A critical assessment of the fibula flap donor site

Bland-Altman analysis of maxillary obturator bulb accuracy in class III Brown classification maxillectomy defects

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Maxillofacial tumor resection leads to major functional and esthetic issues that adversely affect patients' quality of life. Obturators have been used to manage issues such as hypernasality and fluid leakage. However, their adaptation to maxillary defects and patient comfort requires further study. Understanding how material composition influences obturator retention, durability, and long-term satisfaction is essential for optimizing prosthetic design.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this nonrandomized, self-controlled study was to compare the accuracy and patient satisfaction of polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) bulbs on metal frameworks and flexible injection-molded resin bulbs.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Two obturator types were evaluated. Type PMMA-BMF used PMMA bulbs on metal frameworks, while Type FIMR used flexible injection-molded resin bulbs. Adaptation was assessed using 3-dimensional (3D) scanning and superimposition techniques, with root mean square (RMS) values and average positive and negative deviations as key metrics using the Bland-Altman analysis of agreement with bias ±standard deviation calculated and plotted (95% limits of agreement). Patient satisfaction was evaluated using the obturator functioning scale (OFS) domains.

RESULTS

Type PMMA-BMF obturators showed significantly higher RMS and average positive and negative deviations than Type FIMR (P<.001), indicating a less precise fit. The Bland-Atman analysis demonstrated strong agreement between the 2 material types. The limits of agreement were narrower for nondefect sites (0.93), suggesting stronger agreement in these areas than between defect sites (2.55) and obturator bulbs (4.84). Type FIMR showed better statistically significant OFS scores regarding all domains and overall than Type PMMA-BMF (P<.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Type FIMR obturator offers better fit, stability, and patient satisfaction than Type PMMA-BMF. It also improves speech, mastication, and esthetics, highlighting its potential benefits. Further research should address issues such as improving patient outcomes.

Fate of the Flexor Hallucis Longus Muscle at the Donor Site After Fibula Flap Harvest: Assessing Muscle Viability Using Novel MRI Techniques - A Cohort Study

BACKGROUND

Fibula flap dissection sacrifices the blood vessels to the flexor hallucis longus (FHL) and other calf muscles. This novel MRI study investigates perfusion and fibrosis of the FHL muscle after fibula flap harvest.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A cohort study from September 2018 to January 2021, we prospectively recruited head and neck cancer patients who were planned to receive fibula flap transfer for jaw reconstruction. All participants received MRI before and one year after the operation. Muscle fibrosis was quantified via extracellular volume matrix fraction (ECV); muscle perfusion via time to peak (TTP), T2* change, and T2* slope by BOLD sequence. Muscle fibrosis and perfusion were compared before and after the operation.

RESULTS

Total of 18 patients completed the study (mean age: 48.83 years). Significantly increased fibrosis was seen in the postoperative FHL muscle via elevated ECV (11.23%-32.54%, p < 0.001). Despite prolonged TTP in postoperative FHL (38.17-51.83 s, p = 0.343), increased T2* change (8.43%-9.53%, p = 0.369), and increased T2* slope (0.22%-0.23%/s, p = 0.766), these muscle perfusion changes were not statistically significant. Postoperative complications, such as great toe clawing and donor site infection, were not observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite severe fibrosis within the FHL muscle after extensive dissection during fibula harvest and peroneal arterial ligation, the FHL muscle perfusion could be retained from an MRI perspective.

