Enantiodifferentiation through Frequency-Selective Pure-Shift1H Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy

Implementation of pure shift 1 H NMR in metabolic phenotyping for structural information recovery of biofluid metabolites with complex spin systems

NMR spectroscopy is a mainstay of metabolic profiling approaches to investigation of physiological and pathological processes. The one-dimensional proton pulse sequences typically used in phenotyping large numbers of samples generate spectra that are rich in information but where metabolite identification is often compromised by peak overlap. Recently developed pure shift (PS) NMR spectroscopy, where all J-coupling multiplicities are removed from the spectra, has the potential to simplify the complex proton NMR spectra that arise from biosamples and hence to aid metabolite identification. Here we have evaluated two complementary approaches to spectral simplification: the HOBS (band-selective with real-time acquisition) and the PSYCHE (broadband with pseudo-2D interferogram acquisition) pulse sequences. We compare their relative sensitivities and robustness for deconvolving both urine and serum matrices. Both methods improve resolution of resonances ranging from doublets, triplets and quartets to more complex signals such as doublets of doublets and multiplets in highly overcrowded spectral regions. HOBS is the more sensitive method and takes less time to acquire in comparison with PSYCHE, but can introduce unavoidable artefacts from metabolites with strong couplings, whereas PSYCHE is more adaptable to these types of spin system, although at the expense of sensitivity. Both methods are robust and easy to implement. We also demonstrate that strong coupling artefacts contain latent connectivity information that can be used to enhance metabolite identification. Metabolite identification is a bottleneck in metabolic profiling studies. In the case of NMR, PS experiments can be included in metabolite identification workflows, providing additional capability for biomarker discovery.

NMR methods for the analysis of mixtures

NMR spectroscopy is a powerful approach for the analysis of mixtures. Its usefulness arises in large part from the vast landscape of methods, and corresponding pulse sequences, that have been and are being designed to tackle the specific properties of mixtures of small molecules. This feature article describes a selection of methods that aim to address the complexity, the low concentrations, and the changing nature that mixtures can display. These notably include pure-shift and diffusion NMR methods, hyperpolarisation methods, and fast 2D NMR methods such as ultrafast 2D NMR and non-uniform sampling. Examples or applications are also described, in fields such as reaction monitoring and metabolomics, to illustrate the relevance and limitations of different methods.

Study of the Acetylation Pattern of Chitosan by Pure Shift NMR

Chitosan is a biodegradable, antibacterial, and nontoxic biopolymer used in a wide range of applications including biotechnology, pharmacy, and medicine. The physicochemical and biological properties of chitosan have been associated with parameters such as the degree of polymerization (DP) and the fraction of acetylation (F_A). New methods are being developed to yield chitosans of specific acetylation patterns, and, recently, a correlation between biological activity and the distribution of the acetylated units (P_A: pattern of acetylation) has been demonstrated. Although there are numerous well-established methods for the determination of DP and F_A values, this is not the case for P_A. The methods available are either not straightforward or not sensitive enough, limiting their use for routine analysis. In this study, we demonstrate that by applying HOmodecoupled Band-Selective (HOBS) decoupling NMR on signals assigned by multidimensional Pure Shift NMR methods, P_A can be easily and accurately determined on various chitosan samples. This novel methodology-easily implemented for routine analysis-could become a standard for chitosan P_A assessment. In addition, by applying Spectral Aliased Pure Shift HSQC, the analysis was enhanced with the determination of triads.

