C3-Symmetric ligands in drug design: An overview of the challenges and opportunities ahead

C3-symmetry is a type of star-shaped molecule consisting of a central core and three symmetrically attached chains. These molecules are used in drug discovery due to their unique three-fold rotational symmetry, which allows for specific binding interactions and improved molecular recognition. In this text, we provide an overview of synthetic approaches with C3-symmetry as a pharmaceutical tool: progress, challenges, and opportunities. C3-symmetric ligands offer both challenges and opportunities in drug design. Their unique symmetry can enhance binding interactions, but careful consideration of rigidity, synthetic complexity, and target compatibility is crucial. Further research and advancements in synthetic methods and modeling tools will likely drive their exploration in drug discovery, leading to the discovery of potent C3-symmetric ligands.

Tristhiolato Pseudopeptides Bind Arsenic(III) in an AsS3 Coordination Environment Imitating Metalloid Binding Sites in Proteins

The AsIII binding of two NTA-based tripodal pseudopeptides, possessing three cysteine (ligand L1) or d-penicillamine residues (ligand L2) as potential coordinating groups for soft semimetals or metal ions, was studied by experimental (UV, CD, NMR, and ESI-MS) and theoretical (DFT) methods. All of the experimental data, obtained with the variation of the AsIII:ligand concentration ratios or pH values in some instances, evidence the exclusive formation of species with an AsS3-type coordination mode. The UV-monitored titration of the ligands with arsenous acid at pH = 7.0 provided an absorbance data set that allowed for the determination of apparent stability constants of the forming species. The obtained stabilities (logK' = 5.26 (AsL1) and logK' = 3.04 (AsL2)) reflect high affinities, especially for the sterically less restricted cysteine derivative. DFT calculated structures correlate well with the spectroscopic results and, in line with the 1H NMR data, indicate a preference for the all-endo conformers resembling the AsIII environment at the semimetal binding sites in various metalloproteins.

Chemical-Shift Standards for 199Hg NMR Spectroscopy, 25 Years Later

While 199Hg NMR is a well-established tool for elucidating details of coordination chemistry in biochemical and inorganic complexes, historically the technique has been associated with the use of an extremely toxic chemical, dimethylmercury [Me2Hg or (CH3)2Hg], as a reference standard. In the 25 years since an accidental exposure to Me2Hg led to the tragic death of Dr. Karen Wetterhahn, the community has learned a great deal about the insidious neurotoxicity of this compound as well as more appropriate ways to avoid exposure. Here, we track the general shift toward the use of alternative mercury reference standards and away from Me2Hg.

Spectroscopic and computational investigations of organometallic complexation of group 12 transition metals by methanobactins from Methylocystis sp. SB2

Methanotrophic bacteria catalyze the aerobic oxidation of methane to methanol using Cu-containing enzymes, thereby exerting a modulating influence on the global methane cycle. To facilitate the acquisition of Cu ions, some methanotrophic bacteria secrete small modified peptides known as "methanobactins," which strongly bind Cu and function as an extracellular Cu recruitment relay, analogous to siderophores and Fe. In addition to Cu, methanobactins form complexes with other late transition metals, including the Group 12 transition metals Zn, Cd, and Hg, although the interplay among solution-phase configurations, metal interactions, and the spectroscopic signatures of methanobactin-metal complexes remains ambiguous. In this study, the complexation of Zn, Cd, and Hg by methanobactin from Methylocystis sp. strain SB2 was studied using a combination of absorbance, fluorescence, extended x-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy, and time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations. We report changes in sample absorbance and fluorescence spectral dynamics, which occur on a wide range of experimental timescales and characterize a clear stoichiometric complexation dependence. Mercury L3-edge EXAFS and TD-DFT calculations suggest a linear model for HgS coordination, and TD-DFT suggests a tetrahedral model for Zn2+ and Cd2+. We observed an enhancement in the fluorescence of methanobactin upon interaction with transition metals and propose a mechanism of complexation-hindered isomerization drawing inspiration from the wild-type Green Fluorescent Protein active site. Collectively, our results represent the first combined computational and experimental spectroscopy study of methanobactins and shed new light on molecular interactions and dynamics that characterize complexes of methanobactins with Group 12 transition metals.