Assessing Donor Site Morbidity and Impact on Quality of Life in Free Flap Microsurgery: An Overview

Donor site morbidity remains a significant concern in free flap microsurgery, with implications that extend beyond immediate postoperative outcomes to affect patients' long-term quality of life. This review explores the multi-faceted impact of donor site morbidity on physical, psychological, social, and occupational well-being, synthesizing findings from the existing literature. Particular attention is given to the functional limitations, sensory deficits, aesthetic outcomes, and chronic pain associated with commonly utilized free flaps. Advancements in surgical techniques, including nerve-sparing and muscle-sparing methods, as well as innovations, like perforator flaps, have demonstrated the potential to mitigate these morbidities. Furthermore, the integration of regenerative medicine strategies, such as stem cell therapy and fat grafting, and technological innovations, including virtual reality rehabilitation and biofeedback devices, has shown promise in enhancing recovery and minimizing long-term complications. Despite these advances, challenges persist in standardizing QoL assessments and optimizing donor site management. This review emphasizes the need for a holistic, patient-centered approach in reconstructive microsurgery, advocating for further research to refine current strategies, improve long-term outcomes, and develop robust tools for QoL evaluation. By addressing these gaps, reconstructive surgeons can better align surgical objectives with the comprehensive well-being of their patients.

A comparative analysis of free fibula flap donor leg and recipient vessel selection in composite oromandibular defect reconstructions

BACKGROUND

The free fibula flap (FFF) is acknowledged as the primary choice for reconstructing composite oromandibular defects (COMDs), yet the impact of donor leg selection remains inadequately explored. This study aims to investigate the correlation between flap failure and the choice of donor leg and recipient vessel side.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In a retrospective analysis spanning 2011 to 2020, FFFs for COMD were examined using electronic records. Patient data, comorbidities, radiation history, FFF details, and intraoperative variables were considered. Laterality was categorized into "Cis" and "Trans" groups, further subclassified based on blood supply. Analyses involved logistic regression, bivariate analysis, and propensity score matching.

RESULTS

A total of 155 subjects with intraoral mucosal defects repaired only by the skin paddle of FFF were included. Cases were categorized into "Cis" (n = 65; 42%) and "Trans" (n = 90; 58%) groups based on COMD side and donor leg selection. No significant baseline differences emerged. Logistic regression found no laterality impact on total FFF failure. Initially, gender correlated with flap failure, but adjustment diminished the association. Partial skin paddle necrosis correlated with diabetes, not laterality. Propensity score matching revealed no significant differences between right and left legs in laterality or total flap failure risk. Subgroup analysis found no differences in parameters or flap failure rates within "Cis" and "Trans" groups.

CONCLUSION

Donor leg selection in COMD reconstruction with FFFs does not exhibit specificity. Furthermore, despite potential limitations in vessel anastomosis due to pedicle length or trauma history, recipient vessel side selection does not evidently affect flap failure.

Free vascularized fibula leads to hallux toe flexion deformity due to ischemic muscle contracture of flexor hallucis longus

BACKGROUND

This study aimed to investigate the incidence of toe flexion deformity after fibular free flap transplantation and to analyze the etiology of the deformity.

METHODS

Fifty patients underwent vascularized fibular free flap transplantation were retrospectively included. Statistical analysis examined correlations between deformity occurrence and resected fibula length and residual distal fibula length using the χ2 test. Doppler ultrasound and anatomical evaluations were conducted.

RESULTS

Flexion deformity of the first toe was observed in all patients (100%), exacerbated by ankle dorsiflexion. χ2 test revealed no significant correlation between fibula length, distal residual fibula length, and flexion deformity. Doppler ultrasound revealed elevated echoes and blurred textures in the flexor hallucis longus post-fibular transplantation, while anatomical evaluation confirmed the peroneal artery as its primary nutrient supplier.

CONCLUSION

This study reports a 100% incidence of toe flexion deformity post-transplantation. The deformity correlated strongly with ischemic contracture of the flexor hallucis longus.

Planning of physiotherapeutic procedure in patients after mandible reconstruction taking into account donor site: a literature review

BACKGROUND

Mandible tumors are very rare. One of the main methods of the treatments is resection of the tumor and then reconstruction of the mandible. The donor site is often distant tissue-fibula or ilium. Following this, it is necessary to improve the patient in two ways, on one hand restoring the function of the mandible, and on the other hand, improving the donor site area. For that reason, physiotherapy after tumor resection and reconstruction of the mandible is very complicated. The aim of this bibliographic review was to find the methods of the reconstruction of the mandible in the context of patients' functional assessment after surgeries to create effective physiotherapeutic procedures in the feature.