Combination of pure shift NMR and chemical shift selective filters for analysis of Fischer-Tropsch waste-water

Fischer-Tropsch (F-T) process is an important synthesis route to acquire clean liquid fuels through modern coal chemical industry, which converts syngas (CO and H₂) into hydrocarbon, and also generates oxygenates discharged as the F-T waste-water. These oxygen-containing compounds in F-T waste-water have the similar molecular weight and some are even isomers of each other. Hence, it is necessary to develop rapid and efficient analysis tools to obtain identification and quantitative information of the F-T waste-water. The pure shift NMR techniques provided only chemical shift information in one-dimension ¹H NMR spectra, without homonuclear J_H-H coupling. In this work, we tested and compared three pure shift NMR techniques (including Zangger-Sterk, PSYCHE and TSE-PSYCHE methods) in the analysis of two F-T waste-water model mixtures, genuine waste-water and two alcohol isomer mixtures. The results show that J_H-H coupling multiplicities are collapsed into singlets corresponding to individual chemically distinct protons of the compound. For some severely overlapped signals in the pure shift NMR spectra, the chemical shift selective filters with TOCSY (CSSF-TOCSY) experiments were conducted to assist the signal assignment. Thus, pure shift NMR approaches can identify most signals of components, and CSSF-TOCSY can extract the signal of a specific compound. The combination of these two NMR techniques offers a powerful tool to analyze the F-T waste-water or other complex mixtures including isomer mixtures.

Insight into old and new pure shift nuclear magnetic resonance methods for enantiodiscrimination

Enantiodiscrimination and their quantification using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy has always been a subject of great interest. Proton is the nucleus of choice for enantiodiscrimination due to its high sensitivity and ubiquitous presence in nature. Despite its advantages, enantiodiscrimination suffers from extensive signal splitting by the proton-proton scalar couplings, which give complex multiplets that spread over a frequency range of some tens of hertz. These multiplets often overlap, further complicating interpretation of the spectra and quantifications. In the present review, we discuss some of the recent developments in the pure shift ¹ H NMR based methods for enantiomer resolution and enantiodiscrimination. We also compare various pure shift methods used for enantiodiscrimination and measurement of enantiomeric excess, considering the fact that conventional ¹ H NMR fails to provide any detailed insight.

Multiple homonuclear band-selective decoupling NMR: Fast and unambiguous determination of diastereomeric excess

Discrimination and quantification of chiral stereoisomers have been studied by different analytical methods, and NMR has emerged as a powerful one with the advancements in pure-shift NMR methods. In the present manuscript, an al-F1F2-MHOBS-DIAG NMR method for the quantification of diastereomeric excess ratio (dr) has been proposed and demonstrated, using hesperidin and naringin mixtures. This method enables simultaneous quantification of dr at multiple resonances, in a single experiment, and it takes only 10 min to record. The present method uses spectral aliasing and thus demands only very few indirect dwell increments. Further, the measured dr values are very reliable, because we consider several spins for the quantification.

One-Dimensional 13C NMR Is a Simple and Highly Quantitative Method for Enantiodiscrimination

The discrimination of enantiomers of mandelonitrile by means of 1D ¹³C NMR and with the aid of the chiral solvating agent (S)-(+)-1-(9-anthryl)-2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFAE) is presented. ¹H NMR fails for this specific compound because proton signals either overlap with the signals of the chiral solvating agent or do not show separation between the (S)-enantiomer and the (R)-enantiomer. The ¹³C NMR method is validated by preparing artificial mixtures of the (R)-enantiomer and the racemate, and it is shown that with only 4 mg of mandelonitrile a detection limit of the minor enantiomer of 0.5% is obtained, corresponding to an enantiomeric excess value of 99%. Furthermore, the method shows high linearity, and has a small relative standard deviation of only 0.3% for the minor enantiomer when the relative abundance of this enantiomer is 20%. Therefore, the ¹³C NMR method is highly suitable for quantitative enantiodiscrimination. It is discussed that ¹³C NMR is preferred over ¹H NMR in many situations, not only in molecules with more than one chiral center, resulting in complex mixtures of many stereoisomers, but also in the case of molecules with overlapping multiplets in the ¹H NMR spectrum, and in the case of molecules with many quaternary carbon atoms, and therefore less abundant protons.