Mononuclear Ni(II) Complexes with a S3O Coordination Sphere Based on a Tripodal Cysteine-Rich Ligand: pH Tuning of the Superoxide Dismutase Activity

The superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity of mononuclear Ni^II complexes, whose structures are inspired by the NiSOD, has been investigated. They have been designed with a sulfur-rich pseudopeptide ligand, derived from nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA), where the three acid functions are grafted with cysteines (L^3S). Two mononuclear complexes, which exist in pH-dependent proportions, have been fully characterized by a combination of spectroscopic techniques including ¹H NMR, UV-vis, circular dichroism, and X-ray absorption spectroscopy, together with theoretical calculations. They display similar square-planar S3O coordination, with the three thiolates of the three cysteine moieties from L^3S coordinated to the Ni^II ion, together with either a water molecule at physiological pH, as [NiL^3S(OH₂)]^-, or a hydroxo ion in more basic conditions, as [NiL^3S(OH)]^2-. The ¹H NMR study has revealed that contrary to the hydroxo ligand, the bound water molecule is labile. The cyclic voltammogram of both complexes displays an irreversible one-electron oxidation process assigned to the Ni^II/Ni^III redox system with E_pa = 0.48 and 0.31 V versus SCE for NiL^3S(OH₂) and NiL^3S(OH), respectively. The SOD activity of both complexes has been tested. On the basis of the xanthine oxidase assay, an IC₅₀ of about 1 μM has been measured at pH 7.4, where NiL^3S(OH₂) is mainly present (93% of the Ni^II species), while the IC₅₀ is larger than 100 μM at pH 9.6, where NiL^3S(OH) is the major species (92% of the Ni^II species). Interestingly, only NiL^3S(OH₂) displays SOD activity, suggesting that the presence of a labile ligand is required. The SOD activity has been also evaluated under catalytic conditions at pH 7.75, where the ratio between NiL^3S(OH₂)/ NiL^3S(OH) is about (86:14), and a rate constant, k_cat = 1.8 × 10⁵ M^-1 s^-1, has been measured. NiL^3S(OH₂) is thus the first low-molecular weight, synthetic, bioinspired Ni complex that displays catalytic SOD activity in water at physiological pH, although it does not contain any N-donor ligand in its first coordination sphere, as in the NiSOD. Overall, the data show that a key structural feature is the presence of a labile ligand in the coordination sphere of the Ni^II ion.

Hg2+ and Cd2+ binding of a bioinspired hexapeptide with two cysteine units constructed as a minimalistic metal ion sensing fluorescent probe

Hg²⁺ and Cd²⁺ complexation of a short hexapeptide, Ac-DCSSCY-NH₂ (DY), was studied by pH-potentiometry, UV and NMR spectroscopy and fluorimetry in aqueous solutions and the Hg²⁺-binding ability of the ligand was also described in an immobilized form, where the peptides were anchored to a hydrophilic resin. Hg²⁺ was demonstrated to form a 1 : 1 complex with the ligand even at pH = 2.0 while Cd²⁺ coordination by the peptide takes place only above pH ∼ 3.5. Both metal ions form bis-ligand complexes by the coordination of four Cys-thiolates at ligand excess above pH ∼ 5.5 (Cd²⁺) and 7.0 (Hg²⁺). Fluorescence studies demonstrated a Hg²⁺ induced concentration-dependent quenching of the Tyr fluorescence until a 1 : 1 Hg²⁺ : DY ratio. The fluorescence emission intensity decreases linearly with the increasing Hg²⁺ concentration in a range of over two orders of magnitude. The fact that this occurs even in the presence of 1.0 eq. of Cd²⁺ per ligand reflects a complete displacement of the latter metal ion by Hg²⁺ from its peptide-bound form. The immobilized peptide was also shown to bind Hg²⁺ very efficiently even from samples at pH = 2.0. However, the existence of lower affinity binding sites was also demonstrated by binding of more than 1.0 eq. of Hg²⁺ per immobilized DY molecule under Hg²⁺-excess conditions. Experiments performed with a mixture of four metal ions, Hg²⁺, Cd²⁺, Zn²⁺ and Ni²⁺, indicate that this molecular probe may potentially be used in Hg²⁺-sensing systems under acidic conditions for the measurement of μM range concentrations.