METHODS

PEDro, Medline (PubMed), Cochrane Clinical Trials were searched.

RESULTS

767 articles were found. 40 articles were included to this literature review.

CONCLUSIONS

Authors showed different kinds of surgeries strategy for patients with tumors of the mandible. They also showed manners of patients' functional assessment in the localization of transplantation and donor site. It could be useful for physiotherapists during planning of comprehensive physiotherapy.

An objective analysis of composite free flap donor site morbidity in head and neck surgery: Prospective series

BACKGROUND

A poor evidence basis exists regarding the objective donor site morbidity associated with osseous free flap harvest. This study prospectively assessed the objective donor site morbidity associated with osseous free flap harvest for the fibula, scapula, and iliac crest (DCIA) donor sites.

METHODS

A single-site, prospective cohort clinical research study was conducted. Sixty-four patients were recruited between 2017 and 2021. Patients were assessed using a donor site specific assessment tool pre-operatively, and again >12 months post-operatively.

RESULTS

There was a significant reduction post-operatively in assessment tool scores compared to the pre-operative period for the fibula, scapula and DCIA. Females were more likely to report a greater reduction in Harris Hip Score post-operatively compared to males.

CONCLUSIONS

The fibula, scapula, and DCIA donor sites are associated with reduced objective function post-operatively compared to patient's pre-operative baseline. The implications are least pronounced for the fibula.

Analysis of related factors of long-term complications after vascularized fibular transplantation

OBJECTIVES

Free fibula flap is the first choice for jaw reconstruction in head and neck oncology, but postoperative complications in donor site are ignored always. The main purpose of this study was to investigate the long-term complications and potential risk factors of donor site after vascularized fibular transplantation, and to explore the precautions of preparing vascularized fibular flap and the measures of preventing donor site complications.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Data were retrospectively collected on 31 patients who had undergone immediate mandibular reconstruction with a fibular flap after segmental mandibulectomy from 2013 to 2018 in Shanghai Ninth People's Hospital. Thirty-one patients (24 male, 7 female) were available for the long-term complications in donor site analysis from 25 to 96 months after surgery. The data were collected and analyzed, including age at time of operation, early postoperative complications, incidence of dorsiflexion weakness of hallux, donor site missing fibula length, proximal and distal stump fibula length, and subjective evaluation of foot function (AOFAS-hallux, AOFAS-ankle hindfoot, Enneking lower limb function score). In the single-factor analysis in this study, the correlation between related factors and long-term complications was statistically analyzed. For inter-group comparisons of quantitative data, if the normal distribution was satisfied, two independent sample t-tests were used; p < 0.05 was statistical significant. If the normal distribution was not satisfied, Wilcoxon rank-sum test was used, and p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. For qualitative data, the Fisher exact probability method was compared between group differences, and p < 0.05 was statistically significant.

RESULTS

The most commonly encountered complication in our series was dorsiflexion disorder, flexion deformity, numbness of the lateral side of the lower leg, and dorsum of the foot. Ten patients (32.26%) developed hallux flexion deformity after operation, 17 patients (54.84%) had hallux dorsiflexion dysfunction after operation, and 10 patients (32.26%) had numbness of the lateral side of the lower leg and dorsum of the foot. The incidence of hallux dorsiflexion dysfunction, thumb flexion deformity, and sensory disturbance was higher than that of other long-term complications in the donor area. The residual length of fibular distal was related to the dorsiflexion dysfunction and flexion deformity of hallux (p < 0.05). The early complications of donor site were correlated with the hallux dorsiflexion dysfunction (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of dorsiflexion disorder and flexion deformity is higher in patients after fibula transplantation. The less the residual length of fibular distal, the more obvious the long-term complications in the donor site, and the higher the incidence of dorsiflexion dysfunction and flexion deformity of hallux.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The long-term complications of donor site after fibular transplantation seriously affect the quality of life of patients and provide clinical reference for further reducing the occurrence of donor site complications.

