screening of a one-bead-one-compound library

Gramicidin A (1) is a peptide antibiotic that disrupts the transmembrane ion concentration gradient by forming an ion channel in a lipid bilayer. Although long used clinically, it is limited to topical application because of its strong hemolytic activity and mammalian cytotoxicity, likely arising from the common ion transport mechanism. Here we report an integrated high-throughput strategy for discovering analogues of 1 with altered biological activity profiles. The 4096 analogue structures are designed to maintain the charge-neutral, hydrophobic, and channel forming properties of 1. Synthesis of the analogues, tandem mass spectrometry sequencing, and 3 microscale screenings enable us to identify 10 representative analogues. Re-synthesis and detailed functional evaluations find that all 10 analogues share a similar ion channel function, but have different cytotoxic, hemolytic, and antibacterial activities. Our large-scale structure-activity relationship studies reveal the feasibility of developing analogues of 1 that selectively induce toxicity toward target organisms.

The strong hemolytic activity and mammalian cytotoxicity of gramicidin A, a peptide antibiotic, has hindered its non-topical clinical application. Here, the authors report a high-throughput strategy for the discovery of gramicidin A analogues with altered biological activity profiles.

Phospholipid-Dependent Functions of a Macrocyclic Analogue of the Ion-Channel-Forming Antibiotic Gramicidin A

An ion-channel-forming natural peptide, gramicidin A (1), exhibits potent antimicrobial activity against Gram-positive bacteria, although medical applications are limited to topical use due to its mammalian cytotoxicity. We recently reported that the artificial macrocyclic analogue 2 provides a promising starting point for developing new ion-channel-based systemic antibacterial agents because of its low mammalian cytotoxicity compared to that of the parent 1. To dissect the molecular factors involved in the species selectivity of 2, we evaluated the ion transport activities, phospholipid affinities, and conformational properties of 1 and 2 using various compositions of phospholipids. A combination of lipid dot blot assays and circular dichroism (CD) analysis with H⁺/Na⁺ exchange assays revealed that the higher H⁺/Na⁺ exchange activity of 2 than that of 1 in liposomes containing 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylcholine (POPC) or 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-(1'-rac-glycerol) (POPG) is attributable to its higher affinity towards the phospholipids than that of 1. Notably, we also discovered that 2 showed weaker H⁺/Na⁺ exchange activity in liposomes containing 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylethanolamine (POPE). CD analysis of 2 in liposomes indicated that the weak H⁺/Na⁺ exchange activity is induced by disturbance of the ion-conducting β^6.3-helical conformation in the POPE-containing lipid bilayer. These results suggest that the POPE-induced attenuation of the ion-conducting activity of 2 contributes to the alleviation of undesirable mammalian cytotoxicity of 2 compared to that of 1.

Mitigation of peri-implantitis by rational design of bifunctional peptides with antimicrobial properties

The integration of molecular and cell biology with materials science has led to strategies to improve the interface between dental implants with the surrounding soft and hard tissues in order to replace missing teeth and restore mastication. More than 3 million implants have been placed in the US alone and this number is rising by 500,000/year. Peri-implantitis, an inflammatory response to oral pathogens growing on the implant surface threatens to reduce service life leading to eventual implant failure, and such an outcome will have adverse impact on public health and create significant health care costs. Here we report a predictive approach to peptide design, which enabled us to engineer a bifunctional peptide to combat bacterial colonization and biofilm formation, reducing the adverse host inflammatory immune response that destroys the tissue surrounding implants and shortens their lifespans. This bifunctional peptide contains a titanium-binding domain that recognizes and binds with high affinity to titanium implant surfaces, fused through a rigid spacer domain with an antimicrobial domain. By varying the antimicrobial peptide domain, we were able to predict the properties of the resulting bifunctional peptides in their entirety by analyzing the sequence-structure-function relationship. These bifunctional peptides achieve: 1) nearly 100% surface coverage within minutes, a timeframe suitable for their clinical application to existing implants; 2) nearly 100% binding to a titanium surface even in the presence of contaminating serum protein; 3) durability to brushing with a commercially available electric toothbrush; and 4) retention of antimicrobial activity on the implant surface following bacterial challenge. A bifunctional peptide film can be applied to both new implants and/or repeatedly applied to previously placed implants to control bacterial colonization mitigating peri-implant disease that threatens dental implant longevity.

