Towards an Understanding of Li2 O2 Evolution in Li-O2 Batteries: An In Operando Synchrotron X-ray Diffraction Study

Uncovering the Electrolyte-Dependent Transport Mechanism of LiO2 in Lithium-Oxygen Batteries

Lithium-oxygen batteries (LOBs) offer extremely high theoretical energy density and are therefore strong contenders for bringing conventional batteries into the next generation. To avoid deactivation and passivation of the electrode due to the gradual covering of the surface by discharge products, electrolytes with high donor number (DN) are becoming increasingly popular in LOBs. However, the mechanism of this electrolyte-assisted discharge process remains unclear in many aspects, including the lithium superoxide (LiO₂) intermediate transportation mechanism and stability at both electrode/electrolyte interfaces and in bulk electrolytes. Here, we performed a systematic Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics (BOMD)-level investigation of the LiO₂ solvation reactions at two interfaces with high- or low-DN electrolytes (dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) or acetonitrile (CH₃CN), respectively), followed by examinations of stability and condensation once the LiO₂ monomers are solvated. Release of partial discharge product LiO₂ is found to be energetically favorable into DMSO from the Co₃O₄ cathode with a small energy barrier. However, in the presence of CH₃CN electrolyte, the release of LiO₂ from the electrode surface is found to be energetically unfavorable. Dissolved LiO₂(sol) clusters in bulk DMSO solvents are found to be more favorable to dimerize and agglomerate into a toroidal shape rather than to decompose, which avoids the emergence of strong oxidant ions (O₂^-) and preserves the system stability. This study provides two complete molecular-level pathways (solution and surface) from first-principles understanding of LOBs, offering guidance for future selection and design of electrode catalysts and solvents.

Are Operando Measurements of Rechargeable Batteries Always Reliable? An Example of Beam Effect with a Mg Battery

Operando and in situ techniques are becoming mandatory to study Li-ion, post Li-ion, and solid-state batteries. They are essential for monitoring the (electro)chemical and dynamic processes in the battery environment and for providing understanding at different spatial and temporal scales. While operando measurements are becoming more and more routine, scientists have to keep in mind that such experiments are not always harmless for the battery operation, especially when using synchrotron techniques. This is the case in the example described herein with Mg batteries. We show that the electrode reactivity in a InSb/organohaluminate electrolyte/Mg cell is strongly retarded during operando synchrotron X-ray absorption acquisition. Through comparison of ex situ, operando, and in situ data, we demonstrate that this effect occurred only on the samples' volumes exposed to the X-ray radiation. This study illustrates how incorrect conclusions might be drawn from operando measurements, especially when looking at new battery chemistries, and calls for extreme caution when designing and interpreting operando data.

Revealing the Intrinsic Atomic Structure and Chemistry of Amorphous LiO2-Containing Products in Li-O2 Batteries Using Cryogenic Electron Microscopy

Aprotic lithium-oxygen batteries (LOBs) are promising energy storage systems characterized by ultrahigh theoretical energy density. Extensive research has been devoted to this battery technology, yet the detailed operational mechanisms involved, particularly unambiguous identification of various discharge products and their specific distributions, are still unknown or are subjects of controversy. This is partly because of the intrinsic complexity of the battery chemistry but also because of the lack of atomic-level insight into the oxygen electrodes acquired via reliable techniques. In the current study, it is demonstrated that electron beam irradiation could induce crystallization of amorphous discharge products. Cryogenic conditions and a low beam dosage have to be used for reliable transmission electron microscopy (TEM) characterization. High-resolution cryo-TEM and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) analysis of toroidal discharge particles unambiguously identified the discharge products as a dominating amorphous LiO₂ phase with only a small amount of nanocrystalline Li₂O₂ islands dispersed in it. In addition, uniform mixing of carbon-containing byproducts is identified in the discharge particles with cryo-EELS, which leads to a slightly higher charging potential. The discharge products can be reversibly cycled, with no visible residue after full recharge. We believe that the amorphous superoxide dominating discharge particles can lead researchers to reconsider the chemistry of LOBs and pay special attention to exclude beam-induced artifacts in traditional TEM characterizations.