Patient-Reported Outcomes after Fibula Free Flap Harvest: A Pilot Study

SUMMARY

Patient-reported outcomes regarding donor-site morbidity and quality of life for the fibula free flap in head and neck reconstruction patients have not been studied. The authors reviewed and identified patients who had undergone head and neck reconstruction using a fibula free flap (2011 to 2016). Patients were assessed via physical examination and two patient-reported outcomes questionnaires: the Foot and Ankle Outcome Score (score range, 0 to 100) and the Pain Disability Questionnaire (score range, 0 to 100). Quantitative data were analyzed with appropriate statistical tests. Semistructured interviews exploring donor-site challenges were performed and analyzed using thematic analysis. Seventeen patients agreed to participate. Their mean age was 62 years (range, 41 to 81 years). Mean follow-up was 38 months (range, 12 to 65 years). Mean perceived level of function compared to baseline was 67 percent. Mean scores for the Foot and Ankle Outcome Score subscales were 84.6 (pain), 80.5 (symptoms), 86.7 (activities of daily living), 67.7 (sport), and 65.6 (quality of life). The mean Pain Disability Questionnaire score was 26.3 (mild/moderate perceived disability). Higher perceived level of function was associated with higher Foot and Ankle Outcome Score values (pain, symptoms, and activities of daily living, p < 0.05). Donor limbs had decreased range of motion and manual muscle testing scores compared with their contralateral limbs (p < 0.05). Lack of ankle support and balance, resulting in limitations and aversions to daily and sporting activities, were the most common themes regarding donor-site challenges. In conclusion, patients who have undergone fibula free flap harvest struggle with ankle support and balance and face functional difficulties that have an impact on their quality of life. Multidisciplinary approaches for targeted rehabilitation after fibula free flap harvest should be explored to determine the impact on patients' quality of life.

Donor- and recipient-site morbidity of vascularized fibular and iliac flaps for mandibular reconstruction: A systematic review and meta-analysis

The aim of this article is to evaluate the early and late morbidities of the donor- and recipient-site in patients undergoing mandibular reconstruction using either vascularized fibular flap (VFF) or vascularized iliac flap (VIF). Electronic databases, including PubMed, Web of Science, Cochrane Central and Embase, were explored for literature published until October 2020. A total of twenty-four articles reporting complications following mandibular reconstruction surgery with follow-up periods ranging from six to 63 months were selected based on the exclusion criteria. For each research, the JBI Critical Assessment Tool and the ROBINS-I Tool were used to analyze the methodological quality and the risk of bias. A single-arm meta-analysis was performed to have a synthesized analysis of the donor- and recipient-site early and late morbidities. Results showed that the early morbidities in VFF group ranged from 3% to 12%, and the late morbidities in VFF group ranged from 5% to 67%. In VIF group, the early morbidities ranged from 3% to 16%, and the donor-site late morbidities ranged from 6% to 43%. Complications with the top three morbidities in the VFF group were: chronic sensory disturbances at the donor-site (67%), malocclusion (22%) and chronic lower limb weakness (20%); and in the VIF group were: chronic sensory disturbances at the donor-site (43%), chronic pain at the donor-site (26%), chronic gait disturbance (20%). Further controlled clinical trials are needed to assess the long-term outcome of VFF or VIF grafting.

Donor site morbidity of composite free flaps in head and neck surgery: a systematic review of the prospective literature

Composite free flaps represent the cornerstone for the repair of osseous defects in the head and neck. For many patients, there are often multiple defect-suitable donor sites that may be utilised as part of the reconstructive process. Therefore, to optimise patient outcomes, an evidence-based approach to donor site selection is required to maximise quality of life and long-term functionality. A systematic review of the literature was conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidelines to evaluate the evidence for donor site selection based on minimising the associated donor site morbidity and optimising patient functionality postoperative. The fibula is associated with the greatest potential risk for wound healing complications. Fibula and scapula harvest has the potential to have a significant impact on physical performance. The iliac crest is most favourable in terms of aesthetic scar healing outcomes. Overall, however, the quality and quantity of evidence for all donor sites is limited. Each site is associated with specific complications and morbidity, of which the surgeon and patient must both be aware. Whilst a cross-sectional informed opinion of the likely advantages/disadvantages of one donor site over another can thus be made, there are few head-to-head studies available that directly compare donor sites.

