Sequence Similarity and Cross-Reactivity of a Diels-Alder Catalyst and an Anti-Progesterone Antibody

Closely related antibody receptors exploit fundamentally different strategies for steroid recognition

Molecular recognition by the adaptive immune system relies on specific high-affinity antibody receptors that are generated from a restricted set of starting sequences through homologous recombination and somatic mutation. The steroid binding antibody DB3 and the catalytic Diels-Alderase antibody 1E9 derive from the same germ line sequences but exhibit very distinct specificities and functions. However, mutation of only two of the 36 sequence differences in the variable domains, Leu(H47)Trp and Arg(H100)Trp, converts 1E9 into a high-affinity steroid receptor with a ligand recognition profile similar to DB3. To understand how these changes switch binding specificity and function, we determined the crystal structures of the 1E9 Leu(H47)Trp/Arg(H100)Trp double mutant (1E9dm) as an unliganded Fab at 2.05 A resolution and in complex with two configurationally distinct steroids at 2.40 and 2.85 A. Surprisingly, despite the functional mimicry of DB3, 1E9dm employs a distinct steroid binding mechanism. Extensive structural rearrangements occur in the combining site, where residue H47 acts as a specificity switch and H100 adapts to different ligands. Unlike DB3, 1E9dm does not use alternative binding pockets or different sets of hydrogen-bonding interactions to bind configurationally distinct steroids. Rather, the different steroids are inserted more deeply into the 1E9dm combining site, creating more hydrophobic contacts that energetically compensate for the lack of hydrogen bonds. These findings demonstrate how subtle mutations within an existing molecular scaffold can dramatically modulate the function of immune receptors by inducing unanticipated, but compensating, mechanisms of ligand interaction.

Switching antibody specificity through minimal mutation

Antibody 1E9, which was elicited with a hexachloronorbornene derivative and catalyzes the Diels-Alder reaction between tetrachlorothiophene dioxide and N-ethylmaleimide with high efficiency, was successfully reengineered to bind a range of structurally diverse steroids with nanomolar affinities. Remarkably, two mutations (Leu(H47)Trp/Arg(H100)Trp) out of 36 total sequence differences suffice to switch the selectivity of 1E9 to that of the progesterone-binding antibody DB3. In contrast to the double mutant, which tightly binds multiple steroids with differently configured A-B ring junctions, the individual Leu(H47)Trp and Arg(H100)Trp single mutants both exhibit significantly greater specificity than DB3, preferentially binding 5alpha-pregnan-3beta-ol-20-one (K(d) approximately 5 nM) over other steroids. These findings illustrate how easily differently shaped binding pockets can be created through subtle changes to the same primordial germ line template.

Immunological optimization of a generic hydrophobic pocket for high affinity hapten binding and Diels-Alder activity

Antibody 1E9, which binds a tetrachloronorbornene derivative with subnanomolar affinity and catalyzes the Diels-Alder reaction between tetrachlorothiophene dioxide and N-ethylmaleimide with high efficiency, arose from a family of highly restricted germ-line immunoglobulins that bind diverse hydrophobic ligands. Two somatic mutations, one at position L89 in the light chain (SerL89Phe) and another at position H47 in the heavy chain (TrpH47Leu), have been postulated to be responsible for the unusually high degree of shape and chemical complementarity observed in the crystal structure of 1E9 complexed with its hapten. To test this hypothesis, the germ-line sequence at these two positions was restored by site-directed mutagenesis. The ensuing 160 to 3900-fold decrease in hapten affinity and the complete loss of catalytic activity support the hypothesis that these somatic mutations substantially remodel the antibody binding pocket. Mutation of the highly conserved hydrogen-bond donor AsnH35, which sits at the bottom of the active site and is a hallmark of this family of antibodies, is also catastrophic with respect to hapten binding and catalysis. In contrast, residues in the CDR H3 loop, which contributes a significant fraction of the hapten-contacting protein surface, have a more subtle influence on the properties of 1E9. Interestingly, while most changes in this loop have neutral or modestly deleterious effects, replacement of MetH100b at the floor of the pocket with phenylalanine leads to a significant sevenfold increase in catalytic activity. The latter result is surprising given the unusually close fit of the parent antibody to the transition-state analogue. Further fine-tuning of the interactions between 1E9 and its ligands by introducing mutations outside the active site could conceivably yield substantially more active catalysts.