Li2 O2 Formation Electrochemistry and Its Influence on Oxygen Reduction/Evolution Reaction Kinetics in Aprotic Li-O2 Batteries

Aprotic Li-O₂ batteries are regarded as the most promising technology to resolve the energy crisis in the near future because of its high theoretical specific energy. The key electrochemistry of a nonaqueous Li-O₂ battery highly relies on the formation of Li₂ O₂ during discharge and its reversible decomposition during charge. The properties of Li₂ O₂ and its formation mechanisms are of high significance in influencing the battery performance. This review article demonstrates the latest progress in understanding the Li₂ O₂ electrochemistry and the recent advances in regulating the Li₂ O₂ growth pathway. The first part of this review elaborates the Li₂ O₂ formation mechanism and its relationship with the oxygen reduction reaction/oxygen evolution reaction electrochemistry. The following part discusses how the cycling parameters, e.g., current density and discharge depth, influence the Li₂ O₂ morphology. A comprehensive summary of recent strategies in tailoring Li₂ O₂ formation including rational design of cathode structure, certain catalyst, and surface engineering is demonstrated. The influence resulted from the electrolyte, e.g., salt, solvent, and some additives on Li₂ O₂ growth pathway, is finally discussed. Further prospects of the ways in making advanced Li-O₂ batteries by control of favorable Li₂ O₂ formation are highlighted, which are valuable for practical construction of aprotic lithium-oxygen batteries.

First-Principles Study of the Surfaces and Equilibrium Shape of Discharge Products in Li-Air Batteries

Li-air batteries are a promising alternative to Li-ion batteries as they theoretically provide the highest possible specific energy density. Mainly, Li₂O₂ (lithium peroxide) and to a lesser extent, Li₂O (lithium oxide) are assumed to be the discharge products of these batteries formed with the soluble LiO₂ (lithium superoxide) considered to be an intermediate product. Bulk Li₂O₂ is an electronic insulator, and the precipitation of this compound on the cathode is thought to be the main limiting factor in achieving high capacities in lithium-oxygen cells. For the most promising electrolytes including solvents with high donor numbers, microscopy observations frequently reveal crystallite morphologies of Li₂O₂ compounds, rather than uniform layers covering the electrode surface. The precise morphologies of Li₂O and Li₂O₂ particles, and their effect and their extent of contact with the electrode, which may all affect the capacity and rechargeability, however, remain largely undetermined. Here, we address the stability of various Li₂O and Li₂O₂ surfaces and consequently, their crystallite morphologies using density functional theory calculations and ab initio thermodynamics. In contrast to previous studies, we also consider high-index surface terminations, which exhibit surprisingly low surface energies. We carefully analyze the reasons for the stability of these high-index surfaces, which also prominently influence the equilibrium shape of the particles, at least for Li₂O₂, and discuss the consequences for the observed morphology of the reaction products.

Current Challenges and Routes Forward for Nonaqueous Lithium-Air Batteries

Nonaqueous lithium-air batteries have garnered considerable research interest over the past decade due to their extremely high theoretical energy densities and potentially low cost. Significant advances have been achieved both in the mechanistic understanding of the cell reactions and in the development of effective strategies to help realize a practical energy storage device. By drawing attention to reports published mainly within the past 8 years, this review provides an updated mechanistic picture of the lithium peroxide based cell reactions and highlights key remaining challenges, including those due to the parasitic processes occurring at the reaction product-electrolyte, product-cathode, electrolyte-cathode, and electrolyte-anode interfaces. We introduce the fundamental principles and critically evaluate the effectiveness of the different strategies that have been proposed to mitigate the various issues of this chemistry, which include the use of solid catalysts, redox mediators, solvating additives for oxygen reaction intermediates, gas separation membranes, etc. Recently established cell chemistries based on the superoxide, hydroxide, and oxide phases are also summarized and discussed.