Assessment of fibula flap with flexor hallucis longus's effect on head & neck tumor patients' quality of life and function of donor site

OBJECTIVE

Free fibular flaps (FFFs) have been widely used in mandibular reconstruction. It is still unclear whether retaining flexor hallucis longus (FHL) is needed for flaps. This study introduces a comparison in quality of life and donor-site function between those who have and haven't harvested FHL with FFF.

METHODS

Patients with FFFs were single-blind-randomly assigned into the FHL group or nFHL group. Patients were followed up preoperatively and 1, 3 and 6 months postoperatively via subjective evaluations (SF-36/AOFAS) and objective evaluation s(muscle strength and range of motion). Patients' hospitalization and intraoperative information, donor site morbidity were recorded.

RESULTS

Each group had 15 patients. The flap harvesting time in FHL group was shorter significantly than nFHL group (125.9 ± 24.8 min vs 146.7 ± 29.9 min, P = 0.048). There were no significant differences in hospitalization information such as operation time, hospitalization days and cost. Donor site morbidities at 1, 3 and 6 months postoperatively showed no significant differences except for the presence of claw toes (nFHL group > FHL group, 40% vs 0, P = 0.017; 53.3% vs 6.7%, P = 0.014; 60.0% vs 13.3%, P = 0.021). There were no significant differences in SF-36 and AOFAS scores. There were no significant differences in muscle strength and range of motion.

CONCLUSION

Excision of the FHL lowered the flap harvesting time. It did not increase donor site morbidity. The impacts on patients' quality of life and foot function were the same. The surgeons can use the FHL without considering the influence on patients if not retaining the FHL.

Impact of wound closure on fibular donor-site morbidity: a meta-analysis

Background

Vascularized free fibular flaps have been the “workhorses” for reconstruction of many kinds of bone defects. Nevertheless, there is no consensus regarding the optimal wound closure method for fibular donor sites. This study aimed to compare prognostic outcomes of primarily closures (PC) and skin grafts (SG) for fibular donor sites.

Methods

Studies regarding donor-site outcomes of PC versus SG in patients undergoing free fibular flap procedures were included. Two authors individually searched PubMed, Web of Science, EMBASE, Cochrane Library and clinicaltrials.gov up to February 2019, extracted the data and assessed quality of each selected article. Ultimately, The incidences of donor-site morbidities were evaluated.

Results

Five studies with a total of 119 patients were included in our analysis. No significant differences were found with respect to the rates of donor-site problems between the PC and SG groups.

Conclusions

Fibular flap patients undergoing PC and SG wound closures may have similar donor-site outcomes. Additional large-scale studies are necessary to draw a solid conclusion.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12893-019-0545-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

The application of fibular free flap with flexor hallucis longus in maxilla or mandible extensive defect: a comparison study with conventional flap

Background

The repair and reconstruction of maxillary and mandibular extensive defects have put huge challenges to surgeons. The fibular free flap (FFF) is one of the standard treatment choices for reconstruction. The conventional FFF has deficiencies, such as forming poor oral mucosa, limited flap tissue, and perforator vessel variation. To improve the use of FFF, we add the flexor hallucis longus (FHL) in the flap (FHL-FFF). In this paper, we described the advantage and indication of FHL-FFF and conducted a retrospective study to compare FHL-FFF and FFF without FHL.

Methods

Fifty-four patients who underwent FFF were enrolled and divided into two groups: nFHL group (using FFF without FHL, 38 patients) and FHL group (using FHL-FFF, 16 patients). The perioperative clinical data of patients was collected and analyzed.