Cytoprotective effects of imidazole-based [S1] and [S2]-donor ligands against mercury toxicity: a bioinorganic approach

Here we report the coordination behaviour of an imidazole-based [S1]-donor ligand, 1,3-dimethyl-imidazole-2(3H)-thione (L1), and [S2]-donor ligand, 3,3'-methylenebis(1-methyl-imidazole-2(3H)-thione) (L2) or 4,4'-(3,3'-methylenebis-(2-thioxo-2,3-dihydro-imidazole-3,1-diyl))dibutanoic acid (L3), with HgX2 (X = Cl, Br or I) in solution and the solid state. NMR, UV-Vis spectroscopic, and single crystal X-ray studies demonstrated that L1 or L2 coordinated rapidly and reversibly to the mercury center of HgX2 through the thione moiety. Treatment of L2 with HgCl2 or HgBr2 afforded 16-membered metallacycle k1-(L2)2Hg2Cl4 or k1-(L2)2Hg2Br4 where two Cl or Br atoms are located inside the ring. In contrast, treatment of L2 with HgI2 afforded a chain-like structure of k1-[L2Hgl2]n, possibly due to the large size of the iodine atom. Interestingly, [S1] and [S2]-donor ligands (L1, L2, and L3) showed an excellent efficacy to protect liver cells against HgCl2 induced toxicity and the strength of their efficacy is in the order of L3 > L2 > L1. 30% decrease of ROS production was observed when liver cells were co-treated with HgCl2 and L1 in comparison to those cells treated with HgCl2 only. In contrast, 45% and 60% decrease of ROS production was observed in the case of cells co-treated with HgCl2 and thiones L2 and L3, respectively, indicating that [S2]-donor ligands L2 and L3 have better cytoprotective effects against oxidative stress induced by HgCl2 than [S1]-donor ligand L1. Water-soluble ligand L3 with N-(CH2)3CO2H substituents showed a better cytoprotective effect against HgCl2 toxicity than L2 in liver cells.

Mercury Trithiolate Binding (HgS3) to a de Novo Designed Cyclic Decapeptide with Three Preoriented Cysteine Side Chains

Mercury(II) is an unphysiological soft ion with high binding affinity for thiolate ligands. Its toxicity lies in the interactions with low molecular weight thiols including glutathione and cysteine-containing proteins that disrupt the thiol balance and alter vital functions. However, mercury can also be detoxified via interactions with Hg(II)-responsive regulatory proteins such as MerR, which coordinates Hg(II) with three cysteine residues in a trigonal planar fashion (HgS₃ coordination). The model cyclodecapeptide P^3C, c(GCTCSGCSRP) was designed to promote Hg(II) chelation in a HgS₃ coordination environment through the parallel orientation of three cysteine side chains. The binding motif is derived from the dicysteine P^2C cyclodecapeptide validated previously as a model for d¹⁰ metal transporters containing the binding sequence CxxC. The formation of the mononuclear HgP^3C complex with a HgS₃ coordination is demonstrated using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, UV absorption, and ¹⁹⁹Hg NMR. Hg L_III-edge extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy indicates that the Hg(II) coordination environment is T-shaped with two short Hg-S distances at 2.45 Å and one longer distance at 2.60 Å. The solution structure of the HgP^3C complex was refined based on ¹H-¹H NMR constraints and EXAFS results. The cyclic peptide scaffold has a rectangular shape with the three binding cysteine side chains pointing toward Hg(II). The HgP^3CH complex has a p K_a of 4.3, indicating that the HgS₃ coordination mode is stable over a large range of pH. This low p K_a value suggests that the preorientation of the three cysteine groups is particularly well-achieved for Hg(II) trithiolate coordination in P^3C.

Short oligopeptides with three cysteine residues as models of sulphur-rich Cu(i)- and Hg(ii)-binding sites in proteins

Peptides mimicking sulphur-rich fragments found in metallothioneins display unexpectedly different behaviours with the two metal ions Hg(ii) and Cu(i).

A Trishistidine Pseudopeptide with Ability to Remove Both CuΙ and CuΙΙ from the Amyloid-β Peptide and to Stop the Associated ROS Formation

The pseudopeptide L, derived from a nitrilotriacetic acid scaffold and functionalized with three histidine moieties, is reminiscent of the amino acid side chains encountered in the Alzheimer's peptide (Aβ). Its synthesis and coordination properties for CuΙ and CuΙΙ are described. L efficiently complex CuΙΙ in a square-planar geometry involving three imidazole nitrogen atoms and an amidate-Cu bond. By contrast, CuΙ is coordinated in a tetrahedral environment. The redox behavior is irreversible and follows an ECEC mechanism in accordance with the very different environments of the two redox states of the Cu center. This is in line with the observed resistance of the CuΙ complex to oxidation by oxygen and the CuΙΙ complex reduction by ascorbate. The affinities of L for CuΙΙ and CuΙ at physiological pH are larger than that reported for the Aβ peptide. Therefore, due to its peculiar Cu coordination properties, the ligand L is able to target both redox states of Cu, redox silence them and prevent reactive oxygen species production by the CuAβ complex. Because reactive oxygen species contribute to the oxidative stress, a key issue in Alzheimer's disease, this ligand thus represents a new strategy in the long route of finding molecular concepts for fighting Alzheimer's disease.