Homogeneous nucleation of Li2O2 under Li-O2 battery discharge

The development of high-energy lithium-oxygen batteries has significantly slowed by numerous challenges including capacity limitations due to electrode surface passivation by the discharge product Li₂O₂. Since the passivation rate and intensity are dependent on the deposit morphology, herein, we focus on the mechanisms governing Li₂O₂ formation within the porous cathode. We report evidence of homogeneous nucleation of Li₂O₂ crystallites and their further assembly in bulk of the electrolyte solution in DMSO, which possesses a high donor number. After careful estimation of the superoxide ion concentration distribution within a phenomenological model, it was found that the high stability of superoxide ions formed during the ORR towards disproportionation and sufficient diffusivity of (0.5-1.2) × 10^-6 cm² s^-1 enabled Li₂O₂ nucleation and crystallization not only at the surface but also in the electrolyte, and the reaction zone spread throughout the internal space of the porous electrode. High initial supersaturation promoted the homogeneous nucleation of Li₂O₂ nanoplates, which instantly assembled into mesocrystals also in the solution bulk. These results were supported by operando SAXS/WAXS and morphology observations. Thus, although homogeneous nucleation is not dominant, it is important for achieving a high capacity in Li-O₂ batteries.

Structural and electronic properties of small lithium peroxide clusters in view of the charge process in Li-O2 batteries

The Li-O2 battery is an ideal energy storage device due to its highest theoretical energy density; however, its high charge overpotential limits its practical application. Herein, through ab initio calculations, we systematically investigated the structural and electronic properties of small (Li2O2)nm+ (n = 1, m = 0, 1 and n = 2, m = 0, 1, and 2) clusters and calculated the reaction energies of various decomposition reactions. Results show that the (Li2O2)1 monomer has a low spin, whereas the (Li2O2)2 dimer has a high spin. The analysis of bond length, molecular orbitals, and projected density of states reveals that the interaction of O-O is stronger in the cationic cluster than in the neutral one, whereas the interaction of O-Li is weaker in the cationic cluster than in the neutral one; this facilitates the decomposition of cationic lithium peroxide cluster. Furthermore, the calculated reaction energies indicate that the peroxide lithium decomposition preferentially favors two-step reaction over one-step reaction. Finally, the lowest-energy reaction pathway for the decomposition of (Li2O2)2 dimer was predicted to be (Li2O2)2 → Li2O2 → (Li2O2)+ → LiO2 → O2, and the rate-determining step was predicted to be the first step.

Direct Observation of Redox Mediator-Assisted Solution-Phase Discharging of Li-O2 Battery by Liquid-Phase Transmission Electron Microscopy

Li-O₂ battery is one of the important next-generation energy storage systems, as it can potentially offer the highest theoretical energy density among battery chemistries reported thus far. However, realization of its high discharge capacity still remains challenging and is hampered by the nature of how the discharge products are formed, causing premature passivation of the air electrode. Redox mediators are exploited to solve this problem, as they can promote the charge transfer from electrodes to the solution phase. The mechanistic understanding of the fundamental electrochemical reaction involving the redox mediators would aid in the further development of Li-O₂ batteries along with rational design of new redox mediators. Herein, we attempt to monitor the discharge reaction of a Li-O₂ battery in real time by liquid-phase transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Direct in situ TEM observation reveals the gradual growth of toroidal Li₂O₂ discharge product in the electrolyte with the redox mediator upon discharge. Moreover, quantitative analyses of the growth profiles elucidate that the growth mechanism involves two steps: dominant lateral growth of Li₂O₂ into disclike structures in the early stage followed by vertical growth with morphology transformation into a toroidal structure.

A Heavily Surface-Doped Polymer with the Bifunctional Catalytic Mechanism in Li-O2 Batteries

The application of conducting polymers (CPs) in energy storage systems is greatly limited by insufficient reversibility and stability. Here, we successfully incorporated functionalized dopants (Fe(CN)63- [FCN] and PO43- ions) in CPs matrixes to achieve a preferable electrochemical performance. A stable cation inserting/expulsing behavior of surface-doped polycarbazole (PCz) is demonstrated in our work, where doping levels and semiconductor properties of PCz are effectively controlled to adjust their redox properties and stability. With carbon nanotube (CNT) films as the substrate, the CNT/PCz:FCN composite is initially adopted as a free-standing catalytic electrode in Li-O2 cells. The molecule-level dispersed FCN dopants on the surface can work as bifunctional redox mediators on the charge-discharge process. Thus, this composite can not only achieve a low charge plateau of 3.62 V and a regular growth of capacities from 1,800 to 4,800 mAh/gCNT, but also maintain the most of charge voltages under 4.0 V for 150 cycles.