Results

The flaps all survived in two groups. We mainly used FHL to fill dead space, and the donor-site morbidity was slight. In FHL group, flap harvesting time was shorter (118.63 ± 11.76 vs 125.74 ± 11.33 min, P = 0.042), the size of flap’s skin paddle was smaller (16.5 (0–96) vs 21.0(10–104) cm², P = 0.027) than nFHL group. There were no significant differences (P > 0.05) in hospital days, hospitalization expense, rate of perioperative complications, etc. between the two groups. Compared with FFF without FHL, FHL-FFF will neither affect the use of flap nor bring more problems.

Conclusion

The FHL-FFF simplifies the flap harvesting operation. The FHL can form good mucosa and make FFF rely less on skin paddle. It can be used for adding flap tissue and dealing with perforator vessel variation in reconstruction of maxillary and mandibular extensive defects.

Evaluation of donor site morbidity after medial triceps brachii free flap for lower limb reconstruction

INTRODUCTION

The medial head of the triceps brachii muscle (MTB)-free flap is an attractive solution to cover small-to-medium defects of the lower limb. This muscular head has no well-identified function, suggesting minimal impact of its removal on elbow mobility. The aim of this study was to evaluate the safety and reliability of the harvest procedure and the functional and cosmetic morbidity of this donor site.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-four consecutive MTB-free flaps were performed for reconstructive surgery of the lower limb between 2011 and 2015. Patients and their records were retrospectively examined. Functional results were evaluated by assessing elbow extension strength using a dynamometer and with a QuickDASH questionnaire. Cosmetic results were assessed using the POSAS observer and patient scales.

RESULTS

Twenty-four patients were followed up postoperatively for an average of 33.9 [min 12-max 59] months. No major complication (in particular, no ulnar or radial nerve injury) occurred during harvest. No patient complained of elbow pain or reduction in strength. Elbow extension was complete in all patients and the mean strength was calculated at 89 [61.1-112.5] % of the opposite arm. The POSAS scale scored an average 8.6 [7-21] for the observer and 10 [7-26] for the patient. Cosmetic results using the POSAS scale were satisfactory in all patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Objective evaluation of patients who underwent an MTB-free flap for limb reconstruction shows no impact of the harvesting procedure on elbow extension. Patient satisfaction with the donor site was high. From this retrospective study, it appears that this surgery is safe, aesthetically acceptable, and has minimal impact on donor site elbow function.

Functional donor site morbidity longer than one year after fibula free flap: A prospective biomechanical analysis

OBJECTIVES

The fibula free flap is the workhorse procedure for osseous reconstruction. The objective of this study was to investigate long-term functional outcomes of the harvesting site.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

About 19 patients (10 male, 9 female, mean age 58.1 years) were available for the long-term analysis 13-51 months after surgery. Jumping mechanography and balance testing on a ground force reaction plate (Leonardo Mechanograph GFRP) were performed before and surgery. The Esslinger Fitness Index (EFI, maximum peak power in W/kg normalized for age and gender) was considered as primary endpoint. Secondary outcomes were maximum force, range of motion in the ankle joint, sensory limitations, the American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society Score (AOFAS-Score), and subjective perceptions.

RESULTS

We found no significant difference between pre- and postoperative EFI (70.4% versus 66.0%, P = 0.07) and body sway (1.72 cm² versus 2.60 cm² , P = 0.093). The AOFAS-Score was reduced by 8.8 points (99.1 points versus 90.3 points, P < 0.001). Dorsal extenstion (31.6° versus 24.1°, P < 0.001) and flexion (32.3 versus 25.6° flexion, P = 0.011) were significantly reduced and 6 patients had chronic pain.

CONCLUSIONS

Reduced peak power and balance ability seem to be reversible short-term effects after fibula harvesting. We recommend preoperative patient education and standardized protocols for physiotherapy.