Real time band selective F1 -decoupled proton NMR for the demixing of overlay spectra of chiral molecules

The small chemical shift dispersion and complex multiplicity pattern in proton NMR limit quantifications, for instance the determination of enantiomeric excess (ee) for an enantiomeric mixture. Herein, we present a simple proton-proton correlation experiment with band selective homonuclear (BASH) decoupling in both F₁ and F₂ dimensions, for the removal of scalar and residual dipolar couplings to provide collapsed singlet for each chemical site. The method has been demonstrated to separate the severely overlapped spectra of enantiomers using both chiral isotropic and anisotropic phases as well as a small biomolecule, particularly for the diastereotopic protons and also for the determination of ee. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Chiral Recognition by Dissolution DNP NMR Spectroscopy of 13C-Labeled dl-Methionine

A method based on d-DNP NMR spectroscopy to study chiral recognition is described for the first time. The enantiodifferentiation of a racemic metabolite in a millimolar aqueous solution using a chiral solvating agent was performed. Hyperpolarized ¹³C-labeled dl-methionine enantiomers were differently observed with a single-scan ¹³C NMR experiment, while the chiral auxiliary at thermal equilibrium remained unobserved. The method developed entails a step forward in the chiral recognition of small molecules by NMR spectroscopy, opening new possibilities in situations where the sensitivity is limited, for example, when a low concentration of analyte is available or when the measurement of an insensitive nucleus, like ¹³C, is required. The advantages and current limitations of the method, as well as future perspectives, are discussed.

Pure shift 1 H NMR: what is next?

Currently, pure shift nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is an area of high interest. The aim of this contribution is to describe briefly how this technique has evolved, where it is now and what could be the next challenges in the amazing adventure of the development and application of pure shift NMR experiments. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Ultraclean pure shift NMR

“Pure shift” methods can greatly improve the resolution of proton NMR spectra.

Extraction of distance restraints from pure shift NOE experiments

NMR techniques incorporating pure shift methods to improve signal resolution have recently attracted much attention, owing to their potential use in studies of increasingly complex molecular systems. Extraction of frequencies from these simplified spectra enables easier structure determination, but only a few of the methods presented provide structural parameters derived from signal integral measurements. In particular, for quantification of the nuclear Overhauser effect (NOE) it is highly desirable to utilize pure shift techniques where signal overlap normally prevents accurate signal integration, to enable measurement of a larger number of interatomic distances. However, robust methods for the measurement of interatomic distances using the recently developed pure shift techniques have not been reported to date. In this work we discuss some of the factors determining the accuracy of measurements of signal integrals in interferogram-based Zangger-Sterk (ZS) pure shift NMR experiments. The ZS broadband homodecoupling technique is used in different experiments designed for quantitative NOE determination from pure shift spectra. It is shown that the techniques studied can be used for quantitative extraction of NOE-derived distance restraints, as exemplified for the test case of strychnine.

Expedited Selection of NMR Chiral Solvating Agents for Determination of Enantiopurity

The use of NMR chiral solvating agents (CSAs) for the analysis of enantiopurity has been known for decades, but has been supplanted in recent years by chromatographic enantioseparation technology. While chromatographic methods for the analysis of enantiopurity are now commonplace and easy to implement, there are still individual compounds and entire classes of analytes where enantioseparation can prove extremely difficult, notably, compounds that are chiral by virtue of very subtle differences such as isotopic substitution or small differences in alkyl chain length. NMR analysis using CSAs can often be useful for such problems, but the traditional approach to selection of an appropriate CSA and the development of an NMR-based analysis method often involves a trial-and-error approach that can be relatively slow and tedious. In this study we describe a high-throughput experimentation approach to the selection of NMR CSAs that employs automation-enabled screening of prepared libraries of CSAs in a systematic fashion. This approach affords excellent results for a standard set of enantioenriched compounds, providing a valuable comparative data set for the effectiveness of CSAs for different classes of compounds. In addition, the technique has been successfully applied to challenging pharmaceutical development problems that are not amenable to chromatographic solutions. Overall, this methodology provides a rapid and powerful approach for investigating enantiopurity that compliments and augments conventional chromatographic approaches.