On the Stability of NaO2 in Na-O2 Batteries

Na-O₂ batteries are regarded as promising candidates for energy storage. They have higher energy efficiency, rate capability, and chemical reversibility than Li-O₂ batteries; in addition, sodium is cheaper and more abundant compared to lithium. However, inconsistent observations and instability of discharge products have inhibited the understanding of the working mechanism of this technology. In this work, we have investigated a number of factors that influence the stability of the discharge products. By means of in operando powder X-ray diffraction study, the influence of oxygen, sodium anode, salt, solvent, and carbon cathode were investigated. The Na metal anode and an ether-based solvent are the main factors that lead to the instability and decomposition of NaO₂ in the cell environment. This fundamental insight brings new information on the working mechanism of Na-O₂ batteries.

Operando structural study of non-aqueous Li–air batteries using synchrotron-based X-ray diffraction

Non-aqueous lithium–air batteries (LABs) attract attention as a candidate technology for next-generation energy storage devices. It is crucial to understand how the discharge product Li₂O₂ is formed and decomposed by the electrochemical reactions to improve the cycle performance and decrease the charge voltage, which are the most important subjects for LAB development. Here, operando X-ray diffraction with high-brilliant X-rays in a transmission mode was used to observe the intensity and structural changes of crystalline Li₂O₂ in an operating non-aqueous LAB in real time, and the Li–O₂ electrochemical reaction involving Li₂O₂ formation and decomposition was clearly demonstrated. The electrochemically formed Li₂O₂, which had an anisotropic domain size of 10 nm in the c-direction and 40–70 nm in the ab-plane, grew due to the increase of the number of domains during the discharge process. No other reaction products with a crystalline phase such as LiOH were found in either the cathode or anode of the LAB, whereas the accelerated decomposition rate of the domains was accompanied with the change of the domain shape and lattice constant of the c-axis in the latter half of the charge process with voltage higher than 4 V.

The Li–O₂ electrochemical reaction involving the formation and decomposition of crystalline Li₂O₂ was clearly demonstrated by using an operando synchrotron-based XRD in a transmission mode and a special airtight LAB cell.

Functional and stability orientation synthesis of materials and structures in aprotic Li–O2batteries

This review presents the recent advances made in the functional and stability orientation synthesis of materials/structures for Li–O₂batteries.

Operando Multi-modal Synchrotron Investigation for Structural and Chemical Evolution of Cupric Sulfide (CuS) Additive in Li-S battery

Conductive metal sulfides are promising multi-functional additives for future lithium-sulfur (Li-S) batteries. These can increase the sulfur cathode's electrical conductivity to improve the battery's power capability, as well as contribute to the overall cell-discharge capacity. This multi-functional electrode design showed initial promise; however, complicated interactions at the system level are accompanied by some detrimental side effects. The metal sulfide additives with a chemical conversion as the reaction mechanism, e.g., CuS and FeS₂, can increase the theoretical capacity of the Li-S system. However, these additives may cause undesired parasitic reactions, such as the dissolution of the additive in the electrolyte. Studying such complex reactions presents a challenge because it requires experimental methods that can track the chemical and structural evolution of the system during an electrochemical process. To address the fundamental mechanisms in these systems, we employed an operando multimodal x-ray characterization approach to study the structural and chemical evolution of the metal sulfide-utilizing powder diffraction and fluorescence imaging to resolve the former and absorption spectroscopy the latter-during lithiation and de-lithiation of a Li-S battery with CuS as the multi-functional cathode additive. The resulting elucidation of the structural and chemical evolution of the system leads to a new description of the reaction mechanism.