Is intrapulmonary arteriovenous shunting and hypoxemia a contraindication for liver transplantation?

The Importance of Predicting the Prognosis in Patients With Hepatopulmonary Syndrome: A Simple Scoring System

Hepatopulmonary syndrome (HPS) is a pulmonary vascular disorder, complicating hepatic diseases, and is responsible for an increased morbidity and mortality among patients awaiting liver transplantation. Nowadays, it is recognized as an independent risk factor for death in this patient population. The severity of hypoxemia and the advanced stage of the liver dysfunction are determinants for the prognosis. Therefore, the possibility to be successful, thus improving survival, consists of addressing HPS at an earlier stage, giving more attention to moderate evidences of this pathology instead of the severe ones. On the basis of scientific evidence, we suggest a simple scoring system to predict prognosis among patients with HPS, founded on the integration of two main factors: the severity of hepatic disease, expressed as class of Child-Pugh, and the severity of the hypoxemia. This model of prognostic evaluation has the objective of estimating the additional risk of these patients, thereby avoiding a deleterious underestimate of risk and an arbitrariness of management.

Hepatopulmonary syndrome: the paradigm of liver-induced hypoxaemia

The current chapter deals with the concept, clinical manifestations and diagnostic tools of the hepatopulmonary syndrome (HPS) and highlights its most salient pathophysiological, mechanistic and therapeutic aspects. Defined as a clinical triad, including a chronic liver disorder, pulmonary gas exchange abnormalities and generalized pulmonary vascular dilatations, in the absence of intrinsic cardiopulmonary disease, this entity is currently growing in interest with both clinicians and surgeons. The combination of arterial hypoxaemia, high cardiac output with normal or low pulmonary artery pressure, and finger clubbing in a patient with advanced liver disease should strongly suggest the diagnosis of HPS. Its potential high prevalence together with failure of numerous therapeutic approaches depicts a life-threatening unique clinical condition that may dramatically benefit with an elective indication of liver transplantation (LT). A better orchestration of the concepts of the pathophysiology of this lung-liver interplay may foster our knowledge and improve the clinical management and indications of LT.

The hepatopulmonary syndrome: new name, old complexities

On the basis of previous work, our own experience and findings, and the considerations discussed above, we propose a set of four diagnostic criteria for the hepatopulmonary syndrome: 1. presence of chronic hepatic disease (alcoholic, postnecrotic, or primary biliary cirrhosis or active chronic hepatitis)--severe liver dysfunction may not be mandatory; 2. absence of intrinsic cardiopulmonary disease, with normal chest radiograph or with nodular basal shadowing; 3. pulmonary gas exchange abnormalities--an increased alveolar-arterial oxygen gradient (> or = 2.0 kPa) with or without hypoxaemia; 4. the extrapulmonary appearance of intravenous radiolabelled microspheres or a positive contrast enhanced echocardiogram, suggesting intrapulmonary vascular abnormalities. Although these four criteria appear straightforward, there may be other features that are not always present--namely: 1. low transfer factor (diffusing capacity); 2. shortness of breath, with or without platypnoea and orthodeoxia; 3. increased cardiac output and reduced pulmonary vascular pressures; 4. small (or no) increase in pulmonary vascular resistance when the patient is breathing low oxygen mixtures. From the physiological viewpoint, the hepatopulmonary syndrome provides an excellent model for clinical research in the pathophysiology of pulmonary gas exchange. So far it has been possible to show that arterial hypoxaemia in this condition is (1) partitioned into components resulting from VA/Q mismatching, intrapulmonary shunt, and limitations of oxygen diffusion; (2) modulated by the interplay between the intrapulmonary and the extrapulmonary determinants of PaO2, such as cardiac output and minute ventilation; (3) vulnerable to the influence of inadequate pulmonary vascular tone; and (4) resolved when the injured liver is replaced and hepatic function is restored to within normal limits.