Radiotherapy as salvage treatment in patients with Hodgkin's disease or non-Hodgkin's lymphoma relapsing after initial chemotherapy

Evolving role of radiation therapy for hematologic malignancies

Radiation therapy continues to play a paramount role in the therapy of hematologic malignancies, whether as definitive therapy, as consolidation after chemotherapy, as part of bone marrow transplantation protocols, or in palliation. During the past 2 decades, significant advances in radiation therapy have occurred, including the evolution of involved-field irradiation and the adoption of conformal radiation administration. It is hoped that modern techniques will reduce the long-term sequelae associated with radiation-based treatments.

Optimal scheduling to reduce morbidity of involved field radiotherapy with transplantation for lymphomas: A Prospective Australasian Leukaemia and Lymphoma Group Study

This study evaluated delivery of involved field radiotherapy (IFRT) with transplantation for lymphomas timed to minimise toxicity. Patients transplanted for lymphoma had infradiaphragmatic disease irradiated pre-transplant and supradiaphragmatic disease post transplant. A total of 31 patients were studied, with a median follow-up duration of 4 years. Transplant conditioning was according to clinician preference. In all, 14 patients had pre-transplant abdominopelvic IFRT and 19 had post transplant IFRT (including three who had pre-transplant IFRT). Grade III-IV haematological toxicity from pre-transplant IFRT occurred in three patients and from post transplant IFRT in 10 patients. Pre-transplant IFRT had no effect on haematological recovery post transplant, but was associated with a trend towards increased gastrointestinal toxicity (P = 0.094). Pneumonitis due to post transplant thoracic IFRT occurred in one patient. Two patients failed in involved sites after completion of protocol radiotherapy. One case of myelodysplasia has been reported. As sequenced in this study, IFRT was feasible and produced a low incidence of severe pulmonary and haematological toxicities. Patient selection, field size and radiotherapy dose warrant further study.

Salvage central lymphatic irradiation in follicular lymphomas following failure of chemotherapy: a feasibility study

PURPOSE

Management of follicular lymphoma after chemotherapy failure has been controversial and has ranged from watchful waiting to high-dose chemotherapy. High-dose chemotherapy with bone marrow reconstitution may produce clinical and molecular complete responses at the risk of serious morbidity and mortality. It has been previously reported that central lymphatic irradiation (CLI) can achieve long-term relapse-free survival in patients with Stage I, II, or III follicular lymphoma. Therefore, we investigated the feasibility of treating patients in whom front-line chemotherapy failed with salvage CLI instead of instituting more intensive chemotherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Salvage CLI with curative intent for patients with follicular lymphoma was started at The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center in 1992. Eleven patients whose disease showed poor response to or relapsed after chemotherapy were managed with this approach. The median age of the patients was 61 years. Criteria for exclusion included bone marrow involvement or other evidence of Ann Arbor Stage IV disease at any time during the course of the disease. Overall survival and relapse-free survival were calculated from the first day of CLI.

RESULTS

Ten patients were alive at a median follow-up of 25 months (range 9-73 months). The treatment was well tolerated in general. Two patients could not complete CLI: one 75-year-old patient owing to prolonged platelet count depression and deterioration in general medical condition, and a 66-year-old patient because of exacerbation of preexisting pancytopenia and worsening of heart disease. Everyone who completed CLI remains in remission at the time of this report, except for one patient who had a relapse in the right lacrimal gland at 32 months. This patient was treated with local radiation therapy and is free of disease. Eventual recovery of the blood counts was observed for the patients who completed CLI.

CONCLUSION

These results demonstrate for the first time that with CLI, it is possible to achieve complete remission of acceptable quality in follicular lymphoma patients who experience a chemotherapy failure. The main toxicity is limited to transient depression in hematological profiles. The treatment is fairly well tolerated and seems to carry little risk compared with high-dose chemotherapy and bone marrow rescue. Salvage CLI may not necessarily compromise future treatment with chemotherapy, including autologous bone marrow or stem cell transplantation, because the patients' blood counts recover.