Role of mitochondrial outer membrane in the uncoupling activity of N-terminally glutamate-substituted gramicidin A

Of a series of gramicidin A (gA) derivatives, we have earlier found the peptide [Glu1]gA exhibiting very low toxicity toward mammalian cells, although dissipating mitochondrial membrane potential with almost the same efficiency as gA. Substitution of glutamate for valine at position 1 of the gA amino acid sequence, which is supposed to interfere with the formation of ion-conducting gA channels via head-to-head dimerization, reduces both channel-forming potency of the peptide in planar lipid bilayer membranes and its photonophoric activity in unilamellar liposomes. Here, we compared [Glu1]gA and gA abilities to cause depolarization of the inner mitochondrial membrane in mitochondria and mitoplasts, the latter lacking the outer mitochondrial membrane. Importantly, much less gA was needed to decrease the membrane potential in mitoplasts than in mitochondria, whereas the depolarizing potency of [Glu1]gA was nearly the same in these systems. Moreover, in multilamellar liposomes, [Glu1]gA exhibited more pronounced protonophoric activity than gA, in contrast to the data for unilamellar liposomes. These results allowed us to conclude that [Glu1]gA has a much higher permeability between adjacent lipid membranes than gA. Therefore, the fraction of peptide molecules, reaching the inner mitochondrial membrane upon the addition to cells, is much higher for [Glu1]gA compared to gА. Under these conditions, the decreased cytotoxicity of [Glu1]gA could be associated with its low efficiency as a channel-former dissipating potassium and sodium ion gradients across plasma membrane. The present study highlighted the role of the ability to permeate among various biological membranes for intracellular efficiency of ionophores.

Design, synthesis, and biological evaluation of stable β6.3-Helices: Discovery of non-hemolytic antibacterial peptides

Gramicidin A, a topical antibiotic made from alternating L and D amino acids, is characterized by its wide central pore; upon insertion into membranes, it forms channels that disrupts ion gradients. We present helical peptidomimetics with this characteristic wide central pore that have been designed to mimic gramicidin A channels. Mimetics were designed using molecular modeling focused on oligomers of heterochiral dipeptides of proline analogs, in particular azaproline (AzPro). Molecular Dynamics simulations in water confirmed the stability of the designed helices. A sixteen-residue Formyl-(AzPro-Pro)₈-NHCH₂CH₂OH helix was synthesized as well as a full thirty-two residue Cbz-(AzPro-Pro)₁₆-O^tBu channels. No liposomal lysis activity was observed suggesting lack of channel formation, possibly due to inappropriate hydrogen-bonding interactions in the membrane. These peptidomimetics also did not hemolyze red blood cells, unlike gramicidin A.

Preparation and Antibacterial Mechanism Insight of Polypeptide-Based Micelles with Excellent Antibacterial Activities

Traditional antibiotics usually sterilize in chemical ways, which may lead to serious drug resistance. By contrast, peptide-based antibacterial materials are less susceptible to drug resistance. Herein we report the preparation of an antibacterial peptide-based copolymer micelle and the investigation of its membrane-penetration antibacterial mechanism by transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The copolymer is poly(l-lactide)-block-poly(phenylalanine-stat-lysine) [PLLA₃₁-b-poly(Phe₂₄-stat-Lys₃₆)], which is synthesized by ring-opening polymerization. The PLLA chains form the core, whereas the polypeptide chains form the coronas of the micelle in aqueous solution. This micelle boasts excellent antibacterial efficacy against both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. Furthermore, TEM studies clearly reveal that the micelles pierce and then destroy the cell membrane of the bacteria. We also compared the advantages and disadvantages of two general methods for measuring the Minimal Inhibitory Concentration (MIC) values of antibacterial micelles. Overall, this study provides us with direct evidence for the antibacterial mechanism of polypeptide-based micelles and a strategy for synthesizing biodegradable antibacterial nanomaterials without antibiotic resistance.