Optimized production of the Diels-Alderase antibody 1E9 as a chimeric Fab

Monoclonal antibody 1E9, which catalyzes the [4+2] cycloaddition between tetrachlorothiophene dioxide and N-ethylmaleimide, has been re-engineered for production as a chimeric human–murine Fab fragment in Escherichia coli. Stabilizing point mutations in the variable regions of the antibody were identified by replacing residues that rarely occur at individual positions in aligned immunoglobulin sequences with their consensus counterparts. By combining favorable substitutions, double (MetH87Thr–GlyL63Ser) and triple (MetH87Thr–GlyL63Ser–PheL95Pro) mutants were created, which can be produced in good yield (4 and 17 mg L–1cell culture, respectively). The triple mutant exhibits a modest fourfold drop in the apparent kcatvalue for the cycloaddition reaction, but the kinetic properties of the double mutant are indistinguishable from those of the parent murine IgG. The availability of recombinant versions of this catalytic antibody will facilitate efforts to determine the origins of its selectivity and catalytic efficiency through mutagenesis.Key words: catalytic antibody, Fab fragment, bacterial production.

Critical analysis of antibody catalysis

Antibody molecules elicited with rationally designed transition-state analogs catalyze numerous reactions, including many that cannot be achieved by standard chemical methods. Although relatively primitive when compared with natural enzymes, these catalysts are valuable tools for probing the origins and evolution of biological catalysis. Mechanistic and structural analyses of representative antibody catalysts, generated with a variety of strategies for several different reaction types, suggest that their modest efficiency is a consequence of imperfect hapten design and indirect selection. Development of improved transition-state analogs, refinements in immunization and screening protocols, and elaboration of general strategies for augmenting the efficiency of first-generation catalytic antibodies are identified as evident, but difficult, challenges for this field. Rising to these challenges and more successfully integrating programmable design with the selective forces of biology will enhance our understanding of enzymatic catalysis. Further, it should yield useful protein catalysts for an enhanced range of practical applications in chemistry and biology.

Shape complementarity, binding-site dynamics, and transition state stabilization: a theoretical study of Diels-Alder catalysis by antibody 1E9

Antibody 1E9 is a protein catalyst for the Diels-Alder reaction between tetrachlorothiophene dioxide and N-ethylmaleimide. Quantum mechanical calculations have been employed to study the 1E9-catalyzed Diels-Alder reaction in the gas phase. The transition states and intermediates were all determined at the B3LYP/6-31G*//HF/6-31G* level. The cycloaddition step is predicted to be rate-determining, and the endo reaction pathway is strongly favored. Binding of the reactants and the transition states to antibody 1E9 was investigated by docking and molecular dynamics simulations. The linear interaction energy (LIE) method was adopted to estimate the free energy barrier of the 1E9-catalyzed Diels-Alder reaction. The catalytic efficiency of antibody 1E9 is achieved by enthalpic stabilization of the transition state, near-perfect shape complementarity of the hydrophobic binding site for the transition state, and a strategically placed hydrogen-bonding interaction.

Evolution of shape complementarity and catalytic efficiency from a primordial antibody template

The crystal structure of an efficient Diels-Alder antibody catalyst at 1.9 angstrom resolution reveals almost perfect shape complementarity with its transition state analog. Comparison with highly related progesterone and Diels-Alderase antibodies that arose from the same primordial germ line template shows the relatively subtle mutational steps that were able to evolve both structural complementarity and catalytic efficiency.

Immunological origins of binding and catalysis in a Diels-Alderase antibody

The three-dimensional structure of an antibody (39-A11) that catalyzes a Diels-Alder reaction has been determined. The structure suggests that the antibody catalyzes this pericyclic reaction through a combination of packing and hydrogen-bonding interactions that control the relative geometries of the bound substrates and electronic distribution in the dienophile. A single somatic mutation, serine-91 of the light chain to valine, is largely responsible for the increase in affinity and catalytic activity of the affinity-matured antibody. Structural and functional studies of the germ-line precursor suggest that 39-A11 and related antibodies derive from a family of germ-line genes that have been selected throughout evolution for the ability of the encoded proteins to form a polyspecific combining site. Germ line-encoded antibodies of this type, which can rapidly evolve into high-affinity receptors for a broad range of structures, may help to expand the binding potential associated with the structural diversity of the primary antibody repertoire.