Band-selective excited ultrahigh resolution PSYCHE-TOCSY: fast screening of organic molecules and complex mixtures

Precise assignments of (1) H atomic sites and establishment of their through-bond COSY or TOCSY connectivity are crucial for molecular structural characterization by using (1) H NMR spectroscopy. However, this exercise is often hampered by signal overlap, primarily because of (1) H-(1) H scalar coupling multiplets, even at typical high magnetic fields. The recent developments in homodecoupling strategies for effectively suppressing the coupling multiplets into nice singlets (pure-shift), particularly, Morris's advanced broadband pure-shift yielded by chirp excitation (PSYCHE) decoupling and ultrahigh resolution PSYCHE-TOCSY schemes, have shown new possibilities for unambiguous structural elucidation of complex organic molecules. The superior broadband PSYCHE-TOCSY exhibits enhanced performance over the earlier TOCSY methods, which however warrants prolonged experimental times due to the requirement of large number of dwell increments along the indirect dimension. Herein, we present fast and band-selective analog of the broadband PSYCHE-TOCSY, which is useful for analyzing complex organic molecules that exhibit characteristic yet crowded spectral regions. The simple pulse scheme relies on band-selective excitation (BSE) followed by PSYCHE homodecoupling in the indirect dimension. The BSE-PSYCHE-TOCSY has been exemplified for Estradiol and a complex carbohydrate mixture comprised of six constituents of closely comparable molecular weights. The experimental times are greatly reduced viz., ~20 fold for Estradiol and ~10 fold for carbohydrate mixture, with respect to the broadband PSYCHE-TOCSY. Furthermore, unlike the earlier homonuclear band-selective decoupling, the BSE-PSYCHE-decoupling provides fully decoupled pure-shift spectra for all the individual chemical sites within the excited band. The BSE-PSYCHE-TOCSY is expected to have significant potential for quick screening of complex organic molecules and mixtures at ultrahigh resolution. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Measurement of 1H NMR relaxation times in complex organic chemical systems: application of PSYCHE

In complex organic molecules, relaxation times measured from the PSYCHE homonuclear broadband decoupling methods provide a wealth of information on intramolecular dynamics and intermolecular interactions.

A new tool for NMR analysis of complex systems: selective pure shift TOCSY

A new NMR experiment aids the identification of components in complex systems, including mixtures.

Precise Determination of Enantiomeric Excess by a Sensitivity Enhanced Two-Dimensional Band-Selective Pure-Shift NMR

Unambiguous identification and precise quantification of enantiomers in chiral mixtures is crucial for enantiomer specific synthesis as well as chemical analysis. The task is often challenging for mixtures with high enantiomeric excess and for complex molecules with strong (1)H-(1)H scalar (J) coupling network. The recent advancements in (1)H-(1)H decoupling strategies to suppress the J-interactions offered new possibilities for NMR based unambiguous discrimination and quantification enantiomers. Herein, we discuss a high resolution two-dimensional pure-shift zCOSY NMR method with homonuclear band-selective decoupling in both the F1 and F2 dimensions (F1F2-HOBS-zCOSY). This advanced method shows a sharp improvement in resolution over the other COSY methods and also eliminates the problems associated with the overlapping decoupling sidebands. The efficacy of this method has been exploited for precise quantification of enantiomeric excess (ee) ratio (R/S) up to 99:1 in the presence of very low concentrations of chiral lanthanide shift reagents (CLSR) or chiral solvating agents (CSA). The F1F2-HOBS-zCOSY is simple and can be easily implemented on any modern NMR spectrometers, as a routine analytical tool.

Broadband 1H homodecoupled NMR experiments: recent developments, methods and applications

In recent years, a great interest in the development of new broadband 1H homonuclear decoupled techniques providing simplified JHH multiplet patterns has emerged again in the field of small molecule NMR. The resulting highly resolved 1H NMR spectra display resonances as collapsed singlets, therefore minimizing signal overlap and expediting spectral analysis. This review aims at presenting the most recent advances in pure shift NMR spectroscopy, with a particular emphasis to the Zangger-Sterk experiment. A detailed discussion about the most relevant practical aspects in terms of pulse sequence design, selectivity, sensitivity, spectral resolution and performance is provided. Finally, the implementation of the different reported strategies into traditional 1D and 2D NMR experiments is described while several practical applications are also reviewed.

