A new in silico approach to investigate molecular aspects of factor IX missense causative mutations and their impact on the hemophilia B severity

Clinical Implications of Discrepancy between One-Stage Clotting and Chromogenic Factor IX Activity in Hemophilia B

BACKGROUND

 Discrepancy in factor IX activity (FIX:C) between one-stage assay (OSA) and chromogenic substrate assay (CSA) in patients with hemophilia B (PwHB) introduces challenges for clinical management.

AIM

 To study the differences in FIX:C using OSA and CSA in moderate and mild hemophilia B (HB), their impact on classification of severity, and correlation with genotype.

METHODS

 Single-center study including 21 genotyped and clinically characterized PwHB. FIX:C by OSA was measured using ActinFSL (Siemens) and CSA by Biophen (Hyphen). In addition, in vitro experiments with wild-type FIX were performed. Reproducibility of CSA was assessed between three European coagulation laboratories.

RESULTS

 FIX:C by CSA was consistently lower than by OSA, with 10/17 PwHB having a more severe hemophilia type by CSA. OSA displayed a more accurate description of the clinical bleeding severity, compared with CSA. A twofold difference between OSA:CSA FIX:C was present in 12/17 PwHB; all patients had genetic missense variants in the FIX serine protease domain. Discrepancy was also observed with diluted normal plasma, most significant for values below 0.10 IU/mL. Assessment of samples with low FIX:C showed excellent reproducibility of the CSA results between the laboratories.

CONCLUSION

 FIX:C was consistently higher by OSA compared with the CSA. Assessing FIX:C by CSA alone would have led to diagnosis of a more severe hemophilia type in a significant proportion of patients. Our study suggests using both OSA and CSA FIX:C together with genotyping to classify HB severity and provide essential information for clinical management.

F8/F9 variants in the population-based PedNet Registry cohort compared with locus-specific genetic databases of the European Association for Haemophilia and Allied Disorders and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Hemophilia A or Hemophilia B Mutation Project

Background

Hemophilia A and B are caused by variants in the factor (F) VIII or FIX gene. Selective reporting may influence the distribution of variants reported in genetic databases.

Objectives

To compare the spectrum of F8 and F9 variants in an international population-based pediatric cohort (PedNet Registry) with the spectrum found in the European Association for Haemophilia and Allied Disorders (EAHAD) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Hemophilia A or Hemophilia B Mutation Project (CHAMP/CHBMP) databases.

Methods

All patients registered in the PedNet Registry on January 1, 2021 were included in this study. As comparators, data from patients with severe hemophilia included in the CHAMP/CHBMP registry (US center data) and EAHAD were used.

Results

Genetic information was available for 1941 patients. Intron 22 inversion was present in 52% of patients with severe hemophilia A; frameshift (36%), missense (28%), and nonsense (20%) were the most frequent variants in patients with severe hemophilia A who were inversion-negative. The most frequent variants in severe hemophilia B were missense (48%). In nonsevere disease, most variants were missense variants (moderate hemophilia A: 91%; mild hemophilia A: 95%, moderate and mild hemophilia B: 86% each). Comparison with the databases demonstrated a higher proportion of missense variants associated with severe hemophilia B in EAHAD (68%) than in PedNet (48%) and CHBMP (46%).

Conclusion

The PedNet population-based cohort provides an alternative to the established databases, which collect data by selective reporting, as it is a well-maintained database covering the full spectrum of pathogenic F8 and F9 variants, and indicates the number of patients affected by each particular variant.

Unveiling the influence of factor VIII physicochemical properties on hemophilia A phenotype through an in silico methodology

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Hemophilia A (HA) is an X-linked blood disorder. It is caused by pathogenic F8 gene variants, among which missense mutations are the most prevalent. The resulting amino acid substitutions may have different impacts on physicochemical properties and, consequently, on protein functionality. Regular prediction tools do not include structural elements and their physiological significance, which hampers our ability to functionally link variants to disease phenotype, opening an ample field for investigation. The present study aims to elucidate how physicochemical changes generated by substitutions in different protein domains relate to HA, and which of these features are more consequential to protein function and its impact on HA phenotype.