Bioactivity of topologically confined gramicidin A dimers

The d-/l-peptide gramicidin A (gA) is well known as a pivotal ion channel model and shows a broad spectrum of bioactivities such as antibiosis, antimalarial activity, as well as hemolysis. We applied inter-chain disulfide bonds to constrain the conformational freedom of gA into parallel and antiparallel dimeric topologies. Albeit the constructs were not found to be monoconformational, CD- and IR-spectroscopic studies suggested that this strategy indeed restricted the conformational space of the d-/l-peptide construct, and that β-helical secondary structures prevail. Correlative testing of gA dimers in antimicrobial, antimalarial, and ion conduction assays suggested that the tail-to-tail antiparallel single stranded β^6.3 helix dominantly mediates the bioactivity of gA. Other conformers are unlikely to contribute to these activities. From these investigations, only weakly ion conducting gA dimers were identified that retained nM antimalarial activity.

Total Synthesis and Functional Evaluation of Fourteen Derivatives of Lysocin E: Importance of Cationic, Hydrophobic, and Aromatic Moieties for Antibacterial Activity

Lysocin E (1) is a structurally complex 37-membered depsipeptide comprising 12 amino-acid residues with an N-methylated amide and an ester linkage. Compound 1 binds to menaquinone (MK) in the bacterial membrane to exert its potent bactericidal activity. To decipher the biologically important functionalities within this unique antibiotic, we performed a comprehensive structure-activity relationship (SAR) study by systematically changing the side-chain structures of l-Thr-1, d-Arg-2, N-Me-d-Phe-5, d-Arg-7, l-Glu-8, and d-Trp-10. First, we achieved total synthesis of the 14 new side-chain analogues of 1 by employing a solid-phase strategy. We then evaluated the MK-dependent liposomal disruption and antimicrobial activity against Staphylococcus aureus by 1 and its analogues. Correlating data between the liposome and bacteria experiments revealed that membrane lysis was mainly responsible for the antibacterial functions. Altering the cationic guanidine moiety of d-Arg-2/7 to a neutral amide, and the C7-acyl group of l-Thr-1 to the C2 or C11 counterpart decreased the antimicrobial activities four- or eight-fold. More drastically, chemical mutation of d-Trp-10 to d-Ala-10 totally abolished the bioactivities. These important findings led us to propose the biological roles of the side-chain functionalities.

Gramicidin A disassembles large conductive clusters of its lysine-substituted derivatives in lipid membranes

N-terminally substituted lysine derivatives of gramicidin A (gA), [Lys1]gA and [Lys3]gA, but not glutamate- or aspartate-substituted peptides have been previously shown to cause the leakage of carboxyfluorescein from liposomes. Here, the leakage induction was also observed for [Arg1]gA and [Arg3]gA, while [His1]gA and [His3]gA were inactive at neutral pH. The Lys3-containing analogue with all tryptophans replaced by isoleucines did not induce liposome leakage, similar to gA. This suggests that the presence of both tryptophans and N-terminal cationic residues is critical for pore formation. Remarkably, the addition of gA blocked the leakage induced by [Lys3]gA. By examining with fluorescence correlation spectroscopy the peptide-induced leakage of fluorescent markers from liposomes, we estimated the diameter of pores responsible for the leakage to be about 1.6 nm. Transmission electron cryo-microscopy imaging of liposomes with [Lys3]gA showed that the liposomal membranes contained high electron density particles with a size of about 40 Å, suggesting the formation of peptide clusters. No such clusterization was observed in liposomes incorporating gA or a mixture of gA with [Lys3]gA. Three-dimensional reconstruction of the clusters was compatible with their pentameric arrangement. Based on experimental data and computational modeling, we suggest that the large pore formed by [Lys3]gA represents a barrel-stave oligomeric cluster formed by antiparallel double-stranded helical dimers (DH). In a tentative model, the pentamer of dimers may be stabilized by aromatic Trp-Trp and cation-π Trp-Lys interactions between the neighboring DHs. The inhibiting effect of gA on the [Lys3]gA-induced leakage can be attributed to breaking of cation-π interactions, which prevents peptide clusterization and pore formation.