Cyclic Phosphopeptides to Rationalize the Role of Phosphoamino Acids in Uranyl Binding to Biological Targets

The specific molecular interactions responsible for uranium toxicity are not yet understood. The uranyl binding sites in high-affinity target proteins have not been identified yet and the involvement of phosphoamino acids is still an important question. Short cyclic peptide sequences, with three glutamic acids and one phosphoamino acid, are used as simple models to mimic metal binding sites in phosphoproteins and to help understand the mechanisms involved in uranium toxicity. A combination of peptide design and synthesis, analytical chemistry, extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy, and DFT calculations demonstrates the involvement of the phosphate group in the uranyl coordination sphere together with the three carboxylates of the glutamate moieties. The affinity constants measured with a reliable analytical competitive approach at physiological pH are significantly enhanced owing to the presence of the phosphorous moiety. These findings corroborate the importance of phosphoamino acids in uranyl binding in proteins and the relevance of considering phosphoproteins as potential uranyl targets in vivo.

Formation of Mercury Sulfide from Hg(II)-Thiolate Complexes in Natural Organic Matter

Methylmercury is the environmental form of neurotoxic mercury that is biomagnified in the food chain. Methylation rates are reduced when the metal is sequestered in crystalline mercury sulfides or bound to thiol groups in macromolecular natural organic matter. Mercury sulfide minerals are known to nucleate in anoxic zones, by reaction of the thiol-bound mercury with biogenic sulfide, but not in oxic environments. We present experimental evidence that mercury sulfide forms from thiol-bound mercury alone in aqueous dark systems in contact with air. The maximum amount of nanoparticulate mercury sulfide relative to thiol-bound mercury obtained by reacting dissolved mercury and soil organic matter matches that detected in the organic horizon of a contaminated soil situated downstream from Oak Ridge, TN, in the United States. The nearly identical ratios of the two forms of mercury in field and experimental systems suggest a common reaction mechanism for nucleating the mineral. We identified a chemical reaction mechanism that is thermodynamically favorable in which thiol-bound mercury polymerizes to mercury-sulfur clusters. The clusters form by elimination of sulfur from the thiol complexes via breaking of mercury-sulfur bonds as in an alkylation reaction. Addition of sulfide is not required. This nucleation mechanism provides one explanation for how mercury may be immobilized, and eventually sequestered, in oxygenated surface environments.

Zn(II) and Hg(II) binding to a designed peptide that accommodates different coordination geometries

Designed metal ion binding peptides offer a variety of applications in both basic science as model systems of more complex metalloproteins, and in biotechnology, e.g. in bioremediation of toxic metal ions, biomining or as artificial enzymes. In this work a peptide (HS: Ac-SCHGDQGSDCSI-NH2) has been specifically designed for binding of both Zn(II) and Hg(II), i.e. metal ions with different preferences in terms of coordination number, coordination geometry, and to some extent ligand composition. It is demonstrated that HS accommodates both metal ions, and the first coordination sphere, metal ion exchange between peptides, and speciation are characterized as a function of pH using UV-absorption-, synchrotron radiation CD-, (1)H-NMR-, and PAC-spectroscopy as well as potentiometry. Hg(II) binds to the peptide with very high affinity in a {HgS2} coordination geometry, bringing together the two cysteinates close to each end of the peptide in a loop structure. Despite the high affinity, Hg(II) is kinetically labile, exchanging between peptides on the subsecond timescale, as indicated by line broadening in (1)H-NMR. The Zn(II)-HS system displays more complex speciation, involving monomeric species with coordinating cysteinates, histidine, and a solvent water molecule, as well as HS-Zn(II)-HS complexes. In summary, the HS peptide displays conformational flexibility, contains many typical metal ion binding groups, and is able to accommodate metal ions with different structural and ligand preferences with high affinity. As such, the HS peptide may be a scaffold offering binding of a variety of metal ions, and potentially serve for metal ion sequestration in biotechnological applications.