Salvage radiotherapy for Hodgkin's disease following chemotherapy failure

PURPOSE

This study aims to: 1) assess failure-free survival (FFS), overall survival (OS), and failure pattern after salvage radiotherapy (SRT) for patients with Hodgkin's disease (HD) who fail chemotherapy (CT); 2) identify patients suitable for SRT as an alternative to more aggressive salvage regimens.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between 1978 and 1992, 52 patients with relapsed/refractory HD following 26 CT received SRT at the Peter MacCallum Cancer Institute. Patient characteristics at diagnosis were: median age (range 12-63); male-31, female-21; Stage I-4, II-16, III-25, or IV-7. Prior to SRT 27 patients had received the equivalent of both MOPP and ABV(D). The duration of initial complete response (CR) from CT was greater than 12 months in 22 patients. SRT (dose 34-42 Gy) was given to active disease sites.

RESULTS

Five-year FFS and OS rates following SRT were 26 and 57%, respectively. Five-year FFS and OS rates of 36 and 75%, respectively, were achieved in patients who relapsed in supradiaphragmatic nodal sites without B symptoms; in a subset of patients with initial Stage I-II disease the FFS and OS rates were 50 and 86%, respectively. On multivariate analysis significant factors for FFS were B symptoms at the time of SRT (p = 0.003), extranodal involvement (p = 0.011) and histology (p = 0.018). For OS significant factors were B symptoms (p = 0.0007), age (p = 0.014) and number of prior CT regimens (p = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

The relatively poor results of SRT in terms of FFS justify the use of alternative salvage strategies for most patients with Hodgkin's disease who fail CT. However, SRT offers a low morbidity, potentially curative option for a subset of patients. Our data suggest that patients most suitable for SRT are those with relapse in supradiaphragmatic nodal sites and no B symptoms.

Hodgkin's disease

This synthesis of the literature on radiotherapy for Hodgkin's Disease is based on 104 scientific articles, including 2 meta-analyses, 22 randomized studies, 5 prospective studies, and 58 retrospective studies. These studies involve 38,362 patients. The literature review clearly shows that radiotherapy is a cornerstone of treatment for localized Hodgkin's disease. At early stages, long-term survival is 80% to 90% when treatment is tailored to known prognostic factors. There is a tendency toward increased use of chemotherapy as additional treatment, however no evidence shows that it increases survival. To further improve survival following radiotherapy an attempt is being made to reduce long-term toxicity by better defining the patient groups who require lower radiation volumes, and delivering a dose that is as low as possible to avoid secondary solid tumors or delayed cardiopulmonary or gastrointestinal effects, while not jeopardizing therapeutic results. In advanced disease, radiotherapy may be needed as a complement to chemotherapy to effectively control bulky disease. For recurrent disease, radiotherapy may be considered as relapse treatment or additional therapy in conjunction with high-dose chemotherapy.

Age and Hodgkin's disease: the impact of competing risks and possibly salvage therapy on long term survival: an E.C.O.G. study

A detailed review of factors associated with survival was carried out in a cohort of 560 patients treated in two successive E.C.O.G. studies on advanced Hodgkin's disease. The study was undertaken to explore the impact of age on survival and to attempt to identify reasons for any observed differences. Data from two E.C.O.G. studies of patients with advanced Hodgkin's disease were examined separately and then pooled together. A special data request form was developed to capture additional information on treatments utilized for patients who were treated at relapse. The complete remission percentages were identical in both studies (72%) with no significant difference between the three age groupings (< 40, 40-59, and > 60 yr). This was true as well for disease-free survival. Nevertheless, overall survival was significantly better for the under aged 40 group and this difference was narrowed but not eliminated by competing risks. Our analysis of salvage therapy revealed a marginally significant difference in the CR% between the three groups, favoring the youngest cohort (< age 40 yr). The identical remission rate is probably a reflection of the entry criteria eliminating poor risk patients. Among the small number of patients who received radiation therapy, the response rate was 75% (9/12) in the young cohort. Elderly patients appeared to receive less salvage therapy and certainly fewer responses. Survival after relapse showed a similar pattern with the best survival in the youngest group of patients followed closely by the 40-59 yr group, with a poor outcome for those over age 60 yr. We conclude that a variety of conditions, both age and non-age dependent, impact on the survival of patients with advanced Hodgkin's disease who fulfill the rigid criteria for entry into cooperative group trials.