METHODS

An in silico evaluation of 71 F8 variants found in patients with different HA phenotypes (mild, moderate, severe) was performed to understand protein modifications and functional impact. Homology modeling was used for the structural analysis of physicochemical changes including electrostatic potential, hydrophobicity, solvent-accessible/excluded surface areas, disulfide disruptions, and substitutions indexes. These variants and properties were analyzed by hierarchical clustering analysis (HCA) and principal component analysis (PCA), independently and in combination, to investigate their relative contribution.

RESULTS

About 69% of variants show electrostatic changes, and almost all show hydrophobicity and surface area modifications. HCA combining all physicochemical properties analyzed was better in reflecting the impact of different variants in disease severity, more so than the single feature analysis. On the other hand, PCA led to the identification of prominent properties involved in the clustering results for variants of different domains.

CONCLUSIONS

The methodology developed here enables the assessment of structural features not available in other prediction tools (e.g., surface distribution of electrostatic potential), evaluating what kind of physicochemical changes are involved in FVIII functional disruption. HCA results allow distinguishing substitutions according to their properties, and yielded clusters which were more homogeneous in phenotype. All evaluated properties are involved in determining disease severity. The nature, as well as the position of the variants in the protein, were shown to be relevant for physicochemical changes, demonstrating that all these aspects must be collectively considered to fine-tune an approach to predict HA severity.

The Molecular Basis of FIX Deficiency in Hemophilia B

Coagulation factor IX (FIX) is a vitamin K dependent protein and its deficiency causes hemophilia B, an X-linked recessive bleeding disorder. More than 1000 mutations in the F9 gene have been identified in hemophilia B patients. Here, we systematically summarize the structural and functional characteristics of FIX and the pathogenic mechanisms of the mutations that have been identified to date. The mechanisms of FIX deficiency are diverse in these mutations. Deletions, insertions, duplications, and indels generally lead to severe hemophilia B. Those in the exon regions generate either frame shift or inframe mutations, and those in the introns usually cause aberrant splicing. Regarding point mutations, the bleeding phenotypes vary from severe to mild in hemophilia B patients. Generally speaking, point mutations in the F9 promoter region result in hemophilia B Leyden, and those in the introns cause aberrant splicing. Point mutations in the coding sequence can be missense, nonsense, or silent mutations. Nonsense mutations generate truncated FIX that usually loses function, causing severe hemophilia B. Silent mutations may lead to aberrant splicing or affect FIX translation. The mechanisms of missense mutation, however, have not been fully understood. They lead to FIX deficiency, often by affecting FIX's translation, protein folding, protein stability, posttranslational modifications, activation to FIXa, or the ability to form functional Xase complex. Understanding the molecular mechanisms of FIX deficiency will provide significant insight for patient diagnosis and treatment.

Generation of hyperfunctional recombinant human factor IX variants expressed in human cell line SK-Hep-1

OBJECTIVE

To develop recombinant factor IX (FIX) variants with augmented clotting activity.

RESULTS

We generated three new variants, FIX-YKALW, FIX-ALL and FIX-LLW, expressed in SK-Hep-1 cells and characterized in vitro and in vivo. FIX-YKALW showed the highest antigen expression level among the variants (2.17 µg^-mL), followed by FIX-LLW (1.5 µg^-mL) and FIX-ALL (0.9 µg^-mL). The expression level of FIX variants was two-five fold lower than FIX-wild-type (FIX-WT) (4.37 µg^-mL). However, the biological activities of FIX variants were 15-31 times greater than FIX-WT in the chromogenic assay. Moreover, the new variants FIX-YKALW, FIX-LLW and FIX-ALL also presented higher specific activity than FIX-WT (17, 20 and 29-fold higher, respectively). FIX variants demonstrated a better clotting time than FIX-WT. In hemophilia B mice, we observed that FIX-YKALW promoted hemostatic protection.

CONCLUSION

We have developed three improved FIX proteins with potential for use in protein replacement therapy for hemophilia B.