Pure shift NMR

Although scalar-coupling provides important structural information, the resulting signal splittings significantly reduce the resolution of NMR spectra. Limited resolution is a particular problem in proton NMR experiments, resulting in part from the limited proton chemical shift range (∼10 ppm) but even more from the splittings due to scalar coupling to nearby protons. "Pure shift" NMR spectroscopy (also known as broadband homonuclear decoupling) has been developed for disentangling overlapped proton NMR spectra. The resulting spectra are considerably simplified as they consist of single lines, reminiscent of proton-decoupled C-13 spectra at natural abundance, with no multiplet structure. The different approaches to obtaining pure shift spectra are reviewed here and several applications presented. Pure shift spectra are especially useful for highly overlapped proton spectra, as found for example in reaction mixtures, natural products and biomacromolecules.

Pushing the limits of signal resolution to make coupling measurement easier

Novel band selective decoupled pure shift selective refocusing experiments allowed simplification of the measurement of all δ¹H, and J_HH couplings with an ultrahigh spectral resolution in peptides.

Enantio-differentiation of molecules with diverse functionalities using a single probe

Chiral discrimination of molecules with diverse functionalities using a single CSA.

Measurement of T₁/T₂ relaxation times in overlapped regions from homodecoupled ¹H singlet signals

The implementation of the HOmodecoupled Band-Selective (HOBS) technique in the conventional Inversion-Recovery and CPMG-based PROJECT experiments is described. The achievement of fully homodecoupled signals allows the distinction of overlapped (1)H resonances with small chemical shift differences. It is shown that the corresponding T1 and T2 relaxation times can be individually measured from the resulting singlet lines using conventional exponential curve-fitting methods.

Real-time homonuclear broadband and band-selective decoupled pure-shift ROESY

Unambiguous spectral assignments in (1)H solution-state NMR are central, for accurate structural elucidation of complex molecules, which is often hampered by signal overlap, primarily because of scalar coupling multiplets, even at typical high magnetic fields. The recent advances in homodecoupling methods have shown powerful means of achieving high resolution pure-shift (1)H spectra in 1D and also in 2D J-correlated experiments, by effectively collapsing the multiplet structures. The present work extends these decoupling strategies to through-space correlation experiments as well and describes two new pure-shift ROESY pulse schemes with homodecoupling during acquisition, viz., homodecoupled broadband (HOBB)-ROESY and homodecoupled band-selective (HOBS)-ROESY. Furthermore, the ROESY blocks suppress the undesired interferences of TOCSY cross peaks and other offsets. Despite the reduced signal sensitivity and prolonged experimental times, the HOBB-ROESY is particularly useful for molecules that exhibit an extensive scalar coupling network spread over the entire (1)H chemical shift range, such as natural/synthetic organic molecules. On the other hand, the HOBS-ROESY is useful for molecules that exhibit well-separated chemical shift regions such as peptides (NH, Hα and side-chain protons). The HOBS-ROESY sensitivities are comparable with the conventional ROESY, thereby saves the experimental time significantly. The power of these pure-shift ROESY sequences is demonstrated for two different organic molecules, wherein complex conventional ROE cross peaks are greatly simplified with high resolution and sensitivity. The enhanced resolution allows deriving possibly more numbers of ROEs with better accuracy, thereby facilitating superior means of structural characterization of medium-size molecules.

Simultaneous 1H and 13C NMR enantiodifferentiation from highly-resolved pure shift HSQC spectra

NMR enantiodifferentiation studies are greatly improved by the simultaneous determination of accurate ¹H and ¹³C chemical shift differences, even smaller than the NMR resonance line width, obtained from the analysis of highly resolved cross-peaks in spectral aliased pure shift (SAPS) HSQC spectra.